"Have Not Said.." I Rahul Gandhi's Clarification Amid Wealth Distribution Row" I Modi IBarkha Dutt
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 апр 2024
- #congress #elections2024 #inheritancetax
The battle of narratives escalates as the second phase of the 2024 Lok Sabha elections approaches. On one side, Prime Minister Modi's speeches have provoked strong reactions from the Congress and the Left parties, who accuse the BJP of making communal remarks. On the other hand, Rahul Gandhi reaffirms, "Caste census is not politics for me..." .
Barkha Dutt speaks to,
Saba Naqvi, Senior Journalist
Sanjay Jha, Political Commentator & Author
Sandeep Ghose, Public Affairs Commentator
Mohandas Pai, Chairman, Aarin Capital Partners
Swathi Chandrashekhar, Congress Spokesperson
Become A Mojo Story Member Now👇
/ @mojostory
Welcome to Mojo Story, where storytelling meets truth-telling in its purest form. Led by renowned journalist Barkha Dutt, we're dedicated to bringing you narratives that transcend time and format.
From succinct 60-word snippets to immersive videos spanning up to 60 minutes, we explore the spectrum of human experiences and current events through a lens that prioritizes authenticity and integrity. In a world divided by polarization, we stand firm as a beacon of non-partisanship, refusing to be swayed by agendas or affiliations.
Here, you'll find content that goes beyond the noise, beyond the rhetoric, and beyond the confines of bias. We're neither 'Chamcha' nor 'Morcha'-we're advocates for the truth, champions of #PeopleFirst storytelling.
Join us on this journey as we navigate the complexities of our world with curiosity, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the facts. Subscribe now and become part of a community that values truth above all else. Welcome to a space where every story matters, and where the voices of the unheard are amplified.
Subscribe to us for more updates:
Follow us on Twitter:
/ themojostory
Like us on Facebook:
/ themojostory
Instagram:
/ mojostory.in
Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization. 
Развлечения
I no longer have any respect for Manmohan Singh. I work 18 hrs a day, many times 7 days a week. I don't want anyone to touch what I make. Congress wants to spread my wealth to people, so it can get their votes. I was born into a lower middle-class family. I studied and worked. I educated myself. In my third year of college, I started my business with only Rs 3,750. Today, I am employing 8 full-time and 4 part-time workers. There are too many lazy people who want everything for free.
You dont sound educated. Pls try to understand what the manifesto said. Also its something the PM is shamelessly using and twisting facts just to get votes.
You are right. All I.N.D.I.Alliance parties are antinational they have association with enemy countries, Liquor, Drugs and would want to destabilize and demolish our Country and loot all possible from its own people.
Helping poor is wrong? I see nothing wrong with this policy, everyone deserves to live a good life. You are not true nationalist because of you are you will help others with your money not save for children or grandchildren, they can make their own but those poor disabled weak people and unemployed millions of people, let them suffer? It's a bozo thing to not support this scheme. Congress is right with this one
@@TravelConsumerthere has to be some demarcation between what's morally right and what's legally right
Whether a person wants to help someone (poor/rich) it should be left to his morals ... you can't make law to take people's wealth
This is borderline maoism
@@TravelConsumerhelp the poor and they ll always remain poor .
Dear Saba, the foreign media can take a walk! They reaching out to you might give you thrills, but their opinion doesn’t matter to the Indian voter.
So true she is just a trouble not good for India does not like peace.
Kudos to Mr Pai for not holding any punches. What he said is as true as rise of tomorrow's Sun.
Whenever Sanjay Jha speaks I just fast forward his opinions 😂…Congress ki shaadi mein Sanjay Jha deewana 😂
Same goes with Mohan das for me😂
Truth hurts... Well said mohan das pai sir..... I salute you for saying it out loud and clear
That "shut up" was needed.
