That isn't the star of David it's the star of Remphan /Chiun. Stephen spoke of it in the book of Acts quoting Amos 5 Ye took up the tabernacle of Molech and the Star of Remphan, figures which you made to worship them, the star represents the hexagram storm on Saturn Molech the god of chaos is the star god of Saturn in Hebrew Sabbetai. Sattan is a descriptive noun meaning accuser or adversary it was never a name, Revelation 3 :9 should read, "Behold I will make those of the Synagogue of Saturn who say they are Jews but are not, they lie, Behold I will make them come bow down at your feet and they will know I have loved thee.
Oh i have this book! I ordered one for my dad too. Family of diaspora anti-zio jews, its been three generations of anti-z jews, all extremely politically minded, but this book was like a trove of new information. I am so grateful. Even though the topic is so regrettable and heavy. Its getting so heavy in this new way in the past 6 months.
I LOVE Tony Greenstein! His book is so interesting. He spent a lot of time on the Kasner Trail, but he had more interesting conversations with the electronic intifada, in case anyone is interested. It’s not Rania’s fault at all. I just wanted to let everyone know how fascinating his insights are.
They learnt from the British and everythig the British did they first practised it in Ireland that is why we see and understand. The British need to pay repatations.
I've met people who truly do not like Jewish people, but I've never spoke to anyone who articulated any objection to Judaism. I honestly do not believe the word Antisemitism has any validity any longer. As example, Israel claims you are Antisemitic for objecting to them unaliving 6-Year-Old Hind Rajab. The definition clearly must have changed.
Anti Semitism is a red herring to be a Semite you are to speak several Semitic languages Arabic, Aramaic, Hebraic, Semitic Ethiopian Ge'ez and Tigrinya, Tigre of Sudan, Phoenician and Maltese. What is happening in Palestine and Transjordan is brother killing brother.
Zìonists say that definitions are like feelings and change how feelings change. I'm paraphrasing, but that was basically what one Isræli official said. #1984IsHere
Yeah, this it the "new antisemitism" which was created by zionists during the 50/60's ... And the real antisemetics are applauding Israel and supporting the deportation of any jew to Israel (there was a nazi manifestation SUPPORTING Israel in USA DEMANDING that jews MUST go to Israel(... What a strange world to live in
Excellent coverage on this topic. I also have Tony Greenstein's eye opening book, which is why I tuned in to Rania's discussion with Tony. Tgank you very much.
"He who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who helps to perpetrate it. he who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it." "Ad we sow so we reap."
To what extent does the belief of being uniquely " *God's* chosen people ", and the obvious ideological protection (arrogance?) that comes from _THAT_ , have to do with all of this?
Excellent interview, highly informative. Tony Greenstein's book is a mine of information and an indispensable corrective to the many myths surrounding Zionism, Israel itself, to the separation of what is horrifically, historically true of the Judeocide (Holocaust) itself from the ways in which it has been instrumentalised for western political purposes. One of the main things in the interview was to contextualise, and rightly debunk, the myth that Israel exists to keep Jews safe in the world. Tony cites historical examples, but even without those, anyone can see that Israel, because of the way it has structured itself as oppression against other peoples within its borders, is surely the least place on the planet for Jews to be safe. I too was brought up to believe in the historical "necessity" of the Jewish state, and it was a very long and, to be honest, often difficult journey to be rid of those false beliefs, historical distortions and not least, the unconscious racism inherent in the Zionist project. One of Rania's phrases has stuck with me but forgive me if I misquote her (from memory), "Israel is American's weapon in the middle east", ie it's not "ITWAD" (to quote Moshé Machover), Israeli Tail Wags American Dog, it's not Israel, or Zionists, or Jews "controlling" USA policy, the policy comes from western imperial capitalism, the northern hemisphere (largely) ideology terrified of the slightest threat to its hegemony from the (largely) global South. Personally speaking, as everyone knows or should do, Israel claims to speak and act on behalf of, and in the interests of, all Jews everywhere on the planet and if we don't repudiate that dangerous propaganda, we're complicit. People of good will who might not be well informed as to the reality may be inclined to take Israel at its word with the result that some may be misled into accusing all Jews of involvement in Israel's crimes. When that happens, then we have to follow the logic, Israel itself provokes and amplifies antisemitism, which, as the late Irish statesman Conor Cruise O'Brien once called 'A very light sleeper', all too easy to wake up no matter how long it's been quiescent. The late Israeli writer and activist Akiva Orr wrote a book he titled, The UN-Jewish State, surely in conscious echo of Theodor Herzl's The Jewish State. If you look at the best of the ethical tradition in Judaism, not the parts of the Hebrew Bible which Netanyahu and his fascist colleagues like to quote, but the Prophets and the universalist writings in Rabbinic Judaism, you'll easily see that how Israel has behaved for 75 years provides all the evidence you need to invalidate Israel's self-description. And we Jews need to stop that tendency to think of ourselves as forever victims, which can make us seem to hallucinate bogus antisemitism wherever we look (there's more than enough of the real thing still in the world without needing to manufacture more of it). Great interview, thanks so much for posting it, both.
