A while back the owner of a famous restaurant in coimbatore asked Nirmala Sitharaman why different items on the menu are taxed differently, as it is difficult for them to explain to their customers. Later a video leaked where the owner is made to apologise to her privately in front of a few people!
Yeah he asked why if we add cream to a bun , it has more tax 😂😂 and he mentioned in a funny way their customers are saying them to give bun and cream separately so that they can keep it in between them...
My mother is an government employee met an accident and lost her right leg. We had to pay 18% GST on her artificial leg and Walker. This government is taxing on physically handicapped people and their medical needs too. Which is very inhuman.
So what?? Mostly only the gov employes burden the tax collections, what are of they of any use if it cannot help you in times of need@@SunnyKumar-nn5wm
@@nitish31ful cause ppl are so brainwashed by that they cant seem to understand the gravity of their situation , we have a word for ppl like that its called R--Tar--Ded . Do u know the funny thing , pretty sure they are still gonna vote them after this .
Just imagine there was a legit conversation between the top finance minds of india discussing different flavours of popcorn 😭😭😭.... I think the meeting was on PVR while watching pushpa
theathers will face business failure coz they mostly get margins from snacks buyed. increase in price results less people will buy it, decreasing sales.
Any Govt has two jobs, to provide security and to levu taxes, without these two, govt has no meaning, look at your favourite country Pakistan, look at their economists asking for GST like tax
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 Always crying on Pakistan. Grow up dude. If you think your taxes are benefitting the nation then contribute your whole family wealth to the nation's economy instead of ranting about issues in other countries. I think you don't even pay the income tax to begin with. Must be enjoying ancestral wealth.
And who's fault is that? The opposition was in Power for 60+ yrs, they finished off the economy, made national security a joke, made terrprits as heros and top it all off, called hindus Hinsak
@hg8656 that's coz he is a pappu, he also said digital India and UPI won't work, his video proved vegetable vendors too have UPI, whatever pappu says is wrong, will be correct, pappu is a liar and a 🤡
Yeah lmao, they dont even let us bring our stuff in theater and now we cant buy the food there because of the price, watch movie while being hungry uwu.
Funny to expect that government will remove GST on medical insurance. Hospitals and education are the two major cash cows in the country where citizens will never think to spend twice their capacity. They'll come back with a stronger explanation to justify it and explain how other countries do the same 😂😂
Well, they will explain how other countries are doing but the same government don’t function how the other countries government are functioning. That’s the sad reality
Not because bjp is savior but because bjp is the only option left to protect India from this unstable world . If you have a better option, then their is no gst on giving advice on social media
That's not what actual problem is . The actual problem why all this is happening because of no good opposition . People don't have choice to go for someone else , like other parties are even worse , and that's the reason why BJP is doing anything whatever they want very easily .
One of the worst govt. & finance minister of the Indian history😏😤😡😔 Yah government Britishers se bhi aage chale Gaye. After some days they tax on breathing , walking in public place.
@trilokyamohanchakra6351 ok so why unemployment crisis , inflation crisis in India ??? Why communal tension in India ??? Why digging in others religion places??? We are not moving forward we are going to back in time.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351how can u be so blind? How much brainwashing is done on u bro....best gov u say... Look the fck around u, can't u see unemployment, inflation, indian rupee falling, taxes increase, hospitals becoming expensive, religious hatred....its happening literally around u. Use ur brains bro
@@pm09876did other government even tried to solve the problem? And listen do we have problem, yes . Is it easy to solve ? No , it will take time no government in the world can solve there problem in few year
Food should not have too much GST. Only 2-5%. We have enough adulterated food. Govt also allows adulteration of cottonseed oil with sesame oil. Govt should not give permission for such things.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 are you Indian citizen? Do you ever eat in any restaurant in India? Have seen the total tax amount that comes apart from the invoice? How educated are you? To answer your question, Indian govt is for the people, by the people and of the people. As a citizen, everyone can suggest. Also we can ask to ban the adulteration permission because it is our health. You seem a lot provoked by my comment. Are you not a taxpayer?
