Puff in whole video had no more than 15 second when they show her And honestly this performance was bad, they weren't synchronized and sometimes their voices were not good
Xue Fu didn't get any screen time, even if she didn't sing much that's a bit too much. Even if she was on MBC's Global WGM, that's weird... Their singing is a bit lacking, I read it's an old song. Maybe this song doesn't suit them...
one of the reasons I like Taiwanese groups is because they don't look like made up robots! Don't get me wrong, this is coming from a kpop fan! But if you compare the two, taiwanese singers usually have a simple choreo and even when they do it, they don't look that much in sync! But Kpop groups are like 100% in sync! I feel like taiwanese singers don't go through the crazy training cycle kpop groups go through so I admire their entertainment agencies better! Most kpop groups look unhappy or they look too happy that it makes you feel like they're faking it just for the fans which isn't healthy! I prefer a simple choreo than something epic if it means that they had to go through hell to make it perfect! Just no worth it! Don't know if that makes sense but that's how I feel!
I am a Taiwanese. First of all, I am very happy that foreigners like you appreciate the beauty of Taiwanese groups,and I totally agree with you. There is a difference between South Korea and Taiwan in training idols,and I think Taiwan is mainly concerned with personal characteristics. The reasons for this include the social and historical differences between our two countries. I couldn't explain that much, but the performing arts culture can indeed reflect the differences in humanities and the society.
I agree too . Tia just can't sing the starting. She sang good at first ( in the music video ) , but I just don't know why she sang Don't Stop The Music very bad in the recently live performance. Anyway Puff is the best ?
Ugh stop complaining! They're both good and talented! Just because you like the other better doesn't mean they're better! I like all of them and the cameraman is crap but stop saying that one of them isn't good enough!
APHRODIA SYDNEY 你自己上韓網看那幾天的娛樂新聞吧，或找亞洲音樂節釜山都有! 記者可不是粉絲，照片刊的很大，表演隔天的報紙頭版就是郭雪芙的照片，不管是否是因為漂亮而被注意，這都是好事，最少華人圈子的女團比他們強的不是沒有，但是真的不多，美貌、氣質與運氣，也是能力的一種‧ 我可不希望10年後在電視上，只能看到韓國的藝人，華人如果自己不支持華流，未來別人瞧不起的也只會是華人
Yes it is one of there old song. I think due to the girls busy skedule eps. Puff with all her commercials and drama so luck of practice is the main reason. But still Puff is my fab. among the girls.
![Dream Girls -Don't stop the music官方舞蹈版MV [李毓芬+宋米秦+郭雪芙]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oXpe7k219sY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Dream Girls -Don't stop the music官方舞蹈版MV [李毓芬+宋米秦+郭雪芙]](/img/tr.png)
![[HIT] 아시아 송 페스티벌-걸스데이 & 드림걸스(Girl's Day & Dream Girls) - Something.20141107](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hf6kKphvuVc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HIT] 아시아 송 페스티벌-레드벨벳(Red Velvet) - Be Natural .20141107](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j-SpOPDbGkQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[중앙대 사범대학 댄스동아리 E:NCHANT 인첸트] 2023-2 정기공연 | 소녀시대-힘내! Way to go](/img/1.gif)
請大家多給他們一些鼓勵
在釜山氣溫只有5度的天氣下
穿這麼少跳舞真的很了不起！！！！！！
而且這是他們第一次在6萬多人的大型舞台表演
他們花很多時間練習 甚至連膝蓋都跳到瘀青
他們真的很棒了 謝謝他們的表演 ：）
2022 看起來~~~
其實現場音場超好耶
而且三位歌聲沒怯場，很值得鼓勵了！
Needs more puff. I feel like the cameraman loves Tia
I agree you
+Li G yasss I agree
Toi chi thit quach tuyet phu ma thoi
Bruh Puff is trash 🤢 look at her dancing at the start. Literally worst dancer and singer in the group
Puff in whole video had no more than 15 second when they show her
And honestly this performance was bad, they weren't synchronized and sometimes their voices were not good
Tia的節奏感最好
跳舞也不失性感 ❤ ❤ ❤
2019回來看
幹開全麥很厲害了超級...
