@@sunilvalmiki4554correct and IPS will grow stronger because they deal with National Security and a rising India will face bigger and deadly National Security threats specially internal threats
Anpadh log sirf IAS ko sirr pe bitha ke rakhe hai nahi to unka koi real talent nahi hota. Na bridge Bana sakte, na laptop repair kar sakte, na software coding kar sakte h, naa koi surgery kar sakte hai, na koi creative work kar sakte hai. Lekin talent alag field pe hai- Ghus lena 100% karte hai, corruption karna 100% talent hai, illegal property dealing 100% karte hai
Its high time to have specialist bureacrats cadre in government in both state and centre. Instead of those ias or ips who just pass a rat race exam decades before..and nothing more than that.
@@piyushsrivastav7215 No bro I'm an aspirants but I'm an indian though. Nation first 🥇 Top position should be given to their respective field not to an IAS who has not a specific field. Like Top Position in Agriculture shouldn't be given to an IAS who has zero knowledge in Ag... He/she couldn't justify the position he/she hold and can't make good policy on this. We can't be so selfish 😔 bro
@@swapnendukumar3230 Exactly this was a big issue during Previous Government regime. A person having no knowledge of Finance, cannot be appointed as Joint secretary in Finance Ministry, it will be a disaster. But these things were done openly, jis IAS ne Netaji ko madad kiya usko kahi par bhi Joint Secretary banwa diya jata tha
But is decision me kuch bura nahi hai, infact govt. Will get more experienced officials from their respective department to develop that department bcoz of his/her skill and experience
Reality is Group B officers who are back bone of any department, like ASO, Section officers, inspectors, Superintendents , etc are running this country. But no one admits their role. So sad ❤😢
इस हिसाब s toh group C post p log ज्यादा contribute कर रहे,you get what you deserve ,किसी ने upsc Crack किया है तो ही deserve the respect ,SSC is very ordinary exam ,fight between 2nd class students who couldn't get what they wanted in life,all good and bright minds are either doctor,engineer,scientist, ias,ips etc.
It's Indian Civil Services. So under this every cadre should be equally glorified. It's all about choice. ICS officers should be given the choice to choose any sector and to change at any time.
Very immature decision At that higher positions the person is going to make policies that are not going to affect only the selected persons , this will affect the all the classes of societies And IAS is the only service in which officer are interact and very much familiar with the broad section of society, resources and also politics So they can make better decisions by concluding all the aspects rather than a single mindset........
An Officer should think in all directions before creation and implementation of a policy. Officer should have broad mind and knowledge from different fields. Specialist Officers should be in position of Advisory only. I think IAS is the best service for leading a department.
Education is a double edged sword, it enlightens people with both good and bad. The evil achievements are also unlocked, we have witnessed wonderful leaders with very less conventional knowledge and extremely knowledgeable IAS with tons of corruption allegations in baggage. Both side of the coin exists. Either way, till there is inequality and disproportion between skill and pay scale corruption is inevitable.
@@sidbhaiyaMost of them are kiths and kins of corporates and Politicians, apna kaam karake they will retire. IAS is afraid of signing those files because of the noose on his neck in the form of CVC or CBI, Lateral entry chamchas are well connected and protected
@@exoticindiaaIAS are the most incompetent born species... Most of them belong from wealthy background and there is no accountability as it's a permanent job
@@sidbhaiya "Railway officers have valuable experience in managing large-scale operations, dealing with infrastructure, logistics, and public services. Their skills in planning, coordination, and administration are useful in central ministries, especially for projects related to transport, infrastructure, and public services. Their technical knowledge and leadership can help improve policy-making and execution in various areas beyond just railways." This highlights their transferable skills and contributions.
@@sidbhaiyasir nowadays the present govt is blinding even the educated youth to know the difference between IAS and other cadres. After few years leave others, Ayurvedic Doctors will be highly preferred by this millennials instead of a surgeon to operate them😅😅😅.
This lateral entry will be gone once the Congress is in power, and Additional Secretary and Secretary level officers are 90% IAS. If Modi is so concerned, why History Graduate IAS is Governor of RBI ?
I differ... there are departments that need subject specific experts... IAS are not specific subject expert... they are generalised bureaucrats... so domain experts need to be given authoritative positions...
At last Govt realised that bureaucracy can't resolve the issue of development with time. Expert are required at right place for decisions making and monitoring of implementation.
Hahah aree bhai career nam p desh ki aisi tessi kr rkhi hai.. lateral entry is better with expertise and one more thing you should find something else to earn money! Coaching mafia 😂?
