One can hardly ever see the men and women by which history turns. A single turkish soldiers from far outside his nation's heartland would redefine a state that had existed for 500 years into a country that, for all its shakes and stumbles, still persists to our modern day. Here's hoping it need no more dictators though.
look at the ones who dare to call him traitor: either live in self titled religious countries which are corruption-ridden, in civil war or under foreign occupation.. or call themselves ottoman lovers but actully their grandparets the ones who betray ottomans during ww1, siding by brits & french with the delusion of freedom & indepence from ottoman with european help.. as a turk i pray for his soul everyday, thanks to him we live in a modern country, even with swifting politics of today, his reforms give us a space to breath, keeping us one step ahead from rest of the middle east.
We Turks don’t even care what pan-islamist say about Atatürk. He was Saviour of Turkey and Ottoman who defeated hyperpowers and superpowers in Gallipoli and other places.
I am from Bangladesh, I am right wing Muslim myself. But I respect him because he did fought for his country. He saved his country and is a national hero of Turkey which is a friend my country. So I respect him. I don't agree with his religious reforms myself
@@LEO-tm1ck u should read General Patton's report on gallipoli campaing. there you can clearly see Mustafa Kemal made the right decisions at the right time and changed the course of the battle. Their supperiors had to gave him the command of all the forces at some point to push the enemy back. its all written in history. you can keep farting here noones gives a shit.
@@LEO-tm1ck Falkenhayn was a poor and decaying old man and von Sanders could hardly defend his own ass. Know your history before you speak or in your case don’t talk at all at the account of your severe lack of intelligence
bruh there are too many disulissoned arabs or greeks under this comment section. Calling him jew or traitor HAHAHAHA. Just because of a Man of Turk decide to pave a road for his own people for benefits of Turkish that does not mean he was bad person. Ottoman empire was not a utopia like those in trt1 film series.He is a HERO and Always will be !
His father was Jewish and he lived as a member of freemasons, brother. When Kemal Ataturk Recited Shema Yisrael: 'It's My Secret Prayer, Too,'. He Confessed ZICHRON YAAKOV -- There were two questions I wanted to ask, I said over the phone to Batya Keinan, spokeswoman for Israeli president Ezer Weizman, who was about to leave the next day, Monday, Jan. 24, on the first visit ever made to Turkey by a Jewish chief of state. One was whether Mr. Weizman would be taking part in an official ceremony commemorating Kemal Ataturk. Ms. Kenan checked the president's itinerary, according to which he and his wife would lay a wreath on Ataturk's ... Excited and Distressed I thanked her and hung up. A few minutes later it occurred to me to call back and ask whether President Weizman intended to make any reference while in Turkey to Ataturk's Jewish antecedents. "I'm so glad you called again," said Ms. Kenan, who now sounded excited and a bit distressed. "Exactly where did you get your information from?" Why was she asking, I countered, if the president's office had it too? Because it did not, she confessed. She had only assumed that it must because I had sounded so matter-of-fact myself. "After you hung up," she said, "I mentioned what you told me and nobody here knows anything about it. Could you please fax us what you know?" I faxed her a short version of it. Here is a longer one. Stories about the Jewishness of Ataturk, whose statue stands in the main square of every town and city in Turkey, already circulated in his lifetime but were denied by him and his family and never taken seriously by biographers. Of six biographies of him that I consulted this week, none even mentions such a speculation. The only scholarly reference to it in print that I could find was in the entry on Ataturk in the Israeli Entsiklopedya ha-Ivrit, which begins: "Mustafa Kemal Ataturk - (1881-1938), Turkish general and statesman and founder of the modern Turkish state. "Mustafa Kemal was born to the family of a minor customs clerk in Salonika and lost his father when he was young. There is no proof of the belief, widespread among both Jews and Muslims in Turkey, that his family came from the Doenme. As a boy he rebelled against his mother's desire to give him a traditional religious education, and at the age of 12 he was sent at his demand to study in a military academy." You can look into the freemason records and find him as a member of them
@@cenktuneygok8986 he was a freemason, literally no one knows what his intention were, one thing is undeniable however, and it's that I've provided undeniable evidence, both from his parents, his language and background, that he was Jewish, what he wanted would've without any doubt been a country that supports the west, and by default Israel
@@cenktuneygok8986 because they were all supported by France to divide the islamic world The first Arabian nationalist wasn’t an arab he was from Armenia The first iranian nationalist was Reza Shah he wasn’t an Iranian he was from the Caucasus Even in Europe hitler was an austrian and stalin too was not from Russia he was from Caucasus
@@emrekarsidag188 the only brainwashed person here is you. This is why Turks today are known for their close minded stupidity today which all of europe laughs at. A sultan/caliph is not someone who is under house arrest and is forced to be quiet by pashas right? So then how do you attribute such a big title to an important person who is behind closed doors?? So the period from the young Turk revolution 1908 till the formal end of the empire in 1922 there was no caliph nor sultan, because their powers not only were diminished but also only became puppets whom the young Turks chose. By 1924 when it was formally abolished , it was already dead. And so the reason why I say Abdulhamid was the last true caliph is because not only did he have the direct power and prestige but also had to the support of millions of Muslims around the world. The state collapsed 10 years after his dethronement by ittihat ve terraki. Happy with yo response?
One should also keep in my mind that he didn't call himself "The father of Turks". It was his people, the Turks who called him by that name. You may disagree with his rule and ideas if you wish but he was and still is one of our greatest historic heroes.
@@historycinematics8985 I live in Turkiye. My grandfathers and their ancestors before them have stories from that time. It is you foreign Islamists who would be disappointed if you were living in the Ottoman empire during its ending years as it wasn't exactly an utopia as some of you think. Unless you're from Turkiye, all you know about Atatürk is what you read from some book somewhere. We lived it and our relatives taught us much about those times. Even Turkish conservative Muslim people respect him because he was the general that lead the Turkish army against the invaders (the european superpowers) and saved the Turkish nation from colonialism and slavery.
@@tolgacetin2799 lol even religious type leaders like Erdoğan respect him. Because he is a leader who fought for his country. I am pan Islamist myself. I disagree with his religious policy. But I respect him for his contribution to his country.
