We TESTED Carbon Fiber Armor against MEDIEVAL WEAPONS and the results were invaluable!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- PLUSHIE AVAILABLE HERE:
www.makeship.com/products/sha...
If you like the content and want to support the channel, you're welcome to support us through playeUr, Subscribe Star, become a channel member here on RUclips or through Pateon:
PlayeUr: utreon.com/c/shadiversity
Subscribe star: www.subscribestar.com/shadive...
Become a member: / @shadiversity
Patreon: / shadbrooks
NEW Shadow of the Conqueror T-Shirt:
shadiversity.creator-spring.c...
Come check out my other channels!
THE SHADLANDS: / @theshadlands1142
KNIGHTS WATCH: / knightswatch
Subscribe to my website so you don't miss an upload: www.shadmbrooks.com/
Follow me on Facebook: / shadiversity
Follow me on twitter: / shadmbrooks
My novel, Shadow of the Conqueror Audio Book affiliate links:
US: www.audible.com/shadbrooks
UK: www.audible.co.uk/shadbrooks
CA: www.audible.ca/shadbrooks
AU: www.audible.com.au/shadbrooks
Ebook, Paperback and Hardcover available from most major book retailers, here are a few of the main ones:
Amazon affiliate link (be sure to navigate to your country's amazon site):
amzn.to/2XErUaR
Barnes and Noble:
www.barnesandnoble.com/w/shad...
Kobo:
www.kobo.com/au/en/ebook/shad...
Awesome Shirts and chainmail print clothing: teespring.com/en-GB/stores/sh...
Visit Calimacil for the best replica foam swords and LARP weapons: calimacil.com?aff=38
Buy my sword IMPERIOUS from Calimacil: calimacil.com/products/imperi...
Community run discord server: / discord
#castle #castles #sword #swords #knight #longsword #medieval
LAST WEEK TO GRAB THE PLUSHIE! AVAILABLE HERE:
www.makeship.com/products/shadiversity-plush
how does a modern full body armour do against warhammers and pikes?
@@deathcrunch9020 he has never said anything hateful as far as i can tell.
what hate about women?
and lefties? well they tend to ruin everything they touch and want freedom from responsibility as far as i can tell. shiting on their ideology is naturally a good thing.
all colectivists are bad for society.
but i find it ironic that you cry about someone spewing hate while doing exactly that.
It should be noted that carbon fiber is light, what mean that you could have practically way thicker plate.
You guys should try some version of Carbotanium. Pagani used that in one of their cars about 7 or 8 years ago. I've made Armor bits out of Carbon Fiber mixed with powdered Metals, Ceramic, and Graphite. I've made Armor bits from Fiber Glass as well. I've made some Layered Armor bits from Carbon Fiber, Fiber Glass, Abilone Shell Fiber (made the same way as Carbon Fiber and Fiber Glass), Ceramic with Graphite mixed in, then both sides covered in Salt Soaked Denim (3 Day soak just like the Aztecs), then both of those get a nice Leather (more for looks and comfort than practical) Stands up to bullets pretty good. 4 inches thick is a bit much, but it's a quarter the weight of Modern Class 3 Body Armor.
Gents. That dummy is knocked around every episode its used. How about spending $10 and fill some sandbags to reinforce its base.
The Mannequin: "I'm tired, boss"
someday you'll lay at rest...
BUT TODAY IS NOT THE DAY
Tired? Oh that sounds like you need more work out to get your foam flowing!
That's cause it's a womankin 😂
@@xxxlonewolf49 Doing less work but demanding a raise and a promotion to compensate for centuries of discrimination and oppression??
He deserves a nice retirement
Shadiversity, answering the questions nerds have asked for decades but lacked the skills or finances to answer themselves. Thank you for your service!
You can thank the leftist biden economy for that😂....
@@dankdaze42069 he is ausie :D biden isnt at fault there, they have their own corrupted politicians :D
@@dankdaze42069
That hasnt been around for decades but for 4 years......
@@dankdaze42069Even before I was born the economy of the US was made to keep people poor and companys rich and if Trump gets president again, it will get worse, since he owns a big company and will do all he could to make himself more rich.
I know no other industrial country, where you have to work 2-3 low wage full time jobs just to stay alive without going into dept. In fact in my country you could live off a part-time minimum wage job.
