this comments section is annoying asf, r y’all nevies never happy w anything ?? minnie got lines so ofc it would make sense she’s at the edge more, she doesn’t have a dance position. same w miyeon, she got lines because she’s the main vocal for god’s sake so ofc she’s gonna have more edge time.
@@hangjiandeuli8283 I mean, the group has an even amount of members, if someone is the focus then it becomes uneven making the choreography not symmetrical, that's why someone gets hidden behind. That's my theory anyway, I personally think there must be a way to do this without hiding anyone, but I haven't thought of any example.
@Joseph Qualtier being in the center does not mean you sing that part, soojin is in the center for the first chorus then why is it not her line? also yuqi? hmm??? also if you noticed the last "hwa" still sounds the same for the first and second "hwa" and it does not count as a line. Do you know what a line means
@@Juliana-tf7zh first of all, soyeon is the face of the group and center. Its only natural. Second of all, alot of people in the comments are saying "Poor Minnie" but she already has quite alot of lines. I find this really fair.
@@pataya4155 Im not saying it isn't fair, but if you're gonna said she deserved to have the most edge, then why is no one being mad at Soyeon with most lines and less edge? Btw, before you attack me, I'm not saying Soyeon didnt deserved it or that she shouldn't get it, just saying your logic is flaw.
@@Juliana-tf7zh I never said Minnie deserves to have more edge? I just said why "Poor Minnie". I was stating how it's pretty fair as she has alot of lines. And again, soyeon is the center and face of the group, if people were to complain about her distribution, they should definitely check the positions again.
I mean Soojin is the main dancer and Minnie is the tallest member so I can see why it's like that + soyeon is the shortest members and the center, also Shuhua is the 2nd shortest member and Yuqi is the lead dancer so she could have gotten less but she almost didn't have much edge until the half the song so it's ok. But I'm sad that Miyeon has a lot cause she's most of the time hidden and also is second last in center 🙁
Poor Minnie, but at least we can see her. G idle has only 6 members so it's not THAT deep. Miyeon has so many edge time and at the same time she was always in the hidden position so that's worst... I'm happy for Shuhua, she doesn't have so many edge time
@@casperjay7021 well, she is main vocalist and her voice fits G idle's songs very well. What I was saying is, poor Minnie, but at least we can actually see her if she is in the edge. But you are right, it's fair if we count her lines and center. In other hand, I'm disappointed of Miyeon's edge time when she has a lot of hidden time, a position where we can't even see her.
I mean, she's the main vocalist, that's her only position (I think?). She also had a lot of lines. It would only be unfair if she was the main dancer or center.
@@mmmag2710 Even Miyeon is the main vocalist and sang the most with Minnie. Their edge time is fine considering they are not even part of the dance line and carried the song vocally
Yall always say "poor 'blank'" as if they literally give a shit if they had the most "edge distribution". I guarantee you they give 0 fucks about that. They're making their money.
LMAO WHAT? IN SOUTH KOREA SHE'S LIKE THE MOST POPULAR MEMBER BYEE. If anything Soyeon is the least popular member but no one admits it because she gets the most lines.
@@toxicfansaretragic2003 lmao what. Yes Miyeon is the most popular member in SoKo but calling Soyeon the least popular member is too much of a stretch 💀
@@toxicfansaretragic2003 literally 1/3 of international fans biased Soyeon. Poll rankings said so. Soyeon also ranked 4 for the Individual Girl Group Brand Reputation for 2021. She also brought in a lot of fans from her solo career, Unpretty Rapstar, PD101 and KDA. So what if she has the least views and least fan clubs? She is probably the most hated member of idle, so it makes sense that she gets the least views in fancams. I do understand that when idle is not active, she's usually last or 2nd last for brand reputation in idle, but calling her underrated is too much of a stretch when members like Shuhua and Miyeon exists.
this video just literally solved those line distribution problem in a way... there's a reason why our minnie has the most edge cause she has lots and lots of lines and why shu has quite a lot of center time. they must've think bout every aspect (lines, choreos, parts) y'all, *it's all fair.*
The comment section is so annoying...and Minnie Stan's are so toxic tbh. I mean she got more centre than the main dancer she got 2nd most lines she even got 2nd in screentime ....you guys want more ? So we don't deserve anything who's bias are yuqi soyeon soojin Miyeon and Shuhua ?
