Also, I would like to mention a small detail. Felix does not look surprised (but rather sad) during the whole video, not only because he is too young to understand such things, but also because he is the only one who knew about it initially, unlike everyone else. Felix was stuck in this game prison the longest, so he was able to sufficiently realize himself and others
@@aminaqif542 That was the way it was meant to be. I wanted to make not an apple in principle, but a mixture of the character and the soul that possesses it. Therefore, it is something like a human-apple (?) And I won't fix it
I love how the ages and designs of the Andy's Apple Farm characters fit who they originally were in real life before coming into the game, it's creative!
You really put a lot of effort into this, Margaret and Andy actually act like Kamryn and Thomas arguing, while Melody and Felix actually act like children having to listen to their parents argue. Meanwhile Claus represents Arthur a lot. The designs are amazing too. You made the characters act like their actual selves if they were to actually react to the video, and the designs are good, too. Great Work! -Someone in the internet
I love how this actually have a story before they react, not like other video, ppl would just randomly appear in the room and they just doesn’t question anything and just- stare at the screen with a blank expression
FINALLY!! A Gachatuber who do reaction videos that aren't just "tEEhEe iT iS i ThE DepreSsEd toXic cinNAbUn tRappINg YoU in THis MEdIA RoOM" and actually has a backstory of how and why they ended up in the situation they are in of reacting to said video. I also love the little details that they're hooked into what they're watching, and they're actually showing emotion other than just going D: with the blackest shade in GC to make it look like they're.... Sad??? Yeah, you see my problem here. This is the second reaction video I've ever enjoyed watching. Kudos to you!
I love everything about this! The movement of the characters, their different reactions, the designs of the characters, and the general cannon feel it has. I can’t express how much I love this haha! Keep up this amazing piece of art! ❤️❤️
I love how you made Felix(Louis) and Melody(Isabella) they’re so cute and yes ofc Andy(Thomas), Claus(Arthur), and Margaret(idk how to spell the name) are really good
I freaking love the beginnin! The creator doesn't talk to them and the idea of them simply finding a disk and needing to figure everything out themselves is genius. Have yourself a new subscriber!
i like the unique pre-reaction and the mini story! usually people will just, idk, teleport them in with little to no context of what they were doing before hand. it's a nice change of pace!
@@vexxie- I men wasn't the person that became Andy being controlled? He was yelling at voice (or in other words the entity) in his head telling it he didn't want to kill anyone but he was forced to anyways. I noticed someone mentioned it was just like William Afton but William killed for immortality (I think), Andy's real self killed cause he was being manipulated and controlled, that what makes Andy the most easy to sympathies with. Andy's real self had no actual say in what happened and he didn't want any of it, so the real villian here is the entity who manipulated everyone and got basically everyone killed
Have fun trying to sleep at night Andy :) well knowing you are a murderer :) But no seriously I love this video you don't see a lot of Andy's Apple Farm reactions -^- so this was a very nice to watch :)
I love all of the characters designs because they all have the same characteristics from when they were alive and shows which character's are which like for example:Andy has a beard because he use to have one when he use to be alive and another example is Felix being small because he was a child. Keep up the good work! ❤
The effort you put into this is admirable! There's alot of reaction videos that just have 3 screenshots in and no actual dialouge, this is very refreshing! And quite surprising aswell :) i appreciate the effort you did to make this!
Dude i love your designs! Never thought I'd see Andy with a beard but it surprisingly fits him! Great video too! The characters are pretty in character Haha Are you gonna do a followup to this?
I love how all of the designs represent the family, I always knew that Felix would have a younger kid design to him- and they all look so adorable! Also Andy kind of😳
You have a amazing imagination, this concept was really original, I think the other comments speaks for itself if I'm being honest. You got a new subscriber
I loved everything about this (Despite only now seeing the first part of the video) I love how it's like another part of the game with andy's personality and well just his diologue
Currently rewatching this for the 10th time cuz im just INLOVE with the vid!! The designs, the qccurate personalitys.. qnd most importantly... THE LLLOOOOOOOOREEEEEEE‼️‼️‼️
I'm subbing. Your reaction vids are really well done. Instead of the standard reactions, you go further by making it realistic. It's rare to have the characters go into deeper conversations while the video plays.
