I agree I think the tie defender a better ship while tiePhantom should be more used for sabotage or for flanking rebel pilots I also feel the tight defender would’ve been good as a six squad ship or leader of Tie interceptors idk that’s my opinion.
The TIE Phantom was to be made,but the creation of Flechete Torpedoes allowed the Rebellion to blast them pretty hard,whilst the tracking material in the torpedoes allowed them to track damaged Phantoms all the way back to their secret facility. The Rebellion then took out the facility,whilst Darth Vader Force choked the Imperial officer in charge of the project. The TIE Defender,as per the far more superior Legends(the REAL canon of Star Wars,not the Dinsey bull crap)was built,not as much as the TIE Fighters were,but enough that they were still being used nearly 50 years down the line and then some,despite the existence of Gunboats and Missileboats. Both,had they been allowed to grow,would've definitely compensated for the Empires' short comings and defeated the Rebellion should a counter not occur.
Both ships have pros and cons but I think the Tie phantom went into mass production that there would be an effort by the rebels to find countermeasures to the cloaking technology not saying that the rebels wouldn't try and find weaknesses the tie defender if it was mass produced but in all both are cool ships and this is a cool video.
The Rebels did make a countermeasure,the Flachete Torpedo. Not only was it pretty powerful,the tracking material in them allowed the Rebels to track damaged Phantoms all the way to their hidden base,proceeding to destroy it. The TIE Defender,as per the far more superior Legends(the REAL canon of Star Wars,not the Dinsey bull crap)was built,not as much as the TIE Fighters were,but enough that they were still being used nearly 50 years down the line and then some,despite the existence of Gunboats and Missileboats. Both,had they been allowed to grow,would've definitely compensated for the Empires' short comings and defeated the Rebellion should a counter not occur.
forget the cloaking, the phantom is by far the best visibility wise, has 5 guns 3 on fintips and 2 beneath the cockpit, and is top 3 in speed and performance the only tie that beats it is the defender if i remember right and not by alot, like 1490 kph vs 1600 kph. Its cockpit design and fin layout are perfect for visibility issues every other tie has. It also has shields and can make jumps and be piloted by 1 instead of 2 incase u dont have a gunner. Even without the cloaking i think its top 3 and maybe even the best for a straight up dogfight. They should of made this design without the cloaking and strictly a single seater, its 250 kph faster than the fastest tie interceptor.
@@profo4544mate the defender has 6 laser cannons, 2 ion cannons, and missle tubes, is faster, as if not more agile, even it's disney version was stated by vader to rival his tie which was made custom for his use and the force. Plus the tie phantom could not be mass produced with cloaking thanks to a rare crystal used to make the cloak work
@@Thomas-c3u7f The reason i said i didnt like the defender was the cockpit design lol. I actually stated the speeds of both, why are u repeating to me things i said already lol. Do you not fully read comments
Blue laser is to knock out shields and the next disables engines 1 Then 2 on damage Green is stronger then red because of it being concatenated gas and the system that is shooting it. 1 tie phantom, stealth shield 2 defender, damage reflect shield Phantom that takes out shield The defenders clean it up 3 X wings, damage reflect shields
Damn you you can use Tie Defender for frontal assault and Tie phantom could attack behind enemy lines. Rebels will not have a chance!!! Both of them are deadly!!!
How does this video have so little views
I’m wondering about that too! I may try changing the thumbnail... 🤷
@@CrazyKnuckles it's really odd to me like the quality of the video is really good you have so little subscribers this ought to be a crime
Very good video, thx you! :D
Wonder how tie hunter would do againts the phantom. Though what i remember hunters dont have shields i think
Great video!
I agree I think the tie defender a better ship while tiePhantom should be more used for sabotage or for flanking rebel pilots
I also feel the tight defender would’ve been good as a six squad ship or leader of Tie interceptors idk that’s my opinion.
They should've made both. The Phantom can be used for secret special missions
The TIE Phantom was to be made,but the creation of Flechete Torpedoes allowed the Rebellion to blast them pretty hard,whilst the tracking material in the torpedoes allowed them to track damaged Phantoms all the way back to their secret facility.
The Rebellion then took out the facility,whilst Darth Vader Force choked the Imperial officer in charge of the project.
The TIE Defender,as per the far more superior Legends(the REAL canon of Star Wars,not the Dinsey bull crap)was built,not as much as the TIE Fighters were,but enough that they were still being used nearly 50 years down the line and then some,despite the existence of Gunboats and Missileboats.
Both,had they been allowed to grow,would've definitely compensated for the Empires' short comings and defeated the Rebellion should a counter not occur.
You should redo this test using the old stats.
3,3,3,3 for the Defender.
4,2,2,2 for the Phantom.
Both ships have pros and cons but I think the Tie phantom went into mass production that there would be an effort by the rebels to find countermeasures to the cloaking technology not saying that the rebels wouldn't try and find weaknesses the tie defender if it was mass produced but in all both are cool ships and this is a cool video.
The Rebels did make a countermeasure,the Flachete Torpedo.
Not only was it pretty powerful,the tracking material in them allowed the Rebels to track damaged Phantoms all the way to their hidden base,proceeding to destroy it.
The TIE Defender,as per the far more superior Legends(the REAL canon of Star Wars,not the Dinsey bull crap)was built,not as much as the TIE Fighters were,but enough that they were still being used nearly 50 years down the line and then some,despite the existence of Gunboats and Missileboats.
Both,had they been allowed to grow,would've definitely compensated for the Empires' short comings and defeated the Rebellion should a counter not occur.
forget the cloaking, the phantom is by far the best visibility wise, has 5 guns 3 on fintips and 2 beneath the cockpit, and is top 3 in speed and performance the only tie that beats it is the defender if i remember right and not by alot, like 1490 kph vs 1600 kph. Its cockpit design and fin layout are perfect for visibility issues every other tie has. It also has shields and can make jumps and be piloted by 1 instead of 2 incase u dont have a gunner. Even without the cloaking i think its top 3 and maybe even the best for a straight up dogfight. They should of made this design without the cloaking and strictly a single seater, its 250 kph faster than the fastest tie interceptor.
@@profo4544mate the defender has 6 laser cannons, 2 ion cannons, and missle tubes, is faster, as if not more agile, even it's disney version was stated by vader to rival his tie which was made custom for his use and the force. Plus the tie phantom could not be mass produced with cloaking thanks to a rare crystal used to make the cloak work
@@Thomas-c3u7f The reason i said i didnt like the defender was the cockpit design lol. I actually stated the speeds of both, why are u repeating to me things i said already lol. Do you not fully read comments
Blue laser is to knock out shields and the next disables engines 1
Then 2 on damage
Green is stronger then red because of it being concatenated gas and the system that is shooting it.
1 tie phantom, stealth shield
2 defender, damage reflect shield
Phantom that takes out shield
The defenders clean it up
3 X wings, damage reflect shields
Damn you you can use Tie Defender for frontal assault and Tie phantom could attack behind enemy lines. Rebels will not have a chance!!! Both of them are deadly!!!