@@sebresludolf9611 sure mate you can disagree with his policies regarding matters of religion. I as a Muslim don't fully agree with him on all terms either but from a Turkish point of view he was the hero that came at our darkest hour and we cherish his memory for it.
@@tolgacetin2799 exactly. He is a complicated character in world history. Truly a hero who defended his nation from foreign rule, but a person who took several religious freedom away, introduced wrong policy regarding religion. But I believe Muslims of other countries should respect him. He is national hero of a fellow Muslim country. My country of Bangladesh has good relation with Turkey. In my country nobody likes his religious policy, some hate him for his abolition of the Caliphate. But we all do respect him for his contribution in the liberation of Turkey. We respect him because, he is national figure of Turkey a friend country of ours.
Very interesting. The Turks owe this man a lot for keeping their independence. The world would look a lot different if Istanbul had fallen to western powers.
@@girdharsingh4287 they mostly despise him and highly dislike him due to the Population Exchange and the Deportation of Remaining greeks from Asia Minor
The Soviet Union also helped Ataturk even though he was a nationalist. The Soviets lent weapons and generals to help the Turks. In fact, the Tsar planned on taking Constantinople and becoming emperor after World War 1 but the Russian Revolution put a stop to that.
This is nonesense. Nobody owes nothing to this man. Him and his men tried to remove Islam from Turkey, changed alphabet to dressing code, hanged and killed many scholars, copied everything from the West while people themselves already have a great history and culture and everything. Let me ask you a question. When these Young Turks took over the power established their congress in Ankara against the Sultan. WHY suddenly ALL the western powers recognized him? And when westerners occupied Istanbul, why they left without even firing single shot and gave everything to Mustafa Kemal and his man? They must have done some agreements behind the door, and screwing up whole country and its people from the inside and colonize their minds. Look at current Turkey, how they left their true self and Islam (many of young people are proud to be NOT Muslim and hate Islam). Now this is the only thing people should be thankful to him (or cursing him depending on person's position), destroying a country with full of history and culture, and trying to destroy Islam and raising generations without the deen and akhlaq.
Yeah many thanks for giving us naked beaches. Atleast 10× f*** girl before marriage . Legal Wine . And to live in a relationship without any marriage. Morally made our society very strong. Bars are everywhere. Thanks MKA
I'm a Mexican (living in Mexico) and even I know who Mustafa Kemal Ataturk is and even I know he was no Hebrew (lolwtf). Regards to all Turkish patriots from Mexico!
Thank you very much with this valuable information that is helping me understand the Turkish way of life a pray that Türkiye will forever flourish my only thing is that I would love to speak the Turkish language
Please invest in social media management. Your channel is criminally under subscribe where so many pop history channels thrive. I wish you all the best.
Ataturk committed the greatest theft and act of treason possible: the theft of an entire identity. Ataturk banned everything the Turks had ever known and forcefully made them follow everything Europe did. He eliminated Turkish culture, heritage, Islam, and everything that is of importance in life. Many were oppressed during this period and women could no longer were scarves or veils, men could no longer allowed to wear the Fez hat and were basically forced to abandon their traditional, already Westernized Turkish clothing and made to wear European clothes instead. He made it a crime to recite the Athan and pray the prayer in Arabic. He replaced possible unity in the Islamic world with extreme nationalism. He did countless acts of tyranny but if I’d name them all the list would take forever. Now yes, he was a great general and leader but what does it matter? A leader does what he does for his nation. But because of Ataturk the Turkish nation no longer existed. It simply became another European wanna-be nation and till this day Europeans look down upon them and don’t accept them. Now they have no culture nor do they have an identity nor are they Europeans. I’m sure Turks’ ancestors wouldn’t be too happy about what Ataturk did to their nation.
Turkey was formerly Byzantine Istanbul citadel of Orthodox Christianity was Constantinople I can't wait for Israel to clear the Al asqa mosque and rebuild the templeThe Islamic world paying their karma From India to Spain unprovoked invasions bloodshed enslavement religious vandalism etc
8:01 How could the Bulgarian general give his daughter? Bulgaria was attacked by the Romanians and lost important lands back to Turkey. It was still the age of chivalry' Excellent video 📹
He was not soldier of Sultan. But soldier of his people and nation. Don't try to justify the traitor sultan who ran away from the country with an invader British ship...
One question to ardent Ataturk haters (not me. i also hate him, but not to the point of dedicating my life to hate him): Why won't you people villified Enver Pasha and other members of the Three Pashas for their roles in ousting Sultan Abdul Hamid II and greatly reducing his authority, failed to win wars against Italy and Balkan States, brought the Ottoman Empire to WW1 and paved the way for Armenian, Assyrian, and Greek Genocide? Are you giving him a free pass because "at least he's not destroying the caliphate"? Thanks
Enver Pasha is literally liked by no one 😂 He didn’t do anything good for the empire. He screwed them up bad and no one denies that or give him a pass for what he did. But Ataturk was a tyrant who banned religion and didn’t allow freedom of speech. Because of him Turks were forced into atheism.
@@jurtra9090 Enver Pasha paved the way to doom with good intentions just as “the way to hell is paved with good intentions.” He was a true patriot who died a martyr. He didn’t do crazy tyrannies like eradicating Kurdish culture and language or eradicating Islam and Turkish culture forcefully. Ataturk was a dictator who eradicated anything he didn’t like. Enver Pasha was incompetent but even as a pro western reformist he would never take it anywhere near that far. It’s better to have in incompetent guy who works for you rather than a brilliant guy who works against you.
