Israelis: If you are not religious, why live in Israel?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 авг 2023
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
![Megan Thee Stallion - Otaku Hot Girl [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/USxIYOaIpig/mqdefault.jpg)
Judaism it's not religion only but people, culture, history, tradition
A lot of it is a lie
@@FreedomsNurseA lot of what? Be specific
@@GolfUB ruclips.net/video/e1mc4EKrpEY/видео.html The origin of the Ashkenazi people, they are not from the Levant, their DNA origin is mostly from Europe.
I need to watch your channel more regularly (I just made sure I have the bell on). Whenever you interview in Hebrew, I find it easier to understand on your channel than others (well, the subtitles are a big help) because there's a very specific context, so I can listen in for related words.
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
Thank you for the effort. I found your videos are very unique and helpful
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
Judaism - religion
Jewish - ethnicity
Exactly like British, Danish, Irish, Swedish.
Jewish people came from Judea.
I hope it's clear for everyone
Not really. British, Danish and Swedish belonging are based on civic citizenships and living on a same territory. There is no such rule as "you are British if your mother is Swedish, regardless of where you were born". Even if imperfect, comparisons with ethno-religious identities such as the Armenians or the Druze are better.
@@gerfaut9700"jus sanguinus" is the basis for most european countires citizenships.
Most of them don't come from Judea, that's why they're scared to DNA tests
No those people are yazidis
@@JewFromIsrael55522 you guys don't even speak ancient Hebrew. That's Yiddish
There is some kind of duality in a term Jew. It's both ethnicity and religion. For secular people etnicity and culture define their belonging to Israel. I usually think about it in Russian. In Russian you have different two terms for this: еврей (for ethnicity) and иудей (or religion)
Judaism is a religion, not a race. The Jewish race is a lie
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
But aren't Judeans a tribe of the Isralietes?
Judah is a tribe of the isrealites but the people you see today claiming to be them are impostors (genesis 15:13 Then the Lord said to him, “Know for certain that for four hundred years your descendants will be strangers in a country not their own and that they will be enslaved and mistreated there.
@@barbellvgo2424 no, those are Europeans converted to Judaism, the natives of the land are the Palestinians, they are the descendants of the people mentioned in the bible. In biblical times they were Jews who converted to Christianity and later to Islam. It is probed by science that DNA shows that Palestinians are the natives of that land,
Judaism is a religion not an ethnicity.
are you sure?😂
@@haruntanzir3631
Yes of course it is
@@Ermek57 yes so people can convert to jews and become citizen of Israel?
Always great to see Corey's interviews!
As an Israeli I wished to live in Switzerland or Norway or Canada instand but you don't get to choose where you born. Other countries won't accept you in just because you're seeking to live there. But poorer countries in Africa and asia want you and you don't want to go there. So that's reality, you live in a place you wish to leave to a place you always dream but won't let you in.
I just don’t believe you. You are not the person your are claiming you are. Go to France, they are welcoming everyone, especially low IQ without any qualification.
Yes the religious people are taking over (higher birth rate), Israel will be like Iran in the next decades. I also want to leave but I cant
America will let you in
@@ori1676why can’t u leave?
I dont have another citizenship or money for this@@notyourtypicalcomment2399
I have a question for Palestinians: "What is a specific thing that happened to you or an immediate family member that you would have Israel officially recognize and redress if you could?"
Often Palestinians will discuss their grievances in general terms like "This was our land for generations. The Israelis are colonizers" and such. I would like to know specific stories: e.g. "We own a house in Jaffa that Israelis live in now and the courts refuse to recognize that it's ours. I would like the Israelis to give it back" or "My grandmother's jaw was broken by an Israeli during the Naqba and she would like an apology" or "My family's olive grove was plowed under for a settlement. I would like another olive grove and financial compensation for the lost revenue, with interest." That kind of thing.
Do you live in another planet?
All what happened since 48 and you still asking
@@nashmi-8609 Nothing happened to them
Muslims are liars by default
It's called Taqqiya
Nothing happened to them
Muslims are liars by default
It's called Taqqiya
@@nashmi-8609 "All that happened". So , that is exactly the kind of answer I always hear, but never anything specific. I'm not from the region, so all I see is a back-and-forth: Palestinians fire rockets, Israel retaliates, Palestinians feel even more aggrieved. If you are Palestinian, what specific injustice has been done to you personally or your family by Israel other than some kind of general "existing" or "destroying Palestinian culture" or "all that happened"?
@@mirabrown2271it's more about they want to live freely and not in a Israeli police state
Keep up the good work Corey. I like your videos, i hope there will be piece between the Israelis and the Palestinians one day soon. It's about time to work hard for piece negotiations on both sides.
@@ShaniHodiaB. It depends how the older generation wants to teach their future childrens, hate or love, me myself I'm not into any religion, religions are just something that was invented to control people and brainwash them. When you have extremism on both sides, you can never achieve piece because of that, secular jews and secular Muslims can achieve piece but the only thing that stops it is the extremist on both sides and the human greedy nature is also the factor of the issue.
@@ShaniHodiaB also the Palestinians and the Jews of the Middle east are the same people from beginning, cannanites. Both Jews and the Palestinians have the right to the land, even in the Muslims Koran it says that the Jews will come back to their land, but I don't think it refers to the European Khazars who converted to Judaism, those ashkenazi Jews are not the Jews of the Bible, they became Jews much later, zionism and real Judaism is totally different things. The pure Jews is the samarian Jews.
Antichrist will give peace but he is the son of devil the antichrist maschiah
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
Thanks! for doing this.
Thanks!
I was born in Kuwait but the Royal Family’s government there treated me and called me stateless!
Thank God I am American now & converted to Christianity.
No more Muslim!
