Palestinians: Does 'Free Palestine' mean destroy Israel?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2022
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
![Megan Thee Stallion - Otaku Hot Girl [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/USxIYOaIpig/mqdefault.jpg)
"We don't want to destroy Israel. We like the infrastructure you've built. We just want you to go away"
Built what? Palestine is built by middleastern people not people who came here from Eu in 48
@@generaljg4373 🤣
@@generaljg4373 There were 70% of the houses with no indoor plumbing and rampant Malaria and Typhus, the Arabs had no formal schooling and most were illiterate. I suppose the illiterate Arab people were the Engineers and scientists???
hhhhhhhhhhhh precise
@@generaljg4373 You are Great!! We love your comments as you are as a straight man, and set up the opportunity to get the real answers out there,
I’m a Muslim and I truly admire this channel. I’m learning and understanding the Palestinians / Israeli perspective with those challenging questions you ask them. I truly think the only way for peace is for both the Israelis and Palestinians need to accept each other existence, respect each-other so that they can both coexist in one country. No way will Palestinians nor Israelis leave from that land.
1 land but 2 separate states. It will never work otherwise. It hasn’t worked anywhere like Lebanon etc.. for 2 different people to live in one state
اذا توقفت اسرائيل عن سلب اراضي الفلسطينين منهم وترك بيوتهم لهم وليس عن طريق الاستلاء واتيان باناس من مختلف البلدان للاستيلاء على املاك غيرهم
@@khawlaallbassam2557
Do you live there?
Peace can only exist by having two bigots making peace whilst remaining bigoted to do so. Even after Jim Crow laws are abolished, racism persists in many ways. And Roe v Wade shows that equality is not an eternal right under any system of democracy.
The only peace that can be achieved is by social reconciliation and not a political one. Whose to say that Palestine would simply start a war with Israel again, now with a defined army and a strong economy if they were ever given a state back?
@@NicoleBL2 Lebanon should be split into two state's for christian's and muslim's only way for Lebanon to move forward
Yes - and according to this same worldview, Spain is built on Muslim land. India is built on Muslim Land. Anywhere the Ottomans have been driven back, they say is Muslim land and they want it back.
So where does this end?
This response deserves more likes
@@vanessaclaudio3524 Thanks Vanessa. I sorta agree. 🙂
It's not about religion, that's a Zionist tactic only. Palestinians are the descendants of the native people of the region. There are multiple DNA studies indicating that, while the Jews that have settled Palestine are for the most carrying DNA from their host countries (i.e. Poland, Ethiopia, Yemen etc.). The world would be a huge mess if anyone claimed a land that 'belonged' to them 2000 years ago, just because a fictitious book told them so.
How is India built on myslim land the land of Hindustan existed long before that cancer spread
You’re absolutely right
Many interviewees that answered that it does not mean the destruction of Israel, when they explained a little futher it finally became a yes.
I think that it's happened only with the last girl. Some others talked about 2 states solution and things from that kind
People stand with Israel because they love Israel. People who stand with Palestine because they hated Israel. The devil used Palestinian struggle to create hatred from their hearts towards the chosen nation of God Almighty.🇮🇱
@@theshumai Too bad almost all Palestinians do not care for a 2 state solution because that means a Jewish state...even though it has existed now for 70+ years.
it happened with almost every single one. "Okay they can apologize and leave" what does leave mean? Stop existing.@@theshumai
The flip side is that one yes became a constructive one-state democracy of the sort the jewish supremacist state (two months past a successful fascist coup) has always despised. With right of return and solid economic and social support, we could arrive at a good solution. Keeping in mind all these guys are technically PTSD victims at least with conditions a lot of us would rather suicide than live through.
i wouldn't even trust my father in law to be constructive in politics. The Israelis interviewed are IMO far more ugly. That is straight textbook settler colonial shit like out of a story set in the 1800s.
I have no idea why this channel is not more out there. They're literally saying the quiet part out loud lol
“Destroy Israel” is too vague. Freeing the slaves in the US meant “destroying the confederacy,” but it didn’t mean killing or displacing white people. It meant ending the confederacy’s authority.
“Destroying Israel” might mean literally obliterating it. Or it might mean replacing the government and national identity with something secular with equal rights for Jewish people and Palestinians.
@@user-vt4up5ij9d Lol no I watched many other videos on this channel. These people are very clear with what they mean
@@user-vt4up5ij9dbut Israel is a much deeper concept than the confederacy was, historically, theologically, culturally
@@user-vt4up5ij9d False equivalence. The slaves were never offered their own state for obvious reasons. Also, neither group had historical links to the land.
@@user-vt4up5ij9d It would never ever be a secular solution. Islamic secularism generally doesn't work. I would hope for a peaceful solution but when one group has defacto displaced the other group and the other group says they want to take it back and dispel the group currently in power there isn't really a way for the people in power to say "ok sure, sounds good". So either Palestine gathers supports from the Arab world and builds an army to take Israel and defeat the US as well or some kind of two state solution which the Palestinian people would not be happy with but maybe many, many generations down the line people grow to accept would work. How that ever comes to be made in those lands I have no idea when you have two groups of people with such obviously opposing ideologies.
I totally agree with the first lady, she is realist. She may not agree how Israel came about but she acknowledges it’s here to stay, therefore if all people are to live equally free from tyranny then a peaceful solution must be found. I wish a two state agreement could be reached then both nations could live long prosperous lives without fear of war.
I think one state that isn’t called Palestine or Israel. Just call it Holy Lands or something that lets it be for both.
they have been offered a two-state solution four times and each time they have attacked the jews rejecting the plan
the palestinians have turned that solution down every time it was offered.
@@ericksonjustinAK That's not an option at all.
@@Eugenetra7 You might be right. It might be way too idealist, but that might be because thinking there is any solution is too idealist.
ruclips.net/video/LGc8Nhi-yYU/видео.htmlsi=A_26-0fd9m9WRhmu
All the people cheering in the streets after the attack while bodies were being paraded and spit on were not hamas. They were normal Gazans… complacency keeps you guilty whether you’d have the blood yourself or not
True
Same could go to u except you guys actually all carry weapons and are in the army
When you are treated the way the Gazans are treated, it erodes your ability to feel sympathy for the oppressor. What happened on Oct 7th was tragic, but the Israelis have done so much worse.
@@laika5707 What worse? Israel did not invade Gaza, massacred or Parade dead Palestinians bodies on street..Get your facts right..israel Supplies Works, Clean Water, internet, Food & Medical to Gaza..Even Egypt does not offer that..
@@laika5707 Not even close. If you truly believe this, you've been severely mislead. However, it's not all your fault, because lies about Israel are propagated everywhere.
What is under Al Aqsa? What was it built on top of? Who took the land?
It was built on Beit hamikash which was built by Jews . They stole that land
Just like they stole Kashmir from Hindus and now they claim the Big Ben belongs to them 😂
You can claim that Muslims built a temple on a Jewish temple. But: what if those Muslims were descendants from those Jews, who after thousands of years converted? And then, after literally thousands of year, how can anyone defend with a straight face that a Polish, a French or an American citizen have more rights to that land than who has been for countless generation?
There are Roman ruins in Spain; does that mean that Italians must invade Spain? Why are DNA tests forbidden in Israel? Is it because they prove that most its citizens aren't indigenous to that land?
@@Persianyasmine exactly
Palestinians: "Well no, but actually yes."
The Holocaust was in Europe.
Based
Yeah. 😄
@@germanicus1732
As you did to Jewish people?!
Destroy is a stupid word to use, remove the name isreal and all live in peace in Palestine
Arab man:
It says in the Quran that the Jews will be destroyed
Corey: Do you know where it says that in the Quran?
Arab: No Not really
🤦🏻♂️
Technically that guy is right. It's a end of time Hadith.
@@user-nl4qn9qx3s Hadith is Not Quran it’s commentaries by Muslim scholars and Always disputes between Muslims themselves.
The man said Quran and He is wrong because without Judaism and Israel No muslim can go to heaven.