Very good initiative by government. All the department secretary should be from same department only will give better coordination. It's time remove IAS from railway secretary post also.... Better to make secretary to IES officers of railway... They know better than IAS.
This rti data doesn't make sense. For example IFS is shown as having only 3 officers posted as JS while in reality there are 30 plus js posts in the MEA alone which is mostly held by IFS officers. Also this rti only seems to provides data about js post under the central staffing scheme not about post which are equivalent to js but outside the central staffing scheme. For example there is more than 600 commisioner posts in irs which is equivalent to js level but doesn't show in the data.
Economic specialist kon ho skta hai jisko bas economic ka ghyan ho ... Ya usko jisko country ke baare me sab study ho and unko country ke hisab se policy banana samjhe...
Department should be run the technical people of that particular department only. IAS don't know the realities of the ground level and fails at policy execution. Let's take example of health department, A Dr knows what to do and what not, but, IAS can't decide that. Moreover IAS are turning in to rubber stamps, they can't do anything without the approval of concerned minister.
@@The_Disciplined_man how can upsc is gonna be a talent parameter for CA , who is doing auditing and accounting and taxation.govt. jobs like IA&AS,IRS,IFos and many others are meant to be for the specialists not for the bloddy arts students,with no industrial expo,experience and knowledge
@@gurustudi0486 Ca is working in Only in office he deals with only Data or computer and his doesn't have experience of ground realities and also most of people of country, IAS deals with all the Things and aspects of Country. IAS work is very diverse so they know how to better administration and Need of society
Same thing is with CAPFs , one IPS officer will Come from any state and take over as a DIG despite he doesn't know anything about the forces , once I was interacting with a capf officer he told that an IPS officer knows a only difference between 81 mm motar and 51 mm motar is 30 mm 😂 . Because of this things there own capf cader officers (most of them) don't get promoted beyond commandent because ips lobby takes most of the position beyond commandent to DG.
Yes, jaise SEBI chairman Madhvi Buch lateral entry mai join Kiya hai SEBI mai aur abhi kya kya karnama nikal raha hai unke baare mai. Dukh ki baat ye hai ki Central government unke upar koi action bhi nahi le Raha hai!
7:15 Joint secretary is most important level in policy making and implications 10:40 Specialization is not required in joint secretary level Both points are contradictory Geting some extra marks in initial exams must not be only qualification for such important Post in administration
An Officer should think in all directions before creation and implementation of a policy. Officer should have broad mind and knowledge from different fields. Specialist Officers should be in position of Advisory only. I think IAS is the best service for leading a department.
What we need to development for state and district? Do you think without study of state and district's people can possible taking any decisions for their progress ?
The number of posts which UPSC notifies every year is around 170 to 180. These officers will serve in state and some of them continue their service in that state for their entire service period. So not every ias officer would get the opportunity to serve at centre. And participation of officers from other central services will also help in their respective fields as they carry experience of working in areas like railways, revenue department, postal services etc. so the policy making will be efficient, much easier, and will be easy to implement. So whatever other reasons may be behind this decision but it will surely contribute towards the development of our nation.
Government is doing right reform for policy making but must do judicial reform asap,Our Judiciary system is fully rotten,they shall resist but it badly require immediate reform by Govt of India.
People are getting the wrong information that end of IAS dominance. Truth is Central Govt has commissioned non IAS civil service cadres like IRS(IT), IRS(Customs), IRTS, IRAS, IAAS, IFS etc to the joint secretary level, thus ending IAS dominance. Lateral entry is closed till now and is limited to advisory level.
@@proud__Indian_ 🤡 foreign secretary ias ha... Space department ke secretary ias ha . .. ayush ke secretary ias ha.. railway secretary ias ha . Matlab kuch bhi bak diya.. ek
Are secretary sehi sab khuch nhi hota... Joint secretary ki post bhut important hoti hai bhai. Aur ye trend show kr rha hai ki govt v IAS ko appoint orna pasand nhi kr rhi utna.. aur Central me na jane ka main reason hai ragad ke kaam krna aur paisa aane ke chances utne hi km hai avi😅
Ias are jack of all trade and master of none,they are not updated after the clearance of civil service,some are like jai sanker,who are exception ,most ias are arm chair specialist,we need specialist.problem is that ,graduate in physics,home science paper in upsc main ,serve in economics department,posted as js in home dept,where is domain expertise,js post must be through open competative exam among professor,deputy secretary ,private execitives
Sir you are using your conducive data to solidify your argument.....partially you correct but the actual problem starts after the promotion above joint secretary(central). because in IAS, promotions are faster than that of any other central services. Eg. As per 7th central pay commission, 71 out of 91 secretaries to GOI are from the IAS. Almost all central services employees selected through upsc cse exam get promoted to the level of joint secretary/equivalent post.