Yeah read the report on state debt and you'll know why this is done. It's not a whim and fancy, there is financial strife thanks to ladli behanas and greeb mazdoor yojanas
Because it needs approval of almost every state in India as it affects a large sum of their revenue , that's why state governments will not let this happen
Because it needs approval of almost every state in India as it affects a large sum of their revenue , that's why state governments will not let this happen
No , you are wrong because adding petrol and diesel in gst does not affect any industrialist. It only affects both state and central government's tax revenue .
Annapoorna hotel owner based from Coimbatore asked the same question. Later he was forced to apologise privately infront of few people with video on. Later the apologizing video was shared to public.
First, make a silly (mistake) move. Second, make people angry on that topic. Thirdly, make people forget about most essential thing (eliminating tax on health care). I love their politics 💔
@@Ms.LoveLoverSaleena Now they are trying to impose gurukul like education in Odisha, you bectyhes will oppose, oppose hard, then every gurukul, madrassa, convent will have a secular education and muslims will cryyyyy again and again🤣🤣🤣🤣, opposition doesn't understand Politics like Hindu BJP does
I actually have soft corner towards her. Because when Indian govt does something good like starting Vande Bharat train, making Highways, High GDP growth media gives credit to Modi not respective ministers. But when Govt increase tax Nimmo Tai is blamed infact she can't even win a Loksabha sit on her own. So it's clear she does what her leader asks her to do.
Nimmo Tai is the finance minister of my country. And she represents her ministry. So she was to blame. And if she is that much bechari... Resign as simple as it sounds .. if you can't do a job which you are given so apologise.
Is the tax on corn and sugar related to ethanol production for E20 fuel? As E20 requires High Fructose Corn syrup and Sugar cane for producing Ethanol.
I think Public Toilet should also Be Taxed.....as Only Rich People Can spend Rs 10 for Pooping, Poor People Use it Free Outdoor Anyways.... Finance Minister Should think about it.....!!
Great analysis, thank you! I need some advice: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
We can discusses the stratification inside the Tax system, but it's to no real purpose unless we have a clear idea of what the proper work of the government ought to be and what should be left to the people. . . after all the need for a government arose primarily out of a need for the same standard of physical security (i.e. the police and the defence) and basis of criminal right/wrong (i.e. the courts). .
The government should work toward a complete cashless economy so that more people can be brought under the tax slab instead of just trying to milk more and more from people who are already paying taxes.
Popcorn especially packed one are not eat regularly they are used only in cinema halls so if you are already spending 1000 ₹ on movie tickets which include 15% gst then you must not think about spending exta 12 ₹ on 100₹ popcorn In short cinema is category comes under luxury so gst has to be paid
*GST on popcorn* Did you have POPCORN during the ride? No? Let's have it now! Q 1.Why is there a different GST rate on popcorn? A:- •Ready-to-eat popcorn mixed with salt and spices (not pre-packaged and labeled) attracts 5% GST. •Ready-to-eat popcorn mixed with salt and spices (pre-packaged and labeled) attracts 12% GST. •However, when popcorn is mixed with sugar, thereby changing its essential character to a sugar confectionery (e.g., caramel popcorn), it attracts 18% GST. Q 2.Is GST on popcorn a new introduction? A: NO, there is no new imposition of tax in this regard. It is merely a clarification to address the confusion caused by certain field units demanding different tax rates for similar products. The GST Council recommended this clarification to resolve disputes arising from varying interpretations. I hope it was a good ride in my CAR with POPCORN & all your doubts are solved. Nirmala Ji's small "Slip of Tongue" was grabbed by Press & Piddis to spread misinformation to att@ck #Modi Sarkar & FM, without even reading Govt's Press Release. The job of "Indian" media is spread agenda, The job of Piddis is to spread FAKE Information & Create Narratives. They did their Job. Your job is to not give knee-jerk reactions, but to wait for CORRECT information to come out. You have it now. Spread it & throw in ugly faces of Piddis. If you want to oppose this info, oppose with facts. Most welcome. Just don't give intellect argument as "I'm a CA, I know better".😂😂
Congrats for being a CA buddy. Now look. You explained the whole sh*t which everyone knows apparently. What we want is often misunderstood by people like you and that is we understand what is going on but that's not what we want there are bigger fish to fry . We have bigger problems to deal with. This is something we don't expect from the very important people of our finance sector. We middle class people suffer from these things . She has been milking us ever since she is there as a FM. Please don't give me the bullsh*t ... To congress ki sarkar ne kya kiya hai... I hope you are CA enough to behave like a grown person and don't dig the grave. We have a future to deal with
The interest on the India debt is 24% of the total expenditure. What ever was the reason for taking debt, we now have to repay. So we have to pay more or bring more people under compliance. So it's broader discussion rather than just popcorn. So please provide inputs based on broader picture.