I know the Quran change a lot of times something like 70 times
@@marcohuana7824 No that’s not true. The Quran in Arabic is the same but when translated into Persian Pashtun and Urdu; the true meaning was lost.
However the Quran and Hadith are Very different.
The Quran mentions Israel but Not Palestine and neither does the Hadith.
@@sirob1193 Palestines its a fake arabic Nation, the only thing what made them a Nation its ba anti israel (hate jews)
half the people in the video say they dont wanna destroy israel and then after 5 seconds they say israel should be destroyed wow
it just means you are not that smart to understand they make a difference between people and the government ruling.
Not true. They don't want the destruction of Israel, they just want it moved elsewhere. Out of thier native land. Maybe buy a plot of land in Mexico or Canada has a lot of free space nobody uses and move it there.
you half brained fool. we have no problem living with jews but not the jews controlling the state on stolen lands. Yes it means israhell needs to get dismantled. their english isn't top tier that's why they can't explain it in monkey terms for your bum ass
they have the right to return to their homes that was stolen by jewish thieves
Most of them meant the destruction of Israel as a state, not the people.
Most of them are saying yes with no hesitation…. That why they would never have a state.
they will have a state in their own land
@@sizebi-hy5gt There is no "their" land and never was.
@@Rai2M it was , it still is , and it will be , even their book says so its about time my man
I just want to give that first woman a big hug.
I bet she is saying that only because of the discretion of the media and the punishment not real palastanian would say that cz the land is our it's not for Israel we could live in peace as long as that is the case
@@mizoosama8700 live in peace like all the pogroms before 1948? Read some history. It was never "yours" to begin with, Palestinians are not indigenous.
@@LeeLe412 more indigenous than Peter from brooklyn atleast
@@sumerianfarmer5363 If you knew a shred of history you would know Peter who lives in the diaspora in Brooklyn is definitely more indigenous then people who came from Saudi Arabia and colonized the entire middle east, all the way to Europe in the 7th century and think they are indigenous to the entire place
@@LeeLe412 Not at all, you absolute extremist.
i find it funny how they always think there was peace before 1948, it shows that not only did they fail History but also Geography
They just don't consider the murdering of Jews as something bad, for them it was "peace".
There was relative peace, where things are mostly peaceful and there might be a few one-off incidents here and there. But obviously nothing like today since this settler state was created by european jewry so they could have their own personal colonial project.
@@lanoklom9697 clearly you don't know what relative peace means, there was no peace whatsoever
@@lanoklom9697 people like you love saying that they were peace before Israel yet there was never peace with Muslims, not even once. as soon as Islam was invented all peace was destroyed!
@@lanoklom9697 Jews literally have been committing acts of terror and building illegal settlements to ethnically cleanse the region since the late 1880's 😂
Dude, don't ask them as a foreign speaking English. Ask them as an Arab in Arabic.
Then you will hear the truth.
الحقيقة واضحة لا داعي للاسئلة
Short answer: Yes.
They just won't admit it.
Greetings from Egypt to our brothers and sisters in Israel and Palestine. I hope peace will prevail in the Middle East and the whole world. 🇪🇬❤️🇮🇱❤️🇵🇸
I wish Egypt would take over Gaza. It would solve a lot of problems!
Very nice to hear from an Egyptian. Thank you 🇮🇱💙
Bless you
I m afraid we don't have the same définition of Peace.
@@ForeverRepublic he's your brother and he's like a camelion colouring among the arab people because the arabs have dignity and honour which will prevent them from making peace with your so called Israel
So even most of the people who initially said "no" ended up saying "yes, but maybe not right now" :(
They mean the government; who till today has said no to returning hostages from Hamas. Why would jews want a government who doesn’t give a shit about them accept money and power and committing crimes? Plus Palestinians barely have contact with Isreali people if ever. All they know is the IDF who are racist towards them and the government who keeps killing their people. It has nothing to do with the Jewish people of the country at all.
The government divides them on purpose; in fact if they actually spoke to each other in peace (like their did prior to 1948) they would see so many commonalities i many ways
But again the government wants money, power, control. They don’t care for the Jews or the Arabs on that land.
"Can you stop filming?"
I think we can guess what his answer was from that.
Yeah the answer is, I could be harrassed or detained without trial in the middle of the night if I say the wrong thing.
I think it is not 100% clear.
It must be something that brings him into trouble. But with whom? He might feel under thread from either Side.
Once again we see complete historical ignorance
The last answer is the most depressing of all of them, and perfectly demonstrates the ability to make two contradictory statements one after another and appear to believe both of them.
They are separated by the "but" though. We all know that everything that comes before but is almost always a bunch of bullshit.
I would interpret her response as "It's better if I mention a couple of politically correct things to seem morally right, so they won't think I'm a bad person when I will state that Israel must disappear".
@@Helymin
It goes without saying that the political figure of the modern state of Israel must be dissolved... It is the culprit and the main antagonistic variable in this equation...
@@Helymin that's stupid... "But" is a necissary word, it only offers a condition!
It's like "I love pizza but only without cheese as I'm allergic!" It does not change any of the message...
I disagree. It shows how insidious the Palestinian cause is. They lie through their teeth and say "no of course it doesn't mean destroy Israel, don't be ridiculous!" then you push them on it for literally 2 questions and they admit it means destroy israel and ethnically cleanse all the jews.
This is the magic of both wokeism and ji hadism. The ability to say 30 things, all imaginary and self contredicting. Its quite beautifull to see when you visit the middle east or UC berkley lol
The fact that they say with a straight face " We all lived in peace under Islam" 😆
@Hello Hello
Not only the ancient community of Jews in Hebron perished at that time but also the ancient communities in Aza city, Shechem (Nablus) and dozen other. Hebron is well known because of the horrific photos taken and published in newspapers hence made available in archives.
Peace in the ar ab is lamic culture means enslaving all non belivers.
Relative peace*
There is never peace. But there have been relatively peaceful times under Islamic rule, yes.
Someone didn’t read the writings of the Jewish historians…
And they even talked with Hitler about killing all of the Jews in the British Mandate
There you have it from their own mouths.
I am so addicted to these videos. Thank you for sharing these they’re incredible.
The girl from the city of Ramallah said that before the establishment of Israel, "we lived together," and what about the disturbances in Hebron, Jerusalem, Tiberias, Safed, in the years 1921, 1936, 1939, etc.?
The Ottomans in 1914, murdered Jews and deported thousands, while trying to Islamize the whole of the land,
They murdered the Armenian Christians, and the world remembers nothing?
Don't forget the centuries of living as a persecuted yet nominally tolerated minority before that.
They have also collaborated with the nazis. How is that a form of living peacefully with the jews?
Don’t forget about the 800 years of protection and love and living in Muslim lands and from muslims 😂
Jews came to pelistine to help those victims?
I've grown pessimistic. I am a pro Israel Jew who was three years old when Israel was created. So I have watched every scene of this drama l play out. I don't see an ending. Something has to change. I have been pro Palestinian statehood forever and thought at one time an Israel living in peace with Palestinians would be the powerhouse of the Middle East. But that seems more remote now than ever. I am deeply saddened by this and wish peace and statehood to my Palestinian siblings.
Some brother are you... why don't you merry them if you like those maniacs so much, who their sole wish to destroy us, and don't even hide it. They're not your "siblings", they're your people's enemies (if we say things as they're without mincing words), which kinda makes you an enemy sympathizer, as well as a persona non-grata in this land.
What skewed sense of loyalties to your people... just shameful and complete misunderstanding and ignorance of the situation and its driving forces at play.
You're right to be pessimistic, since it's exactly your approach to begin with, which is driving this pessimism forward to the current situation and what making it worse and escalating it (calling murderers maniacs your "siblings" would be one example of this) .
You preferred to mislead yourself with false hopes and deny realities as they truly are (either due to the sources of media which fed you throughout all those years, and painted a very misleading picture, or your lack of personal will, thoroughness and resistance to see things as they're in reality).
Sadly, reality is not make-belief as you wish it to be, so expecting it to blow up in your face was a given when you're basing everything on false premises from the get go. You can't build a house like that when the foundation blocks to build on are all out of whack and based on false information and beliefs.
