The Benchmark Meets The Value Alternative | 2022 Tesla Model S vs 2022 Kia EV6

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 дек 2024

Комментарии •

  • @mitchellsmith4601
    @mitchellsmith4601 2 года назад +29

    You’re a trooper, Alex. You didn’t miss a beat as you were being pelted! A true professional.

  • @joedunc
    @joedunc 2 года назад +8

    Alex on Electrons. I love this channel.

  • @Wised1000
    @Wised1000 2 года назад +17

    I have to agree the Kia and Hyundai are the best EV for the money right now. Personally I preffer the Ionic 5.

    • @KeeperOfTheSevenKeys.
      @KeeperOfTheSevenKeys. 2 года назад

      Yeah, I kind of prefer the Mach E for several reasons but on technical specs, especially that DCFC curve, e-GMP is undoubtable best for money (though no charger routing is a HUGE miss for a car designed to road trip.) Between Ioniq and EV6 I prefer the EV6, I personally hate the Ioniq interior design, though the EV6 is definitely not as cargo or headroom practical.

  • @rratedmotorcyclerides
    @rratedmotorcyclerides 2 года назад +12

    Excellent review we considered a model 3, ioniq5, MG and decided to purchase the EV6 AWD and it's everything good that people are saying about it.

  • @amperformance7998
    @amperformance7998 2 года назад +11

    I appreciate you mentioning that the Tesla's large frunk is possible because of its long hood and large front overhang. One of the primary criticisms of the EV6 in relation to Tesla is the EV6's small frunk, but you're the first reviewer I've seen who put it in context.
    Some reviewers and many commenters attribute the small frunk to poor packaging, when in reality, it is a result of the EV6's low, sloping hood and ultra-short front overhang. Which are unique styling choices made possible by the dedicated electric platform, while also allowing massive passenger space within mid-size exterior dimensions.

    • @GreenBlueWalkthrough
      @GreenBlueWalkthrough 2 года назад

      Porchse, Farrai, Lambo would all disagree as the all have Frunks and trunks it's just expected for a passanger car with out a front engine.

    • @amperformance7998
      @amperformance7998 2 года назад +3

      @@GreenBlueWalkthrough they also all have longer front overhangs and far more space between the passenger cabin and the front of the vehicle, just like the Model S. But is it really expected? Lots of cars without an engine in front do not have a frunk. And not just tiny sports cars, but big people haulers like the Toyota Tarago.
      Sure, Kia could have stretched the nose of the EV6 forward to provide a frunk, but it would have also affected the styling, made the car physically larger, harder to manuever in tight spaces, heavier, and more expensive. Alternatively, they could have pushed the passenger cabin back to provide space for a frunk, but then there would be less passenger and rear cargo space, and the addition of the frunk would not come anywhere near offsetting the space lost in the cabin.
      The obsession with having a big frunk at the cost of everything else is more about novelty and distinction than practicality.

    • @markmiller3279
      @markmiller3279 2 года назад +2

      @@GreenBlueWalkthrough It's a pretfy silly expectation. The hardware can be packaged a variety of ways, and the most efficient packaging usually doesn't leave a lot of unnecessary space in the car's nose unless that's the only space for a trunk. Mid-engined and rear-engined cars have frunks because they have so little room in back. That's just the way their equipment is packaged.

  • @davidjohnson7633
    @davidjohnson7633 2 года назад +11

    Great video! I’m looking forward to more comparisons, including the just released GV60.

    • @normt430
      @normt430 2 года назад +1

      The Cadillac Lyriq has them beat in the $60's.

    • @markmiller3279
      @markmiller3279 2 года назад +1

      @@normt430 The 800 volt charging is a very big deal for some of us. Cadillac has to prove the Lyriq is competitive, while the GV60 is built on a proven platform.

  • @msbgone
    @msbgone 2 года назад +9

    If only the EV6 had the charge door on the other side!! Great vid Alex, these 2 are on the top of my list to get next!! What an ending!!! LOL

    • @joeisawesome540
      @joeisawesome540 2 года назад

      Why the other side? Are you from uk?

    • @msbgone
      @msbgone 2 года назад

      @@joeisawesome540 No from US and my garage is setup with a charge already on the drivers side. Who wants to daily have to walk to the other side of the car and then back to the drivers door to get in. I get overall it may not be a huge deal, but over time it takes more time and it not convenient for home charging. The charge port should always be on the drivers side, whether front or back... NOW if that was designed for the UK that makes more sense! Thanks.

    • @joeisawesome540
      @joeisawesome540 2 года назад +2

      @@msbgone Ohh I see. I found the current door is good for chargers that are on the streets..

    • @msbgone
      @msbgone 2 года назад +1

      @@joeisawesome540 that does make sense since you park on the right side.... Why do I feel they should have one on each side... lol....