yeah, I feel in the same way in front of minnie's stan like minnie's solo stans are so many and they act like Minnie should be first in anything, idk they so fvcking annoying srry for bad english, it's not my first language
This is fair judging their positions 1. Centre 2. Main dancer 3. Vocalist but had less lines so more screentime and was in the front most of the time( Almost all times) 4. Lead dancer, also shined a lot this era 5. Main vocalist had I onic parts , had remained hidden in most of choreo 6. Main vocalist, had high note , good lines , lot of centre, completely owned some songs in the album
@@stanleytang3318 true true and it makes sense soyeon gets a lot of center time bc her position is literally is center but since dumdi era I’ve seen that other members r getting their chances at center lately like dumdi for chorus it was miyeon, yuqi, soojin, and Minnie, and hwaa now a lot of it is soojin and shuhua which I’m glad
From a dancer who has covered as Miyeon in a 6 people group, this side edge distribution is very saddening cause Miyeon is 2nd for edges and more often than not she’s behind another member when it’s not her singing parts. But all of Miyeon’s parts are extremely beautiful, such as the flower like ring they create around her. It’s like Miyeon is introduced like a goddess whenever she sings. Covering as Miyeon, I know I’ll always feel hella beautiful 🥰 It’s pretty fair for Minnie and Shuhua when you consider their vocal parts, where Minnie’s singing parts make up for the amount of edge time and Shuhua’s dance parts make up for her few lines. And Soojin, Soyeon and Yuqi are talented dancers on top of being the vocals/rappers, it makes sense for them to have less edge time. At the end of the day, this choreo and song is impossible without all 6, so I’m very appreciative and in love with this piece.
Listen everyone.. Shuhua doesn't have ANY edge 👏👏 that's really a good thing as she doesn't have many lines so she needs to compensate for it.. Minnie and Miyeon on the other hand are a different story.. Minnie has a high note to highlight her abilities 🔥🔥 And Miyeon is probably is most talked member in the comment section😍😍..so it's really not that deep...
Nevies please calm down. It's not a huge deal for Minnie to have over 1 min edge time. But it's also not nice to say stfu to one another. Can't we be one of the nice and non-toxic fandoms? :D
Why are y'all complaining? Miyeon and minnie had most of the lines of the song, and they also have lots of center time and lines so what should u complain abt that? Yuqi is the lead dancer yet she's one of the bottom and shuhua atleast they give her the spotlight not on the center nor the lines but being not on the edge and soojin is the main dancer y'all, and for soyeon do u need to be shocked?? If y'all are are nevies you must be used to this kind of stuffs
Da frik hwaa is already beautiful on its own, the choreo, the vocals and visuals and y'all demand more? Im a new fan and i expected more from this fandom
guys chill, Minnie and Miyeon got the most edge because they're main vocalist, having lines and they dont have dance position so they will spent most on edge.
I can't deal with this. At this point everyone is just obsessed with every kind of distribution and then comments will say poor x and blah blah all nonsense . Why are you even pitying them because of this edge distribution. Seriously why is this even a thing? So annoying, top notch annoying
The song is 3+ minutes long and there's 2 edges for all 6 members, you can't be mad that one of them has more than a minute of edge time, it's amazing the choreo was made so that the others got so much less, but minnie isn't officially on the dance or visual lines so it makes sense she's last here, she came first for lines in this ep by a mile bc singing is her specialty
@@Juliana-tf7zh I think Minnie deserves it tbh. She's the main vocalist and this song is really vocal heavy so I mean it fits but you do have a point I guess.
@@gashinugu yeah, I agree. I think it's odd how the main rapper and sub vocal got the most in such a heavy vocal song, but I actually feel like excluding Soyeon too much lines and shuhua lack of lines (although I can understand cause it's a heavy vocal song with traditional words and she have difficulty to do so), the distribution were pretty good and the main vocals got a spotlight. But yeah, I think Minnie deserves 70% of lines haha but people would definitely be mad about it.
Overall I dont think that this is a bad distribution Members with dance positions spent more time in the center while members with vocals spent more time on the edge. It would've been unfair if a member had no lines and was only at the edge but that didn't happen. Yeah in a perfect world minnie and miyeon would have less time on the edge but they also got the most lines (soyeon also had a lot of lines but she also has a dance position)
@@onceatiny5738 she does get alot of lines for a main vocal, she is always in the top 3, just look at all of there title tracks and bsides, she got alot of lines in hwaa, and she isn't part of the dance line so she wouldn't get alot of center time.