Very sad for you.
that real pretty girl with the brades made the most sense of them all , we believe or do not believe we are still jews .
She had bright green eyes.
She's using black ppl hairstyle
That just prove they are not Jews, they appropriate the African American culture
African American are real jews
@@TravisRileywho are actually the real biblical Hebrews
good questions in your channel
Jews speak local language, have local culture, local history and local religion.
Arabs speak foreign language, have foreign culture, foreign history and foreign religion.
I got a Jewish Zionist mom. An Egyptian Muslim husband. Dad is Christian. My parents love & go to Israel. Anyhow, I find this fascinating. I think it's because Jews see themselves as a nation whether they practice the religion or not. I am extremely, extremely, extremely Jewish looking & Jews are always saying shalom even though I have a Muslim husband.
extremely Jewish looking, which means Ashkenazi looking or like Palestinian Jews?, or like the Palestinian Christians who are the group with more genes from the Levant.
@adrianabotello9911 I am extremely Ashkenazi Jewish looking...like people literally say shalom..have the nose the eye shape the curly hair...the bottom heavy body but fit. The long oblong face with the jaw. I look Jewish as heck. My mom looks quite a bit like Barbara Streisand...she's naturally blond and had multiple nose jobs because her nose was large
the problem isn't between the Jews and the Muslims, the Muslims are the one who let the Jews in the holy land twice, the problem is having a country their, this country belongs to who lived on it, anyone who lived on it have the right to it, but Eastern Europeans don't at all
Armenians- if you are not religious, why live in Armenia? This line of questioning is absurd. People born into certain countries, cultures, languages won't just leave because they are not so religious. This is home.
It's not absurd. Being Jewish is different, far more different. Being Jewish is keeping Shabbos and unqualified belief in G-D and that G-D granted the Torah at Mt. Sinai.
@@victorblock3421Not true. Judaism isn’t a religion. It’s an ethnicity primarily.
Yet u expect Palestinians to do that? Hypocrites
@@dannyh7894 I have no expectations from Palestinians except for abandoning the terrorism-glorifying narrative and negotiating a final border with Israel.
It’s not the same, those Russians poles can go back their respective countries. Leave the Middle East for middle easterners!
I found a good exercise for you: you must do it for a week. Take note of all the lies that you say (small or big). At the end of the day ask yourselves:
1) How many lies did I tell?
2)What kind of lies are they?
3)Why did I tell them?
4) What’s the wrong behavior behind them? Fear? Need to be appreciated?
5) How many of them may have been avoided?
6) What would happen if I had told the truth?
In most of the cases the answer to the sixth question is that things would not change very much, you would struggle less.
A video about the similarities or the connection between Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Muslims....I think people would reorient themselves when they learn new things.
Thank you
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
@@Peculiarsteve oh wow amen amen amen
Whether you think of it as a religion or a people (it’s both btw), the fact remains that the sole establishment of the ancestral Hebraic homeland was religious based. It’s not something that can be erased or removed. People who don’t want to accept or acknowledge this , that’s their choice but as far as I know it’s always been religious based.
Herzl and Ben Gurion weren't religious
@@robloxfanboy86 they didn’t establish the ancestral homeland.
Let me say this, there is historical and archeological evidence that the Jewish people originated in Israel. That obviates the need for a secular Jew to rely upon religious teachings for raison-d'etre to live in their historical homeland. (I know many Americans from other ethnic groups who have returned to ancestral countries.) And how can we be certain that throughout history each person born into the Jewish community was religious?
@@viewercjg all maybe true, except for the reason why Israel originated there. You guys keep dancing around the most obvious reason as to why Israel existed/exists in the first place. It would never have existed had it not been for God’s command. It’s purpose was to be a light upon other nations in accordance to God. So that’s not going to be the case, then what use is it to Him?
@@viewercjg Gibberish
No one actually knows where Jews originated from, Zionist delusions notwithstanding
Jewish is nationality not just religion
Close;
Ethnicity.
@@maxs.5112 Jews are an ancient civilization, an over 3000 year old people/nation - Am Israel - indigenous to the land of Israel. They existed long before western concepts of nationality, nation (state), race or ethnicity.
The jews running the country are earopean converts. These are not Hebrews.
Without living a Jewish life, there will be no Judaism.
It's both. Jewish religion, culture, language, and nationality are all intertwined, as opposed to Judaism's daughter religions, Christianity and Islam, which are purely religions.
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but where do we submit questions? In the youtube comments, or anywhere?
You email them to Corey.
@@CanadianMonarchistwhich mail :)
What a weird question. People generally live where they were born. You also can’t just move to any country you choose.
He doesn't mean it.
All the people commenting on this video don't understand why he is asking them this question.
As a religious Jew, I know exactly what he means.
Because Israelis claim God gave them the land meanwhile many Israelis don't believe in God or doesn't keep the covenant with God. All they do is kill and displace innocent Palestinians in God's name.
[People] generally live where they were born.
[Palestinians] generally live where they were born.
Yet expulsion of Palestinians and apartheid exists.
@@eh2542 well i think there is something political behind the question. The way that haredim takes most government money to their sector as if they are expecting everyone to lakhzor bitshuva. And the way many israeli trolls would say: get out of this country! You smolan okher israel!
Well, that's one pertinent question. The whole origin of Israel existence is religious only. Not believing in God is itself a substantial mistake one can make. If people live where they were born than Israel would have not existed.
I live in israel bc i was born in israel… its not like theres a house waiting for me abroad if i decide that i dont believe in god lol
Because I was born here, lived here my entire life and I don't need permission from anyone to live here
Shai’s little girl is adorable!
The Jewish people have a ride to the land, not simply because God said so, but because we are indigenous to the land, being Jewish is not simply a religion. It’s an ethnicity. Hitler did not simply kill religious Jews.