2 people can't coexist on the same land, which is demanded entirely by one side (Palestinians), and partially, to a much lesser degree, also by the other (the Israeli side in some circles). It's simple math and logic.
It's precisely your 2 states solution approach, and those who promote it, which is pushing forward this conflict and making your pessimism even worse as time progress. People like yourself, external to the place, are trying to force an unrealistic solution to the people on the ground here instead of actually taking an interest on what those people present here actually want, what is their aim and how they think, taking these basic things into account so that they can propose solutions that can actually solve something, maybe, one day. You have only yourself and the people like you to blame for you pessimism and lack of progress you see to such an unrealistic propositions, which were never possible to implement or meant to be in the first place (I'm referring to the 2 states solution here).
If you want to really consider the most realistic solution available out there, which I'm sure you never even heard of, that would be the Emirates Solution of Dr kedar. Look it up if that of interest for you. If you start having realistic expectations, maybe there would be still hope for some peaceful solution, but if that proposition fails too, the only thing that would be left would be the complete expulsion of one group by the other, whichever group that may be, with one group left to rule the entire land. All or nothing kind of deal.
Maybe if you would start getting more realistic, and not filling yourself with false hopes, and imaginary make beliefs, painting things with pink bcz you want it to be so, you would start feeling less pessimistic. In contrary to you, I'm not pessimistic, I'm quite optimistic.
I would hope, especially from diaspora jews (at the very least), to stop pushing forward and promoting so-called "solutions" that only serve to put in peril risk the fate of your people and their continued presence on this land. That's the absolute minimum I would expect from any fellow Jews, at least if they still pretended to care about their people and nation at all...
Palestinians don't give 2 shits about you, so what that sucking up serving for?
Sad that these days people need to actually specify "pro Israel jew".... How distorted jews abroad became to even consider the other possibility as realistic? Mental affliction is afflicting such people.
And you still wish for them to have a state after watching this clip?
@@arabic2226 spot on!
Don't let that depress you for 2 reasons: 1) all their talk is rhetorical, almost all don't mean it. It's a brain wash reply coined up for a people under dictatorship from a corrupt and couldn't-give-a-damn PA. 2) Arabs are forming peaceful relations both at the political and individual levels. Attitudes are rapidly changing everywhere.
@@arabic2226 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD except through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was separating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Israeli here! I'm pretty amazed at the amount of peace desires! Heartwarming! Palestinians : we are one family, I want to be able to live in Israel, as I recognize you want to live in Palestine, and should be able to do so. Sending peace and love to all my cousins and brothers, friends and foes alike... I know too many of us knows the price of war, and the necessity and warmth of peace, and I'm so glad to hear some of you speak out. Salam, shalom.
The worst wars in history are between brother nations - China v Japan, Britain v France, Russia v Ukraine - and of course, it is still Ishmael v Isaac. As has been said many times - if the Arabs laid down their arms, we'd have peace. If Israel laid down their arms we have holocaust.
Useful idiot
Man, this is fascinating. It just seems like the more people you ask on the street if they’re excepting or willing to be peace between two people. And they just struggle! Struggle to even answer if peace is possible! If it’s so hard to imagine that piece is possible even with random civilians. That’s not a good sign.
imagine if a foreign people invaded your country and established a country within it and put your people through the same things Israelis put Palestinians through for the past 70 years and ask yourself if you'd be willing to live in peace with them.
@@MintGum-sy8zs but…but that did happen. We are not Native Americans and the actual native American people suffered and still suffer in many ways. The Israeli people are originally native to Jerusalem and Jordan. It is their native homeland. They are in control, and it is their native land. Time to think about peace and sharing or their will hardly be a nation of Palestine to make peace with.
@@kaml5076 dude there Palestinian Jews already living in Palestine during Ottoman Empire. This whole shit started with a bunch of European Jews literally came on boats to the shores of Haifa and stir up trouble. I don’t know how far back you can go to justify taking and kicking somebody out their house right now, but if that’s the argument you want to use Modern Arab Palestinians are descendants of Cannanites they were before the Jews. It’s really silly.
@@kaml5076 how long do you have to live in a place to be considered native? Also, don’t you see how silly it is to kick somebody else their house because your grandfather 3000 years ago may have been there. What other person would be allow such logic from with the exception of Jewish people. I know we feel guilty for the holocaust and a bunch of other stuff Europeans did through history, but this is absurd.
@@Tarz2155 two state solution, that is what has been proposed many many… Many times. Almost every single time the notion is rejected by the Palestinian authorities on the notion that no two state solution would be possible. Wars break out… They lose… now they are in the position of being both native descendants of the land and the ones who hold control over it. I don’t believe the Israel nation was the one rejecting the offers of a two states solution.
Do you believe there is an option for two states or two people living there?
If Palestine is free, what does that mean for Israel? Is that a two state solution or do they just need to leave?
Where do they go if they do leave? Literally every single country has committed their own version of a holocaust, not just Germany but everywhere. If you look in most places around them they’re not welcome and they have been literally reduced down to a handful of people. The Arabs who live in Israel are not being reduced. Their population has increased dramatically, I’m not arguing that Gaza is humane or that there aren’t problems. Solution seems to be on the table still but not in the minds of the Palestinians who want freedom. And what would that cost? A peaceful to state solution is probably the only way that Palestine will ever continue into a distant future. I advocate for peace and for the continuation of the Palestine people. That means Hamas should stop if they want any hope for a peaceful outcome.
"I don't want her dead, I just want her not to be alive" -- Stewie Griffin
good start. one is not enough. allah is angry. allah wants the bludd of the guilty!
Literally their words 😂
🤣
They said they want them to leave, be gone, go back to where they came from. Did you watch the video?
"We should live in peace with them", great first answer.
Nope we would live in peace as long as the land is ours and it's named PALASTINE not israel
@@mizoosama8700 I feel like the split is fine, both countries can co exist. Israel is not going anywhere just like most territories that were conquerored once upon a time wont. France was once part of the roman empire, should it be part of italy? It is what it is. Israel could have wiped palestine if they wanted it too a couple decades ago but they decided to try and live with them. Jews have a right to the land too and dont even try to portray them as evil, jews are the most persecuted ethnic group in modern history.
@@Plopi have you looked at a map? That place is tiny and surrounded by 22 ar ab is la mic ethnostate dictatorships.
@@mizoosama8700 what was it called before the colonialist arabs poured in and before the Romans renamed it? Delusional.
@@WaterMelonKillas no one renamed it I was bought from a Jew a long time ago so it's for muslims
my country lost parts to Russia before I was born. We never got those parts back. Did my grandparents and parents teach me to grow up hating Russia and swearing to fight until we had the parts back???? OF COURSE NOT!! Everyone here accepted it and moved forward, happy about the peace and not wanting to harrass the Russians ,and our president has always had good friendly relationships with their president. You can't change history or dwell in it, but you can make sure to live in peace for preventing it to happen again. The Palestinians move their ongoing hate to next generation adding even more hate with every generation. Instead of teaching them to love and to love peace and to move forward and to accept what they have. Israel could not be given to the Jews today, the world has changed, what happened in -48 could not happen today, but it DID happen and so did many other things too, that we cannot change anymore. Let's hope the Aboriginis doesn't start a huge war in Australia and let's hope the Native Americans don't start to claim back America and let's hope my country continues to have peace with Russia. I don't want pieces of my land back, I want only PEACE.
My country lost 750km2 3/4 a village for China. 9 villages also give for China after the war. All the villagers lived in there be part of Chinese citizen now. As a nation, we move on and develop the country with all we have left. And guess what, it’s around the world, many country also lost the land like Palestinian but they are not fighting against it. They keep move on and make their country be better day by day. Only Palestinian mourning for their lost and blaming Israel for their miserable.
@@lufencasada6232these are the most stupid comments. China and Russia aren’t bombing you into the Stone Age, they aren’t ethnically cleansing you or actively completing a genocide of your people. They don’t control your food, water, electricity. They don’t bomb your newborns in incubators. They don’t build a wall imprisoning you, controlling your every movement. Grow a brain, both of you.
