Wouldn't say a ripoff. Likely a coincidence or the author took inspiration from Hilda. Regardless. I'd love to see this be made into an animated series like Hilda was. Looks like if Hilda and Adventure Time was put together. :D
3:16 That face, I don’t know why but that face has some serious “imma bout to commit some crimes vibe” honestly she is already hildas slightly edgy rival
@@baharihidayat1725 And I though hildas massive property damage with the mechanical bell keepers was bad but yeah this kid downright pulled an endgame thanos
@@thunderbro7218dude I remember when that episode came out some people were jokingly saying she committed domestic terrorism. It sounds like an exaggeration but then one guy read through the official def of what that means and realized what she did in that ep actually DOES fit every qualification for it LOL.
As someone who read aster before watched Hilda, I can say that I didn’t notice anything, other than them both being in the mountains and hav in a cute animal siekik
what I'm getting it at is that hilda dna ster are peer IPs so to speak who both had similar ideas and drew inspiration from modern children's entertainment media from around europe.
Hilda feels like watching a show on that one little sibling that gives you endless anxiety as they continuously nearly die and somehow are indestructible
I think I have an idea as to why people say it's a ripoff when there are enough differences to make it an original work. The reason might be because the art style, specifically the colors, is similar enough that it reminds people of hilda. I bet, if you completely change the art style, no one would say it's a ripoff. Just don't judge a book by its cover, Also, reading a bunch of other comments, I'm not sure a many of those commenters actually watched the video (which is really sad)
First, Gumball with Miracle Star, now this. I know Hilda is an adventure series first and foremost, but it would be funny to see her roast HER knockoff.
Most stories written go through certain structures. That doesn't mean it's a ripoff and from what you showed along how you describe its similarities-it's just a natural way of writing. People gain inspiration from others work; albeit, even what you pointed out wasn't a ripoff. There are many stories with a character who have pets as their companions (paranormal park, his dark materials, and fareseer trilogy) and to be honest, there isn't much of a resemblance between the characters. It just seems that Aster has some aspects that you see is similar which is very common in books. Please refrain from saying ripoffs because it does hurt reputations when doing such and is mainly used when the author is clearly going story by story or in many major/minor aspects (such as characters, relationships, storyline, and personality)
If it was a ripoff... the legal department would be involved to cease and desist... if the idea is just different *enough* then they don't have a case. Luke Pearson ofcoruse would not answer your question, why would he? If he said anything to you about it he could potentially put himself in a legal bind... so ofcoruse he wouldn't say anything to you. Inspirations happen all the time, look at harry Potter and Worst Witch.
People really should know the DIFFERENCE between.........INSPIRED BY and RIPOFF, like I just need to watch the art and yes clearly the artist admire Luke Pearson work, and yes they probably love Hilda, but that doesn't make this comic a RIPOFF, who many stories and comics or movies or games are inspired by others that came before.....I know you got the the same conclusion but making the video and entitle as a RIP OFF is not a good thing for the people who made this book (that looks adorable why the heck you do that), not cool dude, not cool.
He put ripoff in the title because of clickbait. Only the people that don't watch the video to the end will not realize that it isn't actually a ripoff.
Hilda isnt a rip off. It was inspired by the aster but still its own. Its like how many shows have art styles inspired by adventure time or steven universe? A lot right. Everyone is inspired by one thing or another what makes the biggest impact is what is known in pop culture like marvel or dc, gumball and its chinese ripoff, rick n morty and everything else.
Dude It's Not a ripoff Maybe a bit similar but magic stories like this existed way before Hilda this is reaching a ripoff is something that obviously changed nothing but copy the entire source material and claimed as there own with to many things that are the same from the og source they are taking from. You clearly don't seem to know that as this Video Implies it is a ripoff like others say it could be a bit Inspired and that's normal so what now you gonna call Ninjago a ripoff of tmnt because they have a blue and red Ninja.
Did a double take when Aster got revealed, I never even considered it being a Hilda ripoff. Similar? Absolutely, but it definitely has its own unique charm and vibes to make it its own thing.
i'd say it's not a direct ripoff, taking the approach of hilda, but doing it's own thing with it. like how undertale takes the rpg aspects of earthbound, but makes it different and it's own thing.
the artstyle is the same to.. OK THAT'S WAY TO MUCH OF A COPY 😭😭😭😭😭😭 EDIT: i thought you meant it was a show cuz the thumbnail makes it look like it is a show but then you pulled out a book lol
![KSI - Dirty [Official Visualiser]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VoDh1h1dPUE/mqdefault.jpg)
I never expected a Hilda ripoff kinda funny to see it though, but honestly I kinda think it's heavily inspired
Yeah I also think it's inspired
Yea its kinda original
@@triciaunknown6757 Same name
This is not a ripoff, did you even watch the video?
It's very good . _ . 👍
I love the animation and creative art style
Wouldn't say a ripoff. Likely a coincidence or the author took inspiration from Hilda.
Regardless. I'd love to see this be made into an animated series like Hilda was. Looks like if Hilda and Adventure Time was put together. :D
I feel like we blur the lines between "inspired" and "ripoffs" too much these days.