You know shad is from australia ?@@dankdaze42069
Carbon fiber is all about shape. It’s about manipulating the force vectors against the shape.
Shear factors
Carbon Fiber, developed by Alliant Technologies. Created to replace steel and aluminum while creating a lowered radar reflection.
Sadly the crap available to civilians does none of that as the resins needed to create Armor level Carbon Fiber are not currently available in any quantity. Not to mention that the true Carbon Chain Fiber, made from fly ash from IPP and woven by HEXCEL is not available to civilians either.
@@user-qx3lm4vw6eis it not available because it's impossible to produce without a military budget and isn't being sold to civilians? Is it regulated strictly?
@@sakesaurus1706 Actually yes, it's availability has to be approved by DARPA and DHS. But there are decent knockoffs available from China that would be more than adequate for LARP.
Hoyt Easton is one of the few civilian companies currently using the HEXCEL produced fiber for their ACC arrow shafts. But the Chinese knockoffs work comparably well but lack the longevity.
Oceangate strongly disagrees 😂😂😂
The thing about carbon fiber is that it's nearly weightless, 2 layers would barely add encumberance, but over a gambeson would appear to be highly effective.
armadillo style rounded plate lamellar over gambeson would be dope
Especially if the gambeson had some Kevlar on it.
Ah, the “Stormtrooper Armor” strategy
Highly effective? What video did you just watch? I just saw a bunch of carbon fiber get completely obliterated. Some of it by a pretty blunt katana.
@@geoffrogers7590 the one where the test pieces were flat, thin, and unsecured, demonstrating worst-case scenario failure points.
Looks pretty sturdy, I bet you could make a submarine out of that stuff!
Once
I was just about to leave the same comment. Lol
Legend
@@HempKnight2112 Same here! 😅
You going to hell 🔥😂😂😂
Carbon fiber is several times the strength of steel per mass, but it is also very brittle. When its breaking force is reached it fails abruptly. You need to laminate it with a strong, flexible material like Kevlar, Dyneema, or Spectra, and you need a minimum of 10 layers (probably more) if you intend to stop arrows from a war bow. Also, the epoxy must be vacuum chambered and cured in a kiln or oven to remove air bubbles and catalyze the resin to maximum strength. The resin manufacturer can tell you the optimum temperature to cure at but if memory serves it is somewhere in the neighborhood of 80 to 90 deg. C (aerospace standards) to achieve maximum strength.
Yep, it would be an inch thick if it was the same weight as steel. Doubt an arrow will penetrate an inch of carbon fiber.
@@davidbeppler3032It might embed still. Give it an even harder top layer to deflect. In case of "Then what's the point of the carbon fiber". To be a solid backbone and prevent the deflection surface from deforming or caving into a dent that can lead to penetration. The resin could catch the tip of an arrow and stop it from deflecting. But a pure surface has a better chance of letting it slide off
When I was younger, I was on my high school rowing team and one day we got a criminal, fiber shell, and you are indeed correct it’s a miraculous material but it’s very brittle It is very vulnerable to crush forces. Bumps that thing on the dock one day, just a little bit and just opened gaping hole. So carbon, fiber armor would be great at all kinds of cutting attacks and someone, but you bring a mace to it or an ax and it’s gonna go right through.
This seems like important info. Hope that Shad team read this.
Came here for the kevlar suggestion
If you actually make armor you better make it as functionally badass as possible
They cannot, as the state they are in (Victoria) has prohibited body armour
Control of Weapons Regulations 2021 bans the use and ownership of body armour by the public.
@@snimmoWouldn’t want the people to be able to protect themselves, lol
@@snimmowow that’s bs
@@AlyssMa7rin The government: Only we're allowed to have guns.
Also the government: You're also not allowed to wear armour against the only people that have guns.
When will people realise that the people in the government have absolutely no care for you? the only way you become a politician is to become a backstabbing snake with no morals.
I like how these two hijacked Shad's channel 😁
How else can he visit castles!
I really like their chemistry, was amusing banter throughout the video
Diversity is in the name 😊
Also didn’t Shad say he had chronic fatigue. Maybe he’s stepping back a bit.
I don't think there are castles in Australia 😄🗡️
@@vonsauerkrautthe castles arent a valid defence against the Emus otherwise there would be!
