CLC(씨엘씨) - '어디야?(Where are you?)' Official Music Video
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2017
- CLC(씨엘씨) - '어디야?(Where are you?)' Official Music Video
Download on iTunes Apple Music: itun.es/us/TLIHlb
#CLC #씨엘씨 #체셔 #CHESHIRE #승희 #유진 #승연 #손 #예은 #엘키 #은빈 #Seunghee #Yujin #Seungyeon #Sorn #Yeeun #Elkie #Eunbin #Kpop #CUBE #6thMiniAlbum #프리즘 #6집미니앨범 #FREESM #MV #뮤비 #뮤직비디오 #어디야? #WhereAreYou? #MusicVideo #ComeBack #Release
CLC's 6th mini album 'FREE'SM' has been released!
'FREE'SM' available on iTunes!
CLC Official RUclips: / officialclc
CLC Official Facebook: / clc.unitedcube
CLC Official Twitter: / cubeclc
CLC Official Fansite: cafe.daum.net/CUBE-CLC
ⓒ All Rights Reserved CUBE Entertainment 
Видеоклипы
This song is not disliked for it's concept and vibe, but for the timing it was released. Many ppl were dissapointed with CUBE releasing this "soft" song after Hobgoblin, when the newer fans were expecting a hard hitting girlcrush song. This song is in fact a masterpiece. What many ppl don't realize is how poorly Hobgoblin was recieved in Korea and some were hating on CUBE and CLC for switching to badass and said it didn't suit them and reminded too much of 4Minute. Given how much hate CLC and CUBE got during Hobgoblin era it is not that surprising that CUBE tried to switch concepts again to try to keep the koreans satisfied.
Actually here is the real tea: The huge attention Hobgoblin got was mainly from 4nias (4Minute fans) who saw their faves get disbanded and their attention turned to CLC, that had released a song which had a 4Minute vibe all over it (because of Hyunas involement in the production and style). And CLC got a lot of hate from 4nias too. So CUBE and maybe even CLC thought, "what's the point in continuing this concept when ppl are just hating on us?"
Sometimes I still think this song and title "Where are you" is meant for the future fans of CLC, the fans that CLC expected to see, but who never came.
Your last words made me soft. I am glad now fans have given an anwser to the girls and the world. I just wish them the best.
This comment is scary, because it's semi-realistic...I wanna cry
"Sometimes I still think this song and title 'Where are you' is meant for the future fans of CLC, the fans that CLC expected to see, but who never came."
ahhhh this makes me so emotional!!!!!!!
I think this song better for B side track not the main tittle, so sad :(
this comment really explains it all
why someone call this as a cute concept? It's kinda mysterious and elegant l love both this song and 'i like it'
People call everything not badass or sexy “cute concept” xd
Dreamy* concept
It’s something like lovely’s, Gfriend and OMG kind off concept, like elegant and dreamy (in this case it’s not inocent)
@@cheshireinclcszone7528 it's more retro elegant, not dreamy
They call this cute concept because of how slow the song is & also the choreography... Kpop fan only know 2 terms the cute concept & girl crush concept
This song was ahead of its time. If they bring this back in a special stage or something like that, especially because right now 80's synth pop (i dunno about genre plz dont fight me) is trending nowadays, this would finally get the recognition it deserves. 😭
Yeah this style is really in trend right now. This song literally came back to my mind today when I had not listened since (last year? idk but many time).
ig the genre is city pop
@@felizaniverseesaw City Pop is not like this. This is synth-pop, 80s music that has a retro sound in the R&B Soul genre.
@@mn8284 it is city pop, it's just more into r&b rather than jazz. you can still hear the brass there every now and then
@@simeonkim4272 Yeah, I hear it but I think it's more synth-pop. I know City Pop is very popular lately, but not all old genres can be called City Pop.
Unpopular opinion: This song and free'sm album is a masterpiece
Agreed :>
I'm not a big fan of the album, but this is definitely one of their best songs.
YES I LOVE THIS AND BAE
tbh "where are you" is a brutally underrated title track of clc
FREE'SM and Nu.Clear are my favourite CLC EPs.
Why people labeled this concept as innocent? I mean am I the only one who think that this is a really mature and elegant concept?