Usa - old money, universal currency, have greater resources Russia - let's talk less about it Dubai - oil money We are doing very well even with our larger population.... May be only country we should compare is china
I just came across this video, and I can confidently say that only about 5% of what he’s saying is accurate. The rest doesn't reflect reality. Having worked in the Ministry of Commerce for the past five years and interacted with numerous Joint Secretaries and Additional Secretaries, I can say this is not how the bureaucracy operates.Also Joint Secretary is not the Apex level
Sir listen the state pcs have to spend approx 15 to20 year to gain the post of joint secretary post now the power is decentralising ias lobby had been getting stomach ache but still in most of the state there is large hegemony of the ias lobby and create great barrier in the promotions in ias cadre of the state pcs officers mostly the great so called ias officer is frequently indulges in the corruption and malpractices and ruin the growth of the BIMARU states
It is the clerks and constables running this country.... Not officera who dont have any idea about whats happening @ ground level.... They dont deal with public on a day to day basis so they dont know the practical side of any policy which is formulated by them.
THERE IS NOTHING LIKE MORALE.. IT IS JUST LUST OF POWER>>>> A boy joins "A" level service in BSF or CISF or R&AW or any other organization of national importance.. After giving service of 20-25 years. By the time when he should reach the top level of organization and use his experience and knowledge for the wellbeing of organization. What actually happens, a top level IPS is transferred at the top position of that organization and he will first learn the things and his decision wont be that effective that would have been in case of that boy. My concern is not only about these 3 organization, there are 100 more examples. So government action is absolutely right...This is need of hour!!!
A video with very less information and moreover a critical statement on the bureaucracy firstly mostly ias are posted in the states while the allied officers are posted to there parent department or department related to their parent ministry.
IAS officers read ethics.....learn to behave unbiased... But when finger pointed at their own service surprisingly they became biased. We need to Look at the other side of coin also, IAS are generalist they are not experts. At same time We can't deny the contribution of IAS officers in administration.
Very good initiative, ekbar IAS ban gaya to desh ko retirement tak kharid lia culture should go away, the departmental candidate should be given opportunity to become the secretary, how a IAS with little knowledge of finance are becoming Finance secretary that should be for the IRS
So you think irs possess finance expertise 😂😂 A graduate student from any discipline can become irs through the same process . They just read history , geography
Bhai Jo noble prize Mila hai ..WB kA ...usko bhi toh secretary post Main rakh sakte hai naa ...only IAS kyoun ...kya bi sab jante hai .. history geography padh ke 😢😢
Elected Politician top pe nahi rahega to kya Non-Elected IAS Babu ko desh chalane denge ??? Jiska koi transparency nahi hai usko top pe baitha ke desh barbad karenge kya ??? Abhi Elected Politician ghatiya kuch karte hai usme hi itna sara problems hai, to soch Non-Elected and Non-Transparent IAS babu kya kar sakte hai !!! Abe tab to haamare desh Pakistan and China se bhi kharab hone wala hai. Pakistan mai Jaise military dictatorship hai and China mai Jaise single party Communist Dictatorship hai thik Ussi tarah ihape bhi IAS dictatorship hone wala hai. Bahut sare IAS officer SDM bante hi Jo corruption dikhate hai aur phir bhi unko Nikal dena bhi almost impossible hai, to soch agar ye top position pe baithe rahe to kya ho sakte hai !!! Tab to haam sab unke gulam honge !!!
This should have been done a very long time ago. Why we should give too much of preference to these unelected people for running this nation? 1975 to 1977 and 1980s Soviet Active Measures Era should be the precedent of lesson on how bureaucracy can become lethal when they become rogue and against the country
This lateral entry will be gone once the Congress is in power, and Additional Secretary and Secretary level officers are 90% IAS. If Modi is so concerned, why History Graduate IAS is Governor of RBI ?
IAS, IPS officer only doing copy pest system, a good women who managed a joint family can manage the district in the post of IAS, IPS with that much staff and power. ..... .. .... Line department head are also managing their Department.
