@@lordmaniel3603 He kind of did, in a way. Apparently he was going to do it for a special DVD release that never came to be. Disney found out and went ahead with it.
My favorite thing about all this is they literally just added the "Maclunkey" shit on top of all the stuff they already changed, so it's a mashup of almost every edit they've already made all in one. I hope in 100 years they keep editing this one scene until this scene alone plays out like a RUclips Poop
@@magdavillafuerte505 Greedo doesn't know how to shoot. That's why Han is letting Greedo jibber-jabber so long. If Han thought Greedo was a threat he would have shot him way earlier. This is why Han was insulted when talking to Jabba, that Jabba didn't send one of his best guys but Greedo instead.
Everyone will be shocked once the version comes out where Greedo actually kills Han and the trilogy goes on with Greedo digitally replacing Harrison Ford.
It's honestly hilarious how although there's literally NO ONE who likes Greedo shooting first more, and it's been very vocalized over the years, they still think, "Okay, but what if... Maclunky."
It’s honestly really stupid. If Greedo shoots first, it takes away any semblance of him being threatening because he misses a shot from literally 2 feet away. That is worse than Stormtrooper aim. Greedo is officially the worst shot in the entire galaxy.
A_FINE_EDITION ... So greedo being blind or stupid enough to not even see or react to Han pulling his blaster off is more threatening than Greedo missing a precipitated shot on someone who was preparing to defend himself ? ... I’m sorry but I don’t follow you on that one :|
fidel garcia 2050 version: Han convinces him to stop his evil ways and they settle it peacefuly, everybody in the Cantina gets up and claps. Then Greedo’s gun accidentally goes off and shoots himself as he shouts Maclunkey!
2077 Jan gets up and greedos Lazer goes right through him so he orders all lazers but then just realized han was a force ghost projecting himself there and dies on some random island
I hope that in some future DVD/Blu-Ray release, you'll be able to build your own Cantina Scene, selecting the cuts, dialogue and subtitles, and just make it a complete mess where both characters are shooting at each the entire time
The band gets up and starts blasting, a shootout breaks out in the cantina while Han stands there frozen twisting his neck like a long worm to dodge every shot
Lucas will never allow it to be like that. He wants people to know his SE solely, not the original version, instead of easing it up and giving people choice and option to have what they want. It's only movies and he should love to please the fanbase which made him rich, but his ego is more important for him to be pleased. A strange guy.
There's a video on RUclips where the Star Trek TNG episode Conspiracy has been changed, so Picard and Piker are continuously firing their phasers. That's what immediately popped into my mind, lol
bigevilworldwide1 Wow how hard is it for you to understand? Lucasfilm has literally come out and said to the press that this was Lucas’ edit. The reason we see it only now is because this is the 4K restoration, which the 2015 digital re-release wasn’t.
So true, Harmy’s version shows how fun that movie was. And now? Take a look the arrival to the cantina scene, that establishing part with al the bad CGI takes so long, it damages the pacing.
It's not common knowledge but there's actually a clause in the original Disney deal that lets George Lucas edit this sequence whenever he wants in perpetuity. Lucas retains total creative control over just this scene. There's an editor ready to go 24/7 at Skywalker Ranch for whenever they get the call.
I am that editor. I quake reach time the phone rings, but it's just a notice to extend my vehicle's warranty. At this point, I don't know which is worse.
@@benfactsdontcareaboutyourf3705 I mean, there's not exactly a way for Disney/Lucasfilm to say "no" if Lucas grandfathered it into the contract of the sale... if he didn't sell, this was the version that was going to become canon, and we can see that even though he did sell, he made sure to make this version canon.
2027: Greedo calls Han a "Maclunkey" and then kills Han, but Han is revealed to actually be a Jedi and spends the rest of the trilogy as a CGI created Force ghost. 2077: For the 100th anniversary of Star Wars, a Special Edition is released and George Lucas' estate reveals in his will that he regretted all the previous changes to this scene. His final wish was for it to return to Han shooting Greedo. The ONLY change is a minor one in that the whole Cantina now yells "Maclunkey!" before Han pulls the trigger, because Han is still triggered by that word.
@C man Man How is that exactly? Fans do not have power to make creative decisions. It's quite weird modern flex to blame fans from your own shitty ideas and decisions. That tells most about personal insecurities and lack of responsibility from the creators part and nothing about the fans. "I made this cartoon/book/movie and it's shitty because of fans!" Yeah, nope, reality does not work that way. You make something and audience either likes it or not, they are not responsible for the end result, you as a creator are. If you let them make decisions for you it's still your problem and means you lack vision what you are trying to create. If you do not like feedback or criticism then its better to just write/create for the drawer and not publish anything. E.g. most of the enchantments Lucas did in e.g. Special Edition were totally unnecessary apart remastering the image quality and sounds and fixing few visual bugs here and there. The constant retouching and changing scenes years after years (even from edition to edition) is even weirder when there was no e.g. inconsistency problems in them in the first place.
A sudden DewBack collision with the cantina and it smashes through the wall right at the moment of their discussion and wall parts and dust are flying around.
But what if... I were to chop the legs off a character’s redemption arc and disguise it as my original vision? Hoh hoh hoh hoh, delightfully devilish, George!
2027: 50th anniversary special editions. Every blaster has its sound effects replaced by Maclunkey. 2077: before his death George Lucas was able to become an AI now every person in the world watches a Star Wars where everything is renewed each year
2222: It has become a tradition to participate in 'The Maclunky': A randomly chosen person has to wear a Greedo suit and get's shoot at by 20 Han Solo cosplayers with neck-spasms. The goal is to utter as many 'Maclunkies' as possible before getting hit.
@bigevilworldwide1 actually this was his decision to do this version was supposed to be re-released in cinema couple years ago(every single star wars was supposed to be re release from episode 1-6) but wasn't because of Disney buying the rights from Lucas , and re release was cancelled. So yes this is George fault
It sounds rhythmic almost, like he’s happy that Han understands him “You bet I have? Han, you old nerf-herder come here for a Greedo-hug you son-of-a-gun”
I seriously can not even believe this is still a thing. If anything their deliberately editing this, over and over, just for kicks! It's campy and full of humor. "Yeah, just re-edit the greedo scene again. Gets'em everytime!" This absolutely has to be case.