Uneducated girl crush stans 🤦🏻♀️, this concept is more Apink LUV
actually this is sexier and more mature than Apink LUV
the dance, the body roll
CLC : who else can induce ballad with some sensual/sexiness
But the concept is more in line with most Apink concepts as it is a feminine concept rather than a cutesy concept, Apink however has to maintain the innocent concept of their’s since they’re married to it, however CLC aren’t married to a concept so if they want they can induce their dance with body rolls too.
P.S. apparently when CLC debuted Cube wanted them to be a marriage between the 4Minute and Apink concepts (both groups were part of Cube at the time)
Mature, feminine and elegant embodiment of innocence.
Not to be confused with the "cutesy" flavor of innocence portrayed in "No Oh Oh."
Only people that don't understand elegant labels it as innocent 🤷
I still don't get why people don't think this is a summer song. It is. As in, it's a lazy summer afternoon song.
aisyah It is depressing for a summer song. It's has very sad lyrics :'( But yea who cares about the seasons wtf!
I get why it may seem depressing but it's more of slow jam
aisyah is a vaporwave concept tho
more retrowave than vaporwave, but when the song came out the comments section of the MV on this channel and CJENMMUSIC was that "cube shouldn't have released the song in summer" "it's too slow for summer" that's why I commented what I commented, but yes genre-wise the song has a lot of 80s elements
aisyah #너_없인_안_된다 to me it's a rainy day with tea kind of song...... I love it so so much
I wish more groups would do ethereal concepts like this :(
Didn't LOONA used to do these? Especially LOONA 1/3 and earlier LOONA songs up to Butterfly?
@@DJ-tx3ux I hope LOONA make this concept for Loonatheballads album :(
@@DJ-tx3ux Yeah, they had this dreamy and ethereal vibe despite how varied their pre-debut releases were in terms of concept and genre.
@@214MDso sad that their recent comeback is totally different :((
@@stansecretnumberperiodthey disbanded their in different sub-units now
This is one of the biggest examples of "wrong timing". This song is one of the best in KPOP but the way it was totally overlooked when it came out
CUBE, im under your bed
From Hobgoblin to this. That was some 360 degree turn! CLC is a very versatile group. People should stop sleeping on them!
JAMFUL O' JIMIN you do realise what a 360 turn means don’t you lmao
youjin’s glare Made me think for a minute too HAHAHA
360°?
Sorry😂
*180 you mean
Nan yeppeuda michin na is the new Palinawara 🔥
Check out CLC's new bop on 1thek channel or CLC's
Disband? Hell NOOO!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I heard people say this comeback was disappointing and it’s the exact opposite. Def my fave clc song
Its not what people expected after hobgoblin but i agree i love this song!
Steeb_ it was generally disappointing TBH especially after the huge hype they created from Hobgoblin, they should’ve proceeded with Black Dress then La Vie En Rose after
maybe because in the intro it sounds like smth is gonna happen and then where are you begins like more loud.
So it kinda weird that part, but the rest is gold
My fav too
the whole point was to show a diff side of clc. it was to prove that yes despite the fact that yes clc can pull of concepts like hobogoblic, they also can pull off soft, ballad like concepts
i’ve said this a million times but i’ll say it again- THIS SONG WAS AHEAD OF ITS TIME. However!! Cube was not smart for releasing it as a title track after Hobgoblin . Being a fan when this was released was depressing.. But it’s a top 5 clc song for me
This song is so beautiful, one of their best songs
Agreed. Looking back I still wonder why Cube didn’t follow up with something similar to hobgoblin. It arguably got the group more recognition than any of their previous releases. Sometimes I feel like they purposefully shot this group in the foot.
@@honesttostrangers7687 If Black Dress or No was released after Hobgoblin, CLC would've been so successful.
@@honesttostrangers7687 hobgoblin only succesfull in internasional but flopped in korea. That's why they released this song to catch Korean fans attention
I don't get why people don't like this side of clc... I really love this concept tbh and everyone looks so pretty here
same, been always repeating it since the day it was released 💙
it's a crime that this masterpiece has such little views :/ honestly, this has been my favorite title track by them since pepe, not to mention every song on the mini album was good. Smh clc is so slept on
people are stanning concept, not stanning clc
Andreas Widjaja i like clcs girl crush and cute songs & i dont like this one. it’s not bc of concept it bc this is not a great song :/
It was just released at the wrong time
I love this song its so calming but the lyrics make me sad:(
KPOP x Vaporwave
People clearly don’t have taste. This is like an 80's ballad song which is really really nice to hear... Still streaming to get this to at least 2 million. Come on Cheshires, we can do it! It has so little views
"good taste in music" doesn't exist. it's a matter of preference.
peky good point......
