You're right! I love, perversely, the imperfections, it means you're really hearing their voices, not the "perfected" over-processed audio track I've heard a hundred times. You go girls! :)
내가 볼땐 나나는 라이브 상태 최곤데.. 저렇게 뛰면서 저정도로 안정적으로 소화해낼 수 있는 아이돌이 어디 있지? 우연히 듣고 너무 잘해서 깜놀ㅋㅋ 방콕시티 컴백무대에 비교하면 호흡도 잘 계산해서 후반까지 한부분도 놓치지 않고 잘하고 있구만... 이 곡의 젤 웃긴 부분은 00:47 나나 머리 마구 흔드는 안무 끝나자 마자 보컬이 또 주어진다는 건데.. 이 얼마나 멍청한 안무냐.. 안무 진짜 무식하게 했네.. 이 방송국도 진짜 무시무시하구만.. 마이크에 아무 음향효과도 안주고 생짜로 부르게 하다니... 뭔가 오캬가 당한 느낌ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I like it when they;re not done up in crazy costumes with crazy wigs. I really like it when they're like this, especially Nana. Hot damn I love her look!
This is how u guys hold live performance mic with choreo (disclaimer: not with that crazy choreo nowadays ok, ) you will out of breath and some means type will appear saying u guys can't sing, can't hold fart when hitting high note etc. Crazy right.
At least they didn't lip-synch this and chose to sing live... and by the looks of their faces they needed a break, so get off their backs -__- there's many different live-versions of this track.
It's interesting to hear that Nana is the most reliable live singer of the trio, at least in this performance. While her range isn't the best, her vocals never flatlined and remained pleasantly clear. Maybe Raina was just worn out?
It's kind of curious how there's a lot of kpop songs inspired by 90's eurodance. This track wouldn't be out of place in a Whigfield record for example. Europop for the pleasure of a new generation.
wow...i finally get to hear nana's voice live...she actually doesn't sound that bad - why does she keep lipsynching on some of her other perfs then? :(
Gracias Oh hye rin In Jin ah y Lizzy por regalarnos esta lindura y superarse asi mismas y poder deleitarnos con su presentación. bla bla parezco acosador jijijiji
Y por mas que busque dentro de los grupos kpop más bellas que ellas no las encontre solo orange caramel lo mejor de Corea disculpen es que las veo asi.
disculpame kader de Benn afett, xochilt Gomez, Alizze, Selena Gomez pero las bellezas de corea son mas bonitas. tambien disculpen mis группа "Подиум" pero las coreanas son mas bellas ...❣ILove you orange caramel
I am still shocked that Nana was once listed as one of the worst singers in K-Pop. She sounds REALLY good here, even better than Raina and Lizzy in this specific performance actually.
![[HD] 110602 Orange Caramel - Bangkok City (LIVE)](/img/1.gif)
it is already rare to see kpop live that isnt playback, and this was great :D
You're right! I love, perversely, the imperfections, it means you're really hearing their voices, not the "perfected" over-processed audio track I've heard a hundred times. You go girls! :)
IKRRR😊
춤추면서 라이브도 잘하네 완전짱이다
내가 볼땐 나나는 라이브 상태 최곤데.. 저렇게 뛰면서 저정도로 안정적으로 소화해낼 수 있는 아이돌이 어디 있지? 우연히 듣고 너무 잘해서 깜놀ㅋㅋ 방콕시티 컴백무대에 비교하면 호흡도 잘 계산해서 후반까지 한부분도 놓치지 않고 잘하고 있구만... 이 곡의 젤 웃긴 부분은 00:47 나나 머리 마구 흔드는 안무 끝나자 마자 보컬이 또 주어진다는 건데.. 이 얼마나 멍청한 안무냐.. 안무 진짜 무식하게 했네.. 이 방송국도 진짜 무시무시하구만.. 마이크에 아무 음향효과도 안주고 생짜로 부르게 하다니... 뭔가 오캬가 당한 느낌ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
yj h ㅇㅇ
ㅇ
어디있냐구? 빌보드에 있잖아 BTS!
BTS 춤추면서 라이브하는 무대보고오자 bts앨런쇼 쳐봐 바로나오니까 못찾겠다 드립치지말구~
Omg this is a pure live with music volume so low, they did really well in singing !!
IKRR
I like it when they;re not done up in crazy costumes with crazy wigs. I really like it when they're like this, especially Nana. Hot damn I love her look!
Their best song
nana looks good tan
They all sounded pretty good live
nana's vocals sounds good here..
Raina hair is pure WIN!
Lizzy and raina looked and sounded like they both are gonna pass out any minute!
Sad but true.
so true :(
*어른들이 더 많이 보는 프로그램이라고 오렌지 캬라멜 역사상 가장 평범하게 옷 입혀서 보냈네*
나나 너무 좋다ㅠㅠ
omy raina is so pretty here
awww love you Lizzy!
