Assalamu alaykum, sheikh jazakallhu khayr, At present many are not following Madhabs. Madhabs made our job easy may Allah (swt) give blessings and peace to the Imams of four Madhabs for making our job easy.
There is a difference between following and blind following. And most importantly, the religion is the quran and sunnah. Nothing else. We take wisdom from the salaf-us-saalih, from the 'ulama, from the madhahib on issues we do not know off, but generally, no we should not simply follow a madhhab.
@@vkak1 assalamu alaykum, brother all four Imams are early generations their knowledge and fear of Allah were more than ours. All of their rulings came from Qur'an and Sunnah. If we follow we should follow one otherwise we will pick and choose which will be choosing from our desire. But those are very knowledgeable like Muhaddithun or Mufassirun they are different. Allah knows best, we try our best. Jazakallhu khayr.
@@Life_Is_A_Test Wa 'Alaikumussalam...no. You need to verify according to the Sunnah. Some of their opinions were not correct. For instance, placing the hands below the navel (hanafi) versus on the chest. The authentic ahadeeth says chest. I'm not saying you cannot follow one, but do not blind follow. Ever!!! The 'ulama themselves says not to do so - Shaykh Al-albany made an entire essay on it, and the imaams themselves said not to blind follow them. People say "I'm hanifi" or "I'm salafi" - no you're Muslim....plain and simple. As a non-scholar, you do have to listen to the scholars....but choose them, see their evidence, their arguments...and judge then. If the matter is not clearly in the Quran or hadeeth, then you can default to the scholar you trust most, as their opinions are from a place of knowledge. However, you should also listen to all of them and see how and why they choose the position they did. We are not incapable of judging from that level.....
@@vkak1where are your qualifications where you can ‘judge’ from that level. If you’re such an 3alim and think you can, all the best to you brother. Otherwise follow a madhab, and there’s vast amounts of adila which exist to prove the necessity of a madhab. Let me give you an example Imagine there are laws, and there are institutions which have studied and interpreted the laws for you through years and juhd, because Allah had chosen these authorities for a reason to be conveyors of the laws. All the madhahib are ahl sunnah, and they all derive from the Quran and sunnah. But to think you are qualified (which I can guarantee you are not, no offence) to make your own judgment is a mockery to your religion.
As a reverted I already do like this( not following any sheikh ) because I am not actually enough knowledgeble to realize Who Is the good scholar and Who Is not. And as I see many muslims fighting over the divergence of opinion of their own scholars ,I prefer to Stick Just on basic knowledge of islam that everyone Agree about.
If a scholar or shaikh is upon Quran and Sunnah learn from them if you see them against it or not from the Sunnah then leave them be. There are great Scholars in islam from past (and present) and you have to look towards Companions of the prophets and 3 fav generations all together to gain knowledge from, at least.
You have a couple of choices. Research for a course in Islamic studies, eg International Open University or, in the absence of starting a formal course, get your advice from the imam at the local mosque you prefer. Don't just accept advice, even if well meaning. Allahu alim.
I try to follow the opinion of the majority of scholars since I don't know enough to choose to follow a madhab nor do I know someone who I can completely follow, but if you want an indicator to who trust you should look at the ones who bring hadiths and Quran and doesn't bring any outsider ideology, for example if they believe in "human rights" or feminism or they try to bend the Quran to suit modern standards or theories, or those who go against what's appearant from hadith and Quran to follow a philosophy. You can distinguish them easily and I almost fell to some of them but subhan allah when someone follows falsehood he doesn't stop at a single issue but they rather go overboard with it until it's appearant.
Its fine to stick to one sheikh, just dont be too fanatic with them and admit it if they make mistake. Also its important to not taklid (following them blindly without consulting quran and hadis)
Don't be a gair muqallid but don't also be a blind muqallid where even if there are clear hadiths about a ruling and you still blindly follow an opposite one.
they aren't dividing it but they have different meanings in Quran without getting away from the correct meaning and Sahaba had different meanings of Quran and it was ok no one said they were wrong
@@user-ib3oe7bv2n ohh ok. Where did he get his education from and from who. How long has he been studying and who gave him his credentials. This guy is a former personal trainer who popped out of nowhere and all of a sudden he is a scholar. He is a tiktoker. Don't get your Deen from tiktokers. I am telling you that this guy is as much a scholar as you and I are Tell me one reputable scholar who advocates for him
i think you got it wrong this time brother your answer is right but he didn't ask it regarding seeking knowledge but to defend whoever he follow like hanifi, makliki, shafaee, hanbaly. that's what i got from the question.
MAZHAB isn't always right. There are some mistakes in all madhabs. So we shouldn't blindly follow a madhab. I don't think that we should follow any madhab at all. Since it's not mandatory for us. Instead we should always strive for knowledge. ALLAH made us as the greatest and the most intelligent creatures on this whole universe. So I think that we should use our brain sometimes instead of blindly following a madhab. ✌️
Yes yes you are so right.. Next time wen ur mom gets sick dont take her to a doctor.. ALLAH has made u the smartest, learn medicines and heal her by urself.. Ok brother???