It is 2M now, check it out
;0
This song takes me back to 1988 to 1990 when here in the United States there were girl groups like "EXPOSE,^
" THE COVER GIRLS "
^ SEDUCTION"
was all over the radio.
this was one of their best releases yet everyone slept on this coz this is not a noisy girl crush sound 💀
This song will forever be one of the unsung crown jewels of Kpop. It is haunting in the best possible way.
seriously, people just don't know what they are missing out by not discovering this
As a Red Velvet stan, if they sang this song it would be a big hit. This songs a huge bop. CLC has everything from visuals to talent. Sad that people can’t recognize this
This song is equivalent of RV's automatic
Nheil Vocal EXACTLY PERIODT and I’m a reveluv ❤️
Nheil Vocal i was just gonna say that yeahhh
Yeah, I always says this. Groups such as RV are praise for versatility but people justify how clc was slept on cause they didnt stick to a concept. I really hate how favoritism and popularity works. No shade to red velvet, the real problems are k fans who slept on real talent.
OMG I'm a Reveluv and I'm obsessed with this song. Same thoughts but CLC did well in this song.
Unpopular opinion: this is CLC's best song
this one and Tears bottle (also known as Depression)
Even more unpopular opinion: I don't like Hobgoblin.
vivi I and Cheshire respect you opinion ☺️ tbh didn’t like it too but I ended up loving the song
@@veIvette I have a love-hate relationship with Hobgoblin, sometimes it hypes me up so much and other times I go: 😶
Yo no puedo decidirme por una XD
thinking about it now, if this was released in 2020 it would've became a hit. Especially since a lot of artists and groups are throwing it back and creating 80s and 90's inspired music. Sigh. I just wish people would open their ears and hearts to clc they deserve the world.
the most underrated song in kpop history !!!!!!
I swear
Am I the only one who actually likes this song and the concept? zjjdjjdn, This is gold
neonki12 youre not alone:)
me too
neonki12 no 😍
neonki12 it's ok :)
I've been listening to this all day. It's so dreamlike
CUBE WE NEED A LIGHTSTICK FOR CLC AND A COMEBACK
Lyn Jened the only group from 2015 batch who didn’t own their lightstick and tour ☹️😔
like right now
For real😵😩
Exactly
They do noe
WHY THIS SONG IS NOT FAMOUS, IT'S ONE OF THEIR BEST SONGS
this is one of the best songs ever made but people weren't ready for this
I don't understand why so many people hate this song.
This is just the definition of beautiful!!
It was because of the timing
People were expecting to get something like hobgoblin
this song followed hobgoblin, they literally lost a lot of chesires after this
this is actually one of my favourite clc songs
i also notice that many international fans are more into bad ass + girl crush concepts, so after hogoblin they must've decided to not stan them anymore
i personally was catched by this son especially, i liked them a lot when they had their debut + kinda drifted off after their concept change but i'm now in love with all of their songs!! i like it when a group can pull of multiple concepts
@@faye626 Bruh like these people who hated this need to be canceled:/
Timing was wrong BUT for me I would have fricken loved it! If only I stood CLC sooner
who's here after watching seunghee's rearranged version?
meeee✌😂
Me
^^
Where can I find the rearranged version?
@@Setgelsaikhan hello this is late but u fan watch it on clc's official channel!
Yujin ate this concept up
Yujin really ate this concept up. So pretty
CLC has literally done every concept and this is seriously my favourite. What did CLC do? *THAT! IM SHOOK*
Johnny Hunt I KNOW!!😍💙🎶
Johnny Hunt they are like cube's snsd haha
yes same! this is my fav so far actually although many dislike it..
hogoblin is nice too but idk i like this more..
then same!
I feel like it's unfair though... I'm confident that if GFriend did the same concept and song, people wouldn't hate it as much as they are on Clc? They would be shocked of how great the song was..
If no one’s bopping to this in 2023, then no one has taste.
yay i have taste then
jenniecults yes u do queen
I’m glad I’m not tasteless
Dusk Lizares NO U AREN’T ✊🏼✊🏼
One symptom of covid-19 is lack of taste. People still ignoring this masterpiece better get checked asap.
