@@chaudang3749 because the current one more focused on Choreo, they are busy following choreo and the instrument without vocal is alot... They forgot that idol are singer too . But fortunately there are still group in this gen that stil lsing live, even if theres only few of them
@@Princess-je4tf 4th gen is literally just choreo. They’re all the same and it gets boring. Plus in 2nd gen they look like they’re actually having fun.
they killed it on stage!!! dancing was so energetic and their vocals were strong as well!! kara's discography is so iconic, they're still mega bops in 2022
too bad the most popular girls in Korea nowadays fail to create great stage like this and only act cute and pretty without any effort to sing and improve KARA is one of idols who never lip sync no matter what circumstances are (good news is many of idols in this new generation never lip sync, ex : their own sister April). However, the most popular group with easier choreograph than Kara cannot sing live and rely much on backtrack therefore their vocal quality will be always questioned. I'm sure they cannot do something like this without lip sync unless they show dramatic improvement (I doubt they have will to do it) I found them late and I love how Seungyeon keep dancing during her injury. This group need to reunite in the near future
And i also like that the idols of that time were not starved in the same extreme way like now. They look so amazing: fit and healthy. And no crazy haircolours.
Still remember this as my first introduction to kpop things, keep this on repeat and they made me know more about kpop…its been 14 years since that moment😅 So much love for you kara❤ 2024 and they slaying it 🔥 Hara you will always be missed🤍
Man I missed when they actually sang Live and you could appreciate the mics being booped but you know they were singing for real. I understand though that in this era the backtrack is heavy cause the choreographies are more complicated and requires so much more energy and back then when they sang live their dance were a little more subtle conserving breath for singing. Oh well
@@oncewithtwice it's been 2 years i don't remember, could have came on automatically while I was just watching youtube while doing something, or I wanted to give it another chance as sometimes I do end up liking old songs I didn't like at first.
i still remember how i used to listen to all kpop grps when i was a teenager that was so cute lol kara was one of my fav girl grps too they were so amazing i'm so sad to what happened to go hara 💔 i also think that all the girl grps of second generation kpop are way too talented than those grps of nowadays....
Its funny I'm kind of sympathetic to the concept of "" the old k pop" but I can't put my finger on where old ends and new starts. I still listen to T'ara quite a bit and I remember and enjoyed Girls Generation dominating the views, sales and hits and I sort of feel that when Girls Generation, Kara and Tara finished many of us moved on. Hara was very beautiful and there's a few Hara versions of Kara's Step. I'm still a little obsessed with Hyomin from Tara she wasn't the prettiest in the group but I really liked her.
I would pin point the start of 3rd gen with exo and red velvets debuts. That's when the sound and everything in kpop started to change and the groups that once dominated e.g: wonder girls, kara, fx, sistar, snsd, 2ne1, Tara, Brown eyed girls, miss a, big bang, shinee, super junior, 2pm, beast/highlight all slowed down activities or there members started doing solo stuff, plus 2013/14/15/16 was the year all the kpop groups that are big now started to debut. But I definitely understand what you mean, I would say where entering the 2nd phase of 3rd gen with the debut of ITZY, stray kidz, ATEEZ, ab6ix everglow, bvndit and txt being the most prominent groups. So this phase i would compare to when 2ne1, fx, sistar 4minute, t-Ara and miss a debut, and followed in the footsteps of wonder girls, kara and snsd.
2nd top 5 fav 1. Kara 2. WG 3. SNSD 4. 2NE1 5. Miss A u cant replace them, i love their carchy song tho they tried to do girlcrush concept since it was trend but Kara was the best for me 3gen top 5 fav 1. OMG 2. BP 3. IOI 4. RV 5. Elris 4th gen top 5 1. LOONA 2. WOO!AH!
After Sunghee left, Hara and Jiyoung joined in 2008. Then in 2014 Nicole and Jiyoung left the group. There was then a show called "The KARA Project" where girls competed to be the next new member of KARA, that's when Youngji won came into the group. Hope that answers any questions you had.
I miss the times when groups ACTUALLY SANG LIVE and the backtrack was only for harmonies and effects.
Me too me too, i can’t stand watching the lack of singing in 3rd gen kpop
@@chaudang3749 because the current one more focused on Choreo, they are busy following choreo and the instrument without vocal is alot... They forgot that idol are singer too . But fortunately there are still group in this gen that stil lsing live, even if theres only few of them
@@chaudang3749 4th gen is even worse
@@Princess-je4tf 4th gen is literally just choreo. They’re all the same and it gets boring. Plus in 2nd gen they look like they’re actually having fun.
@@tofu9069 Yeo and they are becoming more American it’s not even kpop anymore
라이브 잘한다…루팡이 카라랑 정말 잘 어울리는 곡인 것 같음 숏컷도 미쳤고 춤 빡센 것도 노래랑 찰떡
Ugghhhh back when K-pop had a unique taste in EVERYTHING.
