Both are correct. Per the DPD (Diccionario panhispánico de dudas) : Los verbos hacer y dejar, cuando tienen sentido causativo, esto es, cuando significan, respectivamente, ‘obligar’ y ‘permitir’, siguen la misma estructura que los verbos de influencia: «verbo causativo + complemento de persona + verbo subordinado». Tanto hacer como dejar tienden a construirse con complemento directo si el verbo subordinado es intransitivo: «Él la hizo bajar a su estudio y le mostró el cuadro» (Aguilera Caricia [Méx. 1983]); «Lo dejé hablar» (Azuela Tamaño [Méx. 1973]); y tienden a construirse con complemento indirecto cuando el segundo verbo es transitivo: «Alguien lo ayudó a incorporarse, lo estimuló y hasta le hizo tomar café» (JmnzEmán Tramas [Ven. 1991]); «El alcaide de la cárcel le dejaba tocar el banjo todas las mañanas» (Cela Cristo [Esp. 1988]). Notice that it only says "tienden" and therefore there is no single approach - you will get variety, although the most common is to use a direct object when the verb is intransitive and the indirect object is transitive. In your example, the verb is transitive (comer la comida) so the most common would be to use le. spanish.stackexchange.com/questions/15283/part-of-speech-with-hacer-a-alguien-hacer-algo
May i know why is 'Es sábado' but not 'Es el sábado' which in 11:55 "El jefe nos hace trabajar los sábados' which in 12:35 Can someone answer me plz?🙏🙏🙏 Muchas gracias~
Think of the EL as ON in English. Nos vemos el lunes. We'll see each other on Monday. When you put a day after SER, it will not use a definite article.
I generally will use what is easier and more comfortable for me when speaking, but the harder form it’s important to know so I can understand what someone says if they phrase it that way.
Paul, THANK YOU. That whole “hacer + infinitive” vs. “hacer que + subjunctive” is the one thing about Spanish that has bugged me for a few years and I haven’t been able to get an explanation until today! A million thanks!
It varies by region. This construction is unusual because it can take an indirect object pronoun or direct object pronoun. I should have gone down a rabbit hole on that one. I may refilm this one. It will also vary by the particular verb chosen. "La hiceron llorar. - They made her cry." But with sentences like this, le/les will be common. Take a look at this post for example. It uses "les hizo aprender": x.com/DiaaDiaCaracol/status/1168535538695114757?mx=2
'crezcan' refers to 'las plantas', not 'la lluvia'. The subjunctive verb after 'hacer que' is conjugated for the new subject that follows 'hacer que', in this case 'las plantas' - the plants Also the verb in question is 'Crecer' so it would not be 'crea' in any circumstance.
Happy New Year Linda & Paul! Lots of health and happy moments. Great lesson…somehow it sounded as your speed was at 1.1 vs. your regular cadence. Or maybe it is my (false) impression?! 🙂
How much would you charge for a lesson plan to help a native Spanish speaker with a very good grasp on English learn to pass a landscaping test and just high frequency etiquette type content? If my dear friend could pass a written English test, it would change his life and for all of his family, children, grandchildren. I wish we could email, you have been a huge positive influence on me. You couldn't possibly know, but please know, you have undervalued skill and potential here. You should be teaching cops Spanish though union.
@QrooSpanish at least think about it, or what that personalized content might look like or cost. Trump is threatening to deport 3/4 of the agriculture industry in the US, on top of all the other migrant workers he never considered. So it's a very important time for these people working as America's backbone with no pay or thanks to get a hand up and utilize every skill and avenue they have. They already work twice as hard for half the pay, a language barrier in these cases is just insult to injury. Especially people like my friend, who has been here for 30 years and still at the bottom of the ladder and why? Written comprehension and red tape bureaucratic bullshit. Grown men do not belong breaking their backs in a foreign country for $150 a day with no benefits, no social security, no anything. I don't know how they're going to replace all these migrant laborers, honestly. It's not like they're "stealing good jobs". They're filling roles that otherwise wouldn't be fillable. Please, think about this issue and reflect on how there is something you could do, if you wanted.
@ For the example “Our friend made us go to the store.” --Nuestro amigo hizo irnos a la tienda --instead of Nuestro amigo nos hizo ir a la tienda. Or does that just sound weird???
¿Puedes usar el verbo obligar en estos casos? Por ejemplo, Mis vecinos obligan a que sus hijos saquen la basura todas las noches. ¡Gracias por tu respuesta! Me encanta tus videos.
Tus videos hacen que yo aprenda español más rápido. -- Oh! Never mind that! Tus videos me hacen aprender más rápido. Edit: Por favor, no me hagas escribir una oración más complicada.
