They all sound pretty good to me, although I can hear very subtle differences. Siccas is by far the best classical guitar channel on youtube! Recording quality is close to perfection. Thanks, gentlemen!
Since I own a Stephen Eden “Friederich”, I'll say that was my favourite this week! Carbons sound pretty good on it, but goes full technicolour with nylons.
I really enjoyed the interview with Mr. Marquette, as well as his guitar. I however was enamored with the Stephen Eden guitar!! Lovely!!! The sound of the Mönch guitar is also superb!!
I really enjoyed listening to your incredibly talented performance of such an amazing collection of absolutely phenomenal covers of this magical music. Thank you so much 👍👏🌹🌹🌹💕.
I think he means 'elastic' in the sense of flexible and capable of many nuances and tone colours, rather than 'plastic' with less potential for variation of tone colours. Although I have to admit when he first played it, it did initially sound a little 'elastic-bandy'🤣 ... perhaps just more restrained and nuanced would be a fairer description. Tamara Stahl makes beautifully built guitars, and for my personal taste her Number 10, which is a spruce topped little number, that featured on a previous Siccas video, is preferable with a more forward and powerful sound with that spruce edge to it. I've not had the pleasure of playing one of her guitars in person, but the sustain on both models is tremendous, at least in these 'studio' conditions. And I'm considering commissioning a spruce guitar from her in future.
Yes, the Tamara Stahl guitar (cedar) sounds typical cedar: warm, and yet has many colours. I compared and played ( in her workshop) a cedar one ( beautiful sound, but too warm in comparison with my 2007 Alan Wilcox (cedar/cypress- somewhere comparabIe in sound with the Mönch). I decided for Tamara’s Fichte/Paliss model, which has a wonderfull clear, still warm and in the basses deep sound , direct voice and very “sustained”. I play it with much pleasure and the guitar is a wonderful complement to my “old” Wilcox!
@@peterstuart9273 never thought, that I would encounter somebody with a Wilcox: I had one for some years,when I lived in Tuscany and visited him a lot😊
Tamara Stahl is my favorite guitar, warm beautiful, sweet sound, colorful, great volume and sustain, and that's her eleventh guitar! Amazing!
All sound fabulous, but Marquet for me. Sounds fantastic, sustain, tone, mids, lows, highs all balanced beautifully
They all sound pretty good to me, although I can hear very subtle differences.
Siccas is by far the best classical guitar channel on youtube! Recording quality is close to perfection.
Thanks, gentlemen!
Thank you for your kind words! Much appreciated!
Monch in first place by far, the best this week.
Since I own a Stephen Eden “Friederich”, I'll say that was my favourite this week! Carbons sound pretty good on it, but goes full technicolour with nylons.
Good guitars this week. Thank you
I really enjoyed the interview with Mr. Marquette, as well as his guitar. I however was enamored with the Stephen Eden guitar!! Lovely!!! The sound of the Mönch guitar is also superb!!
I really enjoyed listening to your incredibly talented performance of such an amazing collection of absolutely phenomenal covers of this magical music.
Thank you so much
👍👏🌹🌹🌹💕.
Jean Marquet beats all the others by far😊
Stahl guitar: elastic sounding😅😅...to me not a complinent
Yeah, I have never heard of that word being used with a guitar.
I think he means 'elastic' in the sense of flexible and capable of many nuances and tone colours, rather than 'plastic' with less potential for variation of tone colours. Although I have to admit when he first played it, it did initially sound a little 'elastic-bandy'🤣 ... perhaps just more restrained and nuanced would be a fairer description. Tamara Stahl makes beautifully built guitars, and for my personal taste her Number 10, which is a spruce topped little number, that featured on a previous Siccas video, is preferable with a more forward and powerful sound with that spruce edge to it. I've not had the pleasure of playing one of her guitars in person, but the sustain on both models is tremendous, at least in these 'studio' conditions. And I'm considering commissioning a spruce guitar from her in future.
Elastic meaning : able to encompass much variety and change; flexible and adaptable. You can not get a better compliment than this
Yes, the Tamara Stahl guitar (cedar) sounds typical cedar: warm, and yet has many colours. I compared and played ( in her workshop) a cedar one ( beautiful sound, but too warm in comparison with my 2007 Alan Wilcox (cedar/cypress- somewhere comparabIe in sound with the Mönch). I decided for Tamara’s Fichte/Paliss model, which has a wonderfull clear, still warm and in the basses deep sound , direct voice and very “sustained”. I play it with much pleasure and the guitar is a wonderful complement to my “old” Wilcox!
@@peterstuart9273 never thought, that I would encounter somebody with a Wilcox: I had one for some years,when I lived in Tuscany and visited him a lot😊