Southerner born in 1996. Introduced to these guys in 2016. The further one delves into their tracks, the better they become. Big up Manchester on their musical talent. Legends.
All these years later, I still like hearing Ian Brown 'not singing'. I admit, he has lost a lot of it especially his range but that kind of talk was starting up in those days to.
Probably one tune than can bring tears to my eyes. Browns voice on this is eerie and beautiful. From the greatest city on earth. Love from Manchester. MCFC M20
Browny as got an amazing sweet voice so don't know why he changed it to the talking overtly manc accent of his solo releases???? Sing man you got a lovely voice when you do!!!!!
He wasn't always in tune. But whenever he stayed in tune, he was top ten vocalist material. I think he strays once in this performance, but it's where many people would stray slightly. But his voice is so rich that he steals the show.
pains me that this isn’t on streaming, or on the reissues of SC, FM really fumbled with them. the demo version which is the most common is still great, but this one is just magic
Still got this. Unfortunately I gave a loan of it to friend at school . And they must have lent on it to write and the indentations are still visible. Would never sell it though.
An interesting alternative take - but I can hear why they went with the other version - it has more energy... and Reni absolutely fucking ruled on the other version... on this one he's a little more subdued...
Amazing loved it since early 88 when I was 11 never looked back since so glad the roses are back but that new track is utter crap what's happened to them Lord and Manchester for give them
Interesting. I'm so obsessive about this stuff, yet i didn't know about this until I was scouring Discogs for an original copy of Sally Cinnamon recently. Wonder why the switch for the re-releases? I always thought the comparatively terrible 7" version of Sally was a demo, maybe one of the versions of AATS was too, and half arsed admin saw them switched later on. The mystery of where the proper version of Full Fathom Five disappeared to for twenty years always intrigued me, and whether the other version really *is* Peter Hook's mix of Elephant Stone. Someone really needs to write a Revolution In the Head style book about the Roses.
I think personally that it’s all a product of never really quite dropping on to the right deal, producer, line-up and obvious evolution in their sound for about 5 years. All of the above mixed in with the punk diy ethic of the band and those in and around the Manchester music scene. I more or less formed this opinion as I typed it but as I think harder about it maybe the band knew that they were on the edge of something majestic with all the decent tunes that they were amassing and weren’t ready to “sell the whole farm” until they knew everything was right. All in all though, what a fuckin band eh?
I bought the original 12” (without barcode) of Sally back in 1987. A friend and I bought another copy of the 12” in 1989 for another friend at uni. When we played the 1989 version we discovered to our horror both Sally and All Across the Sand were crappy demo versions. Hence the nickname we gave to the 2nd version - “Crap Sally” to distinguish it from the proper one. 20 years later I emailed Paul Birch the owner of FM Revolver records to enquire if he was ever going to release the correct version of All Across the Sand” on CD. The debut album was getting the deluxe treatment and re-release around this time by Silvertone for the 20 anniversary. My hope was the renewed interest in the Roses could result in the original version of this song being available again. Paul Birch didn’t even realise about the different versions until my email. After a series of emails between us he promised me he would re-release it and I would get a free copy. 12 years later I’m still waiting. No wonder they did a paint job on him!
Bones of an impressive romance Scattered all across the sand A secret safe with all the world Too vain to seem so capable Can you hear it calling? Do you feel warmer As the hired hand's exposed? How can a pretty painted shell Send them all packing off to Hell? A freight train laughs and rattles by You kissed the girls and made them die Can you hear it calling? Do you feel warmer As the hired hand's exposed? And I'll never come here again And we will never come here again And we will never play here again, again Can you hear it calling? Do you feel warmer As the hired hand's exposed? After her call After her call After her call Didn't call Can you hear it calling? Do you feel warmer As the hired hand's exposed? After her call After her call After her call Has she called?
Surely the best Ian Brown vocal ever.
Low bar setter.
@@scherben8870 Ian brown live was bad but in the studio he’s very good
@@nameless3321 As is everyone. He's even shitter on twitter.
@@nameless3321 He's alright in the studio. Nothing amazing
@@scherben8870 what because he didn't get conned like you to get a jab you didn't need?
Southerner born in 1996. Introduced to these guys in 2016. The further one delves into their tracks, the better they become. Big up Manchester on their musical talent. Legends.
Born is 1996! Lucky sod
Amazing vocal from Ian.Proves he can sing when he wants to.Best band in the 🌎
Brown sounds fantastic here its only missing reni's backing vocals but still magical xx
Brown's vocals are just fucking fantastic.
All these years later, I still like hearing Ian Brown 'not singing'. I admit, he has lost a lot of it especially his range but that kind of talk was starting up in those days to.
Every single time I listen to this track it gets me ,a band that touched heights others couldn't even dream of
Fantastic guitar work by John and great vocals by Ian. Love It!
Probably one tune than can bring tears to my eyes. Browns voice on this is eerie and beautiful. From the greatest city on earth. Love from Manchester. MCFC M20
I was with you until the last bit 👹🤣
@@thingymebob4940 😂🇾🇪
City scum
isn’t browny from Warrington
Reni is a blue 💙
Fav Roses Track For Me.