    • @joeb4294
      @joeb4294 2 года назад +1

      I had this issue (garage charger and car port on opposite sides) with my i3. My charging cable is long enough that I was able to route it across the ceiling and I installed a cheap EVSE holder on the other side of the garage. It is so much better - I used to to drop the cable on the floor every time I plugged in and then pick up the dirty cable in the morning.

  • @evquietcornerct3210
    @evquietcornerct3210 2 года назад +3

    fantastic ending, great video. i am an EV6 owner and love it.

  • @samaanalkhaldi2364
    @samaanalkhaldi2364 2 года назад +4

    Kia EV6 😍

  • @kennybunker2081
    @kennybunker2081 2 года назад +2

    Dedicated reviewer through rain, hail and probably snow too. 👏🏼

  • @axion8788
    @axion8788 2 года назад +3

    Now, the question is when will the EV6, Ioniq5 and all the other pure EVs actually be available for purchase at MSRP or below. The price gouging on new (and used) (even on ICE cars) is simply out of control.

    • @carguy4life219
      @carguy4life219 2 года назад

      Yea it is insane. I paid $2k over MSRP however I justified by the $7,500 tax credit and massive savings in gas. i end up owing taxes every year so the tax credit really helps and figured I better purchase the car with the tax credit before Kia sells too many EV's which will most likely be soon.

  • @tiger7892
    @tiger7892 2 года назад +2

    I appreciate that you take the time to acknowledge where the vehicles are different because they're targeted at different consumers and price points. Some people just just throw all electric vehicles into the same bucket.

    • @markmiller3279
      @markmiller3279 2 года назад

      What I found surprising was how roomy the Kia was compared to the apparently much larger Model S.

  • @Destorrrrr
    @Destorrrrr 2 года назад +2

    There was not that crazy of a price difference between the Model S and EV6 prior to the $30k price increases since the start of 2021: the Model S was selling for just under $70k from Oct 2020 to Jan 2021. So either it was a $100k vehicle massively underpriced and buyers got them for an absolute steal or Tesla is capitalizing on the supply vs demand dynamic to take in profit on what should be a $70k vehicle and with a price difference that makes more sense for the value added.
    We need more competition to push these prices down

  • @RobStevens64
    @RobStevens64 2 года назад +2

    Loved the dramatic ending to this one, Alex. 🤣

  • @davesutherland1864
    @davesutherland1864 2 года назад

    Hopefully you are back next week without bruises from the hail! Great review - your reviews always come across as very objective, so your comparison is a great way to see how two cars line up against each other without watching a dozen videos!

  • @carguy4life219
    @carguy4life219 2 года назад +1

    I am always very impressed with your reviews. You give the information I need to make a buying decision. I have the same exact EV6 that you have - same trim, same color, etc. I have had it for a little over a month and I daily drive it about 100 miles per day for 5 days week and I only charge it on the 110v and can get through the week easily. So far I am extremely impressed with the EV6 and it never gets old flooring it. On the highway I keep it in ECO mode and use the excellent HDA however off the highway I always keep it in sport mode. My previous car was a newer Lexus RX350 and the car before that was a 2021 Corvette HTC Z51. The Lexus was a great car but a huge snore to drive. I really loved the C8 however it just did not make a good daily driver and I sold it when I could still at least break even on it.
    The EV6 has been a great car for me since it is fun to drive like the C8 but still rides very comfortably with a slight sporty feel. I will be getting a level 2 charger installed soon as my local electric company is rolling out a program for $38 a month for unlimited charging and they come out and install the level 2 charger without any upfront cost and maintain it. The caveat is they configure it to only charge during off peak hours but that is 7:00 PM to 9:00 AM M-F and unlimited on the weekend which are the times I would be charging it anyways.
    Keep up the great reviews!

  • @cobusbotha7256
    @cobusbotha7256 2 года назад

    Very good comparison and video. An umbrella and a wide brim hat for sunny and rainy days in the background would've been very helpful 🙂. Always enjoying the videos.

    • @markmiller3279
      @markmiller3279 2 года назад

      He's in California. The rain and hail this tine of the year was freakish. It almost never rains after March or April.

  • @peterwright837
    @peterwright837 2 года назад +2

    Thanks for the in depth discussion of Eco mode. Since the front motor is disconnected most of the time does that mean the AWD in Eco mode gets the same range as the RWD?

    • @fraserreddick8828
      @fraserreddick8828 2 года назад +2

      A very similar range at least - the AWD is heavier, but does benefit from imroved regen from the second motor

    • @markmiller3279
      @markmiller3279 2 года назад

      It's still a heavier car, but it does have better efficiency than many AWD EVs.