@@lufencasada6232 See the problem you fail to see is that the Chinese don't see them selves as the chosen people of god nor do they want to kick you out, the Zionists in Israel believe the land belongs to jews and thus all the land is their inherit right not the Arabs. Its a different scenario. When the British took Palestine the locals didn't have much of a issue just like the people of your village. But when the Jews came in and took peoples land and houses and kicked them out that's where the issue came about. You think I'm lying watch a video where a Jewish man came inside of a Arab women's house and said if i don't take your house someone else will. The Chinese never said that to the people of your village did they.
So it is ok to invade country 😂
@@kudaibergeno it is not okay. But is it okay to live with hate generation after generation? Isn't it better to accept what happened and make the best of it?
Fascinating interviews. Thank you, Corey.
This is the difficulty of living by slogans, they can mean different things to different people.
Palestinians need a lobotomy. Their education system, media and government have turned them into vile terrorists
This isnt a slogan. What is so difficult in beliving some cultures are genocidal?
Until you ask just 1 or two more quick questions, and realise they actually mean the same thing at the core of it.
A majority of Falestinians are extremists who glorify terrorism, and it's all because of their education, media and government behaviour.
@@dogbert52 There was literally not even one person in the entire video that was edvocating for genocide... it isn't the publics opinion! Yes of course some would like for everyone to just go away not to die as they don't wish death on israelis! But most people would accept peace as long as they get their freedom!
Free palestine means get rid of the occupation and many see Israels Government as reason for this occupation, so they are also advocating it to go away! The only difference between people is a one state and a two state solution!
Israel is a much greater danger to palestinian civilians then palestinians are to israeli civilians! So all we demanding is to free us...
During the 17 year illegal occupation of Judah and Samaria by Jordan, the "Palestinians" never once talked about a "free Palestine." It was only in 1967 when the Israelis won that land by successfully defending themselves (again) from their Arab neighbors, that suddenly the Arabs became the "indigenous Palestine people" who wanted their land. Under International Law, there is no occupation. An occupation only occurs when one sovereign country crosses a national border to invade another sovereign country. Judah and Samaria (so-called West Bank) was never anything but a disputed territory. The pre-1967 "border" was never anything but a cease-fire line at the end of the 1948 war of Israeli independence. Just like the "Palestinian people", the "occupied West Bank" is just a big Arab lie.
Again!! When you say the independence, I just wonder from whom you got independents?!
For international law there is no occupation?!? U are a liar !
In the years immediately after the nakba, Palestinian society was in complete disarray. The PLO formed in 1964 which is arguably marks the point of a solidification of national consciousness of the Palestinians, so what you say isn't 100% accurate, but it is true that in the 50s there was no real organised Palestinian movement. But, you know, they had just been displaced, scattered, their lives destroyed, pushed out of their homes, it takes a while to pick yourself up off the ground.
The fact that a solid national movement and vocally expressed national identity came about later on doesn't in any way invalidate the right and desire of a people for freedom within their homeland (where they still mostly reside, but in unfreedom, and confined to small pockets in terrible conditions). After all, there was no need of a Palestinian cause and identity before they were forced out of most of their homeland - most nationalities form in opposition to another external one; until you are faced with "the other", there is no real need to name "us". Many colonised peoples only named themselves _after_ colonisation. And besides, the country of "Germany" didn't form until 1871, "Italy" a similar time also - that doesn't mean that before then there were no Germans or Italians. (And, similarly, just because Italians, French, Spanish, Portuguese and Romanians are all "Latins", doesn't mean they are interchangeable, or that it would be okay just to kick out all the Portuguese from Portugal and move them to Italy because they're all Romance speakers, or all Christians. That's not how it works.)
And what you said about the Palestinians not trying to "free Palestine" immediately after '48 is only half true. Immediately after the Nakba, sure, but by the 60s the Palestinian revolutionaries had already clearly set themselves apart from the subjects of Jordan, and it was clear that their homeland was Palestine, and not Jordan. It is also clear even before the 6 day war happened in '67 that the Palestinians' goal was self-governance within Palestine, not rule by Jordan. But yes, their primary concern was Israel, not Jordan and Egypt (for obvious reasons!)
There's a lot of hesitancy in the answers....I personally have the instinct to know a person's thoughts by their change of body language. There's a lot of dishonesty in the answers😢
Nothing is what it seems the Arab world 😂
Yup. Me too.
They may be affraid to get on the radar of authorities. But its pretty clear what they think.
also fear of retribution from hamas for saying the wrong thing as well.
Thank you for your videos. I learned a lot and see the true meaning of their view points.
Man, people blame US policy for the continuing problems in that corner of the world, but it looks to me like the real problem is the astonishingly illogical ignorance of so many people living there. And I say this as someone who has a very low opinion of my own county's intellect.
Well then you're a fucking idiot, go read Noam Chomsky you on us policy on Israel and Palestine
@hiOOxkr magkis a small buy growing minority… in the face of the opinions on the other side of the wall they are tame kittens
Ignorance exists everywhere, as you admit in your own US. However, the reality is the US is responsible for issues affecting several parts of the world.
@@lanoklom9697 he didn’t say he is from the US…
@@danthaman743 have a look at his username. 40 Days for Life is a christian anti-abortion campaign, and one of its locations is in Fairfax, VA.
The biggest irony is that it is the Muslims who are either descended from the Arab conquerors or are of other origins and have been assimilated into the culture of the conquerors. Where do the Arabs and Islam originate from? It's incredible how Muslims see not to ask themselves this question. What would they say to the Berbers of North Africa who oppose the arabisation of their culture?
The biggest and maybe tragic irony is that most of them are indeed an arabised people themselves - so "of other origins" is correct - but sure, their culture is from Arabia.
And yes, "reflection" is not their strong suit it seems.
According to the first video only a few thousand of them, living in Jerusalem, are of indigenous Arab descent btw.
The Jewish roots of the Palestinians:
ruclips.net/video/-I55IinfhmU/видео.html
Palestinians of Jewish Origin higher resolution:
ruclips.net/video/IQCr7GaVMWA/видео.html
Jewish signs found among Palestinians (english subtitles)
ruclips.net/video/StlMl077Ei8/видео.html
PALESTINIAN JEWS Arabic subtitles
ruclips.net/video/uAIXdBlUwfU/видео.html
Jewish Roots of Israel's Palestinians, Tsvi Misinai : talk at OU Israel Center:
ruclips.net/video/cx8mvOqrOe0/видео.html
ruclips.net/user/results?search_query=tsvi+misinai
www.jpost.com/magazine/features/the-lost-palestinian-jews
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsvi_Misinai#Project_on_Palestinians
Islamophobic Arabs have never been on the territory of Indonesia and Malaysia, but nevertheless they are Muslim countries
@@Long-Ball-Larry Islamophobic Arabs have never been on the territory of Indonesia and Malaysia, but nevertheless they are Muslim countries
@@snahidfromiraq1433 There is evidence of Arab Muslim traders entering Indonesia as early as the 8th century. However, it was not until the end of the 13th century that the spread of Islam began. Please do some research. Anyway the once softer Islam of Indonesia is being hardened by the intervention and finance of Wahabism from SA
@@shangrila448 Source where did you get this lie to be reliable?
Ask a Palestinian what they really want and they are happy to tell you. It will probably be different than what that blonde-haired, Starbucks-sipping, sheltered, suburban college girl protesting against Israel at UC Berkley THINKS the Palestinians want. 😂😂
2.20: “Someone is joking: “We are going to jail tonight!”” This says quite a lot about what kind of society this is!!!
Free israel from hamas.
Ask those who want to destroy Israel, do they agree to stop using Israeli resources?
Or would they give up their working permits
What the fuck are you talking about Israel is in the palastanian land using it's resources by force
Ask Israel to stop using our resources
The Palestinians are thieves@@robbrown1402
@@robbrown1402 There has never been any Palestinian land in your meaning. Stop dreaming.
the only resource palestinians owned is sand@@robbrown1402
Why do they kreep saying it is " Palestinian land?
