@@MimiKeel Israel is fought for that land they bought that land so shut your mouth and Jews have been living there for a long time not just Palestinians it’s both their homes
It's there is freedom of speech, BUT private property prevails. The activist has not right to protest on private property. I support the UC Berkeley Law Professor, and that's not assault at all.
@@disham Putting your hand on someone isn't fucking battery, oh my lord. Suppose I'm standing around in a crowded place and someone goes, "Hey, let me squeeze through" and they put their hand on my shoulder for half a second. Is this assault and battery? Can I sue this individual for assaulting me? No, fucking obviously not. Now imagine I'm trespassing in their house and they tell me to leave and put their and on my shoulder. It's not assault.
@@zarki-games battery requires physical contact AND intent-- the "hey, let me squeeze through" random stranger in a crowded place most likely has no intent to touch you so not considered battery. This old woman clearly had intent to touch the speaker as she verbally announced her intent followed with her physical horse collar -- so yes, this is by definition battery.
@@disham U can keep leaving ur comments all u want but the fact is the girl talking was in the wrong & the old lady did nothing wrong 2 try & stop her, as long as the young girl was on the old ladies private property!
If a lawyer told her she was free to protest there, she wasn't informed of her first amendment rights or laws regarding trespass. No one, absolutely no one, with a law degree would tell her she has a right to protest on private property
well but a public event for students on a private property, is it then private or public playing the game as usual some people seem to get very upset about private property rights shame they don't say that to the West B settlers!
@@frankbardon Yeah in America! you shamefully do not respect foreign countries to have self determination, and you do not have workers right medical rights prisoners rights there is a lot of work to do before being a fully fledged civilised country.😁
@@Faby-tp7hz private property remains private property. An individual has no constitutionally protected right to free speech on private property, that does not change because of an event being hosted there
Guys. If this was in public, it WOULD be wrong of the older couple, but this is quite literally their home and the young lady and her friends had no right to do what she was doing
@koreannyangtigeractually, she doesn't. It's private property. Free speech only applies to public places. Also, this extremely rude and entitled young woman had lied about this incident in interviews. As a guest in this home her rights extend to her freedom to leave as she was told to.
@koreannyangtigerI think the cameraman was invited( as the gentleman said to the cameraman “you are my guest”), but she was uninvited…I think she has every right to speak out her voice in the public, but it is kind of rude to do such thing in someone’s private property…what’s the point of giving such speech here, when there was hardly any audience outside the house….it seems she just wanted to post it on social media…Yes, it was wrong that innocent people were killed in Gaza, and the war should be stopped as soon as possible. But we should not spread hate to innocent Jewels and they are also supposed to live a normal life in the university and anywhere in the world…we really need love and peace for each other!
The man clearly stated that she was a GUEST at their home. She didn't invade their home and start trouble, yet she was assaulted. I am a Christian and don't side with Israel OR Islam, but I DO stand for truth and justice.
Why did the intolerant professor feel so alarmed & threatened ? The student was only making a speech in trying to make a point. She wasn't coming to illegally squat in the house nor did she force her way in. She wasn't pulling our a gun & intending to kill anyone or using violent gestures like Israeli IDF Terrorists routinely do or the typical American cops or trigger happy rednecks. If she had just listened patiently like all teachers should all the hype could have been averted.
She's a brilliant and brave lady. You sound foolish! She was not trespassing. She was invited, talked against the genocide, therefore was interrupted by genocide supporters, and asked to stop and leave, and she refused to give up! You miss the main point, which is: - on one side, being against genocide! - on the other side, supporting genocide, by interrupting actions against the genocide! Haven't you seen, how they always invent a fake reason, to interrupt and prevent anti-genocide peaceful protests, by hateful violent genocide supporters!
If she is protesting on someone’s property then, the lady has every right to kick her off the property. If that is public property then, the protestor is doing nothing wrong
I dont agree with the obnoxious behaviors of either party, but I will say that it's obvious the "protesting" or whatever they are doing is clearly happening in the backyard. Yes, they do need to leave.
@Obvious4everyone not on private property. This is happening in the owners backyard. Now if the Muslim woman was doing this same thing on the sidewalk out front then that is public and she is legally allowed to do that. She cannot do anything like this in the backyard, on there driveway or front lawn. But again the sidewalk is 100 percent legal.
Go and listen to Golda Meir, one of the founders of Israel, who said: "I am a Palestinian, and have carried a Palestinian passport for several years under British mandate of Palestine. Palestine was the area between Jordan River and the sea." She also said: "One cannot and must not try to erase the past merely because it does not fit the present." Now, we have a conversation with a bunch of either ignorant Zionists or liar propagandists, who even don't have the honesty of early Zionists.
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said: "This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
You learned American Law and order is only designed for kind,honest, hard working,Christians who knows how to be grateful only. Any other cultural or religion will only create chaos. New blood will bring in creative people but they must be tested of understanding of American values and morality.
@@msierox She was not trespassing. She was invited, talked against the genocide, therefore was interrupted by genocide supporters, and asked to stop and leave, and she refused to give up! You miss the main point, which is: - on one side, being against genocide! - on the other side, supporting genocide, by interrupting actions against the genocide! Haven't you seen, how they always invent a fake reason, to interrupt and prevent anti-genocide peaceful protests, by hateful violent genocide supporters!
This is what Palestinians have been dealing with for 75 years by the Israelis, yet Americans support Israelis when they trespass and steal Palestinian land.
@@tye8149speak on it!! they’re all hypocrites that act like they can’t understand shit when 40,000 people are murdered in 6 months but can recognize trespassing just fine. sick in the head.
@bobbyf3887 Typical colonialist mentality! No, THAT IS NOT YOUR COUNTRY, ESPECIALLY IF SOUND AMERICAN; which is occupied by genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Natives! OFFENDED BY EVERYTHING, ASHAMED OF NOTHING!
She actually thinks she’s right, and she’s clearly wrong . Remember that next time you argue with an Islamist. They are always convinced they are right. Different culture.
I have seen worse. Such as the victims of IDF soldiers and Israeli military which the activists are speaking on!! Also 30 year old men punching female protesters at a college they don't attend.. just came to hurt someone
This is why none of their brother Arab countries will let them in. Jordan sent 20,000 back to Palestine a few years ago. Hamas even turned down land for a 2 state solution. The Arab world is tired of Palestine ( Hamas ) actually making trouble.
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said: "This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
@@PoPo-io8ts The girl making a speech was an *invited guest* at a private, nonpolitical event hosted by the professors- which makes her behavior grossly rude. The location is the professors’ backyard where they were hosting a dinner for students.
I'm a Muslim, but it is very wrong to go into people's homes to voice your opinion or protest. When you're not invited to. Once they ask you to leave, you should leave. It is a sin to restraints.
Correct, not long ago I was invited to a dinner party and the host asked us not to talk about politics or religion and we respected that wish, and had a great night
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they say occupying is Zl0 defense not offense. False. Pre & post 1948 Zl0 oppressors Iie on Arabs, etc. Key incidents include 1948 K. David HoteI, 54 Iavon affair, Iiberty & O9 - OlI, lraq wmd Iies etc. Bibi even said the last 2 are good for us answering the qui bono w/ audio on yt! Some ppl claim the bible says it's their land, 1st it's no authority & what verse? Read point 4 and rev 2.9 & 3.9. The children of Abraham are Ismailis who learned Arabic and jues who learned Arabic and became Muslim. Even eldest lsraeIi prime m's have Palestine certificates ...
The title of this video is misleading & mischievous. The girl has no right to be doing her protests from private properties. The professor is not assaulting but stopping the girl, which is her right.
Stopping the young girl from talking about a religious holiday really was so important to this professor, that she had to interrupt, grab the girl's phone and tell her to leave. What a freak. #FireHer
@@david_a_uno Whatever the girl wants to speak about, she has no right to do it on anyone's private property and the professor has every right to stop her. In fact it is the student concerned who should be taken to task for breaking the law. Of course most of this lot don't care about secular laws.
