Barry Schwartz: Our loss of wisdom
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- www.ted.com Barry Schwartz makes a passionate call for practical wisdom as an antidote to a society gone mad with bureaucracy. He argues powerfully that rules often fail us, incentives often backfire, and practical, everyday wisdom will help rebuild our world.
TEDTalks is a daily video podcast of the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes. Featured speakers have included Al Gore on climate change, Philippe Starck on design, Jill Bolte Taylor on observing her own stroke, Nicholas Negroponte on One Laptop per Child, Jane Goodall on chimpanzees, and "Lost" producer JJ Abrams on the allure of mystery. TED stands for Technology, Entertainment, Design, and TEDTalks cover these topics as well as science, business, development and the arts. Watch the Top 10 TEDTalks on TED.com, at www.ted.com/ind...
Can't believe this isn't more popular! It's one of the best TEDTalks out there! Simply fantastic and a great appeal to ethics and morality!
Maybe morality and ethics isn't that attractive as self-centered advice
i Agree
431 VIEWS is not enough for you? Greedy.
10:48 to 12:22 is the most valuable part of this video. Thank you for this mind-blowing insight on how incentives could sometimes demotivate people.
Wow, I found myself applauding to my computer screen several times during this talk.
Old-fashioned wisdom never dies and if we can draw inspiration and insight from it still, the difficulties of today are nothing but an exciting challenge. Thanks for this great TEDtalk.
"A wise person is made and not born"... Thank you Barry Schwartz for a talk full of wisdom
I've thought all these things many times, and with frustration. I'm glad these ideas are finally getting some audience.
One of my best TED Talks. . . A must watch!!!
"Honesty is the firstchapter in the book of wisdom"
--Thomas Jefferson
+Asgeir Bragason No, discernment is the first chapter of wisdom.
Neither. It's called "Watch your back"
Alright TJ, did you look into your slave ownership? LOL
@@nnenna2469 Grow up
this was my favorite ted talk of all time. I honestly have nothing else to say, i only pray that our society makes a reversion toward success through selflessness rather than falsely rewarding selfishness.
years ago, i used to improvise when recommending medicine and food therapies. i would take a minute or two to listen to the customer's concerns. overall, i sold more product, and was the regualar customers' favorite. i would utilize the knowledge from dozens of books i have read, and assist people directly, particularly, in the best way i knew how.
i got fired.
they wanted me to parrot advertising literature and what was in their book. so much for character and moral fortitude in retail.
these days its hard to choose morality over finance.
our environment screams cash. ☹️
Brilliant talk... 'remoralizing work'...the virtue of practical wisdom and hope, and paying attention.
"Life is not like a game of Monopoly, even if you have the most money at the end, you don't win."
Rosebud! ~ Citizen Kane
Nailed it.
But you can play the game one way or the other. You can even cheat the game if you have a ton of money.
How sad you are
A tip: you can watch movies on flixzone. I've been using it for watching loads of movies these days.
So much to think on and appreciate.
Thank you for the Wisdom. I was happy to watch this and grateful to learn 'Respect Learning'. Thank you ~ Thank you ~
Great talk. Thank you❤🙏
"scripts insure against disaster, but what they ensure in its place is mediocrity"
"the reductive appeal to self-interest as the master human motive is a false description of human nature & lead to over-prescription and addiction to surface-level incentives"
love :)
Well hot damn...and I thought no one cared about morals/character anymore. Favorite sentence in the whole video, "A wise person knows when and how to make "the exception to every rule."" It is hard to break free of rules sometimes even when you know when and how to make the exception because people around you will criticize you breaking a rule. But you must have wisdom AND courage to do wise things or else wisdom is lost. Every action starts with courage!
There’s a verry good point! Courage is so important!!!
Best ted-talk ive ever heard
The WISEST TED talk ever. Thank you 🤗
Barry for president 2020
Provocative, inspiring and a great eye opener to see things from different perspective. Amazing - Loved the wisdom shared thing this talk. Kudos!!!!
Amen. I get the chills when I watch ted videos like this
we have put rules before our sanity and souls. Look what happened recently at a supermarket in Georgia where the police restrained poor people from taking perfectly good food that was bound to the landfill because the landowners (sun trust bank) ordered it so.
This talk is simply outstanding.
Thank you Barry Schwartz... No one listens to me when I say moral responsibility is the structure of a successful, civilized society. Now maybe someone will now that I'm not the only one saying it.
How did I miss seeing this lecture before now? I've been subscribed to TED for quite a long time. Good lecture.
I am so, so glad there are still people out there willing to act as the voice of reason and common sense. Slowly but surely we continue to smother ourselves in red tape while an ever-dwindling few act against it.
i'm so sick of control freaks running everything. humans don't need a box- what we need (clearly) is to use our brains more. we have mediocrity everywhere. you can't create true quality of life without inspiring people, and reinforcing social relationship. we have to cultivate our character, raise our leaders; become lights to ourselves and each other.
i like this speech, it is very insightful.
Thank you
So true! I think people in the UK should listen to this talk, especially the banks and the government.