5:15 "Hexagons are best-agons" nice cpgrey reference. great video.
Hexagons are not best-agons triangels are better Hexagons are just easier to produce
Lots of people say that too
@@fmesCC-3636 6 triangles make 1 hexagon, in the end, you cant avoid making hexagons, because they are the best-agons.
@@DuplexWeevil337 They say it because of CGP Grey's video: ruclips.net/video/thOifuHs6eY/видео.html
AHHHH I CAN'T WAIT FOR THE TITAN SWORD. SUPPORT THEM AT ALL COSTSSS
I heard a story about a man that went insane.
He bought a new boomerang and kept trying to throw the old one away.
Tyranth just brute forcing every cutting test with one hand is my favourite part
even when the piercing strikes got through, the CF did a good job of stopping them before they really got to a lethal level. If you had padding beneath, it would be even better
I agree, I've shot 6mm carbon with a crossbow,( modern points and bow) the broadhead made a hole enough to injur but not very deep.
And don't forget the weight advantage.
You can just make it so much thicker than regular armor.
@@AliothAncalagon that's a very good point.
CF is a great ingredient for composite armor.
Important part is composite.
There's a new technique to make graphene. It's really cheap, but a lot of time consuming lab manual labor. For a one-off suit of armor it would probably be worth it, I would throw some of that in the resin.
I would also add a few layers of Kevlar so it's useful in a modern context as well.
I would also continue to use metal plates but make them half the thickness and back them with the composites.
So you end up with the same weight but double the protection or same protection and half the weight.
you know... a couple cm penetration just releases adrenaline... and in the heat of the fight, you don't even feel it...
The durability seemed fairly good for such thin sheets. You could easily make armor multiple sheets thick and still be lighter or thinner than regular armor. Something multiple sheets thick would probably be quite good.
I'm not convinced of that at all. Not from what I just saw. I'd have to see a properly shaped piece of armour made from carbon fiber get shot to make that kind of claim. I've seen what mild steel can do to stop arrows when properly shaped and treated. I.e. it can stop a 160 lbs longbow and take almost no damage. That carbon fiber struggled with 110 lbs and the arrow still got through. The problem with carbon fiber is that the moment it takes damage, it becomes so much weaker for the next blow.
@@geoffrogers7590and was the steel as light as the carbon fiber was in these tests?
@@himedo1512 Carbon fiber is about 1/3 to 1/4 the density of steel. It makes a good amount of difference, but it's not exactly a super futuristic ultramaterial. 4mm thick carbon fiber plate armor would be awesome, be able to stop 12th century cannons, and be the same weight as plate armor of the day, but having armor that's that thick would cause problems around points of articulation. Not to mention that the knight would be very unlikely to survive the cannon, regardless of blunt penetration. The biggest issue with carbon fiber is how inflexible and fragile it is when you're using resin. Against a war pick, hardened steel would likely perform as well as or even better than carbon fiber that has been properly meshed and hardened simply because most steels deform so well and are less likely to shatter into multiple pieces.
In alot of ways, it's similar in effectiveness to ceramic armor. Super effective against a single shot, but after that, it rapidly becomes extremely useless.
@@commode7x carbon fiber plate carriers for days
@@BWeManX Unless you're expecting half a dozen disposable squires to follow you around on the battlefield, replacing broken plates, it's not terribly useful after the first few hits. The benefit of carbon fiber is that it can be weaved into a very lightweight and nigh-unbreakable soft material in order to replace chainmail. Plate armor only makes sense if you're able to R&D a diamond hard composite material that won't fall apart when shattered.
the arrow test suprised me. considering it was a very thin piece and flat + the arrow did get stuck pretty early.
It seems it pierced fairly easily, but got rapidly slowed down. I think the fibers got pushed apart, which meant they tried to squish back together, causing friction on the arrow. Steel and the like are more likely to bend out of the way.
They need to try that again with Tusker Broadheads
@@MrRourk It will be worse. Broadheads are made to slice through unarmored flesh of game animals or burglars. The field point on the first shot was the best tip they could have used of the ones they had. A bodkin would have been superior to all others. The second head they used was a semi-broadhead and the fiber stopped it almost outright. The one you listed, while beautiful and functional, would fare worse. The fiber would catch the blades and just outright stop it. This is what gambesons are for; the weave catches wider arrow blades and can even hamper bodkins.