When mohan gave factual argument on muslim children that's exactly when Saba naqvi made personal comment on mohan that's what they do like they are some higher authority
9% to 18%
@@AjitJoshi686that's double
@@Bhruguraj doable on a larger base !
The problem with Left Loonies is that they live in their eco-chambers. They started dancing as if Congress was winning when they saw a slight perceived weakness in Modi's speeches. Even if the NDA clock is 328+, the opposition INDIA block will lose the election.
As I said earlier, Congress is not playing to defeat the BJP but defeating its own allies to increase its seat tally and vote percentage at the expense of its Allies. As in the past, Allies have grown at the expense of Congress.
Whatever Mohan Pai said is true, which obviously rattles Leftists and Secularists. In the end, Congress's policies are the worst diabolical cocktail of appeasement and Marxism.
Very true!
Saba Naqvi brings nothing at all, to a debate or discussion. What Mohan Pai said maybe the bitter truth with no one likes to talk about out of political correctness.
There is no rational person who does not feel that capitalism with welfare schemes is the best way for humanity
What are you trying to say? Capitalism is the only and only way to eradicate poverty.
Not only I used the word best
Just clarified with editing@@piyushagarwal1350
@@piyushagarwal1350 yes.
Yes capitalism for rich, welfare state for poor.
We appreciate Mr Pai for his brilliance and plain speaking.Great❤
He said after the x ray we will do a revolution? The revolution of what, if nothing was to be done?
'Revolution of nothing' by Rahul the Marxist.
Rightly deserved name - Pappu.
Mohandas great
Mohan rocks !
45 lacs crores to Mahila will come from where ?
Wtf is this saba woman talking about? I am inviting her to come and live in Hyderabad.
Sanjay should answer the congress pitch of appeasement of minorities nd they haven’t really done anything about upliftment of minorities…
How daft are Congress and its supporters? They want inheritance tax on richest 500 families. Those people would leave India or exploit the loopholes in the law. But Mohandas Pai was on fire!! He said what a lot of us feel. Thank you, sir!
Mohandas pai 🎉
Sanjhay Jha is like that guy who loves a girl with all his heart, never looks towards even a shadow of another girl, tattoed her name in his body but the girl is lesbian.
Brilliant 😂😂
Very interesting debate and I agree with Mohandas Pai totally.
why is the muslims should benefit like sc/st/bcs? SC/ST/BCs were historically denied opportunities. You can not say the same about muslims in India. They were never treated as badly as SC/ST/BCs. how can you give benefits to muslims along the lines of sc/st/bcs? Muslims historically on contrary destoyed thousands of temples, killed millions of hindus and destroyed indian heritage. Though currents muslims should not be burdened by the historic crimes their community has comitted, they can not get first access to Indian resources. Poor among muslims should be treat like any poor in open category. Which is fair and just. Anything otherwise is nothing but taking away rightful access of SC/ST/BCs and giving it to Muslim community.
Muslims got 2 nations on thr demand , and got many privileged waqf board, Madrasa education, haj subsidy, Muslim personal law board whr even now marrying a girl child is legal it doesn't comes under child marriage crime.
Saba thinks people recognise her as left wing journalist. lol😂. We think that Islamist have taken over left wing totally
LOOKING AT FROM MAHARASHTRA THE RAM MANDIR HAS BEEN AN ISSUE AND THE PEOPLE SEEM TO BE VOTING IN FAVOUR OF BJP
Mr Pai, well done for speaking the truth..