@@david_a_uno lmao she doesn't have a right to do that in precious Palestinians That freak would get stoned to death and you know but keep turning the other way and keep reporting others comments cuz it's the truth
The situation we see today in Pakistan, increase in prices & inflation, civil & political chaos and destabilisation at our borders, this was all shown to Muhammad Qasim in his blessed dreams years ago. #MuhammadQasimDreams
@@alcazargr.3886 apparently leftists think they can do whatever they want with zero repercussions. And when there's repercussions they scream racism or whatever ism they think fits the scenario.
I mean this exact situation been happening in Palestine why the double standards why the hypocrisy you don’t call the Zionist what they are occupying lands that is not theirs
So, u do understand that others can’t do as they feel like in the professor house but u fail to understand when a Zionist takes over a house of a Palestinian
🤔🤔🤔 think about what this old lady said about palestinians before this incident....i'm pretty sure this young Muslim lady choiced to do This in front her house because something like hatred against palestinian's ppl occured with this old lady before
@@Bryan-cd9clthis is America. The professor is allowed to say mean things about whomever she wants and the protester was on her property. Not in front.
@@honor6004 It is quite clear she does not consent to the woman doing this on her property, I merely used “asked to leave” as shorthand! Btw, learn your grammar, it’s question not exclamation marks.
@kathym.248 The girl reading in a very monotone voice with a bored and blànk look on her face seemed highly sedated. That maybe why she sounded like that. She did that while a guest in the home of that couple, - unless she broke in uninvited -- like Hamas did when they decided terrorize the peacçe loving in Isràel.
She wasn't trespassing when she started the speech. She is a law student and was invited with other law students to the Deans home. Florida has enough nonsense the way it is.
The 42,000 people giving a thumbs up above you are too rabid/crazy to get this concept in America. They live safe little lives here in the U.S., never too far from a Starbucks, instead of actually fighting for something on the other side of the world. If she actually believed in her convictions she would be in Palestine instead of doing performance art in Berkeley, CA.
Stick to your day job which clearly isn't criminal law. Whether you think it was violent enough to rise to the level of an "attack" the younger woman was assaulted. As for the private property bit, the homeowners should call the cops to have them removed or trespassed. Speech is zero excuse for putting your hands on anyone.
@@TheVuduYuDuactually, if you have told someone to leave and they failed to do so you can use the least amount of force necessary also, she was causing a disturbance with her microphone on their property. I don’t think any court would side with her.
as mentioned by others, its an event held by the dean, which he chooses to hold in his backyard rather than on campus. since its related to the school and not a personal event, if they are part of the guestlist he has no right to remove them for speaking an opinion he doesn't agree with due the protected principle of free speech and protest that a core aspect of American universities. Funny how your freedom only seems to be something to be proud of when it comes to arming mentally ill teenagers
Learn the story behind the situation first. This professor is a Jew but he is also kind enough to invite student over to have a dinner at his home no matter religion or race. So don’t let edit videos control your mind. Sad that the world has come to short clips and not the full story also sad when a student abuses opportunity for other people to learn more from this professor. She could have denied the invitation if she didn’t want to be there but chose to use this as a protest opportunity. Sad world we live in now.
Israelis were very kind to Palestinians before 7th October. Giving them jobs, treating their sick in Israeli hospitals, etc. Be careful what you invite in.
Thanks for sharing. I realize that many of the protesters are letting their emotions causing them to forget that Hamas started this war. They share an equal blame for the loss of innocent lives. They really care about what's happening in the region, turn some of that energy towards asking Hamas to be honest and do the right thing.
The same ones saying it’s her freedom to stand on private property and support terrorist are the same ones who would squat in someone else’s home and call it their own
If you're invited over to someone's house, and you're talking to someone else because a number of you were invited, the host does not "have the right" to come and assault you because they don't like what you and the other guests are talking about. If she wants to come and say, "Hey, do you mind turning off the microphone for a second so we can talk?" And if the person doesn't do that then she can say, "Alright, if you don't want to be reasonable, then I'm going to have to ask you to leave." And at that point if she doesn't leave, the host can call the police. Honestly, all she has to do is say, "I'm a well off white boomer and the person who is trespassing is brown skinned" and the cops will be there so fucking fast your head would spin. To reiterate: speaking is not a threat, even if someone is saying something you don't like, unless what they're saying is LITERALLY a threat, like "I'm going to cause you bodily harm." If I'm invited over to someone's house and I say, "I like pineapple on pizza" and the host tackles me, they're in the wrong. Home owners aren't de facto kings/queens. They still have to live under the law. They don't get to invite people over and assault them if they disagree. Not ok.
@@nathaniel1670 Cuz they have a different mindset: *Qur'an 4:59* “O believers! Obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority among you” *Qur'an 5:101* “O believers! Do not ask about any matter which may disturb you.” *Qur'an 8:13* “Whoever defies Allah and His Messenger, ˹know that˺ Allah is severe in punishment.” *Qur'an 3:151* “We will cast t_____r into the hearts of those who have denied the Truth *Qur'an 5:33* “Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) and cause mischief is that they be k___ or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides”
I hope the people who care so much about the ownerhip right of the genocide supporter pfofessor to expel the invited student who speaks against genocide, SHOW THE SAME CARE ABOUT THE OWNERSHIP RIGHT OF MILLIONS OF PALESTINIANS WHO'S HOUSES WERE DEMOLISHED AND OCCUPIED!
It's unacceptable to protest a genocide? Are you for real? And yes, it is assault. You don't get to invite someone onto your property, then change your mind because you didn't like their behavior, and then physically assault them when you did not feel like you were in danger. Basic law.
I am a Muslim, but will not support what the Muslim lady did here. You can express your opinion in support of Palestinians, but it shouldn't be in front of her house. It's their space. So go somewhere else.
@wemibright2470 In the United States it our first amendment right and if she is not on her property she can say it any where . I would also say the professor has no right to put her hands on another person or the professor could go to jail .. our laws in the United States
@@cynthiabragg2611 if someone protest in front of ur house where ur kids stay ,about black lives matter and grab all the media attention, imagine reporters gathered around ur house where ur kids are playing and you lose your privacy...
@@beadsy-dl5up Trespassing is being anyone else's PROPERTY. Are you that dense? Do I need to quote the law, or are you intelligent enough to read and comprehend yourself? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Free speech is a protection from the government taking it away and it occurs on public property. This lady’s house is private property. Please read a book why don’t you. Or better yet the constitution.
@shaydelre1898 If my grandmother grabbed someone's neck, she would be wrong also. The law is clear. Don't put your hand on somebody else when they don't want you to do that. Just call the police ,why is it, a point as simple as this, is so difficult to understand by some.
As university staff hosting a university event they extended their house into a part of the university. They used their class and race privilege to silence a justified, peaceful protest.
The older woman was NOT assaulting her, nor was she being aggressive. The student was clearly misappropriating the First Amendment. Most people would probably have thrown her ass out of there.
What they are doing is wrong, here’s a verse from Quran: “ Enter not houses other than your own, until you have asked permission and greeted those in them; that is better for you, in order that you may remember. And if you find no one therein, still enter not until permission has been given. And if you are asked to go back, go back, for it is purer for you”
So the male law Professor is Jewish, his wife is also a law professor. They opened their home for students to have a BBQ. When the girl started out the wife came down the stairs after the husband was telling the girl to stop and leave. It was a publicity stunt and was the most egregious thing to do at your professor’s home. Now the girl wants to sue the couple and demands that U Berkeley should fire both professors!!!🤦♀️🤯
the old man clearly said the woman talking was a guest. Just because you don't agree with what they are saying doesn't mean you can put them in a half nelson chokehold.