“We got penetration”, says Tyranth…
I wonder how resistant shaped Carbon-fiber is towards swords…
These small bricks aren’t telling much.
Would a small brick of plated iron not provide some information?
@@HvacHeathenNot really. I've seen what a properly shaped iron breast plate can take, and it's a hell of a lot more than a small brick can. I don't even know if shaping carbon fiber in the same way would yield comparable results until I see it done tbh. A big part of me doubts it because carbon fiber just isn't like other materials. The strength comes from the weave and not necessarily the shape of the object it's made into.
@@geoffrogers7590 Another thing is that different materials have different resistances to different types of trauma. Steel is amazingly good when it comes to taking pressure, which makes it an amazing material when it comes to armour. Carbon fiber isn't, it shines when it comes to resistance against expanding. That's why it's amazing material for space projects and was a terrible material for a submarine.
So it would be hard to shape carbon fiber in such a way that it would truly shine when it comes to resistance to external forces.
Carbon fibre on it's own is not an effective armour. It's light and rigid, not tough.
Carbon fibre sandwiching a layer of kevlar, repeated 16 times however. Now you are getting some fairly cut resistant armour at least.
Make the Carbon Fiber an inch thick and show me an arrow going through it. ;)
If you're comparing modern materials maybe check for polycarbonate sheets like Lexan. These are used for replacing windows in areas at risk of vandalism as, while they may scratch, they're resistant to breaking and, too a limited extent, small arms. Quarter inch thick is standard but it would be easy enough to cut a sheet and bolt several layers together. It might actually work better than carbon fiber for armor or shields as it's softer and less likely to shatter.
I believe you need a much thicker layer of lexan to withstand the same amount of punishment as carbon fiber, so it's definitely less efficient, but I guess it would be more cost-effective.
I have worked with lexan and steel sheets before and from my experience, a 1.5 mm thick lexan was easier to cut than a 0.5 mm thick mild steel and a 8 mm thick lexan was easier to saw through than a 1 mm thick mild steel (with the appropriate saws). But I have obviously not tried arrows or bullets (or carbon fiber).
Speaking of bullets, Scott from Kentucky Ballistics easily blasted through a half inch thick "bulletproof" lexan with a standard 9 mm pistol. So you gotta get extra thick with those to start stopping some bullets.
Then composite for all purpose armor?
Honestly HDPE would probably be even more interesting in this application.
@@Sukenus polycarbonate is NOT hard. It's not resistant to scratching, sawing, miling, and similar types of damage. What i noticed tho, is that it doesn't crack or shatter from blunt force, it bends like metal instead, to an extent. I had lexan industrial-grade protective googles that wore of and weren't usable anymore, so i shot them with a pellet gun. They stopped the pellet, but it left a dent similar to ones that are left in sheet metal, sleek round shaped, with no signs of cracking that you'd expect from plastic. I think the googles were like 1.5mm thick polycarbonate.
@@Sukenus Polycarbonate itself isn't bulletproof and anyone that believes it is, is an idiot. It is however, one of two materials used in bullet resistant glass. Glass fragments the bullet. Polycarbonate absorbs the fragments. It is worth mentioning that transparent aluminum does a much better job, being capable of stopping .50 bmg in the same thickness as the typical layering for ballistic glass is made for stopping normal rifle rounds.
These 2 on their own are a special kind of entertainment 😂. It’s chaos and I love it! Great bickering 👏
Got to say, this is absolute quality - informative, entertaining, answering questions no one else has the guts to take on!
"The Gods gave you two hands, I can respect that", says Skyrim guard.
Tyranth: "Nah, I have a curved sword".
Carbon fiber: Good for medieval weapons, terrible for submersibles.
Too soon.
Shout out to boromeer, always taking the brunt of the abuse from shad and the lads. Number 1 employee of shadiversity productions
I can’t wait for a vibroblade to become doable.
we got those. "oscillating cutters", my bad. i said reciprocating before.
@@kingmasterlord A VibroSWORD then
@@charlesfritz7327 simple bladeswap oughta do it
I mean women have vibrators, so we're already halfway there😂
@@kingmasterlord you would need a lot more power than a typical handheld ultrasonic cutter.