I mostly listened to game theory's video cause I never really looked into the game that much but learning about what this game opens up to has actually disturbed me more than anything else in many years
I love your designs of the characters, they are so spot on to how the characters look. Plus I love all the expressions you use on them because they're amazing! 💙💚❤💜
although i noticed a layering issue during the video actually playing and andy himself, its a really well made video. the commentary seems believable and HOLY HELL the character designs are cute :D
What I really love about this is they don’t they don’t interact with the with the creator at all they just find it in the pond I really love that thank you
I’m hoping they find “him” in the Barn again and ask him why he was in there in the first place and why he was chasing Andy But yknow, the characters seem similar to the human characters Thomas is Andy Kameryn Is Margaret Isabella is Melody Luis is Felix the Fish And Arthur is Claus
You have to get referenceS Of the Family like Andy have beard like Thomas Felix is small like Louis Melody is also small like she used to be And yeah sized, characters details all hinted that they were the family gotta love that fact
I like how you make them find it themselves and walk there unlike other gacha tubers who teleport them there but you actually make logic with them finding it and walking there to watch it
ok but seriously. who stays around in a game for hours waiting to find a loop in the song with no backround noises so they can post it for people to use?
My god you scared me with the glichey lines over the video, I just got water in my laptop and I was TERRIFIED, I literally just paused the video to go put it in rice then realized the lines weren't moving and I was being an idiot!! 😭 Great video though!!
*the weather just brings a good mood and foreshadows a lot of good things today. I sure hope this continues for the rest of the day* MatPat: Allow me to introduce myself.
Also, I would like to mention a small detail. Felix does not look surprised (but rather sad) during the whole video, not only because he is too young to understand such things, but also because he is the only one who knew about it initially, unlike everyone else. Felix was stuck in this game prison the longest, so he was able to sufficiently realize himself and others
Btw can you fix Andy like remove his beard.
@@aminaqif542 That was the way it was meant to be. I wanted to make not an apple in principle, but a mixture of the character and the soul that possesses it. Therefore, it is something like a human-apple (?) And I won't fix it
@@coffeesweet204 oh.... Ok then.....
Hi
Andy looks so good i love your design
I love how at the beginning it was so innocent then became really horrifying
Like DOKI DOKI literature club!
@@mellchinoi_does_gacha3216 NO I CANT ESCAPE THE DDLC-
I LOVE ANDY'S APPLE FARM
Kind of like the game it seemed cute at first but then it got more cryptic as time went on
Ya
I love how the ages and designs of the Andy's Apple Farm characters fit who they originally were in real life before coming into the game, it's creative!
literally first minute and im already in love with andy's design lmao
Same
SAMEE
@@ketchup489 i agree with ur username
I know right :D
Same bro
You really put a lot of effort into this, Margaret and Andy actually act like Kamryn and Thomas arguing, while Melody and Felix actually act like children having to listen to their parents argue. Meanwhile Claus represents Arthur a lot. The designs are amazing too. You made the characters act like their actual selves if they were to actually react to the video, and the designs are good, too. Great Work!
-Someone in the internet
Your talking to me?
I love how this actually have a story before they react, not like other video, ppl would just randomly appear in the room and they just doesn’t question anything and just- stare at the screen with a blank expression
I know it feels so fresh and much more interesting that way doesn’t it?
@@SingleIsFreedom..ilyLuka yeah
FINALLY!! A Gachatuber who do reaction videos that aren't just "tEEhEe iT iS i ThE DepreSsEd toXic cinNAbUn tRappINg YoU in THis MEdIA RoOM" and actually has a backstory of how and why they ended up in the situation they are in of reacting to said video.
I also love the little details that they're hooked into what they're watching, and they're actually showing emotion other than just going D: with the blackest shade in GC to make it look like they're.... Sad??? Yeah, you see my problem here. This is the second reaction video I've ever enjoyed watching. Kudos to you!
Something I find funny about Andy's apple farm is that when Andy is offered an apple he just stairs at them, but Felix is fine with fishing
Yup lol
… CaNnIbAlIsM aNd MuRdEr ArE fUn!
I like how mat points out that the fish is fishing but not that an apple has a apple farm
Edit thanks for 210 like wow
😂 maybe this should have been added to his cannibal week 🤣
Hello Internet! Welcome to food theory!
@Ari Darkeneye maybe
@Ari Darkeneye mayhaps possibly
Nah bro he just mass reproducing. I hope-
FINALLY,SOMEONE REACTED TO THAT VID!
The designs and movements are amazing! I love the reactions and,it's just a masterpiece! Great job
This is really cool! I hope you do one about the christmas update, cause it does show more lore and is amazing
ayo danganronpa fan
Ayo other me
Omg yasss
I have been summoned
Yay another fan. : D
You have no idea on how much I wanted someone to do this video I was looking for one like this weeks ago thank you for making this
I like how you gave Andy a beard, saying that he is in a very old video game so he is old.
It's also because Thomas had a beard too
I love everything about this! The movement of the characters, their different reactions, the designs of the characters, and the general cannon feel it has. I can’t express how much I love this haha!
Keep up this amazing piece of art! ❤️❤️
This is really good
Keep doing more stuff like this
Maybe they'll react to the christmas update theory for this game?
i love how you made andy and margaret fight just like kamryn and thomas were, you nailed it in this video!
