Hi Kushal.... today's gathering was awesome....I just could not enter the hall and literally has to squeeze myself and pasted myself against the far wall. Could hear the wonderful conversations for about an hour and half. Feeling sad could not get your signature on my copy of the book. I had to leave for an dinner appointment. Best wishes 👍
THIS!! This is what used to happen in ancient Bharat, the Punya Bhoomi. Many scholars would be invited to debate on special occasions and were given equal opportunity to present their view points and at the end of the day each went home, peacefully without a severed head as it'd happen in Abrahamic cults...Proud to be a Sanatani, the glorious Dharma which says 'Sarvejana Sukhino Bhavantu' 'Vasudaika Kutumbakam' ❤ 🕉 🔱🚩
Good thing i didnt go 😂😂😂 I would have suffocated. But positive thing is, people went in huge numbers. I am happy to see that me going or not going wouldnt have made a difference
Atheism may or may not have better morals- but definitely weaker will to enforce morals. Could Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj have withstood torture of Aurangzeb if he was an atheist?
Yes but they didn't know that religion and God is unlikely. Today with science more than 80% of religion is shown to be pointless . Will sambhaji remain that big of a Shiva bhakt if he knew evolution and other scientific facts??
@@Anomander5622 How does evolution contradict Hinduism? If anything it fits well with the idea of Vasudaiva Kutumbakam, bc evolution literally shows us how all life shares common descent.
It's just moral pontificating, the moment there's a mob outside the door they'll be the first one to read the kalma because muslims are also Hindu for these folks.
@@adityarajan592 Evolution shows that life emerged from certain chemical reactions and random selections. Not 100% certain but very very very high probability. Hinduism talks of vedas which are unauthored. A lot of sects talk of a personal God. Just because some idea is a little bit matching doesnt mean that hinduism is consistent with evolution. Yes, our ancestors did very well in observing the phenomenon around them and we were a great civilisation. But we also have a lot of unscientific things
20:58 dharma is not religion. This has to get into all heads seriously ! 33:59 this is the kind of logical debates our scholars used to have with proper references to where they are getting the point from.
Congratulations kushal for your book🎉 thoroughly enjoyed and it is always a delight to listen and watch four distinguished persons like you guys.Where on earth you would find three nastiks sitting in a room full of astiks discussing about the book,hinduism it is possible only in Bharat 👀🤔❤️✌️🙏
The reason the academia doesn't associate itself with bharatiya but indians is because of where the money lies. If you have structures that were to control a huge chunk of the money flow, that would change the direction.
There's a lot of stutter in the video for me, I would be ok with the bad picture quality was that not happening. Anyways, congratulations on the launch.
@@VedhantBossatheism will replace every religion some day or the other People are becoming rational , logical and questioning everything , that's a milestone for human curiosity Every civilization (egyptian , indus, mesopotamian) has vanished, hinduism and all other religions in this world too will go
@@Nickel287you are believing in a new age atheist myth when the west decristianized , it got replaced by wokeism I suggest u to read kushal's book were he points out that religion is an evolutionary reality rather than a by product of time .
The streaming quality resembles Maharashtra’s roads! Before reaching the good part, you gotta drive through hell filled with potholes!! (Mumbai Pune, Mumbai Goa, Even Samruddhi for now! 😆)
Animals do believe in some kind of Spirituality, according to Scientists. In my opinion, these kinds of Spirituality come from some kind of "Fundamental Existence". God was just a deviation or corruption of that.