They are not, most Israelis have nothing to do with ancient Israelis genetically and did you know which modern populations are the closest to the ancient Israelis? Its the Samaritan, Lebanese and Palestinians what a surprise right? Jacob from Brooklyn is not as ``Jewish`` as Mohamed from Beirut. If i call myself Chinese do i become a indigenous because i feel so? No you have to prove it with your genetic ancestry
Because Judaism is an ethno religion so you don't need to be religious to be Jewish. A jew is a jew no Matter what.
That might be true as a definition but not living as a Jew means destruction.
@@victorblock3421Which also means that the current occupation of Palestinian land is not permitted by God and the time is ticking before they get exiled once again...
Don't you have 72 virgins to blow?@@salahuddinyusuff
The chosen people with 65% of their population being atheist. 😅
So WHO Chose YOU to BE "The Chosen" ???
The disgusting thing is that this arrogant woman laughing in the beginning stating "my family lives here" acting like its a dumb question is exactly contradicting what they did to the Arabs in that region. They well know what they do and think its good. Sickening
@@stillgotyourmom what?!?
All humen love their country it is completely natural and all must respect this.
Common misconception - its not "God promised the land to us" -- its "This is where my ancestors lived and were forced out by Romans and Arabs, now im back"
"For you are crossing the Jordan, to come to possess the land which the Lord, your God, is giving you, and you shall possess it and dwell in it." (Deuteronomy 11:31)
@hrvatskinoahid1048 a fairy tale has nothing to do with it. People want to live in the land their ancestors lived in.
@@mikeySHBK The authenticity of Moses is based on the public revelation at Sinai: God revealed Himself to the entire nation of Israel, at least three million people, and proclaimed before them the Ten Commandments. The entire Jewish people personally experienced that revelation, each individual in effect becoming a prophet, and each one verifying the experience of the other. With their own eyes they saw, and with their own ears they heard, as the Divine voice spoke to them, and also they heard God saying, "Moses, Moses, go tell them the following ..." They did not receive the occurrence of that event and accept it as some claim or tradition of an individual, but they experienced it themselves. That public revelation, therefore, authenticated the bona fide status of Moses as a prophet of God, and the Divine origin of the instructions he recorded in the Torah. That, and that alone, is the criterion for the belief in, and acceptance of, Moses and his teachings.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 in other words... "I think Moses is real because a book says he's real"
@@JewFromIsrael55522 the tanach can say all it wants. Harry Potter says magic is real.
The Israeli Declaration of Independence is a very secular document. It refers to Jewish history in the land called Israel, not
to God. There is one ambiguous exception.
The phrase "Rock of Israel" was used in one sentence, which could be interpreted as either referring to God, or the land of Eretz Israel. Ben-Gurion said "Each of us, in his own way, believes in the 'Rock of Israel' as he conceives it."
To me the Rock is a combination of the land, peoplehood and history. Others also include religion, and there is no denying that this religion had a tremendous effect on history (not just for Jews) and peoplehood. I respect religious people, but I will fight them if they let their ideas endanger Zionism (and thus themselves!). This is happening right now.
Anyway, you don't get to choose your identity or place of birth. I think anyone who leaves Israel is mistaken, in that antisemitism still exists and will not allow them to feel a sense of belonging to any other country. Israelis are also very family-oriented, and the odds of moving an entire family (not just a single nucleus) to another country is nil. Other than that, Israel is the face of the Jewish people whether they like it or not, so they have to fight for it unless they want to be bystanders in their own story.
Israeli declaration was written by Communists. They did not believe in Judaism.
It's a Satanic state and a racist constitution
Then don't use your ethnicity or religion to make a claim over this land. Just go back to Germany.
Zionists are dogs. Everyone hates them when the live in their land. Europeans literally kicked these Zionists out.
So then it's a racist state
Yet it's referred as "The Jewish State"..and civil marriages aren't allowed. Don't give me that bs, just because Israel claims to be secular, doesn't mean it is. Sure, some aspects are like LGBT rights especially in contrast to Muslim theocracies..but we are measuring it by a scale of words vs. gestures..regardless of others.
They call themselves chosen people but do not believe in God.
They do not believe in God but believe God promised them this land.
Religious and observant are 2 SEPARATE THINGS!!
When one asks the question about "Are you X", one must be specific whether they are asking if one is Religious. Or observant. It is possible to be one and not the other! ESPECIALLY in Israel!!
So I’m confused by your comment. In Hebrew you say dati for religious and shomer mitzvot for observant. As far as I know a dati person is shomer mitzvot… no? Did you mean traditional- masorati?
@@faketrailermaker64 Ah! Interesting point! I wasn't speaking about the translations. I meant that people will ask "are you religious?" But people often forget that there is a difference between "religious" and "observant". One can be very religious in their heart, or in their mind, yet not as observant as someone who is very observant, and goes thru all the motions, so to speak, yet is not really very "religious" (meaning their belief in God in their heart and/or mind). They are two separate words, with 2 separate meanings, and not everyone is 100% of both at the same time all the time. No one is! (No matter how much they believe they are.)
Now, as far as someone being dati--as you said, that means that they are shomer mitzvot. And shomer shabbat and shomer kashrut. But often, we are just going thru the motions (it is Elul... this could get very deep! 😆). Personally, as someone who is considered "dati", we put all m
our kids thru Yeshiva, bc of course!, that is just what we do! But I do believe that those who are Masorti and put their kids in Jewish schools and pay a fortune for it when they DO have a choice, are MORE "observant AND religious" than those of us who just go thru the motions that we were taught, no matter the price tag (I am in the US--Yeshiva is VERY expensive, Dati or Masorti!), bc we were taught, as religious Jews, to observe, without question (no matter how deep ones feeling of religiosity is).
