Quick Tap: England v South Africa Post-match Analysis

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 114

  • @sakhiledlamini8867
    @sakhiledlamini8867 4 часа назад +21

    Saffa here🇿🇦 Make Marcus Smith your flagship 10. He’s top shelf.

  • @philipnorton5866
    @philipnorton5866 7 часов назад +9

    First time listening to this channel. Top analysis. Really enjoyed! Thanks, new subscriber 👍

  • @krlauf5307
    @krlauf5307 5 часов назад +9

    England very good team, it's going to happen for you guys soon.

  • @markbruce7674
    @markbruce7674 7 часов назад +21

    It's frustrating playing the Boks... every team they played this year they have shut them down in the last 20min. Teams think they have a chance of winning but don't....another that slipped away is not the case with the Springboks...they have become masters of the last 20min game...

    • @optoms1178
      @optoms1178 6 часов назад +4

      True. NZ used to do this

    • @matthewarmstrong1521
      @matthewarmstrong1521 5 часов назад +3

      That’s a good point, can’t remember when we last conceded a try in the last 20 minutes. Very reminiscent of New Zealand in 2011-2015

  • @Wolf-hh4rv
    @Wolf-hh4rv 8 часов назад +12

    SA here, thought England played very well. Underhill is really good

    • @peternagy-im4be
      @peternagy-im4be 8 часов назад +3

      Boks way better. Much stronger plus flair. Great wingers.

    • @jskok3280
      @jskok3280 4 часа назад +3

      So he's actually on top of the hill.😂

  • @rassienortier5096
    @rassienortier5096 5 часов назад +7

    What makes Kolbe even better, doesn't matter the size in front of him, he will take hom down. He's got a heart of a Buffalo/Rino

  • @krlauf5307
    @krlauf5307 5 часов назад +9

    Underhill an absolute destroyer!! Real English bulldog.

    • @yeahdefinitely6607
      @yeahdefinitely6607 4 часа назад +2

      Agreed - and yet he isn’t in Borthwickw’s top tier of paid players

    • @trimad6128
      @trimad6128 3 часа назад

      Yep he’s been badly missed in the previous tests

  • @TP1988
    @TP1988 3 часа назад +6

    Underhill is incredible. It’s almost a shame that he and Curry are so similar in age, as neither feel easy to leave out.
    I think Curry can work with more combinations as he has such a broad game; but my God, Underhill is just an animal, feels like one who always has to start if fit

    • @martynslinn6607
      @martynslinn6607 2 часа назад

      Couldn't agree more, for all his faults Eddie Jones started with him and Curry, their job was to wreck the opposition game play and it worked.

  • @simonsmith-x8y
    @simonsmith-x8y 5 часов назад +2

    Fantastic insightful breakdown of the game thank you

  • @garyr1522
    @garyr1522 3 часа назад +1

    Excellent analysis, thanks

  • @MarkoCoomo
    @MarkoCoomo 2 часа назад +1

    Great vid, thanks. Very happy when Underhill got called up after being left out. Sure, we got the early try and got the crowd up, but then the Boks split our defence open for 3 tries in aboit 10 minutes, which was just deflating. We seem allergic to taking the lead.
    Boks were good, but we made them look good too.

  • @seamus9750
    @seamus9750 2 часа назад +3

    A GBR without hask is a good listen 😊

  • @DoddyIshamel
    @DoddyIshamel 12 часов назад +4

    Congratulations Alex.
    It's really quite Grim for Borthwick. 8 wins from 21 against tier 1 opponents of which 2 Italy, 3 Wales and 2 Argentina. Only the Ireland win against a top side.

  • @andrewkeppler1000
    @andrewkeppler1000 4 часа назад +3

    Scrap the ban on overseas players would help strengthen England squad.

  • @BretIrwin-pv4rd
    @BretIrwin-pv4rd 7 часов назад +5

    England played well. Real grit. Marcus is a really amazing 10. More nervous with him paying than Farrel. The Bok Backs are phenomenal and we have a country full of them. Bokke. So proud of this team!