I just can't stop laughing every time I watch this new version now.even though I know what the true meaning of the phrase is it just sounds like he's saying to Han "you a******!"
Lucas thinks his edits make Han more heroic but it's the opposite: if Greedo can't hit a man at point blank range then Han didn't need to shoot at all, he could have just reached across and smacked the shit out of Greedo for it
"Daryl?" "Yeah." "Daryl, we need to you come into the studio and record some dialogue for Star Wars." "Mandalorian?" "Nah." "Obi-wan?" "Nope." "Last minute Ep 9?" "Try again." "Final season of Clone Wars?" "Keep going, sport." "Computer game?" "Nope." "C'mon, help me out here...give me a hint..." "...Maclunkey."
2030: Greedo draws his gun. Han Solo stares straight down the barrel and whispers "maclunky". Greedo's blaster explodes in his hand and he does the team rocket blast-off into the tatooine suns.
2050: They pull out ballon swords and fight each other, Han Solo hits him one time and Greedo falls over. Han then whispers maclunky into Greedo’s ear, as he dies.
2070: Greedo's shot goes into Han's nostril and bounces all over the inside of his body, before bouncing back out through his other nostril and killing Greedo.
The most annoying part for me is they just repeated the shot when he said "I've been looking forward to this a long time" look at the mouth movement, it's just repeated. They could of taken any other moment but now I can't unsee that, and now you can't either.
I mean that was obvious that it was repeated, how ELSE could it have been done. The whole edit to the scene with this maclunkey crap is bad and the sliding of the han's head makes it worse as it looks like he statically dislocated his neck. We ALL seen and we all know it so it's not anything new to point that out as it was clear as it could have ONLY been a repeat of the any of the original scenes as there's no way they could have recreated the whole scene just for "updated" look to the original scene like this.
TheSlender003 Official Lucasfilm has confirmed that they are officially retconning that part of Ep IX and Rey shall henceforth be known as Rey Maclunkey.
4 года назад+44
Rey: I'm Rey. Old lady: Rey who? (Rey looks into the distance and smile) Rey: Rey Maclunkey DIRECTED BY JJ ABRAMS
Actually, he does shoot first now. Before in the Blu-Ray release, Greedo shoots one frame before Han. Now, Han's blaster shot goes off before Greedo's, meaning we've gone from "Han is the only person who shoots"(1977-1997) -> "Greedo shoots first" (1997-2019) -> "Han shoots first" (where we currently are).
@MovieManiac33 Fair enough. I just saw a still where Han's blaster bolt was closer to Greedo's than Greedo's blaster bolt was to Han, so I assumed that Han shot first.
Lol the interviewer didn't even ask the question right. He asked "Did you shoot Greedo first or did he shoot you first?" No one got shot. And Harrison is damn tired of being asked.
In the second episode of The Mandalorian's second season, the blaster scorch mark can be seen on the wall in the booth where Greedo missed his shot. I guess this (unfortunately) establishes it as canon that Greedo fires first.
Not really, he could've missed *because* he got shot. We don't really have to listen to Disney to get what we consider canon. We know Han shot first, that was established.
God I forgot how bad that "Han Solo body twitch" looked in the Special Editions and later versions. 1977 original still the best and the way it was meant to be.
You look at the maclunkey and think about how delicious it would be. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it raw. You think about how delicious it would be if you at it cooked. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it boiled.
>Eat maclunkey You look at the maclunkey and think about how delicious it would be if you boiled it. You look at the maclunket and think about how delicous it would be if you cooked it.
Initially, "I bet you have" supposed to be a punchline before taking a shot and killing Greedo. This flow was ruined when 'Greedo shoots first' change was made. Now, this 'maclunkey' thing becomes a new punchline before taking a shot. What's next?!
@@BrotherDoink2 Han breaks into song about how he's tired of his boring live and decides to move to Coruscant and become a jazz singer. Greedo sings about how Maclunkey was his father who died in the Clone Wars and he just wants to follow in his footsteps. Han sings about forgetting the pain and convinces Greedo to follow him in his adventure. And then the whole bar stands up and claps
@@Kriss25Toku LMAO Piss off you fool. You should NOT say "fUcK hOmE aLonE" at all because home alone is amazing! And those movies are NOT "gArbAgE" at all in the slightest, your comment IS garbage thought and that's a fact. Home Alone movies are great as a whole! And you "hating" on that scared child face is pathetic because he's a great character and actor, you know nothing fool! And learn english to as your grammar sucks so bad.
George thought that Han shooting first made him a murderer, and murderers couldn't be redeemed. I think he forgot that the entire trilogy was dedicated to redeeming a child murderer.
Further changes planned. In 2022: "Yeah, I bet you have." "Maclunkey." Waiter arrives. "What would you like?" Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots. In 2025: "Yeah, I bet you have." "Maclunkey jozbo." Waiter arrives. "What would you like?" Han: "Wait." Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots In 2028: "Yeah, I bet you have." "Maclunkey jozbo krispo." Waiter arrives. "What would you like?" Han: "Wait." Greedo: "Go away." Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots. Greedo shrieks "Noooooo" and falls forward.
2039 version: Han: I bet you have. Greedo: Maclunkey jozbo krispo! *Waitress arrives* Han: Wait. Greedo: Sayonara, Han-kun... Ben Kenobi: Don't do it, Greedo. Han has the high ground! Luke: Master! Waitress: What's going on?? *Greedo shoota han* *Han frontflips onto the table* Han: Hasta la vista. *Han shoots* *And everyone claps*
I like that in the original we don’t really see who fires until Greedo falls dead, we just see the smoke and sparks and then we find out oh it was Han who shot
Paul Ashurst yes, hence Han shot second. Besides, if Lucas says his original intent was to have Greedo shot first/simultaneously, then it’s how it is, end of the story.
@@nathanjora7627 Lucas'original vision for that film would have made it a flop. Whatever George says the movie should have been like is superceded by what was originally committed to screen and in the original cut you only hear one shot and greedo goes down. It's supposed to be a quick draw scene and in those scenes one person gets the shot off and that is objectively Han who shot first. There was no second shot. Period.
Oda Swifteye 1) if there were two in Lucas’ mind, and an error was made in the editing room, how do you know only one happened ? 2) you really think the movie would’ve flopped if Greedo has shot first or simultaneously -_- ? Cause as far as I’m aware, it’s one of the few relatively important changes he made, meaning plot wise it was close enough to what he meant to do.