When Kemal Ataturk Recited Shema Yisrael: 'It's My Secret Prayer, Too,'. He Confessed ZICHRON YAAKOV -- There were two questions I wanted to ask, I said over the phone to Batya Keinan, spokeswoman for Israeli president Ezer Weizman, who was about to leave the next day, Monday, Jan. 24, on the first visit ever made to Turkey by a Jewish chief of state. One was whether Mr. Weizman would be taking part in an official ceremony commemorating Kemal Ataturk. Ms. Kenan checked the president's itinerary, according to which he and his wife would lay a wreath on Ataturk's ... Excited and Distressed I thanked her and hung up. A few minutes later it occurred to me to call back and ask whether President Weizman intended to make any reference while in Turkey to Ataturk's Jewish antecedents. "I'm so glad you called again," said Ms. Kenan, who now sounded excited and a bit distressed. "Exactly where did you get your information from?" Why was she asking, I countered, if the president's office had it too? Because it did not, she confessed. She had only assumed that it must because I had sounded so matter-of-fact myself. "After you hung up," she said, "I mentioned what you told me and nobody here knows anything about it. Could you please fax us what you know?" I faxed her a short version of it. Here is a longer one. Stories about the Jewishness of Ataturk, whose statue stands in the main square of every town and city in Turkey, already circulated in his lifetime but were denied by him and his family and never taken seriously by biographers. Of six biographies of him that I consulted this week, none even mentions such a speculation. The only scholarly reference to it in print that I could find was in the entry on Ataturk in the Israeli Entsiklopedya ha-Ivrit, which begins: "Mustafa Kemal Ataturk - (1881-1938), Turkish general and statesman and founder of the modern Turkish state. "Mustafa Kemal was born to the family of a minor customs clerk in Salonika and lost his father when he was young. There is no proof of the belief, widespread among both Jews and Muslims in Turkey, that his family came from the Doenme. As a boy he rebelled against his mother's desire to give him a traditional religious education, and at the age of 12 he was sent at his demand to study in a military academy." You can look into the freemason records and find him as a member of them
@Müsellem-i Hayat Hayat he wasn't a freemason like your parents, your parents are either members of a joke, or they are in one of the 3 low degrees, ataturk was around the 30th and surrounded himself with 7 high degree freemasons in his career, the high degree freemasons are not freedom loving democracy supporters, they support total atheism, and their rituals are some of the most disgusting there is. Your parents are freemasons by name, a real freemason is a historical monster, Roosevelt who was a deceiving imperialist, Churchill who was agenocider in Kenya, and ataturk who was an ultra nationalist when it comes to turk-ism, going as far as to ban Arab and Kurd elements from the state and oppressing the kurds in the east, his group, the young turks, also had a hand in the armenian genocide Please educate yourself, i haven't spent years of my life reaserching these things just to have a random brother tryna teach me something, thank you
Süleyman Demerıl was a Freemason, it’s not that big of a deal honestly. What is, is that he acted against muslim interests at the time (not Arabs there’s a reason they fought him)
@@sulimanthemagnificent4893 you are ignorant and never make a dedicated reaserch, if you are a Muslim you will stand against this group wich seeks to destroy all religions including Islam
Dont care if he is atheist or muslim. Dont care if he was a good president by Turkish Standards. What im grateful for is that he was one of the factors that caused the Ottoman Empire and paved the way for the Independance of my country.
@@jurtra9090 *BECAUSE.....* 1924 Caliphate abolished. Khalifa was driven out of country without a single pai. He was purposely sent to European countries, not in a Muslim country, like Egypt, Syria etc. Traditional religious schools closed, Sheriat (Islamic Law) abolished. 1925 Dervish brotherhoods abolished. Fez outlawed by the Hat Law. Veiling of women discouraged; Western clothing for men and women encouraged. Western (Gregorian) calendar adopted. 1926 New civil, commercial, and penal codes based on European models adopted. New civil code ended Islamic polygamy and divorce by renunciation and introduced civil marriage. Millet system ended. 1928 New Turkish alphabet (modified Latin form) adopted. State declared secular ; constitutional provision establishing Islam as official religion deleted. 1933 Islamic call to worship and public readings of the Kuran required to be in Turkish rather than Arabic. In short : He was a dictator.
@@gazi8412 all these things i have no problem with. As being a dictator he was but he inherited an authorotarian heredaty sultanate he didn't inherit a democracy so in the historical and geigraphical context he didnt do anything strange.
@@gazi8412 well, at least you should understand the condition that Ataturk faced before he decided all of that Ottomans in the early 20th century was a shadow of its former self. It can't even win against the united Balkan States. For all of his wrongs, shouldn't you also blame Enver Pasha and his colleagues too?
he was not donme..not jewsih, not albanian vs.. we had his ancestors documents uop to 500 years.. he is a konyar.. his ancestors were emigrated from anatolia to macedonia for turkification the new conquered regons.. mehmed th second firstly conquered karamanoğulları includes mustafa kemals ancerstor. after mehemed coonquered macedonia. he transferred therse turks to macedonia.. this was an empirial strategy.. his ancestors had documents becasue of they were mevlevi dervishes and worked for empire..
*I am from Bangladesh, and I right wing Muslim myself. I don't like Ataturk for his moves regarding his moves against religious moves. But I respect him. Because he fought for his country, saved his nation from imperial colonial powers. He loved his country, worked and fought for it. He is a national hero of his country. That's why I respect him because he is hero of a country who is a friend of my country. I might not agree with his religious moves but I respect him for his other moves.*
Attaturk was a tyrant who forbid his nation to practice Islam. He also abolished the caliphate and spread nationalism instead. The mans screwed us up and you respect him for defending his country at the cost of the whole Islamic world. Shame
@@historycinematics8985 yes. Like I said I don't like what he did in terms of his religious policy. He will suffer for this in the afterlife. But you can't ignore the fact he saved his country from foreign occupation.
@@sebresludolf9611 He eradicated the entire Turkish identity and heritage. He didn’t save but destroyed the country. It wouldn’t make much of a difference if the British ruled over them instead of the British loving Ataturk. And what good is there in ‘saving’ a country when it’s at the cost of the entire Muslim world? He not only destroyed Turkey but so did he eradicate the caliphate, creating an order of extreme nationalism, allowing Muslims to kill each other instead of working together. The mans was a guy of no respect like you think.
Ataturk was always great he defended Constantinople and Anatolia from aggressive western powers specially greeks who dreamed to take back Constantinople and secondly ottomans at that time were useless and ataturk was not jewish this was racist thing and was insult for turks to say them jews keep in mind turks are turks .long live republic of turkey
Correction ; Mustafa kmal was brought up in ottoman empire ,educated in ottoman empire and trained by ottoman empire so he was like a servant of the ottomans and he should be thankful to ottomans because without ottomans Mustafa was nothing .