2024回來看已經很厲害了...
Tia~
They are singing LIVE!!! REALLY nice job!!!
Are you serious
APHRODIA SYDNEY 你很無聊你知道吧，你自己留言想要給意見就算了，別人覺得表現好的妳來回覆這什麼東西? 人家覺得好你質疑什麼意思的?
自打臉? 上面留言說什麼每個人可以有每個人的意見，那又關你什麼事?
這麼喜歡by2或外國人你怎麼不出國生活算了?
就是有你這種這也弄那也弄，難不成要每個人都跟你一樣批評才爽?
有什麼問題嗎 這位 ^_^?????
黃詩涵 謝謝妳~幫我說話:)
黃詩涵你不也是一直去回覆我的留言嗎？我要不要回覆要不要質疑什麼時候你管得著了? 如果我的質疑會讓她失去表達意見的能力我才覺得神奇呢
按照你的說法我覺得dream girls表現不好也不干你的事啊，你還不是去留言了，你才是自打臉吧
遇到瘋子有理說不清～
I love Tia so much !!
yaassssss
Me too..
Tia lee looks like Solar from mamamoo.
Ji Di Thats what I thought when I first saw Solar lol. They both have similar facial structure
老實說我覺得他們三個人都有自己的工作，別說練習時間了 可能連見面時間都少，而且又唱又跳本來就比較困難，所以說他們準備不充足甚至是丟台灣人的臉這些話是不是有點苛刻過頭了?還有他們在唱dying for love這首慢歌的時候其實是唱得不錯的，建議批評的人可以去聽聽看在下定論也不遲~~
Puff didn't get enough screen time. I know the other girl is the lead and the other one is from Korea is that why she didn't get shown . Smfh
Hey this is the group with puff in it!!!!!! That's soo cool !!!
Thank you for the video!!! Tia
Tia超正的♥ ♥ ♥
Xue Fu didn't get any screen time, even if she didn't sing much that's a bit too much. Even if she was on MBC's Global WGM, that's weird... Their singing is a bit lacking, I read it's an old song. Maybe this song doesn't suit them...
I love Tia
Tia is all around. She has that seductive, beauty, sexy, cute look without evn trying. Her team up with Aaron is Perfectly matched.
Exactly
I love TIA LI!!!!!
Tia's the only one with any decent talent
lil bit mess, honestly.. but Tia's amazing flawless visual saved me
Puff so beautiful
Tia Lee is so pretty, talented & humble. TIA ALL THE WAY!
Puff love you
感覺他們很緊張!!!
不過加油阿!!!!!!!!!
We alyz love puff u r amazing on every thing
現在來看真的好很多🥺全麥欸，超越一堆人（？
Who's here after watching Before We Got Married?
uhmm.. does the cameraman hate Puff or something? I think I can count the seconds of Puff's camera exposure with my ten fingers. like what? o.O
one of the reasons I like Taiwanese groups is because they don't look like made up robots! Don't get me wrong, this is coming from a kpop fan! But if you compare the two, taiwanese singers usually have a simple choreo and even when they do it, they don't look that much in sync! But Kpop groups are like 100% in sync! I feel like taiwanese singers don't go through the crazy training cycle kpop groups go through so I admire their entertainment agencies better! Most kpop groups look unhappy or they look too happy that it makes you feel like they're faking it just for the fans which isn't healthy! I prefer a simple choreo than something epic if it means that they had to go through hell to make it perfect! Just no worth it! Don't know if that makes sense but that's how I feel!