@@disham That was not a fucking chokehold, my dude. She put her arm over her shoulder. There was not a threat that she would chokehold her. It sounds like she was invited over and then started protesting in their house. It's hard to tell because the video is so obviously edited to leave out any prior context, but it seems like stuff happened prior to the start. I think it's safe to assume that they asked her to stop and she didn't, and they may have asked her to leave, and she didn't comply. That being the case, it absolutely falls within reason to do what she did. She didn't break any law, that's ridiculous.
OK, this has NOTHING in common with what is happening in Palestine. You cannot go to someone's home and make unsolicited speeches. If you do, they have the right to kick you out.
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
If you're a human you don't need to defesive with anything if u have humanity. WE are the ppl we need to respected and valued is justvwestern ppl are only value their lives.onother nations their lives non matters.
هم خارج المنزل و يحتجون و هذا ازعجها، فماذا إذا بالنسبة للفلسطنيين الذين يعتدي عليهم الصهاينة و يقتحمون منازلهم بالسلاح و و يبقون في تلك المنازل بالقوة و لا يحق لك قول شيئ علاوة على ذلك سرقتها و طرد سكانها ، كما اجبروا الملايين بمغادرة فلسطين منذ1948
@@hacialibaytimur4849who said the land was owned by the Palestinian? Anyway this is a different issue with Israel and Palestine, come on, use your brain
Muslims here. This girl was in the wrong. You DO NOT take advantage of someone’s hospitality like that. How pathetic and embarrassing. Always the worst among us that get the most publicity and it infuriates me.
Partly because the so called moderate Muslims do NOTHING to police those among you who are extremists. Assault? That wasn't assault! Women don't/cannot commit assualt.
Dying! You have no idea the history of activism! You think protesting is polite and civilized. You clearly need to read a damn history book. As a former Iraq war protestor I can tell you there is NOTHING...NOTHING new they are doing. They are following the tactics of the civil rights movements in America. People sat in and were dragged out of and off private and public property. Civil rights activists were much more bold. I sat in on wallstreet. Stood at CEOS homes and lawns where we were arrested. Lawd the revisionist history on the internet is dumb
Now change the A word to israeal and you got that right. They think they can continue to steal land with their dual citizenship and it’ll be ok but in the END it won’t. Justice will prevail
Frickin conservatives. Acting like protesting is cult behavior. They said the same thing about civil rights protestors and Viet Nam protestors. Of course now they treat MLK Jr like he was some kind of hero, even though they trashed and the time. Hypocrites.
Doesn't matter. If the property owner asked speaker to leave, and she didn't owner can call police, or document it and later have her dealt with legally, but does not have the right to assault anyone.
@@scpsoto1576actually you are wrong. Trespass is both criminal and civil. If I ask you to leave my house and you don’t I DO have the right to remove you. If you don’t believe me go trespass. Tell me how the goes for you
As a Muslim, this is completely wrong, I honestly want to apologize to all the Americans that have to deal with this now… we Muslims came to your country and act as if we own it. Side note: she says in the video “this is my first amendment right”, so? That doesn’t mean you can go into people property and disturb the peace, just like how you have the second amendment right (the right to bear arms) but can’t own a katyusha or p-51.
This nuisance behavior is referred to in the Quran Chapter 2 verse 11: "And when it is said to them, Do not make mischief in the land, they say: We are but peace-makers." Yes, and this is the very issue our brothers and sisters in Gaza are suffering from, is a settler/transient defining their land ownership rights. As a Muslim girl, I find it completely shameful for a Muslim woman in hyjab to park herself on a man's property and then not leave when the owner says you are not welcome here. There is a group of people that have hyjacked our religion of Islam, and they are parading themselves in shameful ways all under the name of Islam. They are slandering Islam and this is not the way of the Prophet pbuh. may Allah SWT guide these kinds of ppl, ameen.
@@a_leafwhat land,I don't understand,do you want to create history yourself,Gaze was never a country or state,and that land was never there land,pls educate yourself and stop being a embarrassment, I don't see any use of you going to school when you just won't use your common sense
@@cyclez6317 some ppl are saying this is a staged scenario she is doing this with the owners as an exercise to show what is happening in Gaza.... however then that would still be misleading because viewers dont know if this is fake and the result would be she is giving wrong message about Islam...
Although I am Muslim, you don’t have the right to force yourself to stay on a private property when asked to leave. This is the land of the free and this Muslim loves America! 🇺🇸
As a Muslim, you should not love America. And as a Muslim, it’s discouraged for us to have own PR or nationality in Kafir countries when there are plenties of Muslim countries out there.
@@zariftanzil1175 There are no settlers in Gaza. The Israeli government forced them to leave in 2005. Gaza is essentially a nation governed by Hamas that launched a terrorist attack on Oct 7th. Sucks to be stupid.
@@JohnJ469 If they're a nation, Israel shouldn't control their borders and infrastructure. That would go a long way to disarming Hamas. Also, more than half of Palestinians in Gaza weren't old enough to vote in the last election in 2006. An election that Israel hoped Hamas would win, and worked towards that end. Hamas was less threatening to them than the PLO
That young lady has only proven her stupidity. the professor has every right to defend everything and everyone in her property, she can have that muslim lady arrested.
In European countries Muslims believe in enforcing Islamic law upon the entire population. Don't need to read between the lines. Muslims already have marked their property.
@@AaronfromEngland1989 Too bad you live in communist England or else I would come onto your steps and protest you. I have read the entire most unholy Qur'an and my wife grew up in Algeria and Morocco so I know how evil Islam is!
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67She didn't get permission to touch, but she touched because the other didn't have permission for a political speech in a privat property which means you need to follow the rules of that owner and don't necessarily have free speech.
You can't exercise your first Amendment right on people's private properties, that's called trespassing.
Tell that to the Israeli settlerZ.
@MimiKeel you should go to Gaza and China where they killed 1 million Muslims. Oh not caring about that would be hypercritial.
Tell that to hamas, you know... the terrorist organisation?@@MimiKeel
@@MimiKeel Israel is fought for that land they bought that land so shut your mouth and Jews have been living there for a long time not just Palestinians it’s both their homes
No kidding. That's exactly what jews give a crap about in Palestine
It's there is freedom of speech, BUT private property prevails. The activist has not right to protest on private property. I support the UC Berkeley Law Professor, and that's not assault at all.
you are obviously not aware what assault and battery is. Putting your hands on someone is considered battery.
What this professor did is nothing 2 what she could have done 2 trespassers legally. Learn the laws!! & stay of private property!
@@disham Putting your hand on someone isn't fucking battery, oh my lord.
Suppose I'm standing around in a crowded place and someone goes, "Hey, let me squeeze through" and they put their hand on my shoulder for half a second. Is this assault and battery? Can I sue this individual for assaulting me?
No, fucking obviously not. Now imagine I'm trespassing in their house and they tell me to leave and put their and on my shoulder. It's not assault.
@@zarki-games battery requires physical contact AND intent-- the "hey, let me squeeze through" random stranger in a crowded place most likely has no intent to touch you so not considered battery. This old woman clearly had intent to touch the speaker as she verbally announced her intent followed with her physical horse collar -- so yes, this is by definition battery.
@@disham
U can keep leaving ur comments all u want but the fact is the girl talking was in the wrong & the old lady did nothing wrong 2 try & stop her, as long as the young girl was on the old ladies private property!
Seems to be Hamas’s problem….they don’t know how to stay off of other people’s property.
😂
Palestine doesn't belong to the Jew ..
Oh, the irony.
Do you even… own a brain?
@@enfantterrible4460 More like the sarcasm 🤦♂️
Young lady was informed of the first amendment, but not trespassing laws…
If a lawyer told her she was free to protest there, she wasn't informed of her first amendment rights or laws regarding trespass. No one, absolutely no one, with a law degree would tell her she has a right to protest on private property
well but a public event for students on a private property, is it then private or public playing the game as usual some people seem to get very upset about private property rights shame they don't say that to the West B settlers!