@@gowonslineinptt4506 Omg those are two songs, were talking about hwaa here, she does get alot of lines in other songs (title tracks and bsides) just because she is main vocal doesn't mean she is eligible to get all the lines, positions don't define how much lines do you get. She gets a fair amount of lines, especially since minnie is also counted as a main vocal, so she does get alot of lines for a main vocal.
Idle is a 6 member group so it makes sense that someone would be at the back at certain parts that needed equal distribution to the left and right side of the dance. i know it's sad that Minnie is at the edge most of the time and Miyeon is at the back half the time but it just makes kinda sense,Miyeon is the weakest dancer in the group that's why she will spend most of the time as a shadow performance wise,Minnie isn't in the dance line either,also she and Minnie already got alot of lines, it would be unfair if they would spend alot of time in the middle,and Soyeon is the center,why would not she spend time in the center. Also why is everyone not acknowledging Shuah is spending the least time at the edge or at the back? You guys never get satisfied, y'all always demand for something. As a new nevie I expected more of this fandom :(
I never really watch a lot of edge because sometimes its better to be in edge than hidden like from the start its minnie and miyeon has better view than yuqi in the back which we can only see her face.
I Felt so bad for minnie he has to be the center all the time cause she is a main vocalist but miyeon hidden at her so she is the number 1 at edge felt so sad for minnie😢
wait- it's fair Minnie is main vocal (and sub rapper), she has no dancing positions and she has a lot of lines and certer I really don't get why u should feel sorry ;-; I mean I can unterstand if you feel sorry for miyeon since she is so many times in the back, but idk just enjoy the music they probrably don't care at all about these distributions
People who got the ranking wrong thinking Minnie is last and Soyeon first but here is the real ranking: 1.Minnie 70.7s 2.Miyeon 59.7s 3.Yuqi 41.7s 4.Shuhua 40.0s 5.Soojin 38.5s 6.Soyeon 34.3s The ranking of edge is last to first so Minnie is actually first and Soyeon is actually last. Some of you may know this but this is just for the people who was wrong with the ranking.
meon is so shady they do edge, center and even "hidden member" distribution SOLELY for Gidle because they like to stir nevie's shit up. you ain't sleek baby we found out
![Eminem - Like My Shit [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vx_IMvFkrfA/mqdefault.jpg)
this comments section is annoying asf, r y’all nevies never happy w anything ?? minnie got lines so ofc it would make sense she’s at the edge more, she doesn’t have a dance position. same w miyeon, she got lines because she’s the main vocal for god’s sake so ofc she’s gonna have more edge time.
FINALLY someone said this.
Thankkk yoturueeueususisisisjauis♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
@@hangjiandeuli8283 I mean, the group has an even amount of members, if someone is the focus then it becomes uneven making the choreography not symmetrical, that's why someone gets hidden behind.
That's my theory anyway, I personally think there must be a way to do this without hiding anyone, but I haven't thought of any example.
@@hangjiandeuli8283 they have an even amount of members so they usually hide the member that just was in the center/ is about to be in the center
finally someone said this Nevies nowdays are getting annoying (half of the people who complain are not even Nevies they dont know anything about Idle)
People feel poor for Minnie because she's at the adge for over a minute when Miyeon is hidding behind most of the time 😢
and shuhua only 4 secs lines
@@oten6007 bruh qhy you only watch one video lol
@@naefirbre nope i watched all of them lmao
@Joseph Qualtier being in the center does not mean you sing that part, soojin is in the center for the first chorus then why is it not her line? also yuqi? hmm??? also if you noticed the last "hwa" still sounds the same for the first and second "hwa" and it does not count as a line. Do you know what a line means
that "hwa" is considered as a harmony and not a line, tbh just like her part in Senorita
How is it poor Minnie? She literally got alot of lines, this is really fair
This! She got a lot of lines, but people can't be satisfied with anything. Plus, she's not even the main dancer or center.
Soyeon had the most lines and less hidden and she's also top in center so I cant understand your point?
@@Juliana-tf7zh first of all, soyeon is the face of the group and center. Its only natural. Second of all, alot of people in the comments are saying "Poor Minnie" but she already has quite alot of lines. I find this really fair.