It’s just pure magic.
And I'll never come here again! Roses at their best.
Love this song
Browny as got an amazing sweet voice so don't know why he changed it to the talking overtly manc accent of his solo releases???? Sing man you got a lovely voice when you do!!!!!
It’s such a shame
I was actually looking for this recently, I could only find a youtube video with a very low quality vinyl rip, thanks for uploading this version.
Never heard this original, simply brilliant
........no words.... just fantastic vocals.
Beautiful song! 🥹
I really like how the back of the cover captures the atmosphere of the song.
love this, thanks for sharing this version.
please play this in 2016
Masterpiece 💥❤️
He wasn't always in tune.
But whenever he stayed in tune, he was top ten vocalist material.
I think he strays once in this performance, but it's where many people would stray slightly. But his voice is so rich that he steals the show.
beautiful
pains me that this isn’t on streaming, or on the reissues of SC, FM really fumbled with them. the demo version which is the most common is still great, but this one is just magic
Proof Ian could sing if he really wanted to.
much better then the other version
No
Still got this. Unfortunately I gave a loan of it to friend at school . And they must have lent on it to write and the indentations are still visible. Would never sell it though.
Beautiful.
i liked this version of "Made on stone" pretty voice of ian brown 🎶❤
RIP Peter Garner 😢
Beautiful noize ❤
OMG thank you
Height of drama stuff, like a movie in two and a half minutes. Stunning musically.
amazing.
Wow
An interesting alternative take - but I can hear why they went with the other version - it has more energy... and Reni absolutely fucking ruled on the other version... on this one he's a little more subdued...
brilliant :)
Fantastic!
Amazing loved it since early 88 when I was 11 never looked back since so glad the roses are back but that new track is utter crap what's happened to them Lord and Manchester for give them
Interesting. I'm so obsessive about this stuff, yet i didn't know about this until I was scouring Discogs for an original copy of Sally Cinnamon recently. Wonder why the switch for the re-releases? I always thought the comparatively terrible 7" version of Sally was a demo, maybe one of the versions of AATS was too, and half arsed admin saw them switched later on. The mystery of where the proper version of Full Fathom Five disappeared to for twenty years always intrigued me, and whether the other version really *is* Peter Hook's mix of Elephant Stone. Someone really needs to write a Revolution In the Head style book about the Roses.
What's this about the "proper" version of full fathom five?
I think personally that it’s all a product of never really quite dropping on to the right deal, producer, line-up and obvious evolution in their sound for about 5 years. All of the above mixed in with the punk diy ethic of the band and those in and around the Manchester music scene. I more or less formed this opinion as I typed it but as I think harder about it maybe the band knew that they were on the edge of something majestic with all the decent tunes that they were amassing and weren’t ready to “sell the whole farm” until they knew everything was right. All in all though, what a fuckin band eh?
I bought the original 12” (without barcode) of Sally back in 1987. A friend and I bought another copy of the 12” in 1989 for another friend at uni. When we played the 1989 version we discovered to our horror both Sally and All Across the Sand were crappy demo versions. Hence the nickname we gave to the 2nd version - “Crap Sally” to distinguish it from the proper one. 20 years later I emailed Paul Birch the owner of FM Revolver records to enquire if he was ever going to release the correct version of All Across the Sand” on CD. The debut album was getting the deluxe treatment and re-release around this time by Silvertone for the 20 anniversary. My hope was the renewed interest in the Roses could result in the original version of this song being available again. Paul Birch didn’t even realise about the different versions until my email. After a series of emails between us he promised me he would re-release it and I would get a free copy. 12 years later I’m still waiting. No wonder they did a paint job on him!
And I'll never come here again and she can never play here again
magic
A rare Treasure.
brilliant
wow
And she can never play here again
Reni❤
Ian is good just John was too loud live roses are fookin great though
Bones of an impressive romance
Scattered all across the sand
A secret safe with all the world
Too vain to seem so capable
Can you hear it calling?
Do you feel warmer
As the hired hand's exposed?
How can a pretty painted shell
Send them all packing off to Hell?
A freight train laughs and rattles by
You kissed the girls and made them die
Can you hear it calling?
Do you feel warmer
As the hired hand's exposed?
And I'll never come here again
And we will never come here again
And we will never play here again, again
Can you hear it calling?
Do you feel warmer
As the hired hand's exposed?
After her call
After her call
After her call
Didn't call
Can you hear it calling?
Do you feel warmer
As the hired hand's exposed?
After her call
After her call
After her call
Has she called?
is this Ian Brown... actually trying to sing... WOW
Great version - though a bit off key at the end!
Kiss the girls and made them die
This is great but let's be realistic. It's not better than the more well known version.
It is great, but agree with you, roses forever
The Roses were stuck in a time warp at this stage. While they were making shite like this, the Happy Mondays were making Tart Tart and such..
Comparing roses to Mondays good one😂
@@edmundblackaddercoc8522 My comment speaks for itself.
beautiful