You can actually see that their eyes were a bit teary and their voices were shaky and cracky(especially Jessica and Yoona). It's also sad that they were just rookies then and they were only 16-18 years old, they were teenagers. Now they're all successful. As a group they sold millions of copies and sold out concerts all over the world. Even their subgroup (TaeTiSeo) is also extremely succesful. As individuals they are also successful. Yoona and Sooyoung in acting. Yuri, Sunny, Tiffany, and Hyoyeon in variety shows. Seohyun in musicals. Taeyeon as a solo singer. And even ex-member Jessica as a designer. Girls' Generation will always be remembered as the Nation's Girl Group.
Just finished watching the 2014 dream concert and coming back to this, the girls have made it so far. Oh yeah, and the reason why they had a black ocean was because the fandoms of male idols were jealous of SNSD being close with them.
Funniest part of this situation is girls generation is now literally the NUMBER ONE kpop girl group. How can people be so cruel to them? They were new and trying to make it and idiots like these people tried to bring them down. Obviously it didn't work! ^-^ girls generation fighting! :')
Sophia Lee Too many, and mainly short after debut, when they're still vulnerable. Luckily I've never been a fan of a group that had this happen to them myself, but one group I do remember is Purplay. I haven't done any research about their disbandment myself, but I heard they were a victim of it.
...Just ran into this tragedy from another channel. They did NOT deserve this at all. That fact that they kept going through their pain... shows how strong they are. To the people who kept their light sticks on, good job on standing up for them when the rest of the haters didn't. Glad to have seen them grow into what they are now. 💖
OH MY GIRLS :( THEY ARE CRYING INSIDE WHILE SINGING....THIS WAS SO CRUEL... BUT WHATEVER ... SNSD ARE IN TOP OF KPOP NOW :D I AM REALLY PROUD OF THEM :)
I'm really proud of them, you can truly see how professionals they were in this time, now look at them they're korean's nation group. They are truly artist.
Crying and singing at the same time? These girls are definition of professional even in their rookie era💙 You know how hard it's hard to even talk especially when try to hold cry ,your throat hurts coz of lump. Sad so many bg fans are like this who bring down successful women while being women themselves 💔
well from this video snsd we can see how much snsd has improved vocally good job! :) they are strong and have such a strong bond tht other girl gorups dont :) they support each other through the toughest times to become korea's number one girl group
Actually some group sing without autotune and one of them is SNSD. f(x) is even better. SM artists usually lip sing for theirs first comeback of a song, to show the dance moves first cuz when you dancing and singing at the same time your dance moves not gonna look powerful.
at the beginning I hate SNSD the most but then Yoona change my mind. now: I LOVE SNSD the most!!!!! Sone Thanks for being there and support our 9 girls
The black ocean wasn't actually for SNSD, it was for sones. Earlier before the concert, it was rumoured that some sones ripped a TVXQ poster to make space for sones. Being the biggest fandom present in the concert (no joke, watch other vids from the concert, it looked like a TVXQ solo concert), cassies decided to turn off their lights and other fandoms followed suit. I am a Cassie and to this day there are still some tension between us and sones. But I do feel bad for SNSD, they were young and obviously hurt.
you believe in rumor... i dont believe on rumor, i look it the cassie are make black ocean and not a rumor, is fact. Dasar dan kamu percaya itu sehingga masih ada sedikit pertentangan antara kamu dan sones, betapa bodohnya. Aku tidak percaya pada rumor aku melihat ini cassie2 busuk itu melakukan dark ocean
If u achieved success easily, u wont appreciate it and bonds wont be strong. But, they had passed through all that. Its kinda empty with OT8 but i still support both Snsd and Jessica. If i miss them, i will watch all the previous vids ♡
cảm ơn Black Ocean vì đã khiến cho S9 của chúng tôi trở nên mạnh mẽ hơn, nhưng đó chỉ là quá khứ. Còn bây giờ là thời đại của Girls' Generation. Power of 9 and PINK OCEAN NEVER OFF! I'm so proud to say that I'm a SONE, from 2007 until forever, and I'll do all my best to keep my girls smile :) SO NYUH Shi DAE is the BEST !!! V-SONE
Oh my god I can't imagine it. How hurt they're preform without cheer and applause 😭😭and must hurt is they have a black Ocean 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭they're really a legendary Queens.