I have really great counters on Shree Aanand Ranganathan’s most thoughtful God non existence theory i have huge respect towards him and i support him as an Naastik because he’s questioning he had this consciousness and he might not respect consciousness but this very consciousness is what proves existence of God at very basic, Im not saying consciousness is what only God is, Theres much to say but what i say I respect Ranganathan Ji for using the consciousness of the same supreme God for what it means for, Im putting it in very simple question and ending the comment here the question is why we not only humans but most living beings have feelings have sense of preservation care and protection?? Yet more to include and ask but this very tendency of living beings anywhere in universe to propagate to save ourselves this tendency given us through science originated by god’s will, The very our natural tendency by birth as humans to know what we are on which this darwinian science is also based this came out of our tendency to know what we are this tendency of ours to know what we are and its only exist in humans is another reason why humans are describes as the only species for liberation as God says, Scriptures also explains that other species are put to be made naturally agnostic who do not care why do we exist because there species are made for the respective souls to face there sins to face there karma and Humans as more conscious and the natural curious beings we are created to get liberated from our sins our Karma thats why the Human as species by the method of science so that soul can get liberate from the Human body thats why theres such difference in other & Human species. Why as a human at very basic and essential level we all have same goodness and same true consciousness this is because the soul is no different within us.
1:52:40 Abjeet bhai you have no idea how how rigorous the discussions on god were used to be, not violent but super rigorous. it is not like aunties discussing about dal makhani recipes. Do you forget about the brutal debates of Shankaracharyas? it is not simple 👍
@@vedprakashtiwari6438 Bhai i don't have command at English language as much as Abhijit, Kushal or other panalist, but yaar it hurts how little these guys know about Hindu Scriptures and core beliefs. Kabhi Kabhi tw lagta hay ye sab natak krke paisa wasul kr rahe hai 😂😂. Anyways inki deemag mai savera aye yahi Kamana hai meri 👍
Why should I care if other species have religion or not? Anand is just facing a shock from trying to come to terms with the fact that perhaps we are insignificant. The shock would only exist in a framework where you have been thinking for the longest time that you were the most important species on the planet.
Anand's view on religion and morality is so juvenile. Ofcourse from a pure rational material sense, humans are insignificant, just a product of a determinist process, and so on. But in that purely material world, there is also no morality, everything every act that we deem absolutely abhorrent across societies is also neutral. We can most definitely return to that world again, where we live no different from animals. But for anything else, for any level of society or civilization, or even sustained individual achievement or human excellence to exist, we need larger meaning and a sense of morality, which has always come from some or the other form of transcendental metaphysics. It is indeed true that no civilization has ever existed without religion. We can either begrudgingly disown human consciousness, or embrace it to achieve all the greatness that humanity is capable of.
Not true. If we all agreed that 'well being' is a good thing then we can build on what is moral and immoral. We do have a sense of morality which is most likely a result of evolution. Even if god did exist it wouldn't make morality objective.
@@someone-jl4sj how would we all agree to that. Morality is indeed intrinsic but it is always distributed across society and followed in a non-rational axiomatic belief based manner.
@@Alduizard I don't see the problem. It's not like all relegious people believe in the same morality. The reason we do not agree on morality is largely because beleif in sky daddy.
@@Alduizard I don't see why non religious morality would be 'worse' than relegious morality. I do see the problem with relegion. I don't think any part of comment suggested that I don't see problem with relegion.
😂😂इनको देखकर लग रहा है जैसे पड़ोस के चार दोस्त मिल कर बोलें "चलो आज सरस्वती पूजा का आयोजन करते हैं",,, सब मस्ती में हैं, खुद से देवी कि मुर्ति ला रहे हैं, खुद से पंडाल बना रहे हैं 😂😂😂
Do you want to know what is actual education and sensitivity? See how he has silenced the applause whenever it rises. A video purely made for intellectual consumption.
Saalon itne saal se in person meetup karenge bol bol kar suspense create karte ho - jab inperson meetup hota hai tw JHOPDI se bhi choti jagah pe venue book karte ho. Itne saal se 1,1 rupees bhej bhej kar maine ek stadium book karwane ki paise de dia in the end SAB KAALE EK JAISE HOTE HAIN greedy.
