Geoff actually hits Bb0 and B0 subharmonic in tiktok waydown cover and in enemy geoff hits an A0 growl dont say it is uncountable it is clearly countable A0 growl
I personally count slided notes unless it’s like a really low chest note then I debate wether it’s countable or not (such as Geoff’s E1 chest in Cheerleader. I always say it’s semi countable) so yes Geoff’s A0 growl is countable. At least I’d say it is
That spoken note from Elliot was definitely chest-fry. Still, a C1 without extended techniques is beyond impressive. Also, just to note, Geoff has an A0 growl in VoicePlay's cover of "Enemy".
Год назад+3
Perhaps yes Or not, Because the grade is very low, hardly anyone keeps it clean
@, regardless, once you get below B1 (even something most basses cannot do), it's super impressive, and this is coming from someone with an E1 in full chest, C#1 in chest-fry, and Eb0 in subharmonics. All three of these guys are next level from the total package they bring to music.
Ils ont tous du talent,sans discuter, mais on en revient toujours au même, personne, non personne n'a la beauté, clarté et la tonalité de la voix de Geoff, sans parler de ses talents d'acteur qu'il imprègne à la perfection. C'est Geoff 🤗🫠😲💯
some corrections though im late: 1:05 was an Ab1 1:35 was chest-fry 1:55 was subharmonic 2:25 was an F#1 3:52 ive always believed was growl, but theres a large debate about it 4:18 was a G1 9:11 was chest-fry 9:57 was a C#1 thank you for making this video, i havent seen stuff like this made recently in a while
2:25 not an F#1, for one it would sound really out of place being a full step down from the 1 in G#, maybe it could sound good but Geoff doesn’t do out there things just to be out there. but also we rarely get F#1 chests in Geoff’s pieces and covers with voiceplay.
@@spilledmilk8029 so you’re saying he went down to a G# then slid down a full step before going back up to the G# Listening to it I kinda hear it although that’s really hard to tell
Couple things: 1): Was Tim's F1 at 4:32 really a chest note? Far as I know he only uses chest-fry and growl to go below G1/F#1, and it sounded a little fry-ish to me. 2): I love how the labels for growl/chest/sub change for Tim and Geoff and Elliott's chest register keeps going down, down, down.
Год назад+3
in this specific presentation He managed to hit in the chest! Now we don't know if it's already part of the registry Or just if it was a really good day.
@ again, given his low-note-technique history I'm not convinced unless Tim or another Home Free member confirms that it was chest, especially as the notes from B1 down sounded chest fryish as well. Not really a big deal, but the discussion here piqued my curiosity
This particular F1 was not chest. He switched to a solid chest fry at the end. However, there is another clip where he hits a much more convincing F1 chest.
Just to clarify at 4:32 it’s a chest fry note and one more thing Geoff’s lowest chest note is F#1 and Tim’s is G1 and Eliot’s lowest chest note is C1/B0
![2022 Bass Battle [Bobby Waters/Geoff Castellucci]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Dr5e8ttLaA0/mqdefault.jpg)
![2022 Bass Battle [Bobby Waters/Geoff Castellucci]](/img/tr.png)
0:38 It's actually a A1*
Geoff's voice is clearest and strongest he wins
I think his voice is the clearest, But the lowest voice is clearly elliott's
@@zaramaob2109 i dont mean it elliot is the lowest sure but quality is more important
I am totally agreed with you, man!!! His voice is the cleanest I have ever heard in my life!!!!🔥🔥🔥🔥Gives me chills!!!💯🔥🙌🏻👑
Geoff actually hits Bb0 and B0 subharmonic in tiktok waydown cover and in enemy geoff hits an A0 growl dont say it is uncountable it is clearly countable A0 growl
I personally count slided notes unless it’s like a really low chest note then I debate wether it’s countable or not (such as Geoff’s E1 chest in Cheerleader. I always say it’s semi countable) so yes Geoff’s A0 growl is countable. At least I’d say it is
That spoken note from Elliot was definitely chest-fry. Still, a C1 without extended techniques is beyond impressive. Also, just to note, Geoff has an A0 growl in VoicePlay's cover of "Enemy".