You're not charging enough. Can you teach diplomats so they can be more culturally sensitive? You're that good. You make it so much less intimidating. Starting with cognate tricks made it the most helpful, nice start.
Great video. Could you also say “Te quiero ir a la tienda” or is this type of sentence always use the subjunctive construct? That is, two subjects, a want.desire that you don’t know will really be fulfilled, etc.
Join the Qroo Spanish Crew: www.skool.com/qroo
Check out the reviews: tinyurl.com/3m2xsms9
Hands down, best Spanish teacher on the platform. Thanks man!
Thank you!
I’m finally breaking into the lowest intermediate level because of you and a handful of RUclipsrs. Thank you so much! Que te vaya super bien este año!
First of all, thank you so much for the donation! I'm so glad to hear that I am playing a part in your success. I love helping people.
Both are correct. Per the DPD (Diccionario panhispánico de dudas) :
Los verbos hacer y dejar, cuando tienen sentido causativo, esto es, cuando significan, respectivamente, ‘obligar’ y ‘permitir’, siguen la misma estructura que los verbos de influencia: «verbo causativo + complemento de persona + verbo subordinado». Tanto hacer como dejar tienden a construirse con complemento directo si el verbo subordinado es intransitivo: «Él la hizo bajar a su estudio y le mostró el cuadro» (Aguilera Caricia [Méx. 1983]); «Lo dejé hablar» (Azuela Tamaño [Méx. 1973]); y tienden a construirse con complemento indirecto cuando el segundo verbo es transitivo: «Alguien lo ayudó a incorporarse, lo estimuló y hasta le hizo tomar café» (JmnzEmán Tramas [Ven. 1991]); «El alcaide de la cárcel le dejaba tocar el banjo todas las mañanas» (Cela Cristo [Esp. 1988]).
Notice that it only says "tienden" and therefore there is no single approach - you will get variety, although the most common is to use a direct object when the verb is intransitive and the indirect object is transitive. In your example, the verb is transitive (comer la comida) so the most common would be to use le.
spanish.stackexchange.com/questions/15283/part-of-speech-with-hacer-a-alguien-hacer-algo
This was a banger Q!
Muy ùtil 👌🏼
Love you Paul. You teach me everything Doulingo leaves out. Let me tell you this video was what I was looking for!!! Thank you.
I'm glad you enjoyed it. :)
This was a SUPERB lesson thanks Paul !
Glad you liked it!
Thanks
Awesome
Great breakdowns of the word construction, uses and grammar structures.
May i know why is 'Es sábado' but not 'Es el sábado' which in 11:55
"El jefe nos hace trabajar los sábados' which in 12:35
Can someone answer me plz?🙏🙏🙏
Muchas gracias~
I think it's like when you say in English "today is Sunday" vs "see you ON Sunday". You can't say "today is on Sunday"
Think of the EL as ON in English. Nos vemos el lunes. We'll see each other on Monday. When you put a day after SER, it will not use a definite article.
@@sabalilla08 I see, thank you so much~
@@QrooSpanish I see, thank you so much~
This video is soooo helpful. Very well explained, and excellent examples. I'm going to practice both constructions a lot today. Thanks yet again!
Glad it was helpful!
This was great! Este vídeo será muy útil cuando voy al Mexico. ¡Mil gracias, Paul! Abrazos ❤😊
You're welcome! ¡Que te diviertas en Mexico!
Cuando VAYA a México !
I generally will use what is easier and more comfortable for me when speaking, but the harder form it’s important to know so I can understand what someone says if they phrase it that way.
Muchas Gracias 🤗
Super duper helpful!!
Muchas gracias! Este leccion fue muy bueno! (in my bad Spanish!)
Esta lección fue muy buena
Paul, THANK YOU. That whole “hacer + infinitive” vs. “hacer que + subjunctive” is the one thing about Spanish that has bugged me for a few years and I haven’t been able to get an explanation until today! A million thanks!
So helpful, thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
Although I'm not quite at this level yet listening to your Spanish is a treat. Sounds clear and natural to me.
Thanks
You're welcome!
Gracias Paul !
One of your best@
Me haces aprender todos los dias!
You are the best!
I have gotten so good in Spanish - largely thanks to your videos - but I had absolutely no problem with the 'harder' way.
That's awesome!
Isn’t the correct way to say “The professor makes them learn something new every day.” “El profesor los hace aprender algo nuevo cada día.”
