I never really go crazy about exo, but this song is just too wonderful. Chen probably has the best vocal technique, BUT i am amazed of every D.O's part, he expressed the lyrics so well without trying hard to be explosive
this song always makes D.O. emotional and he always seems so frail. I wish he had some of the powerful vocals but they need him to show the fragile, frail, soft side. He looks like his going to cry every time. Lay is phenomenal at the piano. And everyone sung great as always.The best part is when they all sing together, it always gives me chills
My eyes were in Lay's most of the time. Baekhyun is not like himself, and anyone noticed that D.O looks like in the verge of crying? Weird... Such a good performance with Luhan around and of course Chen never fails us :)
International netizen always commenting on RUclips and spotting their lights on Korean netizen... I wonder how the Korean netizen feels every time they read our comments? :D Anyways, just as I expected, Luhan's voice is really soft, it matches well with ballad song like this :)
I was never really into EXO but this song is daebak!!! They really got my attention now!!! amazing vocals and holymoly looove Chen's voice the most!! sooo beautiful this song!!
EXO is gonna have a special stage with all of the members later in the week, I heard. I hope they'll perform "The Star" or "First Snow" together. Those are my favorite songs off of their Christmas album. ^^
OMG!!! @4:00 some people got shot or something... it was terrifying!!! By the way Chen's voice is like an angel falling down from the heavens!!! Love their performance... Lay playing the piano just makes it more perfect!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
*sigh* This performance would have blew me out of the water if the harmonies were live and the piano playing was live. These boys got the chops let them sing SM! Gah...
I remember watching a video of this song where Lay is standing near the guys and I think is Luhan who gives him the mic and he sings the part!! I saw it like years ago and I cant find it! it was so beautiful, I cried. if anyone knows what video I am talking about please please please! share it with me!!!!
I hope there will be a performance with Kai dancing ballet. The 4 of them singing, Lay playing piano and Kai dancing in 1 performance would be epic (bit too much but epic~)
Yay, my wish came true ^-^ I really wanted Baekhyun, Kyungsoo, Chen and Luhan singing this song together. And now it came true + Lay played the piano - The only thing that missed, were the others ;3
Chen's voice is amazing, Lay is so handsome!
i love it when Lay plays piano
This is without a doubt the best version of the song. Luhan's soft vocal tone really adds something special :)
Lay on the piano, BaekSooChenLu's vocals and omg Luhan's dark hair 3
there's an angel playing piano beautifully..
I never really go crazy about exo, but this song is just too wonderful. Chen probably has the best vocal technique, BUT i am amazed of every D.O's part, he expressed the lyrics so well without trying hard to be explosive
EXO♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
this song always makes D.O. emotional and he always seems so frail. I wish he had some of the powerful vocals but they need him to show the fragile, frail, soft side. He looks like his going to cry every time. Lay is phenomenal at the piano. And everyone sung great as always.The best part is when they all sing together, it always gives me chills
they are all amazing but CHEN IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT LEVEL
like his voice is a light through the clouds from heaven to people's heart...
My eyes were in Lay's most of the time. Baekhyun is not like himself, and anyone noticed that D.O looks like in the verge of crying? Weird... Such a good performance with Luhan around and of course Chen never fails us :)
love this. Lay played the piano, and D.O. Baekhyun Chen and Luhan…their voices are so awesome as always.
Oooo best performance yet! Cuz lay and luhan is in it too! Those boys are so talented!
i'm obsessed with lay playing the piano *sigh*
How D.O goes all serious while singing.. oh my
Chen amazing voice give me goosebumps when he sing high notes! Also lay is so talent. miss u luhan oppa!😢😭
I am happy that SM finally give the chance to Lay to play piano in the stage. This performance was really awesome.
lay playing the piano is everything oml
Lay~~ and D.O at the end, his eyes omg
Gahd, Luhan & DO really have the most gorgeous faces in EXO. It's also a jackpot that they both hv amazing voices especially D.O.
Lay is amazing
couldn't ignore the fan screaming scarily towards the end of the performance. her voice is already so broken
International netizen always commenting on RUclips and spotting their lights on Korean netizen... I wonder how the Korean netizen feels every time they read our comments? :D
Anyways, just as I expected, Luhan's voice is really soft, it matches well with ballad song like this :)
Lay playing the piano it feels goshh i LOVE him ^^
LUHAN + LAY = PERFECTION
I was never really into EXO but this song is daebak!!! They really got my attention now!!! amazing vocals and holymoly looove Chen's voice the most!! sooo beautiful this song!!
Aw I was really hoping that Lay would sing. He looked so cute and professional playing on the piano though
Simply stunning. Simple outfit, beautiful stage, lay's piano. For me, perfect!
Love Baekhyun and D.O voice. So good ! Awesome
LAY!!! He's so perfect.
EXO is gonna have a special stage with all of the members later in the week, I heard. I hope they'll perform "The Star" or "First Snow" together. Those are my favorite songs off of their Christmas album. ^^
Dio teary eyes ;;-;;
and finallyyyyyyy Luhan ugh i really like his voice, it's really soft T^T
and Lay's piano playing was really good
that person who was screaming at the end surely spoiled the mood lol
Luhan have such a beautiful voice and powerful high notes, they just don't give him the chance to show
OMG!!! @4:00 some people got shot or something... it was terrifying!!! By the way Chen's voice is like an angel falling down from the heavens!!! Love their performance... Lay playing the piano just makes it more perfect!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
Live piano always sounds better. Lay was amazing.