"Israel was not founded because of the Holocaust" you said. Are you sure the Zionists did not use the Holocaust at all in 1948 to obtain UN recognition of the State of Israel?
pretty sure. If you listen to Hitler or Goebbels, you'll see that it was all a plan from long before ww2. Also, you NEED to look into the "holocaust" criticisms on actual free speech platforms.
do you mean the Human Skin Lamp Shades and Human Fat Soap stories, as well as a PLETHORA OF OTHER SHAMELESS LIES BEYOND WHICH YOU'RE ABLE TO CONCEIVE due to your inability to understand the depth and BREADTH of depravity of human sociopathy? Yes, they used the, cough, holocaust to obtain what they wanted. There's a reason, though, why the stories that we hear today weren't widely disseminated in the NYT before 1965, and it's a cynical reason. A very cynical reality. a 9-11-esque reality. a USS-Liberty-esque reality.
@@b1crusade384 Of course. But the Zionists were having trouble building up thier population in Palestine; they needed to create a majority by influx of people and expulsion of the Palestinians. Surely, the Holocaust was used to encourage Jews to move to Palestine in the last moments of 1945-1948.
do you mean the Human Skin Lamp Shades and Human Fat Soap stories, as well as a PLETHORA OF OTHER SHAMELESS cough, uh, truths, BEYOND WHICH YOU'RE ABLE TO CONCEIVE due to your inability to understand the depth and BREADTH of depravity of human sociopathy? Yes, they used the, ack-cough, holocaust, to obtain what they wanted. There's a reason, though, why the stories that we hear today weren't widely disseminated in the NYT before 1965, and it's a cynical reason. A very cynical reality. a 9-11-esque reality. a USS-Liberty-esque reality.
Tony also believes that antisemitism exists and nobody knows why and dismisses the possibility that group behavior could be a factor. He is a good man but cannot escape his conditioning.
Can anyone send me the map of Palestine in the 18s? I want the map the pro Palestinian activist talk about, that looks like a corn icecream , i want that map in the 18s
I like Tony, but why he bashes Kasztner at every opportunity I don't know. That whole case is not as simple as he makes out. You think he's going to get through his rambling speeches without mentioning it, but then, no, here we go - he's going to bore us all again with his ridiculous Kasztner-bashing treatises. I wish he'd just drop the topic.