I'm imagining putting this over textile armor would be a really good combo. Giving it something to diffuse the force into. Probably still wouldn't be as durable as plate, but might be pretty darn good, especially vs any kind of cutting slashing action. Seems like its only really weak against piercing stuff, but if it stops it enough that it wouldn't get through the textile underneath, might nonetheless still be really effective.
It could be highly effective spaces armour. Bind an outer carapace with one about half an inch under by the edges. Run bolts and nuts through as support pillars, the ends can be smooth on the outer shell if desired. Otherwise it may wear your opponent more to have their strikes unpredictably stopped in jarring fashion. Of course under that, still the other stuff
We're lucky Boromir doesn't have real eyes, his two-thousand yards stare would be crushing.
time to become a patreon. so we can actually see a full body armor with exchangeable parts.
They can't make body armour because Australia's government is trash.
Be careful with frayed carbon fiber. The little ends are sharp and can work into your skin. The splinters wont directly cause an infection either as carbon is a natural part of the body, and can work in deep and cause damage.
Lol, try spending months on end as an insulation installer on a jobsite.
@@shanephillips4011 It works it's way out eventually. Sometimes months later.
Those are the same reasons it was considred, and then rejected, for use in implants (like hip replacements)
The body won't react to it, sure. But if its ever damaged/starts decaying, it would cause major problems.
such a underated channel, I love their content 😊
I work in composites as my day job and I can tell you there is not really much of a point of using foam core in a carbon fiber sword. The sword is going to be thin enough as it is that you won't need many layers of carbon fiber to make a traditionaly thick sword. I would just make sure you have at least one layer of UD in the center of the sword to give it rigidity. Biaxe UD Biaxe would probably do the trick. For weight balance I would just put something more dense than carbon fiber in the hilt. Definetly do a vaccum bag after you layup. Infustion would be prefered but thats more complex, you can just wet layup and throw it in a vacum bag and apply like a bar and a half of pressure to it and there yah go.
Skeletonized steel core was my thought. For balance you could do a bit of tungsten or something in the hilt. Depending on the total weight, of course. I think the steel cire is important to holding an edge against other weapons. Skeletonized for weight, and would probably have benefits in structure. Then the carbon fiber maybe inset on the sides if possible to add the remaining rigidity. I think this would work especially well in the blade of Ichigo from Bleach. The curved design would allow for plenty of deflection and glide. To me that means even if you manage to be overwhelmed with a giant sword, it should be light enough and tough enough to not let you down. Hopefully resulting in a genuinely useful partner if for some reason you have to use a sword
Great interaction guys - love your back and forth jibing at each other. Nice tests
So for the curious I made a Kevlar piece and kept a UV damaged piece for the guys which will arrive in their hands soon. No core, just 7 layers or so of biax and a basket weave in the middle most layer. The goal not being to make armour as such, to do that we just go thick, rather we just are trying combinations of materials to see how little mass and size is required to achieve the results.
Also, for any questions you have about the carbon sword, ask away and I’ll do my best to answer below.
Nice work here! Modern combat armor combines kevlar with plates of ceramics like silicon carbide. Have you ever done any experiments in this direction?
@@jamesyoungquist6923 yes, with plates of metal, 3d printed materials, carbon fibre, cast ceramic and tile. Resin impregnated kevlar wrapped around those items helps to contain them when fractured, and soft densely woven kevlar works as a shock damper behind that fracture surface which breaks up projectiles. For a shield, I'm thinking a light foam core, with Carbon Fibre and Kevlar layers front and back would be incredibly light and hold up to a surprising amount of punishment.
@@jamesmckenzie9551 dude that's awesome. Can't wait to see the results
Today I learnt that Nate watches CGPgrey and has learnt the truth about hexagons
"An hour would be way too long!"
Excuse me?
Hey Shad, love your channel and especially how you're turning it into a business. Keep on your path!
Entertaining video. Good job, guys.
mix resin, chopped carbon fiber and titanium coated diamond dust
pour into molds to make 80x60x5 mm lamellae
assemble into klivanion
carbon cataphract
Oh I like this... since we're going the full hog, perhaps replace the chopped carbon with carbon nanotubes?
Haven't heard much about nano technology lately.
@@MissionSilo Now you mention it that is true and the last thing I recall reading was to do with the suspected health hazards they pose to respiratory system.
