The Munro EV: The Future of off-roaders? | Fifth Gear

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 85

  • @johncampbell9216
    @johncampbell9216 11 месяцев назад +1

    Love it. This is what we need; a rugged and utilitarian off-roader stripped down to the basics. Well done!

  • @grabir01
    @grabir01 2 года назад +10

    At 2:52 you need to take care of that brake line. Tie it back or make a control bracket to keep it out of the spring.

  • @buzz8019
    @buzz8019 Год назад +6

    This is what Land Rover should have made instead of the toxic fossil burning fashion blob... new Defender...

  • @RichardLyleEsq
    @RichardLyleEsq 2 года назад +11

    I'd rather have this than an Ineos Grenadier.

    • @oneeleven9832
      @oneeleven9832 2 года назад +1

      You obviously work for Munro…that or your being sarcastic…

    • @RichardLyleEsq
      @RichardLyleEsq 2 года назад +4

      No, I would really rather have one of these.

    • @olivermoore7020
      @olivermoore7020 2 года назад +2

      The INEOS Grenedier is still diesel powered, so new ones can't be produced or sold in the UK after 2030. The Munro is looking further into the future.

  • @daiashthomas
    @daiashthomas 2 года назад +13

    Needs DC fast charging capability, even if its only 50kw

    • @olivermoore7020
      @olivermoore7020 2 года назад +2

      If its a farming vehicle, and it can be recharged overnight on the farm - surely it just needs enough power on an overnight charge get it through a day or two of work?

  • @vincentpollack
    @vincentpollack 2 года назад +8

    In terms of looks I think it would look better with bigger wheels. But if it performs the best with the current wheel size there’s no reason to change it. At the end of the day it’s built for purpose 👌

    • @toyotaprius79
      @toyotaprius79 2 года назад

      So you mean, Coach wheels?

    • @vincentpollack
      @vincentpollack 2 года назад

      @@toyotaprius79 EXACTLY. Back to being a true farmer

    • @Robdutton91
      @Robdutton91 2 года назад

      No reason why it would perform better with smaller wheels, if anything bigger tyres are better for off roading. There’s plenty of room in those arches for some big boy tyres

  • @dgurevich1
    @dgurevich1 2 года назад +3

    Now do one with MWM Spartan.
    An UAZ chassis with electric drivetrain assembled in Czech Republic.

  • @flyme195
    @flyme195 2 года назад +3

    To be a proper working farm vehicle, it needs to be able to tow. What’s it’s towing limit?

    • @tipperarymick5337
      @tipperarymick5337 2 года назад

      They have said it will have a towing rating of 3.5 tonnes, the same as the Ibex it is based on.

    • @stevekelly5166
      @stevekelly5166 2 года назад

      One lamb, half a cow or three bails of hay. Oh, and a tow hitch.

  • @kennethpope4311
    @kennethpope4311 2 года назад +5

    Too pricey to be used as a farm runaround. Looks like it was built by men in sheds but with a mercedes factory price tag.

    • @JohnBaxendale
      @JohnBaxendale 2 года назад +1

      Quite a lot of Range Rovers knocking about on farms though...

    • @tipperarymick5337
      @tipperarymick5337 2 года назад

      @@JohnBaxendale A new Defender or Discovery or Toyota Landcruiser would be just as expensive.

    • @paulbrowne6087
      @paulbrowne6087 Год назад

      Have you seen the prices of new cars these days? A Ford Focus starts at £28,000!!!!. At 60-80k for something like this is a bargain relatively speaking. Plus, businesses can get the VAT back.

  • @michaelloach9461
    @michaelloach9461 2 года назад +7

    How long did the old landy Defender last? Will that last the same amount of time? Its OK trying to be 'green' but how much Carbon does that use to be produced? When that needs new batteries & the like, the Defender will still be working hard on vegetable oil! All the best..............

    • @davidreid2301
      @davidreid2301 2 года назад +1

      Although I agree with you about the misperceptions of EV "environmentally friendliness", I think you've missed the point. It's about the ease driving off road without a clutch and gears, and the superior torque that you simply can't get from a combination engine. Also, the bare basics of the vehicle, as apposed to what the Defender has become - a Range Rover, basically!