It varies by region. This construction is unusual because it can take an indirect object pronoun or direct object pronoun. I should have gone down a rabbit hole on that one. I may refilm this one. It will also vary by the particular verb chosen. "La hiceron llorar. - They made her cry." But with sentences like this, le/les will be common.
Take a look at this post for example. It uses "les hizo aprender": x.com/DiaaDiaCaracol/status/1168535538695114757?mx=2
@@QrooSpanish I was also confused about the direct vs indirect object issue. A video digging into it would definitely be helpful.
Gracias por la información. Siempre aprendo algo de tus videos.
Por favor, ayúdeme con "crezcan".
Creer in the subjunctive for the rain = crea no?
'crezcan' refers to 'las plantas', not 'la lluvia'. The subjunctive verb after 'hacer que' is conjugated for the new subject that follows 'hacer que', in this case 'las plantas' - the plants
Also the verb in question is 'Crecer' so it would not be 'crea' in any circumstance.
Great video Q
Glad you enjoyed it.
Sus videos previos sobre el subjuntivo hicieron que ya yo supiera como iba a ir este. Qroo crew!
Supiera* (recuerda que se conjuga en el subjuntivo)
@joshua-english Ah yeah! Nice catch. I actually meant to type that but in the moment I didn't haha.
Happy New Year Linda & Paul! Lots of health and happy moments. Great lesson…somehow it sounded as your speed was at 1.1 vs. your regular cadence. Or maybe it is my (false) impression?! 🙂
I am a simple man …. I see Qroo Paul and immediately “like”!🎉
Thanks!
Pasar next, porfa 🩵 Thank you for this great lesson! Happy New Year!
How much would you charge for a lesson plan to help a native Spanish speaker with a very good grasp on English learn to pass a landscaping test and just high frequency etiquette type content? If my dear friend could pass a written English test, it would change his life and for all of his family, children, grandchildren. I wish we could email, you have been a huge positive influence on me. You couldn't possibly know, but please know, you have undervalued skill and potential here. You should be teaching cops Spanish though union.
I'm not very good at teaching English to Spanish-speakers. Sorry.
@QrooSpanish at least think about it, or what that personalized content might look like or cost. Trump is threatening to deport 3/4 of the agriculture industry in the US, on top of all the other migrant workers he never considered. So it's a very important time for these people working as America's backbone with no pay or thanks to get a hand up and utilize every skill and avenue they have. They already work twice as hard for half the pay, a language barrier in these cases is just insult to injury. Especially people like my friend, who has been here for 30 years and still at the bottom of the ladder and why? Written comprehension and red tape bureaucratic bullshit. Grown men do not belong breaking their backs in a foreign country for $150 a day with no benefits, no social security, no anything. I don't know how they're going to replace all these migrant laborers, honestly. It's not like they're "stealing good jobs". They're filling roles that otherwise wouldn't be fillable. Please, think about this issue and reflect on how there is something you could do, if you wanted.
Great video. Can you add the pronoun to the end of the infinitive in the second construction?
Perhaps, give me an example.
@ For the example “Our friend made us go to the store.” --Nuestro amigo hizo irnos a la tienda --instead of Nuestro amigo nos hizo ir a la tienda. Or does that just sound weird???
No, it would sound odd. It needs to go before the conjugated verb with this one.
¿Puedes usar el verbo obligar en estos casos? Por ejemplo, Mis vecinos obligan a que sus hijos saquen la basura todas las noches. ¡Gracias por tu respuesta! Me encanta tus videos.
Sí, ¡ese es un buen ejemplo de usar "obligar"!
Excellent video as usual. I want your coffee brand! Bravo!
Tus videos hacen que yo aprenda español más rápido. -- Oh! Never mind that! Tus videos me hacen aprender más rápido. Edit: Por favor, no me hagas escribir una oración más complicada.
¡Bien hecho!
Maravillosa explicacion, como siempre. Gracias.
He aprendido mucho cada día en tus videos. Te nos hace entender muy bien con tu patiencia. Thanks ever so much Qroo Paul!
You're not charging enough. Can you teach diplomats so they can be more culturally sensitive? You're that good. You make it so much less intimidating. Starting with cognate tricks made it the most helpful, nice start.
Thanks! I appreciate the vote of confidence. :)
hola Paul!¿está casado?
Sí, desde hace 25 años.
@@QrooSpanish mis condolencias capo 😭
@@rban123su esposa es hermosísima
Great video. Could you also say “Te quiero ir a la tienda” or is this type of sentence always use the subjunctive construct? That is, two subjects, a want.desire that you don’t know will really be fulfilled, etc.
Your coffee is *definitely* cold by now!
Haha, I know. That was a long video!