They don't want to discuss atul's case, they don't want to discuss the water crisis, they don't want to discuss poverty What they want to discuss is how to get profit from popcorn.
Thanks for mentioning more concerning matter " Tax on Medical insurance"! Public asli cheez ki baat na karke popcorn me hi faanshi huye hein! Opposition ko apne faaltu politics chodke asli mudde me govt. Ko pressure dena chahiye! Aur jab GST council ke meeting hota hei tab kyu opposition led state ke Finance Minister ish mudde ko uthte nehi hein? 😑
Popcorn is already expensive.PVR chargers 370 for a "small tub" which barely has something. Now this tax thing will skyrocket prices.Small tub has like literally nothing,So i visit cinemarc and cinepolis. Some PVR theatres are not even well maintained.
With the variety of mixed popcorn options offered in malls and movie theaters, I wonder how they manage to calculate the portions accurately. Are they really counting each piece?!
The reason she might give for taxing popcorn with high rates is that, "i don't like popcorn, especially ceramalized while I'm on diet, even people shoud not have it💀". Just like she said that i don't eat onion and garlic when asked about rising price on these😁.
Idc what anyone says but this is great. It's not about taxation, it's about countering the frequent problem of high sugar content in food stuffs, a lot of which often aren't even Indian brands so we're not even gonna suffer if those products go down in the market (don't fight me in the replies y'all)
you get sugar, caramelize it, you get popcorn, then you sell the popcorn and separately sell the caramelized sugar sachet. lights a burden on customers to mix it. it is even simple than it sounds, cause it saves money
Because of 18%tax on caramel popcorn people will not prefer to buy it . However it contains sugar in it and has harmful effects on health if consumed in excess amount . Thus ,if they don't eat popcorn its indirect benefit to their health 😅
Ye sab idea kaun deta hain bhai!!! Popcorn has different tax slabs now.. after some days god knows what tax slabs comes … farting might have different tax slabs too 😅😅😅
Salaried person should not pay additional tax on products cause that person has already payed income tax to government ranging upto 30%....why the hell pay additional tax on products???? This is injustice against middle class salaried people who have to pay double tax
A while back the owner of a famous restaurant in coimbatore asked Nirmala Sitharaman why different items on the menu are taxed differently, as it is difficult for them to explain to their customers. Later a video leaked where the owner is made to apologise to her privately in front of a few people!
WTF
this should go viral
What can you expect when the same government is in power for more than ha decade
True
Yeah he asked why if we add cream to a bun , it has more tax 😂😂 and he mentioned in a funny way their customers are saying them to give bun and cream separately so that they can keep it in between them...
My mother is an government employee met an accident and lost her right leg. We had to pay 18% GST on her artificial leg and Walker. This government is taxing on physically handicapped people and their medical needs too. Which is very inhuman.
These items need to be exempted for tax
Then Why vote for same govt again now wait another 5 yr
Ur mother has a gov job
So what?? Mostly only the gov employes burden the tax collections, what are of they of any use if it cannot help you in times of need@@SunnyKumar-nn5wm
@@nitish31ful cause ppl are so brainwashed by that they cant seem to understand the gravity of their situation , we have a word for ppl like that its called R--Tar--Ded . Do u know the funny thing , pretty sure they are still gonna vote them after this .