K-pop fans hated on this so much solely bc it wasn’t girl crush like Hobgoblin but I LOOOOOOVED this since the day it came out. So dreamy
Those pale skins.
Those blank stares.
The water reflection at 1:16
I have a feeling this MV is telling us that they were actually ghosts roaming the garden.
yeah!!! the song is about ghosting so it makes perfect sense
I feel so bad for people that haven’t listened to this song... they’re missing out
me too I feel bad for them
Same
*FLAWLESS. SOPHISTICATED. CLASSY. ELEGANT. BREATHTAKING. MATURE. PASSIONATE. NOSTALGIC.*
PERFECT !!
This song 어디야?(Where are you?) of CLC is such a hidden gem. The feelings it gives, the aesthetics, the vocals shown here cannot be found anywhere else.
This song is a maserpiece, who misssed this, miss a big moment of life
I still don't get why you want them to stick to only one concept. What even is variety and trying out styles? CLC is a fairly new group, of course they're shooting in the dark and exploring all possibilities that makes them feel comfortable. I'm not a Cheshire but I'm glad they're trying out styles, both mainstream and not. Cube is giving them all these options tbh
Cecylle Sulit bc this flop. Hahaha!!!
booming system up Not really
booming system up This album already sold more than the last one.
Julsky Allan Bianson sold more?? What is the difference?? 200?? This concept is flop
booming system up It will flop because you let it flop.
This song has such a 90s vibe and I'm living for it
Lea yessss
80s*
Moreso late 80s
Right i didnt know if it was 90's or 80's and im living for it since now a days you dont really see alot of groups trying to add other eras inspired music
80s
this song is soft and beautiful but also sad, the lyrics :(
I will never forgive the kpop community for sleeping on this banger of a song
THIS MV IS SO PRETTY IM CRYING
sorn never having enough screen time is a constant trend smh
she does have a large majority of the lines so its kind of fair
This music video is so aesthetically and artistically pleasing to me. I love the symbolism how different people wear the red dress, the transitions, and little details are so good!
yeah, compared to other music videos from them I was very pleased with this(hair, outfits, makeup, position). If she is your bias I totally understand why you would want her to shine more.
It is really beautiful, the look and the sound both. One of the best things around right now.
This song is so underrated, STOP SLEEPING ON TALENT, I'll never stop saying this :))
Ok imma stream the whole Freesm album for CLC as a way to Boycott Blockberry Creative
Where are you? 1800 days ❤️
I like this soft concept, it's calming and good for my eyes
Correction: it's good for my soul
literally no one:
ppl born after 2000: omg this gives me so much 90s vibes!!!!!
Time traveling Cheshires! 😹
I mean like if people born after the 2000s and listened to music from the 90s/80s its kinda the same. Not hating just a general opinion!
i literally listened to music from the 90s-
Irony is its 80s sound
But its 80's city pop ... so no
this song is just literal perfection... I wanna cry
This song needs a chart reversal now. Perfect song for the Spring season.
sorry but this comeback was superior, the taste, the visuals, everything it's perfect
The Mv is so aesthetic. I am proud to say that I became a fan in the hobgoblin era but I think I love this concept even more and it suits them perfectly.
still my favorite CLC song. it's heartbreaking that they have disbanded and they did not get the attention they deserved..
The most underrated song of whole KPOP
[EDITED TO INCLUDE RELEASES UP TO DEVIL]
To those of you who say “ugh High Heel is stupid CLC doesn’t do cute” “ugh OT5 is better” “ugh” lemme explain this.
All of the MVs have a story! And they show that the girls obviously aren’t great at being perfectly girly- no matter how hard they try.
I’ll explain: the story of the MVs (not the actual lyrics, but the MV)
Pepe shows that the original 5 are a group of friends, not interested in boys, just having fun together without influence of the outside world. Even if the confusing, Alice in Wonderland style, house, the girls are close and still figure out how to have fun regardless.
Like shows Seungyeon seeing a cute boy for the first time, and becoming absolutely lovesick. Her friends stumble upon here and are confused about her behavior. When she explains, her friends are still baffled, but want to help her get the boy. So they try to track him down, and when they do, they get Seungyeon dressed up and does her makeup- buuuuut Seungyeon doesn’t know how to act in front of the boy, and ends up embarrassing herself.
