Don't know if you watch Jen Phelps, but she asked her viewers which brands they thought were over rated, Charlotte Tilbury was the one most said was just not worth the money or the hype.
I so agree with you on the Charlotte Tilbury foundation stick. I cannot imagine how anyone could like this. Its like taking olive oil and mixing it with Hollywood Flawless Filter. Its the worst.
Totally agree with the NYX blush! I just saw a well known creator put that on, and I immediately gasped a bit! She likes blush and over applies, in my opinion, but wow, that one looked terrible.
I think when you get older you outgrow certain brands . In my teens it was Constance Carol lol, 20s it was Rimmel ,30s Mac & 40s Charlotte tilbury. I can’t wear any of them anymore they’re so drying and look terrible. I was losing hope now at 52 but recently I bought the Dior foundation & primer ,hourglass evil eye pallet and hourglass balm phantom duo and 2 Natasha Denona pallets .I love them all and I have fell back in love with makeup .
Totally agree on the NYX blush, I have seen it used and over pigmented, which i never thought was a thing, and this makes it patchy, also the ELF CC foundation..highlights every flaw 😮
I do appreciate your honest review about the NYX butter blush. I hate nothing more than a super pigmented blush and drugstore blushes tend to be like that. When everyone was raving about them, I thought they must be different, but then I saw your review. Thanks for saving me a few $ 😊
I like the elf cc cream on busy mornings but I need to powder it again within 3hours of it being on. I have just tried the collection foundation and that was amazing for my skin thank for the tip off on that gem.
For some inquisitive reason , these seem to be my favorite type of content of the year?! Especially over- hyped, over-priced illusions of viral beauty launches mostly high end & luxury cash grabbers greedy , misleading , lazy launches of brands not thinking through releases?! 🙅🏼♀️🙇🏼♀️
Totally agree on the CT foundation stick it’s horrendous. I purchased the Murad spf as I wanted something to wear underneath my foundation and I definitely agree with you on that one! It’s so greasy and as you say the only way to wear it is by using a small amount which totally defeats the purpose xx
Thank you for your honesty. As you stated, what works for you or doesn't work for you. Is ones own preference. It's based on skin type, texture, tone, and under tone. Informative product reviews, whether positive or negative, are much appreciated. Happy New Year!
I bought a Nyx buttermelt blush. I agree the shade looked very different in person. I thought I was buying a somewhat neutral pink shade, but is was darker and brighter then I expected. And yes, it is extremely pigmented, I have to proceed with caution! I did learn to love it, though. I bought a glowy shade, and because I use so ridiculously little, I don't really see a glow. But I do kind of love it nevertheless. Took some time though.
I agree with you on the NYX blushes. I still use them but I have to put them on as you said. I put it on the back of my hand and then carefully apply them on to the cheeks. I will not be buying them again if I can get through them before they expire.
I feel the exact same way about the NYX butter blush! thought I was the only one as so many RUclipsrs talk about how great it is. I bought so many shades afterwards and none of them worked even the lightest shade. Too pigmented and applied patchy.
Hi Gemma. Really appreciate your honesty. What works for one doesn't necessarily work for all. I do enjoy the buttermelt bronzer in one of the only neutral tone shades but I apply it very sparingly! Have a wonderdul New Years Eve. Hugs from Wales x
Hey Jema. Happy new year From France. Your Dior bronzer is nicer if you use it as a blush but with a light hand specialy because your are fair It’s going to be very chic for sure. Tangerine is so nice in any season
I think the "worst/dont waste your money" are better when they list a recommendation along side it in a "by this, not that" style. Hope you feel better soon 😊
I only got the Charlotte Tillbury foundation stick as a sample, so glad I didn’t pay for it. Thanks for the tip on the Dior bronzer, it was in my shopping bag. 😬
I have a NYX blush and bronzer and sort of wish I didn't. I really don't like the blush. The bronzer is a wee bit better but not a lot. You called it! Happy New Year from the great state of Texas!
My worst buy of 2024 was the Dior foundation stick. It seriously irritated my skin. I couldn't wear it and had to return it to Sephora. (I suspect the culprit ingredient was the fragrance.) Happy New Year, Gemma! Hope you feel better soon.
