What are Primaries and Caucuses in US Presidential Election? Pros & Cons of this system explained

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 дек 2024

Комментарии • 381

  • @StudyIQEducationLtd
    @StudyIQEducationLtd  4 года назад +16

    Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Facebook - facebook.com/gauravgargeducation
    Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Instagram - instagram.com/tirelesssoul/
    Follow Dr Mahipal Rathore on Instagram - instagram.com/rathore.mahipal
    Follow Dr Mahipal Rathore on Facebook - facebook.com/mahipalrathore

    • @vishwa5315
      @vishwa5315 4 года назад

      What are swing states?

    • @AbhisekMahato07
      @AbhisekMahato07 3 года назад

      @@vishwa5315 There were no domination of any parties, they are neutral in nature for both parties...

  •  4 года назад +172

    Yes India should also have primaries and caucuses! These parties are selling tickets to criminals and naxals which is unfair!!!

  • @parthparikh2500
    @parthparikh2500 4 года назад +36

    I think primaries should be held in India as well. Also tv debates of pm and present of India.

  • @somnathdey4376
    @somnathdey4376 4 года назад +138

    BJP mein primary hogi toh Modi hi jeetega lekin aisa election Congress mein hua toh phir Rahul Gandhi kahi ka nahi rahegaa (saydd) chahe kissibhi Indian states mein pehle ho.

    • @nihitshrivastava2502
      @nihitshrivastava2502 4 года назад +7

      Bhai yehi toh baat hai... Ek baar ko BJP me ho bhi jaye.... Congress me kabhi nhi hona.. yaha pe Rahul-> priyanka -> priyanka ka bada beta(naam nhi pta) unke PM candidates rahenge...!

    • @kirtisuretiya568
      @kirtisuretiya568 4 года назад +3

      are pahle video me procedure ko samjho bhai....kuch bhi bolne se matlab hai?

    • @MJZ1708
      @MJZ1708 4 года назад +2

      Or media me.debate hogi to Modi ki kya bol pynge

    • @zekekace6882
      @zekekace6882 4 года назад

      @@MJZ1708 bhai modi bolne ma boht aage ha.

    • @MJZ1708
      @MJZ1708 4 года назад

      @@zekekace6882 yha bolna nhi pdta facts pr debate krna pdta h Kabhi debate dkhlna American candidates ki

  • @mathstoday5399
    @mathstoday5399 4 года назад +30

    Without internal democracy we can't imagine true democracy

  • @desidiplomacyjaipur
    @desidiplomacyjaipur 4 года назад +26

    मतलब IOWA ,US का उत्तर प्रदेश है।

    • @singh3331
      @singh3331 4 года назад +1

      😹👍

    • @aditeerao9455
      @aditeerao9455 4 года назад

      Kya baat kahi ye to mere bhi dimag mein aa gya tha😂😂😂😂

  • @mohitmudgal.1803
    @mohitmudgal.1803 4 года назад +2

    Yes ...aisa Hona Chahiye...issue democracy aur strengthen hogi...

  • @bali208
    @bali208 4 года назад +25

    Sir..we need a video on how Gaplaa happens in National convention

  • @funnybones7951
    @funnybones7951 4 года назад +1

    Sir ty, for the rich content video. VOTE SWITCHING ALSO NEEDS YOUR EXPLANATION.
    In india surely this system needs to be introduced.
    1. We're deceived most of the times when our MP or MLA switches party bordering our consent , for their transient benefit .
    2. A fresh start will go with internal democratic system within political party ,curbing Father to son ticket transfer legacy .
    3. Sense of National interest will pervade and healthy debates will expose the inclination of candidate.
    4. "We the people of india" will really(indeed not by metaphorical deed) be able to frame our fate .

  • @BrijeshKumar-dy1rn
    @BrijeshKumar-dy1rn 4 года назад +4

    Yeah, in my book this primary and caucus method can improve functionality of our democracy and
    credibility of candidate can be tested and by this process citizen can understand which candidate is preferably good, we will not bound any more to choose some whimsically raised delegates and any political party, it's all what I think

  • @sonugurra5716
    @sonugurra5716 4 года назад +9

    Yes... This method should be there... It will make our democracy strengthen..