The real issue and fact is that before independence, muslim population was just 8% and rest 92% was non-muslim (i.e. hindu, parsee, jains, sikhs, christians and others) in Pre-indpendent Indian sub-continent comprising of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. At present, there are 25 crores muslims are in pakistan, 18 crores muslims in Bangladesh and 20 crores in India which means approximately 63 crores muslims collectively as against 110-120 crores non-muslims, which tentamountly mean muslim population ramphantly incresed four times to 35% percent from 8% in 1947. And now Congress want to give those non-muslims-Hindu, Parsee, Sikhs, Jains and Christians Wealth to those uninterrupted breeding muslims by way ofRedistribution of Wealth. Congress has never said or cited 1% ultra reach billioners wealth in their menifesto. Hence untill then it is safe to assume that congress want to sieze/confiscate those Hindus, Parsees, Jains, Sikhs and Christians wealth (Largely kids and parents of single or two child ) to those Muslims Guspetia's (Bangladeshis & Rohingyas ) and Jyadda Bacchey (Having four wives and sixteen children) by way of Redistribution of Wealth. How to comunicate congress this malafide and sinister agenda to the common man/citizens of Country? obviously Modi an smart politician in election champeign will comunicate in local understanable language where 'Mangalsutra' signify symbolically to Property/Wealth supported by none else but Congress own ex Prime minister Manmohan singh's 9th Dec 2006 statement before Nationa l development Council where he clearly and specifically said that "Muslim MUST have first rights & priority over resources of India. Congress is fully aware of said direct truth & intent of naming Muslims in said NDC meeting and their backlash, hence in current 2024 menifesto they smartly & crookedly replaced/substituted 'Muslims" with expression "Minority". But Conress can not fool people of india anymore by just repharasing, thier intent and agenda is clear like water in nowadays social media.
Jha is delusional. He is rude, selfish and comes across as very very disagreeable..
Not at all. Jha is an undercover for Congress (Rahul)
Thanks to Modi, people have started reading the Congress manifesto.
Rahul Gandhi's grandmother also implemented the Land Ceiling Act in many parts of UP in the early 1970s. Sikhs and Hindus after independence had to undergo huge trouble to develop agricultural land in the Tarai area of UP. Indira Ji pushed to distribute free of charge to Muslim workers. I know of families that lost land between 1973-74 in the Village Rafatpur, Bilaspur in Rampur district UP.
Congress and its socialist agenda. It does not impact Congress politicians with bank accounts in Switzerland.
It was implemented all over India, in MP my in law's lost 50 acres land
Sanjay Jha.
Bro I love listening to you.
Thank you for all that you do. Keep it up.
Likes of you and RG himself are enough to give BJP an edge always.
oh and how can I forget that Money Ieyer Guy.
you are all gems, love you guys
😂😂😂 pls tell me you are being sarcastic.
@@rajbaniwal3236 yes he is.... took sometime for me to get too 😂
Sanjay Jha is like a loyal dog..khangress is right or wrong..always keep loosing and pappu gets embarrassing but he will keep licking their feet 😉
I am dead serious.
@@kshitij_void_ missed the “edge to BJP”. Good one 😆
Saba and Sanjay live in their own cocoon.
The BJP is not expecting Congress to be in power. It means they playing with spirit. They are not taking any opposition lightly.
Iam not happy with PM speech. But as an Indian my question to Muslim saba,barkha when muslim say they will not vote for bjp but vote for non bjp parties which have treated them as co firmed vote bank what is wrong in bjp pandering to Hindu vote bank. Have ever antibjp anti-hindu prominorities lutyens media like barkha rajdeep sagarika saba questioned the wisdom of Muslims who are blindly antibjp. Shameless lutyens media
Thank God someone is calling an elephant an elephant Thank you Mr Pai.
Mr Mohandas Pai, hits the bullseye as always ❤ Demolished brainless arguments made by Sabah ! Kudos 🎉
Barkha you are so partial, Sanjay incorrectly says the rich pay inheritance tax abroad , everyone there with a house pays the tax. Secondly Rahul Gandhi didn’t say the X-ray will be done only for rich people. Then Sanjay mentions Adani became rich during Modi’s time but you didn’t counter by saying Dhirubhai Ambani wall became rich during Congress rule, the story of Ambani is legendary on how congress took bribes from him. Even Nulsi Wadia said that but alas you didn’t bring that up. Lies after lies is being promoted by you. People like you and Rajdeep are turning us into BJP voters.