Does that all make sense?? 🤔 😆
absolutely and thank you for your thoughtful reply!@@skontheroad
@@faketrailermaker64 B'vakasha and kol tov!!
This question leaves a lot of room for unsurprising, obvious responses. Israel was established by Jews, for Jews, regardless of their level of observance.
so much things wrong with what you said
No they are not jews of the Bible they are fake jews they are descendants of ancient Tyre and Sydon people phoenicians
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
According to Exodus, Jews should stay in Iraq instead of Israel.
They don't believe in God, but their country is named after Isaac's son. They don't believe in God, but the very term they go by comes from the fact a certain person was chosen by God, whose descendants were as many as the stars.
What a life.
A lot of Jews from the former Soviet Union are not religious/ are atheist yet moved to Israel because it is the homeland of the Jewish people.
Israel is also a democracy.
Most are not atheists. They believe in God but not religions. However the % who believe and follow Judaism is increasing.
If they are atheists how it’s their homeland ? No god No homeLand
Most of the people comming from Soviet Union to Israel are not . They just got a fake papers just to escape poverty.. I watched one member of Israel parliament saying that probebly 80-85 % are not.This is the reason why they are not religious
@@CanadianMonarchistthere are 'much better' democracies in the world.
Answer (before even watching) because outside of their own homeland, Jews are a minority and as such, whenever times are hard or whenever the majority feels they needed a scape goat, they target Jews. There is ample historic precinct; The Crusades, The Inquisition, Pogroms, Holocaust, modern anti Jewish sentiment, not no mention the second class citizen status - Dhimmi- Jews always had in Muslim majority lands. The only way to avoid that is self determination in Moderns Israel, which stands in their ancient homeland. Jews are in Israel not because of 'Belief in God' , but because it is their ancient homeland. There's vast archeological, historical, religious, linguistic and yes, genetic proof the links Modern Jews to Ancient Levantine Israelites.
So, we’ll take the enemies tactics and use it to our advantage.”
@@AK-ky3ouSo?
@@AK-ky3ou Jews doing suicide bombings against Arabs? I don't think so. Israeli Arabs have just about every right as Jews in Israel do, they even have political parties and seats in the Knesset. Hardly the same situation that Jews experienced as minorities in Muslims majority countries.
the gypsy have been a minority throughout their history, they have always been persecuted and still are yet they don't have any country offered to them
@@YA-kr4fr Apples and Oranges, while it is true they have been persecuted, tre are a number of factors at play: !) Due to their willingly nomadic/travelling life style, a habit that persisted thrown many years, they have themselves made their own integration in host countries more difficult 2) They DO have an Original Homeland, that is the NW corner of the Indian Subcontinent, modern studies of genetics, language, cultures corroborate that. Meaning they could claim a political entity of their own in their ancestral homeland, at least in principle. You would expect such Polity to be in Europe, would you?
Its good to hear they love there country were i live lot of ppl dont do that anymore including me.
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
yup, they love their country that's pretty good, but in terms of Palestine, it's guilt.
3:02 he said *and say - Amen*
"כאן נולדתי, כאן נולדו לי ילדי
כאן בניתי את ביתי בשתי ידי
כאן גם אתה איתי וכאן כל אלף ידידי
ואחרי שנים אלפיים סוף לנדודי"
If you are not religious - why do you live in syria? why do you live in england? why do you live in italy? why do you live in...
lIts like only the Jews should be religious in order to get legitimacy for their own state
The whole concept of establishing the nation of Israel is purely religious. It doesn't mean you have to be religious to live there, however it is the basis for the existence of the nation.
Jews living in Jewdea how awkward...
@wesestes6201 absolutely false. The original jews moving back home in the 1800s and early 1900s were secular. Even in the 40s. It's only in the modern era that religious jews are going home.
It actually wasn’t, interestingly enough a lot of the Zionist founders were not actually religious
Yeah now they would say it has nothing to do with being religious or not. Good question.
"no where else can you be safe like in Israel" - dude that is factually completely untrue.
The Jewish owned land in Israel was bought, and is rightfully owned. Also Judaism is both a religion and a people.
“Bought and owned” … you’re exactly right, nothing was given to you by god, people are a fraudulent pestilence unto the world and have manipulated the very narrative of life itself
Ethnically cleansed and stolen*
@@hayyanalmemsani805 exactly
@@hayyanalmemsani805 exactly
@@hayyanalmemsani805 No, and you can’t name one example of that happening. When the modern state of Israel was established it allowed the Arabs to stay, and gave them citizenship and the same rights as everybody else. The ones that fled were fleeing the conflict they started, and there was never an expulsion program against all non Jews in Israel. Also it’s fact that all the Jewish owned land in Israel was bough whether during, ottoman, British, or modern times.
A-God-we-don’t-believe-in’s-chosen people
One wise programmer:If it works, don't touch it.😂😂
Jews are not chosen - they are descendants of ancient canaanite evil and chosen by satan lucifer - this is absolutely clear
Before Judaism was a religion, the Jews were a people. My DNA is Ashkenazi Jew-I am Jewish no matter what my religious beliefs might be-or not be. I am a Jew and nothing can change that. Israel is important because it gives a place to a displaced people. Every people should have a country-it affirms that you too belong to this earth as a full member of the human race. I don’t want anyone to be a second class citizen of the world.
They never ever believed in God and his Prophets and they want Jerusalem 😂
Why don’t you ask the gay community living in Israel why do they live there?
people in the anglo west thing religion is like a hat that you can put on or take off as you see fit. Religious traditions in the middle east are intimately linked with ethnicity as well. Judaism is the heritage of jewish people, it is not relevant whether you believe in any deities or not. You do not forget how to speak Hebrew just because you don't literally believe in the biblical mythology. Its not the same thing as christianity or islam.