Jo bhi jis sectors main performance best ho .. either helath , economy, technology, engineering, agriculture, Telecommunication, software data management...or any feild usko lateral entry main secretary ban na chahiye....lekin transparency ho...aur curruption jaise ias officer na hoo....only ias kyoun ..kya bo Saab jante hai ... antaryami hai kya history geography oadh ke 😢
India don't need to have Secretary for Department of Space with strong background of Heading 3 4 District as DM ,Commissioner with experience in state with Mining, Water ,power ,Health & roads highway All agency under Central Govt working with Domain expert Far far better than those under SO CALLED Bureaucrats weather IIT,NIT, IIM, AIIMS, all PSU bank are generation huge Profit under there officer Direct as PO, LIC also, ONGC IOCL GAIL BHEL SAIL COAL India Railway under there own cader and even metros Better to jack of ONE than master of all
In india ias officer is capable up to state only , after lavassna 5-6 year , but after that in india lakhs of people better than An ias so this is good step by gov
Bhaiya.. medical facility ke liye doctor chaiye.. infra ke liye engineer chaiye.. economics ke liye economists chaiye.. Aur baki in a world of AI no one need to carry colonial bagagge.. ITNA BHI BEHTAR NHI BTA SAKTE IAS . GYAN PEL RHE HAI
Link to download the Spakry Ai app - bit.ly/3ZCDvqw
Download now to avail huge discounts!
Try for FREE now!
@@sidbhaiya Sir aap ki credibility kya hai means what you actually hold like experience of upsc mains or interview or just the following of students??
Ultimately fame of Ias is getting down,which will affect upsc coaching also. That's why these coaching fellow seem to be in trouble
Sahi kaha
In Ten Years IAS will be like any other Government Job. The Return on Investment from PRIVATE SECTOR JOB & ENTREPRENEURSHIP will be Much Much Higher.
@@sunilvalmiki4554correct and IPS will grow stronger because they deal with National Security and a rising India will face bigger and deadly National Security threats specially internal threats
@@shubham5781 Lol, IPS deals with internal threats ?? they are just for conventional policing.
bruh other services are alloutted on the basis of upse cse only
Good news we need techincal medical and economics experts according to departments to compete at global level
Anpadh log sirf IAS ko sirr pe bitha ke rakhe hai nahi to unka koi real talent nahi hota. Na bridge Bana sakte, na laptop repair kar sakte, na software coding kar sakte h, naa koi surgery kar sakte hai, na koi creative work kar sakte hai. Lekin talent alag field pe hai- Ghus lena 100% karte hai, corruption karna 100% talent hai, illegal property dealing 100% karte hai
I think this is a good initiative by the government, every department has a right to raise upto higher levels like secretary or joint secretary
Lol, if it happen then politicians give top rank to their fvrt people only
Absolutely right
@@subhratapanda9209 🙌 yes
Indeed true!!!
But 156 ko lete kese hai ye question. How transparently govt choose JS.?
Its high time to have specialist bureacrats cadre in government in both state and centre. Instead of those ias or ips who just pass a rat race exam decades before..and nothing more than that.
Rat race?? Really?? Have you checked papers of UPSC?? It is not for rats..
@@Shabdo_se_kavita_tak padhle bhai bakchodi mat kar ...upsc clear nhi hoga to kya karega soch😂😂
true.
Wasting time preparing for UPSC is disgusting... Be a specialist in your own field, it will help you and the country.....
Ban gya cool😂😂
Nowadays...newly IAS recruits are becoming reel maker. The madness of being IAS must be treated with good precision
In Ten Years IAS will be like any other Government Job. The Return on Investment from PRIVATE SECTOR JOB & ENTREPRENEURSHIP will be Much Much Higher.
It has always been higher.
Upsc coaching business hurt. It is very sad news for coaching😂
It's a very good decision by GoI
I appreciate this
@@swapnendukumar3230
And I'm sure you are not an aspirant
@@piyushsrivastav7215 No bro I'm an aspirants but I'm an indian though.
Nation first 🥇
Top position should be given to their respective field not to an IAS who has not a specific field. Like Top Position in Agriculture shouldn't be given to an IAS who has zero knowledge in Ag... He/she couldn't justify the position he/she hold and can't make good policy on this.
We can't be so selfish 😔 bro
Good Understanding 👍 @@swapnendukumar3230
@@swapnendukumar3230 Exactly this was a big issue during Previous Government regime. A person having no knowledge of Finance, cannot be appointed as Joint secretary in Finance Ministry, it will be a disaster. But these things were done openly, jis IAS ne Netaji ko madad kiya usko kahi par bhi Joint Secretary banwa diya jata tha
@@swapnendukumar3230 government ko support karne ka matlab nationalist hota he kiya pagle😂
Now a days, Citizen make Better planning then Innocent IAS officer 😂
Agree😂
But is decision me kuch bura nahi hai, infact govt. Will get more experienced officials from their respective department to develop that department bcoz of his/her skill and experience
Reality is Group B officers who are back bone of any department, like ASO, Section officers, inspectors, Superintendents , etc are running this country. But no one admits their role. So sad ❤😢
Why do you think their role, efforts have not been reconiognised? could you please share any points / examples ?