For 400 years it was Ottoman (Turkish) and from the day the Turks' left, suddenly it is supposedly ONLY "Palestinian"?
It was EVERYBODY'S... Jews, Arabs, Christians, Druze, Bedouins. But there was an entire movement - all over the world, not just in Palestine - for national movements. The Austro-Hunngarian Empire disappeared as did the Ottoman Empire... and nation-states arose - as they always have. HELL, INDIA DIVIDED ITS EASTERN SECTION INTO A NEW COUNTRY - PAKISTAN - AND MILLIONS OF PEOPLE WERE DISPLACE, WITH THE HINDUS GOING EAST AND THE MUSLIMS GOING WEST; NOT EASY -NOT HAPPILY - BUT IT WORKED!
A SEPARATE STATE FOR EACH
WHY IS THAT SO IMPOSSIBLE IN THE MIDDLE EAST?
Muslims have 50 different countries in the world... many conquered by the sword (colonialism!) That isn't enough for them?
They have to destroy the ONE place on earth that is for Jews?
If they hadn't been intent on the destructoin of Israel for the last 75 years they cou:ld have built their State into something as viable as Israel's. But intead they spent their money and energy on military means to try and destroy Israel...
The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem - BEFORE ISRAEL EXISTED - BEFORE THE NAKBA - went to meet HITLER in 1942 - to try and get help in eliminating all the Jews from the Holy Land! That was an Arab attempt at genocide BEFORE any of the present "justifications" for fighting Israel existed!
In the Levant, after the Turks, it was a British Protectorate. NOT 'Palestinian.
In fact - at that time nobody called themselves "Palestinian"; They called themselves Arabs, or Jews or whatever; Then Britain gave 3/4 of their Protectorate to the Hashemite Arabs and Jordan was created. The rest was STILL not "Palestinian".
The UN created TWO States with the remaining land; Neither the Jews nor the Arabs were happy with what was being offerred... But the Jews said YES, the Arabs said NO - and they attcked the new State of Israel - 5 Arab Armies all together. And they LOST!
SO from that day on, those who had left were refugees. From a British Protectorate, NOT from a Palestinian State as they had refused it!
SO HOW DO THEY GET THE RIGHT TO CLAIM THAT EVEYTHING THAT ISRAEL IS BUILT ON IS THEIRS, NOT ISRAELI?
IT WAS NEVER THEIR LAND ONLY.
In fact, until the TWO States were offerred by the UN they were perhaps LIVING there, they perhaps owned a house - BUT THEY DID NOT OWN THE LAND INTHE SENSE OF A COUNTRY.
And the Land they had been given by Britain WOULD HAVE/COULD HAVE been a real State for the last 75 years if the Arabs hadn't decided to make war. When they LOST the war, then they also lost the possibility of contol over the West Bank, Gaza and (later) after the second war) The Golan Heights.
AGAIN - if they hadn't made war - ALL if that could have been a viable state controlled by themselves for the last 75 years. But since they chose war and lost - those territories have existed ever since as atraining ground for the PLO, Hezbollah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad - and terrorist attacks incessantly for 75 years:.
IS IT ANY SURPRISE THAT ISRAEL FINALLY BUILT WALLS TO PROTECT ITSELF AND SET UP CHECKPOINTS?, NONE of that should have been necessary.
OH, and the Jews, Christians and Arabs STILL "get along fine" - INSIDE ISRAEL... where the Arabs who didn't flee and didn't make war against Israel in 1947 STILL live - as EQUAL l citizens of Israel with a political Party, with members of Parliament, with a Supreme Court Judge... NO PROBLEM.
AND CERTAINLY THE OPPOSITE OF AN "APARTHEID STATE";... ANOTHER LIE that tHE Palestinians actually beleive... but it isn't true; NOt about Israel. Ask ANY ISRAELI ARAB and tHEY WILL TELL YOU!
HERE is a video with an Israeli ARAB PALESTINIAN TALKING... HE will give you the real story:
ruclips.net/video/R1cVsyUXxYM/видео.html
not reading allat
It's a shame that you have so few subs, unfortunately this kind of content is considered "boring", as opposed to mainstream media which just show extremes of both sides, it's more entertaining but doesn't reflect the reality of things
Fascinating content, Corey! You are to be commended for asking these brutally honest questions and probing for equally honest answers.
peace here can never be achieved unless one of them will leave and i think it should be the arabs because israel is not their native land it belongs to the jews, they need to resettle to arab world countries like UAE or saudi arabia
Why don’t he go ask Israelis what they would do the Palestinians - get educated - you are illiterate and so is your soul is dirty
Didn't the majority of middle eastern lands oppress and kick out the Jewish ppl who lived in these countries?
4:35 "We can live like we did before. Palestinians and Jews used to live together."
My ancestor was set upon by a group of Arab thugs for refusing to pay protection money; he was left a cripple until his death nearly a year later. This after a previously failed assassination attempt on his life.
Karl Marx wrote in 1854 "Nothing equals the misery and the suffering of the Jews of Jerusalem, inhabiting the most filthy quarter of the town, called hareth-el-yahoud . . . between the Zion and the Moriah . . . [They are] the constant objects of Mussulman oppression and intolerance, insulted by the Greeks, persecuted by the Latins [Catholics], and living only on the scanty alms transmitted by their European brethren."
Ask the Jews of Hebron in 1929 how well Jews and "Palestinians" got on together.
Then there was always the words of the brilliant Maimonides, court physician under the Fatimids and then Saladin's Ayyubids.
*_" God has entangled us with this people, the nation of Ishmael, who treat us so prejudicially and who legislate our harm and hatred.... No nation has ever arisen more harmful than they, nor has anyone done more to humiliate us, degrade us, and consolidate hatred against us."_*
And,
*_"We bear the inhumane burden of their humiliation, lies and absurdities, being as the prophet said, 'like a deaf man who does not hear or a dumb man who does not open his mouth'.... Our sages disciplined us to bear Ishmael's lies and absurdities, listening in silence, and we have trained ourselves, old and young, to endure their humiliation, as Isaiah said, 'I have given my back to the smiters, and my cheek to the beard pullers."_*
All Muslims should read the Pact of Umar, from the ninth century to understand what it was to be a Jew under Islam.
This title is only propaganda machine
Even pla stop arm struggle for their freedom and recognise Israel and they ready for even 67 border but his question is nothing sense
U should ask Israel
They would follow un resolution human rights laws who created Israel
Na
Even all Arab pic muslim countries was ready after 70s for accept Israel but only two state solution
But Israel want Palestinians land houses their blood they forgot Hitler and follow their ways to killings human in hatred
@@shainazion4073 There has never ever existed in any recorded history when a sovereign Palestinian state, nation or people existed.
They have been brainwashed into believing their fake history and conflicting narratives of pure fake.
There are NO PALESTINIAN lands . Palestine was only a geographical region in the Levant named by a ROMAN Hadrian in 135AD.
The Arabs were invented by an Egyptian Arafat in 1964.
Arabs are from ARAB-IA.
Jews are from JUDEA.
Not to mention the countless massacres against the Jews that some Palestinians proudly boast today.
I suspect historical facts have no place in the Palestinian narrative.
it is so interesting to hear all these different opinion ... so once again as always you have to ask questions.
This is really good, insightful content. Would be nice if we could all just get along.
No such thing as a free Palestine as long as the current leaderships and entities are ruling there. "Free Palestine" sounds romantic, but "independed Palestine" would be a better name.
A "free Palestine" does not automatically mean a lot of personal freedom or democratic rights or equality.
Palestine in its current situation is not much more then a dictatorship.