Turks have undergone a century of desislamization, secularisation and westernization; turks, for a century, have been taught a history written by powers sitting in Jewish world; I always wonder why Ataturk agreed upon a deal of the century. If one ever ponders upon it, and what took place throughout that century, everything becomes crystal clear. Jews knew that as long as Turks stand as a powerful Muslim nation the establishment Zionist colonialist Nazi regime of Pigrael would be an impossible dream. Therefore, Ottman empire had to go astray and Turks desislamized so that none stands challenging to what is happening in Muslim world. On the day of judgement, three people would be raised together: Arthur Balfour, Ataturk and Theodore Herzle ( May cursed be these three)
Turkey was formerly Byzantine Istanbul citadel of Orthodox Christianity was Constantinople I can't wait for Israel to clear the Al asqa mosque and rebuild the temple
@@historianslair4971 Forgot about the qaramaathias the ones who slaughtered Muslims at the kabbah threw the corpses into the zam zam well took the black rock from the kabbah for twenty one years and urinated on it every morning ruclips.net/video/d9FiThEJFMo/видео.html
It made me laugh after watching this video😂 Yes you can support him for it's your choice but he dared to bans teaching Quran And the right wing left wing games with the large number of supporters of this criminal praising him as he was a hero😂
I love the fact that pakis or arabs are getting obsessed with him, calling him a traitor and such as if they have a say in the matter yet during his life he never paid attention to those people or their counterparts in Turkish society,not even as he paid on a bug, while cheerfully destroying what they consider sacred and going like "Your opinions are of no consequence bitches, whine and moan all you like. I'll still have my own way no matter what." An attitude which resonates through the mindsets of modern day Turks towards these people, I must happily add.
Actually the outsiders from turkiye don’t actually understands the history of turkish people’s. If they do they would know why Ataturk is being respected all over the turkiye. Its not important always to agree with him. But he did great for turkish people’s. May Allah keep turkish people’s safe. Love from Bangladesh.
One can hardly ever see the men and women by which history turns. A single turkish soldiers from far outside his nation's heartland would redefine a state that had existed for 500 years into a country that, for all its shakes and stumbles, still persists to our modern day. Here's hoping it need no more dictators though.
Saying it doesn't need any more dictators try telling that to the current wannabe dictator Erdogan the mad.
look at the ones who dare to call him traitor: either live in self titled religious countries which are corruption-ridden, in civil war or under foreign occupation.. or call themselves ottoman lovers but actully their grandparets the ones who betray ottomans during ww1, siding by brits & french with the delusion of freedom & indepence from ottoman with european help.. as a turk i pray for his soul everyday, thanks to him we live in a modern country, even with swifting politics of today, his reforms give us a space to breath, keeping us one step ahead from rest of the middle east.
yeah man , too many stupid guys in this comment section
Or is Armenian
Es ist wahr was du Schreibst.
I hope to piss on his grave one day
@@saadshoaib901 rabid dogs are free to piss anywhere..
We Turks don’t even care what pan-islamist say about Atatürk. He was Saviour of Turkey and Ottoman who defeated hyperpowers and superpowers in Gallipoli and other places.
First experience with funny turk youtube comments. Stand tall friend
I am from Bangladesh, I am right wing Muslim myself. But I respect him because he did fought for his country. He saved his country and is a national hero of Turkey which is a friend my country. So I respect him. I don't agree with his religious reforms myself
@@Zain_Passing_By no. Right wing means being Conservative and traditionalist. It's not a European thing only.
You should talk for yourself, you don't represent all Turks.
@@turkishemir5735 He represent all Turks, you arap can disagree
He is still respected in Australia, specifically for the defense of the Dardanelles.
Liman Von Sanders and Erich Von Falkenhayn defended Dardanelles...
@@LEO-tm1ck u should read General Patton's report on gallipoli campaing. there you can clearly see Mustafa Kemal made the right decisions at the right time and changed the course of the battle. Their supperiors had to gave him the command of all the forces at some point to push the enemy back. its all written in history. you can keep farting here noones gives a shit.
@@LEO-tm1ck Falkenhayn was a poor and decaying old man and von Sanders could hardly defend his own ass. Know your history before you speak or in your case don’t talk at all at the account of your severe lack of intelligence
bruh there are too many disulissoned arabs or greeks under this comment section. Calling him jew or traitor HAHAHAHA. Just because of a Man of Turk decide to pave a road for his own people for benefits of Turkish that does not mean he was bad person. Ottoman empire was not a utopia like those in trt1 film series.He is a HERO and Always will be !
There is no single evidence for Atatürk being Jewish (lmao), Slavic or Albanian. He was from Anatolian Turkic families according to Ottoman sources.
His father was Jewish and he lived as a member of freemasons, brother.
When Kemal Ataturk Recited Shema Yisrael: 'It's My Secret Prayer, Too,'. He Confessed
ZICHRON YAAKOV -- There were two questions I wanted to ask, I said over the phone to Batya Keinan, spokeswoman for Israeli president Ezer Weizman, who was about to leave the next day, Monday, Jan. 24, on the first visit ever made to Turkey by a Jewish chief of state. One was whether Mr. Weizman would be taking part in an official ceremony commemorating Kemal Ataturk.
Ms. Kenan checked the president's itinerary, according to which he and his wife would lay a wreath on Ataturk's ...
Excited and Distressed
I thanked her and hung up. A few minutes later it occurred to me to call back and ask whether President Weizman intended to make any reference while in Turkey to Ataturk's Jewish antecedents. "I'm so glad you called again," said Ms. Kenan, who now sounded excited and a bit distressed. "Exactly where did you get your information from?"
Why was she asking, I countered, if the president's office had it too?
Because it did not, she confessed. She had only assumed that it must because I had sounded so matter-of-fact myself. "After you hung up," she said, "I mentioned what you told me and nobody here knows anything about it. Could you please fax us what you know?"
I faxed her a short version of it. Here is a longer one.