@@Faby-tp7hz yeah… in America we have an respect private property rights of our citizens and institutions. Is that a problem?
@@frankbardon Yeah in America! you shamefully do not respect foreign countries to have self determination, and you do not have workers right medical rights prisoners rights there is a lot of work to do before being a fully fledged civilised country.😁
@@Faby-tp7hz private property remains private property. An individual has no constitutionally protected right to free speech on private property, that does not change because of an event being hosted there
Guys. If this was in public, it WOULD be wrong of the older couple, but this is quite literally their home and the young lady and her friends had no right to do what she was doing
@koreannyangtigeractually, she doesn't. It's private property. Free speech only applies to public places. Also, this extremely rude and entitled young woman had lied about this incident in interviews. As a guest in this home her rights extend to her freedom to leave as she was told to.
@koreannyangtigerI think the cameraman was invited( as the gentleman said to the cameraman “you are my guest”), but she was uninvited…I think she has every right to speak out her voice in the public, but it is kind of rude to do such thing in someone’s private property…what’s the point of giving such speech here, when there was hardly any audience outside the house….it seems she just wanted to post it on social media…Yes, it was wrong that innocent people were killed in Gaza, and the war should be stopped as soon as possible. But we should not spread hate to innocent Jewels and they are also supposed to live a normal life in the university and anywhere in the world…we really need love and peace for each other!
Arabs invaded America and now is to late
Arabs invaded America and now is to late
Plus the girl is lying and trying to cause more people to be anti semetic
A muslim here! She definitely has no right to do that on a private property!
That's correct because only Israel can do that to Palestine people.
@@nazacus exatamente correto 👏🏿👏🏿
@@nazacus "Palestine" never existed.
The man clearly stated that she was a GUEST at their home.
She didn't invade their home and start trouble, yet she was assaulted.
I am a Christian and don't side with Israel OR Islam, but I DO stand for truth and justice.
Why did the intolerant professor feel so alarmed & threatened ?
The student was only making a speech in trying to make a point.
She wasn't coming to illegally squat in the house nor did she force her way in.
She wasn't pulling our a gun & intending to kill anyone or using violent gestures like Israeli IDF Terrorists routinely do or the typical American cops or trigger happy rednecks.
If she had just listened patiently like all teachers should all the hype could have been averted.
The student is wrong ,rude, and very tacky. She made herself look foolish instead of getting her point across
She's a brilliant and brave lady.
You sound foolish!
She was not trespassing.
She was invited, talked against the genocide, therefore was interrupted by genocide supporters, and asked to stop and leave, and she refused to give up!
You miss the main point, which is:
- on one side, being against genocide!
- on the other side, supporting genocide, by interrupting actions against the genocide!
Haven't you seen, how they always invent a fake reason, to interrupt and prevent anti-genocide peaceful protests, by hateful violent genocide supporters!
Again... disrespectful people thinking they can can be on private property!! Go to the streets and live their. PRIVATE PROPERTY!!
She was not assaulted..she was chased off private property.
It's not private property, she's on public land
@@anisaayannshe was on a woman’s LAWN aka her house
@@anisaayannwhy are you delusional? Do you not hear/see this is their home?
@@trakaillthey always forcing their own ideologies I detest such nonsense
@@anisaayannblind?
If she is protesting on someone’s property then, the lady has every right to kick her off the property. If that is public property then, the protestor is doing nothing wrong
Yes and the headline saying that she attacked her is false.
@@lululiga333putting your hands on someone without their permission is assault. How thick are you?
Didn't u hear what she was saying about the amendment right?
I dont agree with the obnoxious behaviors of either party, but I will say that it's obvious the "protesting" or whatever they are doing is clearly happening in the backyard. Yes, they do need to leave.
@Obvious4everyone not on private property. This is happening in the owners backyard. Now if the Muslim woman was doing this same thing on the sidewalk out front then that is public and she is legally allowed to do that. She cannot do anything like this in the backyard, on there driveway or front lawn. But again the sidewalk is 100 percent legal.
Law Professor has a right to stop her when it’s in her home. That woman does not know the law.
This isn’t assault. She is telling her to stop illegally disrupting class
Go and listen to Golda Meir, one of the founders of Israel, who said: "I am a Palestinian, and have carried a Palestinian passport for several years under British mandate of Palestine. Palestine was the area between Jordan River and the sea."
She also said: "One cannot and must not try to erase the past merely because it does not fit the present."
Now, we have a conversation with a bunch of either ignorant Zionists or liar propagandists, who even don't have the honesty of early Zionists.
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said:
"This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
You learned American Law and order is only designed for kind,honest, hard working,Christians who knows how to be grateful only. Any other cultural or religion will only create chaos. New blood will bring in creative people but they must be tested of understanding of American values and morality.
Not class. They were hosting a graduation lunch at their home. She was trespassing on private property disrupting people’s lunch.
@@msierox She was not trespassing.
She was invited, talked against the genocide, therefore was interrupted by genocide supporters, and asked to stop and leave, and she refused to give up!
You miss the main point, which is:
- on one side, being against genocide!
- on the other side, supporting genocide, by interrupting actions against the genocide!
Haven't you seen, how they always invent a fake reason, to interrupt and prevent anti-genocide peaceful protests, by hateful violent genocide supporters!
More lies from the left, this professor has a right to defend herself on her own property.
Wow what a statement European Jews arrive in Israel and from day 1 they have more rights than the Palestinians yet they can’t protest ?
Trespassing isn't a right.
And second of all during the Iraq in Afghanistan we had plenty of people on the right that where against that
Defend herself from a mic? lol snowflake
I'm neither right nor left, and I say the professor is a Karen who needs to be arrested.
Now what?
She’s on private property she was asked to leave. She’s trespassing.
Spare us your righteous bullshit
😂😂😂😂😂
“If I don’t steal your home, someone else will steal it,” A settler to a Palestinian woman ...
This is what Palestinians have been dealing with for 75 years by the Israelis, yet Americans support Israelis when they trespass and steal Palestinian land.
Ironic that you understand it when its some white peoples homes
@@tye8149speak on it!! they’re all hypocrites that act like they can’t understand shit when 40,000 people are murdered in 6 months but can recognize trespassing just fine. sick in the head.
Please leave “OUR COUNTRY, YOU ARE GUESTS AT OUR COUNTRY”. This is not Palestine. Go protest over there!!!
She sounds American to me so it is her Counrry
@@melanietaylor5242Anyone can sound American
@@kingwolfboss6144 an accent is usually a good indicator of where someones from and she was in America too so I'd say shes probably American
@@melanietaylor5242An accent can be learnt as well .
@bobbyf3887
Typical colonialist mentality!
No, THAT IS NOT YOUR COUNTRY, ESPECIALLY IF SOUND AMERICAN; which is occupied by genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Natives!
OFFENDED BY EVERYTHING, ASHAMED OF NOTHING!
She actually thinks she’s right, and she’s clearly wrong . Remember that next time you argue with an Islamist. They are always convinced they are right. Different culture.
Tu racontes n’importe quoi, tu es américain ? Ou stupide ?
Meh, just a couple of Biden voters. Imagine the smell...
racist much?
Really?? check again the mentality of those who revel in gen o cide
@@malibudreams2873 is Islamism a race? Lmfao
She wasn't attacked, seriously. Victimhood should be saved for the ones who truly are being attacked.
I have seen worse. Such as the victims of IDF soldiers and Israeli military which the activists are speaking on!! Also 30 year old men punching female protesters at a college they don't attend.. just came to hurt someone
This is why none of their brother Arab countries will let them in. Jordan sent 20,000 back to Palestine a few years ago. Hamas even turned down land for a 2 state solution. The Arab world is tired of Palestine ( Hamas ) actually making trouble.