To dance correctly and clearly as a team is not important. I agree with your point- not robot but in their own special way:))
I agree with you
I am a Taiwanese. First of all, I am very happy that foreigners like you appreciate the beauty of Taiwanese groups,and I totally agree with you. There is a difference between South Korea and Taiwan in training idols,and I think Taiwan is mainly concerned with personal characteristics.
The reasons for this include the social and historical differences between our two countries. I couldn't explain that much, but the performing arts culture can indeed reflect the differences in humanities and the society.
These camera operators are so weird literally only did close ups on two members.
Tia
Puff!!
真的毓芬跳得最好。。很有感覺
PUFF !
Tia is so pretty
Why they didn't show puff that much..tia always appear on the screen can't even see puff sing her full line
Im agree with you i don't know why didn't focus puff enough i saw tia's face all the time i was fed up to saw her
I agree too . Tia just can't sing the starting. She sang good at first ( in the music video ) , but I just don't know why she sang Don't Stop The Music very bad in the recently live performance. Anyway Puff is the best ?
Error typing : Puff is the best !
Ugh stop complaining! They're both good and talented! Just because you like the other better doesn't mean they're better! I like all of them and the cameraman is crap but stop saying that one of them isn't good enough!
I love tia li😘😘😘❤❤😍😍😍😍
love Tia!!!!!!
They sing loud and clear, unlike others, can't really tell they sing or not.
great performance long hair...tia
I love puff guo
雪芙好棒
如果有舞群會更好
我也覺得是
她們整個很賣力 辛苦了
唱現場比現在很多韓國女團好了
現在很多女團都不唱現場連開半mic都沒有
I️ feel like Puff didn’t get enough camera time... 😞
Puff and Roy = 🙌
長得很漂亮倒是真的啦！......
尤其李毓芬在大成報生活購物版亮相時還是個名不見經傳的小模時我就已經注意到她的美了...。
....Thank you KBS the great timing! I still can't believe it 00:22 ^^
puff does not have enough camera time
真的是丟臉丟回臺灣，做為歌手Dream Girls一直都不怎麼樣，她們在臺灣會紅多是因為演戲，而韓國製作方會找上郭雪芙也不過是看準了她在臺灣的人氣，有眼睛耳朵的都看得出來她們根本唱的不好跳得也不好，人家韓國粉絲說好聽點只是在客氣，自己臺灣人還真的相信啊，韓國演藝圈多難生存還沒聽說過，什麼當天很冷或是很緊張，是當其他團體都不怕冷不緊張嗎？
不要說什麼很忙沒有空練習啊之類的話，難道其他人很閒嗎？
我知道她們這次練到瘀血，但事實證明只是她們平常根本沒有花心思，所以最後即使練到瘀血也才如此。臨時抱佛腳沒有用。
可以去翻啊她們當時宣傳期的時候表現也沒跟這差多少，可能還更差，並不是生疏可以拿來講的。
實力這東西本來就是長期累積的，而她們在臺灣都稱不上是多用心的一個團，說是花瓶也不為過。
韓國現在紅成這樣，以為是為國爭光受邀嗎？
我看還比較像是讓國際看笑話了，讓別人都以為臺灣歌手的程度就是如此。
真的丟臉丟大了
真的有如你所說的是丟臉嗎?Dream Girls表演完之後韓國的娛樂頭版，照片幾乎不是郭雪芙就是Dream Girls，甚至只是報導亞洲音樂節的，一樣放的是郭雪芙的照片，請問丟臉在哪裡?
曾經受邀在韓國當地表演的請問有幾個上過頭版?
還有她們臨時抱佛腳練到瘀血的那隻合作舞，占整場的點擊率第二
那是因為郭雪芙跟希澈扮演假想夫妻，所以那些粉絲才會關注她，他們喜歡的依舊不是她身為歌手這一點，你自己去看留言，覺得她們唱得好跳的好的有幾個，好聽點的還不是客氣委婉的帶過去，不然就是放在外貌上，說漂亮啊鏡頭少啊什麼的，再來呢就是一些臺灣的粉絲開始幫她們的狀況不佳找一大堆藉口。
事實上韓國不怎麼邀請臺灣的藝人，所以若真要比當然無從比較，當然臺灣團體到別國表演值得鼓勵，但她們做為歌手本來就不是上上之選。
不過是徒個觀眾比較熟悉的長相。
點擊率跟頭版,報導只不過是因為她是希澈的老婆。
APHRODIA SYDNEY
你自己上韓網看那幾天的娛樂新聞吧，或找亞洲音樂節釜山都有!