They are prisoners of their own religion and dogmas
@@happylucky7354 And they don't seem to get that. Hamas doesn't want freedom for the Palestine people. They just want another Islamic sh*thole, like Iran of Afghanistan or Pakistan. And they are pretty honest about that, but people don't read, aren't able to read or don't understand what they read
I want and need to clarify something that i think corey already knows (he talked about it with his translator before)
A lot of people in Palestine would be really scared to talk about their true feelings and thoughts towards the situation or because if peer pressure to live up to what their community believes is fit to be able to fit in themselves without causing disruption. A situation that i really hope changes with time
Right? I mean the guy @5:15 hesitated with an answer before asking to stop filming. 😮
It's more than peer pressure. Saying the wrong thing can get you tortured or killed. Per Wikipedia (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_number_of_police_officers), the Palestine territory has the third highest ratio of police per civilians in the world, exceeded only by Pitcairn Islands with 2 officers total, and the Vatican with 139 total officers. For scale, if the US had the same police/civilian ratio, there would be 5.7 million police officers.
They call it "Police brutality"... Like the Combine...
@@onyx9943 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD except through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was separating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
This title is only propaganda machine
Even pla stop arm struggle for their freedom and recognise Israel and they ready for even 67 border but his question is nothing sense
U should ask Israel
They would follow un resolution human rights laws who created Israel
Na
Even all Arab pic muslim countries was ready after 70s for accept Israel but only two state solution
But Israel want Palestinians land houses their blood they forgot Hitler and follow their ways to killings human in hatred
I wonder, why you don't ask them about ancient synagogues found on "their " land? What would be their guess?
They answer that the Israelies are lying
I love how its so clear that Islam is peaceful
"They did not allow us to develop and improve." What has Palestine been spending its foreign aid on?
Funny thing is, this is the west bank, they have it better than most arabs living under arab dictators.
Crumpets and tea
3:57 - correction: Israel was built on lands that were PURCHASED whether from Arabs (usually landlords that lived in Beirut, Damascus, Cairo etc.) Turks, churches, foreign governments etc. These are the lands that the Jews settled on before 1948 - before the Palestinians and 5 Arab armies opened a war against the Jews/Israel.
Many of these lands were purchased from foreign owners who fell on hard times. It's like if a mega billionaire bought every rental apartment in New York and then evicted all the residents. While technically it might be legal, you can understand the catastrophic upheaval it means for the masses who are effected.
Truth
Only small percentage of the land was ever privately owned.
e.g. The Neggev desert and the Jewdean desert comprise 65-70% of the land of Israel and still are very sparsely populated.
@@ef2718 ALL the land that the Zionist Jews settled on in 1948 was purchased by Jewish organizations.
If I purchase land in texas does it give me right to declare independant state of texas?
Very nice channel. The interviews helps me a lot to understand the pow of the normal people of the Palestinians. Keep on working and greetings from Germany.
Great video. Thank you for this.
The first man definitly meant : destroy Israël. he just couldn't Say it.
Because he probably works in Israel.
Nobody likes the idea of talking about destroying another country as much as you would think. Especially when the police are around and might take that as a threat.
Definitely has a work permit in Israel and doesn’t want to get fired
Some might want destruction of Israel but who actually cares
How can you tell?
The early Jewish leaders appealed to the Arabs to stay in their houses and help them create a country together. Their answer was having 5 Arab armies attack the one day old country Israel.
before zio came from Europe in 48 there was peace in Palestine all religions living together
There were already 300k Palestinian refugees before Arab nations "attacked." Israel also unilaterally declared itself a state on 70% of Palestine even though the non binding British partian called for a Jewish state on 55% of the land. How convenient of you to leave that information out.
What is going on in Iran now is proof that 'Israel is a light unto the nations"
“It’s not the first time that #Kurds rise up against the Islamic Republic. They’ve opposed it since the beginning. But it’s the first time the rest of Iran has supported them.”
Ava Homa
@@generaljg4373 minus the 1860s massacres on christians and the Hebron massacre on Jews.
@@Ask-Isa lol you know many of the Arab left in wave so for example by 1947 about 30.000 Palestinians left out of fear and by June 1948 between 300.000 to 400.000 thousand Palestinians left out of fear Idf was only responsible for about 5 to 2 percent a very low number and Jews to over 77 percent when we want on the defense and Jordan annexed the West Bank and Egypt set up a military rule in Gaza not creating a Palestinian state
In fact, even before the establishment of the State of Israel, Arabs killed Jews, as in the 1929 Palestine riots.
Jews returned to their ancestral lands and freed it from Arab occupation. The Arabs living in the area were brought as a labor force by the Ottoman Empire. In addition, many of them have surnames that indicate that they come from Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria.
Zionist settlements started in the late 1800’s and formed Jewish terrorist groups
If someone was ignorant about the Palestinians view before watching this, now they definitely know which party is the aggressor.
G’day from a Lebanese born Australian. One of them said every “Muslim wants” in reference to the destruction of Israel, so what about the Jews, Christians and Druze that have always lived in the Holy Lands. One woman smiled as she said yes they should all return from where they came from, does this mean that the Arab Jews that were evicted would be allowed to return along with their stolen property. How about these same Terrorists that killed Jordanians and Lebanese people in a civil war they started. They smiled as they introduced Lebanese victims to the blade after being R@P3D and robbed.
I want my homeland freed of the 700,000 terrorists that live there. Israel must never give in to these terrorists. Peace with Israel not terrorists.
The christians and druz were second class citizens of the islamic ottoman empire before World War 2. They were called : DIMIS. Born to pay the Jizia.
Wait, who are the terrorist in your analogy?
@@Physiker17 so in your limited English you didn’t understand to whom I was referring.
It’s not an analogy or an opinion it’s factual.
The Terrorists are the PLO/Fatah murderers of Lebanese civilians and soldiers starting in 1968 and continuing through the civil war they started and into the 21st century with the Naher Al Bared zbale refugee camp that killed approximately 117 Lebanese soldiers and civilians.
These same Terrorists evicted from Jordan for trying the same thing have in fact killed more Lebanese people than have died at the hands of Israel.
Also the Arab states are making peace with Israel and realising that these terrorists are irredeemable and only want death and destruction.
Even the Palestinians are joining the Israeli military 😂😂😂
What are you talking about? 😅 May God lead you to the righteous way and lift your hatered...
@@Physiker17 Hezzbollah/Hamas etc
2:02 "what if they apologise" its so funny to me when he said it for some reason
"they took our best places from out country" no they didnt, they got a desert and made it the "best places"
My grandparents was born in Begdad and Sidon. They were expelled by Arab Governments just because they were jews and run away to Israel only with their clothes.
Israel has always strived for peace, and for peace Israelis could put the past behind. Unfortunately, i'm not sure the Palestines are able to do the same.
If you look for the core issue , I think it's a moral issue - what do we teach the future generations ?
Israel was not founded on peaceful principles. Maybe read Herzl. He saw what was coming and knew war/dispossession was inevitable for his dream. But other than that I think you are right. It really depends on what is taught, but the status quo on both sides is subpar.
i agree re the status quo - but it is borne of brainwashing/intergenerational trauma; jews need healing. palestinians need resources, safety, land and healing. i do not understand how people can think israel 'has always strived for peace' - watch the video in which all israeli's justify or deny occupation even taking place - thats the problem with teaching - the zionist propaganda@@moonori4595
Not really... Israeli want expel all arab from their lands... That was Israeli mindset
Israel was founded with violence and force, perhaps due to circumstances. Zionism did not gain momentum until the threat of Nazis gave it the legitimacy it needed to garner support. Desperate to escape persecution, European Jews immigrated in massive waves. The US and Britain eventually became overwhelmed and closed their borders. When Britain also ordered a halt to immigration in Palestine (1930s), the Zionists used violence to force more people in. Zionists proceeded with their agenda of creating a Jewish-state knowing Palestine was inhabited. With the assistance of sympathetic British soldiers, they terrorized Palestinians out of their homes, driving them into the desert, burning down homes and villages. The situation became untenable and after WW2 Britain handed the problem over to the UN. Zionists found a new sponsor in America and the rest is history.
“We will spirit them [the Arabs] across the frontiers discreetly.”
- Hertzl, founder of Zionism
“We must expel the Arabs and take their place…. I support forced transfer and see nothing unethical in it.”