Stories about the Jewishness of Ataturk, whose statue stands in the main square of every town and city in Turkey, already circulated in his lifetime but were denied by him and his family and never taken seriously by biographers. Of six biographies of him that I consulted this week, none even mentions such a speculation. The only scholarly reference to it in print that I could find was in the entry on Ataturk in the Israeli Entsiklopedya ha-Ivrit, which begins:
"Mustafa Kemal Ataturk - (1881-1938), Turkish general and statesman and founder of the modern Turkish state.
"Mustafa Kemal was born to the family of a minor customs clerk in Salonika and lost his father when he was young. There is no proof of the belief, widespread among both Jews and Muslims in Turkey, that his family came from the Doenme. As a boy he rebelled against his mother's desire to give him a traditional religious education, and at the age of 12 he was sent at his demand to study in a military academy."
You can look into the freemason records and find him as a member of them
@@aintankha6617 fax
@@cenktuneygok8986 he was a freemason, literally no one knows what his intention were, one thing is undeniable however, and it's that I've provided undeniable evidence, both from his parents, his language and background, that he was Jewish, what he wanted would've without any doubt been a country that supports the west, and by default Israel
@@cenktuneygok8986 because they were all supported by France to divide the islamic world
The first Arabian nationalist wasn’t an arab he was from Armenia
The first iranian nationalist was Reza Shah he wasn’t an Iranian he was from the Caucasus
Even in Europe hitler was an austrian and stalin too was not from Russia he was from Caucasus
@@aintankha6617 Lie more cry more.
Dude, your thumbnails have definitely gotten ALOT better as of recent!
I learned a lot in this one!
I’m glad, cheers Matt!
@@HikmaHistory can you do one for Sultan Abdulhamid ii , the last caliph?
@@MH-jg6vk the last caliph? Man you guys are brainwashed
@@emrekarsidag188 the only brainwashed person here is you. This is why Turks today are known for their close minded stupidity today which all of europe laughs at. A sultan/caliph is not someone who is under house arrest and is forced to be quiet by pashas right? So then how do you attribute such a big title to an important person who is behind closed doors?? So the period from the young Turk revolution 1908 till the formal end of the empire in 1922 there was no caliph nor sultan, because their powers not only were diminished but also only became puppets whom the young Turks chose. By 1924 when it was formally abolished , it was already dead. And so the reason why I say Abdulhamid was the last true caliph is because not only did he have the direct power and prestige but also had to the support of millions of Muslims around the world. The state collapsed 10 years after his dethronement by ittihat ve terraki. Happy with yo response?
@@emrekarsidag188 no comment as usual?
One should also keep in my mind that he didn't call himself "The father of Turks". It was his people, the Turks who called him by that name. You may disagree with his rule and ideas if you wish but he was and still is one of our greatest historic heroes.
Your ancestors would disagree with you that’s for sure. You’d disagree with yourself if you knew who Kemal really was.
@@historycinematics8985 I live in Turkiye. My grandfathers and their ancestors before them have stories from that time. It is you foreign Islamists who would be disappointed if you were living in the Ottoman empire during its ending years as it wasn't exactly an utopia as some of you think. Unless you're from Turkiye, all you know about Atatürk is what you read from some book somewhere. We lived it and our relatives taught us much about those times. Even Turkish conservative Muslim people respect him because he was the general that lead the Turkish army against the invaders (the european superpowers) and saved the Turkish nation from colonialism and slavery.
@@tolgacetin2799 lol even religious type leaders like Erdoğan respect him. Because he is a leader who fought for his country. I am pan Islamist myself. I disagree with his religious policy. But I respect him for his contribution to his country.
@@sebresludolf9611 sure mate you can disagree with his policies regarding matters of religion. I as a Muslim don't fully agree with him on all terms either but from a Turkish point of view he was the hero that came at our darkest hour and we cherish his memory for it.
@@tolgacetin2799 exactly. He is a complicated character in world history. Truly a hero who defended his nation from foreign rule, but a person who took several religious freedom away, introduced wrong policy regarding religion. But I believe Muslims of other countries should respect him. He is national hero of a fellow Muslim country. My country of Bangladesh has good relation with Turkey. In my country nobody likes his religious policy, some hate him for his abolition of the Caliphate. But we all do respect him for his contribution in the liberation of Turkey. We respect him because, he is national figure of Turkey a friend country of ours.
Very interesting. The Turks owe this man a lot for keeping their independence. The world would look a lot different if Istanbul had fallen to western powers.
A lot of Greeks despise him for not attaining them their reqonquista goal.
@@girdharsingh4287 they mostly despise him and highly dislike him due to the Population Exchange and the Deportation of Remaining greeks from Asia Minor
The Soviet Union also helped Ataturk even though he was a nationalist. The Soviets lent weapons and generals to help the Turks. In fact, the Tsar planned on taking Constantinople and becoming emperor after World War 1 but the Russian Revolution put a stop to that.
@@freakrx2349 yess Ottomans were on loosing side in the war with Tsar Russia.
This is nonesense. Nobody owes nothing to this man. Him and his men tried to remove Islam from Turkey, changed alphabet to dressing code, hanged and killed many scholars, copied everything from the West while people themselves already have a great history and culture and everything.
Let me ask you a question. When these Young Turks took over the power established their congress in Ankara against the Sultan. WHY suddenly ALL the western powers recognized him? And when westerners occupied Istanbul, why they left without even firing single shot and gave everything to Mustafa Kemal and his man?
They must have done some agreements behind the door, and screwing up whole country and its people from the inside and colonize their minds. Look at current Turkey, how they left their true self and Islam (many of young people are proud to be NOT Muslim and hate Islam).
Now this is the only thing people should be thankful to him (or cursing him depending on person's position), destroying a country with full of history and culture, and trying to destroy Islam and raising generations without the deen and akhlaq.
great vid, though I'm sure comment section aint gonna be fun
Thank you! Don't worry about them!
Thank you Mustafa Kemal Atatürk 🇹🇷 You saved my country from becoming syria or afghanistan
he made it western puppet. Erdogan is saving the country
you are not Turk and he is Jewish
@@ahmadfrhan5265 ok Ahmed from Somalia.. anything else??