I've heard of this "Black Ocean" incident and I always thought it be something really sad and hard to endure since it was stated that the girls performed in "complete darkness an silence" and people referred to this incident as "Cruel" so I expected something worse but this was nothing seriously...People were cheering for them and there were light sticks and balloons for them and GG just performed like nothing happened. Are there any interviews where SNSD talk about this incident?
+Dulce Lie It's called editing. 3:20 u see a black dome but it cuts off right before you can see the whole audience lol It got edited out of broadcast there's more than enough fancams and even documentaries that u can google around for to figure out it was a real thing. You can see the girls tearing up and Jessica even choking up at 1:10. Surely they wouldn't, if it wasn't a big deal lol
hurts seeing this black ocean but they still sing and smile for the audience despite all this even Jessica was gonna cry her voice shook around 1:10 I think: (((
They didn't smile much. Their voice sound strange maybe because they were sad and were about to cry. But they didn't give up despite all these difficulties. That's why they succeed and are on the top of Kpop now.
Was this happen because the rumour of junsu and taeyeon dating? I do knew the rumour/scandal (i ship them, basically ship everyone paired with taeng) but i cant catch the timeline when the situation happened
why does everybody says they are crying? what happend? i think thats so cute, because this performance is really energicy and powerful, GG where so sweet at this time. And now, The Boys, IGAB and Mr Mr are rocking! Saranghae SNSD!
If you see many Fancams of this, you can clearly hear other fandoms fan chanting "WONDER GIRLS" to show their disrespect towards SoShi. Almost the whole stadium was black because other fandoms turned off their light sticks to show disrespect.
in their recent talk show some of snsd members said they were so energetic and happy because they thought the audience became silent because they were focusing on them, some other snsd members did noticed the black ocean and some other were just too absorbed in performing to notice what was happening. yes, it was seohyun. keke.. i love snd!!! :)
![[드림콘서트] 소녀시대(Girls' Generation ) 'Mr. Mr' 브라질 2014 특집](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CVuYlGqlG_o/mqdefault.jpg)
You can actually see that their eyes were a bit teary and their voices were shaky and cracky(especially Jessica and Yoona). It's also sad that they were just rookies then and they were only 16-18 years old, they were teenagers. Now they're all successful. As a group they sold millions of copies and sold out concerts all over the world. Even their subgroup (TaeTiSeo) is also extremely succesful. As individuals they are also successful. Yoona and Sooyoung in acting. Yuri, Sunny, Tiffany, and Hyoyeon in variety shows. Seohyun in musicals. Taeyeon as a solo singer. And even ex-member Jessica as a designer. Girls' Generation will always be remembered as the Nation's Girl Group.
Dont forget that sunny is really big and popular in radio shows :)
Jessica's also a solo singer
@@michaelstewart7865 PERIODSÉ!
Omg they were only 16-17?😭😭😭😭
in black ocean, their smiles are more brighter. "Black Ocean" just made 9 girls more stronger and brighter to become a star in dark sky.
People who shouting "wonder girls" during this performance must be crying right now seeing our girls make a comeback for their 15th anniversary.
Wonder Girls is an ICONIC & LEGENDARY group,the people screaming them aren't even their fans they are Super Junior fandom lol,stop being dumb lmao
Absolutely
Just finished watching the 2014 dream concert and coming back to this, the girls have made it so far. Oh yeah, and the reason why they had a black ocean was because the fandoms of male idols were jealous of SNSD being close with them.
Jkmo 321 no =))) because of their stupid fans too :)
Jkmo 321 no
and all the people don't know that this girls will be NATIONS GIRL GROUP,LEGENDARY KPOP GIRL GROUP
they are now 😭 fuck those bg fandom
They went from experiencing the biggest black ocean, to becoming the best ever girl group in KPOP. That's what real queens do. 👑
Funniest part of this situation is girls generation is now literally the NUMBER ONE kpop girl group. How can people be so cruel to them? They were new and trying to make it and idiots like these people tried to bring them down. Obviously it didn't work! ^-^ girls generation fighting! :')
***** unfortunately it has worked for many groups though. for some reason people seem to enjoy bringing groups down, to force them into disbandment.