Gemma: Great info. Subbed. RE The CT “Tin Man” stick: Have you tried the under eye (I use all over) highlighter by Catrice? Best part: $6.00 (maybe about £4. for you). It got so much buzz and it does not disappoint! FABULOUS. Also, I agree with your thumbs up on the ELF Soft Glam Foundation being chef’s kiss -on a nurse’s budget. 🧑🍳 💋
Thought it was me, the NYX Butter blushes, UGH!! I love most of their products, but these look ridiculous on my fair, mature, olive undertone skin. The color is "off" and they are patchy, too dark or too glittery. Many blessings for a wonderful 2025!!💖💖💖
Totally avoided the Dior bronzers because of your previous review! Hello tangerine!!😂 By the way your makeup is stunning today😍What have you got on your skin and eyes? Pure beautiful perfection ❤Get better soon♥️
I felt the same about the skintint until I went 2 shades darker. Prime with the CT flawless poreless, apply LOADS of the tint stick and work in with fingers. Set with a spray like Mario surreal skin and you will have a glowy day in a good way!
The NYX blush was horrendous on me too. There were no samples to try in boots so I had to go off the image on the display and when I got it home and opened it, it was a bright almost fuchsia pink..I'm fair like you!! So pigmented that I just cannot use it without looking like a clown.
Thank you for being honest about the nyx buttermelt blush. Everyone else loves it because they are getting paid to love it. Thanks also for using common sense with the refy mascara. What ridiculous gimic.
Thank you. This however is one of the reasons why I don’t do reviews on beauty products because what works for one will not for another.your vlogs are always helpful though.Have a Happy New Year!!! X
Soooo glad you mentioned the Maybelline plumping gloss!! If you are one of those people that loves pain and discomfort go ahead and buy - absolutely awful!!! 😂
Love you humor. I personally cannot stand any Charlotte T products not a single one. I have not bought any but I have tried at sephora. I have found amazing drug store dupes from elf revlon and many others. Happy New Year!
What a shame that you have to explain that this is your personal opinion. Surely, that's obvious, but I guess not to some?🤔🤷♀️ Nice to know your views, so we can make our own choice whether we purchase or not.❤
Hi Gemma...just wondered if you could recommend a lotion/serum to use on my 61 yr old sensitive skin after using my new red light therapy panel that I got for xmas
I have thst Refy mascara I didn't buy it, it was in a christmas box, and it's still to be tried, but thanks for the warning, luckily I bought a 20x magnifying mirror, must make sure I use it. The great thing for me is if I don’t like something I can reach my bin from my dresser 😅😅, I will be very carefull and I have lots of mascaras tp go through so non get a second chance. Xx😊❤
Excellent reviews, I haven't tried any of those products, but with so much choice it's really helpful to get your thoughts, reassuring to know I'm not the only one with duds😂, my only consolation is recycling them at boots😅. Thank you, get well soon💐💐💐
Ohhh that damn Murad SPF! I tried the one Gemma mentioned and a previous version. Can’t believe I fell for it twice AND that Murad tried putting the formula out more than once.
LOL, the conclusion could be, there is no one company that has great product across the line for every type of skin. It's all trial and error, and then, your skin changes on you. This is life.
I'm sure you've watched Charlotte Holdcroft's video where she changed her opinion of the CT foundation stick? She changed the way she uses it and now it's a favourite. I know your skin types aren't the same though x
If you are looking for a tinted SPF you can try Sunforgettable total protection face shield FLEX from Colorscience. It is a mineral sunscreen that adapts to your skin tone. It is my one-and-done and i love it. I mix Fair and Medium but you will probably only need Fair.
Hi Gemma, I highly recommend Drmtlgy’s Universal Tinted Moisturizer spf 46. I absolutely love the formula alone or under makeup. Another amazing tinted moisturizer (without spf) is Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin. I was late to discovering it but it has become my favorite foundation in 2024.
Right off the bat, I KNEW Charlotte's stick was going to make your worst list. Mine went unused and unloved until I just started using it as a highlighter stick at the very end of my makeup routine. And BAM! Perfect highlighter stick. Not too shimmery, not blinding, just right for THAT purpose. Sometimes you just have to figure out new ways to use a product. Happy New Year ALL!
I don’t think you were the only one who hated the NYX blush, Gemma. I think Tati wasn’t a fan of it too. I really don’t like NYX’s color palette in general and I hate their marketing/packaging. The “glue” primer concept was stupid…I’ll never know if the product was good because the glue bottle was really off putting.