  • @singh3331
    @singh3331 4 года назад +2

    caucus is where they can debate and select, while primaries is where they vote and select without discussion ; many states have caucuses while others have primaries ; primaries evolved from caucuses to weed out corruption and bring in transparency

  • @SahilKumar-fh4pr
    @SahilKumar-fh4pr 4 года назад +12

    Sir , I want a video on " How America an oil deficit country is now exporting the oil to other countries" ?

    • @sv-yk5gi
      @sv-yk5gi 4 года назад +1

      They have shale oil in excess...which they export.

    • @sunilmishra1736
      @sunilmishra1736 4 года назад

      They got a reserve of potential oil in Atlantic Ocean by excavation..

    • @singh3331
      @singh3331 4 года назад

      Google "fracking"

    • @aditeerao9455
      @aditeerao9455 4 года назад

      @@singh3331 thanxxx pal!!

  • @yogendrapratapsingh7639
    @yogendrapratapsingh7639 4 года назад +4

    Thanks 🙏 Mahipal Guruji

  • @ankitchaudhary9856
    @ankitchaudhary9856 4 года назад +2

    Sir, please make a video on "vote switching" that you'd mentioned.

  • @shailmasti3228
    @shailmasti3228 4 года назад +4

    Yes
    This system should be in our country also
    It will be a much better system that present "high-kamaan" culture

  • @piyushparasar5963
    @piyushparasar5963 4 года назад +2

    Please make a video on convention.... It is interesting to know about his procedure

  • @Niksa3.0
    @Niksa3.0 4 года назад +74

    This system will be nightmare to all other parties except BJP....all know the reason....parivar hi party he

    • @nihitshrivastava2502
      @nihitshrivastava2502 4 года назад +4

      Well said bro..!

    • @MdShadab-jt5rg
      @MdShadab-jt5rg 4 года назад +5

      RSS is a parents of BJP. So BJP v isi (parivar) category me ata hai.

    • @Niksa3.0
      @Niksa3.0 4 года назад +14

      @@MdShadab-jt5rg RSS me sabka naam Gandhi ya modi nahi he Bhai. You can join RSS and with your remarkable efforts you can also become next PM or CM.

    • @shakirmushtaq8038
      @shakirmushtaq8038 4 года назад

      The Bharatiya Janata Party has emerged as the largest dynastic party in Maharashtra after the assembly elections with as many as 16 MLAs from political families entering the assembly.
      In fact, in percentage terms, BJP has emerged as the party with best success rate of dynasts in both Maharashtra and Haryana elections.
      jis jis ko moaka mila hai us ny loot liya . y would not politicians son/daughter be politician, when in the real terms it is the best post anybody can have.

    • @MdShadab-jt5rg
      @MdShadab-jt5rg 4 года назад

      @@Niksa3.0 ha bhai tumhare is baat ko mai accept krta hu bt India me koi v party independent nai . jaise congress k dekh lo jo v high post pe hota hai wo gandhi family se hi hota hai bt BJP v isi relationship wali category me hi aati hai qke jo RSS me hota hai whi BJP k high post pe hota hai.

  • @parshantverma6267
    @parshantverma6267 4 года назад

    Yes sir make video on switching .....plz

  • @saumyaranjan5071
    @saumyaranjan5071 4 года назад

    Sir! How can we relate it with proportional representation. Make a video please regarding this

  • @gauravsoni4027
    @gauravsoni4027 4 года назад

    Yes, absolutely possible. And it's right way to choose right candidate.
    And it's overcome is always positive and for development.

  • @ajittogaur6304
    @ajittogaur6304 4 года назад

    Vote switching kya hai sir bataye

  • @WolfPanchal
    @WolfPanchal 4 года назад +6

    we too must have this system

  • @syasifiqubal2110
    @syasifiqubal2110 4 года назад +1

    Yes
    ..they must learn from us

  • @anshrajput3970
    @anshrajput3970 4 года назад

    Banayiye video sir.. vote switching pr

  • @satviktripathi4390
    @satviktripathi4390 4 года назад +3

    Yess sir plz make a video on switching in national convention of American election

  • @nishant9895
    @nishant9895 4 года назад

    Yes I India should have Primaries and Caucaus , It will brighten up the Election nature In India and also makes the Democracy stronger at National Level as well as International Level.
    But keep in mind the Drawbacks of this System.... We will have to try to improve the this system to makes it better in Indian Phenomenon.