Very true
She is hardcore leftist
mohan pai was spot on on his 9 to 18 % fact. it's a concern for other non muslim community.
There are not 2 but 3 people on this panel who are Modi haters…tell me who’s the 3 rd one???😅😅
The host herself 😂😂😂
Too early to have a debate on the subject of 'Wealth Distribution in India'. Never expected Mrs Barkha Dutt to have this debate at this juncture.
Thank you Pai for speaking truth
So according to Saba Naqvi Congress has open license and blanket immunity to use phrase like..... Chowkidaar Chor hei, Maut ka Saudagar, and thousands of other abuses and gaalis but PM Modi is not allowed to even name infiltrators as Guspetia (more thna 3 crores Bangla deshi infiltratd in India from Bangladesh before 1970 and thereafter and Rohingyas, who are openly committing crime and sometime running back to origin country in case of arrest like situations) and "jyadda Bacchey" terms same as unconstitutional. Surprisingly, why muslims themselves assuming jyadda bacchey mean they themselves alone? as Modi ji has not named muslim specifically ( except reference of manmohan singh's muslim statement)
Rahul Gandhi should have told he will do things to reduce inequalities not say he will scan the people’s wealth and redistribute wealth.. this is definitely disaster communication.. forget for a moment his intent
Khata khata khat..khata khata khat...pappu will distribute others wealth while doing infinite scams...😅😅😅😅
Please go out and vote for Modi so we can develop our country. We cannot let RaGa sell our country, and distribute our hard-earned money to a bunch of lazy people who are busy producing their family cricket team. Hum 2 hamare 11. 🤣🤣🤣😆🤣
I can hear music in my head of "dreaded mulla" music everytime i see saba thinking with her eyes rolled
The quality of debates on this show has plummeted. No difference between the cacophony and one sided debates on mainstream media. Asking why the narrative has become redistribution when you have joined the bandwagon rather than focusing on the original issue for anything more than 24 hours!
Why don’t you start a debate show? Sitting in couch and blabbering is so easy😂. People who can’t plan 3 meals for entire week suggest picking good topic everyday 😂
It is not a narrative it's a fact and already done by Indira in 1970s Land ceiling act where many farmers lost thr land
Mohan Das Pai is on fire.🔥🔥🔥
Bravo!!! Mr mohandas Pai for calling spade a spade and bursting the false narrative by Saba and Sanjay jha
THATS IS WHAT I SAID TO SANJAY JHA , WHEN MOHANDAS PAI SAYS PEOPLE DO NOT TAKE US SERIOUSLY BUT DO TAKE MODI AND RAHUL SERIOUSLY. MODI JI HAS TAKEN THIS TO PEOPLE OF INDIA AND ITS A SELF GOAL BY RAHUL FOR OPPOSITION.
Why is one eyebrow of Mohandas pai black and the other white?
Edit: Skipped Sanjay Jha's English vocab exhibition. He can make money like Rapidex English speaking course.
😂😂1
Why not call Niira Radia for a debate with you. Atleast one lakh views will be guaranteed. No opinion on comment section.
Sanjay Jha you have clarified Congress position as well as it could be done. Your exposition of prime minister and BJP is appreciated.
RaGa has just advanced the de facto results date 😅
I no longer have any respect for Manmohan Singh. I work 18 hrs a day, many times 7 days a week. I don't want anyone to touch what I make. Congress wants to spread my wealth to people, so it can get their votes. I was born into a lower middle-class family. I studied and worked. I educated myself. In my third year of college, I started my business with only Rs 3,750. Today, I am employing 8 full-time and 4 part-time workers. There are too many lazy people who want everything for free.
SALUTE TO YOU MOHANDAS PAI CALLING A SPADE A SPADE .GREAT. SABA THAT IS WRONG STATEMENT , YOU SHOULD NOT BECOME PERSONAL. YOU CAN HATE MODI BUT DONT BECOME PERSONAL. WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY RANT . NICELY ANSWERED BY MOHANDAS PAI .