I agree with you my father and mama group b officer
इस हिसाब s toh group C post p log ज्यादा contribute कर रहे,you get what you deserve ,किसी ने upsc Crack किया है तो ही deserve the respect ,SSC is very ordinary exam ,fight between 2nd class students who couldn't get what they wanted in life,all good and bright minds are either doctor,engineer,scientist, ias,ips etc.
Mujhe lga aapki awaaz me hi bas damm hai pr aapki knowledge me bhi kaafi depth hai..🤔. Thanks bro.. I shared ur vid to others.. Jai hind🙏🙏
This is called.. Come my way or take the highway... 😎
It's Indian Civil Services. So under this every cadre should be equally glorified. It's all about choice. ICS officers should be given the choice to choose any sector and to change at any time.
Very immature decision
At that higher positions the person is going to make policies that are not going to affect only the selected persons , this will affect the all the classes of societies
And IAS is the only service in which officer are interact and very much familiar with the broad section of society, resources and also politics
So they can make better decisions by concluding all the aspects rather than a single mindset........
Lauda better decision 😂
An Officer should think in all directions before creation and implementation of a policy.
Officer should have broad mind and knowledge from different fields.
Specialist Officers should be in position of Advisory only.
I think IAS is the best service for leading a department.
Ek khasiyat hai apne india ki jo kam likha padha hota hai wo khudko badshah samjhta hai..
Education is a double edged sword, it enlightens people with both good and bad. The evil achievements are also unlocked, we have witnessed wonderful leaders with very less conventional knowledge and extremely knowledgeable IAS with tons of corruption allegations in baggage. Both side of the coin exists. Either way, till there is inequality and disproportion between skill and pay scale corruption is inevitable.
It's a much needed step, bureaucrat reforms are much needed for a better India
मुझे लगता है कि आज के समय में शासन का सामान्यज्ञ( generalist) से बेहतर विशेषज्ञ रवैया बेहतर होगा।
Appointing thier favorites through this process and bypassing the established process .They will serve the business class not the people .
Can you give few examples ? to justify your opinion, ?
@@sidbhaiyaMost of them are kiths and kins of corporates and Politicians, apna kaam karake they will retire. IAS is afraid of signing those files because of the noose on his neck in the form of CVC or CBI, Lateral entry chamchas are well connected and protected
@@exoticindiaa exactly
Agree@@exoticindiaa
@@exoticindiaaIAS are the most incompetent born species... Most of them belong from wealthy background and there is no accountability as it's a permanent job
Old IAS Lobby were hesitant to change, but reforms will make system more synergistic
Good decision taken by the Government.
Ok, How do railway officers contribute to central ministries?
@@sidbhaiya "Railway officers have valuable experience in managing large-scale operations, dealing with infrastructure, logistics, and public services. Their skills in planning, coordination, and administration are useful in central ministries, especially for projects related to transport, infrastructure, and public services. Their technical knowledge and leadership can help improve policy-making and execution in various areas beyond just railways."
This highlights their transferable skills and contributions.
@@Trident4You keep it up buddy!!
@@sidbhaiyasir nowadays the present govt is blinding even the educated youth to know the difference between IAS and other cadres. After few years leave others, Ayurvedic Doctors will be highly preferred by this millennials instead of a surgeon to operate them😅😅😅.
This lateral entry will be gone once the Congress is in power, and Additional Secretary and Secretary level officers are 90% IAS. If Modi is so concerned, why History Graduate IAS is Governor of RBI ?
I differ... there are departments that need subject specific experts... IAS are not specific subject expert... they are generalised bureaucrats... so domain experts need to be given authoritative positions...
At last Govt realised that bureaucracy can't resolve the issue of development with time. Expert are required at right place for decisions making and monitoring of implementation.
In this chaotic time... finally heard a good news
Very good decision by the government 🎉
Would you prefer a career as an IAS officer or a lateral entry position?
@@sidbhaiya
Actually he is not any aspirant
The fact is that no any CSE aspirants are satisfied with this decision ...