What's worst the fact that Greedo missed a LASER not even a meter away from the target, or the fact that Han dodged a laser traveling at the speed of light.
Lasers in star wars definitely dont travel at the speed of light though, less than a bullet probably. Its not even laser. More like plasma shots or something
**After the 50th version** Greedo sings "Mr Brightside" from the killers and starts break dancing and han whips out a ripstik wavyboard and backflips with it and breaks Greedo's back.
Your mind is full of thoughts about Maclunky, you think about how the maclunky will taste if you boil it, you think about how the maclunky will taste if you cook it
cat ...you are right. my longing for the unknown has been quenched. all this time wasted.. searching and the whole time its been right there in front of me. the very structure of my DNA is being rearranged by maclunky, soon my human shell will shed. maclunky.. in its purest form
You look at the maclanky and think about how delicious it would be. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it raw. You think about how delicious it would be if you at it cooked. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it boiled.
Man the scene just grinds to a HALT when he says “Maclunkey”! I know it’s only like 2 seconds, but those 2 seconds take away from Han’s perfect ‘last thing you’ll hear before you die’ line of “yes I’ll bet you have!”
@Goomba Jenkins the ''luke, i am your father'' phenomenon is easily explainable. its because when it is referenced in pop culture you have to add ''luke'' for context. ''no, i am your father'' is less recognizable out of context. so all the pop culture references saying ''luke'' are the reason people remember it that way.
@Goomba Jenkins you'd be surprised how little some actors remember from the movies/shows they were in. Do you think you remember correctly everything you've said or done? many actors actually don't watch their own movies or at least watch them way less than the audience. Samuel L Jackson is one of the few actors who remembers most of his lines from his movies.
@Rising Horizon Gaming Well George Lucas (Wether he liked it or not) gave the EU comics the go ahead while he still owned star-wars( before Disney). And he's one of the directors who's working on "The Mandalorian show." Plus, George Lucas even said,"If i didn't sell Star-Wars to Disney i would've love to make a Boba fett movie." So take that as you will.
I hope the next version, Han doesnt shoot at all. This time he moves his head and dodges Greedo's shot, which bounces off the wall and kills himself.
Bad Luck Greedo!
No wtf
Don’t give George ideas.
@@MegaManDBZX George doesnt have creative control anymore. This change was apparently made before he sold it.
BUT THE FUCKING WALL IS SOLID NOT BOUNCY WALL, WTF
I like how all of Greedo’s lines are translated except for “Maclunkey” as if to further make that line seem out of place.
Maclunkey is an english word I guess.
The phrase "maclunkey" is actually Huttese (the language spoken by the hutts) and it is translated as "ma klounkee", meaning "This is the end of you."
@@jamesshort3760 So I've heard. Funny that they didn't put that in the movie.
It was like when they don’t subtitle curse words for censorship purposes.
@@jamesshort3760 no, it means "my clunky". It's an insult which means old fashioned.
“Yes, I bet you have.”
“Maclunkey”
You really outdid yourself this time George.
Goddamn you, George Lucas!
But we still love you.
pretty sure George didn't edit it this time
@@lordmaniel3603 He kind of did, in a way. Apparently he was going to do it for a special DVD release that never came to be. Disney found out and went ahead with it.
Its like poetry
george doesn't own the rights to star wars, he didn't do this
"It's over Anakin, I have the high ground!"
"Macklunkey"
Thank you for the mental image of Hayden saying "Macklunkey" with his angst voice and pure hate Anakin stare
“It’s over Anakin! I have the high ground.”
“Mmm-“
“Don’t try it.”
“Maclunky.”
Oh god
High ground obi wan would still win. I mean... 𝐡𝐞 𝐡𝐚𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐡𝐢𝐠𝐡 𝐠𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝
YOU UNDERESTIMATE MY MACKLUNKEY!
My favorite thing about all this is they literally just added the "Maclunkey" shit on top of all the stuff they already changed, so it's a mashup of almost every edit they've already made all in one. I hope in 100 years they keep editing this one scene until this scene alone plays out like a RUclips Poop
GREEDO GOT SAND IN MY PINGAS
Tell Jabba sauce
beautiful souos
Eva 64 HAN THE SKY HAD A MACLUNKY!
Macklunkey maaaaaaaaaaaa cklunke jabba pingas mack my macklunkey
The way Han casually breaks his neck to dodge the blast cracks me up every time
Like the old "guy who moves his head" from Aladdin meme.
Tecnically he doesn't move his neck anymore but his head, implying Greedo doesn't know how to shoot.
Cracks just like his neck did.
@@magdavillafuerte505 Greedo doesn't know how to shoot. That's why Han is letting Greedo jibber-jabber so long. If Han thought Greedo was a threat he would have shot him way earlier. This is why Han was insulted when talking to Jabba, that Jabba didn't send one of his best guys but Greedo instead.
Looked like he was about to do the Walk like an Egyptian dance.
George Lucas: I’m altering the cantina scene. Pray I don’t alter it any further.
This scene’s getting worse all the time...
KamektheMagikoopa1 Lucas: perhaps you think you’re being treated unfairly?
Star Wars fans: nobody can ruin Star Wars more than George Lucas
Disney: Maclunkey!
jettspyder And Disney didn’t remove George’s edits, despite having full authority to do so
Julian R but Disney had the final say, and this is what they went with.
Petition to make the Han/Greedo scene slightly different in edits every year. Why? Because it would be fucking hilarious to keep this gag going.
Will not stop until Greedo performs a lavish dance number, in Huttese, before returning to be shot, after he shoots twice and throws a cane.
Everyone will be shocked once the version comes out where Greedo actually kills Han and the trilogy goes on with Greedo digitally replacing Harrison Ford.
Yeti Man LMAO
Yeti Man pissed myself laughing reading that
Waiting for them to CGI a baby bonett onto Greedo's head because why the hell not at this point...
The way he says maclunky just sounds like some weird meme edit
sos
it basically is
It sounds like text to speech
i think it was to disney
Gotta love how Han is able to dislocate his neck without moving any other nerves or tendons.
🤣🤣🤣
Seriously what was that
He be one sassy nigga, uh-uuuh
That movement is not impossible (Greedo was just a bad shot and would have missed anyway)
I feel like Mariano Yuba's comment is being way too overlooked.