Your lips look like they are smeared with oil. I think you have a complex about your lips. Why not try a frosted very pale lipstick .The oil slick on your lips imho ruins the effect of your otherwise immaculate makeup
Charlotte Tilbury is the most over rated and expensive makeup / skin care ..the emperors new clothes
I couldn't agree more.
The magic / secret etc 😂
DARLINGS 😬
@@k.popper2620😂
Don't know if you watch Jen Phelps, but she asked her viewers which brands they thought were over rated, Charlotte Tilbury was the one most said was just not worth the money or the hype.
Being honest is never a bad idea. I appreciate it😊
I am always here for a WORST OF video!! Helps me learn what is good/bad in cosmetics.
I so agree with you on the Charlotte Tilbury foundation stick. I cannot imagine how anyone could like this. Its like taking olive oil and mixing it with Hollywood Flawless Filter. Its the worst.
Totally agree with the NYX blush! I just saw a well known creator put that on, and I immediately gasped a bit! She likes blush and over applies, in my opinion, but wow, that one looked terrible.
I can’t use the Nyx blush either. I’m very fair and even the lightest colors are way too pigmented for me.
I think when you get older you outgrow certain brands . In my teens it was Constance Carol lol, 20s it was Rimmel ,30s Mac & 40s Charlotte tilbury. I can’t wear any of them anymore they’re so drying and look terrible.
I was losing hope now at 52 but recently I bought the Dior foundation & primer ,hourglass evil eye pallet and hourglass balm phantom duo and 2 Natasha Denona pallets .I love them all and I have fell back in love with makeup .
Totally agree on the NYX blush, I have seen it used and over pigmented, which i never thought was a thing, and this makes it patchy, also the ELF CC foundation..highlights every flaw 😮
I do appreciate your honest review about the NYX butter blush. I hate nothing more than a super pigmented blush and drugstore blushes tend to be like that. When everyone was raving about them, I thought they must be different, but then I saw your review. Thanks for saving me a few $ 😊
I agree with you about the Nyx blush. I have to use it very sparingly, which is too much of a pain.
Your honesty is always refreshing. Thanks for all your reviews and opinions on products this year.
Happy New Year. Hope you’re feeling better. X
You're not alone on the NYX blushers and bronzers. I have no desire to go there.
La. Ros posey is the best sun block hands down, no question.
I like the elf cc cream on busy mornings but I need to powder it again within 3hours of it being on. I have just tried the collection foundation and that was amazing for my skin thank for the tip off on that gem.
Love your honesty - this is what we watch you for xx
Thanks Gemma hopefully you feel better very soon
& have a fantastic new year 🎊 🎊 🎉🎉
I'm glad you mentioned the NYX blush. I was thinking about buying it.
The nyx blush is lovely just very pigmented, definitely worth a try, will last an eternity 😂 xx
For some inquisitive reason , these seem to be my favorite type of content of the year?! Especially over- hyped, over-priced illusions of viral beauty launches mostly high end & luxury cash grabbers greedy , misleading , lazy launches of brands not thinking through releases?! 🙅🏼♀️🙇🏼♀️
Totally agree on the CT foundation stick it’s horrendous. I purchased the Murad spf as I wanted something to wear underneath my foundation and I definitely agree with you on that one! It’s so greasy and as you say the only way to wear it is by using a small amount which totally defeats the purpose xx
Thank you for your honesty. As you stated, what works for you or doesn't work for you. Is ones own preference. It's based on skin type, texture, tone, and under tone. Informative product reviews, whether positive or negative, are much appreciated.
Happy New Year!
I bought a Nyx buttermelt blush. I agree the shade looked very different in person. I thought I was buying a somewhat neutral pink shade, but is was darker and brighter then I expected. And yes, it is extremely pigmented, I have to proceed with caution! I did learn to love it, though. I bought a glowy shade, and because I use so ridiculously little, I don't really see a glow. But I do kind of love it nevertheless. Took some time though.
I’m with you on the Nyx blush and bronzer both were patchy. And everyone I saw use it on RUclips looked patchy.
I agree with you on the NYX blushes. I still use them but I have to put them on as you said. I put it on the back of my hand and then carefully apply them on to the cheeks. I will not be buying them again if I can get through them before they expire.
Yes i as well can hear your not feeling well hope you feel better. Soon but yes you look amazing 🤩❤
I feel the exact same way about the NYX butter blush! thought I was the only one as so many RUclipsrs talk about how great it is. I bought so many shades afterwards and none of them worked even the lightest shade. Too pigmented and applied patchy.