It's better to ask who's knowledgeable At the same time use common sense In today's age we have internet live shows and Videos of well known Sheikhs It's really easy to ask and find
But how if for some cases we follow another madhab ? Like for example, we pray down prayer with qunut like madhab imam syafi'i, but in other case we follow madhab hanbali, that it is okay to touch your wife before prayer, as what prophet Muhammad salallahualihi wassalam did by kiss Syaida Aisyah RA, kiss her forehead before he prayed. How about this case ?
Did you learn tawhid The beautiful names of Allah Fiqh Hadith Osol al fiqh Osol al hadith Nahw Poetry Jarh wa ta'deel If not then know that the ocean of islamic knowledge is endless to our minds You still have a long way akhi
@@Oussama-sabouh you didn’t even mention Quran. I noticed that none of these salafi duat have memorised Quran, it’s not that important to them, their enemies and people they refute are the huffadh amongst the Muslims
The Mashaykh were on a payroll in the times of the khilafahs too. Doesn't comrpomise their loyalties. Bro they are dedicating their whole lives to ilm, if they don't take payemwnt from the rulers, you want them to take money from the general masses?
@@ChosenOne563 ulul Amr does not include scholars. You should listen to scholars to learning the religion but here the verse specifically talks about people in power i.e Rulers and governments
The questioner was asking is it OK to be a salafi however bro faris never understood it correctly since this terminology is used by deobandis to attack salafis
@@RN-bo4zz Explain what you mean? The differences between Salafis and Deobandis is not just a few fiqh issues. Deobandis are predominantly Ash’ari/Maturidi in Aqeedah. Some of them call upon the dead like the Shia. Many of them follow Sufi beliefs and practices and innovate in the religion which is common in the subcontinent among a lot of Muslims. Many (if not all) blind follow the Hanafi madhab religiously. They are not all on the same level of misguidance but I’m not sure what you mean ‘two sides of the same coin’
@@user-hc1fm9vh8t deobandis hate sufis and anything to do with the grave worshippers. They acc try their hardest to not be associated with the sufis and try to make themselves out to be the 'real hanafis'. By two sides of the same coin i mean, the enemy of my enemy is my friend sort of thing. - i am aware they are NOT exactly the same.
Assalam Alaikum I am living in a floor which has non muslims too. People are cooking pork without putting lids on their pots so I am afraid the steam would contaminate my food. Is it forbidden to live with non muslims in that case? Also whats your opinion on shared fridge and microwave where food doesn’t touch?
Ghair muqallid meant to say following shafayi, hanafi etc. One has to follow Allah and his Rasool (pbuh). Any proof about madhabs in Quran and sunnah.? No. .. QURAN AND HADITH IS SUFFICIENT. We do respect the work done by them. what requirements are you talking about given by Allah? What madhab you follow? What you answered please quote Quran and Hadith for this.
@@mohonaferdoussosi1708 A Muslim woman may wear whatever hijab she wants, so long as she does not wear a colour that is only for men, and she does not wear a garment that is an adornment in itself and doesn't show her awrah
"They have taken their rabbis and monks as well as the Messiah, son of Mary, as lords besides Allah, even though they were commanded to worship none but One God. There is no god ˹worthy of worship˺ except Him. Glorified is He above what they associate ˹with Him˺!" [9:31]
31. “They have taken their rabbis and monks as their lords”. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself explained its true significance. According to a tradition, when Adi bin Hatim (may Allah be pleased with him), who was formerly a Christian, came to the Prophet (peace be upon him) with the intention of understanding Islam, he asked several questions in order to remove his doubts. One of these was: “This verse accuses us of taking our scholars and monks as our lords. What is its real meaning. For we do not take them as our lords.” As a reply to this, the Prophet (peace be upon him) put him a counter question: “Is it not a fact that you accept as unlawful what they declare to be unlawful, and lawful what they declare to be lawful?” Adi confessed, “Yes, it is so.” The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied, “This amounts to making them your lords.” Incidentally, this tradition shows that those who themselves set limits to the lawful and the unlawful without the authority of Allah’s Book, assume for themselves the rank of godhead, and those who acknowledge their right of making laws take them as their lords. It should be noted that they have been charged with (a) attributing sons to Allah, and (b) giving the right of making laws to others than Allah. These are to prove that their claim that they believed in Allah is false, even though they should believe in His existence. But such a wrong conception of Allah makes their belief in Allah meaningless.
He already did. Being knowledgeable enough to know what is haram, or halal, or what is right, or wrong, or what are the interpretations of Hadiths. That's what the scholars do that ghair muqallid don't follow.
The people who say i don't follow any Madhab or any of the 4 Imaam, i would urge you to don't send ur kids to school for education, teach them at home and when anyone gets sick in ur family don't go to a doctor. Learn medicines and heal them ok??
@@Azamkhan-yv5th no muhammad and his companions were the best and knew better So you should follow the hadith dalil if the madhab goes against it Some scholars have said its an obligation to follow the madhab of your country and when there is dispute between the words of our prophet sallalahou alayhi wa salam and between a madhab you have to follow the hadith proof
What if one follows the 5 pillars of Islam, doesnt get involved with riba or zina, follows the dos and donts of the Quran to the best of his/her ability, however does not pledge allegiance to a particular Sheikh, but follows the teachings of many different Sheikhs that make sense...would such a person in the eyes of muslims be classed as a muslim or a deviant.