Streaming tatti🤮 hai bhai and behen log. Kushal ne kanjusi me BSNL ka internet, aur wo bhi 2G scam wala pack dalwaya tha, tatti streaming karne ke liye. Hey Kushal! Is video ko dubara 4K me upload kar bhai.
Well if just mutual respect and identification requires to be hindu then whats the need for theology can a infian muslim be hindu just cause he respects hinduism and is a practicing muslim can a jew be hindu if she respects hinduism and what are the criteria to be a hindu can a jew practice judaism and identify as hindu be a hindu These atheists seem to be crap
Saalo itni kharab video and audio quality. Never livestream again cause the last book launch was still better than this. Was so keen on listening to today’s session. Sab barbaad.
streaming quality of 2013 great
Stay corrected , 2007
2003
1963 with color filter applied on it
I think 1957 will be a great year for independent India
@@sauravrao234 60s quality
quality stream starts @ 18:30 thank me later 😀😀
Thanks
Jiska channel hai usko to sunlo bhai😂
@@Epicurousdemoschannel vale ko itna fark padta to dhang ka video dalta.
Thanks. So helpful
Thaaaanksss
hey kushal the "2009 mallu bhabhi mms" aesthetic is great, really adds a new dimesnion to the experience... thnx
The most accurate disctription 😭
Indeed
hahahahaha
At 58:20 just when abhijit says "why i want to preserve hinduism" an indi alliance ad popped up💀
Lol 😂
They are targeting all right wing channels with ad. Also reporting the same channels thru Dhruv’s Squad.
😂😂
Utube is playing their game
😂😂😂
Hi Kushal.... today's gathering was awesome....I just could not enter the hall and literally has to squeeze myself and pasted myself against the far wall.
Could hear the wonderful conversations for about an hour and half.
Feeling sad could not get your signature on my copy of the book. I had to leave for an dinner appointment.
Best wishes 👍
Same here . 😅
THIS!! This is what used to happen in ancient Bharat, the Punya Bhoomi. Many scholars would be invited to debate on special occasions and were given equal opportunity to present their view points and at the end of the day each went home, peacefully without a severed head as it'd happen in Abrahamic cults...Proud to be a Sanatani, the glorious Dharma which says 'Sarvejana Sukhino Bhavantu'
'Vasudaika Kutumbakam' ❤ 🕉 🔱🚩
Yes bro
sham is a hulk 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Chad Bihari, Virgin Punjabi JK
Ghatotkach
Seriously, had no idea he was so huge
He lifts weights
Resembles puneet isaar
Good thing i didnt go 😂😂😂 I would have suffocated.
But positive thing is, people went in huge numbers. I am happy to see that me going or not going wouldnt have made a difference
This means, they are not used to this kind of response.
Good problem to have.
Atheism may or may not have better morals- but definitely weaker will to enforce morals. Could Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj have withstood torture of Aurangzeb if he was an atheist?
Good nuanced view. Agree or disagree, this is the type of conversation that needs to be initiated.
Yes but they didn't know that religion and God is unlikely. Today with science more than 80% of religion is shown to be pointless . Will sambhaji remain that big of a Shiva bhakt if he knew evolution and other scientific facts??
@@Anomander5622 How does evolution contradict Hinduism? If anything it fits well with the idea of Vasudaiva Kutumbakam, bc evolution literally shows us how all life shares common descent.
It's just moral pontificating, the moment there's a mob outside the door they'll be the first one to read the kalma because muslims are also Hindu for these folks.
@@adityarajan592 Evolution shows that life emerged from certain chemical reactions and random selections. Not 100% certain but very very very high probability. Hinduism talks of vedas which are unauthored. A lot of sects talk of a personal God. Just because some idea is a little bit matching doesnt mean that hinduism is consistent with evolution. Yes, our ancestors did very well in observing the phenomenon around them and we were a great civilisation. But we also have a lot of unscientific things
20:58 dharma is not religion.
This has to get into all heads seriously !