High Heel shows the girls, with the addition of two new friends, all trying to become girly-girls. It shows the whole process of them learning to bake and make tea, try to learn how to do cute makeup and hair, walking in high heels... but they all suck at it. Sorn and Seungyeon fall over trying to wear heels. Yeeun made awful tea and Macarons. Yujin getting the worst makeover by her friends. They all realize how much they don’t suit the girly style, but continue practicing because they want to be what they think boys like. In the end, they perfect the girly techniques- but find out how pricey (literally) being a girl is.
No Oh Oh shows the 7 falling back into their old style, but still trying to be more charismatic in a girly sense. Sorn practices in front of a mirror different cute poses, but is clumsy. Yeeun seems to be wearing a big purse for the first time- and ends up getting the strap caught on a door. She gets flustered at her failed first attempt and is shown frustrated on her couch. Seungyeon cooks up a nice sandwich at home, and starts to bite into it- but hesitates. Elkie seems to try to be an edgy girl at school, although it’s not exactly her usual type. Yeeun burns her phone, realizing she doesn’t want to worry about getting a call from a boy. Seungyeon eats her sandwich, because she understands she doesn’t have to be tidy or stingy with food to impress. Sorn puts on bright blue mascara, because she doesn’t want to be a dainty girl who does poses- she wants to be bold. The girls finally start to understand that they don’t need to change who they are.
Hobgoblin shows that, as the girls have gotten older, their style has matured as well. They like being bold, sensual, and dark- not dainty little girls who only want to impress boys. They seem to really throw that standard down the trash with this MV. After finding who they really want to be, they decide to break it to the world- crush stereotypes and say “we will be who we want whether you like it or not” and “want me for who I am, not who you expect me to be”. They all have weapons, and start destroying TVs, mirrors, busts, because they all represent things that society expects of them. TV has many stereotypes about Asian women, how they should act, hosts who pick on those who stray from the standard. Many girls stare in the mirror to pick on their own insecurities, and spend hours trying to “fix” what society has told them is wrong. The busts are of famous legendary women (I’m assuming), that are possibly symbols of purity, elegance, virginity. The girls destroy those to show that they’re breaking from the mold, and flowering into grown women tired of standards.
Where Are You? shows the girls’ soft side, because everyone has one. The girls are still sensitive, and don’t want you to be too intimidated- because that’s not what their message is. They want people to realize that they aren’t just girly girls, or edgy punks, or tomboys. They want people to realize that they have variety, multiple colors, and while they were dark before, that’s just their style. They had to get your attention somehow, and show they are just any girl group- they’re CLC. They’re asking “where are you?” because after Pepe, when they changed concepts, so many people left and ignored CLC. Hobgoblin came, and while many people loved it, there were still those who complained because “they can’t stick to a concept”. CLC wanted people to understand with this that they’re are very versatile. While they are independent, they’re still sensitive, and hear what you say about them.
Black Dress shows the girls’ peak maturity. It’s another sensual and dark video expressing the girls’ growth. They don’t care to impress anymore. Eunbin pole dances, and while usually pole dancers are performing for strangers to entertain- she’s performing for her friends. She knows she doesn’t have to impress them, because they’re already close. She’s simply expressing her artistry and her friends are admiring her. Yeeun stares in the mirror at her hair- not because she’s wondering if it’ll show her femininity, but because she’s wanting to cut it all off. She worries at first because she knows society will correlate her cutting her hair, as cutting off her femininity. So she waits, probably for advice from her friends. We see the girls walking around with scissors, black feathers, both considered a bit intimidating. There’s another female bust that ends up getting covered in black paint- another symbol of purity being diminished because a girl doesn’t have to be pure to be good. Yeeun gets the push to go to the mirror again, and although I said we weren’t looking at the lyrics, in her rap she even says “why are you hesitating, follow your instincts” right before she makes the initial chop.
Distance is the other side of Black Dress- the girls are confident in their concepts, and love their evergrowing fan base. But, they can’t help but wonder, are they really doing what their fans want? They can’t help but want to do what others want, despite how much they themselves love their work. They still feel tied to their past criticisms, as shown by the girls being bound. “I try to ignore it.” They try to look away from the hate, though, by blindfolding themselves and sticking to each other. They’re human, though, and words hurt, no matter how much they distance themselves from it.