It that sense Judaism is more similar with the Pagan religions of the old world where God was connected to certain,place,city,people or region regardless if someone believed or not you had to the ritual and festivals,you have to sacrifice to make God happy(although Judiasm ditched that)and many other little things,that make Judaism unique as in Middle of the old world religions and new.
Every tradition of Judaism is directly tied to God. They circumcise their boys because God told them to. They rest on the Sabbath because God told them to. They only eat kosher food because God told them to. They live in Jerusalem because they claim God gave it to them. When you take God out of the equation, all of these Jewish traditions become absolutely meaningless.
@@YA-kr4frthats proof of ignorance but not hypocracy.
lavnet is literally the heart of the middle east.
Question to French: if you are not religious, why do you live in France?
It’s not from the outside that say this, it is the Israeli politicians of which the outside world quotes…
Anyway, everyone should have land so hopefully you guys can all work that out. Make sure you’re fair.
"God gave it to us" was the excuse they used to take the land from the owners. They're now using "because we were born here". What about the people that were born there before you? Hypocrisy in Vogue!
Justifying global conquest for allah
Quran (8:39) - "And fight with them until there is no more fitna (disorder, unbelief) and religion is all for Allah"
Jevvs also lived on the land and it was never palestinian land to begin with. The arabs should not have started a war after they rejected the UN partition.
If you don't believe in god, why do you live in the US?
this is different bro this land Palestine or call it whatever you like is a HOLY LAND that GOD give only for the believers if you are not a believer of the GOD of MOSES,Yeshua(jesus),Muhammed(peace be upon them) and you keep breaking the LAW of Moses, Muhammed(peace be upon them) the commandments, then you shall go back to where you came from because GOD WILL punish those people who are not believers on this land, GOD order in the TORAH to people and says "DO NOT KILL" in the ten commandment now look who kill those 30,000 innocent people in GAZA ?
i know how those Zionists think they think that we Palestinians are those Amalekites which mention in the Torah and that WRONG,
GOD WILL NEVER EVER order some people to kill other people in this horrible way, if they are people who are really bad people he will destroy them by his own, i mean like Noah(peace be upon him) story GOD NEVER ORDER NOAH To GO and kill those bad people but he order NOAH to Build the Ship and then ALLAH command the sky to rain and the whole earth full of water and every one of the bad people had drown this is how GOD PUNISH PEOPLE,
because shedding blood will lead to hate and that hate will never be forgotten
there is a wise man says, "I warn you against shedding blood, indulging in it and making a habit of it, for blood never sleeps.”"
and that why i am as a Muslim for sure Believe that the Torah have been corrupted because this verse that says go kill Amalekites will never ever be told by ALLAH to Moses (peace be upon him), it's only the devil who can tell that thing.
we MUST KNOW the we Christians, Jews and Muslims brothers our only enemy is Satan (devil) his the only enemy for mankind, so We MUST stuck to our holy books, and we must all only follow what is common in these three holy books that how we defeated this cursed Satan, this Satan is enjoying right now watching us kill each other's disobeying ALLAH(GOD)
Think about it like this. Thousands of years ago, where the Jews started out is where Israel exists today. Even if they did it for religious reasons back then, regardless of the reason, it is where they started out as a people. So their descendants, whether those descendants are religious or not, are from this area.
They are descendants of slavic people slavic people are not jews they want to rule
Some of them mixed with other people after the Romans invaded, but before the Romans came they were in the land of Israel for more than a thousand years, since the time of the Pharaohs
@@canopeaz
No they came from different slavic countries and descendants of Canaan
@@Ermek57 No their ancestors are originally from where the state of Israel is located now. Let’s remember that at around the time of Israel’s independence, a majority of the Jews there had been persecuted and expelled from Libya, Tunisia, Egypt, etc, not slavic countries.
@@canopeaz
Are you stupid? Canaan exactly this place
They are descendants of Canaan
my mother from japan, can i occupy the country if i get enough people like me ? and clame its my promised land ?
The answer to the question is very simple because of antisemitism. Because for Christians it doesn't matter at all if a Jew living in their countries is religious or not, many of them still don't like Jews and don't want them in their countries. Many Jews in Europe were secular and wanted to assimilate totally in the countries they lived in. They still encountered antisemitism and persecutions. That's what prompted for example Herzl to establish Zionism - when re reached this conclusion that to the Christians the Jews will always be a different and undesirable element in their countries, religious or not.
All correct, however, the majority of Jews in Israel are descendants of refugees who fled to Israel from Arab countries.
500,000-700,000 Arabs fled to Arab Countries from Israel and became refugees.
900,000-1,000,000 Jews fled from Arab Countries to Israel and became refugees, their descendants make the majority of Israelis.
You don’t hear about the refugees who fled to Israel, Israel has absorbed those incoming refugees, while the Arab countries for the most part did not, they use them as a political tool (a common cause, a unifying topic, a diversion from poverty, poor health care, poor education and corrupt governments).
I appreciate the fact that you didn't say "Muslims." Because reading history, especially in countries like Morocco, Iraq, Yemen, Syria...etc. Jews generally flourished, especially during the Abbasid Caliphate onwards (until the creation of Israel, of course).
@@f4wnz132not really, jews were most of the time second class citizens and faced persecution several times
@@LeastPatrioticIsraelbelike Not really. Sure there were mobs and riots but those were purely political. Jews were scientists, doctors, poets, wazirs, artists, musicians, and anything they wanted to be, and as much as any Muslim. The only thing they couldn't be is Caliph, as that position was reserved for Muslims. If you want to mention Jizya, then I suggest you look up Jizya rates (especially when compared to Zakat) and who was exempt from them. You can also listen to Dr. Roy Casagranda on the subject matter. If you want to talk about the term "Dhimmi" then it literally means ward of the state with the same connotation. It's not a bad thing being a protected class.