Star Wars:we edited the greedo scene
Everyone: Yes I bet you have
Disney+: MaCkLuNkY
*P O W*
Disney: Pray we don't alter it any further
Damon Cassada It's outrageous! It's unfair!
@@DamonCassada345 it's Lucas's change
Top 3 best lines from A New Hope:
3. "I find your lack of faith disturbing."
2. "May the Force be with you."
1. "Maclunkey"
MisterNinetySeven 😂😂😂😂
Hello there
"Jabba, you're a wonderful human being."
It's honestly hilarious how although there's literally NO ONE who likes Greedo shooting first more, and it's been very vocalized over the years, they still think, "Okay, but what if... Maclunky."
SomeNerdyBoy I don’t mind it
It’s honestly really stupid. If Greedo shoots first, it takes away any semblance of him being threatening because he misses a shot from literally 2 feet away. That is worse than Stormtrooper aim. Greedo is officially the worst shot in the entire galaxy.
There always has to be one contrarian. It's called hyperbole, people!
A_FINE_EDITION ... So greedo being blind or stupid enough to not even see or react to Han pulling his blaster off is more threatening than Greedo missing a precipitated shot on someone who was preparing to defend himself ?
... I’m sorry but I don’t follow you on that one :|
SomeNerdyBoy not “they.” this is entirely George, one of the last changes made prior to Disney’s purchase
Everyone who likes this comment agrees with this change and thinks it improves the film for the better.
Then Greedos gub accidentally goes off and he shots himself
fidel garcia 2050 version: Han convinces him to stop his evil ways and they settle it peacefuly, everybody in the Cantina gets up and claps. Then Greedo’s gun accidentally goes off and shoots himself as he shouts Maclunkey!
Star Wars: Star Trek Edition.
Confetti flies from the ceiling.
2077 Jan gets up and greedos Lazer goes right through him so he orders all lazers but then just realized han was a force ghost projecting himself there and dies on some random island
I hope that in some future DVD/Blu-Ray release, you'll be able to build your own Cantina Scene, selecting the cuts, dialogue and subtitles, and just make it a complete mess where both characters are shooting at each the entire time
The band gets up and starts blasting, a shootout breaks out in the cantina while Han stands there frozen twisting his neck like a long worm to dodge every shot
This comment made me tear up, props to you for writing the funniest shit possible
Lucas will never allow it to be like that. He wants people to know his SE solely, not the original version, instead of easing it up and giving people choice and option to have what they want. It's only movies and he should love to please the fanbase which made him rich, but his ego is more important for him to be pleased. A strange guy.
There's a video on RUclips where the Star Trek TNG episode Conspiracy has been changed, so Picard and Piker are continuously firing their phasers. That's what immediately popped into my mind, lol
George: "I have altered the scene. Pray I don't alter it any further."
Fans: "this scene is getting worse all the time"
George: Additionally, if I ever return to Star Wars, I will edit the scene once more so those fans who criticize everything will be more upset
Joaquin Barboza George Lucas didn’t alter it, it was Disney
Vorphine Disney has confirmed that last edit was made by Lucas before selling Lucasfilm
@@joaquinbarboza3223 oh
bigevilworldwide1 Wow how hard is it for you to understand? Lucasfilm has literally come out and said to the press that this was Lucas’ edit. The reason we see it only now is because this is the 4K restoration, which the 2015 digital re-release wasn’t.
Star Wars, a film famous for being saved in the editing process, now infamous for being butchered in the editing process.
Ironic. They could save the original version with editing, but not the special editions.
So true, Harmy’s version shows how fun that movie was.
And now? Take a look the arrival to the cantina scene, that establishing part with al the bad CGI takes so long, it damages the pacing.
blah blah blah
RuyLopezQB6 and the purpose of that was...?
@@Purp1ehaz3 I get bored of being told how Lucas was both saved from his own franchise and at the same time later ruined it
It's not common knowledge but there's actually a clause in the original Disney deal that lets George Lucas edit this sequence whenever he wants in perpetuity. Lucas retains total creative control over just this scene. There's an editor ready to go 24/7 at Skywalker Ranch for whenever they get the call.
I am that editor. I quake reach time the phone rings, but it's just a notice to extend my vehicle's warranty. At this point, I don't know which is worse.
Greedo: IM GONNA SAY THE M-WORD
Han: THATS RACIST, YOU CANT SAY THE M-WORD
Greedo: MACLUNKY
xD
MS. ORGANA GET DOWN!
@@rekius328 Alderaan explodes
Can't say that... Greedo has the M-word pass
Cringe
Fans: Maybe we'll get the original versions of Star Wars now that Disney owns it
Disney: Muhclunky
@J.A. Harper They let it happen.
@@benfactsdontcareaboutyourf3705 I mean, there's not exactly a way for Disney/Lucasfilm to say "no" if Lucas grandfathered it into the contract of the sale... if he didn't sell, this was the version that was going to become canon, and we can see that even though he did sell, he made sure to make this version canon.
@@EscapeVelocity11186 Ah George putting salt on the wounds before he left.
I guess I don't understand what you mean by "original versions"
@@zehermanator2710 Oh dear.
2027: Greedo calls Han a "Maclunkey" and then kills Han, but Han is revealed to actually be a Jedi and spends the rest of the trilogy as a CGI created Force ghost.
2077: For the 100th anniversary of Star Wars, a Special Edition is released and George Lucas' estate reveals in his will that he regretted all the previous changes to this scene. His final wish was for it to return to Han shooting Greedo. The ONLY change is a minor one in that the whole Cantina now yells "Maclunkey!" before Han pulls the trigger, because Han is still triggered by that word.
Takin' it EZ with DZ faf😂😂😂
2080: Han pulls out the coaxium he got from Solo: A Star Wars Story and throws it down Greedo’s throat, blowing him up
Maclunkey
Next version: A giant CGI dinosaur walks in front of them, recreating the mystery around who shot first.
@C man Man How is that exactly? Fans do not have power to make creative decisions.
It's quite weird modern flex to blame fans from your own shitty ideas and decisions. That tells most about personal insecurities and lack of responsibility from the creators part and nothing about the fans.
"I made this cartoon/book/movie and it's shitty because of fans!"