@@policy8analyst That's exactly what Nazis said about Jews!
The similarities, between NAZIs and NAZIonists, are mind buggling!
"Matti (Mattityahu) Peled in San Francisco May 1992 (you can watch the video on YT"), said:
"This is the situation we have to live with and I have no doubt that direct consequence of the occupation anyone, who said occupation corrupts, was absolutely right, and we are occupying the West Bank and the Gaza Strip for the last 25 years, and this is corrupting us maybe even more than the American Aid ..."
“The Nazis made me afraid to be a Jew and the Israelis made me ashamed to be a Jew.”
Dr Israel Shahak (a holocaust survivor)
She wasn’t assaulted, she was asked to leave but instead decided to make a political statement. This kind of behavior is both pathetic and disgusting!
If she's so passionate about Palestine, she should go there and offer humanitarian relief.
yes! go help, leave
Entitled brat with no manners.
That wasn’t an attack. She was fairly restrained given the circumstances.
BS!
They can protest in public places.She has no rights to make a speech in front of a private property and disturb the neighborhood.
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
In fact, this looks like a public place that does not look like the inside of a house. look carefully . Humanity does not depend on any place
And she was an *invited guest* at a private event, which makes her speech much more rude than just a protest.
@@PoPo-io8ts The girl making a speech was an *invited guest* at a private, nonpolitical event hosted by the professors- which makes her behavior grossly rude. The location is the professors’ backyard where they were hosting a dinner for students.
@@videojgl Humanity does not depend on any place
I'm a Muslim, but it is very wrong to go into people's homes to voice your opinion or protest. When you're not invited to. Once they ask you to leave, you should leave. It is a sin to restraints.
Thanks bro we need common sense or problems will arrive.
Correct, not long ago I was invited to a dinner party and the host asked us not to talk about politics or religion and we respected that wish, and had a great night
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they were invited, if they say leave our home, aren't they proving Palas tine right or teI avev should go to n. poIe and leave ppl alone in that logic, no?
they say occupying is Zl0 defense not offense.
False. Pre & post 1948 Zl0 oppressors Iie on Arabs, etc. Key incidents include 1948 K. David HoteI, 54 Iavon affair, Iiberty & O9 - OlI, lraq wmd Iies etc. Bibi even said the last 2 are good for us answering the qui bono w/ audio on yt!
Some ppl claim the bible says it's their land, 1st it's no authority & what verse?
Read point 4 and rev 2.9 & 3.9.
The children of Abraham are Ismailis who learned Arabic and jues who learned Arabic and became Muslim.
Even eldest lsraeIi prime m's have Palestine certificates ...
Not a Muslim invading someone else’s home and then crying that *they’re* the victim when that person takes their home back. Never. 😂
Jacob the thief?? 🤔🤔🤔
Hasbara will not succeed
“Student trespasses on private property and gets appropriate response”
Fixed the headline for you
She isnt assaulting anyone. That girl is illegally protesting on a private property.
It's still assult, because she isn't the police.
EXACTLY!
@adc821 so people can just come on YOUR PROPERTY AND PROTEST? With no accountability???
@@adc821 so you can shoot someone trespassing but you can't grab them? Lmao make it make sense.
@@SuperJasondennis they were invited originally and when they refused to leave the police shoild have been called
The title of this video is misleading & mischievous. The girl has no right to be doing her protests from private properties. The professor is not assaulting but stopping the girl, which is her right.
Stopping the young girl from talking about a religious holiday really was so important to this professor, that she had to interrupt, grab the girl's phone and tell her to leave. What a freak. #FireHer
@@david_a_uno Whatever the girl wants to speak about, she has no right to do it on anyone's private property and the professor has every right to stop her. In fact it is the student concerned who should be taken to task for breaking the law. Of course most of this lot don't care about secular laws.
@@david_a_uno lmao she doesn't have a right to do that in precious Palestinians
That freak would get stoned to death and you know but keep turning the other way and keep reporting others comments cuz it's the truth
We need the IDF in America we would have less ignorant people.
@@erikhyndman1115cringe
The student is wrong here. Very wrong.
It's exactly the situation in Israel.
You're family is in great danger and people are telling Israel is wrong.
Well... now you can know how it feels for the Palestinians who have had their private property taken away for more than 70 years.
If she's on private property then they have to leave, period. If she's on public property she has freedom of speech rights.
yep, no tolerance for first ammendment at my door. How utterly American and democratic. Mind boggling hypocrisy.
She had to respect the owner of the house. She's disrespectful
She was pointing to the fact that people like you have allowed a whole country occupied by evil guests
Same for israel. Israel was uaing palesitinians private property. Palesitinians saying 'leave our houses' since 1948
@@arshedahmed9782there's never been a State of Palestine
She was trespassing on private property. This isn't an attack. Stop gaslighting
She's not even trespassing. Was invited in and then immediately started to do something they asked her not to do. That's pretty Scummy.
The situation we see today in Pakistan, increase in prices & inflation, civil & political chaos and destabilisation at our borders, this was all shown to Muhammad Qasim in his blessed dreams years ago. #MuhammadQasimDreams
Do you really think they could enter that residence without permission? 😕
@@alcazargr.3886 apparently leftists think they can do whatever they want with zero repercussions. And when there's repercussions they scream racism or whatever ism they think fits the scenario.
@@backhandsmack1358if somebody started randomly protesting and screaming at me I’d probably do the same. Especially if I have no control over it.
this isnt assault, this is trespassing.
As a liberal.. I'm against this sort of protesting. She trespassed on someone else's property. Period.
So, it's wrong to occupy someone else's land? Hmmmm.
liberal?? As a liberal, you should accept everything that comes, including these guys in your own yard
@@anonnon4737Israel left Gaza to the Palestinians…THEY voted Hamas in to power. HAMAS is the problem, not Israel.
@@anonnon4737It’s wrong to believe lies like what you just said, sheep.
@@mnbvcxzlkjhgfdsapoiuytre-pm9wl
Looking for any reason to be confrontational, hey? No secret which political party you're affiliated with.
This is the professor’s home. She has a RIGHT to say leave. The Palestinian supporter was out of order, despicable and rude
tht stupid professor
I mean this exact situation been happening in Palestine why the double standards why the hypocrisy you don’t call the Zionist what they are occupying lands that is not theirs
So do you understand now? What happened?
So, u do understand that others can’t do as they feel like in the professor house but u fail to understand when a Zionist takes over a house of a Palestinian
If she pays rent or exchanged in anyway or is invited, her 1st amendment rights are still active
Imagine going on someone else's property and refuse to leave
This Muslim lady has no right to start a protest at this professors home!! It’s extremely rude!!!
🤔🤔🤔 think about what this old lady said about palestinians before this incident....i'm pretty sure this young Muslim lady choiced to do This in front her house because something like hatred against palestinian's ppl occured with this old lady before
@@Bryan-cd9cl you just created that in your head!! You have no clue what happened!!
It's illegal
@@Bryan-cd9clthis is America. The professor is allowed to say mean things about whomever she wants and the protester was on her property. Not in front.
@@TheLandon8806 Right but the professor should not have touched the student.
There was no assault here… the protester was trespassing on private property.
They're good at scraaming help while breaking laws
The guy says she's a guest,.. what trespassing you rancorous
@@honor6004As soon as she was asked to leave she ceased being a guest!
@@fusionfan6883
Where did you get the "asked to leave" part from !!
@@honor6004 It is quite clear she does not consent to the woman doing this on her property, I merely used “asked to leave” as shorthand! Btw, learn your grammar, it’s question not exclamation marks.
Old man is right First Amendment doesn't mean shit on someone's private property and that person has the right to revoke your presence.
