Not surprising, it was this song's aim after all to show the problems of prolonged capitalism, especially when you're not constantly funded by USA's dollar printing machine anymore
@@sturmassierdev Unfortunately it did so by claiming the solution was socialism and that the GDR did everything better. Now matter how you turn it, at the end of the day, everyone lies for their own greed.
@@YungIsyan afd coper wellcome. 1- born new german population can work in factories for future. OR SHUT UP and accept imigration. And eu is what made germany economic powerhause again today. Not nationalist and protectionist policies. That's why shut up.
@@YungIsyanRight Wing? You Mean The Direction Of Nationalists That Shout At Eachother While Not Even Living In Their Own Country? The Left Is Internationalist, Always Has Been Always Will Be Then If The Americans Decide To Let Their Left Turn Into Some Woke Bs Then It's Their Fault But The Rest Of The World Is Not As Retarded
Jedes Wort eine Lüge oder ohne Berücksichtigung des damit verbundenen Unrechts. Und heute wollen irgendwelche Wessis uns Ossis sagen, wie schön angeblich der Sozialismus sei.
I am german, i just googled it and found nothing. 'Weißer' (White or whiter but also an old word for someone who has knowledge) could be a name and 'Keis' can mean intermediate level of administration between state and the municipalities.
it is a propaganda term ........ "die weißen Bruderschaften" where a bunch of fraternities that where anti communist it is basicly a socialist conspiracy theory that those fraternitys secretly control the government........... - funny enough when this song was released they where already baned (becouse they organised duels)
Dieses Lied: "Gemeinsam sind wir stärker, Kollege, reih dich ein. Die für Recht und Frieden kämpfen Werden unaufhaltsam sein!" Lied der Partei: Die Partei, die Partei die hat immer recht und Genossen es bleibet dabei. Denn wer kämpft für das Recht, der hat immer Recht. Gegen Lüge und Ausbeuterei. Schön auf Linie, so muss das :D
This sounds more like a GDR-made agitprop song aimed at West Germans. The sound and choir is very „Eastern“. But of course they may just be imitating the Socialist 1950s style.
Wenns nach mir ginge hätten wir die DDR wieder um Inovationen und Bildung zu fördern, jedoch würde ich das Geldsystem abschaffen, Tauschhandel soll es sein
@@g.f.w.6402ja und wer hat diese Länder bombardiert die NATO und die USA ich zitiere mal jemanden Hitler wurde zwar besiegt aber seine Sache lebt weiter😅
Axel Springer was the founder and publisher of BILD newspaper which had a deeply conservative leaning back then and was/is still widely circulated. Franz-Joseph Strauß was the conservative, some would say even right-wing, minister president of Bavaria, with aspirations of becoming Federal Chancellor (he never did).
@@hewhoremains-kang Well actualy, that was supposed to be a joke (both the comment and the reply) and by the looks of it both him and you didn't get it. ☝️🤓
But - it was the GDR-worker who was supressed and locked in....This song sounds as if it was made by some unmature spoiled youth from rich families in Western Germany.
The worker from the east lived better, his rights were protected to the detriment of his employers and the borders of the GDR were always open with all socialist republics (with the exception of Cambodia, the GDR considered this regime fascist under the guise of socialism).
@@hassanalihusseini1717 According to official statistics, more Germans fled to the East than to the West. And the Eastern "dictatorship" was overthrown by a police coup, and Germans who tried to defend the country were shot by "democratic forces"
More like a celebration of the communist idea of direct democracy and workplace democracy, the song focuses on "if you were all in power, the country wouldn't be so shitty."
Are you an anarchist or something? Because it's quite telling that all of the current AES countries were founded on ML principles, applied to their material conditions. You see, there is still a tiny problem that prevents the abolition of the state (at its current state anyway). Like, idk... the existence of antagonistic capitalist interests that are willing to use any means (billions have been spent on propaganda, assassinations, coups, g***cides, etc) to ensure their dominance. Do you know of Salvador Allende or Mohammad Mosaddegh, for example? They were democratically elected leaders and by no means MLs (but socialist adjacent). And what happened to them? You can find out in the official US statements. So I suggest you reconsider your idealistic and caricatured view of socialism and its historical development. Because so far it can only be built and preserved by taking a firm stance against the capitalism with its invasive institutions and mechanisms! Oh, and it also doesn't mean that people's demands aren't taken into account by the socialist state (if they don't fundametally contradict its general line). Since we're commenting under a Germany-related video, in the GDR people could participate in referendums regarding the government policies (which wasn't the case in the FRG) and form a variety of public organisations (even for LGBT people, while in the FRG they were criminally prosecuted).