@@f4wnz132 they werent all political persecutions. Dhimmis werent always protected. Most of the time jews were still second class
A Blessed Shavuah Tov To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion From Judea and Samaria: The Biblical Heartland of The Nation State of The Jewish People, Israel 🇮🇱.
* The Jewish People have returned to Zion, reclaimed their ancestral homeland and reestablished their communities.
All Jews have a share in the world to come..
@@ShaniHodiaB oh ok, I think you responded to an old comment I made in another video . But interesting thank you.
@@ShaniHodiaB
Please don't encourage Rodriguez by responding to him.
Thank you
I absolutely love this one it’s not just about religion it is Jewish Culture and they love it!
But the land is tied to mitsvos the food is tied to mitsvos the culture is tied to mitsvos....
The question isn't applicable to those born and raised in Israel.
That’s like asking a secular Saudi why he lives in Saudi Arabia
It's not the same.
@@abid6053you are correct.
Muz linz have 58 countries
+
Israel dosnt enforce je wish laws on non je ws.
@@abid6053 why not?
@@dogbert52 You can't compare Israel with the rest of the world because it's literally an apartheid. If you're not religious or don't believe in being "chosen" then how do you feel comfortable living in a place where you have more rights just because you're from a certain ethnic background? That doesn't even make sense.
Contradictions in human form. Even before Israel was established and even after it is abolished.
The ancient Israelites were forbidden from enterong the promised land because of unbelief. They were removed to Babylon for 70 years because of unbelief. Then in 70 AD they were removed because of unbelief.
Jews are commanded to settle in Israel in Deuteronomy 11:31.
Well also graven images and worshiping of Statues. This is why the Christians who are descendants of Israel cannot move back until they return to GOD fully!
I have a question for the palistinians: what did you expect Israel to do when you tried killing all of them. (This isn't for right now I'm talking about in 1948 when they tried killing all the Jews)
What history have you been reading? 😂😂😂
@@f4wnz132 true history
Good question.
"I'm the victim cuz the J's didn't just lay down and die in 1,948"
Are you saying the Palestinians of today were directly responsible and should be held liable for actions of 1948? Poppycock.
foreign colonialist interlopers who came from Germany Poland Ukraine etc violently dispossessed and you wonder why they resisted 😂😂😂😂😂😂 🖕🏽🖕🏽🖕🏽🖕🏽🖕🏽FU all seriously
There’s no negotiating with such 💩 for brains views
Why do people love to tell others how they should or shouldn't live? Live your live as you wish. Just dont be Christian , oh and muslim...
Judaism is actually Christianity you just misunderstood
A better question would be - if you are not religious, why MOVE to Israel?
@@JewFromIsrael55522
What the hell do all your replies have to do with my comment? I see you have a lot to take off your chest, so go do it elsewhere.
A good question. It's interesting to know how this question will make them think.
God is important ❤
Out of all the weird questions people have you ask, this is one of the weirdest..
Jews having roots in Israel is not a biblical myth, it’s a historical fact, a well documented one with tons of archaeological proof and documented writings, we are here because this is where we came from historically and this is where we are now because we were born here.
I agree in part but it's not such a weird question. If you are an atheist, what does it mean to be a Jew at all? If you don't believe in the soul, meaning for life, or spirituality at all, then you are just an animal or a sack of meat. Not only are you no different than a monkey but certainly no different than any other human being. So, why should you get to live in Israel and not another human being? The one man answered that a Jew is a person born to a Jewish mother but who says that? The religion says that. Of course you don't have to be religious to be a Jew and to live in Israel but without our Torah, you're just a meat puppet with no purpose to life living on an artificially demarcated piece of dirt.
No it does make sense, Palestinians and Israelis fight for the land for religious reasons, they both claim Jerusalem. If you are not interested in being religious and don't believe in God anymore then you are a zionist non Jew which is really terrible for your government, for the Palestinians and for the purpose of your existence.
Many people of Italian decent become assimilated into other countries. Your argument doesn't hold water.
Most adolfs and achmet have no idea about je wish or world history. They are just trying to legitimize the overwhelmening je wish dehumanization/ demonization prevalent in their societies.
Je ws are used as a distraction by the rulers of failed societies since time immemorial.
ha ha ha
Give us your opinion Corey
This is what bothers me an atheist from Russia or New York with Jewish ancestry , have claim to this land while Palestinians don’t
I’d like to ask Israelis what they think of Netanyahu and how he’s handling the Israeli response to October 7-what they like about his response and what they don’t like.
For every non Jew that thinks Judaism is about the bible stuff, there s one that thinks that Judaism is about money and world
Domination and they are not particularly shy about letting you know their beliefs. That s why I decided to move back to Israel once I become independent (I was born in there but my family moved to Europe when I was a kid)
Wow
we all know it's all about satan stuff. you do too.
Troll! Lol
Biblical Judaism is a beginning level of Christianity
@Ermek57 christianity is the literally antithesis of Judaism
Because Israel is a secular country (simple as that).
You can be religious or atheist
Because it's colonial state doesn't have relationships with religion, it's a European occupation
Simple like that 🤗
6:05
PfAHAHAHHA!!!
You can't make this sh*t up 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
3:01 The guy says "Say Amen..." (Not "He's the man..") - Apropos being religious....
I love it. Very simple answers and represents a nation, strong Nation
strong? they are not religious
Like any democratic country there is freedom of choice with respect to religiosity, and that’s ok, but I was a little stunned by the comment at 6:04. “What is the connection between Israel and God?” What? A little saddened that an Israeli Jew could ask this question. 😢
He’s highly ignorant that’s why.