Same Piitroda ko sunke dil aag bsbul hi gaya
Only Modi can explain any scheme of opposition clearly to the voters !
😂😂😂
PM Georgia Meloni has just invited our Maharaja to attend G 7 summit in Italy. What does it mean ! koi Sickular jawab do. Nation wants to know😂
Defending Congress is like pushing a boulder uphill. At some point, you're going to get crushed.
My residential land and Agricultural in Kashmir Valley stands grabbed by the govt without my consent. On the top of it, the compensation of my agricultural plot of land has been paid to a Muslim who has no legal right over the same. So what Manmohan Singh wanted to be done for Muslims including Saba already stands implemented .
Saba will have no objection to this proposal. The religion she belongs to is the third largest land holder in India following RAILWys and DEFENce.
It will be wrong to see Big Business Houses as mere exploiters They can become engines of progress
Mohandas asking Saba to shut up is unnatural of him
Mr Mohan took the bull by its horns..
I am rom herabad I am going to delhi sine sonia rahul priyanka are distributing their illegal money i wll also take anbody coming with me
Dude.. ill book the cab... let's go.. i mean free wealth badly...😅😅
7:00 ❤ Mohandas Pai 😊
Mohan is the only guy who spoke the truth..apart from sandeep who tried.
Why haven’t you showed him stating that he will do redistribution
I strongly disagree with Rahul Gandhi's proposal for a caste census or financial survey, as it lacks a clear purpose and plan for implementation. Our current government aims to empower citizens and promote dignity, and I believe we should focus on constructive initiatives that promote unity and inclusive growth.
Given India's large and diverse population, creating jobs for all may be a challenging task, but our government is taking steps in the right direction by encouraging small businesses and startups. This approach can help foster self-employment opportunities and stimulate economic growth.
While some individuals like Ambanis and Adanis have accumulated significant wealth in recent years, it's important to acknowledge that they have also generated employment opportunities for many Indians. Additionally, the government has made significant progress in simplifying investment in the Indian stock market, making it easier for citizens to invest and creating new wealth opportunities.
Rather than focusing on divisive politics based on caste and creed, we should work towards building a more united and prosperous India. Let's engage in constructive discussions and avoid personal attacks, focusing instead on finding solutions that benefit all citizens.
On lighter note @sanjay Jha please tell us how much you get paid to defend congress AKA rahul Gandhi so vehemently and loyally. Your loyalty has no bounds. You go Tommy 😂😂😂
mohan rocked shabha shocked 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yes she is shocked because he spoke the truth. They think they can abuse Modi and Hindus day in & day out and stay silent on all that INDI ALLIANCE PARTIES are doing appeasing Musl and abusing and looting Hindus.
Then they always bring up the victim card. Last video shows her saying that what Modi said was "Hate speech" and why, because he said infiltrators. Modi never even mentioned the word Musl. But she said he has made it about Hindu/Muslim. She forgets to state that RAGA started the whole thing.
What Modi & Mohandas have said is correct. It's difficult for Congi supporters to digest the truth.
Jha , as usual sounds frustrated and vitiating while demeaning Modi.
Saba ,too, has not corrected herself and jumps to paint Modi as muslim-basher.
Understand the chronology of the Congress statements....... what the PM said was quoting ex PM and Pappu. ..... what Modi said was less ludicrous than what Congress said about CAA or what Barkha said about CAA
Modi ji has been forced to take H M divide option because Modi ji did a fantastic job of eradicating caste based politics and united all sections of Hindu society.
With Congress emphasis on making caste divides relevant, it is important that Modi ji unites all Hindus again.
You can blame Modi ji for being communal only if you blame Congress for being casteist.
Mr Pai has hit the nail on the head. India is going the right way under PM Modi.