Just take a look at the Inheritance Cycle, a book series heavily “inspired” by The Lord of the Rings and countless others.
3:16
That face, I don’t know why but that face has some serious “imma bout to commit some crimes vibe” honestly she is already hildas slightly edgy rival
She erased whole reality. If thas not considered a crime idk what.
@@baharihidayat1725
And I though hildas massive property damage with the mechanical bell keepers was bad but yeah this kid downright pulled an endgame thanos
"I just took a huge dump" face
@@thunderbro7218dude I remember when that episode came out some people were jokingly saying she committed domestic terrorism. It sounds like an exaggeration but then one guy read through the official def of what that means and realized what she did in that ep actually DOES fit every qualification for it LOL.
I read Aster and watched Hilda and never considered any correlation between them… interesting!
As someone who read aster before watched Hilda, I can say that I didn’t notice anything, other than them both being in the mountains and hav in a cute animal siekik
As someone who has read both books I completely agree it may look like a ripoff but there’s a vast majority of difference between them
“And, unlike Hilda, aster has a father” 1 YEAR LATER OMG THE LATEST HILDA SEASON SHOWS…..{spoiler}
Adler! *sorry if its wrong*
Maybe a crossover between Aster and Hilda and that would be cool actually. British and French.
Y e s
Hey yeah that could be connected to it
hilda is scandinavian
Thank you for showing me something to bring back the lost feelings of some legendary shows that have ended! I’m so grateful 😊
honestly, this one seems interesting because of how the character, the illustrations, and the similarities
what I'm getting it at is that hilda dna ster are peer IPs so to speak who both had similar ideas and drew inspiration from modern children's entertainment media from around europe.
If Amphibia and Hilda had a child it would be this (and I love both franchises ‼️)
Hilda feels like watching a show on that one little sibling that gives you endless anxiety as they continuously nearly die and somehow are indestructible
Steven Universe:
You hit the NAIL on the head
If it's is somehow possible she is Hilda's cousin
I think I have an idea as to why people say it's a ripoff when there are enough differences to make it an original work. The reason might be because the art style, specifically the colors, is similar enough that it reminds people of hilda. I bet, if you completely change the art style, no one would say it's a ripoff. Just don't judge a book by its cover,
Also, reading a bunch of other comments, I'm not sure a many of those commenters actually watched the video (which is really sad)
as someone with the original hilda and the troll book, and not a copy, i literally watch hilda everyday when home from school.
First, Gumball with Miracle Star, now this.
I know Hilda is an adventure series first and foremost, but it would be funny to see her roast HER knockoff.
DID U WATCH THE VIDEO? ASTER ISN'T A RIPOFF
This keeps happening in the comments section, this is not a ripoff you idiot
The similarities seem to simply come from classic folklore themes that Hilda is also based on.
Most stories written go through certain structures. That doesn't mean it's a ripoff and from what you showed along how you describe its similarities-it's just a natural way of writing. People gain inspiration from others work; albeit, even what you pointed out wasn't a ripoff. There are many stories with a character who have pets as their companions (paranormal park, his dark materials, and fareseer trilogy) and to be honest, there isn't much of a resemblance between the characters. It just seems that Aster has some aspects that you see is similar which is very common in books.
Please refrain from saying ripoffs because it does hurt reputations when doing such and is mainly used when the author is clearly going story by story or in many major/minor aspects (such as characters, relationships, storyline, and personality)
I like how in season 3 Hilda’s grandma is named astrid
Wait...
Astrid is not her grandma she's her great aunt
*SWEET HOME ALABAMA*💀
This Hilda season 4
something that could fill this empty void of mine, more hilda-like content!!
In season 3 of Hilda they visited there grandma named ASTRID. (Very similar)
SHE'S HILDA'S GREAT AUNT BROOOOOO💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
Wait maybe aster should have cartoon like hilda
Ooh that would actually be really cool
@@0yaSumi6908 I know
@@0yaSumi6908 when hilda season is over we can see her cousin in French hilda is british that live in Norway but we can go to franch so let’s hop ok
Honestly, I think it's just the color palette.
The art style seems more like Adventure Time, with a bit of Hilda graphic style.
Hillda has a father, hilldas mom just "broke up/ divorced him"
And we do get to see him
YOOOOOOO A HILDA RUclipsR!!! AWESOME!!
5:23 Mom went to the store to buy M I L K
It dose look hilda ha at less when there no more hilda we have this
If it was a ripoff... the legal department would be involved to cease and desist... if the idea is just different *enough* then they don't have a case. Luke Pearson ofcoruse would not answer your question, why would he? If he said anything to you about it he could potentially put himself in a legal bind... so ofcoruse he wouldn't say anything to you. Inspirations happen all the time, look at harry Potter and Worst Witch.
Nah, it might be inspired. But IMO its it’s own thing
I love the aster books so much!!!!!!!!!!!