Yeah, nope, reality does not work that way. You make something and audience either likes it or not, they are not responsible for the end result, you as a creator are. If you let them make decisions for you it's still your problem and means you lack vision what you are trying to create. If you do not like feedback or criticism then its better to just write/create for the drawer and not publish anything.
E.g. most of the enchantments Lucas did in e.g. Special Edition were totally unnecessary apart remastering the image quality and sounds and fixing few visual bugs here and there. The constant retouching and changing scenes years after years (even from edition to edition) is even weirder when there was no e.g. inconsistency problems in them in the first place.
LMAO
Brilliant!
A sudden DewBack collision with the cantina and it smashes through the wall right at the moment of their discussion and wall parts and dust are flying around.
sounds like a better idea than watching han unrealistically moving his neck to dodge the bullet
This shit is embarrassing, how many times can you change such a simple scene. The original was perfect now it's a clunky mess .
Steve Fernando I think you mean a muh CLUNK ee mess
Its clunkeeey
Why are you making a big deal about this when the Max Rebo Band still exists?
Exactly
counterpoint: Maclunkey
*in George Lucas voice* “Well, you know, the story just isn’t complete without Maclunky.”
I like that this scene has become George Lucas's Steamed Hams
You know, Solo, these hamburgers are quite similar to the ones they have at McLunkeys.
@@aneveningwithebola2727 No noooo, patented Hutt burgers. Old family recipe.
@@scottski02 Ah, I see.
"A MACLUNKEY?! At this time of year, at this time of day, in this part of the planet, localised entirely within the cantina..."
But what if... I were to chop the legs off a character’s redemption arc and disguise it as my original vision? Hoh hoh hoh hoh, delightfully devilish, George!
Me: I did it. After 22 years, I’ve made my peace with the Special Editions.
Lucas: MACLUNKEY.
Yes, I bet you have.
*M A C L U N K Y*
I will never make peace with them, nor subject myself to them ever again. I got the Despecialized editions and I’m free.
i hope your peace is as strong as iron... after that MACLUNKEY that happened there
It was Disney who made that edit not Lucas, because he doesn't own Star Wars now.
Honestly, I laughed out loud at “Maclunkey”. It’s just hysterical
It makes me laugh every time I hear it. It doesn't even sound like Greedo ffs!
2022: The shot reflects from added CGI dinosaur and hits Greedo
2027: 50th anniversary special editions. Every blaster has its sound effects replaced by Maclunkey.
2077: before his death George Lucas was able to become an AI now every person in the world watches a Star Wars where everything is renewed each year
2222: It has become a tradition to participate in 'The Maclunky': A randomly chosen person has to wear a Greedo suit and get's shoot at by 20 Han Solo cosplayers with neck-spasms. The goal is to utter as many 'Maclunkies' as possible before getting hit.
Everybody: No more changes!
George: Over my dead maclunkey
@bigevilworldwide1 actually this was his decision to do this version was supposed to be re-released in cinema couple years ago(every single star wars was supposed to be re release from episode 1-6) but wasn't because of Disney buying the rights from Lucas , and re release was cancelled. So yes this is George fault
@@johnhandzlik659 I dont believe you
@@Replica_Films2000 then don't believe me go Google it
That’s the idea
John Handzlik glad he got one more jab in at the people who won’t shut up about this scene
Me: oh they must’ve turned it back to the original cause everyone has been-
*watches updated version
*cries
*Cries in Maclunkey
Does Maclunkey mean “please shoot me while I shoot at this wall?”
Lmao
I think it means this well be the end of yoy
In huttese thats's mean ,,you're dead man"
Or it could mean "F**k you!" Only explanation why there is not a translation box.
Vedji It means “Han shot first”
There wa also footage of Greedo killing himself in prison, but it was mysteriously destroyed.
That cheery-sounding “Maclunkey!” was so out-of-place it made me laugh. This is now my favorite version of this scene.
John Jekyllson IKR?
It sounds rhythmic almost, like he’s happy that Han understands him
“You bet I have? Han, you old nerf-herder come here for a Greedo-hug you son-of-a-gun”
Young Nation
That honestly feels kind of like a HONDO line.
I seriously can not even believe this is still a thing. If anything their deliberately editing this, over and over, just for kicks! It's campy and full of humor. "Yeah, just re-edit the greedo scene again. Gets'em everytime!" This absolutely has to be case.
I'm hoping they'll add party hats next time.
I just can't stop laughing every time I watch this new version now.even though I know what the true meaning of the phrase is it just sounds like he's saying to Han "you a******!"
Hilarious that someone recorded that McKlunky line at least 6 years ago, and there wasn’t the slightest leak or rumor about it until it aired.
GREEDO SHOT FIRST! STOP SAYING HAN DID!
@@fuzzyotterpaws4395 it's actually which version you watch, in the original han does.
Lucas thinks his edits make Han more heroic but it's the opposite: if Greedo can't hit a man at point blank range then Han didn't need to shoot at all, he could have just reached across and smacked the shit out of Greedo for it
he just made han worse by killing a worthless bounty hunter
"Daryl?"
"Yeah."
"Daryl, we need to you come into the studio and record some dialogue for Star Wars."
"Mandalorian?"
"Nah."
"Obi-wan?"
"Nope."
"Last minute Ep 9?"
"Try again."
"Final season of Clone Wars?"
"Keep going, sport."
"Computer game?"
"Nope."
"C'mon, help me out here...give me a hint..."
"...Maclunkey."
Actually, his name is Larry.
@@Gemnist98 I was thinking of his other two brothers, my mistake ;)
(Gunshot)
MACLUNKY TO YOU TOO
2030: Greedo draws his gun. Han Solo stares straight down the barrel and whispers "maclunky". Greedo's blaster explodes in his hand and he does the team rocket blast-off into the tatooine suns.
2040: all guns are removed from the scene for being too violent. Instead, Greedo shouts "maclunkey!" Then immediately drops dead from a heart attack.
2050: They pull out ballon swords and fight each other, Han Solo hits him one time and Greedo falls over. Han then whispers maclunky into Greedo’s ear, as he dies.
2060: Greedo sits on an explosive whoopy cushion placed there by Han and goes boom.
George Lucas: I’m altering the scenery. Pray I don’t alter it any further
2070: Greedo's shot goes into Han's nostril and bounces all over the inside of his body, before bouncing back out through his other nostril and killing Greedo.
Fans: "George would you PLEASE STOP CHANGING IT!"