  • @skyemalcolm
    @skyemalcolm 2 года назад

    ABRP on your phone plus a $30 Bluetooth LE ODB2 dongle will absolutely give you live SOC and thus as you might dynamically reroute due to traffic or whatever the new destination SOC on ABRP updates accordingly. I have all this running on my EV6 and it works beautifully.

  • @GreenBlueWalkthrough
    @GreenBlueWalkthrough 2 года назад

    Thanks for the refresher on the charge connectors good info!

  • @tbaker2610
    @tbaker2610 2 года назад

    Way to report in a hail storm-you are the best!

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    Where did we get the Rain? Asking for San Diego.

  • @Jeff-wb3hh
    @Jeff-wb3hh 2 года назад

    Alex, at the end of this video you explained that even GM's Ultium platform is not a native 800v architecture like the Kia and you said the GM charges at 800v but the systems operate at 400v which does not save as much weight saving efficiency as the Kia. Could you explain that in more depth?

  • @CMCNestT
    @CMCNestT 2 года назад

    A decent length hood also adds decent front crumple zones.

  • @Erigion
    @Erigion 2 года назад

    I'm annoyed that the heat pump isn't available on the rwd gt line

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    Tire width on the Tesla is very good.

  • @directorjustin
    @directorjustin 2 года назад +1

    Haha, great video and the ending was funny too! 😂

  • @mavsguy842
    @mavsguy842 2 года назад

    I love your dedication Alex, I hope you survived. To the person who loaned their Model S, I hope it survived unscathed. If I were watching my loaned Model S outside as it began hailing, I'd be mighty worried.

  • @judo-rob5197
    @judo-rob5197 2 года назад +1

    Nice comparison.

  • @hessulipoika13
    @hessulipoika13 2 года назад

    How does tesla peak 250 with 400V system?

    • @EVBuyersGuide
      @EVBuyersGuide  2 года назад

      They push the limits on current, somewhere over 600A

  • @anthonymillett16
    @anthonymillett16 2 года назад

    Thanks Alex!

  • @CSAlso2
    @CSAlso2 2 года назад

    Wow, way to be a pro and finish out the shot, even in hail!

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    Charge station performance is more of a concern for the non-Teslas.

  • @puddleglum5610
    @puddleglum5610 2 года назад +10

    Teslas are insanely overpriced compared to competition, in my opinion. The slight advantages of the Model S do not justify it being double the price.

    • @donwilber1628
      @donwilber1628 2 года назад

      Not only that, if you try to order a model S now, it's delivery shows Nov 2022 - Feb 2023

    • @smartelectriccar
      @smartelectriccar 2 года назад +1

      @@donwilber1628 because demand is so high .... guess the Tesla is just better for many eh?

    • @PNSP
      @PNSP 2 года назад

      @@smartelectriccar This is not the only case for Teslas. I put a deposit down for EV6 and the estimated delivery time is around Dec 2020 - Feb 2023.

  • @williamwu1985
    @williamwu1985 2 года назад

    how about mention of EV6 no battery preconditional and no battery heater in RWD model? make rwd model almost useless during even a mild weather at 35F. (1 hour and 20 mins charging to 80%)

    • @dasunikat1534
      @dasunikat1534 2 года назад

      That is just WRONG. Even in winter conditions it never took more than 40 minutes for me to charge to 80%.

    • @williamwu1985
      @williamwu1985 2 года назад

      @@dasunikat1534 are you having RWD model?

    • @EVBuyersGuide
      @EVBuyersGuide  2 года назад

      All EV6s heat and cool the battery. The heat pump is optional and battery conditioning is done by "winter mode" in the infotainment. A more direct "precondition" option for fast charging supposedly is happening soon but when "winter mode" is enabled the battery will be kept in the right window for DC charging with only limited exceptions.

    • @williamwu1985
      @williamwu1985 2 года назад

      @@EVBuyersGuide the RWD model do not have battery heater, for some reason Hyundai/Kia do not use resistance heater to heat the battery, I am assuming they are not in the same coolant loop. Only AWD model with heat pump some how gets this dedicated resistance battery heater that only heat the battery.
      For AWD model, you are right, we need a battery precondition feature which could coming soon, but from my knowledge , Hyundai/Kia have no ability to do over the air update for anything other than head unit software. I also do not think Hyundai will provide a software update to dealers to do this precondition update since this will make dealer more work load. I heard only 2023 model year will gets this precondition features l, and this is exactly happen in Europe.
      For RWD model, there is no ability to update the precondition feature because the hardware is not there. Some people on RUclips provide ODBii data when fast charge a RWD model, find out the battery heater reading is 0amps drawing compare to AWD models and charging lost(kw showing on EA screen vs kw goes into battery) is much smaller in RWD model vs AWD model. I think they find out about 8kw used for that dedicated battery heater.
      I own RWD ioniq 5 , I test many times that this car need over 1hour from 10% to 80% in the spring time at outside temperature 35F to 40F. And close to 50 mins at 40F to 45 F.