- Ben-Gurion, first PM of Israel, Zionist
Netanyahu and many in his cabinet come from a long history of extreme Zionism. Bibi has made clear (as many Zionists have in the past) that Israel is not just a homeland for Jews, but should be a Jewish-only state. This is the real moral dilemma. But perhaps too much blood has been spilled already for it to matter. Hopefully, extremism will be buried on both sides with each passing generation, and give birth to a hope for peace, tolerance and equality for everyone.
The Palestinians were peaceful to the Jewish migrants ,
What did they get as a reward for that?
Dispossessing their ppl and declaring a nation for the refugees,that can come at any moment and became citizens .
That's the type of peace you wanna put in the table.
the saddest thing for me is that most of my people have never even thought about these questions before . they try to find the answer on the spot
but after a short conversation with me or other people that think sanely they change their minds
the clear solution is a unified single state or a federation ... only because the two states are so interconnected you cant set any borders especially after all of theses settlement were built
but this would never happen before each side open their eyes and realise this truth
They not only thought , but most muz ar abs pastalinis , know exactly what they want to do to je wish men , and another delightfull plan for je wish women. The only solution is returning the migrants of peace to their 22 ar ab is lamic states.
Your instinct should never be “yes my political ideology and goal is the genocide of another nation” no matter what. The fact that most said they are in favor of the destruction of Israel is sick and genocidal and has no excuse. This is what the Palestinian education system does to the people most are regular people who would never think that under a normal system
@@JustaRandomGuy890 did they?, I thought the responses were very equal
A single binational state: absolutely not. That would makes no sense whatsoever and would be just a recipe for disaster. 2 states or a federation of 2 states is Ok
@Taleb, Israeli guy here telling you my eyes are open. Happy to hear you are here with us in this.
That was an important question
Question for Corey. This is a question that can be asked to an interviewer who interviews a group of people. Do you show all your interviews? If not, then what % of the interviews do you show? If you don't show all the interviews, then that means you made decisions not to show certain interviews. On what basis did you use not to show a certain interview.
This is relevant because if the person doing the interview has an agenda, they can choose to only show the interviews that help advance their agenda.
Before 1917, there was no Palestine or Israel. There was the Ottoman empire. During this time no one called themselves "Palestinians". So after the Ottoman empire disappeared, there was no official owner. The British administered the area but did not claim "ownership" of it. That's why it was a "mandate", and not part of Britain. They can't say it's "their land". What they are referring to is the land that was used by invading Arab armies to attack Israel. Once the area you live in is used as a launching point for attacks, you give up any claim to this land. Maybe if the Arabs would have immediately tried to make peace in 1948 right after the war, the people would have been allowed to return...but that isn't what happened.
San remo conference
They dont accept reality, they dont respect deals and they dont lose with dignity.
They are always the "victims".. though they all seem to be doing pretty well to me....
there was already israel in 1000 and 725 BCE, the "palestine" word thing was never used through out milleniums until 1964 because arabs adopted this term at this year and they started calling themselves "palestinians"
There was a lot of fighting between Jews and Muslims before 1948.
@@drdonna4915 muslims did not existed until because during the kingdom of israel time existence, islam did not existed at that time, islam only existed in early mid 600s because muhammad founded it but arabs do existed at that time
As an Israeli, I really liked the first woman and the guy from 6: 58. They're the only ones who understand that Israel is here and you can love it or hate it, but it's not going anywhere. The only solution is to live in peace. You can't just say Israel doesn't exist and except them to "go back to where they came from״ because we all know that's just impossible. Until both sides will understand the we both live here and it's going to stay like that no matter what, I don't believe there will be peace.
Shut up israeli
What Israel did to Palestine simply cannot be forgiven... This is fueled by vendetta, and Palestinians have a lot of it...
Once again, from my perspective I don't care if its called Israel or Palestine. The Jews and Arabs have to figure this one out, among themselves.
@@onyx9943 You mean to the region called Palestine? It was not recognizd as a state.
yeah only she did not accept Israel out of love, but out of necessity, she is aware better than her spoiled brat child that under PA or Hamas their situation worsens without Israel at the corner. this is a sort of love-hate relationship. in short frenemies.
Corey! Your materials are true treasure in archives of these times - they sould be put to the new
Ark of the Covenant, really XD. Best style journalism, bravery and very intelligent way of interviewing people. Pray for Pulitzer for it! ;)
Why do you never ask them about Palestinian Apartheid and all of "Palestine" being completely Judenrein? You always cede the higher ground to them
@12:56 "The world is a big place, they can find a place", There are 22 ARAB COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD.
The Jews were literally kicked out (forcefully, and that is an understatement) from every piece of land on this earth, including some of these Arab countries . And now, when they establish a country for them to be safe in, the Palestinian, whom their leaders denied the two state solution in 1947, and a large portion of its population are immigrants from neighboring Arabs countries - wants them to go find another place, This is insane.
Riddled with bullshit. The fact is that Israel was built on stolen Palestinian land. No excuse you can give would justify that fact. Kicked out of every country? That’s the excuse for ethnically cleansing Palestine? You think you should just be handed a free home, is that what you are saying?
It's not insane. Not all ethnicities have countries.
Also, if the entire world hates you it probably means you deserve it
Why are you asking Arabs and Palestinians in particular to pay for the prosecution of Jewish people by Europeans!?
@@LoganNYC why you ask from jews to go back to land that tehy didnt belong and to leave the only jewish land and state in history?
israe (what you called palestine) was jewish place long before arabs and muslims came here.
@@SigalDa where/when did I ask Jewish people to leave?
This is why it is hard to hope for a 2 state solution. Most Palestinians do not want it. They do not accept that the Israelis/Jews are in Israel to stay. They just keep repeating ‘they took our land and they need to leave’.
5:21 When she says they will go back to where they came from. They are exactly where they came from.
And if she wants to send them back to Europe, does she know what happened to them in Europe?
And what about the Arab Jews, where will they return? They were expelled from the Muslim countries they came from and there too they were subjected to torture and abuse.
The arab got most of palestine 74% its call Jorden!
The Israeli Palestinian conflict from the first place is all about 26% of palestine!
So how can you say that israel got most of palestine? While Jorden bigger then israel?
Jewish and Druze have rightful claim upon 21% of palestine.
Therefor isreal have the right to exist!
The peacefull eternal victims strike again.
"We just want to be free, so all J must leave".
In some inexplicable way, that the interviewees "don't know", Jews would leave Judea.
There used to be a one-hour video describing Jews mysteriously disappearing from earth, Palestinians taking over and within a week destroying each other, yet still blaming Jews for it. I'm not sure if anyone translated it into English, but it was great.
whats wrong with that , same as french settlers left algeria
@@Zack-hv9cl See if you can grasp this. The homeland of the French is France. The homeland of Jews is Judea. (Went home. Done now.)
@@Zack-hv9cl algerians didnt clain paris habibi.
Why do you put two subtitles over each other ?
That last girl... Listen to what she says: "We are a simple people, Israel did not let us evolve"... This is the whole Palestinian story in a sentence. Palestinians do not take responsibility for their situation, they only want to blame Israel. While the real enemy for their future is Hamas. Israel left Gaza in 2005, since then they elected Hamas and it is the one responsible for their education, health, economics, infrastructure... But all they did was prepare for war against Israel... Built terror tunnels instead of water and electricity factories. Denying Gazans basic normal life conditions.
*This is a perfect example of why education and awareness are so crucial when it comes to this specific conflict. Many of these Arabs are saying factually incorrect statements:*
1. Palestine wasn't a country pre-israel it was introduced by the British in the 20th century, and along with their occupation, the term was revived officially as well
2. Jews and Arabs did not live in constant peace, uprisings, pogroms, lynches and massacres were recorded dozens of times during the British Mandate inflicted against one another. Antisemitic propaganda by local Arab seikhs was common place which stimulated much of the local hate and attacks in their native Jewish neighbours.
3. Jews aren't from other lands. Just because an Arab was born in France, doesn't make him ethnically French, his origin isn't erased and not relevant. The same is the case for the Jews, we are from Judea, and just because we were hosted in many countries internationally, doesn't suddenly make us belong ethnically to those countries.
Following Oslo accords control over the education system was transferred to the hands of the PA.