What groups were brought down?
Sophia Lee Too many, and mainly short after debut, when they're still vulnerable. Luckily I've never been a fan of a group that had this happen to them myself, but one group I do remember is Purplay.
I haven't done any research about their disbandment myself, but I heard they were a victim of it.
Honestly, listen to 1:10 you can hear how hard Jessica is trying to not cry
T-------------T
LOL DID YOU SEE Yuri and sooyoung? 1:02 XDD awehh even when the damn black ocean was happening
LilyLoveschu yuri and sooyoung be like : "nah, eat this, black ocean" 😂😂
@@salmuyregoo hahahahaa 🥺❤️
It looks and kinda sounds like they are going to cry if i was one of them i would have cried
Jessica looks ike she was crying
you can hear Jessica's voice trembling I feel so sad watching this😭😭😭
Just say goodbye to black ocean.. Now, tomorrow, and forever we are just see beautiful pink ocean..
SO NYEO SHI DAE!!!!!!!
9IRLS 9ENERATION ♥
You could really see through Taeyeon's eyes that she's really crying deep inside. My dorky leader :(
sones who are in this concert , thank you, the best!!
Now they're are The National Girl Group. I'm proud of my girls.
Only snsd experienced this hard time..thats why they are very different from other and they are so special..
...Just ran into this tragedy from another channel.
They did NOT deserve this at all.
That fact that they kept going through their pain... shows how strong they are.
To the people who kept their light sticks on, good job on standing up for them when the rest of the haters didn't.
Glad to have seen them grow into what they are now. 💖
OH MY GIRLS :( THEY ARE CRYING INSIDE WHILE SINGING....THIS WAS SO CRUEL... BUT WHATEVER ... SNSD ARE IN TOP OF KPOP NOW :D I AM REALLY PROUD OF THEM :)
I'm really proud of them, you can truly see how professionals they were in this time, now look at them they're korean's nation group. They are truly artist.
i guess half of the haters now become a SONE lol
Blue Totoro LOL idiots then, hardcore SONE now XD so proud
Blue Totoro LOL idiots then, hardcore SONE now XD so proud
SNSD for ever. After seeing this, no wonder you shines even brighter after the black ocean. You are now invincible, goddesses of kpop.
Crying and singing at the same time? These girls are definition of professional even in their rookie era💙
You know how hard it's hard to even talk especially when try to hold cry ,your throat hurts coz of lump.
Sad so many bg fans are like this who bring down successful women while being women themselves 💔
The fact they were rookie that time😢now look at them people are now paying respect to them,SNSD paved the way
i'm not even their fans but seeing this performance make me really proud of them.. they are now given title as the best girl group ever :"D
well from this video snsd we can see how much snsd has improved vocally
good job! :)
they are strong and have such a strong bond tht other girl gorups dont :)
they support each other through the toughest times to become korea's number one girl group
Remember this " Star can't shine brightly without darkness"
02:44 i can see jessica eyes 😥 and i start crying
through this black ocean we can see how great are they all now
Able to see shining star in the black sky. Is the best moment of my live
Actually some group sing without autotune and one of them is SNSD. f(x) is even better. SM artists usually lip sing for theirs first comeback of a song, to show the dance moves first cuz when you dancing and singing at the same time your dance moves not gonna look powerful.
Just when they were debuted and lately they sang live
Black ocean! :( but now everywhere it's pink ocean ^^ u girls did well despite facing the crowd with bad response!
at the beginning I hate SNSD the most but then Yoona change my mind. now: I LOVE SNSD the most!!!!!
Sone Thanks for being there and support our 9 girls
Why did you hate them?
Why?
The black ocean wasn't actually for SNSD, it was for sones. Earlier before the concert, it was rumoured that some sones ripped a TVXQ poster to make space for sones. Being the biggest fandom present in the concert (no joke, watch other vids from the concert, it looked like a TVXQ solo concert), cassies decided to turn off their lights and other fandoms followed suit. I am a Cassie and to this day there are still some tension between us and sones. But I do feel bad for SNSD, they were young and obviously hurt.