That lady goin crazy now
Prev FM was far far better … this is what happens when you give the role to the one who has no idea about economy
As if she is the one making all these decisions 😂
@@abhinav9760 ownership!
@@abhinav9760 So who is making decisions
@@crazyylife she's just a government puppet, you need to know a lot about politics
Just imagine there was a legit conversation between the top finance minds of india discussing different flavours of popcorn 😭😭😭.... I think the meeting was on PVR while watching pushpa
More like top idiots
"Tax se koi bachega nhi saala"
Underrated comment 😂
😂
They won't discuss things like this popcorn, they classify based on packaging and ingredients.
Another thing to prove "Tax like west service like Somalia"
No country in the west taxes like this.
GST equivalents in western countries are usually only 2-5% on food.
@@alphabetagamma4142Germany 🤔
Number of tax prayer is very less than western country @@alphabetagamma4142
Neither the Taxes are like Western Countries nor the Services are like Somalia. We just lie in middle
@@Champion.Gaming all thanks to 25cr muslim population that doesn't want to move forward but want to go back to 632AD
Next taxes on air, sunlight, rain
Oh its coming
There is already tax on air and water purifier, we can't even get clean air without paying taxes
Tu 5 min dhoop me jayada kaise baitha tax nikal 👺👺😂
@@Vxsu9090 Tax on sun cream:
tax air for making it worst of all the places on this planet
Now theatres have excuse to sell popcorn at Rs.30,000
Hey! Don't like em, don't buy em
@trilokyamohanchakra6351 I don't, I always smuggle my own popcorn.
@@wlockuz4467 If u are caught u can be blacklisted from the place or fined , this happened to some guys .
theathers will face business failure coz they mostly get margins from snacks buyed. increase in price results less people will buy it, decreasing sales.
@@wlockuz4467 and our brothers muslim sneak b0mbs before 2014
At this point they will increase GST on anything and make excuses
Any Govt has two jobs, to provide security and to levu taxes, without these two, govt has no meaning, look at your favourite country Pakistan, look at their economists asking for GST like tax
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351
Always crying on Pakistan. Grow up dude. If you think your taxes are benefitting the nation then contribute your whole family wealth to the nation's economy instead of ranting about issues in other countries. I think you don't even pay the income tax to begin with. Must be enjoying ancestral wealth.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351Provide security to whom exactly? To the politicians? Or to the family of politicians and rich kids?
@@notrealitachi first go to school then come back I'll answer. What do you mean whom you pidiot, to citizens
@@notrealitachi go to school first
Govt hates salaried employees. She should tax more and more so Indians will start exploring western countries.
What to do, they can't win elections without being a burden on salaried employees
@ it feels like we are being raped bro 😢
And so racism will increase because indians are migrating too much
Aur fir racism aur bhi zyada hoga kyuki indians are migrating too much
By that logic this block headed FM will start imposing 18% GST on diabetes patients too.
Nobody likes taxes so deal with it
😂😂😂 dudeeeeee..... Where were you..!!???
Funniest thing I read today!
In near future they gonna tax air too
@@zaty0 they already do by taxing insurance.. which people will need after few years 😂😂
Well they are already taxing air purifier so .....
Bhai uske liye hawa v honi chahiye.. poore desh me co2 hi he😂
@@lost_meninsurance is still a luxury in India
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351maybe for you but it is a necessity for everyone.
Popcorn should be the last thing we should worry about.
Yeah but It just shows how petty the people "incharged" are.
So don't you think we have already reached the last?
With no opposition government has gone crazy
And who's fault is that? The opposition was in Power for 60+ yrs, they finished off the economy, made national security a joke, made terrprits as heros and top it all off, called hindus Hinsak
Opposition is itself Crazy
They are all impotent too
Rahul gandhi opposed GST multiple times... But smart people of our country made him 'Pappu'
@hg8656 that's coz he is a pappu, he also said digital India and UPI won't work, his video proved vegetable vendors too have UPI, whatever pappu says is wrong, will be correct, pappu is a liar and a 🤡
Damn, snacks getting sold in theaters were already price af, and this adds a whole new reason to not get em.. or maybe I'm just broke 😂
I can watch a new movie with the same price of popcorn I buy
Yeah lmao, they dont even let us bring our stuff in theater and now we cant buy the food there because of the price, watch movie while being hungry uwu.