No comes after the girls have contemplated everything, they’ve sat and thought about the words of their fans and critics alike. By now, they’ve fully accepted that they aren’t going to adhere to what others want. They aren’t going to make themselves fit into the tastes and expectations of others. “What I do with me is my business, I love me.” CLC is tired of trying to wear “red lip, earrings, heels” what everyone wants them to. They’ll wear these things if they please, and so they do- but it’s only for themselves.
ME further goes with the theme of No, showing CLC’s confidence in experimenting with their concepts and appearances. They’re basking in their new love for themselves, and they’re telling everyone that they’re nothing wrong with liking yourself and calling yourself beautiful. “Do it like me, follow me follow me.” The girls are telling their fans, audience, and even critics that they should love themselves as well.
Devil is playful, teasing, fun, on the surface, but it’s got a much deeper message. “I tried to be polite, but why do you keep bothering me?” Critics are still there, although much less than before, and the girls are questioning why these critics are still bothering to try to intimidate and provoke them when it no longer works. By now, CLC is done being sweet and polite to these people. They’re ready to tell them what’s what, and that they’re no longer going to appear cute. The video shows the girls tricking each other, hurting each other, but then getting revenge in return. They’re basically saying “you might push me down, insult me, and say I’m no good, but you’ve truly just made me stronger, and I’m not going down without a fight”.
The story so far is that CLC doesn’t dress to impress anymore- they do what they want and enjoy what they do, but still want people to understand that they have feelings. They listen to criticisms, and take it to heart, but still want to be individuals with their true personalities. They acknowledge the girly concepts were confusing and awkward, because it’s not what they wanted to do. They knew typically people loved the cutesy concepts, and wanted to try it- but it was obvious it wasn’t their style, so they went back to their roots of dark and sensual. When people complained of yet another concept change, they had to explain that they were listening. Then shown that this is just who they are- versatile girls who love the boldness of being unique individuals.
-Syno
MermaidSyno your comment is so amazing omg,we need to spread it everywhere and give you credits ofc
MermaidSyno Could you explain Distance, please?
kpop 24/7 For real.
there are persons who thinks ot5 is better? imagine clc without elkie or eunbin... it's just a no
jenniecults CLC honestly kind of feels empty? without Elkie and Eunbin.
Its so bad that the whole fandom, say that where are u is an underated bop, but we don’t stream, the mv is stuck in 1.9 mlls of views, we need to wake up 🥺
When their MVs were in 1tk ofc they had bigger numbers there. That's the problem of putting them in other yt channels but it can also reach a wider audience and in fact, that happened. I'm here because I really love this song, is such a soft gem
Thanks to someone's worst songs list, I discover this awesome song and add it to my playlist.
In the worst song list really???
LMAO 😂😂sometimes it be like that..
From whom???
CLC OT7 FOREVER
No matter what everyone said, i truly believe this is one of the best songs of clc and even kpop itself
I hate all these fake fans that only supported clc during hobgoblin era.
"OhMyGOd ThEyRe sO TaLEntEd iM GOnNa StAN FoRevER" but it's just they change the concept and...
Karen yeah fr
Exactly. I love Clc for who they are and im upset I didn't stan them from the start.
Yeah, I'm sad I only discovered them like 3 months ago :( they're so talented 💜💜
ikr
I became a fan bc of this comeback hehe
Happy birthday to ELKIE.
I hope everyone sees this and vote for Choi Yujin at Girls Planet 999.
for people that say that this is a CUTE CONCEPT, the story of this MV and the lyrics have a dark and sad story,
The girls first were happy because they waited for love for so long until they finally got it. This guy wanted to meet them on the same park as the music video, and the girls waited and kept waiting for him, but he never showed, that's why they say "where are you?" multiple times on the song. (In the chorus part). If you search the lyrics, YeEun's rap says: "without you, this has no sense". The girls then felt sad and they falled in depression, until they ended by taking their own lifes. AND THAT'S WHY they are like, so pale and also dressing up with just white clothes at the final part of the MV, which makes us understand that those are the girl's ghosts, waiting for the reunion with the guy that left them alone
(wow it's been a year- anyways yea ill leave this as a theory because i went over the line with the depression thing)
Is this just a theory?