When the zi0naz1 jwsh regime and project started with supremac1st racist ideology ,everything they do is judged by that standard. For example the founder of Political Zionism, Theodor Herzl wrote in his diary in 1895, “When we occupy the land, we shall bring immediate benefits to the state that receives us. We must expropriate gently the private property on the estates assigned to us. We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our own country. The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly.” Israel Zangwill, another important political Zionist said in a talk in 1905, “(We) must be prepared either to drive out by the sword the (Arab) Tribes in possession as our forefathers did or to grapple with the problem of a large alien population, mostly Mohammedan and accustomed for centuries to despise us.” Around 1928, Shabtai Levi, a land purchasing agent for Baron de Rothschild wrote in his memoirs, “He (the Baron) advised me to carry on in similar activities, but it is better, he said, not to transfer the Arabs to Syria and Transjordan, as these are part of the Land of Israel, but to Mesopotamia (Iraq), He added that in these cases he would be ready to send the Arabs, at his expense, new agricultural machines, and agricultural advisers.” Around 1930, Zionist Socialist (Mapai) leader, David Hacohen wrote, “… I would not accept Arabs in my trade union, the Histadrut; to defend preaching to housewives that they not buy at Arab stores; to prevent Arab workers from getting jobs there… To pour kerosene on Arab tomatoes, to attack Jewish housewives in the markets and smash the Arab eggs they had bought; to praise to the skies the Keren Kayemet that sent Hankin to Beirut to buy land from absentee effendi (landowners) and to throw the fellahin (peasant farmers) off the land - to buy dozens of dunams - from an Arab is permitted, but sell, God forbid, one Jewish dunam to an Arab is prohibited.” Menahem Ussishkin, chairman of the Jewish National Fund, and member of the executive of the Jewish Agency, said in a 1930 speech to journalists, “We must continually raise the demand that our land be returned to our possession … if there are other inhabitants there, they must be transferred to some other place. We must take over the land. We have a greater and nobler ideal than preserving several hundred thousands of Arab fellahin.”.a speech in July, 1938, Ben-Gurion said, “In the proposal of transferring the Arab population from the area, if it is possible voluntarily and if not by coercion, it would be possible to expand the Jewish settlement…The basic difference with the Commission proposal is that the transfer will be on a much larger scale, from the Jewish to the Arab territory;. If it were possible to transfer Arabs from one village to another within the British Mandate - it is difficult to find any political or moral argument against the transfer of these Arabs from the proposed Jewish-ruled area…. And is there any need to explain the value in a continuous Jewish Yishuv…”. Also in July, 1938, Yosef Bankover, founding member of the Kibbutz Hameuhad movement and member of the Haganah Regional Command, said, “…as for compulsory transfer, as a member of Kibbutz Ramat Hakovesh, I would be very pleased if it would be possible to be rid of the pleasant neighbourliness of the people of Miski, Tirah and Qalqilyah.”. Another leader of the Kibbutz Hameuhad movement, Aharon Zisling said, “I do not contest our moral right to propose population transfer. There is no moral flaw in a proposal aimed at concentrating the development of national life. On the contrary: in a new world order it can and should be a noble human vision…”. Then in August, 1938, Berl Katznelson, a labor leader, wrote, “The matter of population transfer has provoked a debate among us: Is it permitted or forbidden? My conscience is absolutely clear in this respect. A remote neighbour is better than a close enemy. They will not lose from being transferred and we most certainly will not lose from it…. But it never crossed my mind that transfer to outside the Land of Israel would mean merely to the vicinity of Nablus, I have always believed and still believe that they were destined to be transferred to Syria or Iraq.”.
AMAZING + Wonderful interview !
And now the Star of David is the new Swastica..
Hardly. The swastika stood for justice and prosperity.... The star of Remphan or the star of Solomon... Stands for the synagogue of satan.
That isn't the star of David it's the star of Remphan /Chiun.
Stephen spoke of it in the book of Acts quoting Amos 5 Ye took up the tabernacle of Molech and the Star of Remphan, figures which you made to worship them, the star represents the hexagram storm on Saturn Molech the god of chaos is the star god of Saturn in Hebrew Sabbetai.
Sattan is a descriptive noun meaning accuser or adversary it was never a name, Revelation 3 :9 should read, "Behold I will make those of the Synagogue of Saturn who say they are Jews but are not, they lie, Behold I will make them come bow down at your feet and they will know I have loved thee.
@@Sonofthe1655 Sorprendente! Realmente no sabía esa información sobre la estrella de ... Remphan !
No, it's not. Jews are not Israelis. #NotInMyName
more like the stupid scarf all of the Pro Hamas protestors wear is the new Swastika.
They will pay back them all what they have done to innocent Palestinians !!!
AMEN TO THAT..
so you support retaliation, just like Israel did for OCT 7?
@@RUclipssTop10restitution is part of the part to reconciliation and liberation and peace.
*path
@@razi1569 burning babies is restitution?
109 countries can't be wrong.