So ineffect, to be a true practising Muslim, one has to follow the Quran, Sunnah and Sheikh in order to have a chance to attain paradise and avoid punishment. Personally I feel Muslims (especially the ones I have met) simplify their belief structure in order to attract others into the faith, by saying if one recites the Shahaadah he/she is a Muslim. However, when one delves into the actual religion, it is layered in complexity and one has to consult many different books and then the Sheikh for interpretation of meanings etc and even then another group will have a different point of view.
I don’t think there were “mathhabs” at the time of the rasool (peace and blessings on him) or during the sahaba or even shortly after the sahaba. Allah says to follow Quran and sunnah and to ask the scholars of knowledge, not follow a certain sheikh or mathhab.
Brother with respect if you actually read what I said with understanding, you wouldn’t have said all of that. I’ve been speaking Arabic all of my life but I never claimed to know all knowledge, etc. Ofcourse there’s more to learn and can sometimes things can be misunderstood by all of us including in deen. However, all I said was we should learn from Quran, sunnah hadiths, and the scholars of knowledge. So we shouldn’t divide into different math’habs and follow certain scholars/sheikhs etc. This will cause a divide in the ummah no matter how you look at it. So we should ask scholars to explain things that we don’t understand, on rulings, etc etc. but we shouldn’t just follow one with a certain math’hab. We’ll start to argue and fight plus divide overtime weather we like it or not. May Allah keep all of us on the right and bring you blessings, brother.
"You don't think? " explains you're just in thoughts. But there were Sahaba madhabs and difference of their views . Just seek knowledge you'll know it and better not talk of what you've no knowledge about, not everyone is commanded to speak up for Islam. Jazakumullah khayran
@@UMMAHWASATIYYAH “Better not talk of what you know no knowledge about”. You sound arrogant my friend. I’ve never heard of sahaba having madthabs. Madthabs are named after the 4 imams, not sahaba. I have respect for the imams and may Allah give them and all Muslims Jannah. The sahaba may have differed in opinions on some matters, but that’s not whole madthabs. You should take your own advice by saying better not speak without knowledge. Where did you get this knowledge from? You just only made a statement. May Allah bless us all.
There were no madhabs at the time because these people were companions of the Messenger of Allah (SAW), or they had direct access to these companions. Thus, they were the most knowledgeable people of the religion after the Prophet (SAW). Fast forward to modern times: obviously, none of us was alive during the events of the Seerah, so it’s become hearsay. That’s why it’s so important to follow the views of the ones who possess the most accurate knowledge of our religion, and whose work has been widely accepted for generations. This is why we have madhabs: their Imams were highly knowledgeable and respectable Muslims, and their opinions are generally accepted as legitimate by most, if not all, scholars throughout the past 1400 years.
@@ThatsMADDD "I've never heard of Sahabah having madhabs" doesn't mean it's not there Habibi. The most knowledgeable pf Sahabah madhabs it's said to be Ibn Taymiyyah Rahimahullah, and if know the 7/8 Scholars of Medinah during Sahabah error you'll understand what I mean, if you don't go chek it Baarakallahu fiik 😊
Yes, but who is right. So many different schools of thougts, so many different shieks with different interpretation. My inlaws follow something else my parents follow something else, my husband picks and choose something else....So I dont follow anything apart from reading Salah, and trying to do good, and do dhikr and remember my lord.
If you're worried about who's right and wrong, hear all sides of the story, but believe me, most of the time people who do what they do, don't know why they do what they do, nor do they know why they do what they do, nor have they questioned why they do what they do. Be like Abraham, find truth in the ocean of falsehood!
yeah why not, let’s do some low fat shirk by following sheiks and madhabs. because Allah’s Quran and the simple dheen is not good enough. Besides we need to keep 1000’s of sheikhs busy with something to do, otherwise they will have to go and gain some skills and do some work.
I'm not trusting any Sheikh who has studied the religion because Jews did the same and their scholars changed their religion. And people were fooled because they followed the scholars blindly, some xyz scholar knows better than you and following him with blind faith is not Islam. I will never follow some nerd book worm 🪱 who has just read books for 60 years but achieved nothing practical. Rather someone who has studied little but went out and implemented it.
I've read Qur'an once as a whole in translation and I still haven't any madhab, sect, imam or anyone repeat everything I understood there.... Tbh when I read that translation I was having doubts about the authenticity of Qur'an and all, one can change the meaning of words over time and so on, but I read a part in there that sent shivers through my bones, it gave me a literal earth quake, for some time I couldn't even focus as my eyes betrayed me by not being able to focus, but I found my answer there, I've never heard a single imam or Muslim say what saved me from doubting Islam.... I can't find it on the internet either, anyway I'm looking for the said translation, when I find it I'll share the said thing I read. Hopefully that'll be an alarm to people who've gotten too comfortable by the coddling of their sheiks.
@@bim1537 lol, no offense akhi, but you can't pick up a book and understand the scholary works, as 90%+ are only in Arabic, yet alone the hadiths and the Quran itself. You are a Muqallid. We have to stay in our lines
Should women prostrate like a dog with her elbows touching the ground or should the bukhari 532 apply to them too... The mountains aren't made out of a single stone.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 as per hanfee madhab, women should prostrate like dogs... When madhab clash with plain hadith and verses of Quran and people choose not be like jews in following the rabbi/scholars, they begin to doubt everything that was taught to them and when more and more of what they've been taught turns out to be false they become Muslims... As for the people who turn a blind eye to truth, they live their life in ignorance by calling themselves muslims while they're not, while some leave the fold of Islam publicly... A question that stumps all so called Sunni dawah people is , as per Sunni madhabs Qur'an is uncreated word of God and us is co-eternal with God and is thus an attribute of God. (As per all madhabs as far as I know.) Then in the very same Qur'an it is said that isa/Jesus is Kalam/word of God, by the same precedent won't isa/Jesus be uncreated word of God, co-eternal with God and thus an attribute of God.... If you say isa was word converted into man, then in the judgement day Qur'an will come forth as a man shining in light as a witness and as a pleader...