God, I love TEDtalks. These videos should be mandatory in . . . IDK school? Work? Everyone needs to see 'em. They open the eyes and the mind.
Thanks for the pointing me towards Schwartz's other work. It's good to see that I wasn't reading too much into this one. Cheers!
Janitors don't have it easy. Very true.
This guys's talk is easy to understand! THanks for great infomation/.
Very nice to listen to the guy's voice, he speaks the truth of course, great talk!
I think this guy is totally right and everything he said makes sense... What we need, are heroes.
Slight rephrase: What we need is to BE heroes.
teach kids and adults both young and old on the right things to do
Ted Talks are valuable and motivating.
That's what I call an ethical sermon.
I couldn't agree more with many of the points. Question: "teacher's must lead by example," is one of the premises. If the use of force is wrong (not virtuous) and teachers must lead by example for your model to be successful, how can they teach from a position of moral authority and strike (a forceful action?)
This talk was six years ago and still not much evolution has happened around this subject, though it is so necessary, it rather has been going in the other direction in my country. All Belgium leaders should have a look at this, the rules here are getting absurd and are taking place of morality, which is incredibly problematic... Glad to have run into this talk since it confirms what my assumptions on morals and rules are, if someone not gets what I say now, I can show them this talk which explains it very clearly.
Now it's 11 years ago
I'd like to take this opportunity to publicly insult the intellect and moral character of those (currently 77) people who gave this a thumbs down.
In this world of abject idiocy in the name of regulation and procedure, this presentation makes me weep tears of hope.
Well it's up to 82 now, but that should be set against 2,852 thumbs ups.
The ratio is still cause for hope.
Bravo sir! Logic does at times encourage hope. That it might be concerning the human species is still more rare and exciting. My thanks for your perspective.
timb37 8:48 ff "...moral skill is chipped away by an over-reliance on rules..."
Reminds me of certain religious types; they got a book of rules and never make a moral decision except in defence of the rule book.
Every time I do what I know is the right thing, I am punished for it. I see the same happen to others.
We are all training each other to be bad people, because that is what makes the rich richer and the powerful have more power. And how dare we do otherwise?
Congratulations ! Your life journey includes advanced ethical behavior : doing what is right Because it is right, without regard to personal gain. This is "the heros journey". A difficult path....
Some professions seldom allow for goodness. It is tough to make a loving being a moral individual in these times.
EXCEPTIONAL!! Flawless speech, one of the best TED talks I have seen.
adding on to my comment from before, its like what a lot of antique pickers say "one mans trash is another mans treasure" and a happy mood is my treasure I give to the people, whether its the free food thing, talking to them about their day, or just making them laugh, its all worth it to me and I dont regret a single thing
Distant memory sparked by this talk: how the janitor at my grade school was a beloved guy.
I love this guy.
He's brilliant.
same.
i love his books.
This is a big problem nowadays. This video has to go viral.
At this age, being moral can get you a lawsuit and losing the job.
I lost 2 jobs by standing upon principle. I believe that it is a test of character.
@@wordsculpt True. I think there is a saying, something like "Would you rather work at a job where you hurt people because 'it's just my job' or be fired from a job for doing the right thing and helping those in need?"
If a job would fire you for doing the right thing, then you should probably be proud to not be supporting or representing such an organization. (Though I'm sure the immediate reprecussions of being fired were no less challenging and I hope you got through them ok!)
Actually.. regarding the Chicago school system case.. the reason why the entire class has been scripted is that psychologists had found that teaching a 1st grade class reading skills in a script format where every single child repeats, for example, words that begin with B is that studies show that there is a SUBSTANTIAL increase in reading skills in the class verses not doing a script, i'm a teacher and i would never teach to a script b/c it wouldn't be fun, but it really does work
Fabulous talk! Barry Schwartz, you are a moral hero.
"Excessive incentives demoralize and reduces morality.
Celebrate moral exemplars.
Demand that people who teach - acknowledge and celebrate moral heroes.
Any work you do that involves other people is moral work.
We should strive to be moral exemplars - someone is always watching.
Practical wisdom allows the other virtues to be displayed.
People want to be allowed to to be virtuous.
Organizations should structure themselves to support rather than suppress wisdom."
Woaah this was one of the best talks ever done, what an orator he made !
I really enjoyed this. Information was passed! Thank you 🙏🏿
Please watch this video twice if you run a company or organization - then really think on it.
is what i did.
even took notes.
Very well done, we need more wisdom and respect.
Another great guy.
👍 3:35 “Practical wisdom," Aristotle told us, "is the combination of moral will and moral skill.” ― Barry Schwartz
The standing ovation was deserved. What a great speech!
It is so important to stand for ordinary heroes
its true, moving forward isn't on how many people we pass. but how many people we help.
This is terrific because it is so self-evident.
_Blessing full of blessings._
😇
This is one of the BEST talks ever!