Charity should start from Gandhi home
Welcome to Hyderabad team MoJo
Immediately put maids and drivers under min wage and give PPL good govt schools then we will see who is right and who is wrong
Barkha, why are you calling individuals like Mohan as blind and close-minded? History will ridicule such narrow perspectives, even his own grandchildren might feel ashamed. Though he might have accomplished some commendable deeds, his legacy will likely be remembered for his limited mindset.
My question to these antibjp pro Rahul acolytes will pappu on becoming PM will national the property of so called Modi friends Ambani, Adani.
Why don't anchors just shut the microphones of those that talk for more than what they are alloted. That should be a more fair debate or conversation on National TV. Just shut them off...and warn them in advance. And in the case of disturbances during other's tlak time you could make some penalty or something. Otherwise this type of program is being seen as unfair and boring. So please be aware and make an exaple. It is frustrating ti see you the anchor trying to speak while the most agressive person continues to blabber on and an. I would like to see this otherwise most people will not view these program who are anchored by our trusted journalists.
SABA NEEDS MEDICINE.
Sabha giving nonsense. Just take district in Karnataka, Ms population has increased from 11% to 24% in many districts just in last 14 years, shocking. This kind of breeding not only puts them in perpetual poverty but also is dangerous to the planet. Their population has been exploding even in European countries.
saba from diffrent planet :) ... then why Mr Gandhi is reverting back on his steatment
poor sanju jha hahahah i pity him........neither here nor there hahahahaaaaaaa
Mohan was on point!!
@Barkha: I wonder how you could still introduce Mr Pai as just a "political analyst"!! I mean yes you have the freedom to invite to your show a man who is no less than a blatant liar and a religious fanatic and a bigger Modi-fan than any random BJP worker, and you have the freedom to give him long free airtime to go on a communal speech in your show.. what you could do the least is to introduce him in a moderately acceptable way, just like you did for Mr Sandeep or Mr Sanjay.
The least.. from you.
Sandip looked absolutely non-plussed after Saba's satirical rejoinder!!
Inequality wasn't created by BJP only in last 10 years but mainly by 70 years of Congress.
Population explosion of Muslims is true and Modiji has courage to say so.
Don't take some Qureshi book but see ground reality district wise.
If People vote for local issues in Muincipal and state, then why does Modi go and champion them in Muincipal elections?
I dont know what is the problem woth these guys when Adani makes more money .. he is running and employing pple to make money .. what idiots .. 😊
It's unfortunate barkha who campaigned for plum portfolio for her pay master dmk during UPA rule is speaking about morality in politics. People of this country have not forgotten the niradia tapes.
I would like to remind Rahul Gandhi funded barkha congress both under nehru,indira,Rajiv opposed OBC reservation because they knew OBC is a myth in India.
Sanjay Jha has an IQ similar to that of RAGA.
The suspended Congressmen is licking the ground to get his entry into party even if a window is kept open.
As for Saba, who is gyrating her hips because some foolish foreign media houses sought her opinion not realising she belongs to a community which is enjoying eating the cake and having it,while the majority are working hard, paying taxes and then find that there is an opposition which only speaks of appeasement and freebies.
Hahaha........Saba is real joker !
No point in criticising Barkha, she has been the most neutral journalist out there since I have followed her during COVID. PS - I support Modi
Lolz.. she never talked about what was the laws of Congress and what Muslims feel about non believers
I m fan of Barka programme. My only comment is avoid speaker like Sanjay Ja. He never answer for the questions but full of poisonous always abusing PM in a ugly way
Barkha Dut ji.. somewhere ur leaning gets highlighted.. please adhere to objectivity of conducting debate
Please send this guy (Rahul) to Italy
Mohan das Pai is so arrogant. So sad to hear him
Pai is consistently radical in his loud opinions…he accuses others of perversion..
Oh oh oh
The famous arm chair ideologue ranting every day. let him go to his native place work for the upliftment of poor people.like what PK is doing . After all Congress doesn't have any vacancy as of now