Faber-Castell Goldfaber Aqua Vs Albrecht Durer Watercolor Pencils Comparison

Hey Artnerds! Earlier this month, we reviewed Faber-Castell's Albrecht Durer watercolor pencils. Today we're checking out their Goldfaber Aqua watercolor pencils, and comparing the two!
Winsor and Newton Watercolor Pencil Review: • Winsor and Newton Wate...
Faber-Castell Albrecht Durer Watercolor Pencils Review: • Faber-Castell Albrecht...
Derwent Inktense Pencils Review: • Derwent Inktense "Wate...
Supracolor II Pencil Review: • Supracolor II Watercol...
Prismacolor Watercolor Pencils Review: • Prismacolor Watercolor...
Full shownotes here: docs.google.com/document/d/17...
48 pencil set, sent by Faber-Castell
This review was not sponsored or commissioned by Faber-Castell- this review is of my own volition, and all opinions are my own. This is part of a larger series reviewing watercolor pencils.
Part of their Creative Studio Line
Comparing it to Faber-Castell Albrecht Durer Line
Created for Student and hobby artists
$1.25 per pencil on Blick tinyurl.com/w6codbk
Set of 48- $35.01 on Amazon ( amzn.to/2KP4gk3)
Set of 24: $31.99 on Amazon (amzn.to/2XHRmtw) vs $25.82 (amzn.to/2OcnfHw) for Albrecht Durer
Faber-Castell site promises soft and intense color laydown, outstanding colour brilliants (tinyurl.com/vtylxdn)
Faber-Castell Goldfaber Aqua Compared to Faber-Castell Albrecht Durer Watercolor Pencils
Harder lead, not as buttery as the Albrecht Durer
not a lot of dust
Water swatching:
Colors activate pretty readily
Not as pigmented as the Albrecht Durer
Side by side comparison:
Blues (140, 120) are noticeably different in the Goldfaber Aqua line from the Albrecht Durer line. Leads are harder, not as buttery. Goldfaber pencils feel a bit thinner than the Albrecht Durer pencils, and have slightly smaller leads. Definitely not as pigmented.
Side by Side swatches:
Albrecht Durer watercolor pencils are MUCH more saturated and pigmented than the Goldfaber Aqua. The Goldfaber Aqua are quite pale in comparison. Goldfaber is slightly harder not as buttery, and doesn't feel as nice in the hand.
Colorwheel
104, 107, 121, 126, 143, 120
Some dust, not as dusty as other watercolor pencils I've reviewed
Harder than other watercolor pencils
Color caps are slightly deceptive, esp with the blues, making it harder to select colors quickly
Wet:
Most of the color sloughs off from the paper onto the brush into my wash cup
Water is pretty muddy- maybe a lot of optical brighteners?
Colors are rich and saturated while wet
Colors dried vibrant
Better color activation with the Albrecht Durer- You can see more of the pencil is dissolved- not as many pencil marks
Layer Test:
These pencils get consumed fast
Do that same weird layering thing that the Prismacolors did where top layer activates, bottom doesn't, colors don't really mix
Colors don't really mix this way
Secondary Color Swatches:
Much cleaner than mixes I could achieve.
Compared to Albrecht Durer, doesn't dissolve nearly as well, Albrecht Durer both layers have better activation
Pigmentation is way better in the Albrecht Durer pencils
Verdict:
Do not handle as well as Albrecht Durer watercolor pencils- but that makes sense, they're Student watercolor pencils, not professional. However, when listings say 'highest quality materials', it's understandable that there might be confusion!
In terms of performance, I would put these above Prismacolor Watercolor pencils but below Winsor and Newton watercolor pencils. If it comes down to the Goldfaber Aqua vs Albrecht Durer watercolor pencils though, I recommend spending a little more money and getting the Albrecht Durer.
Color activation, pigmentation, and pigment saturation are better with the Albrecht Durer watercolor pencils. Pencils are also lightfast tested and list lightfastness on individual pencils, so if you care about archival quality, Albrecht Durer is a better pick. Color names listed on pencils make it easier to pick the colors you want, Goldfaber Aqua is more guessing. Goldfaber Aqua pencils feel lighter, and the core is slightly smaller, so you're getting less overall pigment per pencil.
Music:
Kevin MacLeod- DD Groove
Meditation Impromptu 03
Impact Lento
Tranquility
Dream Culture
#FaberCastell #FaberCastellGoldFaber #GoldFaberwatercolorpencils

[@Nattosoup]

These are Faber-Castell's student grade watercolor pencils, compared to Faber's professional grade, the Albrecht Durer. I hope you guys found this comparison helpful, particularly when selecting which watercolor pencils are right for you.

[@awhitney3063]

I've watched about three different reviews of Goldfaber vs. Albrecht trying to decide, and your review was by far the most helpful and informative, you did a really good job.

[@Nattosoup]

Awesome, thank you! I'm really glad my review was able to be so helpful!

[@BarbaraDick-r5]

Great review thank you

[@jillwiswall5386]

Very helpful to see the differences between student and professional grade, thanks!

[@emilyerdbeere9210]

Thank you for this wonderful test! The Albrecht Dürer look strange with water, the colour flows uncontrolled... I don’t like this Effekt because I want to have control and no effects

Thank you for the video. Why don't you have more views????