From song, choreography, fashion/outfits.
KARA 4EVER !!! NICOLE FIGHTING !
these girls deserve more for singing live than today's kpop girl groups
You can tell they are singing live bc one of the girls tapped the mic and it was clear, they didn’t need backtrack periodt
Back when members had their own looks. Boy and girl groups.
Goo Hara is such a visual I miss her
카라 외모때문에 지금까지 몰랏는데 노래진짜잘했구나..
승연 누나가. 열심히했다는게. 넘멋있고 이쁘다 승연누나는. 뭘해도. 잘할뜻 진심
2nd Generation Girl Groups are definitely lit. Even though I have my bias. Still they are all really good.
they killed it on stage!!! dancing was so energetic and their vocals were strong as well!! kara's discography is so iconic, they're still mega bops in 2022
Still in 2024. Just slayed 5th Karasia tour.
I missed old kpop 😫
too bad the most popular girls in Korea nowadays fail to create great stage like this and only act cute and pretty without any effort to sing and improve
KARA is one of idols who never lip sync no matter what circumstances are (good news is many of idols in this new generation never lip sync, ex : their own sister April). However, the most popular group with easier choreograph than Kara cannot sing live and rely much on backtrack therefore their vocal quality will be always questioned. I'm sure they cannot do something like this without lip sync unless they show dramatic improvement (I doubt they have will to do it)
I found them late and I love how Seungyeon keep dancing during her injury. This group need to reunite in the near future
they will in the future
Kara at their COOLEST is in Lupin era
And i also like that the idols of that time were not starved in the same extreme way like now. They look so amazing: fit and healthy. And no crazy haircolours.
구하라 너무 멋지고 예쁘다...... ㅠㅠ
I miss the old kpop I miss Kara and t-ara and f(x) and snsd and wg and secret and after school
black eyes and Sistar
Me too😢
Me too, i love kara n snsd so much
Miss A & WG 😭
we all do sis
Idols today could never!!
ルパンの時は特にハラちゃんとニコルかっこいいな！！！
ハラちゃん…
Used to be biggest kpop group back then.
전설의 그룹 컴백을 축하합니다.!! 현제는 2022 12월
Kara how dare you disband before I could see you live
SNSD, T-ara, KARA, After School (Orange Caramel), WG, BEG are the best kpop GG. They are mostly all rounder - Singing, variety, acting, modeling.
dont forget 2ne1
@@Unknown-gc8ogI LOVED THEM ALSO
Sistar was good too
i still love it! i miss hara's hair flip tho.
I MISS YOU KARA
I miss the look too
I CANT FIND A BETTER LIVE...
KARA ALWAYS ROCK THE STAGE
The fanchants🔥🔥
Not gonna forget them never.
Always queens! KARA🙏
ร้องสด เต้นสู้ตายมากกก สมัยนั้นวงไหนลิปซิ้งคือบ้งนะพูดเลย
I love that all of them look freaking gorgeous
They had pretty faces and amazing bodies
Still remember this as my first introduction to kpop things, keep this on repeat and they made me know more about kpop…its been 14 years since that moment😅 So much love for you kara❤ 2024 and they slaying it 🔥 Hara you will always be missed🤍
This was my jam 💜💜 Gyuri my forever goddess!!
Man I missed when they actually sang Live and you could appreciate the mics being booped but you know they were singing for real.
I understand though that in this era the backtrack is heavy cause the choreographies are more complicated and requires so much more energy and back then when they sang live their dance were a little more subtle conserving breath for singing. Oh well
懐かしい。。
ハラちゃん大好きだよ❤
Rip goo hara :"(
No
Dwonne Nicole what??
@@aftathebloom she committed suicide November 2019. So sad.
I miss KARA.
This is Kpop ♡
この頃のKARAが最高✨✨
I never liked this song so I never watched a live and honestly still don't but these fits!! They killed it! They slayed this concept
So why are you watching this if you don’t like the song? Genuine question.
@@oncewithtwice it's been 2 years i don't remember, could have came on automatically while I was just watching youtube while doing something, or I wanted to give it another chance as sometimes I do end up liking old songs I didn't like at first.
@@zabe3187 Oh ok, that makes sense
i still remember how i used to listen to all kpop grps when i was a teenager that was so cute lol kara was one of my fav girl grps too they were so amazing i'm so sad to what happened to go hara 💔 i also think that all the girl grps of second generation kpop are way too talented than those grps of nowadays....
It’s 2021 and this song is still a banger🤩
Omg! I miss this era! ❤ :')
We miss you Hara ♥♥
Tbh I clicked for the holo outfits and stayed because the song is a bop
Its funny I'm kind of sympathetic to the concept of "" the old k pop" but I can't put my finger on where old ends and new starts. I still listen to T'ara quite a bit and I remember and enjoyed Girls Generation dominating the views, sales and hits and I sort of feel that when Girls Generation, Kara and Tara finished many of us moved on. Hara was very beautiful and there's a few Hara versions of Kara's Step. I'm still a little obsessed with Hyomin from Tara she wasn't the prettiest in the group but I really liked her.