記者可不是粉絲，照片刊的很大，表演隔天的報紙頭版就是郭雪芙的照片，不管是否是因為漂亮而被注意，這都是好事，最少華人圈子的女團比他們強的不是沒有，但是真的不多，美貌、氣質與運氣，也是能力的一種‧
我可不希望10年後在電視上，只能看到韓國的藝人，華人如果自己不支持華流，未來別人瞧不起的也只會是華人
韓國當道，他們辦音樂節自然很多別國的人會注意，有很好的曝光率，是很好的機會讓他們看到臺灣流行音樂，但請的卻是Dream Girls這樣的團體，讓大家以為臺灣的歌手現在都是如此。
我沒有不支持華流，我也不是韓迷，我也很希望臺灣娛樂產業可以有很好的發展，而正是因為韓國現在實力堅強我們才會相對的備受威脅，她們這種表現對比韓國團體只是顯擺著臺灣多不堪一擊。
你現在的心態就只是求國際能看臺灣一眼，不管到底端的是什麼東西，沒錯，美貌也是能力的一種，但是歌手講求的是音樂，我們應該要宣揚的是臺灣的音樂，不是可以短暫吸引人目光的外貌，難道你打算以後臺灣推出去的就是這種外貌團嗎？原來我們的流行音樂特色就是漂亮?
不要講得好像Dream Girls在華人女團裡面是比較強的一樣，她們只是比較紅的，而為什麼應該不用我重複強調，不管是臺灣還是大陸經營女團都很不成功，這是主要原因，並不是因為她們好。
我都已經快要懶得跟你再講一遍，不管是記者還是粉絲，她們會被邀請和關注只不過是因為郭雪芙是金希澈的老婆，我也用不著去翻報導，我沒有不相信她們被報導了，只不過那根本無所謂，因為那沒辦法證明什麼。
我們應該要藉由這種機會讓國際看到臺灣的流行音樂值得被關注(不是讓漂亮的藝人被關注)，漂亮對於我們的音樂產業發展一點幫助也沒有，人們會被外貌吸引住沒錯，但不會因此對臺灣的音樂產生興趣，10年之後華流可能還是會被韓流壓著打，而正是因為有你這種人的這種心態。
台灣就是一堆這種只知道謾罵而不知道鼓勵的人太多，難怪被人稱為鬼島，在我看來你的心態才有大問題，對於只看到負面的人，心態怎麼健康‧
韓國團體真的有比較好嗎?台灣歌手有比較差嗎?見仁見智吧!!~
不好意思說一句!在郭雪芙還沒跟金希澈演出夫妻之前，我知道是SJ，但是成員有誰我還真搞不清楚‧
韓國團體歌不錯聽，舞蹈的也好看，但是我從來沒有因為聽到他們的歌而起過雞皮疙瘩，但是台灣倒是有好幾個歌手能做到這點‧
最後吐嘲你一個現實，如果連引起別人的注意都做不到，你既使說他在好，那都是屁‧
多給台灣歌手一些鼓勵，讓他們的路更長，都好過自以為是的批評，把台灣歌手的路都斷光，妳也是台灣人，也是在老外眼中的華人，不是嗎‧
Hay❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
puff didn't have any lines ?
why kbs not showing that puff girl? do they have a grudge her?
Is it their song? Why aren't they organized on their steps? *no bashing
Yes it is one of there old song. I think due to the girls busy skedule eps. Puff with all her commercials and drama so luck of practice is the main reason. But still Puff is my fab. among the girls.