  • @akshayshukla3260
    @akshayshukla3260 4 года назад +2

    Sir..I think it will be great for our democracy bcz many celebrities are being elected and given by parties and they don't know local problem..

  • @_AkashsainiH
    @_AkashsainiH 4 года назад

    As my opinion a type of system like primary and caucous must be included so that party members have a choice to select who will got tickets.

  • @jaimingirigauswami5170
    @jaimingirigauswami5170 4 года назад

    Yes India need this system

  • @ayushsrivastava767
    @ayushsrivastava767 4 года назад +1

    Sir your videos are the BEST on study iq platform

  • @ashutoshprabhat3553
    @ashutoshprabhat3553 4 года назад

    Yes sir primary system or something like that, should be in Indian electrol system also.

  • @sauravsagar3022
    @sauravsagar3022 4 года назад

    Plz make a more detailed video with pros n cons on us elections

  • @schakraborty95
    @schakraborty95 4 года назад

    India must adopt this concept

  • @pawanmehta6552
    @pawanmehta6552 4 года назад +3

    I think ye system India main bhi hona chahiye taki political parties ki internal democracy bani rahe
    Aur candidates ka selection democratic process se ho

  • @SangeetaKumari-fw2us
    @SangeetaKumari-fw2us 4 года назад

    Yes Primary and Caucus process should be in India also but one the basis like Super Tuesday.
    Due to lack to these type of process in India sometimes party itself nominates criminal record candidate.

  • @kiran-bf2jj
    @kiran-bf2jj 4 года назад +68

    यहां तो राहुल गांधी सारे Iowa aur caucus जन्म से पहले ही जीत गया है

  • @sauravsenapati377
    @sauravsenapati377 4 года назад +1

    Sir make another video on switching of votes...

  • @amankhalkho9859
    @amankhalkho9859 4 года назад

    Yes sir plz make another video for general knowledge

  • @vatsalgokani7371
    @vatsalgokani7371 4 года назад

    Amazing source of information for a completely unaware person like me, thanks a lot STUDY IQ 🤘🏻

  • @deepaparikshit3130
    @deepaparikshit3130 4 года назад +1

    Yes, that seems to be a good thing because knowledge of candidates in all matters can be tested by the public. Goonda elements with muscle and money might be sidelined. Neither people like Rahul and Sonia can escape scrutiny.

  • @AjayYadav-ko5pu
    @AjayYadav-ko5pu 4 года назад

    Yes Sir please make video on National Convention , General election ,electoral college ..the all process, elaborate it sir

  • @saij910
    @saij910 4 года назад

    Sir, please make a video on “vote switching “

  • @golujadoun5289
    @golujadoun5289 4 года назад +1

    Make vedio on VOTE SWITCHING

  • @ayushsrivastava767
    @ayushsrivastava767 4 года назад +1

    I loved the video sir
    Please do more videos like this
    And also do more on America
    I personally want to see more on America
    This is my personal view

  • @navneet2649
    @navneet2649 4 года назад

    @10:20, who bears the various costs associated with each delegate - the presidential candidate by himself or the party allocates funds to presidential candidate so they can further spend it on their delegates? Are funds equally allocated to the presidential candidates by the party?

    • @mahipalrathore1
      @mahipalrathore1 4 года назад

      Candidates run funding campaign to gather money.. Visit any candidates website and check.

  • @akhilrohilla1979
    @akhilrohilla1979 4 года назад +1

    Ha sir another video banao

  • @raviraut8313
    @raviraut8313 4 года назад

    Please come with next video as you mention

  • @vijaytalwar5662
    @vijaytalwar5662 Год назад

    Primary elections are conucted by political party or state government?.

  • @ankurshukla6637
    @ankurshukla6637 4 года назад +1

    Sir..
    Is it possible that you made this video after seeing a video from VOX...
    IF yes than its very good...