Perhaps yes Or not, Because the grade is very low, hardly anyone keeps it clean
@, regardless, once you get below B1 (even something most basses cannot do), it's super impressive, and this is coming from someone with an E1 in full chest, C#1 in chest-fry, and Eb0 in subharmonics. All three of these guys are next level from the total package they bring to music.
@@johndeeregreen4592 that's for sure
Ils ont tous du talent,sans discuter, mais on en revient toujours au même, personne, non personne n'a la beauté, clarté et la tonalité de la voix de Geoff, sans parler de ses talents d'acteur qu'il imprègne à la perfection. C'est Geoff 🤗🫠😲💯
1:37 is growl look at tim attentively
3:18 is chest fry
I wouldn't say it was a chest-fry I think it's just his timbre that made it sound like it.
It's not
chest kankam tim'in timbre'ından dolayı chest fry gibi duyuluyor da türkler her yerde aqnlkafhgalnkdfh
In friends in the other side geoff has a more clear F1 chest
It’s slided tho. Geoff hasn’t held an F1 chest in a professional piece and to me that’s what really counts
@@red5250 In voiceplays newer song, Whiskey In The Jar he did
@@m1aa-p4r god smite me if i hadnt heard of that alr lmao
yes i know, i dont listen to acapella as much anymore though
1:05 was definitely a G#1
Agreed, just pitched it myself and it is a G#1
some corrections though im late:
1:05 was an Ab1
1:35 was chest-fry
1:55 was subharmonic
2:25 was an F#1
3:52 ive always believed was growl, but theres a large debate about it
4:18 was a G1
9:11 was chest-fry
9:57 was a C#1
thank you for making this video, i havent seen stuff like this made recently in a while
9:11 didn't seem to me chest fry
2:25 Clearly not an F#1
@@vaiprala The G#1 is there right after he did sing the F#1.
2:25 not an F#1, for one it would sound really out of place being a full step down from the 1 in G#, maybe it could sound good but Geoff doesn’t do out there things just to be out there. but also we rarely get F#1 chests in Geoff’s pieces and covers with voiceplay.
@@red5250there is a Ab right before the F#, but it was probably marked late
@@spilledmilk8029 so you’re saying he went down to a G# then slid down a full step before going back up to the G#
Listening to it I kinda hear it although that’s really hard to tell
can you make a video of Dimash vs Vitas vs Adam Lopez vs Nicolas Sedda?
Couple things:
1): Was Tim's F1 at 4:32 really a chest note? Far as I know he only uses chest-fry and growl to go below G1/F#1, and it sounded a little fry-ish to me.
2): I love how the labels for growl/chest/sub change for Tim and Geoff and Elliott's chest register keeps going down, down, down.
in this specific presentation He managed to hit in the chest! Now we don't know if it's already part of the registry Or just if it was a really good day.
@ again, given his low-note-technique history I'm not convinced unless Tim or another Home Free member confirms that it was chest, especially as the notes from B1 down sounded chest fryish as well. Not really a big deal, but the discussion here piqued my curiosity
This particular F1 was not chest. He switched to a solid chest fry at the end. However, there is another clip where he hits a much more convincing F1 chest.
@@BassManMatteo Where?
@@anymous1485 It’s in a link on this comment, it might not show up because RUclips bans links sometimes
Geoff is mostly clean while the other two have singing over them. Geoff just hits that shit with no one else around to cover up issues
All are amazing but Geoff’s low notes are clear and Tim’s range is crazy!
6:47 what is that clip from?
If you're referring to the Geoff Castellucci clip, it's "The Rains of Castamere", if you mean the Tim Foust clip, that's "Honey I'm Good"
@@sparklefluff thank you, also I was referring to the the Geoff clip
Geoff ❤ king 👑
Just to clarify at 4:32 it’s a chest fry note and one more thing Geoff’s lowest chest note is F#1 and Tim’s is G1 and Eliot’s lowest chest note is C1/B0
I think Geoff's lowest is F1. I think his slide in Friends On The Other Side is countable
We finally have got a definitive F1Chest from Geoff, in Voiceplay's recent cover of Whiskey in the Jar!!!!
9:56 C#1
He hits a B0 later in the song though
thanks for the correction! These are difficult notes to get even deeper
5:25 is F#1 all the time.
clearly not