Funny to expect that government will remove GST on medical insurance.
Hospitals and education are the two major cash cows in the country where citizens will never think to spend twice their capacity.
They'll come back with a stronger explanation to justify it and explain how other countries do the same 😂😂
Well, they will explain how other countries are doing but the same government don’t function how the other countries government are functioning. That’s the sad reality
Bhakts: still i will vote for them because they are saviours of hindus
Not because bjp is savior but because bjp is the only option left to protect India from this unstable world .
If you have a better option, then their is no gst on giving advice on social media
Okay andh bhakth. The only problem is these gobars are pulling india back to the stone age! 😂 @@Watt22314
That's not what actual problem is . The actual problem why all this is happening because of no good opposition . People don't have choice to go for someone else , like other parties are even worse , and that's the reason why BJP is doing anything whatever they want very easily .
You'd rather have rahul gandhi as a pm??
@@Popo-l5rIn Karnataka farmers chose Cong over BJP in 2023 for freebies etc, now the same farmer's land is in Waqf board, karlo jo karna hai 😂😂
0.013% of lacks of crore is actually a significantly large amount then it seems.
I can't believe people eat so much caramel popcorn.
It’s clearly says that they will get 300 cr annually after the popcorn tax not “lacks of crores “
300 cr if every popcorn is caramel. Ofc in reality it would be way lower. i.e 30 cr overall india in a year
Dudes think out of the box it just not confined only to popcorn what about other condiments??? What about other snack options??
This is the curse we invited for ourselves. Lets brace up for the next 4 years. All the Best my dear Indians.
Awwww Congi chamcha spotted
Imagine farmers in Karnataka, elected Cong in 2023, hoping for freebies MSP etc, instead got their land Waqf 😂😂😂
Then Whom To Vote ?
Exactly @@prk1834
@@prk1834 can't vote anyone 😂 . No one's good domocracy and election is myth
Nirmala is india's Kamala Harris😂😂
Nope, Kamala is a whole another league of stuupid, Priyanka Gandhi suits for Kamala and Joe for Rahul Gandhi
GST in india is complicated AF being a CA Student learning GST is harder than ever
May be CA isn't for you
One of the worst govt. & finance minister of the Indian history😏😤😡😔
Yah government Britishers se bhi aage chale Gaye. After some days they tax on breathing , walking in public place.
Sorry but this is THE best govt, in the last 5yrs, we have had more FDI than we had from '47 to 2019.
@trilokyamohanchakra6351 ok so why unemployment crisis , inflation crisis in India ??? Why communal tension in India ??? Why digging in others religion places??? We are not moving forward we are going to back in time.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351how can u be so blind? How much brainwashing is done on u bro....best gov u say... Look the fck around u, can't u see unemployment, inflation, indian rupee falling, taxes increase, hospitals becoming expensive, religious hatred....its happening literally around u. Use ur brains bro
@@pm09876everything was fine except digging part you wouldn’t let your land be snatched just because it will hurt somebody.
@@pm09876did other government even tried to solve the problem? And listen do we have problem, yes . Is it easy to solve ? No , it will take time no government in the world can solve there problem in few year
Food should not have too much GST. Only 2-5%. We have enough adulterated food. Govt also allows adulteration of cottonseed oil with sesame oil. Govt should not give permission for such things.
So now you'll tell how much tax should govt levy? Wow the entitlement of Cong chomchas in amazong
@trilokyamohanchakra6351 food is an essential. Some restaurants do charge more.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 are you Indian citizen? Do you ever eat in any restaurant in India? Have seen the total tax amount that comes apart from the invoice? How educated are you?