George Lucas: *"MACLUNKEY!"*
The head tilt is still the worst part of it
It's not even a tilt, it just pops or glides to the left
That shit is funny asf, its a michael jackson style tilt.
[RabbitHole] That’s why I like the 1977 one because it doesn’t have it
He literally just dislocates his head.
How about the shadow of Han's left hand? It moves up when his hand moves down.
They'll just keep on adding more to this one scene until it's a whole damn movie on its own
Don’t give Disney more ideas!
Maclunkey A Star Wars Story
Aaron Landry George Lucas is the one who changed it tho
@@tafram3342 beat me to it by a year
"Who Shot First?": The 10th Film by Quentin Tarentino
The Whole movie is 2 hours of Han and Greedo Talking before trying to shoot eachother
The most annoying part for me is they just repeated the shot when he said "I've been looking forward to this a long time" look at the mouth movement, it's just repeated. They could of taken any other moment but now I can't unsee that, and now you can't either.
I mean that was obvious that it was repeated, how ELSE could it have been done. The whole edit to the scene with this maclunkey crap is bad and the sliding of the han's head makes it worse as it looks like he statically dislocated his neck. We ALL seen and we all know it so it's not anything new to point that out as it was clear as it could have ONLY been a repeat of the any of the original scenes as there's no way they could have recreated the whole scene just for "updated" look to the original scene like this.
Everybody: Han shot first!
George Lucas: Maclunkey
Greedo shot first
Sounds like an expletive in response to the fans!
This has nothing to do with George Lucas anymore he sold Star Wars/ Lucas films
Jack Lame it’s actually George. He made this edit a long time ago but this version never came out since they stopped after the TPM rerelease.
@@IP_Films01 yeah but Disney decided to release it so
Rey’s parents were the Maclunkeys confirmed
Yeah, about that...
TheSlender003 Official Lucasfilm has confirmed that they are officially retconning that part of Ep IX and Rey shall henceforth be known as Rey Maclunkey.
Rey: I'm Rey.
Old lady: Rey who?
(Rey looks into the distance and smile)
Rey: Rey Maclunkey
DIRECTED BY JJ ABRAMS
You gotta spell it MacLunkey
I watched oneyplays, and somehow, without me even looking for it. This video pops up.
I’m not even mad. There was no reason for this, yet they did it anyways. This is hilarious.
The Fantastic Drill IKR
The Fantastic Drill I hadn’t seen the 2011 version either so I didn’t know they shot at the same time now. I’m dying hahaha
Casey Penk ... Greedo or Han ?
‘Cause Han definitely shot second.
@ChandSlam This wasn't Disney. It was our good old pal Georgie boy.
ChandSlam this wasn’t a change by disney
"MacClunkey" is Rodian for "I have the high ground...or do I "
Ed Vega no
Rodian for "This will be your end"
@@thefilmfan6326 Yes, mine was a joke
@@Milordvega No shit
@@danielbold6167 don't be rude. He was just meming.
Next version:
Han shows Greedo the sequel trilogy and Greedo kills himself
Ok
@@DerpaTure9503 No, the prequel trilogy is positively fantastic by comparison.
Underrated
Ryan Hussain so is your channel but you dont see me complaining
Also no the prequels are good
@@DerpaTure9503 No, it's brilliant masterpiece. Prove I am wrong.
So now not only does han not shoot first but he does not even get the last word :{
Actually, he does shoot first now. Before in the Blu-Ray release, Greedo shoots one frame before Han. Now, Han's blaster shot goes off before Greedo's, meaning we've gone from "Han is the only person who shoots"(1977-1997) -> "Greedo shoots first" (1997-2019) -> "Han shoots first" (where we currently are).
No in 1977 Greedo doesn't shoot first. He actually didn't shot at all. He juste explose whit a lot of smoke and no visible blaster shot from Han
@MovieManiac33 Fair enough. I just saw a still where Han's blaster bolt was closer to Greedo's than Greedo's blaster bolt was to Han, so I assumed that Han shot first.
that's a good point, that gun fire was the perfect punchline to his little sarcastic quip.
I'm sorry, I didn't catch a word you said. I was staring at your doughnut. Mahclunkeeey.
Interviewer: "Who shot first? Han or Greedo?"
Harrison Ford: "I don't care!"
That's because he is a normal human being.
Well then get the greedo actor!
@@cryztalyzed7372 actress*
Maclunkey
Lol the interviewer didn't even ask the question right. He asked "Did you shoot Greedo first or did he shoot you first?" No one got shot. And Harrison is damn tired of being asked.
In the second episode of The Mandalorian's second season, the blaster scorch mark can be seen on the wall in the booth where Greedo missed his shot. I guess this (unfortunately) establishes it as canon that Greedo fires first.
Not really, he could've missed *because* he got shot. We don't really have to listen to Disney to get what we consider canon. We know Han shot first, that was established.
@@matthewsimon6170 also, it's a Mos Eisley bar. Anybody could have been getting shot there everyday.
No, it establishes the Mandalorian as equally non-canon :p
How much you wanna bet greedo said “bruh”
"This will be your end" In Rodian
Give it 5 years
Nah he said Ok Zoomer
That alien who is scratching his head after this scene is perfect. That’s how we all feel about Maclunkey
God I forgot how bad that "Han Solo body twitch" looked in the Special Editions and later versions.
1977 original still the best and the way it was meant to be.
What were they thinking with these weird edits? I cannot comprehend.
if Han hadn't dodged, the blaster still wouldn't hit him
Agreed, It honestly has no point in being edited. Especially when each version has a different outcome of who shot first 🤣
If Han didn't break his neck, he would still have his neck
Cho Koon Storm Trooper reflexes
Don't give George any new ideas
Kahgro George freaking sold Star Wars to Disney 7 years ago- I mean 8
Replay button:
0:28
I don't get many days off work. It's Sunday, and this is now my whole day. Thanks a lot 🤨
*continues pressing replay
You the real mvp
M A C L U N K Y
You look at the maclunkey and think about how delicious it would be. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it raw. You think about how delicious it would be if you at it cooked. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it boiled.
You look at the macklanky and realize how delicious it would be.
>Eat maclunkey
You look at the maclunkey and think about how delicious it would be if you boiled it. You look at the maclunket and think about how delicous it would be if you cooked it.
boil em, mash em, stick em in a stew
you think about how delicious it would be if you ate it raw. you think about how delicious it would be if you ate it cooked.