There's also that belief of no free will, and all things we do are done as Allah wills, not by the will of Allah, but as Allah wills. The difference between two being, as Allah wills meaning we have no real control over our actions or intentions, but Allah decides everything for us, making us puppets who think that they have self-awareness and freedom of some sort... While by the will of Allah meaning, Allah dozen't stops us from doing what we intend to do or think, meaning Allah having greater control over us, but we are free to act how ever we like, while what's destined for us is known by Allah already, Allah isn't forcing us to do anything... Btw the example of Qur'an and above concept of free will, kicks me out of the fold of Islam as per the 4 madhabs.... For I believe that there's freewill inbetween the qadr and Qur'an is word of God, is commandment from God, comes from the knowledge of God, is truth from God, yet is still a creation from God, for Allah if so wills can create new humans with different characteristics and send messengers to them in different orders than what is described in Qur'an, for Allah can make new species and send messengers to them....
@@mashpantm3623 the fact that you said Quran is Allah's command (Quran 2 :117) is proof it is uncreated, as Quran 7 :54 separates creation & command. It is from Allah and will return to Allah in end times as Quran 17 :86 says in tafsir ebn Kathir!
Assalamu alaykum, sheikh jazakallhu khayr, At present many are not following Madhabs. Madhabs made our job easy may Allah (swt) give blessings and peace to the Imams of four Madhabs for making our job easy.
There is a difference between following and blind following. And most importantly, the religion is the quran and sunnah. Nothing else. We take wisdom from the salaf-us-saalih, from the 'ulama, from the madhahib on issues we do not know off, but generally, no we should not simply follow a madhhab.
@@vkak1 assalamu alaykum, brother all four Imams are early generations their knowledge and fear of Allah were more than ours. All of their rulings came from Qur'an and Sunnah. If we follow we should follow one otherwise we will pick and choose which will be choosing from our desire. But those are very knowledgeable like Muhaddithun or Mufassirun they are different. Allah knows best, we try our best. Jazakallhu khayr.
@@Life_Is_A_Test Wa 'Alaikumussalam...no. You need to verify according to the Sunnah. Some of their opinions were not correct. For instance, placing the hands below the navel (hanafi) versus on the chest. The authentic ahadeeth says chest. I'm not saying you cannot follow one, but do not blind follow. Ever!!! The 'ulama themselves says not to do so - Shaykh Al-albany made an entire essay on it, and the imaams themselves said not to blind follow them. People say "I'm hanifi" or "I'm salafi" - no you're Muslim....plain and simple. As a non-scholar, you do have to listen to the scholars....but choose them, see their evidence, their arguments...and judge then. If the matter is not clearly in the Quran or hadeeth, then you can default to the scholar you trust most, as their opinions are from a place of knowledge. However, you should also listen to all of them and see how and why they choose the position they did. We are not incapable of judging from that level.....
@@vkak1ok so you take Albani over other scholars then?
@@vkak1where are your qualifications where you can ‘judge’ from that level. If you’re such an 3alim and think you can, all the best to you brother. Otherwise follow a madhab, and there’s vast amounts of adila which exist to prove the necessity of a madhab. Let me give you an example
Imagine there are laws, and there are institutions which have studied and interpreted the laws for you through years and juhd, because Allah had chosen these authorities for a reason to be conveyors of the laws.
All the madhahib are ahl sunnah, and they all derive from the Quran and sunnah.
But to think you are qualified (which I can guarantee you are not, no offence) to make your own judgment is a mockery to your religion.
As a reverted I already do like this( not following any sheikh ) because I am not actually enough knowledgeble to realize Who Is the good scholar and Who Is not. And as I see many muslims fighting over the divergence of opinion of their own scholars ,I prefer to Stick Just on basic knowledge of islam that everyone Agree about.
If a scholar or shaikh is upon Quran and Sunnah learn from them if you see them against it or not from the Sunnah then leave them be. There are great Scholars in islam from past (and present) and you have to look towards Companions of the prophets and 3 fav generations all together to gain knowledge from, at least.
You have a couple of choices. Research for a course in Islamic studies, eg International Open University or, in the absence of starting a formal course, get your advice from the imam at the local mosque you prefer. Don't just accept advice, even if well meaning. Allahu alim.
I try to follow the opinion of the majority of scholars since I don't know enough to choose to follow a madhab nor do I know someone who I can completely follow, but if you want an indicator to who trust you should look at the ones who bring hadiths and Quran and doesn't bring any outsider ideology, for example if they believe in "human rights" or feminism or they try to bend the Quran to suit modern standards or theories, or those who go against what's appearant from hadith and Quran to follow a philosophy.
You can distinguish them easily and I almost fell to some of them but subhan allah when someone follows falsehood he doesn't stop at a single issue but they rather go overboard with it until it's appearant.
