For me, it was Silent Hill 2. I grew up watching horror movies with my mom, so things like blood, gore, torture, and dismemberment were nothing new. But that one scene where you walk into the apartment and find Pyramid Head with the Mannequins...? That's when you know you've just entered a very special place in Hell.
The broken neck ghost from the first fatal frame freaked me out a LOT.... Riiiight up until i had to fight her in the end cause by that point i was so pissed if she wasnt already a ghost i was gonna make her one.
@@ajaakola2 Right!?? I'm so happy to see others who like it. I swear I only ever see/hear contempt and hate for it but I really loved it despite its transparent flaws (and I started w/ the OG 1 & 2). It had, imo, one of the better stories for SH, did the horror aspect more effectively in many ways, and ugh, that Akira Yamaoka piano music... some of his best stuff, I'd say. You guys are cool.
I can't decide between any of the first four, they're all great, all scary for different reasons. I feel if one of them doesn't scare an individual for whatever reason then another one of the titles definitely will. SH3 might've been the one that made me freeze with fear many times just from the sounds alone.
This is coming from a huge resident evil fan but neither silent hill nor resident evil hold a candle to the absolute terror that was fatal frame! Had to look up a guide when I played cuz shit was scary and hard
I like Silent Hill and Resident Evil more, but… yeah, Fatal Frame 1, especially, was definitely scary af! I played it years after it came out and it got me, and I’m a huge horror fan that’s pretty desensitized to it all.
the enemy encounters aren’t the issues it’s the ambiance of the rooms you enter that is scary, the machine like noises and sounds of things moving around that’s what makes that game terrifying
Amanda 😢 im right there with you when it comes to scary games. Play the happiest music when you play. Makes it easier, the scariest parts about video games... the sound. You kill them zombies! YOU'RE SO BRAVE!
I whole silence hill thing you all did, got me, because remember Ash rain and running around in a circle for hours not sure what to do in the game back in the day
Silent Hill 3 was my first foray into the series. When I walked into the Lakeside Amusement Park and saw Robbie the rabbit all messed up, it really freaked me out. Couldn't stop playing it though 😅
I couldn't even get past the apartments in Silent Hill 2 as a kid. Not because I got stuck but because it was too scary. I later came back with more resolve and finally played the game in earnest.
I'd watch an Amanda/Silent Hill stream of any of the first 4 games for sure. I think many others would too. (Yes, I liked 'The Room.' Yes, I'm aware of its flaws and love it anyway. Yes, I will fight you.)
As a young child, i absolutely DESPISED that man because Titanic was the only movie of his I had seen at the time😂 Great actor. Love the guy. Funny and kind human being as well.
Jason rocking the Jason vorhess mask rocks man and Amanda don’t worry it’s just a game not like creatures that are on there are real right there not right guys don’t do this to me again you said outlast whistle blower wasn’t out there omg I gotta go 😢❤😅 ahhhhhhh spooky season yeah baby
I will never forget when SH1 dropped staying up with my family taking turns and when my brother was playing in the beginning and walking down the alleyway and it gets super dark and that dude was butchered and up on the fence and I was like 'ohh my God", and immediately had all my hair stand up on my arms and got a super uneasy feeling. Personally I love SH2s writing more, but nothing beats the og
I started with silent hill 2 then SH 3 even though i knew SH 1 comes before 3 but it was the best choice for me I loved how confused i was didn't understand the story was till i played SH1 then all the pieces came together
I cannot put into words how stressful that game makes simply opening a freaking DOOR. Never, not even in RE, did I ever think to myself during a video game "Thank God it's locked. I hope I can just leave and never have to go in there"
4 is spookiest. 1 is eeriest. 2 is the deepest. 3 is the hardest. Imo the rest are all good two but the scariest upon first post through is shattered memories on Wii. I damn near threw out my back throwing the monsters off my back. But after the first run, I feel it’s just gimmicky.
Part one is the scary one. The rest are more spooky than scary. The first one was revolutionary and demonic so it always hits the hardest. But this is just my opinion...
Silent Hill 1 i think is scarier than 2 or 3. The room is extremely scary
Silent hill 4 wasn't that scary to me imo it was 3 that scared me for some reason lol
@Beaterspanx95 three definitely is spooky but idk 4 scared me especially the apartment sections haha.
Also just the ps1 graphics give a naturally uneasy feeling
The room is extremely scary!
For me, it was Silent Hill 2.
I grew up watching horror movies with my mom, so things like blood, gore, torture, and dismemberment were nothing new.
But that one scene where you walk into the apartment and find Pyramid Head with the Mannequins...?
That's when you know you've just entered a very special place in Hell.
Silent Hill 1 is an Absolute Must.Classic an one of the best games Ever Made.For it's time,it's a rather long an very fun an scary game...