To answer your question, Indian govt is for the people, by the people and of the people. As a citizen, everyone can suggest. Also we can ask to ban the adulteration permission because it is our health. You seem a lot provoked by my comment. Are you not a taxpayer?
@@Jigglypuffcartoonhe is offended because you criticised his favourite party 😂.
Important question - Is it only her deciding the tax structures? I'm sure there is a team and other political members responsible for the policies.
Every state finance minister including opposition led state 😂! This is real fun 😂
Yeah read the report on state debt and you'll know why this is done. It's not a whim and fancy, there is financial strife thanks to ladli behanas and greeb mazdoor yojanas
Yeeaa beek gai hai government 😂
Kabhi nhi bikegi, jab tak RSS hain tab tak nhi
Why can't they had petrol and diesel on GST 😅😅😂😂
Because it needs approval of almost every state in India as it affects a large sum of their revenue , that's why state governments will not let this happen
Because it needs approval of almost every state in India as it affects a large sum of their revenue , that's why state governments will not let this happen
@@Watt22314 more, more than state approval, need approval of Adani and Ambani, 😊
No , you are wrong because adding petrol and diesel in gst does not affect any industrialist. It only affects both state and central government's tax revenue .
@@Watt22314Ambani will lose his money and If ambani loses he will pull down the other thief adani too.
Yoooo , we got Finance minister discussing about Popcorn Flavours before she starts taxing people for breathing
Caramel Popcorn companies will start selling Caramel masala packs separately😅
WOW what an amazing comment done by Rashid raza from bihar
Literally Pirates of taxation 😂😂
Annapoorna hotel owner based from Coimbatore asked the same question. Later he was forced to apologise privately infront of few people with video on. Later the apologizing video was shared to public.
Wo log tax slab me aate hi nhi h
Jo bhakt bjp ko support krte h
Aur unhe ye tax zyada nhi lgta 😂😂😂😂
First, make a silly (mistake) move. Second, make people angry on that topic. Thirdly, make people forget about most essential thing (eliminating tax on health care).
I love their politics 💔
There's a reason he's called the Chanakya of politics
That's the crazy pov🙏🙏🙏
@@Ms.LoveLoverSaleena Now they are trying to impose gurukul like education in Odisha, you bectyhes will oppose, oppose hard, then every gurukul, madrassa, convent will have a secular education and muslims will cryyyyy again and again🤣🤣🤣🤣, opposition doesn't understand Politics like Hindu BJP does
I actually have soft corner towards her.
Because when Indian govt does something good like starting Vande Bharat train, making Highways, High GDP growth media gives credit to Modi not respective ministers.
But when Govt increase tax Nimmo Tai is blamed infact she can't even win a Loksabha sit on her own. So it's clear she does what her leader asks her to do.
Nimmo Tai is the finance minister of my country. And she represents her ministry. So she was to blame.
And if she is that much bechari... Resign as simple as it sounds .. if you can't do a job which you are given so apologise.
The government you choose..
Is the Government you Deserve..
Xongress would have made everything free. 😢
Is the tax on corn and sugar related to ethanol production for E20 fuel? As E20 requires High Fructose Corn syrup and Sugar cane for producing Ethanol.
Tax on popcorn is lesser after GST than before
Great you raised this, keep it up guys
And these guys used to troll the previous governmental tax 😂
She is like a Kalki from UI movie,taking revenge against people😂
After some days … potato onions have tax slabs 😅😅😅😅 wah re FM!
Just wait, free air will be paid soon, and she will apply 25% tax on it...
😡😡😂😂
That day isn't far, when she'll start charging taxes on oxygen.
I think Public Toilet should also Be Taxed.....as Only Rich People Can spend Rs 10 for Pooping, Poor People Use it Free Outdoor Anyways....
Finance Minister Should think about it.....!!
Added sugar in tea/coffee will be in different tax slabs??
FM is thinking gst is his husband's money😅😅😅
This is a bonus for the people who voted for bjp👍enjoy every moment
Bruh we got customized gst before gta 6
The government has much more important things to do like finding hypothetical temples under any and every piece of land.