I love how you made Felix(Louis) and Melody(Isabella) they’re so cute and yes ofc Andy(Thomas), Claus(Arthur), and Margaret(idk how to spell the name) are really good
I freaking love the beginnin! The creator doesn't talk to them and the idea of them simply finding a disk and needing to figure everything out themselves is genius.
Have yourself a new subscriber!
Sooo glad your not lazy, I love the wording of your character reactions as it feels like how they would actually put it together as they watch it.
17:39 I liked how Felix the fish called Andy the apple "dad"
Can you blame him, though? That's a kid..
i like the unique pre-reaction and the mini story! usually people will just, idk, teleport them in with little to no context of what they were doing before hand. it's a nice change of pace!
i like how they got to react to the video, not like the others where the creator teleports the characters to the reaction room
I'm giving Andy the most comfort now.
GIVE ME HIM.
Must. Give. Hug. >=^
*Gives Andy a hug*
But Andy's real self killed somebody-
@@vexxie- just like Willam afton but people still like him
@@bearbean2063 Exactly
@@vexxie- I men wasn't the person that became Andy being controlled? He was yelling at voice (or in other words the entity) in his head telling it he didn't want to kill anyone but he was forced to anyways. I noticed someone mentioned it was just like William Afton but William killed for immortality (I think), Andy's real self killed cause he was being manipulated and controlled, that what makes Andy the most easy to sympathies with. Andy's real self had no actual say in what happened and he didn't want any of it, so the real villian here is the entity who manipulated everyone and got basically everyone killed
Have fun trying to sleep at night Andy :) well knowing you are a murderer :)
But no seriously I love this video you don't see a lot of Andy's Apple Farm reactions -^- so this was a very nice to watch :)
I’ve never played, or watched any videos of Andy’s Apple Farm, but I already love the lore!
I really like how you gave the video an honest intro. Instead of just teleporting them into this room to watch the video.
I love all of the characters designs because they all have the same characteristics from when they were alive and shows which character's are which like for example:Andy has a beard because he use to have one when he use to be alive and another example is Felix being small because he was a child. Keep up the good work! ❤
The effort you put into this is admirable! There's alot of reaction videos that just have 3 screenshots in and no actual dialouge, this is very refreshing! And quite surprising aswell :) i appreciate the effort you did to make this!
Dude i love your designs! Never thought I'd see Andy with a beard but it surprisingly fits him! Great video too! The characters are pretty in character Haha
Are you gonna do a followup to this?
I love how all of the designs represent the family, I always knew that Felix would have a younger kid design to him- and they all look so adorable!
Also Andy kind of😳
I LOVE EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS, THE DESINGS, THE REACTIONS, THE VIBE, THE GAME ITSELF, THE THEORY, ITS SO GOOD🙌🏻
Watch superhorrorbro
And it be more scary
can we just talk abt the designs for a sec like can we just admire the creativity
Okay, I'm less than 2 minutes in, and I'm already in love with the character designs, they are great!
You have a amazing imagination, this concept was really original, I think the other comments speaks for itself if I'm being honest. You got a new subscriber
I loved everything about this (Despite only now seeing the first part of the video) I love how it's like another part of the game with andy's personality and well just his diologue
ah, what a better way to watch game theory videos! now i can both enjoy matpats theorys, aswell as cool chibi characters!
I love this so much the designs are just great and my heart burned when Felix said dad😢
Currently rewatching this for the 10th time cuz im just INLOVE with the vid!! The designs, the qccurate personalitys.. qnd most importantly... THE LLLOOOOOOOOREEEEEEE‼️‼️‼️
Yooooo this is so good! Love the idea, your designs, their reactions...everything is so well done!
I'm subbing. Your reaction vids are really well done. Instead of the standard reactions, you go further by making it realistic. It's rare to have the characters go into deeper conversations while the video plays.
I love the short moment where everyone gets the irregular eyes while MatPat is trying to figure out what Margaret is
I mostly listened to game theory's video cause I never really looked into the game that much but learning about what this game opens up to has actually disturbed me more than anything else in many years
This was so good you need a break after doing this masterpiece it must have been hard work
I love your designs of the characters, they are so spot on to how the characters look. Plus I love all the expressions you use on them because they're amazing! 💙💚❤💜
This is wonderfully made! One of my favorite reaction videos I’ve seen
This is so well ade! The old grahpic added. how you made them. Their reaction! All of it! I love this and I am subscribing :D
Omg finally someone made this!!!
Im so happy!
although i noticed a layering issue during the video actually playing and andy himself, its a really well made video. the commentary seems believable and HOLY HELL the character designs are cute :D
bro they where so happy at first like "woah this looks cool can't wait to see-" sees the video "I have depression and suddenly I wanna hurt somebody!"