I don’t feel like the first game gets enough love
It doesn’t. Literally one of the best games ever made.
Silent hill lowkey freaked me out as a kid .
MY FAVORITE SERIES!!
Shattered Memories on Wii is overlooked but it’s an absolute smash
Team Amanda strikes again way to go for keeping up the conversation with the customers 😂
No no no she doesn’t like horror that’s an L
@@Arklay_98 😆
I see streaming potential here, guys! MAKE IT HAPPEN!
Silent hill 3 is a sequel to the first game ???? 🤯🤯 that’s crazy
You didn't know that ??
@@dbzpark1931 I didn't either
Didn't own a console growing up
@@DaDragon555 okay that's understandable
He aint wrong
The Silent Hill franchise is my favorite next to Fatal Frame and older Resident Evil
I heard you, you nasty, wiggly Witchetty Man!
I LOVE SILENT HILL! And I will be listening to the soundtrack on repeat this holiday (Halloween) season.
Silent Hill The Room 4ever
Crimson Butterfly was another one of those fantastic horror games that you either loved or had nightmares about
Yeah that Dub was Nightmareish😊
The broken neck ghost from the first fatal frame freaked me out a LOT.... Riiiight up until i had to fight her in the end cause by that point i was so pissed if she wasnt already a ghost i was gonna make her one.
there's a fine line between being scared, and rage quitting.
2, 1, 3. 1, 2, 3 is fine. But 2 remake is almost out so if you want to have it fresh in mind for the compare, that's not a horrible idea
One bite always leads to a second bite😮
There should have been a 3 second pause after Amanda when out of frame, then a blood curdling scream
Quit telling her that lie. You always start with the original Silent Hill on PS1 1st gen.
That is true but remember next week is the SH2 Remaster release so it’ll at least get her caught up with SH2 story so she can compare if necessary.
I started with the room. I love the series, start wherever you want.
No you literally don’t…
@@falco621sh4 room is still pretty underated
@@ajaakola2 Right!?? I'm so happy to see others who like it. I swear I only ever see/hear contempt and hate for it but I really loved it despite its transparent flaws (and I started w/ the OG 1 & 2).
It had, imo, one of the better stories for SH, did the horror aspect more effectively in many ways, and ugh, that Akira Yamaoka piano music... some of his best stuff, I'd say.
You guys are cool.
for halloween games i actually like to play dead space 1-3 but all the Silent hill games are pretty good too imo
One of the best games of all time
I was more confused than the scared my first playthrough of Silent Hill.
The first game is a timeless classic and the strongest in my opinion.
Oh god. Silent Hill 2 is arguably the scariest of the series
I found 2 the weakest horror wise.
I can't decide between any of the first four, they're all great, all scary for different reasons.
I feel if one of them doesn't scare an individual for whatever reason then another one of the titles definitely will.
SH3 might've been the one that made me freeze with fear many times just from the sounds alone.
I literally played it last year for the first time and fell in love
This is coming from a huge resident evil fan but neither silent hill nor resident evil hold a candle to the absolute terror that was fatal frame! Had to look up a guide when I played cuz shit was scary and hard
I like Silent Hill and Resident Evil more, but… yeah, Fatal Frame 1, especially, was definitely scary af! I played it years after it came out and it got me, and I’m a huge horror fan that’s pretty desensitized to it all.
Love 3, something about that costume change and light saber
Amanda's going for that employee of the month again.
I can’t play scary games, but I find watching them on RUclips I do enjoy.
the enemy encounters aren’t the issues it’s the ambiance of the rooms you enter that is scary, the machine like noises and sounds of things moving around that’s what makes that game terrifying
Amanda 😢 im right there with you when it comes to scary games. Play the happiest music when you play. Makes it easier, the scariest parts about video games... the sound. You kill them zombies! YOU'RE SO BRAVE!
Im Forty years old, i've had seventy jobs, watching you guys work is the longest i've held a job.
I whole silence hill thing you all did, got me, because remember Ash rain and running around in a circle for hours not sure what to do in the game back in the day
Amanda is a legend!! ❤
Amanda it’s always spooky season!
Gotta introduce her to silent hill the room 😂😂😂
love you guys ❤
Silent hill is top tier!!!! Definitely busting out the p2 tonight!!!!!
Love Silent Hill
Silent hill game franchise was interesting. U got this Amanda 👍
Silent Hill 3 was my first foray into the series. When I walked into the Lakeside Amusement Park and saw Robbie the rabbit all messed up, it really freaked me out. Couldn't stop playing it though 😅
I couldn't even get past the apartments in Silent Hill 2 as a kid. Not because I got stuck but because it was too scary. I later came back with more resolve and finally played the game in earnest.
going in SH blind was wild! Atmosphere was awesome
Amanda needs to stream this
Amanda with her One Bite Shirt !!!