@@pataya4155 Im not saying it isn't fair, but if you're gonna said she deserved to have the most edge, then why is no one being mad at Soyeon with most lines and less edge?
Btw, before you attack me, I'm not saying Soyeon didnt deserved it or that she shouldn't get it, just saying your logic is flaw.
@@Juliana-tf7zh I never said Minnie deserves to have more edge? I just said why "Poor Minnie". I was stating how it's pretty fair as she has alot of lines. And again, soyeon is the center and face of the group, if people were to complain about her distribution, they should definitely check the positions again.
I mean Soojin is the main dancer and Minnie is the tallest member so I can see why it's like that + soyeon is the shortest members and the center, also Shuhua is the 2nd shortest member and Yuqi is the lead dancer so she could have gotten less but she almost didn't have much edge until the half the song so it's ok. But I'm sad that Miyeon has a lot cause she's most of the time hidden and also is second last in center 🙁
Shuhua is not the second shortest anymore, she's taller than Miyeon and Yuqi
Minnie was 3rd in center distrib so that compensates for this
Poor Minnie, but at least we can see her. G idle has only 6 members so it's not THAT deep. Miyeon has so many edge time and at the same time she was always in the hidden position so that's worst...
I'm happy for Shuhua, she doesn't have so many edge time
How poor?? She always sings the most. It's fair
@@casperjay7021 well, she is main vocalist and her voice fits G idle's songs very well. What I was saying is, poor Minnie, but at least we can actually see her if she is in the edge. But you are right, it's fair if we count her lines and center.
In other hand, I'm disappointed of Miyeon's edge time when she has a lot of hidden time, a position where we can't even see her.
I mean, she's the main vocalist, that's her only position (I think?). She also had a lot of lines.
It would only be unfair if she was the main dancer or center.
@@mmmag2710 Even Miyeon is the main vocalist and sang the most with Minnie. Their edge time is fine considering they are not even part of the dance line and carried the song vocally
Yall always say "poor 'blank'" as if they literally give a shit if they had the most "edge distribution". I guarantee you they give 0 fucks about that. They're making their money.
Miyeon is so underrated i swear😞
I also think that way
LMAO WHAT? IN SOUTH KOREA SHE'S LIKE THE MOST POPULAR MEMBER BYEE. If anything Soyeon is the least popular member but no one admits it because she gets the most lines.
@@toxicfansaretragic2003 lmao what. Yes Miyeon is the most popular member in SoKo but calling Soyeon the least popular member is too much of a stretch 💀
@@gowonslineinptt4506 lmao how? She gets the least amount of fancam views AND she has less fan clubs than the other members?
@@toxicfansaretragic2003 literally 1/3 of international fans biased Soyeon. Poll rankings said so. Soyeon also ranked 4 for the Individual Girl Group Brand Reputation for 2021. She also brought in a lot of fans from her solo career, Unpretty Rapstar, PD101 and KDA.
So what if she has the least views and least fan clubs? She is probably the most hated member of idle, so it makes sense that she gets the least views in fancams.
I do understand that when idle is not active, she's usually last or 2nd last for brand reputation in idle, but calling her underrated is too much of a stretch when members like Shuhua and Miyeon exists.
Minnie is 2nd in distribution and 3rd in center so that makes up for the edge distribution but Miyeon was behind everyone all the time 😢
Hey, I’ll tell my ranks
Line:
1- Soyeon
2- Miyeon
3-Minnie
Center:
1- Soyeon
2- Minnie
3- Yuqi
Edge:
1- Soojin
2- Soyeon
3- Yuqi
this video just literally solved those line distribution problem in a way... there's a reason why our minnie has the most edge cause she has lots and lots of lines and why shu has quite a lot of center time.
they must've think bout every aspect (lines, choreos, parts) y'all, *it's all fair.*
Minnie - the most edge time
Miyeon - the most hidden time
Shuhua - the least line
=> I'M FINE
The comment section is so annoying...and Minnie Stan's are so toxic tbh. I mean she got more centre than the main dancer she got 2nd most lines she even got 2nd in screentime ....you guys want more ? So we don't deserve anything who's bias are yuqi soyeon soojin Miyeon and Shuhua ?