    • @michaelloach9461
      @michaelloach9461 2 года назад +1

      @@davidreid2301 You want the reward for driving off-road, hone your skills & don't let the car do it for you. It's not a servant, it's a tool. If you cannot use the tool (like a screwdriver) learn how to use it. A screwdriver doesn't drive in screws by itself!

    • @Robdutton91
      @Robdutton91 2 года назад +1

      @@davidreid2301superior torque? My car has the same amount of torque and it’s a naturally aspirated petrol V8 developed 30 years ago. Yes it comes a millisecond later than the electric motors but it’s a whole lot more fun than an EV.

  • @gigabane7357
    @gigabane7357 Год назад +1

    The entire vehicle should be skinned in those thin rugged 'walkable' solar panels and a custom multi mppt controller. charges itself up to the maximum possible no matter if in use or parked or partially shaded.

    • @MBTIMemes
      @MBTIMemes Год назад

      exactly what I've been thinking

  • @Dead_Albatross
    @Dead_Albatross 2 года назад +1

    That's identical to a foers ibex. If be surprised if it wasn't actually a foers ibex.

  • @fifthgearuk
    @fifthgearuk  3 года назад +3

    Watch our brand new series, Thursdays at 9pm on Quest or via Discovery+ www.discoveryplus.co.uk/show/fifth-gear-recharged-uk

  • @bobeden5027
    @bobeden5027 2 года назад +1

    I want one!

  • @julianlawrence-ball2279
    @julianlawrence-ball2279 2 года назад

    Range? Recharge time?

  • @davidrfrench
    @davidrfrench 2 года назад +5

    I came mainly for all the anti-electric doomsayer comments, and I wasn’t disappointed.

  • @jimskirtt5717
    @jimskirtt5717 2 года назад +1

    So it's an Ibex, then.

  • @alexkarlson6181
    @alexkarlson6181 Год назад

    Яка ціна?

  • @cameraprepper7938
    @cameraprepper7938 2 года назад +1

    Will it be made with steering on the left side for Europe ?

    • @paulbrowne6087
      @paulbrowne6087 Год назад

      I would say that 100% they'll offer LHD versions.

  • @badsamaritan8223
    @badsamaritan8223 2 года назад

    I wanna see this compared to the Bollinger B1

  • @digitalplayland
    @digitalplayland 10 месяцев назад

    Amazing car. So beautiful! It should cost 15k.

  • @sc1837
    @sc1837 2 года назад

    Roof struts look Like they are designed to scalp people.. this seems rough even for a test vehicle.

  • @tophat2002
    @tophat2002 Год назад

    Will it last 20 years....

  • @dirkdiggler9964
    @dirkdiggler9964 Год назад

    Is that an off road milk truck?

  • @joshhancill7273
    @joshhancill7273 2 года назад +6

    65 grand for that. I’ll just buy a petrol defender.

  • @IAmSoMuchBetterThanYou
    @IAmSoMuchBetterThanYou 2 года назад

    Vanderhall Brawley is a similar idea

  • @dhirenderkumarcarandgadget5520
    @dhirenderkumarcarandgadget5520 2 года назад +3

    Silent and superb

  • @Saintsmanbidford
    @Saintsmanbidford 2 года назад +2

    @1.21: “EV vehicles”?🙄

  • @AR-zr1om
    @AR-zr1om 2 года назад +2

    What a poor review. Tells you pretty much nothing about the car it can drive on grass and carry a small bag?

  • @dodgygoose3054
    @dodgygoose3054 Год назад

    Get them to Australia!!!!!!!!!

  • @JoeyBaby47
    @JoeyBaby47 2 года назад +1

    It would be hilarious if run out of juice on the trail. You aren't going to 5 gallon your way out of that.

    • @JohnBaxendale
      @JohnBaxendale 2 года назад

      Whack a solar panel on the roof and let it recharge itself :)

    • @JoeyBaby47
      @JoeyBaby47 2 года назад +1

      @@JohnBaxendale In how many days? How about when it is cloudy? If you are on a tight trail, you are blocking everyone and everyone will be waiting for a while.

    • @JohnBaxendale
      @JohnBaxendale 2 года назад

      @@JoeyBaby47 You’d have to be really dumb to get it that wrong, it’s not like modern EV’s have a sub-300 mile range, especially off-road where they’re way more predictable than an ICE vehicle.

    • @Neojhun
      @Neojhun 2 года назад

      Yep a Single vehicle is a very bad idea. But you can tow charge a BEV with Regen. Main thing is just have a massive battery with pleanty of range thus you never run out. Your silly hypothetical is pointless.