    • @mahipalrathore1
      @mahipalrathore1 4 года назад

      Made a video about entire election system 3 years ago..but couldn't cover this aspect in detail.. Was waiting for primaries to start from that time... To make this video.

  • @sv-yk5gi
    @sv-yk5gi 4 года назад +3

    We have multi party system its very hard to make this system into effect though this is very effective system and its very hard to control our population.

  • @RaviRanjan-dq3ct
    @RaviRanjan-dq3ct 4 года назад

    Yes please make video on convention

  • @abhaysingh8151
    @abhaysingh8151 4 года назад

    Yes ,it should also be follow in india

  • @srinidhikedilaya7639
    @srinidhikedilaya7639 4 года назад

    yes in India there should be primaries and caucuses so as to end dynasty politics and to have a strong effective opposition. Primaries and caucuses should become law and ECI should ensure it.

  • @kajaljha2719
    @kajaljha2719 4 года назад

    primary and caucus Is the process that takes much time as well as money also, India can find out the any other way like this process so that any comman person can fight for election.

  • @BeesWho
    @BeesWho 4 года назад

    Hi, Please make video on National Convention as well. Thanks

  • @ramadharchouhan9705
    @ramadharchouhan9705 4 года назад +3

    India me aisa Hona Chahiye ki kis seat pe kaun lade party k worker decide kre by voting..

  • @prajetadebroy
    @prajetadebroy 4 года назад

    In our town Municipal Election Nomination done by Caucuses

  • @googlesignin9563
    @googlesignin9563 4 года назад

    Yes It must be in India too.

  • @jayantaborah8053
    @jayantaborah8053 4 года назад

    Sir USA ka election model India me v hona chahiye.. Kya yeh possible he karna?

  • @Jeenuagrawal
    @Jeenuagrawal 4 года назад

    Please make video on vote switching

  • @ankurshukla6637
    @ankurshukla6637 4 года назад

    Sir
    To how much I know..2 states in USA have different electoral college voting system..e.g.if there are 5 member of Representatives seats in a state and if a party wins 3,,than all 5 goes to his party...but not all state have it...
    Can u make a video on that...please...

  • @login..3164
    @login..3164 4 года назад

    Sir you say seating president rarely challenged by other person bt if any person whose are 2 times in seating president then which process party choose his candidate.. Eg former president election

  • @KALKISENAPATI
    @KALKISENAPATI 4 года назад +2

    👍👍👍👍Indian democratic process is best❤️❤️❤️ just wait some time this will shine after some purification process 💐💐💐

    • @mohdsalim8839
      @mohdsalim8839 4 года назад +1

      What is this purification? Pls elaborate

    • @manishmohit3726
      @manishmohit3726 4 года назад

      What purification? Only ‘purification’ I know is “purges”.

  • @aktiwari5778
    @aktiwari5778 4 года назад

    राज वंशो के प्रति भक्ति ये भारतीय जनमानस का hidden secret है।

  • @celestialkakashihatake4697
    @celestialkakashihatake4697 4 года назад

    Sir please make video on National convention too.

  • @Nitishkumar1516713
    @Nitishkumar1516713 4 года назад +1

    Make a video more about US election especially convention.

  • @Amitdas-gk2it
    @Amitdas-gk2it 4 года назад +11

    Rotation hona chaiye every year taaki every state Ko pehle mauka mile.

  • @anshushashank3910
    @anshushashank3910 4 года назад +2

    Sir you have already made video on us president election

  • @hariomkumarpremjee8887
    @hariomkumarpremjee8887 4 года назад

    Sir maleshiya ke new PM mohiudin yashin par please video banaye

  • @ankitranjan4130
    @ankitranjan4130 4 года назад

    yes please sir make video on complexity in national party convention

  • @bwz_prashant
    @bwz_prashant 4 года назад

    Sir, Mahipal sir ke sabhi video me volume Thora kam rahta hai than Study IQ other videos. Please look into it

  • @niteshgangani1825
    @niteshgangani1825 4 года назад

    It should be done.