yeah, I feel in the same way in front of minnie's stan
like minnie's solo stans are so many and they act like Minnie should be first in anything, idk they so fvcking annoying
srry for bad english, it's not my first language
This is fair judging their positions
1. Centre
2. Main dancer
3. Vocalist but had less lines so more screentime and was in the front most of the time( Almost all times)
4. Lead dancer, also shined a lot this era
5. Main vocalist had I onic parts , had remained hidden in most of choreo
6. Main vocalist, had high note , good lines , lot of centre, completely owned some songs in the album
I feel so bad for Miyeon tbh. I think the choreographers need to inovate about the formations, it's horrible to see only 5/6 members and one hiding
Yeah and its not just formation Miyeon is always put in the back from hidden distribution but then again it doesn't both me too much
Yeah it is horrible but it’s hard to have formations of a 6 member group where one person isn’t hidden. 1 hidden = 1 centre basically
@@stanleytang3318 true true and it makes sense soyeon gets a lot of center time bc her position is literally is center but since dumdi era I’ve seen that other members r getting their chances at center lately like dumdi for chorus it was miyeon, yuqi, soojin, and Minnie, and hwaa now a lot of it is soojin and shuhua which I’m glad
It's bc there are 6 members if one member is not hidden, the left and right will be uneven
@@aussieboi814 yup I know that lol
Miyeon Dance Position:
Song: 3:18
Center: 0:39
Edge: 1: 00
Hidden: almost 0:46
Without 5/6 formation: almost 1:05
"Normal": 0:11 (mostly first chorus)
100% she not making a hidden distribution!
isn't Minnie the tallest member? cuz if she is then that explains why
she is
She and Soojin
Omg, Soyeon looks so little here lol. Tiny Bean. 😊💕
Minnie is 2nd in line and 3rd in center so it is fair
From a dancer who has covered as Miyeon in a 6 people group, this side edge distribution is very saddening cause Miyeon is 2nd for edges and more often than not she’s behind another member when it’s not her singing parts. But all of Miyeon’s parts are extremely beautiful, such as the flower like ring they create around her. It’s like Miyeon is introduced like a goddess whenever she sings. Covering as Miyeon, I know I’ll always feel hella beautiful 🥰
It’s pretty fair for Minnie and Shuhua when you consider their vocal parts, where Minnie’s singing parts make up for the amount of edge time and Shuhua’s dance parts make up for her few lines. And Soojin, Soyeon and Yuqi are talented dancers on top of being the vocals/rappers, it makes sense for them to have less edge time. At the end of the day, this choreo and song is impossible without all 6, so I’m very appreciative and in love with this piece.
It's not bad Minnie got a lot of lines and center time so it's okay
It makes sense Soojin is the main dancer and Minnie and Miyeon don’t have a dance position and they got lines and the main vocalists they are.
Miyeon was about 42 seconds hidding behind someone :(
Poor Minnie :(
But Happy for Soojin bc she 2nd and she the main dancer
"People feel poor for minnie because she's at the edge for over a minute when miyeon is hidding behind most of the time"
Listen everyone..
Shuhua doesn't have ANY edge 👏👏 that's really a good thing as she doesn't have many lines so she needs to compensate for it..
Minnie and Miyeon on the other hand are a different story.. Minnie has a high note to highlight her abilities 🔥🔥 And Miyeon is probably is most talked member in the comment section😍😍..so it's really not that deep...
Nevies please calm down. It's not a huge deal for Minnie to have over 1 min edge time. But it's also not nice to say stfu to one another. Can't we be one of the nice and non-toxic fandoms? :D
minnie is still shining, even sitting on the edge😌💕
Miyeon owns Edge and Hidden position 😍😍😍😍😍
Yes cube😍 hide our visual😍😍
TXTies :(
Why are y'all complaining? Miyeon and minnie had most of the lines of the song, and they also have lots of center time and lines so what should u complain abt that? Yuqi is the lead dancer yet she's one of the bottom and shuhua atleast they give her the spotlight not on the center nor the lines but being not on the edge and soojin is the main dancer y'all, and for soyeon do u need to be shocked?? If y'all are are nevies you must be used to this kind of stuffs
Da frik hwaa is already beautiful on its own, the choreo, the vocals and visuals and y'all demand more? Im a new fan and i expected more from this fandom
가만 보면 해외팬들이 팬덤 내 분열을 자주 일으키는 듯. 어떨 때는 분량이 많고 춤 실력의 차이와 곡 분위기에 따라 늘 차이가 있기 마련인데 누가 불쌍하다, 누가 더 불쌍하다 ㅇㅈㄹ
I'm even a little happy for Shuhua in this return, but just as upset for both Shuhua and Miyeon(
Can u pls do the hidden distribution? seems like the main vocals are those who are hidden at the back and edges the most 😭.