I do remember (perhaps incorrectly) testing indicated significant improvement in flex and strength... It also feels we are one step away from suggesting Mytheril in terms of absurdity 😁
@@justinhollis5579I mean. Most strong fibers can ruin your lungs. Fiber glass. Carbon fiber. Carbon nano tubes. It's important to wear the proper ppe. Speaking from experience, bad lungs REALLY suck
youtube sabotages my attemps to elaborate
search "tech ingredients super strong epoxy with diamonds"
What you guys need to do now is test a sheet of steal that is twice as thick as the big square. While it would be a shot video, it would work as a "Base Line" so everyone can see how useful carbon fiber is.
For the sake of a fair comparison, you'd want the same thickness for all the test samples. I think comparing aluminum to carbon fiber would also be an interesting test.
@@kaylinosprey3306 I only suggested double because I'm fairly positive a strong sharp might puncture .5mm steel sheet. Oddly enough a google search failed to even consider this.
I don't know about you, but google as a search engine is getting worse and worse.
In general carbon fiber is more comparable to aluminum. So I agree with the other person
Haven't watched a Shad video in a bit. Love the new do Tyranth! Looks good on ya brotha.
Time to test pure-resin armor.
get one of those larper plastic armors?..
I've got you, we'll just get the guys to paint shad with resin and voila.
The arrow was very impressive. A mil of steel and Boromir would have been absolutely skewered. Considering the width and weight I think it did great. I think a mil of sheet steel on the outer layer would go a long way to stopping the edges and a thicker middle layer of foam would go a long way to stopping and absorbing a lot more kinetic force to slow down the chops and cuts before they transfer all that force through the entire piece on a very thin point or edge. And it wouldn't add much ofma difference in weight.
Just wanted to say Shad, youve lost a noticeable amount of weight and you look good man! Proud of you!
Even though I'm not TOO big on the whole "competition" side, you gotta love Tyranth's understanding of materials and making/building. And you gotta love Nate's YEARS of experience on wielding and using weapons. Together, they were the ideal hosts for this test.
I luv the dynamic between the two boiz😂😂😂😂
I make carbon fiber aerospace parts. Some of the window pieces they cut out will absolutely stop everything you have there and most modern arms. Thickness matters.
Couple this with steel wire tire armor 😅
Interesting stuff, guys! Good on you.
Yes! I've been saying this for like months! Old armor : New materials! Thank you!
You tested padding, mail, tyres, plate and carbon fiber........ But what about Dragons?
That’s what the asbestos layer is for. jk need modern starship material if you don’t want cancer
Day like 119 of asking for a video on the misconceptions of Medieval weddings
That might be a video better suited to Jason Kingsley of Modern history TV
@@mythguard6865 ok
A great composite armor. And a great composite duo for the video. Thanks, guys.
I am a retired aircraft technician and have a lot of experience with advanced composites. Carbon fiber is very strong but it is not very resistant to cutting or being pierced. Kevlar is far more resistant to being cut and pierced. All of the modern body armor uses a lot of kevlar. Most bullet resistant vests for higher caliber bullets also use ceramic and steel plates. I think for resistance to swords and arrows several layers of kevlar with a backing of carbon fiber would work well. Also if you have access to plate armor you should use it as a form. Put on several coats of mold release wax then do a wet layup starting with 3 or 4 layers of carbon fiber (the first sheet should have the weave being at zero degrees in relation to top and bottom of the breast plate with the 2nd layer being oriented at 45 degrees with the 3rd layer 45 degrees opposite to the 2nd layer with the 4th layer at 90 degrees. Then follow up with several layers of kevlar with the same orientations as the previous ones. Then put this into a vacuum bag with a vacuum pump while the resin cures. Look up how to vacuum bag a composite layup. Before putting it in the vacuum bag you put a sheet of perforated plastic sheet, then a sheet of breather cloth. The perforated sheet is usually mylar that has a series of small holes on a 3/8th inch pattern and the breather cloth is very similar to polyester fiber fill sheets used in making quilts. This is readily available at fabric stores, the thicker the better. The perforated sheet prevents the breather sheet from sticking to the layup. The holes in the perforated allows the excess resin to be sucked out, the breather sheet serves two purposes. It absorpts the excess resin as well as giving the vacuum bag to evenly apply the force of the bag across the whole part. When you suck the air out the air that surrounds the part presses down with 14.6 lbs per square inch. Using a vacuum bag gives an optimized ratio of resin to cloth which gives the most strength. A resin rich lay up is far weaker and very brittle. You will find that a composite breast plate with its compound curves will be very strong and should resist sword blows as well as arrows. If arrows pierce it make one with more layers of kevlar.