@@milliyetci5672 am not from Somalia I would be proud though
@@milliyetci5672 yes I have a lot to share. do you care about the truth or not?
Mustafa kemal's family descend from turks from karamanoglu beyliği
Jew*
@@ahmadfrhan5265 no
@@burakasik3937 Yes he is
@@ahmadfrhan5265 your mom is jew
He saved Turkey
Thank you Mustafa Kemal Atatürk 💖
Elektrikçi gurbetçi knk yine buldum seni😅
Yeah many thanks for giving us naked beaches.
Atleast 10× f*** girl before marriage .
Legal Wine .
And to live in a relationship without any marriage.
Morally made our society very strong.
Bars are everywhere.
Thanks MKA
I'm a Mexican (living in Mexico) and even I know who Mustafa Kemal Ataturk is and even I know he was no Hebrew (lolwtf).
Regards to all Turkish patriots from Mexico!
Great recount of MK Ataturk early history. Looking forward to the part II.
He saved Turkey from Greece, Britain, France, Italy and Russia.🤔
A line from movie karan arjun
WHAT AAA JOKE😂😂😂
I was gripped right at the start with background music alone!
You're too kind my friend!
@@HikmaHistory Thanks!
Thank you very much with this valuable information that is helping me understand the Turkish way of life a pray that Türkiye will forever flourish my only thing is that I would love to speak the Turkish language
Atatürk ❤❤❤ Saviour of Turkey and Ottomans🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷
Ataturk was a Freemason and he worked to destroy Islam in Turkey.He is not a hero.
Wish there was someone like him for the Mughals.
Please invest in social media management. Your channel is criminally under subscribe where so many pop history channels thrive. I wish you all the best.
Thank you!
Atatürk most based man ever 🇹🇷❤️
atajew*
@@ahmadfrhan5265 he was not a jew u racist asswipe u probably would cry islamphobic if someone called u a terrorist pfffff
@@ahmadfrhan5265 Don’t cry
@@arvinhut5228 why ve would I? you worship your enemies 🏳️🌈🇺🇸🇪🇺👦🏼 not me
What do you think of Ataturk?
Project Dictator Playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLTZaOylOgJT_SJK0TDVk9rc1tDuJ4Pj8N&jct=EcnFldDEvsTmHs3r3jC3nfOqVjERfg
"1 unavailable video is hidden" Right after yours...
Ataturk committed the greatest theft and act of treason possible: the theft of an entire identity. Ataturk banned everything the Turks had ever known and forcefully made them follow everything Europe did. He eliminated Turkish culture, heritage, Islam, and everything that is of importance in life. Many were oppressed during this period and women could no longer were scarves or veils, men could no longer allowed to wear the Fez hat and were basically forced to abandon their traditional, already Westernized Turkish clothing and made to wear European clothes instead. He made it a crime to recite the Athan and pray the prayer in Arabic. He replaced possible unity in the Islamic world with extreme nationalism. He did countless acts of tyranny but if I’d name them all the list would take forever.
Now yes, he was a great general and leader but what does it matter? A leader does what he does for his nation. But because of Ataturk the Turkish nation no longer existed. It simply became another European wanna-be nation and till this day Europeans look down upon them and don’t accept them. Now they have no culture nor do they have an identity nor are they Europeans. I’m sure Turks’ ancestors wouldn’t be too happy about what Ataturk did to their nation.
Turkey was formerly Byzantine Istanbul citadel of Orthodox Christianity was Constantinople
I can't wait for Israel to clear the Al asqa mosque and rebuild the templeThe Islamic world paying their karma
From India to Spain unprovoked invasions bloodshed enslavement religious vandalism etc
8:01
How could the Bulgarian general give his daughter?
Bulgaria was attacked by the Romanians and lost important lands back to Turkey.
It was still the age of chivalry'
Excellent video 📹
You’re spreading the same lies as the haters of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk about his origins…
He’s 💯 % Turkish 🇹🇷 ❤
Mustafa kemal was of Greek Albanian Muslim decent but his mother was Turkish this was very common in the Ottoman Empire
His Father and Mother %100 Yörük and Kocacık Turkısh 🇹🇷
He f*cked your ancestors 1922 :))
Hahaha cry 😂
no
Ah good choice, can’t believe I forgot about him 👍
He was not soldier of Sultan. But soldier of his people and nation. Don't try to justify the traitor sultan who ran away from the country with an invader British ship...
Brother also make a detailed video on Enver Pasha
Maybe in the future
im waiting for the next video here
I recommend to the blind beleivers '' do investigation''
One question to ardent Ataturk haters (not me. i also hate him, but not to the point of dedicating my life to hate him):
Why won't you people villified Enver Pasha and other members of the Three Pashas for their roles in ousting Sultan Abdul Hamid II and greatly reducing his authority, failed to win wars against Italy and Balkan States, brought the Ottoman Empire to WW1 and paved the way for Armenian, Assyrian, and Greek Genocide? Are you giving him a free pass because "at least he's not destroying the caliphate"?
Thanks
Enver Pasha is literally liked by no one 😂 He didn’t do anything good for the empire. He screwed them up bad and no one denies that or give him a pass for what he did. But Ataturk was a tyrant who banned religion and didn’t allow freedom of speech. Because of him Turks were forced into atheism.
@@historycinematics8985
atheism? 90% of Turkey is Muslims, so your argument here is wrong. You confuse secularism with atheism, pal.
@@historycinematics8985 then Enver Pasha is clearly worse than Ataturk right? are you agree or disagree with this statement?
@@jurtra9090 Lol Muslim on paper but if you ask them to say the Shahada they’ll be lost 😅 Barely 5% will be proper practicing
@@jurtra9090 Enver Pasha paved the way to doom with good intentions just as “the way to hell is paved with good intentions.” He was a true patriot who died a martyr. He didn’t do crazy tyrannies like eradicating Kurdish culture and language or eradicating Islam and Turkish culture forcefully. Ataturk was a dictator who eradicated anything he didn’t like. Enver Pasha was incompetent but even as a pro western reformist he would never take it anywhere near that far. It’s better to have in incompetent guy who works for you rather than a brilliant guy who works against you.