Wait till everyone learns they made it up with the intent to become unimpeachable genocidal supremacists.
How about thinking for yourself, based on your own research, rather than let others decide for you.
+143
Oh i have this book! I ordered one for my dad too. Family of diaspora anti-zio jews, its been three generations of anti-z jews, all extremely politically minded, but this book was like a trove of new information. I am so grateful. Even though the topic is so regrettable and heavy. Its getting so heavy in this new way in the past 6 months.
I LOVE Tony Greenstein! His book is so interesting. He spent a lot of time on the Kasner Trail, but he had more interesting conversations with the electronic intifada, in case anyone is interested. It’s not Rania’s fault at all. I just wanted to let everyone know how fascinating his insights are.
They learnt from the British and everythig the British did they first practised it in Ireland that is why we see and understand.
The British need to pay repatations.
Who financed Cromwell?
@@sprsmoke Who?
@@sprsmoke his statue is at the houses of parliment in London, tell youall you need to know.
@@cyberhermit1222 What planet are you talking about?
Very interesting guest. I was unaware of the whole story Zionism and found it enlightening. Thank you.
you should read 51 documents by Lenin Brenner and Goliath by Max Blumenthal
ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for Israel
You mean Palestine, the victims... Israel is the bad guys.
Tony welcoming Rania to her own show = power moves only
He and she are right. Norman Finkelstein had said the same things.
What a brilliantly informative listen!
I've met people who truly do not like Jewish people, but I've never spoke to anyone who articulated any objection to Judaism. I honestly do not believe the word Antisemitism has any validity any longer. As example, Israel claims you are Antisemitic for objecting to them unaliving 6-Year-Old Hind Rajab. The definition clearly must have changed.
Anti Semitism is a red herring to be a Semite you are to speak several Semitic languages Arabic, Aramaic, Hebraic, Semitic Ethiopian Ge'ez and Tigrinya, Tigre of Sudan, Phoenician and Maltese. What is happening in Palestine and Transjordan is brother killing brother.
Zìonists say that definitions are like feelings and change how feelings change. I'm paraphrasing, but that was basically what one Isræli official said. #1984IsHere
Yeah, this it the "new antisemitism" which was created by zionists during the 50/60's ... And the real antisemetics are applauding Israel and supporting the deportation of any jew to Israel (there was a nazi manifestation SUPPORTING Israel in USA DEMANDING that jews MUST go to Israel(... What a strange world to live in
And how stupid are we to believe them.
For generations.😮
Go check what they teach the kids in gaza, My kamp. IDF are finding hitlers books everywhere
This is one of the landmark interviews of Breakthrough
Excellent coverage on this topic. I also have Tony Greenstein's eye opening book, which is why I tuned in to Rania's discussion with Tony. Tgank you very much.
"He who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who helps to perpetrate it. he who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it."
"Ad we sow so we reap."
Speak for Justice and your called anti semitic.
To what extent does the belief of being uniquely " *God's* chosen people ", and the obvious ideological protection (arrogance?) that comes from _THAT_ , have to do with all of this?
By the way, folks, Rania Khalek is not journalist but activist.
I have Tony book interesting thank you for this interview
Excellent interview, highly informative. Tony Greenstein's book is a mine of information and an indispensable corrective to the many myths surrounding Zionism, Israel itself, to the separation of what is horrifically, historically true of the Judeocide (Holocaust) itself from the ways in which it has been instrumentalised for western political purposes. One of the main things in the interview was to contextualise, and rightly debunk, the myth that Israel exists to keep Jews safe in the world. Tony cites historical examples, but even without those, anyone can see that Israel, because of the way it has structured itself as oppression against other peoples within its borders, is surely the least place on the planet for Jews to be safe. I too was brought up to believe in the historical "necessity" of the Jewish state, and it was a very long and, to be honest, often difficult journey to be rid of those false beliefs, historical distortions and not least, the unconscious racism inherent in the Zionist project. One of Rania's phrases has stuck with me but forgive me if I misquote her (from memory), "Israel is American's weapon in the middle east", ie it's not "ITWAD" (to quote Moshé Machover), Israeli Tail Wags American Dog, it's not Israel, or Zionists, or Jews "controlling" USA policy, the policy comes from western imperial capitalism, the northern hemisphere (largely) ideology terrified of the slightest threat to its hegemony from the (largely) global South. Personally speaking, as everyone knows or should do, Israel claims to speak and act on behalf of, and in the interests of, all Jews everywhere on the planet and if we don't repudiate that dangerous propaganda, we're complicit. People of good will who might not be well informed as to the reality may be inclined to take Israel at its word with the result that some may be misled into accusing all Jews of involvement in Israel's crimes. When that happens, then we have to follow the logic, Israel itself provokes and amplifies antisemitism, which, as the late Irish statesman Conor Cruise O'Brien once called 'A very light sleeper', all too easy to wake up no matter how long it's been quiescent.