33:59 this is the kind of logical debates our scholars used to have with proper references to where they are getting the point from.
Congratulations kushal for your book🎉 thoroughly enjoyed and it is always a delight to listen and watch four distinguished persons like you guys.Where on earth you would find three nastiks sitting in a room full of astiks discussing about the book,hinduism it is possible only in Bharat 👀🤔❤️✌️🙏
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🙏🏽
Jai BHARAT 🇮🇳🙏🏽
Jai SIYARAM 🙏🏽🙏🏽
Such a pleasure to be there today and the show was housefull 😅
+5 iq points after seeing this session
Just for remembering
I was here 😊
Bhai kitne log the audience mei ?
Myself also, even asked question at 1 hr 38 min time snap
Marking my check here too
Please upload the recorded video!!! Not the live stream.... It's not watchable!!!!
The reason the academia doesn't associate itself with bharatiya but indians is because of where the money lies. If you have structures that were to control a huge chunk of the money flow, that would change the direction.
Exactly my point
There's a lot of stutter in the video for me, I would be ok with the bad picture quality was that not happening. Anyways, congratulations on the launch.
Congratulations on your Book Kushal, awesome discussion .
It was awesome sham is so huge
Warming to see kushal’s mum and dad looking at him with pride
The video quality suited my CRT monitor
Bhai Nokia 110 se 3GP me isse zyada clear video aati hai...... hadd hai bhai
21:55 - cheery picking in hinduism?
24:55 - difference between atheist and agnostic
I want a logical debunk of Vimoh.
What is there to debunk he is a New age 2008 type atheist who still believes humanism and secularism can replace religion
@@VedhantBossyes secularism and industrialisation is best ( good joke
@@VedhantBossatheism will replace every religion some day or the other
People are becoming rational , logical and questioning everything , that's a milestone for human curiosity
Every civilization (egyptian , indus, mesopotamian) has vanished, hinduism and all other religions in this world too will go
@@Nickel287you are believing in a new age atheist myth when the west decristianized , it got replaced by wokeism I suggest u to read kushal's book were he points out that religion is an evolutionary reality rather than a by product of time .
@@Nickel287cringe, you dont know much kid... be mature 😂😂
Such bad internet quality. Was really looking forward to it😢
The streaming quality resembles Maharashtra’s roads! Before reaching the good part, you gotta drive through hell filled with potholes!! (Mumbai Pune, Mumbai Goa, Even Samruddhi for now! 😆)
Great to know the book launch happened. Video is Unwatchable. Please upload better streaming quality.
My favourite people at one place 😊
Let's go💪😁
Aaj ke zamane mein 2 mega pixel ka camera kaha mila tumhe😢
😂
offically launch the book? mumbai mei kya trial ball launch hua tha?
😁
Animals do believe in some kind of Spirituality, according to Scientists. In my opinion, these kinds of Spirituality come from some kind of "Fundamental Existence".
God was just a deviation or corruption of that.
Damn, nicely put.
Great conversation...lekin stream matt karo ....Acha camera se recording Karke daal do ...bahot he kharab quality hai
I must say the camera quality is top notch.
yae 2005 ki video have kya?
Are nahi bhai 😊
Video quality of the rig Vedic era after the battle of 10 kings
I have really great counters on Shree Aanand Ranganathan’s most thoughtful God non existence theory i have huge respect towards him and i support him as an Naastik because he’s questioning he had this consciousness and he might not respect consciousness but this very consciousness is what proves existence of God at very basic, Im not saying consciousness is what only God is, Theres much to say but what i say I respect Ranganathan Ji for using the consciousness of the same supreme God for what it means for, Im putting it in very simple question and ending the comment here the question is why we not only humans but most living beings have feelings have sense of preservation care and protection?? Yet more to include and ask but this very tendency of living beings anywhere in universe to propagate to save ourselves this tendency given us through science originated by god’s will, The very our natural tendency by birth as humans to know what we are on which this darwinian science is also based this came out of our tendency to know what we are this tendency of ours to know what we are and its only exist in humans is another reason why humans are describes as the only species for liberation as God says, Scriptures also explains that other species are put to be made naturally agnostic who do not care why do we exist because there species are made for the respective souls to face there sins to face there karma and Humans as more conscious and the natural curious beings we are created to get liberated from our sins our Karma thats why the Human as species by the method of science so that soul can get liberate from the Human body thats why theres such difference in other & Human species. Why as a human at very basic and essential level we all have same goodness and same true consciousness this is because the soul is no different within us.