Hi Gemma. Really appreciate your honesty. What works for one doesn't necessarily work for all. I do enjoy the buttermelt bronzer in one of the only neutral tone shades but I apply it very sparingly! Have a wonderdul New Years Eve. Hugs from Wales x
Hey Jema. Happy new year From France. Your Dior bronzer is nicer if you use it as a blush but with a light hand specialy because your are fair It’s going to be very chic for sure. Tangerine is so nice in any season
I love the refy mascara, builds up well and is mostly lengthening. Never poked my eye 😂😂 xx
I think the "worst/dont waste your money" are better when they list a recommendation along side it in a "by this, not that" style.
Hope you feel better soon 😊
Great video on fails but with a good explanation for each. Thank you so much ❤❤❤
NYX blushers...... awful! Bought it, tried it, chucked it in a bin. Totally on your side Gemma.
I only got the Charlotte Tillbury foundation stick as a sample, so glad I didn’t pay for it. Thanks for the tip on the Dior bronzer, it was in my shopping bag. 😬
Love your videos Gemma..your entitled to your opinion you speak how you find..Happy New Year ❤
I have a NYX blush and bronzer and sort of wish I didn't. I really don't like the blush. The bronzer is a wee bit better but not a lot. You called it! Happy New Year from the great state of Texas!
I love your honest review of all of the products you try, It saves grief to not buy things when their are so many choices available, for me anyway-
My worst buy of 2024 was the Dior foundation stick. It seriously irritated my skin. I couldn't wear it and had to return it to Sephora.
(I suspect the culprit ingredient was the fragrance.)
Happy New Year, Gemma! Hope you feel better soon.
You are so fortunate in the US that you can return makeup products. Buyer beware in the UK & Ireland.
You were spot on about the NYX Gemma.better to be honest.All the best for 2025 🎉☃️
"Fills me with dread" 😂
Gemma: Great info. Subbed. RE The CT “Tin Man” stick: Have you tried the under eye (I use all over) highlighter by Catrice? Best part: $6.00 (maybe about £4. for you). It got so much buzz and it does not disappoint! FABULOUS. Also, I agree with your thumbs up on the ELF Soft Glam Foundation being chef’s kiss -on a nurse’s budget. 🧑🍳 💋
Thought it was me, the NYX Butter blushes, UGH!! I love most of their products, but these look ridiculous on my fair, mature, olive undertone skin. The color is "off" and they are patchy, too dark or too glittery.
Many blessings for a wonderful 2025!!💖💖💖
Totally avoided the Dior bronzers because of your previous review! Hello tangerine!!😂 By the way your makeup is stunning today😍What have you got on your skin and eyes? Pure beautiful perfection ❤Get better soon♥️
Love whatever lip colour you're wearing in this video, really suits you! What is it?
I felt the same about the skintint until I went 2 shades darker. Prime with the CT flawless poreless, apply LOADS of the tint stick and work in with fingers. Set with a spray like Mario surreal skin and you will have a glowy day in a good way!
The NYX blush was horrendous on me too. There were no samples to try in boots so I had to go off the image on the display and when I got it home and opened it, it was a bright almost fuchsia pink..I'm fair like you!! So pigmented that I just cannot use it without looking like a clown.
Hi Gemma I hate it too ! You’re not alone so it’s ok it’s not a skin tint it’s a something from that should have stayed in the lab !!! .
Thank you for being honest about the nyx buttermelt blush. Everyone else loves it because they are getting paid to love it. Thanks also for using common sense with the refy mascara. What ridiculous gimic.
I love your honesty! Happy New Year!🧡
Another great video, thank you for your opinions ☺️ do you have any thoughts on the tatti lashes ? X
Thank you. This however is one of the reasons why I don’t do reviews on beauty products because what works for one will not for another.your vlogs are always helpful though.Have a Happy New Year!!! X
Looking for a neutral or cool tone brown matte pen liner. Everything seems so red!!! ❤
Have a look at VB. 😍
Soooo glad you mentioned the Maybelline plumping gloss!! If you are one of those people that loves pain and discomfort go ahead and buy - absolutely awful!!! 😂
The CT foundation stick I use like the Hollywood filter under foundation
Guess what I found cleaning out my closet this weekend? My Pampered Wolf t-shirt! I can’t wait for summer! I forgot how pretty that dusty blue is. ❤❤❤
@@JPMJPM oh wow! I wore my hoodie the other day xxx
Love you humor. I personally cannot stand any Charlotte T products not a single one. I have not bought any but I have tried at sephora. I have found amazing drug store dupes from elf revlon and many others. Happy New Year!