Good trick whole india is just discussing Popcorn and forgot health care insurance
So we buy ingredients with added gst and mixed all of them and prepared popcorn extra added gst wah!...😂😂😂 Kya scene hai
Cinema hall main kucch andhar lake nehin jane deta.....usmain kisiko problem nehin...yeh hain log😂😂
what do we think, we are telling for 10 years, but this psychopath will do what it wants
Total Cinema😎.... btw where's my popcorn?.... not the real one... the emogi one... use it while u can😜
Popcorn minister 😂😂
Me paying EMI for the popcorn I ate 2 years ago
We Got Nirmala Tai taxing people for caramel popcorn before she taxes people for begging
At first when I heard this I thought it was some kind of meme or joke by someone, then I realised it's real 💀.
Great analysis, thank you! I need some advice: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
it's a win-win, more tax for big companies, less for small vendors
India has his priority on regarded things like Religion when we should go for healthcare and education
Reminds me of a time when monarchs used taxes as a way to mop savings. Like taxes on men keeping beards, tax on windows in houses, etc.
Health and education must be first priority of every government. Education up to college degree must be nationalized.
We can discusses the stratification inside the Tax system, but it's to no real purpose unless we have a clear idea of what the proper work of the government ought to be and what should be left to the people. . . after all the need for a government arose primarily out of a need for the same standard of physical security (i.e. the police and the defence) and basis of criminal right/wrong (i.e. the courts). .
The government should work toward a complete cashless economy so that more people can be brought under the tax slab instead of just trying to milk more and more from people who are already paying taxes.
Everyone Blaming Nirmala......
Meanwhile Modi Who's the real Mastermind behind 🥸
Popcorn especially packed one are not eat regularly they are used only in cinema halls so if you are already spending 1000 ₹ on movie tickets which include 15% gst then you must not think about spending exta 12 ₹ on 100₹ popcorn
In short cinema is category comes under luxury so gst has to be paid
Higher taxation on HFSS has been a demand. This must be a start towards it.
*GST on popcorn*
Did you have POPCORN during the ride? No? Let's have it now!
Q 1.Why is there a different GST rate on popcorn?
A:-
•Ready-to-eat popcorn mixed with salt and spices (not pre-packaged and labeled) attracts 5% GST.
•Ready-to-eat popcorn mixed with salt and spices (pre-packaged and labeled) attracts 12% GST.
•However, when popcorn is mixed with sugar, thereby changing its essential character to a sugar confectionery (e.g., caramel popcorn), it attracts 18% GST.
Q 2.Is GST on popcorn a new introduction?
A: NO, there is no new imposition of tax in this regard. It is merely a clarification to address the confusion caused by certain field units demanding different tax rates for similar products. The GST Council recommended this clarification to resolve disputes arising from varying interpretations.
I hope it was a good ride in my CAR with POPCORN & all your doubts are solved.
Nirmala Ji's small "Slip of Tongue" was grabbed by Press & Piddis to spread misinformation to att@ck #Modi Sarkar & FM, without even reading Govt's Press Release.
The job of "Indian" media is spread agenda, The job of Piddis is to spread FAKE Information & Create Narratives. They did their Job. Your job is to not give knee-jerk reactions, but to wait for CORRECT information to come out. You have it now. Spread it & throw in ugly faces of Piddis.
If you want to oppose this info, oppose with facts. Most welcome. Just don't give intellect argument as "I'm a CA, I know better".😂😂
Congrats for being a CA buddy.
Now look.
You explained the whole sh*t which everyone knows apparently.
What we want is often misunderstood by people like you and that is we understand what is going on but that's not what we want there are bigger fish to fry . We have bigger problems to deal with. This is something we don't expect from the very important people of our finance sector.
We middle class people suffer from these things . She has been milking us ever since she is there as a FM.
Please don't give me the bullsh*t ... To congress ki sarkar ne kya kiya hai...
I hope you are CA enough to behave like a grown person and don't dig the grave. We have a future to deal with
This govt is goin nuts day by day
The interest on the India debt is 24% of the total expenditure. What ever was the reason for taking debt, we now have to repay. So we have to pay more or bring more people under compliance. So it's broader discussion rather than just popcorn. So please provide inputs based on broader picture.