Only in India do we have devout Darwanian atheists propogating Hindutva and upholdinh Hindu religion!!!
if u hate hindu religion so much, why not move ur ass to an islamic state.
Best of luck 🤞
Sham is Desi Hulk
Sanatanis please unite
Bencho miss kar diya 😢
Sushant shud be on the stage. Hes tge best🎉
Ladies and Gentlemen The four horsemen are here.🎉🎉
If u people were in Europe
People would have made cult of all of u guys
Great knowledge
Great debate
🫡🫡🫡
Omg I love Abhijit ❤
BC aisa lag raha hai nokia 6610 pe mms dekh raha hun. Thanks for the nostalgia.
oh bhai. avengers assemble. BRING ME RAGA
Bhai konse jamane main shoot kiya hain ye video ?
Abhi kiya hai bhai 😊
Beautiful event ruined by worst streaming quality, never expected..... Highly disappointed with Audio Video quality.
Finally ♥️🔥
The sound quality is very poor on this podcast
1:52:40 Abjeet bhai you have no idea how how rigorous the discussions on god were used to be, not violent but super rigorous. it is not like aunties discussing about dal makhani recipes. Do you forget about the brutal debates of Shankaracharyas? it is not simple 👍
Correct!
@@vedprakashtiwari6438 Bhai i don't have command at English language as much as Abhijit, Kushal or other panalist, but yaar it hurts how little these guys know about Hindu Scriptures and core beliefs. Kabhi Kabhi tw lagta hay ye sab natak krke paisa wasul kr rahe hai 😂😂. Anyways inki deemag mai savera aye yahi Kamana hai meri 👍
Are koi nhi, he meant in a sweet way, he wasnt refrerring to simple discussions as fhat level of aunties@@nepalistories108
Foursome awesome
but....when you rent a rat-hole space, any crowd will look like "Overflowing".
Atleast the Audio quality is okay this time
Quality of video sucks…. Was looking forward to this book review.
There's a Punjabi inside bihari Sham Sharma.
AR was really insufferable in this discussion. Doesn’t let the program remain academic or professional.
Do something to make your audio better
It starts being reasonably ok at 11.30 - of course even then video freezes.
Oh well….
Why should I care if other species have religion or not? Anand is just facing a shock from trying to come to terms with the fact that perhaps we are insignificant. The shock would only exist in a framework where you have been thinking for the longest time that you were the most important species on the planet.
which species do u belong to?
Anand's view on religion and morality is so juvenile. Ofcourse from a pure rational material sense, humans are insignificant, just a product of a determinist process, and so on. But in that purely material world, there is also no morality, everything every act that we deem absolutely abhorrent across societies is also neutral.
We can most definitely return to that world again, where we live no different from animals. But for anything else, for any level of society or civilization, or even sustained individual achievement or human excellence to exist, we need larger meaning and a sense of morality, which has always come from some or the other form of transcendental metaphysics. It is indeed true that no civilization has ever existed without religion. We can either begrudgingly disown human consciousness, or embrace it to achieve all the greatness that humanity is capable of.
Not true.
If we all agreed that 'well being' is a good thing then we can build on what is moral and immoral. We do have a sense of morality which is most likely a result of evolution.
Even if god did exist it wouldn't make morality objective.