Wenn's nach dir ging, könnte hierzulande Vieles besser sein, Darum steh nicht bloß beiseite, Tritt doch für dich selber ein! 18 millions did so in 1989, so what?
@@macewindu9100Heute ist nicht besser als vor 1989/90? Man sollte es miterlebt haben, bevor man redet. Oder: Pflaster entfernen, mit denen damals die Augen zugekebt waren. "Früher war alles besser, da hatten wir einen Kaiser" ist ja lustig, aber die Realität in der DDR vor 35 Jahren war erbärmlich.
Das ist nicht wahr. In Deutschland herrscht Ungleichheit, weil die Regierung eine Marionette der USA ist. Solange sich das nicht ändert, wird niemand gleich sein und es wird immer schlimmer werden.
![Es zittern die morschen knochen [German + English Lyrics]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VPKDH3Um9IQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Some may not like the fact that this song is more relevant today than ever since its creation.
Not surprising, it was this song's aim after all to show the problems of prolonged capitalism, especially when you're not constantly funded by USA's dollar printing machine anymore
@@sturmassierdev Unfortunately it did so by claiming the solution was socialism and that the GDR did everything better. Now matter how you turn it, at the end of the day, everyone lies for their own greed.
yeah. But in right wing direction. Not internationalist leftist femboy migration direction
@@YungIsyan afd coper wellcome.
1- born new german population can work in factories for future. OR SHUT UP and accept imigration. And eu is what made germany economic powerhause again today. Not nationalist and protectionist policies. That's why shut up.
@@YungIsyanRight Wing?
You Mean The Direction Of Nationalists That Shout At Eachother While Not Even Living In Their Own Country?
The Left Is Internationalist, Always Has Been Always Will Be Then If The Americans Decide To Let Their Left Turn Into Some Woke Bs Then It's Their Fault But The Rest Of The World Is Not As Retarded
West-German commie/pro DDR songs always go hard, also then tend to still be relevant
Interesting how communist west Germany was even though it was ran by capitalist America and most of the allies
well i am a Libertarian but commies and fascists do make good songs
@@baronbrummbar8691you are the fash lmao
@@jeongbun2386 if you say so...........
@@baronbrummbar8691 so called "libertarians" have quite a less than ideal record when it comes to their fascist tendencies
„Doch du stehst da beiseite“ ist der offizielle Titel, der auch auf der Platte steht.
Freundschaft! Wie heißt die Platte, was für Songs sind da (außer sicherlich Krupp und Krause) noch so drauf? Salve!
@@michaelmelt7885die ganze platte ist auf dem kanal des genossen
@avraamavramovich@michaelmelt7885 die ganze platte ist auf dem kanal des genossen
You're truly a comrade for not only uploading this but also for digitising this, amazing job! :)
Wow! Very high quality version, may I know where you found it?
I digitized it from the album it came on
ruclips.net/video/JOotEtli0hs/видео.html
@@roedagardet thx!
Not a single lie was said in this song.
@kizrgdWe will, together.
Kein lugen
@kizrgd „we“ bezieht sich auf den Kommunismus, weil die Gemeinsamkeit als Stärke gilt in deren Augen
@kizrgd Rule number 1: Don’t be a dick.
Jedes Wort eine Lüge oder ohne Berücksichtigung des damit verbundenen Unrechts. Und heute wollen irgendwelche Wessis uns Ossis sagen, wie schön angeblich der Sozialismus sei.
I never knew Eminem was a communist
Epik video 🗿🍷
Münchner Songgruppe 💪
Heute relevanter als je zuvor 🚩
Erzählen Sie mal!
that bass is fire
Agreed
Chefkoch macht so weiter, es war ein schönes Video.
Has never been so relevant, even today everything is still the same...
Verdammt, immer noch relevant...