Its fine to stick to one sheikh, just dont be too fanatic with them and admit it if they make mistake. Also its important to not taklid (following them blindly without consulting quran and hadis)
Don't be a gair muqallid but don't also be a blind muqallid where even if there are clear hadiths about a ruling and you still blindly follow an opposite one.
As Muslims we have to follow The Quran and Sunnah.
Yes you are right.. Next time wen ur mother did sick, don't go to a doctor learn medicines and heal her ok???
Yes but how much of qur'an and sunnah do you understand? Do you interpret it yourself?
@@Abu_Tuesday very well said brother...
Madhab help us to understand Quran and sunnah
Asalamwww 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Allah bless this Shaikh
آمين يا رب العالمين.
As Muslims we have to follow The Quran and Sunnah.
"With all due respect" wasnt good enough, if you know you know😂
Idk
confusion
What you know?
@@ChosenOne563 sheikh assim says it with the right expressions
جزاك الله خير
What are your qualifications ? You present as a member of the ulimma, are you? Who did you study under?
This is how Muslims STARTS War ? Are you studdnt Engineer
what did he say wrong though? he is right,you cant classify hadiths without help of the shioukh
@@IslamHany-dg6xi didn't you read his comment he is doesn't want get answer how you literally Ask Question Like This Btw I LOVE SHEIKH
He isn’t a scholar and he has said that plenty of times, he’s a student of Aziz Farhan i think
"Indeed Those Who Have Divided The Religion And Become Sects, You (O Prophet Muhammad) Have Nothing To Do With Them"
Quran 6:159
they aren't dividing it but they have different meanings in Quran without getting away from the correct meaning and Sahaba had different meanings of Quran and it was ok no one said they were wrong
This Isn't division... Rather the school we follow for
I follow you sheikh greetings from Germany
I follow sheikh yabooty from Turkey
Don't be gullible This guy has nothing. No qualifications. Follow reputable scholars from the Muslim countries. Not RUclips personalities
@bashird467 As far as I know, he is a scholar
@@user-ib3oe7bv2n ohh ok. Where did he get his education from and from who. How long has he been studying and who gave him his credentials. This guy is a former personal trainer who popped out of nowhere and all of a sudden he is a scholar. He is a tiktoker. Don't get your Deen from tiktokers. I am telling you that this guy is as much a scholar as you and I are
Tell me one reputable scholar who advocates for him
As Muslims we have to follow The Quran and Sunnah.
Follow the madhab but don't give a tag like non believers.
i think you got it wrong this time brother your answer is right but he didn't ask it regarding seeking knowledge but to defend whoever he follow like hanifi, makliki, shafaee, hanbaly.
that's what i got from the question.
Brother Faris clearly mentioned Madhbab.
Yep ❤
❤❤❤❤
I dont think you understand the question, ghair muqalid is a term used by people in the subconitnet to insult Ahlul Hadith/Salafis
Or... it can mean exactly how he understood the question.
He brother Faris has given correct answer though.
His sheikh is chatGPT
I think the questioner is asking if he should blindly follow an imam. And it’s a Urdu slur BTW labelled at Ahlul Hadith.
Allahumma Barek
MAZHAB isn't always right. There are some mistakes in all madhabs. So we shouldn't blindly follow a madhab. I don't think that we should follow any madhab at all. Since it's not mandatory for us. Instead we should always strive for knowledge. ALLAH made us as the greatest and the most intelligent creatures on this whole universe. So I think that we should use our brain sometimes instead of blindly following a madhab. ✌️
Jazakumullahu khayran
Yes yes you are so right.. Next time wen ur mom gets sick dont take her to a doctor.. ALLAH has made u the smartest, learn medicines and heal her by urself.. Ok brother???
@Azamkhan-yv5th my dad's a general surgeon with over 40 years of experience, so you're actually right, 😆 🤣 😆
@@INSERT_YOUR_NAME_HERE you must be really dumb to find my comment funny... Grow up...
@@INSERT_YOUR_NAME_HERE you must be really dumb to laugh at my comment... How old are you??
Than what's the difference between Muslims and Jews, Christians 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
It's better to ask who's knowledgeable
At the same time use common sense
In today's age we have internet live shows
and Videos of well known Sheikhs
It's really easy to ask and find
But how if for some cases we follow another madhab ? Like for example, we pray down prayer with qunut like madhab imam syafi'i, but in other case we follow madhab hanbali, that it is okay to touch your wife before prayer, as what prophet Muhammad salallahualihi wassalam did by kiss Syaida Aisyah RA, kiss her forehead before he prayed. How about this case ?
Assalmualikum akhi is it halal to study philosophy like stoicism
Refrain from it brother it will cause doubts, scholars of the salaf said dont
study Sabr instead, we have everything in Islam and it's without shirk.
Did you learn tawhid
The beautiful names of Allah
Fiqh
Hadith
Osol al fiqh
Osol al hadith
Nahw
Poetry
Jarh wa ta'deel
If not then know that the ocean of islamic knowledge is endless to our minds
You still have a long way akhi
@@Oussama-sabouh you didn’t even mention Quran. I noticed that none of these salafi duat have memorised Quran, it’s not that important to them, their enemies and people they refute are the huffadh amongst the Muslims
@@TefaUKIbn taymiyyah studied it to refute it. Thug life😜
If not following a madhab they follow a sheikh. But isn't following a madhab following 1400 years of the greatest of shayukh?