@@someone-jl4sj how would we all agree to that. Morality is indeed intrinsic but it is always distributed across society and followed in a non-rational axiomatic belief based manner.
@@Alduizard I don't see the problem.
It's not like all relegious people believe in the same morality.
The reason we do not agree on morality is largely because beleif in sky daddy.
@@someone-jl4sj you dont see a problem with religion? Then what's the argument?
@@Alduizard I don't see why non religious morality would be 'worse' than relegious morality.
I do see the problem with relegion.
I don't think any part of comment suggested that I don't see problem with relegion.
When 3 monkeys get together there will always be overcrowding.
😂😂 and what are you??? Donkey
All the best
😂😂इनको देखकर लग रहा है जैसे पड़ोस के चार दोस्त मिल कर बोलें "चलो आज सरस्वती पूजा का आयोजन करते हैं",,, सब मस्ती में हैं, खुद से देवी कि मुर्ति ला रहे हैं, खुद से पंडाल बना रहे हैं 😂😂😂
Do you want to know what is actual education and sensitivity? See how he has silenced the applause whenever it rises. A video purely made for intellectual consumption.
Yaar sham bhai bihar aae mil nahi paye, mast marine drive chalte litti chap khane✌️
VHS? or Betamax? 🤔
Bhai allo🥔 se record kri thi kya ??
Bhai isse achha selfi camera mey whats call kardeyta, wuality better aati
Book launch hai, kya MMS leak? 😂
Quality kaha haii?
Fun!
More more and about different topics science, history and others too
sham is the reincarnation of Ghatokacch
Mujhe laga mera network 🛜 kharab hai
This interview was recorded with a calculator.
Saalon itne saal se in person meetup karenge bol bol kar suspense create karte ho - jab inperson meetup hota hai tw JHOPDI se bhi choti jagah pe venue book karte ho. Itne saal se 1,1 rupees bhej bhej kar maine ek stadium book karwane ki paise de dia in the end SAB KAALE EK JAISE HOTE HAIN greedy.
Fuck, Sam is a Monstrous Guy
Poor quality video and audio 😞
kushal uncle ne itne book bech kar ek dhang ka setup bhi nahi lagaya
Hindu have no problem when u create god of your own but the problem comes when u impose gods on hindus .islam and Christianity 😊
Only if you realized that being an atheist is acceptable..."Nāstika" is the problematic one.
Streaming tatti🤮 hai bhai and behen log.
Kushal ne kanjusi me BSNL ka internet, aur wo bhi 2G scam wala pack dalwaya tha, tatti streaming karne ke liye.
Hey Kushal! Is video ko dubara 4K me upload kar bhai.
😂😂😂 jaldi ka kam shaitan ka 😂
IIC me internet achha nhi tha
Why is the video and audio quality so pathetic. Was this held in mars?
Well if just mutual respect and identification requires to be hindu then whats the need for theology can a infian muslim be hindu just cause he respects hinduism and is a practicing muslim can a jew be hindu if she respects hinduism and what are the criteria to be a hindu can a jew practice judaism and identify as hindu be a hindu
These atheists seem to be crap
27:50
Abhijit ki mummy bhi wahi baithi hai
Video quality very very bad
No, can’t continue. Sorry but even audio is terrible.
Sham ❌ Puneet Issar ✅
Saalo itni kharab video and audio quality. Never livestream again cause the last book launch was still better than this. Was so keen on listening to today’s session. Sab barbaad.
The a;theists in Ins;tagram a;re an;ti-hin;ddu a;nd kn;ow no;thing ab;out o;ur cul;ture.
Fun fact- this video was shot through a potato 😂
Anand Ranganathan is a Right wing Atheist 😅
Desi book launch leaked mms
Are you guys enjoying 4k 90fps?
Hope there's another video of this because there's no way I'm watching anything in such shit quality.
😅😅😅 why such 2000s mms quality video.
Chalu kamse kam Mike thik hai iss baar