GST like Developed countries
Services like 3rd world countries
Mr Bean, showed the value of popcorn along time back
Govt should definitely focus on taxing popcorn
They don't want to discuss atul's case, they don't want to discuss the water crisis, they don't want to discuss poverty
What they want to discuss is how to get profit from popcorn.
Sitaraman ❎
Queen Victoria ✅
Thanks for mentioning more concerning matter " Tax on Medical insurance"!
Public asli cheez ki baat na karke popcorn me hi faanshi huye hein! Opposition ko apne faaltu politics chodke asli mudde me govt. Ko pressure dena chahiye! Aur jab GST council ke meeting hota hei tab kyu opposition led state ke Finance Minister ish mudde ko uthte nehi hein? 😑
Tax is so surreal just like her mind !
Popcorn is already expensive.PVR chargers 370 for a "small tub" which barely has something. Now this tax thing will skyrocket prices.Small tub has like literally nothing,So i visit cinemarc and cinepolis. Some PVR theatres are not even well maintained.
What are they doing about cigars and liquor? Is it healthier than popcorn?
With the variety of mixed popcorn options offered in malls and movie theaters, I wonder how they manage to calculate the portions accurately. Are they really counting each piece?!
The reason she might give for taxing popcorn with high rates is that, "i don't like popcorn, especially ceramalized while I'm on diet, even people shoud not have it💀".
Just like she said that i don't eat onion and garlic when asked about rising price on these😁.
Idc what anyone says but this is great. It's not about taxation, it's about countering the frequent problem of high sugar content in food stuffs, a lot of which often aren't even Indian brands so we're not even gonna suffer if those products go down in the market (don't fight me in the replies y'all)
you get sugar, caramelize it, you get popcorn, then you sell the popcorn and separately sell the caramelized sugar sachet. lights a burden on customers to mix it.
it is even simple than it sounds, cause it saves money
This wasy reaction too. At least now, some Indians will reduce sugar intake.
@@TheOpposition You could also sell dried corn and chopped sugarcane. That will have Zero GST.
Pirates of taxation 😂😂😂
Because of 18%tax on caramel popcorn people will not prefer to buy it .
However it contains sugar in it and has harmful effects on health if consumed in excess amount .
Thus ,if they don't eat popcorn its indirect benefit to their health 😅
Why doesn't the govt reduce tax on zero sugar drinks 😅
Jarur nirmala tai pushpa movie dekhke aayi hai , tabhi unko popcorn 🍿🍿 me tax ka idea aaya 😂😂
Ye sab idea kaun deta hain bhai!!! Popcorn has different tax slabs now.. after some days god knows what tax slabs comes … farting might have different tax slabs too 😅😅😅
Health care is necessity❤
Salaried person should not pay additional tax on products cause that person has already payed income tax to government ranging upto 30%....why the hell pay additional tax on products???? This is injustice against middle class salaried people who have to pay double tax
No one wants to pay tax
I swear, this was so unbelievable i thought this is an AI vedio 😂
Nirmala sitaram✖️
Nimala taxaram✔️
I’ll just happily munch on the plain popcorn-fewer added sugars & fats, and much easier on the wallet! 🍿🧂 😂😂😂
No one else motivated me to leave this country 💀
Don't remember ever a more polarizing minister than niramala Sitharaman. The lady was not even elected by us for God sakes!!!😂
The problem is, ppl want freebies these days.. but they fail to understand where that money comes from..
And here you go...
Mai 🍿 nhi khati😂
What is the difference between this and untouchability system we had in past . It's crazy even British tax us better
Imagine popcorn having tax😮
A real joke with the people
We called her Tax Kasubi.
I think this government has crossed all limits on taxes. Middle and lower classes are tortured because of this tax system.
Logic: lets introduce more tax so that Middle class will have something else to worry about 😊
Mujhe kya, mujhe toh 2100 rupees aur free rashan aur free bijli chahiye❤