Where's part 2 and 3?
Here is an idea.
Make videos about ethnicities around the world.
Kurds, Persians, Turks, Hazaras, Slaves, etc.
kurds = pers
When Kemal Ataturk Recited Shema Yisrael: 'It's My Secret Prayer, Too,'. He Confessed
ZICHRON YAAKOV -- There were two questions I wanted to ask, I said over the phone to Batya Keinan, spokeswoman for Israeli president Ezer Weizman, who was about to leave the next day, Monday, Jan. 24, on the first visit ever made to Turkey by a Jewish chief of state. One was whether Mr. Weizman would be taking part in an official ceremony commemorating Kemal Ataturk.
Ms. Kenan checked the president's itinerary, according to which he and his wife would lay a wreath on Ataturk's ...
Excited and Distressed
I thanked her and hung up. A few minutes later it occurred to me to call back and ask whether President Weizman intended to make any reference while in Turkey to Ataturk's Jewish antecedents. "I'm so glad you called again," said Ms. Kenan, who now sounded excited and a bit distressed. "Exactly where did you get your information from?"
Why was she asking, I countered, if the president's office had it too?
Because it did not, she confessed. She had only assumed that it must because I had sounded so matter-of-fact myself. "After you hung up," she said, "I mentioned what you told me and nobody here knows anything about it. Could you please fax us what you know?"
I faxed her a short version of it. Here is a longer one.
Stories about the Jewishness of Ataturk, whose statue stands in the main square of every town and city in Turkey, already circulated in his lifetime but were denied by him and his family and never taken seriously by biographers. Of six biographies of him that I consulted this week, none even mentions such a speculation. The only scholarly reference to it in print that I could find was in the entry on Ataturk in the Israeli Entsiklopedya ha-Ivrit, which begins:
"Mustafa Kemal Ataturk - (1881-1938), Turkish general and statesman and founder of the modern Turkish state.
"Mustafa Kemal was born to the family of a minor customs clerk in Salonika and lost his father when he was young. There is no proof of the belief, widespread among both Jews and Muslims in Turkey, that his family came from the Doenme. As a boy he rebelled against his mother's desire to give him a traditional religious education, and at the age of 12 he was sent at his demand to study in a military academy."
You can look into the freemason records and find him as a member of them
Lie more. Atatürk is Türk, only Türk.
@Müsellem-i Hayat Hayat he wasn't a freemason like your parents, your parents are either members of a joke, or they are in one of the 3 low degrees, ataturk was around the 30th and surrounded himself with 7 high degree freemasons in his career, the high degree freemasons are not freedom loving democracy supporters, they support total atheism, and their rituals are some of the most disgusting there is.
Your parents are freemasons by name, a real freemason is a historical monster, Roosevelt who was a deceiving imperialist, Churchill who was agenocider in Kenya, and ataturk who was an ultra nationalist when it comes to turk-ism, going as far as to ban Arab and Kurd elements from the state and oppressing the kurds in the east, his group, the young turks, also had a hand in the armenian genocide
Please educate yourself, i haven't spent years of my life reaserching these things just to have a random brother tryna teach me something, thank you
Süleyman Demerıl was a Freemason, it’s not that big of a deal honestly.
What is, is that he acted against muslim interests at the time (not Arabs there’s a reason they fought him)
@@sulimanthemagnificent4893 you are ignorant and never make a dedicated reaserch, if you are a Muslim you will stand against this group wich seeks to destroy all religions including Islam
keep crying
Talking about this man, especially in channels about Islam, will bring you a very civilized conversation. Be warned
Betul bro
Dont care if he is atheist or muslim. Dont care if he was a good president by Turkish Standards. What im grateful for is that he was one of the factors that caused the Ottoman Empire and paved the way for the Independance of my country.
Well, for other Muslims, he was considered a traitor
@@jurtra9090 *BECAUSE.....*
1924 Caliphate abolished. Khalifa was driven out of country without a single pai. He was purposely sent to European countries, not in a Muslim country, like Egypt, Syria etc. Traditional religious schools closed, Sheriat (Islamic Law) abolished.
1925 Dervish brotherhoods abolished. Fez outlawed by the Hat Law. Veiling of women discouraged; Western clothing for men and women encouraged. Western (Gregorian) calendar adopted.
1926 New civil, commercial, and penal codes based on European models adopted. New civil code ended Islamic polygamy and divorce by renunciation and introduced civil marriage. Millet system ended.
1928 New Turkish alphabet (modified Latin form) adopted. State declared secular ; constitutional provision establishing Islam as official religion deleted.
1933 Islamic call to worship and public readings of the Kuran required to be in Turkish rather than Arabic.
In short : He was a dictator.
@@gazi8412 all these things i have no problem with. As being a dictator he was but he inherited an authorotarian heredaty sultanate he didn't inherit a democracy so in the historical and geigraphical context he didnt do anything strange.
@@gazi8412 well, at least you should understand the condition that Ataturk faced before he decided all of that
Ottomans in the early 20th century was a shadow of its former self. It can't even win against the united Balkan States. For all of his wrongs, shouldn't you also blame Enver Pasha and his colleagues too?
Do you care that millions of Turks went to hell cuz of him?
Why did he keep the crescent symbol in the flag when he banned like all religious elements within Turkiye?
Why do you care about this and not that when many countries have crosses on their flags?
Ooooo, my feed just got flooded with dictators! Today is good day. Hehehe. Starting with your video. 😉
he was not donme..not jewsih, not albanian vs.. we had his ancestors documents uop to 500 years.. he is a konyar.. his ancestors were emigrated from anatolia to macedonia for turkification the new conquered regons.. mehmed th second firstly conquered karamanoğulları includes mustafa kemals ancerstor. after mehemed coonquered macedonia. he transferred therse turks to macedonia.. this was an empirial strategy.. his ancestors had documents becasue of they were mevlevi dervishes and worked for empire..
Great man , father of the Turks.
Didnt even watch the video but can tell its full of false leading information.