  • @ianjacobs2998
    @ianjacobs2998 10 часов назад +10

    Playing at 60% and winning is phenomenal 👏😮

    • @optoms1178
      @optoms1178 6 часов назад +1

      That's accurate! Imagine what will happen when we're at 100%

    • @LindilechristopherMgqobele
      @LindilechristopherMgqobele 3 часа назад +1

      DNA setup we were designed to do so!❤❤😂😂😂

  • @normanbarrett1307
    @normanbarrett1307 2 часа назад +2

    If England played Ireland next week, they would win. The tide will turn, the glass is filling up past half already. I will always support the team playing England, but I am expecting to be disappointed more often next season.

  • @peterp9918
    @peterp9918 5 часов назад +1

    100% agree about Underhill

  • @mikecl8803
    @mikecl8803 7 часов назад +8

    Not sure why everyone is being hard on england, they might be losing but definitely getting better. Think these big games this autumn will do them well for the 6 nations. Im south african, but think england jist need to work on the last 20mins, that is where they lose it. Got ro improve the bench,

    • @rodwellchigome7567
      @rodwellchigome7567 7 часов назад

      They have lost 3 in a row at home. Of course they should be pissed or despondent.

    • @mikecl8803
      @mikecl8803 3 часа назад

      @rodwellchigome7567 that's true, but England are just going through what we went through for 3 years, had the odd good game, got clapped in others, im starting to see an improved England side that are going to be dangerous, once they get the bench sorted out and play 80min.

    • @rodwellchigome7567
      @rodwellchigome7567 3 часа назад

      @mikecl8803 Definite improvement for sure. But losing can become a bitter habit. 6Ns first 2 are up against Ireland and France. England's recent wins have come against Wales and Italy only.

    • @mikecl8803
      @mikecl8803 3 часа назад +1

      @rodwellchigome7567 yeah I agree sadly losing can become a habit, like winning does too, but, England did beat Ireland last 6 nations and very nearly beat France , so they win big games, I just think once they click, they will be top of the north again, Ireland are great, but look to be on a slight decline, don't think they will fall yet, still got some great players coming in. Wales is an example of a team never trying new players, building depth at all, it was win at all costs, they were damn good during their time, but as soon as good players started retiring, never changing their style, same game plan every game, they never bleed new players or changed there game plan, not sure how they going to recover at the moment, England is evolving, a little slower than I'm sure there supporters want, but they are definitely.

    • @SteveWarlee
      @SteveWarlee 2 часа назад +2

      ​@@mikecl8803
      Klapped 😂😂.
      U can't expect the poms to understand clapped other than clapping bro.

  • @matthewbazeley2984
    @matthewbazeley2984 4 часа назад +1

    England's game is showing signs of where they are heading, I think it's really promising. Steward had a great game but I think its a big ask for a man of his frame to tackle international wingers and he gets exposed on 1-2-1's. I'd love to see him at 12.

  • @rodwellchigome7567
    @rodwellchigome7567 6 часов назад +1

    Our Boos didnt even get out of 2nd gear. Gave Eng multiple opportunities to get back into it.

  • @martynslinn6607
    @martynslinn6607 2 часа назад +1

    If everything is broken but nothing is getting fixed points to two things, we have not got a leader on the pitch and we have not got one off the pitch. If Borthwick stays he then needs to lead and England need a leader on the pitch not necessarily a Captain

  • @fionnmckool
    @fionnmckool 6 часов назад +4

    England has improved a lot. However without Smith you are lost. Where is the new blood. 5_6 new guys should have been blooded. Management not looking to future, getting a win was more important.

  • @floatpoint1050
    @floatpoint1050 5 часов назад +1

    Not a peak springbok performance, but I am also hoping that we don't peak too soon before the next WC.