    • @EVBuyersGuide
      @EVBuyersGuide  2 года назад

      This is not correct. The lack of the battery heater feature does not mean the car cannot heat the battery at all. The battery heater is honestly oddly named and the appropriate term would be “additional battery heater”. I have discussed this in depth with the EGMP platform engineers. The cabin heater and heater loop will heat the battery as well, but it will take longer to achieve the same temperature profile if you don’t get the battery heater. The coolant loop is the same in both, the battery heater is not a PTC heater in the coolant loop, it’s a heater pad essentially on the pack in addition to the water loop.

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    I see 240 charging all over for the Hyundai-Kias. They do need heat pump work and better charging prep but... to 80% in 18 minutes.... they should move on to the other challenges.

  • @bdoleza
    @bdoleza 2 года назад

    WOW you should get hazard pay for this video!! You are the hardest-working car reviewer in the game right now, bar none!!

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    Still like the traditional sun roof more.

  • @JW77
    @JW77 2 года назад +1

    South Bay, rain? Are you in a different universe?

  • @tube1906
    @tube1906 2 года назад

    Did you survive the hail storm? lol

  • @ibmtpx24
    @ibmtpx24 2 года назад

    I would like to buy an ev that has the most simplified instrument panel. I ha e essential physical buttons for door lockw, windows up and down, glove box switch, AC and audio controls. I don't want gigantic screens and everything requires my eyes hunting for them behind layers of drop-down and hamburger menus.
    Call me old fashioned but shouldnt it be easier with new technology?

  • @danit5553
    @danit5553 2 года назад

    Kia pays good $$$ for advertising!!!👍

  • @garrettw99
    @garrettw99 2 года назад +1

    I think Elon started the hail storm

  • @Obloms
    @Obloms 2 года назад +1

    I mean video is interesting, but kind of pointless. Different types of vehicles and different price brackets.

  • @igorgetsin3646
    @igorgetsin3646 2 года назад

    Unfortunately good looking EV stopped at Model S and Model X for Tesla. Replaced with "affordable" Model 3 and Y that are not really affordable, but have more cost cutting evidence than Kia Rio. This comparison demonstrates quiet clearly what happens when a company stops innovating. As for the range just remember that EV6 does it with 77kwh battery, Model S ... wait it's not disclosed. If you review old videos of the early Model S 60, 75 and 90 , all these were pretty close in range. Tesla range is not a miracle but a result of ever increasing battery packs.

  • @sprockkets
    @sprockkets 2 года назад

    Probably a better compro is the upcoming electric Genesis G60 or whatever the number is lol.

  • @duanekimball9423
    @duanekimball9423 2 года назад

    How many people can afford a $100K car vs $50K car. It's not 1/2

  • @corpnupe85
    @corpnupe85 2 года назад

    No comparison between a Tesla and a kia.

  • @smartelectriccar
    @smartelectriccar 2 года назад +2

    I’m not cross shopping a Tesla S and a Kia ... one is an incredible technology rocket, and the other appeals to logical budget buyers like Alex

  • @amigatommy7
    @amigatommy7 2 года назад

    The BMW I4 looks awful compared to the GV70 Electric.

  • @adamiq
    @adamiq 2 года назад

    And now bannana box test.

  • @inciwillard991
    @inciwillard991 2 года назад

    Dog mode. None of the other EV's thought about it! I don't camp but I use my dog mode on my model S frequently and if I wanted so many buttons to push I would've hang on to my Range Rover so, there!

  • @rule1capital
    @rule1capital 2 года назад

    Don't compare 2 cars that aren't price comparable... This is just doing Tesla bad... Tesla Model 3 starts at $47,000, even after all the price hikes... Very disingenuous comparison...

  • @chrisfriends7911
    @chrisfriends7911 2 года назад

    The Tesla has 95% more tech features. The Kia is just a basic EV.

  • @danit5553
    @danit5553 2 года назад

    Tesla model S and Kia Ev6 its like Ford Mach e and Toyota Prius!🤦

  • @p3dtesla118
    @p3dtesla118 2 года назад +2

    Nay come on, why are you even compare some garbage kia to Tesla model S NOT compatible at all !! You can compare a Chevy bolt or Hyundai Kona yes, BUT not to tesla !!

    • @DonMulligan1
      @DonMulligan1 2 года назад +1

      yet it would seem fairly comparable in all but price...

  • @normt430
    @normt430 2 года назад

    Hyundai EV's = old Toyota/Honda/Nissan

  • @rolan2dr
    @rolan2dr 2 года назад

    I don’t like kia or Hyundai