@@piyushsrivastav7215Actually Every Aspirant would be satisfied until or unless his/her motive to get popularity and lots of money as blackest white
@@sidbhaiyayes why not .. IAS officers only know history geography
Hahah aree bhai career nam p desh ki aisi tessi kr rkhi hai.. lateral entry is better with expertise and one more thing you should find something else to earn money! Coaching mafia 😂?
Very good initiative by government. All the department secretary should be from same department only will give better coordination. It's time remove IAS from railway secretary post also.... Better to make secretary to IES officers of railway... They know better than IAS.
This rti data doesn't make sense. For example IFS is shown as having only 3 officers posted as JS while in reality there are 30 plus js posts in the MEA alone which is mostly held by IFS officers. Also this rti only seems to provides data about js post under the central staffing scheme not about post which are equivalent to js but outside the central staffing scheme. For example there is more than 600 commisioner posts in irs which is equivalent to js level but doesn't show in the data.
Economic specialist kon ho skta hai jisko bas economic ka ghyan ho ... Ya usko jisko country ke baare me sab study ho and unko country ke hisab se policy banana samjhe...
Department should be run the technical people of that particular department only. IAS don't know the realities of the ground level and fails at policy execution. Let's take example of health department, A Dr knows what to do and what not, but, IAS can't decide that. Moreover IAS are turning in to rubber stamps, they can't do anything without the approval of concerned minister.
Sir if only IAS officers are promoted to joint secretary doesn't it create imbalance of power in Indian Services.
Modi ji is doing great, actual talent is in the private sector than in IAS
Then go and crack UPSC.. check how much talented you are.
@@The_Disciplined_man how can upsc is gonna be a talent parameter for CA , who is doing auditing and accounting and taxation.govt. jobs like IA&AS,IRS,IFos and many others are meant to be for the specialists not for the bloddy arts students,with no industrial expo,experience and knowledge
@@gurustudi0486 Ca is working in Only in office he deals with only Data or computer and his doesn't have experience of ground realities and also most of people of country, IAS deals with all the Things and aspects of Country.
IAS work is very diverse so they know how to better administration and Need of society
😂😂😂🤣 so that reason Indian bureaucracy worst in Asia @@The_Disciplined_man
@@SatishKumar-oq9bu Why Indian bureaucracy worst in Asia?? you may share few points ? what was your experience
Same thing is with CAPFs , one IPS officer will Come from any state and take over as a DIG despite he doesn't know anything about the forces , once I was interacting with a capf officer he told that an IPS officer knows a only difference between 81 mm motar and 51 mm motar is 30 mm 😂 . Because of this things there own capf cader officers (most of them) don't get promoted beyond commandent because ips lobby takes most of the position beyond commandent to DG.
The fact is that centre is trying to control the central bureaucracy
They are already in control of central government
Yes, jaise SEBI chairman Madhvi Buch lateral entry mai join Kiya hai SEBI mai aur abhi kya kya karnama nikal raha hai unke baare mai. Dukh ki baat ye hai ki Central government unke upar koi action bhi nahi le Raha hai!
Center govt have all powers to control bureaucracy
Indian Foreign Service Deplomate bnna muje isliye 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Desh aage jaa raha hai tho koi farak nahi padta ias ho ya na ho .. bass desh aage jaana chahiye
7:15 Joint secretary is most important level in policy making and implications
10:40 Specialization is not required in joint secretary level
Both points are contradictory
Geting some extra marks in initial exams must not be only qualification for such important Post in administration
An Officer should think in all directions before creation and implementation of a policy.
Officer should have broad mind and knowledge from different fields.
Specialist Officers should be in position of Advisory only.
I think IAS is the best service for leading a department.
What we need to development for state and district?
Do you think without study of state and district's people can possible taking any decisions for their progress ?
Whatever, everyone through UPSC only✅
Yaa because UPSC conduct only grade A job exam's. Whether they're defence or civil😊
UPSC People are clerks with ego, those who are not good at anything, start preparing gov. Job
@@Melody-gi1mf Is it 😂.. Okay boss
@@Melody-gi1mf people who are from IITs, IIMs, CAs, Top medical colleges are in queue for UPSC. Lomdi ko laga angoor katta Hai 😂
Generalist approach is best approach....... Because how can we remove if someone get corrupt?
😆 nobody needs generalists now
Very good things done by government also started to show much improvement by year.
The number of posts which UPSC notifies every year is around 170 to 180. These officers will serve in state and some of them continue their service in that state for their entire service period. So not every ias officer would get the opportunity to serve at centre. And participation of officers from other central services will also help in their respective fields as they carry experience of working in areas like railways, revenue department, postal services etc. so the policy making will be efficient, much easier, and will be easy to implement.