First amendment rights? Girl you are on someone else's property YOU have no RIGHT to exercise YOUR RIGHT ON SOMEONE ELSE'S PROPERTY.
It’s not assault if she’s trespassing
So, it's wrong to occupy someone else's land? Hmmmm.
@@anonnon4737 too obtuse, your point?
@@sidecar7714 if you don't get the point, I can't help you, and you may want to work on your knowledge of criminal law.
@@anonnon4737 Obtuse
Adjective
annoyingly insensitive or slow to understand.
@@sidecar7714 I know what obtuse means, but you missed the point.
Assault???
Not if your trespassing.
Don't come to Florida with that nonsense
Floridaman don't put up with it!
Right!!!!
@kathym.248 The girl reading in a very monotone voice with a bored and blànk look on her face seemed highly sedated. That maybe why she sounded like that. She did that while a guest in the home of that couple, - unless she broke in uninvited -- like Hamas did when they decided terrorize the peacçe loving in Isràel.
Those people whose house she's in are not responsible for what's going on in Palestine.
She wasn't trespassing when she started the speech. She is a law student and was invited with other law students to the Deans home. Florida has enough nonsense the way it is.
@@garymartin9777 When you're asked to leave and refuse, you're trespassing.
On private property, be careful. Expressing your First Amendment rights could lead the owner expressing there 2nd Amendment rights.😳
Yup.
Trespassing on private property has nothing to do with first amendment rights.
She was not attacked for speaking for Gaza.. she was called for trespassing
Exactly
colonizers don't have a right to be entitled.
Sure, Opie. Sure.
@@tutu3909they didn’t directly colonise you silly boy
Газа террористы,хамас.
She can do that on public property but not on individual's property.
Yes agree , that's what Palestinians going through , the satanyahu people take Palestinians land and house , then claiming that's their land 😂
The 42,000 people giving a thumbs up above you are too rabid/crazy to get this concept in America. They live safe little lives here in the U.S., never too far from a Starbucks, instead of actually fighting for something on the other side of the world. If she actually believed in her convictions she would be in Palestine instead of doing performance art in Berkeley, CA.
Расскажи про частную собственность активистам BLM 😂😂
Once a muslim will always a Jihadi. Either she is in burkha or shirt pant their ideology is spreading islam in anyways
that's not her house tho.
First of all, she is not "attacked" by the professor! Secondly, she has no right to do this on private property!! Good grief!
Stick to your day job which clearly isn't criminal law. Whether you think it was violent enough to rise to the level of an "attack" the younger woman was assaulted. As for the private property bit, the homeowners should call the cops to have them removed or trespassed. Speech is zero excuse for putting your hands on anyone.
As far as I know if the person is on my property I have a right to defend it ask them to leave if they don't
The big boys coming our to play😂
@@TheVuduYuDuactually, if you have told someone to leave and they failed to do so you can use the least amount of force necessary also, she was causing a disturbance with her microphone on their property. I don’t think any court would side with her.
as mentioned by others, its an event held by the dean, which he chooses to hold in his backyard rather than on campus. since its related to the school and not a personal event, if they are part of the guestlist he has no right to remove them for speaking an opinion he doesn't agree with due the protected principle of free speech and protest that a core aspect of American universities. Funny how your freedom only seems to be something to be proud of when it comes to arming mentally ill teenagers
@@Rocky12323 Perhaps in some jurisdictions. Where I live even that least amount of force can get you assault charges. Courts will surprise you.
Learn the story behind the situation first. This professor is a Jew but he is also kind enough to invite student over to have a dinner at his home no matter religion or race. So don’t let edit videos control your mind. Sad that the world has come to short clips and not the full story also sad when a student abuses opportunity for other people to learn more from this professor. She could have denied the invitation if she didn’t want to be there but chose to use this as a protest opportunity. Sad world we live in now.
Was this confirmed?
Confirmed or not you can’t go into someone home and protest it’s still wrong
Israelis were very kind to Palestinians before 7th October. Giving them jobs, treating their sick in Israeli hospitals, etc. Be careful what you invite in.
Thanks for sharing. I realize that many of the protesters are letting their emotions causing them to forget that Hamas started this war. They share an equal blame for the loss of innocent lives. They really care about what's happening in the region, turn some of that energy towards asking Hamas to be honest and do the right thing.
@@jrhartley4819 Are you gaslighting or are you that ignorant? They butchered, tortured, and controlled every bit of life of every Palestinian.
The same ones saying it’s her freedom to stand on private property and support terrorist are the same ones who would squat in someone else’s home and call it their own
They have no right to trespass, leave these folks alone. THIS IS AMERICA
This is America? You are suporting zionists and they are stoling palestinians homes
R.e.p.e.n.t time for us!! 😮
She wasn't trespassing. She was invited as part of the law school's student body. Try to keep up, 'Murican.
Hypocrite. Americans literally arm Israelis while they have been doing this to the Palestinians for the last 75 years.
Iraq. Afghanistan. Vietnam. Libya...etc
You better tell that to your damn country
This 'activist' is supporting Hamas and protesting at people's homes is against the law. What a DOPE.
No one has the right to do this when they are on private property. The owners of that property have every right to force them to leave.
Not on private property you are trespassing once told to leave .... PERIOD
If you're invited over to someone's house, and you're talking to someone else because a number of you were invited, the host does not "have the right" to come and assault you because they don't like what you and the other guests are talking about.
If she wants to come and say, "Hey, do you mind turning off the microphone for a second so we can talk?" And if the person doesn't do that then she can say, "Alright, if you don't want to be reasonable, then I'm going to have to ask you to leave." And at that point if she doesn't leave, the host can call the police. Honestly, all she has to do is say, "I'm a well off white boomer and the person who is trespassing is brown skinned" and the cops will be there so fucking fast your head would spin.
To reiterate: speaking is not a threat, even if someone is saying something you don't like, unless what they're saying is LITERALLY a threat, like "I'm going to cause you bodily harm."
If I'm invited over to someone's house and I say, "I like pineapple on pizza" and the host tackles me, they're in the wrong. Home owners aren't de facto kings/queens. They still have to live under the law. They don't get to invite people over and assault them if they disagree. Not ok.
@@cyrusmagnus Exactly, I don't know why this has to be explained in exhaustive detail
@@nathaniel1670 Cuz they have a different mindset: *Qur'an 4:59* “O believers! Obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority among you”
*Qur'an 5:101* “O believers! Do not ask about any matter which may disturb you.”
*Qur'an 8:13* “Whoever defies Allah and His Messenger, ˹know that˺ Allah is severe in punishment.”
*Qur'an 3:151* “We will cast t_____r into the hearts of those who have denied the Truth
*Qur'an 5:33* “Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) and cause mischief is that they be k___ or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides”
@user-84-rg9-8n2 have you ever looked into any of the jewish laws??
I hope the people who care so much about the ownerhip right of the genocide supporter pfofessor to expel the invited student who speaks against genocide, SHOW THE SAME CARE ABOUT THE OWNERSHIP RIGHT OF MILLIONS OF PALESTINIANS WHO'S HOUSES WERE DEMOLISHED AND OCCUPIED!
She's on the professor's property and is asked to leave when she starts behaving in an unacceptable way. That is not assault. Learn basic law.
The title is ridiculous
А почему сионисты на чужой щемле😢?
Good thing you agree then that European hasidic jews can't steal the land of indigenous people in Palestine.
Such poetic justice ❤
@@victorialuchek2164why do Arabs occupy so many countries when they come from Arabia??
It's unacceptable to protest a genocide? Are you for real? And yes, it is assault. You don't get to invite someone onto your property, then change your mind because you didn't like their behavior, and then physically assault them when you did not feel like you were in danger. Basic law.
Clearly nobody knows that is Erwin Chemerinsky. I promise you that he understands the contours of free speech.
I agree with the homeowner. I don't care what she believes in, she doesn't get to hijack someone's gathering in a private home.