I thought Super Junior's poster was the one that got ripped off
Snsd lover nope, it was TVXQ's
ohh thats so bad of those few sones
Snsd lover haha it's okay~so many years later, cassies and sones are friends :P
you believe in rumor... i dont believe on rumor, i look it the cassie are make black ocean and not a rumor, is fact. Dasar dan kamu percaya itu sehingga masih ada sedikit pertentangan antara kamu dan sones, betapa bodohnya. Aku tidak percaya pada rumor aku melihat ini cassie2 busuk itu melakukan dark ocean
Bandingkan dengan Dream Concert tahun ini! Stadiumnya dipenuhi dengan warna 'PINK'! Proud of them :') SOSHI JJANG!
love the balloons and the courage of the girls to continue performing ..
omo! Jessica :'( Star can't shinning brighty without darkness :') love soshi !
This is so sad
Why did they do this
Some fans thought they were flirting with members of a boyband and definitely weren't okay with it.
+Bug smh so what...
Lana Smith ikr
They still were amazing:')
Fans Shouted "WONDER GIRLS" seriously 😌 this is SNDD performance not Wonder Girls performance 😌
Rude very
That immature sone try to make snsd jealous they try protest.. How can they use wonder girls
We are Forever
I love seeing this knowing they thrived and are now on top of the k-pop wave. My girls are the bomb!
to everyone who was present at this dream concert, you should be a shamed for bullying others.
If u achieved success easily, u wont appreciate it and bonds wont be strong. But, they had passed through all that. Its kinda empty with OT8 but i still support both Snsd and Jessica. If i miss them, i will watch all the previous vids ♡
cảm ơn Black Ocean vì đã khiến cho S9 của chúng tôi trở nên mạnh mẽ hơn, nhưng đó chỉ là quá khứ. Còn bây giờ là thời đại của Girls' Generation. Power of 9 and PINK OCEAN NEVER OFF!
I'm so proud to say that I'm a SONE, from 2007 until forever, and I'll do all my best to keep my girls smile :) SO NYUH Shi DAE is the BEST !!!
V-SONE
What happens when we aren't optimistic. Girls Generation Now Known Worldwide
It's sad because Sm had to edit screams into this so you couldn't hear all the fandoms chanting.
Oh my god I can't imagine it. How hurt they're preform without cheer and applause 😭😭and must hurt is they have a black Ocean 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭they're really a legendary Queens.
Stars cannot shine without Darkness
They sing live. ❤❤❤
I'm a wonderful but nobody deserves a Black ocean this is so sad.
1:58 Hyoyeon's hand is trembling, poor baby :(
that's why they deserve what they have NOW
#ProudSONE
#SONEForever
#6yearsSONE
I am proud to be SONE from the start and haven't change my mind.
LOVE TAEYEON!!! LOVE SNSD!!!
ok watch dream concert 2013 that is amazinggggg all sones are singing :") crying
Yuri & Taeyeon gave no shit to the haters. 😂❤❤❤❤❤
At 3:03 you can hear the haters in the crowd shouting 'wonder girls!!'
The black ocean. Brings back memories
I hate who do this black ocean!! Now u can see our girls more brighter than anything!! Im proud of uo 0t9!
the fact that they sang live. I've never been proud
i'm waiting for Dream Concert 2013 tonight. Power of 9 and PINK OCEAN NEVER OFF!
Thank for Black Ocean :) Because it made our Girls stronger :)
It's 2020!🙏
Endless Pink Ocean Forever!
Loudest Yeah at 3:06! ❤️
Forever Sone! 😌
Even if noone cheered, So Nyuh Shi Dae still performed their best. So Nyuh Shi Dae is the one and only!!
today is Dream Concert
it has been 5 years
so many things changed :)
and the lyrics are ironically "don't tease me"
I've heard of this "Black Ocean" incident and I always thought it be something really sad and hard to endure since it was stated that the girls performed in "complete darkness an silence" and people referred to this incident as "Cruel" so I expected something worse but this was nothing seriously...People were cheering for them and there were light sticks and balloons for them and GG just performed like nothing happened. Are there any interviews where SNSD talk about this incident?