  • @johnemerson5383
    @johnemerson5383 2 года назад

    And not a single mention of the range of the vehicle.

    • @JohnBaxendale
      @JohnBaxendale 2 года назад

      By the time it hits the market it'll be two or three times what it would be today.

    • @thembrown
      @thembrown 2 года назад

      There is only 1 car in the range. It's called the Munro ev

  • @jimhud134
    @jimhud134 2 года назад

    Is that James May @ 00:39??? 😆

  • @vikramrao6391
    @vikramrao6391 2 года назад

    65k ? The Rivian R1T is less than that and looks and feels a million times better, Inlove the Munro but not for 65 K

    • @BALANCEDPORTFOLIO
      @BALANCEDPORTFOLIO 2 года назад +1

      You'll never get the R1T in the uk for 65k unless they build a factory here

    • @paulbrowne6087
      @paulbrowne6087 Год назад

      RIT is $100k with a couple of options. The R1S will likely be starting at $100k upwards. Munro going for a different market also.

  • @paulb4uk
    @paulb4uk 2 года назад +2

    looks terrible like a pile of scrap flung together .

  • @wolfpackgames4674
    @wolfpackgames4674 2 года назад

    wish it had independent suspension and wish the farmer didn't have solar panels, they're not worth using if you're going "carbon neutral" if you actually know the production process

  • @Mick1714
    @Mick1714 2 года назад

    You cannot homologate that car.

  • @stevewalsh-balshaw1727
    @stevewalsh-balshaw1727 2 года назад +2

    Too heavy too big too expensive, I'll take an ice jimny any day over this for off roading

  • @PooleAcademyofWingChun
    @PooleAcademyofWingChun 2 года назад +1

    😂 carbon neutral, getting your electric from a power station

    • @buzzofftoxicblog791
      @buzzofftoxicblog791 2 года назад

      Thank you just a thought Embodied energy, refining crud oil it requires lots of electricity 🤔 🔥 locked in carbon that's why even burning dirty coal in far off power stations is better than toxic petrol burning ice, if used directly charging a ev, is just better, plan globaly is to go 100% renewable energy most being produced locally, smart micro grids home energy production with bi directional charging using ev,s as a charge bank, pasive homes. All transport will go electric for all because it works for all. End the con of toxic war fossil fuel burning the one driver of anthropogenic extinction it is a locked in carbon 🔥 it's all about science sadly big oil have good misleading PR for global control and lie. Time to end the toxic fossil war F.U.D cartel age before it ends us all anthropogenic extinction.

    • @PooleAcademyofWingChun
      @PooleAcademyofWingChun 2 года назад

      @@buzzofftoxicblog791 hahaha , all go on electric and then they will say there is not enough so you can’t use your car

  • @jonscot8393
    @jonscot8393 2 года назад

    No. EV's don't like water. And recently one blew up after trying to get it out of a flooded road.

    • @Neojhun
      @Neojhun 2 года назад

      LOL that's some insane LIES!
      Japan's Sōryū-class SUBMARINE uses Lithium Ion batteries.

  • @simeontofiakwa1431
    @simeontofiakwa1431 2 года назад

    Looks like a car made by Uni students as their last project wtf is this ....and these are the same pple who want their own government

  • @berthelin1
    @berthelin1 2 года назад +1

    1

  • @diamondsy96
    @diamondsy96 2 года назад +1

    Love the look of the car but Carbon neutral it is not, I can't wait for this crazy EV fad to be over

    • @bellshooter
      @bellshooter 2 года назад

      You will be very disappointed, EV's are the present and future of motoring, and prices will become on parity as volumes rise and cheaper marques supply vehicles. The new Defender starts at £46,000, and goes up to £109,000.

    • @Neojhun
      @Neojhun 2 года назад

      LOL Not a fad. Delayed stifled technology we should of had a decade ago. Your easily influenced mind has no clue how this stuff works. That's like saying The Internet is a fad.

    • @diamondsy96
      @diamondsy96 2 года назад

      @@bellshooter 😂😂😂😂

    • @diamondsy96
      @diamondsy96 2 года назад

      @@Neojhun 😂😂😂😂

  • @ronaldezz
    @ronaldezz 2 года назад +4

    Spare me electric car reviews, not interested 😒