Sheikh tell me What is the limit of staying gair Muqallid?
But can we follow more than one ?
U can follow the stronger evidence.
The problem is sheikhs are on a payroll so their loyalties are compramised
Is there a problem in being paid?
Doctors get paid also, are you going to question their “loyalties” as well?
The Mashaykh were on a payroll in the times of the khilafahs too. Doesn't comrpomise their loyalties. Bro they are dedicating their whole lives to ilm, if they don't take payemwnt from the rulers, you want them to take money from the general masses?
@@sizosi3238problem is when sheikh is paid he becomes a slave and can't say anything against rulers even if they are bad
@@AbuYusha1425yes
We have to look to the Quran in order to say it is haram or halal not the hadiths
Actually both
Are you from Quraniyoon
Yea dont follow anyone just follow the quran
What about our beloved prophet muhammad sallalahu alayhi wa sallam?
@@bobmabob
Follow him, may God bless him and grant him peace, on the condition that you do not violate the Qur’an
If you stick to the five pillars, THAT’S ENOUGH. no need to shakes or sheikhs. This is not Christianity; No need for a priest. Islam is simple
Quran mention to follow Allah and Rasool and ulul Amr, Ulul Amr are rulers and scholars.
@@ChosenOne563 ulul Amr does not include scholars. You should listen to scholars to learning the religion but here the verse specifically talks about people in power i.e Rulers and governments
The questioner was asking is it OK to be a salafi however bro faris never understood it correctly since this terminology is used by deobandis to attack salafis
I don’t get why deobandis beef salafis.
They’re two sides of the same coin
Both traditional, “Ahle hadith” and all that
@@RN-bo4zzfor real. I never understood that too
@@RN-bo4zz Explain what you mean? The differences between Salafis and Deobandis is not just a few fiqh issues. Deobandis are predominantly Ash’ari/Maturidi in Aqeedah. Some of them call upon the dead like the Shia. Many of them follow Sufi beliefs and practices and innovate in the religion which is common in the subcontinent among a lot of Muslims. Many (if not all) blind follow the Hanafi madhab religiously. They are not all on the same level of misguidance but I’m not sure what you mean ‘two sides of the same coin’
@@user-hc1fm9vh8t deobandis hate sufis and anything to do with the grave worshippers. They acc try their hardest to not be associated with the sufis and try to make themselves out to be the 'real hanafis'.
By two sides of the same coin i mean, the enemy of my enemy is my friend sort of thing. - i am aware they are NOT exactly the same.
@@user-hc1fm9vh8tI haven’t seen deobandis calling upon the dead, but yes they are innovators who also have deviant creed of the asharis
Savage 😅 🔥
As Muslims we have to follow The Quran and Sunnah.
You can also talk about Islam on social media. God knows the difference between treating non-Arab Asian African workers in Gulf countries.
Are u a scholar? The Prophet Muhammed saw came with everything i need. I dont think u know
So what about new reverts?
Assalam Alaikum I am living in a floor which has non muslims too. People are cooking pork without putting lids on their pots so I am afraid the steam would contaminate my food. Is it forbidden to live with non muslims in that case? Also whats your opinion on shared fridge and microwave where food doesn’t touch?
Ghair muqallid meant to say following shafayi, hanafi etc.
One has to follow Allah and his Rasool (pbuh).
Any proof about madhabs in Quran and sunnah.? No. ..
QURAN AND HADITH IS SUFFICIENT.
We do respect the work done by them.
what requirements are you talking about given by Allah?
What madhab you follow?
What you answered please quote Quran and Hadith for this.
wearing colorful jilbab is permissible? ?
Colourful clothes defeat the purpose of hijab and modesty.
😔😔
@vongolaatzi5390 ok i got it
@@mohonaferdoussosi1708 A Muslim woman may wear whatever hijab she wants, so long as she does not wear a colour that is only for men, and she does not wear a garment that is an adornment in itself and doesn't show her awrah
@@lol44658 ok thank you..
"They have taken their rabbis and monks as well as the Messiah, son of Mary, as lords besides Allah, even though they were commanded to worship none but One God. There is no god ˹worthy of worship˺ except Him. Glorified is He above what they associate ˹with Him˺!" [9:31]
31. “They have taken their rabbis and monks as their lords”. The Prophet (peace be upon him) himself explained its true significance. According to a tradition, when Adi bin Hatim (may Allah be pleased with him), who was formerly a Christian, came to the Prophet (peace be upon him) with the intention of understanding Islam, he asked several questions in order to remove his doubts. One of these was: “This verse accuses us of taking our scholars and monks as our lords. What is its real meaning. For we do not take them as our lords.”
As a reply to this, the Prophet (peace be upon him) put him a counter question: “Is it not a fact that you accept as unlawful what they declare to be unlawful, and lawful what they declare to be lawful?” Adi confessed, “Yes, it is so.” The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied, “This amounts to making them your lords.” Incidentally, this tradition shows that those who themselves set limits to the lawful and the unlawful without the authority of Allah’s Book, assume for themselves the rank of godhead, and those who acknowledge their right of making laws take them as their lords.