"Entitled/delusional student stages a protest at the private residence of a college professor." There, I fixed your headline.
Invited by to do so by the wrong people
Wrong people are the president's of university getting kickback
white woman brain
Go away Palestinians
Defienden la propiedad privada cuando les conviene, de otra forma se ocupa, se apropia, se roba... también es un buen titular
That’s not assault it’s on private property
She was not assaulted. The professor has a right to protect her property and to get the garbage off of it.
I am a Muslim, but will not support what the Muslim lady did here. You can express your opinion in support of Palestinians, but it shouldn't be in front of her house. It's their space. So go somewhere else.
@wemibright2470 In the United States it our first amendment right and if she is not on her property she can say it any where . I would also say the professor has no right to put her hands on another person or the professor could go to jail .. our laws in the United States
It’s their space???? Really??? So when the Palestinian are in their space at home and they are being bombed where should they go?
@@fairnesspaul2594 Stop pretending you care about 🇵🇸, you're just using it to disruption other people's lives.
Loser, a muslim can be a loser and hypocrite too, you are just that
@@cynthiabragg2611 if someone protest in front of ur house where ur kids stay ,about black lives matter and grab all the media attention, imagine reporters gathered around ur house where ur kids are playing and you lose your privacy...
The professor has the right to defend herself against illegal occupation.
So does Palestine
@@learningwithnkno
@@PrakharPrakhar-dh9soyes they do
@@PrakharPrakhar-dh9so that's how a Hippocrate is recognised by there double standards trades
@learningwithnk So Go To Gaza and Defend it! Your Not Defending it Here!
How much is this radical Muslim getting paid to do this .....
She needs to go Protest Hamas. Israel won 76 years ago.
When I think of Jerusalem. I think of Jews and Christians, never Muslims.
The First Amendment is not protected when the law is being broken. Trespassing is a crime.😆😆😆
How do you know she was trespassing?
@africanhistory The professor said,"This is not your house, this is my house and I want you to leave!". What else do you need? 😁
@@africanhistory common sense
@@cajunlogicdiy Since WHEN is a set of stairs called a house
@@beadsy-dl5up Trespassing is being anyone else's PROPERTY. Are you that dense? Do I need to quote the law, or are you intelligent enough to read and comprehend yourself? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
It’s illegal and she’s disgusting for thinking this is okay. What is wrong w these kids? Nobody owes you anything.
Free speech is a right. Nobody gives it. It is the law.
@@kiankian1588 it's the old lady's house, she told her to LEAVE. what if that was your grandma?
Free speech is a protection from the government taking it away and it occurs on public property. This lady’s house is private property. Please read a book why don’t you. Or better yet the constitution.
@shaydelre1898 If my grandmother grabbed someone's neck, she would be wrong also. The law is clear. Don't put your hand on somebody else when they don't want you to do that. Just call the
police ,why is it, a point as simple as this, is so difficult to understand by some.
@@kiankian1588not on private property
Private property. She is not assaulting anyone. The student should have been escorted by police
As university staff hosting a university event they extended their house into a part of the university. They used their class and race privilege to silence a justified, peaceful protest.
This Muslim woman has no right to use someone else’s property for whatever she is preaching or agitating. Disrespectful behaviour
Bro wtf
That doesn’t justify her being at someone else’s private property what’s happening there is what’s happening there separate things
A war against radical Islam is coming.
Is it illegal?
So what about Israeli illegal immigrants stealing houses from Palestinians for decades?
She has no right to protest at someone else's house.
Amen
They're letting her stay with them and she does that. That's ridiculous. That's why people have a problem with them.
Agree so out of character
Tell that to israel settlers since 1947
@@abdullahiabdirizack1673 then move to Israel to tell them! Not at someone's property!
You have no right to privacy or property if the Palestinian's don't have a right to life. You can't have human rights without ALL human rights
The older woman was NOT assaulting her, nor was she being aggressive. The student was clearly misappropriating the First Amendment. Most people would probably have thrown her ass out of there.
The young lady was out of line on this one. She exploited the kindness of these homeowners and was asked to leave. They should have just left.
What they are doing is wrong, here’s a verse from Quran: “ Enter not houses other than your own, until you have asked permission and greeted those in them; that is better for you, in order that you may remember. And if you find no one therein, still enter not until permission has been given. And if you are asked to go back, go back, for it is purer for you”
This is the face of Islam. All smiles until they are inside and fester.
So the male law Professor is Jewish, his wife is also a law professor. They opened their home for students to have a BBQ.
When the girl started out the wife came down the stairs after the husband was telling the girl to stop and leave.
It was a publicity stunt and was the most egregious thing to do at your professor’s home.
Now the girl wants to sue the couple and demands that U Berkeley should fire both professors!!!🤦♀️🤯
@@e.d.4369 Amen
@@arbonneladyTNthat's called a demon type of movement 😅😅😅
The students invaded the professor’s private house. They should be charged with tresspass.
U dumb? The guy said u r guess in our house
the old man clearly said the woman talking was a guest. Just because you don't agree with what they are saying doesn't mean you can put them in a half nelson chokehold.
@@disham That was not a fucking chokehold, my dude. She put her arm over her shoulder. There was not a threat that she would chokehold her.
It sounds like she was invited over and then started protesting in their house. It's hard to tell because the video is so obviously edited to leave out any prior context, but it seems like stuff happened prior to the start. I think it's safe to assume that they asked her to stop and she didn't, and they may have asked her to leave, and she didn't comply.
That being the case, it absolutely falls within reason to do what she did. She didn't break any law, that's ridiculous.
the students, of which she is one, were invited by the professors.
G0D waits on / America/ to Repent😮
❤️🖤🖤🖤🖤
❤️❤️🤍🤍🤍
❤️💚💚💚💚
Americans in Support of a Free Palestine 🇵🇸
This is NOT assault. That’s a university not a protest club. Take it home
OK, this has NOTHING in common with what is happening in Palestine. You cannot go to someone's home and make unsolicited speeches. If you do, they have the right to kick you out.
In fact, it is a humanitarian issue. Secondly, these people could not bear to hear the sound of a microphone, so what about the Palestinians under the rubble of their house???
You right because they just talk not stealing there house
If you're a human you don't need to defesive with anything if u have humanity. WE are the ppl we need to respected and valued is justvwestern ppl are only value their lives.onother nations their lives non matters.
هم خارج المنزل و يحتجون و هذا ازعجها، فماذا إذا بالنسبة للفلسطنيين الذين يعتدي عليهم الصهاينة و يقتحمون منازلهم بالسلاح و و يبقون في تلك المنازل بالقوة و لا يحق لك قول شيئ علاوة على ذلك سرقتها و طرد سكانها ، كما اجبروا الملايين بمغادرة فلسطين منذ1948
Reminds us of Palestine then
I am A Muslim, That girl Shouldn't do these in a Private Property, Fasting is your personal thing , Just keep it personal!
Israil doing this Palestinian own land so they should leave the Palestinian house then.
@@hacialibaytimur4849wtf that got to do with these people
@@hacialibaytimur4849who said the land was owned by the Palestinian? Anyway this is a different issue with Israel and Palestine, come on, use your brain
Doesn’t give you the right to put your hands on anyone. Religion doesn’t mean a fkn thing.
Rude person
I'm muslim and i still condemn her actions because sister you have no right to exercise your amendment right in the people's private property
They are trespassing and have no rights to be there
Muslims here. This girl was in the wrong. You DO NOT take advantage of someone’s hospitality like that. How pathetic and embarrassing. Always the worst among us that get the most publicity and it infuriates me.
Thank you for speaking the truth. ❤❤❤
How inconvenient for that spoiled brat professor to have someone speak about US sending weapons for genocide.
Partly because the so called moderate Muslims do NOTHING to police those among you who are extremists.