I don't think many secular Israelis think through this dilemma.
@louisek.5512 Some families in Israel raised there children with a lot of animosity to God and the faith because of what happened in the Holocaust. not too difficult to understand.
Zionism was never about religion.
Theodore Herzl himself was completely secular, and even considered converting to Christianity, and first proposed Argentina as a possible location for a Jewish state.
Zionism is, was, and always has been about ethno-nationalism - in other words, racial chauvinism, or, if you prefer, racial supremacy, within certain geographic borders. Which, of course, necessitated the domination and expulsion of those already in those borders.
That's why Zionism, and by extension Israel, are both intrinsically evil.
Revelation 2:9 I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
You're asking the wrong question. How can you not believe in god while living in Israel?
This question is bs coming from a people of christian and muslim belief that think Jews as a followers in a religion.
Jews are tribal people or indigenous people with folk belief (judaism) in the Land of Israel.
It is like asking to the american natives or australian aboriginal or kiwi maoris who are no longer believing in their ancient folk belief why they dont migrate elsewhere.
Have anyone asked the same questions to any muslim or christian Indians or Chinese in India and China why dont they live elsewhere because they no longer believe in their former ancient belief? This is stupid
Love this guy's videos❤ I'm sure there are many Muslims the actually praise you my friend you seem like a honest person❤
They're right, as a righteous gentile, i 100% support israel 🇮🇱
They are not Jewish according to the new testament.
How exactly are you a righteous gentile? What Beit Din granted you that status and why?
@@judeancupcake7553 Anyone who accepts upon himself the fulfillment of the seven Noahide commandments and is precise in their observance is considered one of "the pious among the gentiles" and will merit a share in the world to come.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048*hahahaha the 7 commandments that invented by one of the rabbis to make the Jews still superior to the likes of this person who call himself gentile*
*Where in the scripture it says Jews and non Jewish should practice different things?*
A High Priest is superior to everyone. "You have therefore learned that even a gentile who engages in Torah study is considered like a High Priest." (Sanhedrin 59a) @@criticalthinker1123
I think this is a good question for Olim.
birthright - now i understand, in a larger sense.- includes citizenship, belonging to a family, community, culture.
How so? most Israelis have nothing to do with ancient Israelis genetically and did you know which modern populations are the closest to the ancient Israelis? Its the Samaritan, Lebanese and Palestinians what a surprise right? Jacob from Brooklyn is not as ``Jewish`` as Mohamed from Beirut.
What a stupid question. Firstly Jewishness is nor only religion. Secondly, all of those people already have family and roots there. Thirdly, non-Jews are murdered all the same when there's antisemitism. Hitler didnt spare non-religious Jews. Therefore at least a large portion of Jews must have a state that guarantees their safety.
Jewishnees is nothing but a religion, don't be ridiculous
It's actually excellent question for people don't believe in a God but believing that he gave them this land 😂
Not a single one of them his DNA and his roots belong to her as you're claiming, palastinians are living under the most brutal occupation in the modern history for your "safety" , what a logic! that's antisemitic too ! People shouldn't die so you can feel safe
Palastinians have the right to end this brutal occupation, whole the existence of isnotreal is illegal!
I live in in israel because here the jews are the majority and the army is ours and we don't need to beg or ask favors from foreign governments to protect our rights.
Ah, but you do. Without help of uk and usa you wouldn't be treating native arabs like the nazis treatment of jews.
@@a7md69without israeli technology you wouldnt have smartphones..... or even your lil reeligion based on fragments of je wish scripture.
But do go on.... enjoy that goat that your people love so much
Best answer yet to a relatively dumb question. Yes, it's the only place on the planet where as Jews we're master of our own fate, can live in dignity and aren't "guests" in other countries and subject to the whims of how they feel about us at any given time.
💯
but you stole from the arabs.
they were living on this land way before your great great parents were even born@@shevetlevi2821
By the argument of tradition and ancestry the Palestinians have also the right live freely in Palestine.
Unbelieveble...
Those people are so chill lmao (which is cool)
What a dumb question.
Italians, if you're not religious, why live in Italy?
Your question would have made more sense if you had said Vatican City.
@@eros727 Maybe, if the original question was addressing the orthodox only.
@@thunderstruck1078 yeah but there was no such thing as orthodox or non orthodox when ancient Israel was around. It’s establishment was solely based on a religious aspect. Thus the question begs itself, why deviate from that original framework when it’s sole purpose was in adherence to God’s commands? I don’t care personally if people believe in God or not, and they can live wherever they want. Israel today is of course not the religious homeland that it used to be thus the whole question should actually be why is there an Israel today if it’s not going to be a religious homeland like it used to be?
@@eros727 You can ask the same question for any nation on the planet.
I simply prefer when all people live in their own land, so on one hand they are able to be masters of their own fate and on he other hand we avoid the problem of value imposition to the native population from the position of a guest.
@@thunderstruck1078 actually no, you can’t. Not every nation is said to have been directly commanded by God to establish a homeland within a certain piece of land. Every nation cannot say that it’s founders were prophets. There’s a huge difference in your premise. There are many Jews who don’t call Israel home, they can be religious or secular or atheist if they wish to be. My contention is that Israel in on of itself, was primarily and initially solely established as a homeland for people who believed in God. Thusly if it becomes a non religious or theistic nation, it’s core existence then becomes arguable.
Isreal is just country and i dont think it matters if you are or your not unless you get mistreated for not believing in god then its time to leave. Jews have no right to control someone elses thought. it just a country like any other.
No they occupied arabs lands illegally
No one want to see them ancient canaanites again
God is not a big man in the sky God is the real man in you
God is not a man.