It should be noted that they have been charged with (a) attributing sons to Allah, and (b) giving the right of making laws to others than Allah. These are to prove that their claim that they believed in Allah is false, even though they should believe in His existence. But such a wrong conception of Allah makes their belief in Allah meaningless.
So when did madhabs come into existence? As mutazilites were killed and their books burnt...
Can you please explain the conditions
He already did. Being knowledgeable enough to know what is haram, or halal, or what is right, or wrong, or what are the interpretations of Hadiths. That's what the scholars do that ghair muqallid don't follow.
Present day moulvis and sheikhs are running a business instead of preaching Islam.
100%halal like the sahabis
The people who say i don't follow any Madhab or any of the 4 Imaam, i would urge you to don't send ur kids to school for education, teach them at home and when anyone gets sick in ur family don't go to a doctor. Learn medicines and heal them ok??
Sure
u dont need to follow a madhab, u can simply follow a sheikh
@@urfellowlibyan the 4 Imaam were the bestest of sheikh.. Till qayamat....
@@urfellowlibyan yep fr
@@Azamkhan-yv5th no muhammad and his companions were the best and knew better
So you should follow the hadith dalil if the madhab goes against it
Some scholars have said its an obligation to follow the madhab of your country and when there is dispute between the words of our prophet sallalahou alayhi wa salam and between a madhab you have to follow the hadith proof
Rabbi faris
What if one follows the 5 pillars of Islam, doesnt get involved with riba or zina, follows the dos and donts of the Quran to the best of his/her ability, however does not pledge allegiance to a particular Sheikh, but follows the teachings of many different Sheikhs that make sense...would such a person in the eyes of muslims be classed as a muslim or a deviant.
So ineffect, to be a true practising Muslim, one has to follow the Quran, Sunnah and Sheikh in order to have a chance to attain paradise and avoid punishment.
Personally I feel Muslims (especially the ones I have met) simplify their belief structure in order to attract others into the faith, by saying if one recites the Shahaadah he/she is a Muslim. However, when one delves into the actual religion, it is layered in complexity and one has to consult many different books and then the Sheikh for interpretation of meanings etc and even then another group will have a different point of view.
@@RandomDNA321 thats the beauty of islam.
Seeking knowledge
@@AnaAthari Mistakenly, I thought the beauty of Islam was in it's simplicity of the message.
@@RandomDNA321 many beauties of islam
@@AnaAthari some kind of contradictory.
How do u know?
I don’t think there were “mathhabs” at the time of the rasool (peace and blessings on him) or during the sahaba or even shortly after the sahaba. Allah says to follow Quran and sunnah and to ask the scholars of knowledge, not follow a certain sheikh or mathhab.
Brother with respect if you actually read what I said with understanding, you wouldn’t have said all of that. I’ve been speaking Arabic all of my life but I never claimed to know all knowledge, etc. Ofcourse there’s more to learn and can sometimes things can be misunderstood by all of us including in deen. However, all I said was we should learn from Quran, sunnah hadiths, and the scholars of knowledge. So we shouldn’t divide into different math’habs and follow certain scholars/sheikhs etc. This will cause a divide in the ummah no matter how you look at it. So we should ask scholars to explain things that we don’t understand, on rulings, etc etc. but we shouldn’t just follow one with a certain math’hab. We’ll start to argue and fight plus divide overtime weather we like it or not.
May Allah keep all of us on the right and bring you blessings, brother.
"You don't think? " explains you're just in thoughts. But there were Sahaba madhabs and difference of their views . Just seek knowledge you'll know it and better not talk of what you've no knowledge about, not everyone is commanded to speak up for Islam.
Jazakumullah khayran
@@UMMAHWASATIYYAH “Better not talk of what you know no knowledge about”. You sound arrogant my friend. I’ve never heard of sahaba having madthabs. Madthabs are named after the 4 imams, not sahaba. I have respect for the imams and may Allah give them and all Muslims Jannah. The sahaba may have differed in opinions on some matters, but that’s not whole madthabs. You should take your own advice by saying better not speak without knowledge. Where did you get this knowledge from? You just only made a statement. May Allah bless us all.
There were no madhabs at the time because these people were companions of the Messenger of Allah (SAW), or they had direct access to these companions. Thus, they were the most knowledgeable people of the religion after the Prophet (SAW).
Fast forward to modern times: obviously, none of us was alive during the events of the Seerah, so it’s become hearsay. That’s why it’s so important to follow the views of the ones who possess the most accurate knowledge of our religion, and whose work has been widely accepted for generations.
This is why we have madhabs: their Imams were highly knowledgeable and respectable Muslims, and their opinions are generally accepted as legitimate by most, if not all, scholars throughout the past 1400 years.
@@ThatsMADDD "I've never heard of Sahabah having madhabs" doesn't mean it's not there Habibi. The most knowledgeable pf Sahabah madhabs it's said to be Ibn Taymiyyah Rahimahullah, and if know the 7/8 Scholars of Medinah during Sahabah error you'll understand what I mean, if you don't go chek it
Baarakallahu fiik 😊
I like to follow you Shaikh
Yes, but who is right. So many different schools of thougts, so many different shieks with different interpretation. My inlaws follow something else my parents follow something else, my husband picks and choose something else....So I dont follow anything apart from reading Salah, and trying to do good, and do dhikr and remember my lord.
