Islamic Philosophers Face Off: Suhrawardi’s Light Meets Ibn Sina’s Logic

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 37

  • @arsalanshaikh3763
    @arsalanshaikh3763 2 месяца назад +2

    Very informative video, thanks a lot for sharing.

  • @sheikhishfaq3758
    @sheikhishfaq3758 13 дней назад

    Thanks for such a video

  • @info8595
    @info8595 2 месяца назад +3

    Thoroughly enjoyed this imaginative debate! Suhrawardi undeniably won the conversation with his profound insights and illuminationist philosophy.

    • @mr.safensound4238
      @mr.safensound4238 Месяц назад

      Yet Ibn Sina is one of the father's of modern science that has led us to where we are now. Debating with AI on the Internet. What exactly has the 'profound illuminationist' provided in comparison?

  • @persiancountaryball2775
    @persiancountaryball2775 2 месяца назад

    Very informative and interesting
    Make more such debates

  • @kayan1221
    @kayan1221 2 месяца назад

    Awesome. Thanks.

  • @ShameerShahzad-cj2fd
    @ShameerShahzad-cj2fd 2 месяца назад

    Great!
    Keep it up

  • @africanhistory
    @africanhistory 14 дней назад

    very good.

  • @1God4All-313
    @1God4All-313 24 дня назад

    Can we do a debate between cathars/bogomils. Vs catholic/orthodox

  • @PercivalDark
    @PercivalDark 2 месяца назад

    Are you actually quoting the scholars? If not, how do you simulate their discussion?

    • @AtticBooks
      @AtticBooks  2 месяца назад +3

      We do not directly quote the scholars or manually study their works. Instead, we input their books into AI models, which then simulate the discussions based on the content. The AI is trained to analyze the arguments and writing styles from these texts, allowing it to generate conversations that reflect the scholars’ intellectual approaches. This way, the simulations are created directly from the texts without us manually interpreting or quoting the material.

    • @mohammedaligodil2547
      @mohammedaligodil2547 2 месяца назад

      Voices of both Scholars not in tune as previous videos. Make it mere more dramatic unnecessarily.

    • @africanhistory
      @africanhistory 14 дней назад

      @@AtticBooks scary! AI done this?

  • @KazemJalali-z5v
    @KazemJalali-z5v 2 месяца назад

    These two were Persian Legends. they had nothing to do with Islam. They were just happened to live in an era were Arab Muslims invaded Persia and forced Persians to convert to Islam and forced to write and speak in Arabic.

    • @whyiamashia9497
      @whyiamashia9497 2 месяца назад

      Buddy they were Muslims and if you don’t like that no one cares go cry about it.

    • @zakymalik6920
      @zakymalik6920 Месяц назад +4

      😵😵‍💫🫨 Bro you've literally lost your mind

    • @frostyigloo
      @frostyigloo Месяц назад +1

      Who is a famous persian philosopher before Islam with great contributions?

    • @zakymalik6920
      @zakymalik6920 Месяц назад

      @@frostyigloo Zaratushtra & Mani

    • @frostyigloo
      @frostyigloo Месяц назад

      @@zakymalik6920 philosophy is reaching coherent conclusions using reasoning free from fallacies. Both of these people presented "spiritual revealed truths" rather than philosophical methodology and conclusions.

  • @NaseerAhmed-sc5bl
    @NaseerAhmed-sc5bl 2 месяца назад

    Islam has been opposed to philosophy which taken from Aristotle, Pluto and others

    • @cmserrone
      @cmserrone 2 месяца назад +4

      Islam has preserved philosophy for the West Al Ghazali only debated the shortcomings of philosophy but did not dismiss it entirely. In Dunya, Muslims need both reason and revelation.

    • @galacticdream3486
      @galacticdream3486 2 месяца назад

      The Prophet opposed philosophy?

    • @muhammedtrawally1798
      @muhammedtrawally1798 2 месяца назад

      Philosophy is human knowledge which contains both good and bad in it.
      When it comes to metaphysics, the Islamic understanding of god is very different from greek philosophical understanding, that is why Islam opposes philosophy.
      But as for the rest of the sciences like maths, physics and the like, Islam has no problem with it.

    • @NaseerAhmed-sc5bl
      @NaseerAhmed-sc5bl 2 месяца назад

      @@muhammedtrawally1798 Islam doesn’t except Greek paganism to talk about our creator

    • @muhammedtrawally1798
      @muhammedtrawally1798 2 месяца назад

      @@NaseerAhmed-sc5bl that is exactly what I am saying, it is call metaphysics