Unfortunately a very relevant tune, even today.
Хор позитивных гномиков радует
Thats a very nice song, comrade
Certified bop
Did humanity deserve the DDR? No, not even close. But, it existed nonetheless.
Danke, sehr schön
The “White Circle Laws” must be an obscure or extremely rare word
I am german, i just googled it and found nothing. 'Weißer' (White or whiter but also an old word for someone who has knowledge) could be a name and 'Keis' can mean intermediate level of administration between state and the municipalities.
it is a propaganda term ........ "die weißen Bruderschaften" where a bunch of fraternities that where anti communist
it is basicly a socialist conspiracy theory that those fraternitys secretly control the government...........
-
funny enough when this song was released they where already baned (becouse they organised duels)
I neither know what that means
There’s a translation in the description if you haven’t seen it already
@@baronbrummbar8691
White Brotherhood?
Hey sir do you know any instrumental of this song?I need it pls
Я первый
Молодец
timeless hit
Dieses Lied:
"Gemeinsam sind wir stärker,
Kollege, reih dich ein.
Die für Recht und Frieden kämpfen
Werden unaufhaltsam sein!"
Lied der Partei:
Die Partei, die Partei die hat immer recht
und Genossen es bleibet dabei.
Denn wer kämpft für das Recht,
der hat immer Recht.
Gegen Lüge und Ausbeuterei.
Schön auf Linie, so muss das :D
А третий тем более я
Очень душевная песня
This sounds more like a GDR-made agitprop song aimed at West Germans. The sound and choir is very „Eastern“. But of course they may just be imitating the Socialist 1950s style.
The music group has been funded by the east.
If this were just external propaganda, the song would have been lost in time because it would not have found a response from its audience.
Osten ist besser
Träum weiter. xD
@@VinylLPFreakund du kommst aus Bayern?🤡
@@HansSchultzRP da hast du recht
Im Moment nicht wirklich wenn man sieht wie die Leute im Osten gegen ihre Interessen und im Interesse der Reichen wählen
@@MaxLeonUhlitz er hat definitiv recht
Butter
statt Kanonen
Mehr Lohn
Statt Divisonen
И второй тоже я
Wenns nach mir ginge hätten wir die DDR wieder um Inovationen und Bildung zu fördern, jedoch würde ich das Geldsystem abschaffen, Tauschhandel soll es sein
Calling West Germany the 4th Reich would be unfair, because it would imply the 3rd Reich really ended.
Und warum kommen dann täglich ca. 1000 Illegale nach Deutschland, wenn das Dritte Reich angeblich nicht geendet hat?
de jure, it lives on
de jure it is the only legitimate governing body
Die DDR war die Fortsetzung des Dritten Reiches mit anderen Mitteln.
Die Regierung Westdeutschlands war voller Nazis, die Geschichte bestätigt dies.
@@g.f.w.6402ja und wer hat diese Länder bombardiert die NATO und die USA ich zitiere mal jemanden
Hitler wurde zwar besiegt aber seine Sache lebt weiter😅
who is Springer and Strauß
Axel Springer was the founder and publisher of BILD newspaper which had a deeply conservative leaning back then and was/is still widely circulated.
Franz-Joseph Strauß was the conservative, some would say even right-wing, minister president of Bavaria, with aspirations of becoming Federal Chancellor (he never did).
@@Charon.1 ahhh ok thank you, im assuming those two wanted germany’s borders to return to what they were in 1935 or did they want more
@@america7082 they probably wanted reunification
@@america7082 every party wanted to return to the german borders of 1937 until the 70s
@@nicholasoneal1521the CDU (the party Strauß belomged to) demanded the eastern territories back until 1990
Workers of the World unite!
We exiting out of NATO with this one 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Realitätsgetreu
Also a good title would be german anti centrist song
Was that der Führer in the first crowd photo?!!!
no
@@NotRealOoccaTrust Wait, everyone with a small mustache is not Adolf?!?!?
yea@@jakubkrasny
@@jakubkrasny🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦
@@hewhoremains-kang Well actualy, that was supposed to be a joke (both the comment and the reply) and by the looks of it both him and you didn't get it. ☝️🤓
Stuss
But - it was the GDR-worker who was supressed and locked in....This song sounds as if it was made by some unmature spoiled youth from rich families in Western Germany.