If you're worried about who's right and wrong, hear all sides of the story, but believe me, most of the time people who do what they do, don't know why they do what they do, nor do they know why they do what they do, nor have they questioned why they do what they do.
Be like Abraham, find truth in the ocean of falsehood!
Its not recommended
yeah why not, let’s do some low fat shirk by following sheiks and madhabs. because Allah’s Quran and the simple dheen is not good enough. Besides we need to keep 1000’s of sheikhs busy with something to do, otherwise they will have to go and gain some skills and do some work.
I'm not trusting any Sheikh who has studied the religion because Jews did the same and their scholars changed their religion.
And people were fooled because they followed the scholars blindly, some xyz scholar knows better than you and following him with blind faith is not Islam.
I will never follow some nerd book worm 🪱 who has just read books for 60 years but achieved nothing practical. Rather someone who has studied little but went out and implemented it.
I've read Qur'an once as a whole in translation and I still haven't any madhab, sect, imam or anyone repeat everything I understood there.... Tbh when I read that translation I was having doubts about the authenticity of Qur'an and all, one can change the meaning of words over time and so on, but I read a part in there that sent shivers through my bones, it gave me a literal earth quake, for some time I couldn't even focus as my eyes betrayed me by not being able to focus, but I found my answer there, I've never heard a single imam or Muslim say what saved me from doubting Islam.... I can't find it on the internet either, anyway I'm looking for the said translation, when I find it I'll share the said thing I read. Hopefully that'll be an alarm to people who've gotten too comfortable by the coddling of their sheiks.
How to ask you question ❓
you just did
I think it's in his instagram story
Enjoying your Coke Zero ?
I think I do identify as a ghair muqallid. Didn't know the term existed, but I feel like this is okay.
Do you know how to speak arabic?
@@liby254 No.
@@bim1537 So how can you be ghair muqallid lol? The entire religion is in Arabic
@@liby254 Because I can?
@@bim1537 lol, no offense akhi, but you can't pick up a book and understand the scholary works, as 90%+ are only in Arabic, yet alone the hadiths and the Quran itself.
You are a Muqallid. We have to stay in our lines
Any Sheikh can guide people??? I dont think so. Sheikh in this level must undrestand science of Hadith , Rejal , Feghh etc...
I am pretty sure ppl who are muqallid don't become ghayr muqallid overnight, so what is the middle phase? Talib al ilm?
Should women prostrate like a dog with her elbows touching the ground or should the bukhari 532 apply to them too... The mountains aren't made out of a single stone.
@@mashpantm3623 Dont see why Bukhari 532 shouldn't apply to them.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 as per hanfee madhab, women should prostrate like dogs... When madhab clash with plain hadith and verses of Quran and people choose not be like jews in following the rabbi/scholars, they begin to doubt everything that was taught to them and when more and more of what they've been taught turns out to be false they become Muslims... As for the people who turn a blind eye to truth, they live their life in ignorance by calling themselves muslims while they're not, while some leave the fold of Islam publicly...
A question that stumps all so called Sunni dawah people is , as per Sunni madhabs Qur'an is uncreated word of God and us is co-eternal with God and is thus an attribute of God. (As per all madhabs as far as I know.) Then in the very same Qur'an it is said that isa/Jesus is Kalam/word of God, by the same precedent won't isa/Jesus be uncreated word of God, co-eternal with God and thus an attribute of God.... If you say isa was word converted into man, then in the judgement day Qur'an will come forth as a man shining in light as a witness and as a pleader...
There's also that belief of no free will, and all things we do are done as Allah wills, not by the will of Allah, but as Allah wills. The difference between two being, as Allah wills meaning we have no real control over our actions or intentions, but Allah decides everything for us, making us puppets who think that they have self-awareness and freedom of some sort... While by the will of Allah meaning, Allah dozen't stops us from doing what we intend to do or think, meaning Allah having greater control over us, but we are free to act how ever we like, while what's destined for us is known by Allah already, Allah isn't forcing us to do anything... Btw the example of Qur'an and above concept of free will, kicks me out of the fold of Islam as per the 4 madhabs.... For I believe that there's freewill inbetween the qadr and Qur'an is word of God, is commandment from God, comes from the knowledge of God, is truth from God, yet is still a creation from God, for Allah if so wills can create new humans with different characteristics and send messengers to them in different orders than what is described in Qur'an, for Allah can make new species and send messengers to them....
@@mashpantm3623 the fact that you said Quran is Allah's command (Quran 2 :117) is proof it is uncreated, as Quran 7 :54 separates creation & command. It is from Allah and will return to Allah in end times as Quran 17 :86 says in tafsir ebn Kathir!
Completely wrong reply
😂reached level 😂😂😂😂
Bro is gatekeeping knowledge
Ohh just like the Hindus follow a Guru or Baba. Got it.
Not a shiekh
This seems arrogant of the sheiks tho!
School of thought is a business. Stay away from it.
How is it a business?
@@Allahuakbarx1000hanafis are divided into Naqshbandi, qadiri, chisti, suhrawardi , barelvi, Deobandi. Change my mind.
@@Xaviergonzalez85 Abu Hanifah رحيم الله is free from those sufi/misguided sects
@@Xaviergonzalez85 how so are they a business?
U haven't answered my question. A business generates profit. These schools of thought we're made beacuse of difference in opinions.
madhkhali???