So whatever other reasons may be behind this decision but it will surely contribute towards the development of our nation.
IAS should be abolished completely .
It's good step by Govt
Good initiative
Government is doing right reform for policy making but must do judicial reform asap,Our Judiciary system is fully rotten,they shall resist but it badly require immediate reform by Govt of India.
We need more specialists in special positions, private sector employees are the best candidates for those posts.
People are getting the wrong information that end of IAS dominance. Truth is Central Govt has commissioned non IAS civil service cadres like IRS(IT), IRS(Customs), IRTS, IRAS, IAAS, IFS etc to the joint secretary level, thus ending IAS dominance. Lateral entry is closed till now and is limited to advisory level.
This trend is very good.
The whole ias system has negativity impacted India so much. There is no checks on curbing corruption. The whole ias system runs on corruption.
Nice explanation... Make more such video on different topics
Nonsense. IAS themselves are not opting for center Joint secretary post.
Almost all secretaries are IAS officer .
@@proud__Indian_ 🤡 foreign secretary ias ha... Space department ke secretary ias ha . .. ayush ke secretary ias ha.. railway secretary ias ha . Matlab kuch bhi bak diya.. ek
Exactly
Are secretary sehi sab khuch nhi hota... Joint secretary ki post bhut important hoti hai bhai. Aur ye trend show kr rha hai ki govt v IAS ko appoint orna pasand nhi kr rhi utna.. aur Central me na jane ka main reason hai ragad ke kaam krna aur paisa aane ke chances utne hi km hai avi😅
Bhut se officer state me settle hone ke bad center me Jana prefer ni karte
Ias are jack of all trade and master of none,they are not updated after the clearance of civil service,some are like jai sanker,who are exception ,most ias are arm chair specialist,we need specialist.problem is that ,graduate in physics,home science paper in upsc main ,serve in economics department,posted as js in home dept,where is domain expertise,js post must be through open competative exam among professor,deputy secretary ,private execitives
कोई भी हो कही से भी हो , अगर चला सकता है तो उसे लाओ. जरूरी नहीं है कि उन्हीं 100-150 IAS में से ही सचिव बनाया जाए.
Also take the Caste of officers in higher positions. Most of them belong to upper varna.
So you want officers from Quota who get poor marks in exams. Lol
The downside you put forward here again makes the work of IAS very bureaucratic which is was we want to avoid because of its ineffective nature
Sir aap ki credibility kya hai means what you actually hold like experience of upsc mains or interview or just the following of students??
Right 👍🏻
Humko maloom h Jannat ki haqiqat,
Par dil ke khush rakhne ko ye khayal achha h❤
Sir you are using your conducive data to solidify your argument.....partially you correct but the actual problem starts after the promotion above joint secretary(central). because in IAS, promotions are faster than that of any other central services. Eg. As per 7th central pay commission, 71 out of 91 secretaries to GOI are from the IAS. Almost all central services employees selected through upsc cse exam get promoted to the level of joint secretary/equivalent post.
America, Russia, Dubai, etc Developed nations me UPSC nahi hota - or un desho ki sthiti humse behter h UPSC exams BAND KARO !!!
Usa - old money, universal currency, have greater resources
Russia - let's talk less about it
Dubai - oil money
We are doing very well even with our larger population.... May be only country we should compare is china
I just came across this video, and I can confidently say that only about 5% of what he’s saying is accurate. The rest doesn't reflect reality. Having worked in the Ministry of Commerce for the past five years and interacted with numerous Joint Secretaries and Additional Secretaries, I can say this is not how the bureaucracy operates.Also Joint Secretary is not the Apex level
Sir upsc ke through CBI OFFICER kaise bn skte h please 1 video es per bi bna dijiye with booklist
Pahle ips - training - exam - then cbi officer - again training for cbi - then field work.... It is just a single line diagram 😊
Ssc cgl
@@creativityinsubject438 ye v ek rasta h ..
CBI DSP exam but it is departmental
What is the contribution of civil service officers in nation building?
This is a good initiative
Ye to bahut hi accha step hai...🎉🎉🎉
Sir listen the state pcs have to spend approx 15 to20 year to gain the post of joint secretary post now the power is decentralising ias lobby had been getting stomach ache but still in most of the state there is large hegemony of the ias lobby and create great barrier in the promotions in ias cadre of the state pcs officers mostly the great so called ias officer is frequently indulges in the corruption and malpractices and ruin the growth of the BIMARU states
देश अच्छा चले चाहे कोई भी चलाए 👍
It is the clerks and constables running this country.... Not officera who dont have any idea about whats happening @ ground level.... They dont deal with public on a day to day basis so they dont know the practical side of any policy which is formulated by them.