@@Elena-ib5gf no, because even the lyrics tells you the whole story (yes it is)
This is literally an angsty fanfic- q _ q Ma girlS
this is a huge stretch lmao if you actually read the lyrics, its just a sad song about heartbreak and being ghosted. what you wrote sounds like an angsty pre-teen fanfic
lmao, don't write theories saying as it's official. That was just so cringy. CLC would never lmao
this song is beautiful. whoever says it's bad and not worth listening to should get their ears check... i mean are y'all okay???? how can you not love this absolute masterpiece???
the use of mirrors here is cool
insane how in 2017 clc was given two title tracks in a row that would pass as 2022 releases
SORN'S "I never knew" IS BEAUTIFUL
UH RIGHT!?!? ITS SO SMOOTH THIS WHOLE SONG IS SO SMOOTH I LOVE IT
Best songs of CLC ever but nobody know
fr where are you, clc TTTTT
Happy birthday "where are you?" 🥰🤍
This is art ,guys.
I think cube is trying to show what CLC is. Back when they debuted it was announced that they where the sister group of both 4minute and APink. And I think cube is trying to prove this versatility with the CRYSTAL(4minute) concept and this(APink) concept.
Nawi XXI crystal is different to mold and is strong which is strong concept while clear is purity, cleaness which is an innocent ,cute concept. Versatility is in the face of clc name
nostalgia
The most underrated release but their best one in my opinion. Truly a city pop anthem. They were ahead of their times
I like groups that aren't afraid to branch out
"Every adventure requires a first step"
for the first time clc charted in 5 music charts for more than 12 hours IM PROUD
Taeil Bloom really??? What music chart? When? Wow thats a great step...
MelodyCheshiresUniverse I know they charted in Sorbida (?) and bugs for over a day and charted on naver for 12 hours but I can't remember what the others were
M 9922 wow thats a great achievement, slowly gaining chart is a great way that they are recognized on korea
music charts like soribada, olleh, naver, genie & bugs although they didn't charted on melon or mnet it's still okay
their peaks are
Olleh - #5
Genie - #56
Bugs - #52
Soribada - #73
Naver - #92
and yes olleh and some others charted for a day and it's a website, search for example (soribada top 100)
I'm cried, im cried~ while listening this song and elkie's solo song called I dream. :'(
Ok now "Where Are You" CLC
We're waiting (sobs)
so many of y'all uglies commenting! I too payed attention to CLC when Hobgoblin came out, but it was obvious they weren't going to keep that concept. To the people complaining about the badass concept, did you purchase that album? Did you stream it? The badass concept didn't do well in Korea so, cube wasn't going to keep doing something that wasn't working for the girls. Now if that concept had broken chart barriers and sold even more copies, maybe then we could have talked about unexpected change of concept.
This concept isn't even a "cute" concept which you guys like to label on every single girl group. Just because they have on girly clothes and soft styles does not automatically mean cute. This is an 80s style song, that is feminine but does not use aegyo, or cute poses. Also the girls vocals can be heard well. They are not high pitched in a cutesy tone ex) OC 'Aing'.
I love cute concepts but learn how to identify the difference between concepts instead of just labeling something pink "cute".
Aimee M. go off sis!
Aimee M. Deserves to be top comment^^
Aimee M. CUBE FIX IT
+SO ICE ICE BABY right? its like more mature/feminine than thier previous concepts, Im really digging it. Plus the album was good. I loved every song on crystyle and now Free*Sm is showing such a nice side to them, loved every song as well! This is a great fit.
Aimee M. Are you saykng they're not cute here? How dare you. Lol. I loved hobgoblin, and they could have gotten more attention nationally if they continued it. Ex: black pink; CLC could have been that other badass group since no one really does it. YG shouldn't be the only 1 to find success with it.
The aesthetic of this MV is amazing
My favorite CLC song
The most underrated comeback
Who's here after Seunghee redo their best work!?🙌
Clown Boss TV meee
Meeeeeeerr
People really out there complaining about this concept saying Hobgoblin was better and completely ignoring the fact that Pepe exists? I love this song and the concept, it suits them and they look really elegant.
I am darclua who is you Well, Pepe and Hobgoblin are fucking bops, even high heels. But tbh... This one isnt for them. I mean, I love them and appreciate every song from them but I think Hobgoblin's concept was made for them. Still love the song tho.