Makes sense since they arent in dance line
What's the point of making one?
Why make one when it’s usually Miyeon and some Soyeon that were hidden
Minnie edge queen
"People feel poor for minnie because she's at the edge for over a minute when miyeon is hidding behind most of the time" :'))
Yay miyeon 2nd
R L her timer is still kinda bad Soojin and Soyeon actually have the least which is better since Soojin is the main dancer
guys chill, Minnie and Miyeon got the most edge because they're main vocalist, having lines and they dont have dance position so they will spent most on edge.
Thank you~ 3
Shuhua top three!!!!❤️
wow minnie is so edgy
i'll see myself out
Log out for me
My name is candle
my name is ken doll
My name is Kendall
omg, so perfect!!😍
Honestly i am so happy for Shuhua, she shines a lot in the dance
youre amazing aa
Please put the Brand New Ikcon and Hot issue from the Gidle
wow so smart that you put the member timer on the last position haha
I could've sworn miyeon had the most edge
thats hidden, shes usually at the back behin someone
I can't deal with this. At this point everyone is just obsessed with every kind of distribution and then comments will say poor x and blah blah all nonsense . Why are you even pitying them because of this edge distribution. Seriously why is this even a thing? So annoying, top notch annoying
They are called "Line-nazis"
Please make it for Aespa-Black Mamba too
The song is 3+ minutes long and there's 2 edges for all 6 members, you can't be mad that one of them has more than a minute of edge time, it's amazing the choreo was made so that the others got so much less, but minnie isn't officially on the dance or visual lines so it makes sense she's last here, she came first for lines in this ep by a mile bc singing is her specialty
People just sees Minnie has the most edge time and ignores miyeon has almost 1 minutes edge time and has more time hiding behind the ohers.
Imagine if this was the line distribution
Thanks and vídeo, the cherry bullet"love so sweet",please!
This is how the line distribution should've looked like
Agree!!
No...
People would cancel Minnie for singing too much haha
@@Juliana-tf7zh I think Minnie deserves it tbh. She's the main vocalist and this song is really vocal heavy so I mean it fits but you do have a point I guess.
@@gashinugu yeah, I agree. I think it's odd how the main rapper and sub vocal got the most in such a heavy vocal song, but I actually feel like excluding Soyeon too much lines and shuhua lack of lines (although I can understand cause it's a heavy vocal song with traditional words and she have difficulty to do so), the distribution were pretty good and the main vocals got a spotlight. But yeah, I think Minnie deserves 70% of lines haha but people would definitely be mad about it.
can you do the hidden distribution please?
Fair
wow
I'm so proud of shuhua
انتي تنزلين اخر الناس ليش؟
Shuhua is 3rd wow
You complain because Shuhua got less lines, and now complain because Minne was always at the edge and Miyeon at the back. Gosh
Can you please make tutorial
Woww
Ohhh Minnie my uttt
Bruh this is so unfair Minnie got the most edge wth choreographers
Minnie owed this song in my opinion :) (the whole album really)
FIRST
Hidden Distribution pleaseee 🙏
Overall I dont think that this is a bad distribution
Members with dance positions spent more time in the center while members with vocals spent more time on the edge. It would've been unfair if a member had no lines and was only at the edge but that didn't happen.
Yeah in a perfect world minnie and miyeon would have less time on the edge but they also got the most lines (soyeon also had a lot of lines but she also has a dance position)
The only member a dance position is soojin and soyeon center
They gotta stop hiding miyeon so much
Well they have a even amount of members so they have to hide on member for the choreography, she gets alot of lines yall are so ugh
@@hussey3867 did you forgot about the Miyeon drought from Senorita to Oh My God???
@@hussey3867 she gets alot of lines ? for a main vocal ? no
@@onceatiny5738 she does get alot of lines for a main vocal, she is always in the top 3, just look at all of there title tracks and bsides, she got alot of lines in hwaa, and she isn't part of the dance line so she wouldn't get alot of center time.
@@gowonslineinptt4506 Omg those are two songs, were talking about hwaa here, she does get alot of lines in other songs (title tracks and bsides) just because she is main vocal doesn't mean she is eligible to get all the lines, positions don't define how much lines do you get. She gets a fair amount of lines, especially since minnie is also counted as a main vocal, so she does get alot of lines for a main vocal.