  • @davidpells4298
    @davidpells4298 4 часа назад +2

    England have tons to be positive about .For starters Marcus Smith probably best nr 10 in the World right now ..They look just a few yards off the pace ..Very few ...Boks depth but more importantly experience pulled this off ...Give England time ...as a Bok fan we get having to be patient and frankly went thru the exact same process in Rassies early year or two .He had a 50% win record .Same as Borthwick..If I can be critical, Steve Borthwick cannot tie Rassies shoelaces when it comes to communicating these processes in a brutally honest way thereby buying time with the fans and of course media .. Borthwick is a closed book Needs to open it a bit methinks ..

  • @paulrooy371
    @paulrooy371 10 часов назад +17

    Thank you England for a proper Test!
    English supporters... your team is not as bad as you think... don't give up on them.... keep making your tweaks and start finding a way to win...
    Our Boks didn't maybe play at 100% but when you've got enough standout brilliant performances and a culture of winning it's always going to be difficult for any team playing SA....
    Well Done Boks! Heart & Soul of SA!
    🏉🏉 RWC 2027 🏉🏉
    Boks for The Win!!! Back-to-Back-to-Back Champs!!!
    🚀💥🎉🚀💥🎉🚀💥🎉

    • @optoms1178
      @optoms1178 6 часов назад +1

      Yes 🇿🇦🇿🇦

  • @bigowl2542
    @bigowl2542 3 часа назад

    Goode analysis…
    Always wondered why Alex didn’t get more chances with England. I am a believer that England would have gone further if they had used the Farrell Goode partnership the way Saracens did. Surely when you have a team competing and winning Europe you take that into your national team.
    When all is said and done Goode will go down as one of the Prem’s best ever players/full backs and should be considered Mr Saracens. Personal highlight was the season Saracens beat Clermont in the final. Thought Goode was the best player on the pitch that game and the whole European comp he was unplayable. I remember they compared him to Willie Le Roux who was at wasps, Goode was superior in all the stats, incredible player and importantly a nice bloke. Wish him all the best.

  • @optoms1178
    @optoms1178 6 часов назад +3

    The Springboks weren't firing at all cylinders, but we still managed the win. Imagine what it'll be like when in top form! Let's go Bokke 🇿🇦❤️🇿🇦

  • @woesmevrou5673
    @woesmevrou5673 2 часа назад +1

    Damian de Allende is a superstar! But so is Marcus Smith!

  • @woesmevrou5673
    @woesmevrou5673 Час назад

    It’s a South African thing to grab a chance moment and turn it to an advantage. England had chances and did not capitalise. Marcus Smith can’t be the only one who makes magic happen on the field. There were plenty of moments that I was tense - the Boks were not exactly playing the way I expected, except in flashes.

  • @AshtonCarolus
    @AshtonCarolus 8 часов назад +1

    Game Management asd the ability to adapt in situations is the difference between winning and losing for Eng. Its has become increasingly apparent of their predictability in the last quarter of the game. Just a simple mindset change and maybe some leadership on the field would love. Damn Owen Farrel is the difference.

  • @TimboStash
    @TimboStash Час назад

    Loving goody's comments. Only thing I'd add is that Borthwicks snoozey personality and his data driven approach is lettung us down hence the switch offs (not necessarily his fault but..). The boys need coaching to become 'mentality monsters'. I don't think that's his forte

  • @samu-n1m
    @samu-n1m 4 часа назад

    Good luck to the green machine but Smith was our headache ,From the 50th minute onwards I noticed the faces of the English Looked tired

  • @BrettStealth
    @BrettStealth 7 часов назад +2

    Etzebeth played centre at school level

    • @Wolf-hh4rv
      @Wolf-hh4rv Час назад +1

      Except matric, coach moved to lock

  • @matthewarmstrong1521
    @matthewarmstrong1521 6 часов назад

    The boks did well vs 16 men in my opinion. But in all seriousness Steward is a massive problem for us. He is the best in the air. I think the difference between the sides was South Africa know how to win.
    We played three 1 point wins in a row in a World Cup. So the players know how to win and win big moments. They don’t panic and they don’t give up. Someone always steps up. To play the springboks is hard but to play the best springbok team this century is truly daunting. England don’t need to be too hard on themselves. They are going to be a problem in 2027. This week they just came across a team that have forgotten how to lose and are the master of the last 20 minutes