  • @bkr8890
    @bkr8890 4 года назад

    भारत में कॉकस जैसी समूह सभाएं और प्राथमिक चुनाव चुनावी प्रक्रिया को और जटिल बनाएंगे, पर दलीय राजनीति में सुधार की भी प्रबल सम्भावना होगी। हां उम्मीदवारों की सार्वजनिक सत्यापन/स्क्रुटनी अवश्य होनी चाहिए

  • @pankajrawal941
    @pankajrawal941 4 года назад

    Sir plz make a video on convention
    Or how to shifting take place in this process

  • @DileepYadav-bc6vt
    @DileepYadav-bc6vt 4 года назад

    Sir how you collect all these information and how much time does it take to create one video?

  • @milanswarnim
    @milanswarnim 4 года назад

    ofcourse it is not only possible but also necessary.

  • @piyushparasar5963
    @piyushparasar5963 4 года назад

    Wow such a good informative video.. Thank you sir

  • @rinku405800
    @rinku405800 4 года назад

    Sir publically elected, who our leaders choose

  • @alimohtashimkhan2711
    @alimohtashimkhan2711 2 года назад

    Beautiful lecture.

  • @navneet2649
    @navneet2649 4 года назад

    @04:50 , who can vote for delegates in Caucus/Primary - any citizen or only those citizens who are either member of democratic or republican party?

    • @mahipalrathore1
      @mahipalrathore1 4 года назад +1

      Every state has different rules for that. Some states only members allowed.
      Some states, anybody

    • @navneet2649
      @navneet2649 4 года назад

      @@mahipalrathore1 Thanks a lot sir for ur reply! Feeling blessed to have have got a reply from a personality like you!

  • @manishmamgain11
    @manishmamgain11 4 года назад

    Normal people khn apna voting right use karte hai sir??

  • @rhythmjoshi3864
    @rhythmjoshi3864 4 года назад

    Seperate video on vote switching please...this question was lingering in my mind since long

  • @vishwa5315
    @vishwa5315 4 года назад

    What are swing states?

  • @mdtariquehashmi4358
    @mdtariquehashmi4358 4 года назад

    Try to another video on this topic

  • @jayantjaiswal5
    @jayantjaiswal5 4 года назад

    yes this should be done in India

  • @navneet2649
    @navneet2649 4 года назад +1

    Video needed more clarity! A lot of major ques were unanswered in the video! Pls try to make part 2 of this video to explain the unanswered ques if one video becomes too long!

  • @neerajomkashyap4671
    @neerajomkashyap4671 4 года назад

    Yes it should be in India

  • @shanti4969
    @shanti4969 4 года назад

    Yes india should also do primary type internal election.

  • @Anaishabhakti2209
    @Anaishabhakti2209 4 года назад

    Definitely yes

  • @ashishkn95
    @ashishkn95 4 года назад

    yes please make a video

  • @sanganivikash1632
    @sanganivikash1632 4 года назад

    It can be ,but not yet.India should make more robust democracy.Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @competitionclasses5275
    @competitionclasses5275 4 года назад

    Yes sir It should happen

  • @navneet2649
    @navneet2649 4 года назад

    @07:25, what abt a citizen who is not a party member of either democratic or republican party, can he not vote in Primary/Caucus for a delegate?

    • @mahipalrathore1
      @mahipalrathore1 4 года назад +1

      In some states. Not all.. Rules differ state to state

  • @shubhamtiwari5460
    @shubhamtiwari5460 4 года назад

    Very interesting and unique subject ! Great to watch !

  • @xyzrana3808
    @xyzrana3808 4 года назад

    Very well-explained!

  • @sanyamjain2315
    @sanyamjain2315 4 года назад

    Yes sir banao video

  • @Krishna-cx2gk
    @Krishna-cx2gk 4 года назад

    Yes, this party democracy is very good idea, and in India it will be breakthrough if adopted. But like in USA small states will have less role compared to large states. This loophole should be taken care of before adoption of this idea.

  • @imranhussain1315
    @imranhussain1315 3 года назад

    Area wise alaska bada ha. Not texas

  • @AJ-gk3jk
    @AJ-gk3jk 4 года назад

    Yes it can be done sir ji