It was openly confessed by sc that this one song is adapted from the polish tune.. this is not lift, this is called adaptation..there is much difference between the original and the madhumati song if you listen it carefully.. thats because sc modified it with his creative input.. dont underestimate the genius of sc..the original songs by him are masterpieces..
i always preferred genuinity many thanks for your cllection that whitsling hemantbabu admitted for this famous song ei raat tomar aamar from western influence
If you understand the music, let's be honest - regardless of how I feel as an Indian, the first part of the song (the dhrupada or refrain) is an exact replica of the Polish song. This isn't just an adaptation, it's a note-for-note copy of the original tune.
@@greatgrand695 abe ye copy nahi hai, bahut difference hai original aur madhumati k gaane mein.. starting bass same hai.. salil chowdhury usko modify kiye hai.. agr salilda khud nahi blte, to log is similarity ko pehchaan bhi nahi pate..
It was openly confessed by sc that this one song is adapted from the polish tune.. this is not lift, this is called adaptation..there is much difference between the original and the madhumati song if you listen it carefully.. thats because sc modified it with his creative input.. dont underestimate the genius of sc..the original songs by him are masterpieces..
i always preferred genuinity many thanks for your cllection that whitsling hemantbabu admitted for this famous song ei raat tomar aamar from western influence
It Is Inspired Thats Clear
He Is Genius
If you understand the music, let's be honest - regardless of how I feel as an Indian, the first part of the song (the dhrupada or refrain) is an exact replica of the Polish song. This isn't just an adaptation, it's a note-for-note copy of the original tune.
"Szła Dzieweczka Do Laseczka " Polish song 1863
Inspired and good work by Salil Chowdhury on the original song.
Bollocks.
Tu pakka bangaali hoga
@@greatgrand695 abe ye copy nahi hai, bahut difference hai original aur madhumati k gaane mein.. starting bass same hai.. salil chowdhury usko modify kiye hai.. agr salilda khud nahi blte, to log is similarity ko pehchaan bhi nahi pate..
Bahari with no skill commenting on salil chowdhury 🤣🤣🤣, salil chowdhury openly mentioned about it, 'Bahari' ko nhi pata 🤣, illiterate bum 🤣
But the song tune looks the same...
It's inspired
Tempo badhadiya bas 😂