The were screaming wonder girl during there performance and booing them
Dulce Lie yeah, allkpop is known for misleading their readers
there was a little part of the audience that was pink, the rest was black
+Dulce Lie It's called editing. 3:20 u see a black dome but it cuts off right before you can see the whole audience lol
It got edited out of broadcast there's more than enough fancams and even documentaries that u can google around for to figure out it was a real thing. You can see the girls tearing up and Jessica even choking up at 1:10. Surely they wouldn't, if it wasn't a big deal lol
+Dulce Lie and also the cheers werent for snsd.. the fans kept screaming wonder girls
OMG, you can clearly hear them chant "wonder girls"
Anyway, I'm just missing my girls
heartbroken!! snsd i love you always and i will support u till the end!
They were very happy in that era, love u girls
all of fanclubs turned off their lightstick except SONE and chanted Wonder Girl instead of SNSD
hurts seeing this black ocean but they still sing and smile for the audience despite all this even Jessica was gonna cry her voice shook around 1:10 I think: (((
I have been looking for song for years!!
What is it called?!
Girls generation - Girls generation
:)
Dream concert 2019 bring me here 😻😻😻
what is this song i like it
+oompa loompa ok
Its 2018. Still here..
They didn't smile much. Their voice sound strange maybe because they were sad and were about to cry. But they didn't give up despite all these difficulties. That's why they succeed and are on the top of Kpop now.
Its so sad when they don't have their camera, autotune, and false sense of security i can hear them nervous, off key, and just uncomfortable looking.
everyone will nervous when she/he see black ocean in their performance:')
2021 ❤️
I wonder what happened back stage after their performance. If they cried then I want to cry with them.. this is sooo heart breaking! 💔😭
Rhis steong girls now become the.most powerful in the world.
whats the title of the song?
Same as name of girl group. Try to search girls generation so nyeo shidae Or snsd girls generation
SNSD FOREVER!!
Wheres the bullying? i don't get it, did i miss something?
awesome live
Was this happen because the rumour of junsu and taeyeon dating? I do knew the rumour/scandal (i ship them, basically ship everyone paired with taeng) but i cant catch the timeline when the situation happened
Who's watching in 2020?
Go little Rockstar😭😭😭😭👍🏻
Thank sone in this day
why does everybody says they are crying? what happend?
i think thats so cute, because this performance is really energicy and powerful, GG where so sweet at this time. And now, The Boys, IGAB and Mr Mr are rocking!
Saranghae SNSD!
Cuz they experience the black ocean
If you see many Fancams of this, you can clearly hear other fandoms fan chanting "WONDER GIRLS" to show their disrespect towards SoShi. Almost the whole stadium was black because other fandoms turned off their light sticks to show disrespect.
in their recent talk show some of snsd members said they were so energetic and happy because they thought the audience became silent because they were focusing on them, some other snsd members did noticed the black ocean and some other were just too absorbed in performing to notice what was happening. yes, it was seohyun. keke.. i love snd!!! :)
even so,there are still sones at there~
what song is this
Sorry for the late reply. But if you didn’t know it’s called ‘girl generation’
Snsd be strong we're the SONE will be always by ur side
Btw they improve a lot in singing live
Soshi jaaaaaaang
thanks to the fans who flied their balloons🙂
this hurts my soul man
why they to that to soshi?
참 억울하거등요... 잘못도 없이 이거 당하고 사과하는 굴욕을 넘어서 최고의 그룹이 됐다. 자랑스럽다.
SONE bây giờ và mai sau, mãi mãi không bao giờ dù 1 tíc tắc cũng không có ý nghĩ dời bỏ SNSD
Those Korean fans were sooo cruel!! Lyk wtf? How dare they do tat to the queens?! U got international sones cheering you around the world!!! ❤️
2:00 jajajajaja :D
I will forever be inside of you ..... always a SONE
I can hear “Wonder Girls” lmao 💀
THE NATION !