Lion edge please
Faster than the cannonball 🤩😂😂
oh
Idle is a 6 member group so it makes sense that someone would be at the back at certain parts that needed equal distribution to the left and right side of the dance. i know it's sad that Minnie is at the edge most of the time and Miyeon is at the back half the time but it just makes kinda sense,Miyeon is the weakest dancer in the group that's why she will spend most of the time as a shadow performance wise,Minnie isn't in the dance line either,also she and Minnie already got alot of lines, it would be unfair if they would spend alot of time in the middle,and Soyeon is the center,why would not she spend time in the center. Also why is everyone not acknowledging Shuah is spending the least time at the edge or at the back? You guys never get satisfied, y'all always demand for something. As a new nevie I expected more of this fandom :(
Shuhua is the weakest dancer of the group so...
@@binettenia607 Miyeon is
Based in Meon's distributions
Miyeon
Line: 3° place
Center: 5° place
Edge: 5° place
Screen: ??
SS ( Solo Screen ): ??
Album: 2 ° place
Overwall: 11 points
Minnie
Line: 2° place
Center: 4° place
Egde: 6° place
Screen: ??
SS: ??
Album: 1° place
Overwall: 14 points
Soyeon
Line: 1° place
Center: 1° place
Edge: 1° place
Screen: ??
SS: ??
Album: 5° place
Overwall: 19 points
Soojin
Line: 5° place
Center: 3° place
Edge: 2° place
Screen: ??
SS: ??
Album: 3° place
Overwall: 13 points
Yuqi
Line: 4° place
Center: 2° place
Edge: 4° place
Screen: ??
SS: ??
Album: 4° place
Overwall: 11 points
Shuhua
Line: 6° place
Center: 6° place
Edge: 3° place
Screen: ??
SS: ??
Album: 6°place
Overwall: 4 points
1. Soyeon
2. Minnie
3. Soojin
4/5. Miyeon
4/5. Yuqi
6. Shuhua
shuhua getting third!
Can u do hidden distribution
Sorry,but what is Edge distribution?...I'm new in k-pop and I don't speak very well english
Members who are on the edge .
@@Kat-y_L thanks
@@mazare5 you're welcome.
I never really watch a lot of edge because sometimes its better to be in edge than hidden like from the start its minnie and miyeon has better view than yuqi in the back which we can only see her face.
I Felt so bad for minnie he has to be the center all the time cause she is a main vocalist but miyeon hidden at her so she is the number 1 at edge felt so sad for minnie😢
wait- it's fair
Minnie is main vocal (and sub rapper), she has no dancing positions and she has a lot of lines and certer
I really don't get why u should feel sorry ;-;
I mean I can unterstand if you feel sorry for miyeon since she is so many times in the back, but idk
just enjoy the music they probrably don't care at all about these distributions
@@-jsyxlcj4887 Yeah your right minnie is a main vocalist
I mean, despite Mini having 70, it's generally still kinda fair???
Is it me or this not in order of singing?
The person who is singing is in the center
This is really sick, why is more important all the line, screen time than the song?
Stop being so toxic
When they are lined up as 2 at the outside of the middle is still considered the edge so this isn't that accurate
Stop with the "poor minnie" she got alot of lines thats most important
Aespa black mamba
Y’all are weird but then again watching edge videos is weird as fuck too....there are bigger things n life to worry about
Miyeon isn't the only member who gets hidden lol
Hii
People who got the ranking wrong thinking Minnie is last and Soyeon first but here is the real ranking:
1.Minnie 70.7s
2.Miyeon 59.7s
3.Yuqi 41.7s
4.Shuhua 40.0s
5.Soojin 38.5s
6.Soyeon 34.3s
The ranking of edge is last to first so Minnie is actually first and Soyeon is actually last.
Some of you may know this but this is just for the people who was wrong with the ranking.
meon is so shady they do edge, center and even "hidden member" distribution SOLELY for Gidle because they like to stir nevie's shit up. you ain't sleek baby we found out
Really. How toxic all people here. Every kind of distributions that the last member got the least, you would say "POOR"
Jajajjajajaja ya no entiendo nada.
이건 뭔 개소리야.....?
At least soyeon get some edge and hidden this time unlike in oh my god
Stfu
Wow