Marsha Joy 1 year isn't old
the song is not old at all actually. you just can't compare girl groups in taiwan to korean girl groups. they're not trained at the same level.
Hi😁
Puff
雪芙的舞蹈有跟很多跟別人不一樣- -
是跳錯嗎?
芙芙並沒有跳錯喔！只有最後那個是大家自己跳和芙後面有忘記一點
一開始也是只有芙有那一段的舞蹈，你可以找官方舞蹈版查
嘉欣徐 他應該是說1:23~1:26那裡吧，雪芙很明顯掉拍了…且有些地方也會看旁邊的跳
那就是有點跳錯囉！！
嘉欣徐 有跳错吗？ sin chen 她有看旁边吗？
❤PUFF❤
这个影片虽然没有那么多糊糊的镜头，但下一个影片和girls day合作的something有比较多糊糊的镜头
我愛的毓芬
唱現場！！！
至少人家敢真唱 唱的也沒走太多音
麻吉亼 能上这样的舞台不错了台湾多少艺人上过
沒走太多音...，噗～
puff～
台下觀眾整個一頭霧水....哈哈哈哈
Their dancing... not in sync! 😱😱😱
Looks like they are dancing on their own.
既然知道是在那麼大的場面表演更應該準備到最完美不是嗎 一個專業歌手舞者該有的態度。
歌和舞都這樣
這種表現根本像趕鴨子上架
真的不要丟台灣的臉啊…
那你上去表演啊?
只會批評說風涼話
zeng jing-yi
你有事嗎 那是身為一個藝人該有的態度好嗎？
每個職業都有應該守好的本分
而他們到了韓國就代表著我們臺灣
表演的不好不該受指教嗎
我的確是滿風涼的真抱歉啊呵呵 因為我的身分不是藝人
你上去表演看看啊~我看你就有多厲害
哈哈哈 也是可啊啊你是要來看嗎
你先買下那個場再說吧
Sandy Lin 又不一定要買這個場景阿有必要這樣嗎？
cute tia li
好乾...
加油！
再接再厲
听到歌声时，观众都吓呆了
Tia *V*
확실히 우리나라 가수보다가 대만 가수를 봐서 그런지 뻣뻣하고 부자연스러운 면이 없지않아 있네 대만에선 엄청잘나간다 하던데 대만아이돌 수준이 다이런건가 특히 곽설부 연기로 봤을땐 귀엽던데 제일 뻣뻣하다
is this promotion of C-pop in the land of K-pop?
米秦❤
郭雪芙是在跳什麼啊？看看啊昏好嗎
真的。。。李毓芬真的是團裡最會唱又最會跳的女神
真的。。。李毓芬真的是團裡最會唱又最會跳的女神
They need to improve their dancing, and yea they hardly showed puff
luv..tia 😘..she's so gud
後面真的很亂。音量的控制 真的要加強。
Love Tia and Puff,......but tia should really stick dancing/singing......not acting...sorry
her acting is natural, please open up your eyes carefully if you know how to judge.chisin...
我们的糊糊穿最少嘞，一点镜头都不给她吗？好坏哦！
Best Tia
郭雪芙不會跳舞？
還以為她們要唱韓文的…………😂😂
為什麼不帶伴舞阿~好尷尬的感覺…
Em Diana 其實只要歌手本身的實力夠堅強的話，伴舞是可有可無的…😮
秦回韓國
當然不能跟韓女團比，光唱歌就很喘，不過整體還可以
2266
吵架瘦的
хреново поют
Ceritanya apa sih.. mana lagu bahasanya susah dimengerti.. cingsafuciesingfasiah hah singtgaule hahahaha ..
。。。
bad
好難聽
춤진짜못춘다각목임?고등학생들연습시켜도저거보단잘추겠네
That was so bad 0_0
有夠難聽 覺得丟臉
真的很丟臉…