I preffer gerkhins
>wake up
2020: This scene becomes an interactive Turn-Based shootout complete with HP Bars and -Midichlorian- MP Bars
Fun fact, Anakin said Maclunkey to Obi-Wan in Revenge of the Sith, just in Basic:
“this is the end for you, my master.”
2019 and Han's head still jerks to the side like amateurish editing.
It looks like something out of a YTP.
The bright red laser bolts look like s-ht, too!
BrickNinja 99 Han’s rubber neck looks like a cartoon
@@aaronlandry3934 Exactly. That's what makes me think of a YTP.
BrickNinja 99 The addition of “Maclunkey” is also very RUclips Poop esc.
Initially, "I bet you have" supposed to be a punchline before taking a shot and killing Greedo. This flow was ruined when 'Greedo shoots first' change was made. Now, this 'maclunkey' thing becomes a new punchline before taking a shot. What's next?!
Two words. Musical number.
@@BrotherDoink2 Han breaks into song about how he's tired of his boring live and decides to move to Coruscant and become a jazz singer. Greedo sings about how Maclunkey was his father who died in the Clone Wars and he just wants to follow in his footsteps. Han sings about forgetting the pain and convinces Greedo to follow him in his adventure. And then the whole bar stands up and claps
@@BrotherDoink2 Broadway Musical or Bollywood?
@@heyoyo10gaming4 both
“Maclunkey”
*Han pulls out a lightsaber and beheads Greedo for such an insult*
Me: "Hey Greedo, what's the name of that actor from Home Alone again?"
Greedo: 0:28
Macaulay Clunky?
Fuck home alone that movies was garbage and i hate the scared child face
@@Kriss25Toku I sense much anger in you. Good, good... let the maclunkey flow through you! Strike Home Alone down!
@@Kriss25Toku LMAO Piss off you fool. You should NOT say "fUcK hOmE aLonE" at all because home alone is amazing! And those movies are NOT "gArbAgE" at all in the slightest, your comment IS garbage thought and that's a fact. Home Alone movies are great as a whole! And you "hating" on that scared child face is pathetic because he's a great character and actor, you know nothing fool!
And learn english to as your grammar sucks so bad.
I’m surprised they haven’t created a “diplomatic” solution to this scene by now.
Farhad Azizi IT’S JUST BEEN REVOKED
@@LuckyLuke7895 "Uh, Han, Greedo didn't really set you up for that Lethal Weapon line."
@@scottski02 oh... I’LL HAVE WHAT SHE’S HAVING.
Well, it was an aggressive negotiation.
Im pretty sure this is it.. How can you not hate this version?
Next version: Someone else kills Greedo.
He kills himself
He kills Han Solo
@@cckiller0053 LOL the next special edition is they just replace Han Solo with Greedo
PokeDude011 Hahahaha!
Time traveling Rey.
i thought this was a joke or parody, so I checked it on Disney Plus and when i can't stop laughing now i found out this is actually real.
What was even wrong with the “Han shot first” idea? The guy’s a rogue who kills for a living.
And it was self-defense anyway.
Leia shoots first at someone who is going to stun her. Han shoots first at Vader. Shoots first at EVERYONE.
George became older and had a crisis of conscience which apparently only effected his feelings about this scene.
He also has a gun pointed at him, and just told Han that he intended to kill him
George thought that Han shooting first made him a murderer, and murderers couldn't be redeemed.
I think he forgot that the entire trilogy was dedicated to redeeming a child murderer.
Next version:
Hayden Christenen replaces Greedo
Sad
SuperRocketKnight I mean he did a good job In episode 6
I'll be okay with it if he still says Maclunkey.
So Han shoots his father-in-law...
Works with me
Greedo: Did you hear theres a new special burger at McDonald's?
Han: Really? What is it called?
Greedo: The Maclunkey
Absolutely nobody:
Greedo: MACLUNKY
MacCauley Culkin: Yes?
Further changes planned.
In 2022:
"Yeah, I bet you have."
"Maclunkey."
Waiter arrives. "What would you like?"
Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots.
In 2025:
"Yeah, I bet you have."
"Maclunkey jozbo."
Waiter arrives. "What would you like?"
Han: "Wait."
Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots
In 2028:
"Yeah, I bet you have."
"Maclunkey jozbo krispo."
Waiter arrives. "What would you like?"
Han: "Wait."
Greedo: "Go away."
Greedo shoots. Then Han shoots.
Greedo shrieks "Noooooo" and falls forward.
I've come up with a better one.
Han: Yes, I bet you have.
Greedo: Maclunkey.
Han: WHO'S scruffy-looking?
(Shoot-off)
2039 version:
Han: I bet you have.
Greedo: Maclunkey jozbo krispo!
*Waitress arrives*
Han: Wait.
Greedo: Sayonara, Han-kun...
Ben Kenobi: Don't do it, Greedo. Han has the high ground!
Luke: Master!
Waitress: What's going on??
*Greedo shoota han*
*Han frontflips onto the table*
Han: Hasta la vista.
*Han shoots*
*And everyone claps*
@@QuartzIsAnOxide Sadly that actually sounds like something Lucas would do.
They should make it an actual battle. Going back and forth and using the cantina tables as cover. Give Greedo more screentime.
Illustraful that’s fucking hilarious
Nobody:
Not Even a single soul:
Greedo:MACLUNKY
Missing at point blank range, Greedo must be the shittest Bounty Hunter ever.
That_One_Guy_Named_Rami Han scooted his head over
Andrew Dembouski still
@@AndrewDembouski Yeah to be fair Han looks pretty human; I wouldn't have expected him to be able to dislocate and relocate his neck at will.
EA Battlefront 1: I'm about to end that one guy comment career.
Manuel Amaya Muhclunky
Next version:
Han tells him a pun, both of them laugh, they order shawarma
Greedo just gets up and leaves
Release the Marvel Cut.
Thank you for putting MacLunky in the title so I could find this video easily.
I like that in the original we don’t really see who fires until Greedo falls dead, we just see the smoke and sparks and then we find out oh it was Han who shot
Andrew Dembouski *we find out Han shot him.
Both could’ve shot, from all we see.
@@nathanjora7627 no...hence han shot first
Paul Ashurst yes, hence Han shot second.