What a shame that you have to explain that this is your personal opinion. Surely, that's obvious, but I guess not to some?🤔🤷♀️ Nice to know your views, so we can make our own choice whether we purchase or not.❤
I love the CT foundation stick. However, i think it's been named terribly. Mix it with the Dior stick foundation and the result is stunning.
Hi Gemma...just wondered if you could recommend a lotion/serum to use on my 61 yr old sensitive skin after using my new red light therapy panel that I got for xmas
I have thst Refy mascara I didn't buy it, it was in a christmas box, and it's still to be tried, but thanks for the warning, luckily I bought a 20x magnifying mirror, must make sure I use it. The great thing for me is if I don’t like something I can reach my bin from my dresser 😅😅, I will be very carefull and I have lots of mascaras tp go through so non get a second chance. Xx😊❤
Oh no! I am going to use the CT stick today . I use it over DM blurring balm
I have a couple of the lip plumper glosses and I have had no problems. Just a 3 on tingle scale (1-10)
Sounds like an allergic reaction for sure.
Excellent reviews, I haven't tried any of those products, but with so much choice it's really helpful to get your thoughts, reassuring to know I'm not the only one with duds😂, my only consolation is recycling them at boots😅. Thank you, get well soon💐💐💐
Haven’t seen anyone like the Tilburry foundation stick or the murad spf.
Ohhh that damn Murad SPF! I tried the one Gemma mentioned and a previous version. Can’t believe I fell for it twice AND that Murad tried putting the formula out more than once.
I purchased that painful plumping gloss and it went in the bin yuck!
First time watching you. I don't see where you share what makeup you have on in this video. Curious about the eye shadow.
LOL, the conclusion could be, there is no one company that has great product across the line for every type of skin. It's all trial and error, and then, your skin changes on you. This is life.
I'm sure you've watched Charlotte Holdcroft's video where she changed her opinion of the CT foundation stick? She changed the way she uses it and now it's a favourite. I know your skin types aren't the same though x
If you are looking for a tinted SPF you can try Sunforgettable total protection face shield FLEX from Colorscience. It is a mineral sunscreen that adapts to your skin tone. It is my one-and-done and i love it. I mix Fair and Medium but you will probably only need Fair.
I disagree about the Murad SPF, I was happy with it as I didn't have to use a moisturizer. The prize is ridiculous though.
Hi Gemma, I highly recommend Drmtlgy’s Universal Tinted Moisturizer spf 46. I absolutely love the formula alone or under makeup. Another amazing tinted moisturizer (without spf) is Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin. I was late to discovering it but it has become my favorite foundation in 2024.
I can hear you’re poorly but boy you look good on it 😂
Right off the bat, I KNEW Charlotte's stick was going to make your worst list. Mine went unused and unloved until I just started using it as a highlighter stick at the very end of my makeup routine. And BAM! Perfect highlighter stick. Not too shimmery, not blinding, just right for THAT purpose. Sometimes you just have to figure out new ways to use a product. Happy New Year ALL!
❤❤❤❤❤
I've yet to find a Charlotte Tilbury product I like.
Her lipsticks are fabulous - the only thing I buy from her brand as I find everything else totally overrated.
Maysama LED pulse light face mask, stopped working after a few months. No response from their customer service. Very disappointing.
I don’t think you were the only one who hated the NYX blush, Gemma. I think Tati wasn’t a fan of it too. I really don’t like NYX’s color palette in general and I hate their marketing/packaging. The “glue” primer concept was stupid…I’ll never know if the product was good because the glue bottle was really off putting.
the teddy lipstick from maybelline is awfull fur me. Dry, strange feeling, ickkkkk
Absolutely horrific product!! They were the WORST!
What are you wearing on your face today?
That CT foundation stick is awful - such a rip off and is in no way foundation.
Your lips look like they are smeared with oil. I think you have a complex about your lips. Why not try a frosted very pale lipstick .The oil slick on your lips imho ruins the effect of your otherwise immaculate makeup
you seem to be a very rude person
You seem to waste a lot of money. Don't you read the reviews first
The Nyx blushers make me think of the old Motorola PEBL cellphones.
Yes, I am also slightly "vintage"...
(and I 💖 the Charlotte Tilbury Stick !! 🫢🙀)