  • @marco-dn7kd
    @marco-dn7kd 5 часов назад +1

    Happily enough for the rest of the world, Pollard will not last forever to finish the job like he did yesterday and at the last RWC. Libbock is not of the same league when facing the posts.
    I am sure that England will be ready for the 6 Nations and the wind will eventually turn.
    I did not know this excellent show yet, congrats Andy!

    • @jerrybuirski2344
      @jerrybuirski2344 Час назад

      Be afraid, be very afraid, Sacha FM will be the Bok flyhalf at RWC27!

  • @danraine
    @danraine 6 часов назад

    I consume a lot of rugby content, including subscribing to Charlie’s telegraph for the rugby articles. This analysis is very thoughtful and added some much needed nuance and layers vs the usual ‘England are the worst team ever, and I blame [select player person thinks should never play for England again]

    • @danraine
      @danraine 6 часов назад

      Except the force field comments 😂

  • @paulchristopher8634
    @paulchristopher8634 12 часов назад +15

    Sorry but Coach Steve Bothwick has had two years to gel a winning team but he has failed miserable. How much longer will the RFU give him

    • @loki_of_earth
      @loki_of_earth 11 часов назад +6

      Until the next world cup. He was low on experience when he became England coach and is still learning on the job. I'd still rather have him than his predecessor but would've liked to have seen either O'Gara or Townsend instead.

    • @fionnmckool
      @fionnmckool 5 часов назад

      Give Felix jones the job

    • @matthewarmstrong1521
      @matthewarmstrong1521 5 часов назад +3

      South African here, England will click and when they do they will win 80% of tests they play

    • @AZJZ97
      @AZJZ97 5 часов назад +1

      You can’t judge him from the RWC year. He did the best he can with his limited time with the playing group.
      Though this year has been abysmal but England are only just off the pace. They’ve competed in every one of their losses. They’re marginally off the top teams; the gap needs to be closed during the 6N. Anything below 2nd place would be a failure

    • @ianwardle7523
      @ianwardle7523 5 часов назад

      @@AZJZ97he’s useless!

  • @domknill
    @domknill 5 часов назад

    England are a frustrating team to watch. They’re close to being a really good side but something isn’t working. Individual errors are costing them in attack and defence and there is a distinct lack of cohesion. We lose the ball inoffensive positions too frequently instantly putting our defence under pressure and giving opponents easy points. I feel this reflects the churn of coaches, especially in defence. I worry that our coaches aren’t world class in any area and it seems like an old-boys club. We are relying on individuals to make it happen rather than team plays. I’m going to keep faith though.

  • @loki_of_earth
    @loki_of_earth 11 часов назад +1

    Alex Goode should've had more England games. Regardless, his analysis is great, some rugby iq I hope England will tap into when he hangs up his boots.

  • @andrewharris1837
    @andrewharris1837 10 часов назад +10

    Too depressing to review England.Even against 14Boks they cant game manage their way out of a wet paper bag😮

    • @peternagy-im4be
      @peternagy-im4be 8 часов назад

      They will continue to lose to the good teams home and away. This will not change.

  • @stevehicks5780
    @stevehicks5780 2 часа назад

    Give Borthwick the 6 nations to prove England potential and if he doesn't deliver, sadly, he'll have to go.

  • @davidwalker2402
    @davidwalker2402 2 часа назад +1

    Everybody raves about smith, but he was tired 20 minutes to go and made many mistakes. He cannot long kick he cannot long pass and in fact he very rarely passes. He looks great because he trys to do it all himself instead of organizing his team and driving them thats his job and he is not that good at it.

  • @stevewturnbull
    @stevewturnbull 2 часа назад

    You can analyse all you like but the bottom line is England lack a nucleus of world class players with the ability to change a game with a moment of skill. Smith is the only one in that category.