Yes I loved me some Pepe. I actually love the hyper cutesty side of them like Pepe & they rocked hoboglobin 😍 they can do anything and I'm still in love 😍
This song never popped up for me, i just heard about it in a reaction and looked for it. i feel like i sleep on their non-hits. This and To the Sky are both really solid. i'm going back through to find more missed gems.
i never liked Pepe, so i was a bit late following them. i think Hobgoblin is their best song, inspite of it copying Hyuna's rap tone(style is fine to copy).
yes in fact the song really relax me
Aaron Kepley HyunA wrote Hobgoblin
Yooo only 2m?!? How? This is a certified bop
Coming here the song is not appreciated by many because of Hobgoblin was Hype in 2017 but look at this masterpiece... No one can done of this like CLC did.. What a versatile QUEEN
Stop sleeping on "eodiya" she deserves better
If you really want CLC to be succesful don't only focus on youtube views, BUY THEIR ALBUM
That's how you support your artist, if you can't afford it then focus on streaming it. Every bit of support counts, the album is actually really good, we can't let this flop guys
I agree but if for some reasons people call this "a flop" then it clearly means that this concept isn't (this people) cup of tea. We cannot expect them to buy an album they dislike
On the other hand, I just really hope they will finally get the recognition they deserve.
I have been waiting forever so I can buy it off iTunes... it hasn't been released yet TT
BREATHE IF YOU THINK BTS ARE THE BEST Hello fellow Army, you are so right, we must do whatever we can, the album is really good. Regardless of what some are saying, the concept change suits them well. I became a fan because of Hobgoblin but I appreciate this concept too, I love everything about this comeback. Love ur name btw 😁
Perscenthe I bought it two days ago! It became available!
I saw on hanteo that clc only sold two albums today...TWO😭😭😭😭😭
this is still one of their best comebacks to this day. didnt deserve to flop.
I miss you eunbin
Unpopular opinion: it’s their best song
Idk about best song but definitely my favorite CLC song. Now this is Really an unpopular opinion
YES
this is EXACTLY my style, i love almost anything that has 80s vibes because it reminds me of my childhood :') and the visuals are AMAZING! the girls are beautiful, their dancing is cute, the aesthetic and concept..just everything works so well together. i'm gonna stan!
sebaekxingmi an intellectual
Even though 80s was not my childhood, still love this too :) it is beautiful, I agree
@@Kata_Rini’m elkie’s age heh but my mom was young in the 80s so i listened to a lot of the music growing up! it’s so good 🤌
i miss you clc :(
one of my fav title song... just wrong timing.
even tho they changed their style from hobgoblin honestly, i kinda like this one lell it seems more original and unique like the velvet side of RV
That's what I was thinking.
rys s i agree its a nice song but sadly the velvet side of RV never sold as well T_T
ThatNORMgirl The velvet side of rv did sell well in Korea. That's why they had 5 wins. But international fans didn't like it as much.
Scarletrose23 When i say sell as well - i mean *compared to their red sides* , not *other grps sales.*
Their velvet sides usually sell less than a quarter of what their red sells :(
_IMO you shouldnt use just 'One of these nights' to compare but also their other velvets cos even One of these nights sold abt 1/3 of the other red sales_
ThatNORMgirl I used ootn because the other songs were in the era when they weren't popular. Even happiness didn't do well. But I see where you're coming from.
clc ahead of their time, everyone is releasing city pop retro concepts now 😌
I cant believe people actually hate this song
It’s about to be 2022. Y’all still need to rerelease this song.
People with taste: *watches this in 2020*
Peple with taste also watch it in 2021 😍
@@lisatran6690 people with taste watches this in 2022
@@cinnamorolI. People with taste watches this in 2023
2021
As a non-Cheshire and casual K-pop listener, I vote this as CLC's best comeback/concept so far. It's not too cutesy-cringey like Pepe or High Heels were, or overpowering like Hobgoblin. It's feminine, elegant, classy, natural…it matches the idea of "crystal clear" the most. The song's great, so is the dance. Hopefully they try more slow/ballad songs in the future (:
❤️❤️❤️
this song is one of their best songs, but int. fans would rather have hobgoblin, while korean fans would rather have high heels.
but i guess only a few like this.
Same even though im an international fan
Yeah fell in love with this at first listen and didn't know that they released this
Pepe is not a comeback it’s a debut
i miss you yujin
Beautiful retro Kpop sound, like Wondergirls Reboot album.