Police armor verses mideval weaponry
Agree. It would be very useful to know which weapons are most effective against Police.
One of my favorite Australian RUclips channels. Always cool stuff
Just discovered your channel. Awesome!
You could make a sick shield out of carbon fiber (with a steel rim). It would be way less cumbersome and more protective than your usual wooden shield. You could even pad the front of the carbon fiber shield to reduce incoming blows even more
I saw your video yesterday on the state of the channel. I have really strong anecdotal evidence to contribute. I'm working on a composite material project. A number of times I've searched terms related to "carbon fiber" on YT over the passed month. I've been steering towards boring lecture and fabrication type stuff and more towards exotic materials but this was popular, released recently, a channel I've spent dozens of hours on, and very very topical. This should have ABSOLUTELY been recommended to me. It's also a great alternative to all the powerpoint presentations.
It's funny that you've done this, we were just down at the archery range firing arrows at carbon fibre and fibreglass pieces to see how they'd do (spoilers, not well). Got another more extensive test planned with different layers, cloth weights, as well as some kevlar parts.
The delamination issue could probably be solved cheaply by drilling a few holes and putting pop rivets in strategic places.
One could also vastly increase it's armor value without increasing the weight to much by using cheap metal strapping with holes to run a mesh across the armor, makes it much stronger vs bladed weapons but doesn't do much for arrows, the attachment points then serves the same purpose as the pop rivets.
Evidently James is pretty passionate about the sword project if he volunteered samples for testing as armor. I hope he’s pleased with the results which honestly surprised me as well. It’s not as good as steel but is far better than say wood, the classical organic composite shields are made of.
Interesting nerdy stuff, love it.
The loose fit actually helps the carbon fiber here as the force is allowed to tilt the piece inward and increase the final angle at which the force of the edges are at their greatest.
Guy with a beard looks like a Champion, can see him and his posse wrecking sections of an enemy line.
A double layer of the fibre that's spaced might hold up better. By the time the broadest portion seems to sink into the structure, the slower moving edge won't have enough momentum to get through the second layer.
When carbon fiber is under tension, it holds up well. Under compression it tends to delaminate and crush. The edged weapons pierced pretty well, and the axe and katana would snap the resin, causing the whole plate to collapse. One important point about these, same as Kevlar for vests, is that they take damage from each hit and do become more likely to fail with every hit. If an officer takes fire and their vest is hit, that vest is expended and needs to be replaced.
Thank you!
Okay, now this is an experiment I love to see. I could use this as reference material for world building purposes
He knows about the bestagons! Yesss!
That was really fun to watch and interesting to know! The katana probably isn't the best weapon to test a thrust and a chop with, though.
I know you guys were focused on one particular piece for the bulk of your testing because that's what you were asked to do. However I would've loved to see the arrow tests done with the one that had the extra resin on it. Just going off what was in the video here, it and the main piece you guys tested seemed to be your best performers. I would've loved to see how the one with extra resin performed against the arrows vs the big piece you all tested.
Interesting. After the video about not getting recommended this came up in my feed.
In full support of the use of safety glasses in this episode.
Definitely need more of that in the Shadlands.
I'd be really interested to see these materials properly shaped into armor that was put together in a serious effort.
You guys should try some injection molded carbon composites. I did a facility tour at a supplier for work a while back and they had some ridiculously strong and light stuff. It's not as pretty as carbon fiber weave, but it's strength is omni-directional. It would also make more sense to use for kitting-out an army. The mold is expensive, but once you have it you can produce pieces very quickly and cheaply compared to layering weave. You'd need several molds to account for various sizes, but even then, if you are armoring thousands of people, economy of scale would more than make up for the upfront cost.
Laminated CF armour requires 2 foam screens minimum that are porous enough to allow full resin penetration. You also need to weeve some fibres directly though the mesh to increase layer bonding to prevent delaminatiin on the foam layer.