Besides, if Lucas says his original intent was to have Greedo shot first/simultaneously, then it’s how it is, end of the story.
@@nathanjora7627 Lucas'original vision for that film would have made it a flop. Whatever George says the movie should have been like is superceded by what was originally committed to screen and in the original cut you only hear one shot and greedo goes down.
It's supposed to be a quick draw scene and in those scenes one person gets the shot off and that is objectively Han who shot first.
There was no second shot. Period.
Oda Swifteye 1) if there were two in Lucas’ mind, and an error was made in the editing room, how do you know only one happened ? 2) you really think the movie would’ve flopped if Greedo has shot first or simultaneously -_- ?
Cause as far as I’m aware, it’s one of the few relatively important changes he made, meaning plot wise it was close enough to what he meant to do.
What's worst the fact that Greedo missed a LASER not even a meter away from the target, or the fact that Han dodged a laser traveling at the speed of light.
Lasers in star wars definitely dont travel at the speed of light though, less than a bullet probably. Its not even laser. More like plasma shots or something
Yep, blaster bolts are streams of ionized gas plasma magnetically yeeted from guns in Star Wars. Lasers are a different thing.
@@MaxMax-tt6db Whether it travels at light speed it not that relevant though. Han is not dodging that from 1 metre away.
@@Romans8-9 I mean probably not, he isn't force sensitive, but jedi can evade them. Those projectiles aren't that fast
@@MaxMax-tt6db I think we can both agree this was a stupid edit. lol
"It's over Han, I have the Maclunkey."
Disney: ok if you need anything else just let me know
George: hey Disney, when you bring greedo out.....can you make him say MACLUNKY
*Sometime in the year 2259*
"We've edited the scene. It's now exactly the same, but Greedo and Han have swapped places where they are sitting."
and greedo doges the bullet
And Star wars ends
@@SlothyTheDemon No, it turns into a completely new saga of Greedo with his infamous Maclunkey.
When I first saw this I literally thought it was a RUclips poop. What the actual hell man 🤣🤣🤣
Greedo: "I'm gonna say the M-word!"
Han: "Mrs. Organa, get down!"
Greedo: *M C L U N K E Y*
*low quality explosion sound effect*
Mrs. Organa where are you? Are you ok?
@@thescreenslaver8520 she is no longer with us solo and with her death I am free to say the M word whenever I please
Bekeon G.
Palpatine: Not if I have anything to say about it and I do. Prepare for my senate beam. *UNLIMITED POWER!*
**After the 50th version**
Greedo sings "Mr Brightside" from the killers and starts break dancing and han whips out a ripstik wavyboard and backflips with it and breaks Greedo's back.
I love how every change done to this one scene, makes everyone lose their collective sanity.
1977: Ralph McQuarrie
2019: Ralph McClunky
"maclunky" will always put a smile on my face
Your mind is full of thoughts about Maclunky, you think about how the maclunky will taste if you boil it, you think about how the maclunky will taste if you cook it
cat ...you are right. my longing for the unknown has been quenched. all this time wasted.. searching and the whole time its been right there in front of me. the very structure of my DNA is being rearranged by maclunky, soon my human shell will shed. maclunky.. in its purest form
NUTE GUNRAY: This is getting out of hand.. Now, there. 8,964,618,918 of them
We should never have made this bargon.
😂
Next version: Greedo’s shot hits a mirror and reflects back at him. Solo doesn’t fire at all
Han captures the shot with two pocket mirrors like in Totally Spies and turns it back on him like it's a turbolaser
@@FluffyDragon that shit broke all physics
nah it should bounce off a piece of metal like in angry birds star wars
Speaking of mirrors, imagine how funny it would be if the Death Star shot Alderaan and the laser accidentally hit a mirror
and people complain about how CGI Jabba looked in the added scene
"The Senate will decide your fate"
"I am the Senate"
"Not yet."
*IT'S MACLUNKY THEN*
Honestly the OG is the only one that even looks natural
You look at the maclanky and think about how delicious it would be. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it raw. You think about how delicious it would be if you at it cooked. You think about how delicious it would be if you ate it boiled.
Maclunky roughly translates to "I'm Force sensitive!"
Can it Osmosis Jones!
the hell
What if you
Wanted to go to heaven
But God said
MACLUNKEY
I'd shoot first would breaking my neck to dodge his shot.
Palpatine: I am all of the sith!
Rey: MACLUNKEY
Man the scene just grinds to a HALT when he says “Maclunkey”! I know it’s only like 2 seconds, but those 2 seconds take away from Han’s perfect ‘last thing you’ll hear before you die’ line of “yes I’ll bet you have!”
This is probably why and how The Mandela Effect exsists
It ripples out, man.
@Goomba Jenkins Han and Greedo have Mandela effect
@Goomba Jenkins they remember it differently so Goerge and disney altered the scene the way they remembered
lol
@Goomba Jenkins
the ''luke, i am your father'' phenomenon is easily explainable. its because when it is referenced in pop culture you have to add ''luke'' for context. ''no, i am your father'' is less recognizable out of context. so all the pop culture references saying ''luke'' are the reason people remember it that way.
@Goomba Jenkins you'd be surprised how little some actors remember from the movies/shows they were in. Do you think you remember correctly everything you've said or done? many actors actually don't watch their own movies or at least watch them way less than the audience.
Samuel L Jackson is one of the few actors who remembers most of his lines from his movies.
I genuinely thought psychicpebbles was making up the macklunky bit because it sounded so ridiculous
nope no gaslighting, they actually did this. Apparently George Lucas said that mcglunkey was the key to all of star wars
At this point it's clear Lucas is trolling us.
Good on him.
Evens Lindsay
We deserve it.
This is what we get for not liking the new trilogy
@Jakob Waack Do you mean the prequels, cause even George Lucas doesn't like the sequels.
@Rising Horizon Gaming Well George Lucas (Wether he liked it or not) gave the EU comics the go ahead while he still owned star-wars( before Disney). And he's one of the directors who's working on "The Mandalorian show." Plus, George Lucas even said,"If i didn't sell Star-Wars to Disney i would've love to make a Boba fett movie." So take that as you will.
When you’re a professional sent to kill someone but you miss a point blank shot
maclunkey
First, it was shot fired.
Then, it was shots fired.
Then, it was shots fired, reverse uno.
Then, it was shots fired, shots fired, reverse uno.