W/ regards to education specifically, I think part of the reason "scripts" are used is because to do this kind of great, individually specific teaching about character/respect for learning may entail telling pupils that the correct way to think/act is something very different from the way their parents think/act, or form the way most people in their part of the country/tax bracket act. To teach you what cartoon robots at the state legislature told you to is much more benine /populist.
Now we're getting into semantics. I'm on the side of there being no difference between hard and soft science.
Mapping out our culture sounds like cultural science.
After this discussion, I am also now changing my thinking. Wisdom does come from experiences, self- and social awareness, but also from science. And will continue to grow as scientists increase our knowledge of the both the physical and social sciences.
Wisdom comes from families and nature. Information comes from technology and machines and the state is a machine. We are starved for wisdom and drowning in information.
This really needs to shown in Freshmen business classes
I loved this speech, but I wish it would have also addressed the issue of this belief, birthed by the Western hustle-culture, that virtue somehow counters success. This fear that being virtuous makes you weak, or at the very least puts you at a disadvantage to someone who is not inclined to be virtuous. How do we fix that? How do we incentivise someone to model themselves after Atticus Finch rather than the "mergers & acquisitions" guy who is somehow always portrayed as being more "successful". When we talk about celebrating moral exemplars, we need to address, what we have been taught to value and reward as a society, what we understand as "abundance" and how we achieve it and the fear mentality that we have cultivated to support our modern version of success.
YES!
Looking forward to curling up with this later, when I'm not at wor--errrr!!! I mean, once I get back home.
@Crazylalalalala
Yes. He wrote a book called "The Paradox of Choice".
Amazing talk! =)
very good
In principle I agree with you.
In this case it was more like advocating responsible behavior over irresponsible behavior. As much as this requires some reasonable guidance about the specifics it still seems like the better path as a principle.
Amen!
Eloquently said!
@rigimp you've oversimplified his message to the point of making it ridiculous. In his first video he's saying that choice is a paradox that has good consequences which everyone is already aware of and bad consequences such as paralysis and dissatisfaction with results due to growing expectations. In this video he's saying that practical wisdom needs to accompany rules otherwise bureaucracy and "standard procedures" end up replacing people using and developing their moral will and moral skill.
All sounded interesting and very plausable. I´m not sure about the surveys but either way he had valid points in telling the psychological developement of the people in the terms of moral thinking. As far as the part with the teachers and the curiculum goes, that part gave me a small tear because it´s exactly how I´ve thought throughout the years in the teachers academy. Sure we get security in these rules but we get only mediocry.
need more people like you
Excellent.
so it is real sad that most people leaving video comments proving they don't know how to listen are the very people that need to be listening
I wish I had this video to email to my "seniors" (whose moral compass was totally bent) at my last major job...
Great respect for Barry's words. For some reason when I hear him I remember A. P. J. Abdul Kalam (11th President of India).
Another great talk. TED is my new favourite thing.
dead on! one of the best crowd reactions from ted's audiance yet
As a side note, Barry, Jon Favreau, one of the "100 Most Influential People in the World" according to Time magazine, wrote Obama's inauguration speech. . .
WOW, that was a great one. I love TED Talks!
fantastic speeach! very motivational
This is so true.
When a person says "What's good for one person isn't necessarily good for another," they're talking about specifics, not essentials. At the widest abstractions, universal truths can be discerned. Productive work is good for everyone; the form of that work is highly dependent upon interest, talent, and a whole host of other things.
The good is not just a matter of opinion. We can be right or wrong about it, and good and bad are objectively discernable truths.
I love the talk ❤️
Hehe I was thinking about the same concepts today and incidentally stumbled on this video (funny how some days seem to have a theme to them). For example whats wrong with being stopped by a police officer while speeding? Its never the intention that counts but only the act of (usually biased) observance. Our society is very limiting and does not breathe. It is very stiff and inorganic. Its only up to everyday folk - the foundation of everything - to change anything.
I think I'd distinguish between simple specific advice to 'go shopping' which after all is just being told what to do, vs a general directive that encourages you to use your own virtue. If it turns out that using your own virtue is more dangerous than shopping so be it.
Consciousness illuminates choices, wisdom eliminates them..
Explain why?
Scorched awareness lets you know what choices you have, wisdom helps you discern which ones you need.
Your a smart guy for making that point. I entirely agree!
This guy is amazing. I support this!
Much of what he is talking about has to do with how legalistic we've become. The willingness to sue other people (as a form of winning the lottery) is WAY too common.
The other is an extremely paternalistic government which more and more grows because people want the AUTHORITY to solve all their problems.
Climate Change is really a major issue today . Nice video .
one of the hardest decisions in life is "is doing the right thing worth losing my job?" if my job knew how much I stole from them and gave to the people I wouldnt have the house I have now. if somebody couldnt pay 20 cents they would fire me if I accepted just the dollars, I gave coffees to tired truck drivers who have to keep driving at night, people are surprised that I do this and theyre even more surprised with how many years ive been working, and my only answer is "I care"
thanks!
one word for it -- masterpiece!!
also 18:32 till the end, that's the foundation then the mastery of chosen skill comes next
& then maybe we'll have a better world