This is how u guys hold live performance mic with choreo (disclaimer: not with that crazy choreo nowadays ok, ) you will out of breath and some means type will appear saying u guys can't sing, can't hold fart when hitting high note etc. Crazy right.
Nanaaaa and rainaaa ♥
헐 그냥 생라이브네
At least they didn't lip-synch this and chose to sing live... and by the looks of their faces they needed a break, so get off their backs -__-
there's many different live-versions of this track.
Nana es perfecta ...OMG!!!
라이브쩐다
if i was in the audience i would not be sitting haha, love these girls
Orange Caramel
luv they
Orange caramel 09-01-2022 Raina Nana and Lizzy
que linda musica
@HeroSavage I agree! When I saw Raina sings at 0:54, she can't hold her breathe like she do. x_x
raina is so freakin pretty
and sexy
Don't blame other singers!!!!!!
I love OC and GsD!!!
0:08 is Nana
0:19 is Lizzy
0:24 is Raina
they sound off key and are almost sleeping and still better than other girls group i've seen
edit: I was such a hater at 16
lmfaoaooao
It's interesting to hear that Nana is the most reliable live singer of the trio, at least in this performance. While her range isn't the best, her vocals never flatlined and remained pleasantly clear. Maybe Raina was just worn out?
Raina was so tired
Damn ads........
AHH! SARANGHAE NANA
It's kind of curious how there's a lot of kpop songs inspired by 90's eurodance. This track wouldn't be out of place in a Whigfield record for example. Europop for the pleasure of a new generation.
orange caramel needed a break especially raina and lizzy
@SoshiJuNiOrx3 it's supposed to it's them singing without there voices tweaked a little
Rainaaa!
so cut
Nana
They look so tired with all the non-stop promoting (they were even promoting for After School at the time) This makes me really sad as a fan :-(
So crazy, Lizzy and Raina really make me laugh !!!
lizzy!!!
wow...i finally get to hear nana's voice live...she actually doesn't sound that bad - why does she keep lipsynching on some of her other perfs then? :(
Disculpenme por las mujeres del mundo pero estas tres son las más bellas del mundo que hermosas mmmm....
Gracias Oh hye rin In Jin ah y Lizzy por regalarnos esta lindura y superarse asi mismas y poder deleitarnos con su presentación. bla bla parezco acosador jijijiji
Y por mas que busque dentro de los grupos kpop más bellas que ellas no las encontre solo orange caramel lo mejor de Corea disculpen es que las veo asi.
disculpame kader de Benn afett, xochilt Gomez, Alizze, Selena Gomez pero las bellezas de corea son mas bonitas. tambien disculpen mis группа "Подиум" pero las coreanas son mas bellas ...❣ILove you orange caramel
무대자체가 존니썩었다 가요쇼는반성해랔
Lizzy beautiful
NANA!!!!
@HeroSavage No i didnt mean it like that he or she was saying they dont sound like the recorded version.
😁😁😁
Lizzy
Nana
Nana worst singer?! Omg have they heard Girls Day Hyeri's voice .-. Anyways love orange caramel and this song (:
😍👍👍
Raina
lol i saw the infinite version and i think sungjong is supposed to be nana,sungyeol is rania and L is Lizzy lol
I was hoping for a better live...
Lizzy
Hermosas las 3 only said
I like AS but I love OC :D
Lizzy!
Nana..
RAINAAAAAAAAAAAA
Tbh it's awkward when Raina is doing the yeah yeah yeah thing cause no one is singing chorus and what sake for thr adlib? 😂
no she do adlibs like extended version for this version. you must hear it b4. thx
NANA THE BEST..*W*
レイナ れいな レイナ れいな! reina
リジ りじ リジ りじ リジ！ rizzy
なな ナナ なな ナナ なな！ nana
Lizzy
nana~~
NANA!!!!!!!
Sounds like a backyard party
lizzy is the best...
nanaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!
Lizzyyyyy
She's just really soft and the backing music blocks her out :\
lizzy!
NANA!!!
They look so tired...
Lizzy^^
Mi Raintaro mi dientes de lata
the reason they sound bad in this one compared to others is they don't have earpieces here compared to the other preformance
They sound so tired
I am still shocked that Nana was once listed as one of the worst singers in K-Pop. She sounds REALLY good here, even better than Raina and Lizzy in this specific performance actually.
They all looked so tired
Lizzy (L)
@breadeoneq Yeah man you bet she is. I think Nana is the hottest member of After School. For sure.
I bet they were really tired.
They look tired. Deserve a break.
Is rainy drunk?
they just tired
lizzy
lizzy... again :)
Rainaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa :X :X :X
Raina is DRUNk :))))
헐 노래 왜 이렇게 못해;;
Gloria ㅋㅋ 님 노래 저렇게 불러봐요 못하다니 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 참..