I want Hilda season 4 and another movie and that's final
People really should know the DIFFERENCE between.........INSPIRED BY and RIPOFF, like I just need to watch the art and yes clearly the artist admire Luke Pearson work, and yes they probably love Hilda, but that doesn't make this comic a RIPOFF, who many stories and comics or movies or games are inspired by others that came before.....I know you got the the same conclusion but making the video and entitle as a RIP OFF is not a good thing for the people who made this book (that looks adorable why the heck you do that), not cool dude, not cool.
He put ripoff in the title because of clickbait. Only the people that don't watch the video to the end will not realize that it isn't actually a ripoff.
I ended up here bc of hilda and nano lol, i saw aster bfp on amazon but never considered buying it
If it's good I'll definitely let it fill the Hilda shaped void in my soul
First Gumball, Then Gravity Falls, what next?
And by the way I just started get into this series.
Shut up and watch the video, I’m tired of comments saying this is a rippoff
@@SpongeBob-lt8mu I did, I was just joking
Tbh Aster sounds almost as interesting as hilda
I have a classmate named aster I showed this to her and I got detention.
💀
Hilda isnt a rip off. It was inspired by the aster but still its own. Its like how many shows have art styles inspired by adventure time or steven universe? A lot right. Everyone is inspired by one thing or another what makes the biggest impact is what is known in pop culture like marvel or dc, gumball and its chinese ripoff, rick n morty and everything else.
one thing is for sure, it's not bootleg at all
ASTER!? A24 is behind this, it all makes sense!
What the fuck did I mean by this!?
If there is another ripoff of Hilda, then that Hilda clone would have Periwinkle hair (purplish blue hair)
Dude It's Not a ripoff Maybe a bit similar but magic stories like this existed way before Hilda this is reaching a ripoff is something that obviously changed nothing but copy the entire source material and claimed as there own with to many things that are the same from the og source they are taking from. You clearly don't seem to know that as this Video Implies it is a ripoff like others say it could be a bit Inspired and that's normal so what now you gonna call Ninjago a ripoff of tmnt because they have a blue and red Ninja.
Exactly! It’s not a ripoff, but possibly a bit inspired by Hilda
I read the first 2 books, it's really good, hoping for more books, also, og hilda books were mad ugly.
The map is looks like hilda's map
Try to draw a good looking fantasy map. Similar, right?
I only just found out Hilda books exist and I want to buy them all now..
Did a double take when Aster got revealed, I never even considered it being a Hilda ripoff. Similar? Absolutely, but it definitely has its own unique charm and vibes to make it its own thing.
i mean is hilda a moomin ripoff?
According to the creator Luke Pearson, Hilda was originally going to be a Moomin oc like a fan-character
But as the years passed she ended up as his own character and her own little world
i'd say it's not a direct ripoff, taking the approach of hilda, but doing it's own thing with it. like how undertale takes the rpg aspects of earthbound, but makes it different and it's own thing.
that spark when 2:05 says a bee is too fat to fly lol
0:43 WHY IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THE H WORD REY SAID?!??!?!?!?!
Chill
hell.
Wait no I read that
Hey yall, Its 2023 and I still watch Hilda 😼😼🤭🤭
Kid: can I have hilda
Mom: no we have hilda at home
Hilda at home:
It would be great to watch an episode talking about the battle of Hilda and its fake version like gumball 😂😂
It isn’t a fake version, I read both books. Also, aster came out before the show and the plot is so different. Did you even watch the video?
@@SpongeBob-lt8mu And Hilda's books came out long before Aster's books.
@@pollointerestelar7439 I mean sure but dosnt change the point
This would be a good show
I think there’s was named zilda 🤔
5:30 Don't give Luke Pearson ideas please XD
No, it's the fandom you need to worry about.
Please don't do it!
I don't think it's a rip-off, but it still doesn't have that level, or more so "vibe" of aw-struck charm that only Hilda has.
Wait a second did you find all the Easter eggs I did
Hilda is like bluey Dora horrid Henry and owl house
"mommy says you went to the store to get *M I L K* "
I think the reason there's no show or so is because there's only 2 books and not much to go on
I wish Aster have a cartoon on Nickelodeon
UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
UUUUUUUUUU
UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!
Review zilda! Another ripoff which is EXACKY ATHE SAME, just look at the intro in the show of both of them
Do you like it or do you hate it
...... THIS AIN'T HILDA MATE THIS IS A MONSTROSITY?!
5:20 well, that didn't age well
Woolly dogs are extinct T-T
Oh no they didn't...
the artstyle is the same to.. OK THAT'S WAY TO MUCH OF A COPY 😭😭😭😭😭😭
EDIT: i thought you meant it was a show cuz the thumbnail makes it look like it is a show but then you pulled out a book lol
It’s honestly hilarious that HILDA got a rip-off.
Damm you
:)
Are you alavie
Ripoffs are 👎🏾
People who reply
👇🏾
I just got into Hilda and i love it so much it reminds me of Amphibia
There’s an actual ripoff. it’s called Zelda search it up it is not ok
I can't stand Aster's art style.
Yeah me too
5:20 yes