The PA revised the education system and schools textbooks (Used to be Jordanian textbooks) to have more hate preaching of Jews and revised history. Recently some European countries that give donation to the PA have put a halt on donations until the issues with school textbooks are rectified.
1 yes it was othman caliphate and province name was pelistine with very few Jewish population.
2. Dose antisemitic riots justify to occupy the whole pelistine? And settle the jews all over the world to protect few jews?
3 if jews Claim is right than we need to accept Chrookee people to claim USA. Aborigins claim Australia and Maori claim New Zealand. Basically this claim is flawed and stupid.
4
Why jews are settling by the name of Israel in pelistine? Alternate proposal was Africa and Europe too if you dig deep.
@@mmulbatoora653 Your logic is flawed and here's why:
1. Jews have been a minority in their land for 2000 years similar to the aboriginals in North and south America.
2. How are Jews settling Judea? Are Italians settling Italy? Are the japanese settling Japan? Are the Arabs settling Arabia?
3. Jews don't only have a claim, we literally fought the British out along with all Arab colonialism as well. It's one thing to have a claim and another to fight and win that claim.
4. Palestine itself is a European colonialist term coined by the Romans in 70 CE and later by the British in the 20th century. *Israel is the true virgin and original name of the land.*
@@noamrotstain3182 haha my statement is flawed but your claims are correct
1 if Jews were in minority than why they are calling all the Jews to settle in Israel?
Just to out number pelistinians to gain full control.
2 they are not settling as some tribe or ethnicity they are settling as religious Group lol Italian Spanish Moroccan under one name as Jews so your argument is flawed again.
3 this is Joke of the century Jews fought British actually Britishers conspired land for jews they wanted to get rid of jews because of their notorious nature.
4 the land is called pelistine I don't know how you are not aware it's Falasteen in Arabic and you are accusing English speaking people they named in Arabic lol
Dose it make any sense English people naming in Arabic. Lol
5 2 Nov 1917 Belfour declaration issued by Birish Govt lol what was that dude British Govt helped along with France And USA they all wanted to collect Garbage in one place unfortunately the decided Land of pelistine to dump their Garbage. Jews thougt they are their well-wishers actually they Got rid of jews.
@@mmulbatoora653 my dude, Jews aren't only a religion. We're an ethnicity. Who told you that you could talk about a subject you know nothing about? And you're the symbol of an ignorant man-only an idiot wouldn't want to learn from the actual people living here.
You can see who has the intelligent and kind faces and who do not. Hatred is ugly.
This us fascinating thank you
Skipped history in the university ? Never been a palestinian country or people !
What a stupid argument. Still doesn’t give anyone the right to slaughter and ethnic cleanse the indigenous people to the land
.Many many Palestinians came to Israel during the 20s from surrounding countries to benefit from the higher standard of living. You can verify this by asking arabs in Israel. The most striking thing I observed in Palestinian society outside Israel is the lack of open debate, diversity of opinion (on all subjects) and the conformity - maybe through fear. Real education and freedom of speech are a prerequisite for peace.
the highest level of lie is when you perpousely make a lie that you keep repeating until you think its true
pure bullshit, you talk as if we were living in caves, they are the settlers , they came to us , we were here , we had everything , they didn't add anything that benefited us.
Palastinain's are one of the most educated people in terms of literacy rate and pHD per capita your racist ignorant moron. You must believe all the racist lies that say Palastnians are uneducated savages.
@@Zack-hv9cl And the lie that the Arabs and Muslims are Palestinians is the largest lie.
I wouldn't say most. Borders have also changed many times in the last 150 years.
Going through the videos from both sides in this channel, the sharp fact of who is looking for peace rather than invasion was very very obvious
That shop owner looked terrified.
PLO leader Zuheir Mohsen explained to the world in 1977 the following:
"The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan"
great short question with very true answers
good job
Basically they refuse to live with them.
And thanks guys, you are doing a great gob.
Well done Corey. Difficult to do but done well. I pray for peace in the land which is Holy to so many
Only if Israel remains strong and powerfull
@@emanuell5926 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD except through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was separating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Amen🙏
Forget about it - holy wars never end.
you are still essentislly hindu does your mouth cqn shut up?
I watch this channel a lot... the first woman who spoke in the video... she is also the first to recognize the current situation... and it gives me a lot of hope... hope for a better future... because I also recognize that they are here... as an Israeli
I think a lot of people see this, I'm in the west but when i say free Palestine i mean 2 things:
- Declare it as an independent state
- Stop controlling what goes in or out from other countries, let them be self determined fully, currently it is a prison and i cant blame prisoners for being freedom fighters.
They if they keep attacking after that they can still be struck. But as it stands now you are killing prisoners.
Besides that I don't think any of the land has to be returned, that ship has sailed.
It seems like the clearest path to peace, both sides pressing for a solution like this.
Palestinians need to control their worst elements that want israel destroyed. And isreal needs take the first steps to make this new state work.
Free palestine and a prosperous safe Israel that the jewish people have worked hard to make a reality.
Right, maybe Ukrainians should also recognize the current situation that Russia now owns the donbass and other territories.
They to should stop their attacks on Russia for a better future, right?
the old ppl are more reasnoble and actually lived the hystory the younger ppl drunk more of the coolade of their educational system so they want to figth israel
"we are going to jail tonight" explains everything.
Surely Israel should never allow anything less than annexation of Judea and Samaria
This video was like a motivation video for me to keep Israel strong against these assholes who want to kick me out of the country I was born in.
Free Palestine my ass.
Free Israel, more like.
Just because u were born there does not mean u own it.
@@nasimsamporna7779same with palestinians lol
Lol your parents already did this atrocity to them they born here their parents born in here their great great grandfathers born in here they never been anywhere else basically most of the Palestinians share the same dna "Genetic fingerprinting" with the jews it means they were jews and became over time christians or muslims or stayed jews
Can you feel how they feel now ?
Only the idea of it made you angry!!!
@@nasimsamporna7779Just because Arabs were born in British Palestine it doesn’t mean they owned it, right?
Would be interesting to hear more from the last girl.
“If I am born in France, can I take France?” Well in fact yes, as a French-born citizen, you are definitely eligible to run for political office:)
Yeah I did find it strange to end the interview there. What do you mean take france, conquer it and banish all French people? If that's what she meant then it's basically like saying Israelis shouldn't take the land from Palestinians just because they were born there, but surely they should still be allowed to live there and not be banished, just like anyone who was born in France would in France.
Yes, they should be allowed to live there, but there are no Jews in countries run by Arabs, let's be honest. On the other hand, there are plenty of Arabs in countries run by Jews and there are a ton of Arabs in countries run by Christians. So who's intolerant and oppressive? Those Arabs are. Absolutely reprehensible people with genocidal thoughts masqueraded as freedom fighters.
And he only asked her if they can live in Palestine.. Insane.
I think the girl was a little confused there, about the assumption that Israel exist or not that her opinion based on.
I kind of want to ask her what about the Arabs that's not indigenous to this land, but maybe that would be sound like I'm looking for a fight
You misunderstood her perspective. She meant take it from inhabitants already living there not run for office. Israeli Jews born in Israel or even Jews from New York can simply steal or 'take' Palestinian land in the West Bank.
6:07 Yeah, when you born in France and raised there, you could consider this your home, even though your parents were immigrants.
The momentary panic in the eyes says it all when the question is asked.
Congratualtions! You've just shot Ben Gvir's new campaign video.
I m afraid. The more WE learn the less Peace has a chance. But the first women shows THERE IS HOPE..... The other Palestinians would probable kill her first though...
Howdie , What is ben gvir?
@@dogbert52 An Israeli politician who has the balls to handle things properly.
@@dogbert52 Ben Gvir is an Israeli politician who's a far-right extremist, from a terrorist group known as Kahanists. Every sane patriotic Zionist would want him removed from Knesset, he's one of the biggest threats to Israeli society.
@@starhopper1706 thanks. Interesting guy. Googled him. He isnt too extreme.
Not a single soul said anything about having a free government.
These people are frightened to answer truthfully knowing they are endangering their own lives