The worker from the east lived better, his rights were protected to the detriment of his employers and the borders of the GDR were always open with all socialist republics (with the exception of Cambodia, the GDR considered this regime fascist under the guise of socialism).
@@fudotoku8179 No, they were state owned slaves.
@@hassanalihusseini1717 proofs?
@@fudotoku8179 They fled to the "evil" west and after that they overthrew the east German dictatorship.
@@hassanalihusseini1717 According to official statistics, more Germans fled to the East than to the West. And the Eastern "dictatorship" was overthrown by a police coup, and Germans who tried to defend the country were shot by "democratic forces"
Gotta say, these people really know how to make propaganda songs. Maybe that's why socialism works so well, huh... Oh wait
First German in space was from the DDR not the capitalist west Germany.
maybe read up on the actual living conditions in the GDR before you make your asinine state department-approved comment
@@comradeLucienne My current state surely doesn't approve of my previous comment.
@@YourBoss_CORP where do you live?
@@comradeLucienne Brazil, and the situation here is harsh...
"Wer steckt die profite ein" Die Antwort hat euch ein Mann vor 80 Jahren gegeben, aber trotzdem wird er gehasst
Wenn du Hitler meinst, dann Nein, der wird zurecht gehasst.
Noch nie so viel dumme Scheiße gelesen.
Falls du auf Adolf anspielst... bitte geh einfach du Reaktionär.
@@linkebazille5943 Erzählt mir jemand mit nem USSR upload, seinen Kanalnamen seiner politischen Ideologie widmet und sein Profilbild Hänno ist
@@linkebazille5943 Weisst du überhaupt was ein Reaktionär ist?
It sounds quite anti statist, sad that it is meant in a red way😢
More like a celebration of the communist idea of direct democracy and workplace democracy, the song focuses on "if you were all in power, the country wouldn't be so shitty."
Are you an anarchist or something?
Because it's quite telling that all of the current AES countries were founded on ML principles, applied to their material conditions. You see, there is still a tiny problem that prevents the abolition of the state (at its current state anyway). Like, idk... the existence of antagonistic capitalist interests that are willing to use any means (billions have been spent on propaganda, assassinations, coups, g***cides, etc) to ensure their dominance. Do you know of Salvador Allende or Mohammad Mosaddegh, for example? They were democratically elected leaders and by no means MLs (but socialist adjacent). And what happened to them? You can find out in the official US statements.
So I suggest you reconsider your idealistic and caricatured view of socialism and its historical development. Because so far it can only be built and preserved by taking a firm stance against the capitalism with its invasive institutions and mechanisms! Oh, and it also doesn't mean that people's demands aren't taken into account by the socialist state (if they don't fundametally contradict its general line). Since we're commenting under a Germany-related video, in the GDR people could participate in referendums regarding the government policies (which wasn't the case in the FRG) and form a variety of public organisations (even for LGBT people, while in the FRG they were criminally prosecuted).
What is Pro-GDR?? Pro-US? 😂😂😂
German Democratic Republic, east Germany. The communist half of Germany.
It means pro east Germany ( German Democratic republic)
What did you mean by this?
noooo
GDR/DRR is east germany
Wenn's nach dir ging, könnte hierzulande
Vieles besser sein,
Darum steh nicht bloß beiseite,
Tritt doch für dich selber ein!
18 millions did so in 1989, so what?
es ist nicht besser.
@@macewindu9100Heute ist nicht besser als vor 1989/90? Man sollte es miterlebt haben, bevor man redet. Oder: Pflaster entfernen, mit denen damals die Augen zugekebt waren.
"Früher war alles besser, da hatten wir einen Kaiser" ist ja lustig, aber die Realität in der DDR vor 35 Jahren war erbärmlich.
Das ist nicht wahr. In Deutschland herrscht Ungleichheit, weil die Regierung eine Marionette der USA ist. Solange sich das nicht ändert, wird niemand gleich sein und es wird immer schlimmer werden.
Tja, ihr habt verloren.
Du nennst also Palästinenser Lied Nazi Musik? Wer hat dir ins Gehirn geschissen? Richtig die Mainstream Medium