Many people have commented that this question was weird, uninformed or naive. On the contrary I think this may have been the most profound question I have seen here. The premise of this question is, I believe, the conflict between Israeli's and Palestinians, just as this is primarily the premise of Corey's channel. Palestinians often retort that this is their homeland, that they have a history in this land and they were born here. The Israelis say the same. But many Jews will argue, irregardless or their own personal origin, that the land of Israel itself is important because it was designated by God as the land Jews should live in. In comparison, the same land does not rank as important within the Arab religion. So, setting aside any immediate or even long term history or statehood, occupation or the like, the Jews claim that, if we were to start over again now, from scratch, it would make no sense for the Arabs to live in the land while the Jews should rightly be centered there. Ask the question again with that context and we now see why its suspect that an irreligious person should feel they have a better claim at the land than a Palestinian. Just move somewhere else.
The Jewish people have thousends of years of history in this land. They built their civilization there, their language, the city of Jerusalem - all done by them, there. This is a fact, and a good enough reason for modern Israel. God's promised land - this is purely a belief.
The Arab religion? Should I also call Christianity the Jewish religion?
Irregardless isn’t a word; it’s regardless or irrespective. There are approx 30 countries with Islam as the official religion and approx 50 countries with Christianity as the official region. You seem to have a problem with one secular Jewish major nation. Why is that? Why should we live somewhere else? How were religious minorities such as Zoroastrians, Yazidis, Christians, Druze, Jews, etc treated in Muslim majority countries? The answer is they were second, third, and fourth class citizens.
@@7135HOLLY Initially the jews do not have a land and suddenly you want one based on ur belief. You want to take an occupied land by force. Do you think God will agree with your way taking the land? Ask yourself Jews. Taking the land by killing thousand of innocents is the order of God or the order of devil?
@@mohamadazliazman2899 You must be referring to the Arab conquests of North Africa. The Arabs murdered, raped, pillaged their way across North Africa, wiping out all religions other than Islam. Maybe you can tell us all about Malaysia's bumiputera which is institutionalized racism written into law. Only Malaysia could throw Singapore out which then became one of the most successful countries in the world and treat their non Malay population like second class citizens. Please don't preach to anyone about liberty and freedom when you live in a barely second world, third world country with a history of racism where Hamas thrives. In addition to all of the pogroms Jews suffered in the Middle East, 900,000 Jews were thrown out of the Arab countries and Iran after 1948. Those who weren't killed were stripped of their citizenship, forced to leave and left penniless. The Jews in the Middle East were dhimmis - we're no longer your dhimmis. Google the Farhud in Iraq. There are videos on YT where "Arabs take a DNA test" and are shocked/embarrassed that the DNA results show that they are partially Jewish, confirming the forced conversions to Islam. Ask yourself, taking the land and killing millions of non-Muslims during your conquests.
An uniformed and frankly naive question. Every respondent essentially said the same thing, that being Jewish is a national, ethnic and cultural identity, and not just religion. This is innate to virtually every Jewish Israeli.
That's the issue, the nation state was created for the descendants of Israel, his son Judea. More specifically the land was "Given by God" so if they are not even believing in God, the question is relevant to ask considering the existence of the country was founded upon the religion.
Corey, interesting question.
From the responses to your question it is quite evident that most if not all claim to be atheists or agnostics, yet hold on to the notion that they are the chosen people.
Chosen by whom? If one does not believe in God.
Which one of them said they are chosen? @@ahmedabdulsamedbhuskhaw8903which
@@ahmedabdulsamedbhuskhaw8903 None of them claimed to be the "chosen people". They said that they live in Israel because they were born there. In Hebrew this notion doesn't even exist, the expression is "am segulah", which is infinitely more complex and nuanced than what people understand when they say "chosen" in English, it implies a singular, distinct relationship with the divine. But then this is irrelevant, since he interviewed secular israelis for this video.
Given by god 😅😅😅
my parents are jews therefor I am a jew.I do not have to be religious.I can be a non believer only in Israel.
This is my home . I believe in something in a bigger power,not nesesarly jewish.
Frenchs said same things when they lived in Algeria. For less than one decade, everybodies go out. This is what will happen to these people.
That's a stupid question. We are indigenous to the land. It's something your born with not you believe in or not
You came from slavic countries your ancestors are slavic you are not indigenous - you can see it by your looks
The cannanites have more bloodright to the land then the relative short reign of the Israelites
And Canannite blood is closer to Palestinians.
@@ou6775
No palestinians are Arabs not canaanite and ingenious to this land
Jews are ancient canaanites and occupied this land illegally
@@ou6775
And canaanites are enemies of biblical jews
God said ancient Israelites destroy land of Canaan and canaanites
Descendants of ancient Israelites all nations of the world and this so called jews occupied Palestine are descendants of thise canaanites - occupation is illegal and contradiction to God's decree
@@ou6775
All nations have bloodright to this land and Palestinians also because they are arabs
But canaanites occupied land illegally with satanic masonry help because GOD SAID DESTROY CANAANITE WHICH IS MODERN JEWS NOW YOU NEED BACK HOME TO SLAVIC COUNTRIES IT IS PALESTINIAN LAN - FREE FREE PALESTINE FROM ANCIENT EVIL CANAANITES JEWS
These folks are like a Capitalist opting to live in a Communist country, setting up a publishing house, then selling Marxist literature.
Not really, israel has always been a state based on jewish ethnicity, not religion.
@@user-ql8lt2uy5sJust old, worn -out words, friend.
@@MrResearcher122 what do you mean
@@user-ql8lt2uy5s That term "ethnic" has become a bit of a stretch. Term 'ethnic group' only entered the dictionary in the 70s.