I would pin point the start of 3rd gen with exo and red velvets debuts. That's when the sound and everything in kpop started to change and the groups that once dominated e.g: wonder girls, kara, fx, sistar, snsd, 2ne1, Tara, Brown eyed girls, miss a, big bang, shinee, super junior, 2pm, beast/highlight all slowed down activities or there members started doing solo stuff, plus 2013/14/15/16 was the year all the kpop groups that are big now started to debut. But I definitely understand what you mean, I would say where entering the 2nd phase of 3rd gen with the debut of ITZY, stray kidz, ATEEZ, ab6ix everglow, bvndit and txt being the most prominent groups. So this phase i would compare to when 2ne1, fx, sistar 4minute, t-Ara and miss a debut, and followed in the footsteps of wonder girls, kara and snsd.
진짜 이쁜 여전사들 같다...
I love it, I will remember them forever 🥰
RIP Hara🖤
I wanna tell my friend who watched About Time that Mika's bestfriend is here..missed them OT5
2nd top 5 fav
1. Kara
2. WG
3. SNSD
4. 2NE1
5. Miss A
u cant replace them, i love their carchy song tho they tried to do girlcrush concept since it was trend but Kara was the best for me
3gen top 5 fav
1. OMG
2. BP
3. IOI
4. RV
5. Elris
4th gen top 5
1. LOONA
2. WOO!AH!
Same taste..cool
2020 here..i miss Kara
NO CUZ HOW AM I JUST FINDING THIS I LOVE THIS THEY'RE MY FAV IDC😭❤
Hopefully, you will enjoy their comeback very soon!
과거로 돌아갈수 있다면... 그놈 만나는걸 막아야 한다..........
Love kara😭😭😭
Goo Hara 😭😭😭
The KPOP best time ( for me )
This is the best version of kara, forget youngji. This is version I want to come back when it's time.
Exactly.
Esta fue la mas grande epoca del KPOP
No puedo creer que hay muerto 😪😪😪😫😫 HARa por que lo hiciste
スンヨンちゃん可愛い//
so sexy so cool so pretty the outfits the make up everything fine 😻💖😳😔💕
하라 보고싶당 ㅜ ....
They were amazing
꼬꼬무에 한승연 나와서 오랜만에 카라 동영상 보고 싶어서 보고 있던 중에 구하라가 더 눈에 들어오네 악플만 아니면 정말 오래 활동했을텐데... 다시 한 번 명복을 빌게요
素晴らしい
Not seen this yet, thank for recommendation youtube
Love KARA 💋💋💋💋💋🙏
Miss them
have you ever thought that this is the og girl crush/badass concept (if i'm mistaken please kindly correct me)
nobody does it like they did
Kara5 !
I need solo fancam and group full performance cam
Nice Song
Beautiful ladies 😍👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
여전히 귀엽넹
Watching this August 2021
One of my favesss 😭😭
KARA.... 😊..❤️)
The memories🙏
El mejor video.que ví 🤗🤗🤗🤗
좋아요~
제2이효리가 될수있는 하라씨보고시프네요
💖
💐💐💚💚🌷🌷
KARA
watching it in 2022
Still amazing in 2023
My girls!!
의상 화려한거 보소
2024 in here
Samee haha 9 mins ago
Any viewers 2020?
Where are u from?
hi 🙋
#RIPHARA
Rip goo hara
miss
하라가 짐살아있다면 솔로해도 크게성공할텐데 이정현이나 이효리 아이유처럼
KARA♡
Who's the other girl? Other than Gyuri, Hara, Youngji, and Seungyeon
Youngji isn't there. 0:35 is Jiyoung, 0:42 is Nicole.
+miah Oh so when they recruited new members...Youngji was the only one...?
After Sunghee left, Hara and Jiyoung joined in 2008. Then in 2014 Nicole and Jiyoung left the group. There was then a show called "The KARA Project" where girls competed to be the next new member of KARA, that's when Youngji won came into the group. Hope that answers any questions you had.
Avery Warren nicole
Jiyoung
박규리ㆍ한승연ㆍ니콜ㆍ구하라ㆍ 한명몰라ㅋㅋ 아무튼 노래 ㅎ^^😊
강지영이에요 ㅋㅋ
연예인음반발매:발성연륜소리역량감정(인간이겪을법한'인생사'가 노랫소리로 들을수 있었다)
ㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡㅡ
시청자초본주소:안전환경가정주민사람(우리가겪을법한'세상사'가 지문기계로 뽑을수 있었다)
♥시청자초본주소김종열♥
2:23
2021 :(
2021
what happen to them now?
They're rich & own expensive buildings i seoul.