Assault? That wasn't assault! Women don't/cannot commit assualt.
What hospitality are you speaking of . She goes to school there . She was not visiting.
@@Sensualsadist It was at the Professor’s private home. It was private property not at the University.
This cult behavior by these activists is getting old.
Dying! You have no idea the history of activism! You think protesting is polite and civilized. You clearly need to read a damn history book. As a former Iraq war protestor I can tell you there is NOTHING...NOTHING new they are doing. They are following the tactics of the civil rights movements in America. People sat in and were dragged out of and off private and public property. Civil rights activists were much more bold. I sat in on wallstreet. Stood at CEOS homes and lawns where we were arrested. Lawd the revisionist history on the internet is dumb
Now change the A word to israeal and you got that right. They think they can continue to steal land with their dual citizenship and it’ll be ok but in the END it won’t. Justice will prevail
FR
it pisses me off cause there are real good activists out there getting the stigma from these idiot ones
Frickin conservatives. Acting like protesting is cult behavior. They said the same thing about civil rights protestors and Viet Nam protestors. Of course now they treat MLK Jr like he was some kind of hero, even though they trashed and the time. Hypocrites.
This wasn't assault..this was self defense...she was on their property.
Free Palestine from all lies and liers as well as from sins, transgressions and iniquities
She wasn’t attacked. She was being obnoxious.
1000%
Doesn't matter. If the property owner asked speaker to leave, and she didn't owner can call police, or document it and later have her dealt with legally, but does not have the right to assault anyone.
@@scpsoto1576actually you are wrong. Trespass is both criminal and civil. If I ask you to leave my house and you don’t I DO have the right to remove you. If you don’t believe me go trespass. Tell me how the goes for you
@@brianholloway6205no, they were invited.
He says it himself, "you are guests in our house."
@@laman012 invitations can be revoked. It’s clear there was a revocation…don’t step into legal semantics with me
As a Muslim, this is completely wrong, I honestly want to apologize to all the Americans that have to deal with this now… we Muslims came to your country and act as if we own it.
Side note: she says in the video “this is my first amendment right”, so? That doesn’t mean you can go into people property and disturb the peace, just like how you have the second amendment right (the right to bear arms) but can’t own a katyusha or p-51.
This nuisance behavior is referred to in the Quran Chapter 2 verse 11:
"And when it is said to them, Do not make mischief in the land, they say: We are but peace-makers."
Yes, and this is the very issue our brothers and sisters in Gaza are suffering from, is a settler/transient defining their land ownership rights.
As a Muslim girl, I find it completely shameful for a Muslim woman in hyjab to park herself on a man's property and then not leave when the owner says you are not welcome here.
There is a group of people that have hyjacked our religion of Islam, and they are parading themselves in shameful ways all under the name of Islam.
They are slandering Islam and this is not the way of the Prophet pbuh.
may Allah SWT guide these kinds of ppl, ameen.
@@a_leafwhat land,I don't understand,do you want to create history yourself,Gaze was never a country or state,and that land was never there land,pls educate yourself and stop being a embarrassment, I don't see any use of you going to school when you just won't use your common sense
@@a_leaf I agree sister, this is completely wrong.
@@cyclez6317 some ppl are saying this is a staged scenario she is doing this with the owners as an exercise to show what is happening in Gaza....
however then that would still be misleading because viewers dont know if this is fake and the result would be she is giving wrong message about Islam...
@@a_leaf exactly, if this was staged then at least address that and put a disclaimer or something in the video
UNBELIEVABLE HYPOCRISY!
How many Muslims would allow a CHRISTIAN to stand up on the steps of their property and proclaim their belief?
She didn’t assault her. The student was told to leave & was on private property. At that point she was trespassing.
If she is at the professor’s house then the professor should have her arrested for trespassing on her property.
The problem is she lives in California and if she calls the police they won't do anything.
The police would arrive 2 days later just to get a report.
@@evansusmc If it takes cops three days to show up, you’ve got plenty of time to follow triple S protocol.
The professor needs to show some better muscle
@@finngamesknudson1457 what protocol?? I have no idea what that is
I'm a Muslim, and I believe you should leave that woman alone. It's her private property. You have no rights to be there.
Its funny though.
Someone who hateful would not touch you, that woman who wants her to leave was being nice
@@jocelyntimothe6778 so if id hit someone, that also wouldn't be hateful, right?
Litterally ignored what the lady withthe hijab said about this lol
@@affable0072yea lol not everyone has to care about the useless point you’re trying to make 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
The Professor did NOT ATTACK THE YOUNG WOMAN.
Funny how this is splitting the woke.
Although I am Muslim, you don’t have the right to force yourself to stay on a private property when asked to leave. This is the land of the free and this Muslim loves America! 🇺🇸
I'm starting to lose hope in Muslims. So thank you for your logical perspective
As a Muslim, you should not love America. And as a Muslim, it’s discouraged for us to have own PR or nationality in Kafir countries when there are plenties of Muslim countries out there.
And this Catholic American loves his USA loving Muslim Brother!! And will help him back up the us constitution anyday!!!
When people tell you to leave THEIR property, you LEAVE.
And what about Palestine which is the land of Palestinian???
@@user-yn1xw6xf2lyap yap yap all hou do is yap
Unless you're Israeli
You have no property if your country has open Borders. You private area is meaningless, and soon to be worthless.
I wish Israeli could understand this
It's not assault ! She is telling her the facts !
Send the protesters to Palestine that is where it would take effect
She needs to go to Palestine. See how well they treat her.
“Leave our house” is exactly what the Palestinians should have said to Hamas instead of helping them come to power.
they've been saying it to illegal israeli settlers long before hamas even existed. it seems it didn't help the cause
@@zariftanzil1175 There are no settlers in Gaza. The Israeli government forced them to leave in 2005. Gaza is essentially a nation governed by Hamas that launched a terrorist attack on Oct 7th. Sucks to be stupid.
West Bank told hamas to leave and once they did, 700,000 illegal chosen people settlers came in... that never happened in gaza because hamas resisted.
ye
@@JohnJ469 If they're a nation, Israel shouldn't control their borders and infrastructure. That would go a long way to disarming Hamas. Also, more than half of Palestinians in Gaza weren't old enough to vote in the last election in 2006. An election that Israel hoped Hamas would win, and worked towards that end. Hamas was less threatening to them than the PLO
That young lady has only proven her stupidity. the professor has every right to defend everything and everyone in her property, she can have that muslim lady arrested.
I hope she was arrested
Acting so entitled
Is it true that islam teaches d e a th to America,? if that is the case, how can islam be welcome in America?
actually she doesn’t, you can’t assault someone in california to make them leave, we don’t have the Castle Doctrine.
@@libreverdaderamente4450thats not true
In European countries Muslims believe in enforcing Islamic law upon the entire population. Don't need to read between the lines. Muslims already have marked their property.
Yes, and the homeowner has a right to push her ass off her property😂
Facts: A trespassing young woman bulling an old couple in their own home.
Why didn't the police arrests her?
This was NOT an assault. This Muslim girl should have been arrested!
no crime.
Trespassing on personal property she is on the steps
@@Stylenwavin She was on THEIR steps - THEIR property!
The old lady needs to be jailed
@@AaronfromEngland1989 Too bad you live in communist England or else I would come onto your steps and protest you.
I have read the entire most unholy Qur'an and my wife grew up in Algeria and Morocco so I know how evil Islam is!
This is wrong. The elder woman is right
How come? She touched her without permission and tried to stop her free speech. Shut tf
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67those protesters were on her private property. Come on.
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67the woman has every right to protect her PRIVATE property
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67She didn't get permission to touch, but she touched because the other didn't have permission for a political speech in a privat property which means you need to follow the rules of that owner and don't necessarily have free speech.
@@MONKEY.D.LUFFY67 Who invited hamas to the pulled pork sandwich party