LOOOL
the west wont leave anyone to live in peace
*I am from Bangladesh, and I right wing Muslim myself. I don't like Ataturk for his moves regarding his moves against religious moves. But I respect him. Because he fought for his country, saved his nation from imperial colonial powers. He loved his country, worked and fought for it. He is a national hero of his country. That's why I respect him because he is hero of a country who is a friend of my country. I might not agree with his religious moves but I respect him for his other moves.*
Are you sure you’re a Muslim?
Attaturk was a tyrant who forbid his nation to practice Islam. He also abolished the caliphate and spread nationalism instead. The mans screwed us up and you respect him for defending his country at the cost of the whole Islamic world. Shame
@@historycinematics8985 yes I am pretty sure I am Muslim. A sunni Muslim to exact.
@@historycinematics8985 yes. Like I said I don't like what he did in terms of his religious policy. He will suffer for this in the afterlife. But you can't ignore the fact he saved his country from foreign occupation.
@@sebresludolf9611 He eradicated the entire Turkish identity and heritage. He didn’t save but destroyed the country. It wouldn’t make much of a difference if the British ruled over them instead of the British loving Ataturk.
And what good is there in ‘saving’ a country when it’s at the cost of the entire Muslim world? He not only destroyed Turkey but so did he eradicate the caliphate, creating an order of extreme nationalism, allowing Muslims to kill each other instead of working together. The mans was a guy of no respect like you think.
Some none turkish mullahs says things bad about him
Please post more videos about
- Islamic Golden Age
Kings and Generals already made a video about it
@@jurtra9090 i know,thank you for information!!
What golden age hahaha
@@scotishjohn ignorance is bliss
sultan's soldier ? come on man :)
Great nationalist
Turkish war of secular
Ah the crypto jews. Still having questions whether I am one from conspiracy theory readers when they hear my ancestors were from Selanik.
Ataturk was always great he defended Constantinople and Anatolia from aggressive western powers specially greeks who dreamed to take back Constantinople and secondly ottomans at that time were useless and ataturk was not jewish this was racist thing and was insult for turks to say them jews keep in mind turks are turks .long live republic of turkey
He is a traitor
according to Abdul from Pakistan and Muhamed from Somalia
Says a nobody like you
I am Turkish. Ataturk is a traitor
May he burn in hell.
@@milliyetci5672shut the fuck up
he wasn’t actually born in 1881. he just told everyone he was born in 1881 because that’s the year he started his education.
No, there is a story like that about his birthday, not about his birth year.
Correction ; Mustafa kmal was brought up in ottoman empire ,educated in ottoman empire and trained by ottoman empire so he was like a servant of the ottomans and he should be thankful to ottomans because without ottomans Mustafa was nothing .
xD Thats stupid comment :)
100% false.. the ottomans were a massive failure
🧐👍💯🥇🇹🇷👏
He was no crypto jew fam.
He was a traitor
Traitor: Saves the country from almost Complete partition
U are on the happy pills
Said the traitor
according to Abdul from Pakistan and Muhamed from Somalia lol
So many of his men died needlessly in his campaign during the winter in the Caucasuses.
You're not thinking of Enver Pasha?
@@HikmaHistory Maybe I'm confusing the two
He's no legend he destroyed the empire
He actually saved Ottomans lol
Ottoman was already extremely weakened before Atatürk lol
Yeah not like the Ottoman empire was already a rump state, he just wanted to abolish the empire at its golden age lol
@@nenenindonu golden age? Ottoman's golden age was 15th to 17th century, and it was on a slow and steady decline since then
@@jurtra9090 Thats what Im saying people act like Atatürk ended the empire at its golden age
he should have asked 3 times, 4, 5, 6, etc..., cocky ataturk
Atashirk
Turks have undergone a century of desislamization, secularisation and westernization; turks, for a century, have been taught a history written by powers sitting in Jewish world; I always wonder why Ataturk agreed upon a deal of the century. If one ever ponders upon it, and what took place throughout that century, everything becomes crystal clear. Jews knew that as long as Turks stand as a powerful Muslim nation the establishment Zionist colonialist Nazi regime of Pigrael would be an impossible dream. Therefore, Ottman empire had to go astray and Turks desislamized so that none stands challenging to what is happening in Muslim world. On the day of judgement, three people would be raised together: Arthur Balfour, Ataturk and Theodore Herzle ( May cursed be these three)
A zionist ? 😂
Turkey was formerly Byzantine Istanbul citadel of Orthodox Christianity was Constantinople
I can't wait for Israel to clear the Al asqa mosque and rebuild the temple
i can't wait for saints paul cathedral to be converted to a Mosque and White House to become a Madrasa.
@@historianslair4971
Lol
The A bomb would be dropped over Mecca and Medina first
ROFL 🤣😂🤣😂
@@historianslair4971
Here a refresher in your hi
@@historianslair4971
Forgot about the qaramaathias the ones who slaughtered Muslims at the kabbah threw the corpses into the zam zam well took the black rock from the kabbah for twenty one years and urinated on it every morning
ruclips.net/video/d9FiThEJFMo/видео.html
@@historianslair4971
Black September massacre of palestinian
General Zia Al haqq did this
ruclips.net/video/sRavSeto_lo/видео.html
I am Turkish and this video is full of lies. Have you ever read ilber ortayli's book?
I prefer Kazım Karabekir over Atatürk.
How come?
@@HikmaHistory Duo to its role in the opposition after the independence war.
It made me laugh after watching this video😂
Yes you can support him for it's your choice but he dared to bans teaching Quran
And the right wing left wing games with the large number of supporters of this criminal praising him as he was a hero😂
I love the fact that pakis or arabs are getting obsessed with him, calling him a traitor and such as if they have a say in the matter yet during his life he never paid attention to those people or their counterparts in Turkish society,not even as he paid on a bug, while cheerfully destroying what they consider sacred and going like "Your opinions are of no consequence bitches, whine and moan all you like. I'll still have my own way no matter what." An attitude which resonates through the mindsets of modern day Turks towards these people, I must happily add.
Actually the outsiders from turkiye don’t actually understands the history of turkish people’s. If they do they would know why Ataturk is being respected all over the turkiye. Its not important always to agree with him. But he did great for turkish people’s.
May Allah keep turkish people’s safe. Love from Bangladesh.
Atabok I'm turkish