What I really love about this is they don’t they don’t interact with the with the creator at all they just find it in the pond I really love that thank you
For so long I was waiting for this and it came true
Girl
WE NEED THE NEXT ONE FOR SHOWEL NIGHT!!!!!!!!
I love this vid (keep doing this stuff)
I’m hoping they find “him” in the Barn again and ask him why he was in there in the first place and why he was chasing Andy
But yknow, the characters seem similar to the human characters
Thomas is Andy
Kameryn Is Margaret
Isabella is Melody
Luis is Felix the Fish
And Arthur is Claus
And Peter is a entity stuck in Thomas's mind!
That's exactly what I was thinking!
Am really looking forward to their reaction to MatPat's second theory on their game! The designs are great and I love their reactions.
You have to get referenceS
Of the Family like Andy have beard like Thomas
Felix is small like Louis
Melody is also small like she used to be
And yeah sized, characters details all hinted that they were the family gotta love that fact
fuсk future
come back to past withou gacha
I like how you make them find it themselves and walk there unlike other gacha tubers who teleport them there but you actually make logic with them finding it and walking there to watch it
Every moment this video plays We can just tell Andy has so much ptsd from this
I love how creative the start of video is, unlike others where they got teleported out of nowhere and is totally chill with it:)
You should really make them react to the next episode of the Andy’s apple farm game theory!
THE CHARACTERS LOOK SO GOOD!!! HOW DID YOU MAKE THEM LOOK SO GOOD?! (I love it :] )
I would love to see a sequel to this
Good theory game theory and I really like your characters they’re so pretty!!!!!
This is what everyone calls a masterpiece ✨💕
I absolutely love the way you set this video up!! Very creative
thank God i finally found you i thought your channel was deleted or something
Love your ctc style makes him look cool as hell
I AM IN LOVE WITH THIS VIDEO
question: are you planning on making a react video on the second game theory video? (If not it’s totally fine)
Andy: ❌
Andy wit beard: ✔️
“ first character in the game that started with the letter a”
Andy: am i a joke to you
THIS IS FUCKING INSANE
It is incredible!!!!!
You get the honorary award of one of the best gachatubers out there
ok but seriously. who stays around in a game for hours waiting to find a loop in the song with no backround noises so they can post it for people to use?
*Andy thinking it’s gonna be a good day*
Coffeesweet: Are you sure about that?
Anyone here in 2024?
Me
The red Charmander reporting for duty
Yup
Me!!
Yes
"Confused map hat needs to know whats going on in this this" got me diein🤣🤣
why is this in my recommended
2:15 “if HE was lying in the lake“
WOAH that kinda foreshadowed- idk if you put he on purpous but that was really good foreshadowing ngl
"Oh, what a wonderful day today!"
The fandom, LITERALLY THE FANDOM: haha, *no.*
These are amazing characters I love how much time you put in these it really looks like from the game
I loved this video when I was in my Andy apple farm phase
I also played the game and beat it all
"Thomas eastwood"
My goofy ahh mind: THOMAS THE TRAIN ENGINE!!11!!1!
I love how you didn’t just shove them into a room and told them to react like all the other videos I’ve seen like this.
I liked the beginning of your video when they find the disk, I really hoped there would be a conversation after the video. But still great video 😍
OMG!! IVE BIN SEARCHING FOR ANDY'S APPLE FARM GACHA FOR SO LONG THANK YOU!!!!
Finally someone who actually used the normal beard instead of a accessoryyyyy
My god you scared me with the glichey lines over the video, I just got water in my laptop and I was TERRIFIED, I literally just paused the video to go put it in rice then realized the lines weren't moving and I was being an idiot!! 😭 Great video though!!
andy looks like he waited a million years for melody to sing lmao
i love your desings and the reaction were canon!
this video is very cool!
FINALLY SOMEBODY MADE THIS VIDEO-
:DDD
AND ITS SO GOOD😭
this is so original like seriously first time i see this its always them who get teleported in all other react thing
Felix so schmol I love him **insert hand grabbing with large eyes**
Finally something that make sense then just pop out of the thing air
*the weather just brings a good mood and foreshadows a lot of good things today. I sure hope this continues for the rest of the day*
MatPat: Allow me to introduce myself.
never see this type of opening before, it's kinda unique to see this, from all the reactions, i have seen this is by far the most promising.
Holy crap that theory video was heavy, I'm definitely staying up all night
The characters are just amasing keep up the good work
20:24 it’s kinda giving will and the shadow monster
this gotta be one of the best gacha reaction videos ive ever seen
THE WAY WHEN I SAW THE BLACK MAN I JUST PULLED OUT A MIDDLE FINGER