  • @Alex-mj5dv
    @Alex-mj5dv 6 часов назад +2

    Smith is a masterful attacker and creative as they come.. he still can’t seem to manage a tight game, and he’s nearly at 40 caps now. He was running in circles like a headless chicken at the end, devoid of ideas.
    Few players are being found out at Test level.. Randall - his pass is not good enough. Freeman.. well, he’s great for Saints, but he’s not Will Jordan.
    Sleights attacked well but defensively poor, as may be expected with inexperience.
    I’m not sure on Ollie Lawrence either, even at his preferred 13, with more space, attack and defence was poor - but for sure, the centre partnership is still clunky.
    Congrats though Goodey !!

  • @simonhemphill2013
    @simonhemphill2013 7 часов назад

    Regarding the lineout we should appreciate that South Africa have one of the best defensive line outs as well as attacking. Englands line outs plans had to be designed around that, trying to avoid the opposition’s strengths. They will learn a lot from this experience

    • @danraine
      @danraine 6 часов назад

      The low-risk plan was pretty well executed, secured a few penalties, but as Goodie said makes it very hard to launch an attack from. End up running Early as first receiver to get some front foot

  • @tonyalways7174
    @tonyalways7174 5 часов назад

    The 6N will decide Borthwick’s fate. I’m expecting England to be in the top 2 and that would keep him in his job. Below that and he’s done.

    • @jonnygeorge7325
      @jonnygeorge7325 5 часов назад

      After the 1st two matches of the 6N it will be over - we will be 2 defeats from 2 and then attempting to scupper wins against Wales and Italy and playing for some form of pride against Scotland. In fact, Scotland is our level at the moment (even though they beat us regularly), we fight it out with them for 3rd place.

  • @gerardglines2566
    @gerardglines2566 7 часов назад +1

    Borthwick gone ? Also skipper scum half full back center !

  • @nialllennon4664
    @nialllennon4664 7 часов назад

    England's defence is so bad. Genge was scorched by the SA 9. Not his fault, but a prop shouldn't have been there.
    Later Kolbe was left unmarked in a wide channel leaving Steward with too much ground to cover.
    England didn't protect their no9 at the base of rucks which lead to charge downs.

  • @fredkelly6953
    @fredkelly6953 4 часа назад

    England still want to drop kick their way to glory. It is that last quarter mindset that has to change because you stop pressuring the other team, you lose the killer, it's what happened to New Zealand this wee, but it's almost written into the English dna, it has to change and that means a new coach.

  • @pdewaal100
    @pdewaal100 2 часа назад

    A lot of ifs & buts from Goode 😂

  • @theschoolformen3665
    @theschoolformen3665 3 часа назад +1

    Poor referee, he should’ve worn all white, all decision were reversed after highlights

  • @SteveWarlee
    @SteveWarlee 2 часа назад

    I think England played well. SA were uncohesive.
    Power wise SA just muscled their way to victory. SA individually won that game. England asleep marking kolbe. The only time libbok did anything useful.

  • @simsimvuyele5494
    @simsimvuyele5494 4 часа назад

    If Wiese is not first choice who is, Grant played well, Fassi did nothing special also nothing really terrible.

  • @MobBarley00
    @MobBarley00 10 часов назад +4

    I thought England were very good in many parts of the game. Would be a bit stupid to get rid of Borthwick now if you ask me.

    • @ColinAnderson-hy2oj
      @ColinAnderson-hy2oj 9 часов назад

      Agreed. Get rid of RFU's governing body!

    • @markbennett9787
      @markbennett9787 7 часов назад

      I agree, the only person I would like to see in his place is Rob Baxter and I wouldn’t want to see him enticed away from Exeter at the moment.