One problem I want to bring to attention is that non of these pieces look shaped like armor would be to redirect and deflect the energy of blows, for example arrows or axe blows would have a harder time connecting a perpendicular hit and glance off on shaped armor. If using flatter pieces, having stacks laced together more akin to traditional Samurai armor would have been a better test if wanting to use simple flat pieces.
This, along with hearing Shad's Veritasium video, makes me wonder how this carbon fiber would do with an iron vs steel core
Seems like interesting material, if it's relatively light weight then they should try stacking a few layers on top of each other, see how that holds up.
You'll still have to layer multiple sheets to get proper resistance. Have to manage the tradeoff in weight and thickness with level of resistance required.
Next step for shadiversity is: can a sword cut through quartz plated aluminum steel. My head Canon is nope
Seems like Carbon fibre can deflect slashing much better than piercing. feels similar to those heavier clothing pieces you received and reviewed in that way. Informative video as always.
would be excited to see how a "Scale armour" made of CF would do, or even Chain mail as the CF seems to be best against slashing rather then stabbing
Alright you know what, I'll be honest I hadn't clicked notifications in a little while and I was a little grumpy but YOU GOT ME ON THIS ONE
And hey more than an hour would Not be too long, do not forget your beginnings! Haha
You bunch of nerds! Love you.
Very interested to see future experiments in the hopes that you stumble across a piece of semi accessible carbon fiber armor for the everyday man. Not bullet proof (though that would CERTAINLY be interesting as well!) but stab/spike resistant.
So I had a thought. If you think of the carbon fiber like a blade wouldn’t you want to stack it so you wouldn’t be cutting into the layers? The structure and effectiveness is like a bulletproof vest. You wouldn’t shoot into the side of the vest. It would pass through the layers instead of getting caught. So would it be a good idea to maybe find a way to wrap the carbon around the edges ? Therefore it is reinforced by the layer count.
One thing that I always thought would make great armor was what they make North American football pads out of. That would be really cool to see you guys test!
It's a bit worrying that the swords bite into the edge of the fibers so easily, as those are the dimensions you'd really want to keep their shape if they were swung against something else (though I guess they're omitting the hard steel edges and possible springy materials to cushion the blow).
I love how the different parts of the axe were used against the actually-tough carbon fibres so we got an idea of how well they actually work (especially after hearing so many people swear axes/picks weren't "really" used against it.)
Thanks for the video, the bromance is real lol
from what i'm seeing.. the best combination might be a mixt between carbon fiber plates and some very light cloth armor. because the cloth will be able to stop even more of the thrust the arrows are dealing. for example you pack carbon fiber in some cloth armor and place them in pockets.. you'll definetly be able to stop arrows cuts and thrusts ( but may not stop the one with the spike that punctured the carbon earlier )
forgot to add, even the pockets would stop some of the force because it's in a pocket and if the armor is kinda moveable ( meaning if the arrow hits the armor itself will disperse the pressure as well like a t shirt being pulled on to the side while wearing it or something)
Carbon nanotubes rolled into tungsten carbide I feel is what tank armour is going it made out of in the future once nanotube production has become more optimised
Exactly those are composite. Carbon fiber gives you a light durable frame. Blunt impact and pressure resistance not penetration or cut resistance.
there's a company who makes camera equipment and accessories for camera rigs called smallrig, they make 15mm carbon fiber rods at varying lengths. if you were looking for something to chop, those type of rods are probably reasonably priced to do testing on
i want to say i enjoy this style of video alot more, its far more relaxed with less music and shilling. Just good old discussing and testing.
i'd like to see a real armor made of that, with double layer etc seems it look to be pretty light.
I'd say, resin & CF laminated together 15-20 layers, & shaped like classic plate, prob'ly would work well.
ty really does have quite a bit of strength.
the foam would act as a frangable layer to absorb shock, but once it cracks, it's not providing protection; in the same way as motorcycle helmets do. aka, you get one hit in any area before protection is significantly lost. There'd need a different solution, esp since sowrds and shock go together
combine this with chain link. this will give you stopping power, slashing protection and ballistics protection. Take old and new armor tech and combine it.
It would interesting to see how those bits of carbon fiber would perform as scale armor. Shape each cf 'scale' with a slight ridge?