The late Israeli writer and activist Akiva Orr wrote a book he titled, The UN-Jewish State, surely in conscious echo of Theodor Herzl's The Jewish State. If you look at the best of the ethical tradition in Judaism, not the parts of the Hebrew Bible which Netanyahu and his fascist colleagues like to quote, but the Prophets and the universalist writings in Rabbinic Judaism, you'll easily see that how Israel has behaved for 75 years provides all the evidence you need to invalidate Israel's self-description. And we Jews need to stop that tendency to think of ourselves as forever victims, which can make us seem to hallucinate bogus antisemitism wherever we look (there's more than enough of the real thing still in the world without needing to manufacture more of it).
Great interview, thanks so much for posting it, both.
Yahod is the ward in Arabic for Jewish . Yahood means Jewish in Arabic
Star of David is a swastika
The Belfour Declaration. ......
"Israel was not founded because of the Holocaust" you said. Are you sure the Zionists did not use the Holocaust at all in 1948 to obtain UN recognition of the State of Israel?
pretty sure. If you listen to Hitler or Goebbels, you'll see that it was all a plan from long before ww2. Also, you NEED to look into the "holocaust" criticisms on actual free speech platforms.
They used money.
do you mean the Human Skin Lamp Shades and Human Fat Soap stories, as well as a PLETHORA OF OTHER SHAMELESS LIES BEYOND WHICH YOU'RE ABLE TO CONCEIVE due to your inability to understand the depth and BREADTH of depravity of human sociopathy? Yes, they used the, cough, holocaust to obtain what they wanted. There's a reason, though, why the stories that we hear today weren't widely disseminated in the NYT before 1965, and it's a cynical reason. A very cynical reality. a 9-11-esque reality. a USS-Liberty-esque reality.
@@b1crusade384 Of course. But the Zionists were having trouble building up thier population in Palestine; they needed to create a majority by influx of people and expulsion of the Palestinians. Surely, the Holocaust was used to encourage Jews to move to Palestine in the last moments of 1945-1948.
do you mean the Human Skin Lamp Shades and Human Fat Soap stories, as well as a PLETHORA OF OTHER SHAMELESS cough, uh, truths, BEYOND WHICH YOU'RE ABLE TO CONCEIVE due to your inability to understand the depth and BREADTH of depravity of human sociopathy? Yes, they used the, ack-cough, holocaust, to obtain what they wanted. There's a reason, though, why the stories that we hear today weren't widely disseminated in the NYT before 1965, and it's a cynical reason. A very cynical reality. a 9-11-esque reality. a USS-Liberty-esque reality.
Eff Hillsdale College
Why havent the children of Gaza been evacuated?
They are there to expand the Arab population to another billion who knows what zi is about
By whom.There are nearly a million of them. 😮
Savon is the French word for soap. Rania said it was the Hebrew word for soap. I don’t know Hebrew. Are we both right?😊
It’s so refreshing to finally find a channel that is purely about opinion and nothing to do with presenting facts.
Tony also believes that antisemitism exists and nobody knows why and dismisses the possibility that group behavior could be a factor. He is a good man but cannot escape his conditioning.
Can anyone send me the map of Palestine in the 18s? I want the map the pro Palestinian activist talk about, that looks like a corn icecream , i want that map in the 18s
I like Tony, but why he bashes Kasztner at every opportunity I don't know. That whole case is not as simple as he makes out. You think he's going to get through his rambling speeches without mentioning it, but then, no, here we go - he's going to bore us all again with his ridiculous Kasztner-bashing treatises. I wish he'd just drop the topic.