Chen and Lay were sooo good
d.o. look so 😍 i wish if they give him more line 😣 but chen's voice is OMG😍
디오짱
와.. 몇몇인 무개념 엑소팬들 싫다. 노래듣고싶은데 어떤년혼자 계속 빽빽 소리지르고 미친.. 어째든 노래는 너무 좋다 ㅎㅎ
다섯 천사~♡
엑소노래중 가장 좋아하는 곡이에요.
우울할때 힘이 되어주는 노래..
This is AMAZING. I love Chen OPPA so much
The one playin piano- Lay
00:19 - D.O kyungsoo
00:34 - Baekhyun
00:43 / 01:13 - Luhan
00:58 - Chen
Definitivamente Lay en el piano se ve tan lindo, sexy, formal, todo
The stage is so... pretty! Really love this song!
*sigh* This performance would have blew me out of the water if the harmonies were live and the piano playing was live. These boys got the chops let them sing SM! Gah...
wow that was breathtaking
Still....fangirling over Chen. =))
My wish came true. Lay is the pianist for the live performance :)
wow I didn't know Lay could play the piano soo well xD
I remember watching a video of this song where Lay is standing near the guys and I think is Luhan who gives him the mic and he sings the part!! I saw it like years ago and I cant find it! it was so beautiful, I cried. if anyone knows what video I am talking about please please please! share it with me!!!!
Oh my god Lay!!!SO great my piano boy!
I hope there will be a performance with Kai dancing ballet. The 4 of them singing, Lay playing piano and Kai dancing in 1 performance would be epic (bit too much but epic~)
exactly what i was thought. Hopefully it will comes true..
WOW what a beautiful presentation really good combination make five, lay on the piano and baekhyun, luhan, chen and D.O incredible voices
This song has a lot of emotions to it. I don't care if some people hate exo, but I Love Exo. Exo Fighting!!
EXO are the best 🙏🙏Who from BTS can sing like this ? That’s right , no One
Chen is not my bias but he looks kinda hot here. Anyway great performance.😍😭👌
The person who was screaming towards the ending made me laugh so hard omg
OHHHHHHHHHHHHH This performance was soooo!!!! GOOOD!! LAY With the PIANO!! AND BAEKHYUN AND LUHAN Oh!! I love this!! They look like angels!!
LAY IS GREAT AT PIANO
I LOOOOVE this song!! And is it just me that I see Luhan's eye is like sparkly?? ;p
His eyes are always sparkly ㅍ.ㅍ
Luhan amazing singer Angelic Voice
Lay why you so cool
Yay, Luhan and Lay are here too.
if singing D.O look very serious and emotional.make me fell so sad omg
Realmente hermoso, sus voces me encantan, Lay toca de lo más lindo... Y las locas fans del fondo .l. ¿No se pudieron aguantar?
울 애기들 노래 너무 잘한다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
ㅁ ㅣ 틘 음색~ ㅁ ㅣㅊ ㅕ ㅆ ㅓ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
chen's powerful voice
AND MY EARS HAVE BEEN HEALED OH LORD
lay u just killed it slay as always *-*♥♥♥♥
Where was Lay? All I saw were D.O., Baekhyun, Chen, and Luhan?
Chris Williams he is the one playing the piano💙💙
It wish they could perform both the Chinese and Korean version of this song
the best voice.... chen
CHEN es espectacular adoro su voz es la mejor k he escuchado *-*
let`s make miracles in december. EXO No1!!!
The hell are those people screaming in the background? It's terrifying T_T
4:00 Is someone dying?
Aaliyah Sanchez I'm so glad that I'm not the only one who heard that sound >.
hahaha XD
Dolce Izadora what did the people say？anyone knows？someone knows korean？？？
i think they were doing the fanchant XD
OMG... Luhan ♥ aww!!!! NUNCA ME CANSARE DE ESCUCHAR ESTA CANCION Y TERMINAR LLORANDO :'(
The person screaming at the end sounds so scary :(
Best so far. All 5 of them are so mesmerising!!
seriously pure perfection when they sing, wow amazing! love this song!
omfg Baekhyun
omg i thought it was just me -_-
this performance really moved my heart gah
Yay, my wish came true ^-^ I really wanted Baekhyun, Kyungsoo, Chen and Luhan singing this song together. And now it came true + Lay played the piano - The only thing that missed, were the others ;3
Exo-L here✋ This song is my favorite Salanghae Exo!!
so nice lay play the piano♥♥♥
와 저때 다 진짜 애기같냐 왜케
Chen. That's all I need to say.
Yixing *-*
D.O I love you S2
we are one EXO, saranghaja! since 2012 love you!
I realised that their voice is bit different between the last performance. :(( I love their voice in the last performance. In the music bank i think
After watching EXO's Showtime ep9, I cannot help thinking about Chen's cell phone case hahahahahaha
IT'S PINK.. AM I RIGHT?
Best and my favorite performance by far
that screaming at 4:00 0_0!! it sounded like the exorcist scream! so rude!!
P.S. Lay was hot playing the piano!!
My lay☺️💕💕
Luhannnnnn blackhair. Omgomgomg
1:28-1:30 luhan oppa look like sad
exo-m baby don't cry live luhan oppa look like crying
엑소 디오 아파 없어 ,, 아프잖아
i thought their voice is a little bit pitchy especially to Chen.. but overall i love them and this song! peace! :)
This song makes me really sad... I cant even understand it.
Baekhyun!!!!
Same!!!
SMTOWN !!!! I FREAKIN LOVE YOU FOR DOING THIS !!!!