  • @annettekolb3103
    @annettekolb3103 7 часов назад +1

    England you gave us a good run to the point where i stopped watching.
    Borthwick must just stop trying to copy Rassie. He will never be Rassie. Borthwick must bring his experiences to the team not the boks experiences.
    Good luck word on the street Cheka next in line after Borthwick's contact end after this tour

    • @ianwardle7523
      @ianwardle7523 5 часов назад

      I’d take anyone over Borthwick.

  • @davidpearn2484
    @davidpearn2484 7 часов назад +1

    england back's dreadful defending absolutely dreadful.

  • @brizzleb-n2r
    @brizzleb-n2r 5 часов назад +2

    Why isn't anyone saying it how it is?
    1. England don't have the squad depth and quality in all positions, our poor bench highlights this.
    2. We can't defend and are lightweight in the backs, all teams keep spreading it wide and scoring tries for fun.
    3. We lack an inspirational, alpha leader and captain who will kick ass if the team aren't doing what they are supposed to do.
    4. Nice guys finish last, English people are too polite, we need to win ugly sometimes, and get into opponents heads, look at Rassie.

  • @Marius_vanderLubbe
    @Marius_vanderLubbe 12 часов назад +4

    The rugby world is happy. An excellent France v AB'S game and another loss for ros bif!

    • @PatrickKelly-lz3pv
      @PatrickKelly-lz3pv 8 часов назад

      Glad your happy Jock.

    • @Marius_vanderLubbe
      @Marius_vanderLubbe 8 часов назад

      @@PatrickKelly-lz3pv 'You're' - using the economy of the Scots there, Jock.

    • @Marius_vanderLubbe
      @Marius_vanderLubbe 7 часов назад

      @@PatrickKelly-lz3pv 'You're', Jock.

    • @jonnygeorge7325
      @jonnygeorge7325 4 часа назад

      Despite a golden generation and a home World Cup, France have won one trophy in 14 years 😂😂.

    • @trimad6128
      @trimad6128 3 часа назад

      Original!Your one brain must be working overtime🙄

  • @theschoolformen3665
    @theschoolformen3665 3 часа назад

    Talking kak, Jasper is our first choice 8

  • @marioadams8931
    @marioadams8931 3 часа назад

    England kicks too much position away

  • @janniemeyer9951
    @janniemeyer9951 4 часа назад

    In the end the only difference was the genius of one or two players in a team. In this case it was Kolbe. Every team should have Kolbe, Dupont. Ex factor, individual brilliance.

  • @SpencerCourtis
    @SpencerCourtis 8 часов назад +2

    THREE BLATANT NO TRIES!
    Knock on overlooked - England first try. Brutal off the ball tackle on Labock by England overlooked - England second try. Forward pass by England overlooked - England third try.
    Has this something to do with the multi-billion $ betting industry or as per normal, bias towards South Africa?
    Not to mention the 'forward pass' try denied South Africa!!!

    • @glynmatthews678
      @glynmatthews678 6 часов назад

      😂... slightly biased analysis

    • @jkmb5758
      @jkmb5758 6 часов назад +1

      Sure, I also thought there was inconsistency in the officiating and I understand that it's difficult to be gracious in defeat, but at least let's try and be gracious in victory.

    • @Topaz2008
      @Topaz2008 6 часов назад

      Don't do that, be sad, be angry, be disappointed BUT don't do that, it makes you look bitter and ugly..... Springboks won because they were the better team on the day, don't become like the All Black's who becomes THAT when they loose, when we lost to Ireland and Argentina we too could have picked all the decisions that went against us, but the difference between South African supporters when we lose we BLAME our team for their purformance try it, it helps you sleep better

    • @SpencerCourtis
      @SpencerCourtis 3 часа назад

      @@jkmb5758 one plus one equals two. If we overlook that and go for one plus three quarter equals two, no matter how gracious that may sound, it will negative impact the greater truth.

    • @trimad6128
      @trimad6128 3 часа назад

      Sad man

  • @davidbrown2571
    @davidbrown2571 2 часа назад

    England's tackling has been poor .

  • @fabianelliott96
    @fabianelliott96 6 часов назад

    England or Engshit