'Marxist and anti fascist' lol
When Palestinian leadership promise to repeat October 7th “again and again”, you can’t disassociate it from the holocaust.
When the zi0naz1 jwsh regime and project started with supremac1st racist ideology ,everything they do is judged by that standard. For example the founder of Political Zionism, Theodor Herzl wrote in his diary in 1895,
“When we occupy the land, we shall bring immediate benefits to the state that receives us. We must expropriate gently the private property on the estates assigned to us.
We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our own country.
The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly.”
Israel Zangwill, another important political Zionist said in a talk in 1905, “(We) must be prepared either to drive out by the sword the (Arab) Tribes in possession as our forefathers did or to grapple with the problem of a large alien population, mostly Mohammedan and accustomed for centuries to despise us.”
Around 1928, Shabtai Levi, a land purchasing agent for Baron de Rothschild wrote in his memoirs, “He (the Baron) advised me to carry on in similar activities, but it is better, he said, not to transfer the Arabs to Syria and Transjordan, as these are part of the Land of Israel, but to Mesopotamia (Iraq), He added that in these cases he would be ready to send the Arabs, at his expense, new agricultural machines, and agricultural advisers.”
Around 1930, Zionist Socialist (Mapai) leader, David Hacohen wrote, “… I would not accept Arabs in my trade union, the Histadrut; to defend preaching to housewives that they not buy at Arab stores; to prevent Arab workers from getting jobs there… To pour kerosene on Arab tomatoes, to attack Jewish housewives in the markets and smash the Arab eggs they had bought; to praise to the skies the Keren Kayemet that sent Hankin to Beirut to buy land from absentee effendi (landowners) and to throw the fellahin (peasant farmers) off the land - to buy dozens of dunams - from an Arab is permitted, but sell, God forbid, one Jewish dunam to an Arab is prohibited.”
Menahem Ussishkin, chairman of the Jewish National Fund, and member of the executive of the Jewish Agency, said in a 1930 speech to journalists, “We must continually raise the demand that our land be returned to our possession … if there are other inhabitants there, they must be transferred to some other place. We must take over the land. We have a greater and nobler ideal than preserving several hundred thousands of Arab fellahin.”.a speech in July, 1938, Ben-Gurion said, “In the proposal of transferring the Arab population from the area, if it is possible voluntarily and if not by coercion, it would be possible to expand the Jewish settlement…The basic difference with the Commission proposal is that the transfer will be on a much larger scale, from the Jewish to the Arab territory;. If it were possible to transfer Arabs from one village to another within the British Mandate - it is difficult to find any political or moral argument against the transfer of these Arabs from the proposed Jewish-ruled area…. And is there any need to explain the value in a continuous Jewish Yishuv…”.
Also in July, 1938, Yosef Bankover, founding member of the Kibbutz Hameuhad movement and member of the Haganah Regional Command, said, “…as for compulsory transfer, as a member of Kibbutz Ramat Hakovesh, I would be very pleased if it would be possible to be rid of the pleasant neighbourliness of the people of Miski, Tirah and Qalqilyah.”.
Another leader of the Kibbutz Hameuhad movement, Aharon Zisling said, “I do not contest our moral right to propose population transfer. There is no moral flaw in a proposal aimed at concentrating the development of national life. On the contrary: in a new world order it can and should be a noble human vision…”.
Then in August, 1938, Berl Katznelson, a labor leader, wrote, “The matter of population transfer has provoked a debate among us: Is it permitted or forbidden? My conscience is absolutely clear in this respect. A remote neighbour is better than a close enemy. They will not lose from being transferred and we most certainly will not lose from it…. But it never crossed my mind that transfer to outside the Land of Israel would mean merely to the vicinity of Nablus, I have always believed and still believe that they were destined to be transferred to Syria or Iraq.”.
Iss he Marxist or anti marxist
Marxist
Where is the rest of the interview, you want to educate or dollar wtf!??
Daughter don't give plat form such and Diot
He and she are right. Norman Finkelstein had said the same things.