You're absolutely adorable Amanda 😊😆 Silent Hill is my favorite Horror series of ALL TIME! Just started the Silent Hill 2 Remake
Alright get those Jimmies unwrestled buddy
Agreed, well done sir. Also silent hill 3 is best silent hill so we saved best for last!
Try the Dead Space remake. It’s scary and pretty at the same time.
True
Silent hill is by far the most beautiful game ever made, imo
HD collection if you're worried about grafx's.
Ok now we need video and audio of Amanda playing silent hill 2 and you guys just kill the lights at the worst moment 😂😂
I'd watch an Amanda/Silent Hill stream of any of the first 4 games for sure. I think many others would too.
(Yes, I liked 'The Room.' Yes, I'm aware of its flaws and love it anyway. Yes, I will fight you.)
My first Silent Hill was the room
As a young child, i absolutely DESPISED that man because Titanic was the only movie of his I had seen at the time😂
Great actor. Love the guy. Funny and kind human being as well.
I helped someone with a walkthrough Silent Hill 1 and 2 and in my opinion those games are only like 5% scary. The other 95% is annoyance.
23 is number one on a whole other level…
“Spooky season 🤗”
Jason rocking the Jason vorhess mask rocks man and Amanda don’t worry it’s just a game not like creatures that are on there are real right there not right guys don’t do this to me again you said outlast whistle blower wasn’t out there omg I gotta go 😢❤😅 ahhhhhhh spooky season yeah baby
Never got into the silent hill series during the ps2 era. I just played the remake of silent hill 2 and I gotta say, I’m blown the fuck away. 10/10
Out of all the horror games to pick
Trick question, play all of them in order cause they great games
You can do it Amanda!!!!
The suffering was a good horror game as well
Need a follow up video with her reaction to the game hahahaha
The best part is that the 2nd one is the scariest of the 3
I always felt the first was the scariest in the series, but I can understand that.
Expensive games I wish using roms/ bios weren’t illegal
Jason is right on this one.
lol I think that’s Bowman left zip line; but I also just started a veteran replay for trophy cleanup/prep for BO7 campaign.
I will never forget when SH1 dropped staying up with my family taking turns and when my brother was playing in the beginning and walking down the alleyway and it gets super dark and that dude was butchered and up on the fence and I was like 'ohh my God", and immediately had all my hair stand up on my arms and got a super uneasy feeling.
Personally I love SH2s writing more, but nothing beats the og
Silent Hill 2 is definitely the scariest game Ive ever played. Even to this day..... ESPECIALLY to this day
I like to start in order
I bought that gane when i was a freshman. It scared the crap out of me. It was uncomfortable being on my toes for that long.
Manhunt 2 is so underrated and never talked about. 😣
You got this #TeamAmanda! Just play in the day time :P that's how I got through them.
It's just a video game but it's still scary!
I agree with Amanda on this one
4 Secret Room is the best one.
1 has a distinct charm that the others dont have though
I started with silent hill 2 then SH 3 even though i knew SH 1 comes before 3 but it was the best choice for me I loved how confused i was didn't understand the story was till i played SH1 then all the pieces came together
Hit up Fatal Frame 1 and 2. Classics.
The only one you should ever play, Silent Hill 2 👍🏻
Omg…I have that one sitting on my shelf barely played 😂
Could you make more of these videos?
SILENT HILL 4 THE ROOM OS THE BEST BY FAR THE ONE WITH THE BEST JUMP SCARES AND STORY
Started the first one last week. Didn't know this though.
And then you got four, which is a stand alone game, but it has connections to part two.
Down pour scared the shit out of me
The Evil Within is one of those its only a game talks.
Got the Jason mask with a nose tampon. 😂
Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem
I did get the Goncon 3 set up for Silent Hill: The Arcade recently
Silent hill 2 remake is incredible btw if anyone that’s a big fan of the original should definitely play the remake I highly recommend it.
I preferred fatal frame personally but good games, I sometimes wish I had kept playing them after the ps2
Good luck lol that game still freaks me out
I want that mask
Origins then 1-3 is how I play the SH series.
I've only ever played SH1. I should get on it.
Congrats on the baby
I cannot put into words how stressful that game makes simply opening a freaking DOOR. Never, not even in RE, did I ever think to myself during a video game "Thank God it's locked. I hope I can just leave and never have to go in there"
4 is spookiest. 1 is eeriest. 2 is the deepest. 3 is the hardest. Imo the rest are all good two but the scariest upon first post through is shattered memories on Wii. I damn near threw out my back throwing the monsters off my back. But after the first run, I feel it’s just gimmicky.
The suffering part one and part two enough said
Everyone knows you have to start with Book of Memories on PS Vita
🤣
Part one is the scary one. The rest are more spooky than scary. The first one was revolutionary and demonic so it always hits the hardest. But this is just my opinion...