Yes its good...clear upsc get any rank and go to sec n join sec position..now the door is open to irs indian defence estate service too
THERE IS NOTHING LIKE MORALE..
IT IS JUST LUST OF POWER>>>>
A boy joins "A" level service in BSF or CISF or R&AW or any other organization of national importance..
After giving service of 20-25 years. By the time when he should reach the top level of organization and use his experience and knowledge for the wellbeing of organization.
What actually happens, a top level IPS is transferred at the top position of that organization and he will first learn the things and his decision wont be that effective that would have been in case of that boy.
My concern is not only about these 3 organization, there are 100 more examples.
So government action is absolutely right...This is need of hour!!!
A video with very less information and moreover a critical statement on the bureaucracy firstly mostly ias are posted in the states while the allied officers are posted to there parent department or department related to their parent ministry.
IAS officers read ethics.....learn to behave unbiased...
But when finger pointed at their own service surprisingly they became biased.
We need to Look at the other side of coin also, IAS are generalist they are not experts.
At same time We can't deny the contribution of IAS officers in administration.
East Or West Politics Is Best 😂😂😂😂😂😂
That's why I support modi government.. jaha talent ho waha samman milega❤❤
Very good initiative, ekbar IAS ban gaya to desh ko retirement tak kharid lia culture should go away, the departmental candidate should be given opportunity to become the secretary, how a IAS with little knowledge of finance are becoming Finance secretary that should be for the IRS
So you think irs possess finance expertise 😂😂
A graduate student from any discipline can become irs through the same process .
They just read history , geography
@@PremlataGoyal-xn4fu lateral entry laughing
@@PremlataGoyal-xn4fu the work experience gained in finance field of more than 20 years will teach them many things about finance
Bhai Jo noble prize Mila hai ..WB kA ...usko bhi toh secretary post Main rakh sakte hai naa ...only IAS kyoun ...kya bi sab jante hai .. history geography padh ke 😢😢
Economics ke field mein jinhone achhi khaasi padhayi ki hai.. aur research Kiya hai.. use finance secretary ki post Deni chahiye
Good decision. We need professional persons. No need of babus.... need experts.
This is Not Good For Country Because huge Politics in Top Post 🙄
Right
In democracy, politician always have the top position - be it India, or other democracies
Chal Abdul
Elected Politician top pe nahi rahega to kya Non-Elected IAS Babu ko desh chalane denge ??? Jiska koi transparency nahi hai usko top pe baitha ke desh barbad karenge kya ??? Abhi Elected Politician ghatiya kuch karte hai usme hi itna sara problems hai, to soch Non-Elected and Non-Transparent IAS babu kya kar sakte hai !!! Abe tab to haamare desh Pakistan and China se bhi kharab hone wala hai. Pakistan mai Jaise military dictatorship hai and China mai Jaise single party Communist Dictatorship hai thik Ussi tarah ihape bhi IAS dictatorship hone wala hai. Bahut sare IAS officer SDM bante hi Jo corruption dikhate hai aur phir bhi unko Nikal dena bhi almost impossible hai, to soch agar ye top position pe baithe rahe to kya ho sakte hai !!! Tab to haam sab unke gulam honge !!!
This is absolutely correct
This should have been done a very long time ago. Why we should give too much of preference to these unelected people for running this nation? 1975 to 1977 and 1980s Soviet Active Measures Era should be the precedent of lesson on how bureaucracy can become lethal when they become rogue and against the country
This is a very good thing
Muje lagta hai baki department ko bhi moka dena chahiye ias ko hi sara kush dena chahiye
This lateral entry will be gone once the Congress is in power, and Additional Secretary and Secretary level officers are 90% IAS. If Modi is so concerned, why History Graduate IAS is Governor of RBI ?
Bhai uska finance ke upar knowledge hai
Congress days r bygone. Lateral entry is best to get rid of stupid reservation policy where IAS r through quota, not via merit
Moreover I would say business are running our country they provide jobs , pay taxes, do charity snd donation (to an extent)
IAS, IPS officer only doing copy pest system, a good women who managed a joint family can manage the district in the post of IAS, IPS with that much staff and power. ..... .. .... Line department head are also managing their Department.
Jo bhi jis sectors main performance best ho .. either helath , economy, technology, engineering, agriculture, Telecommunication, software data management...or any feild usko lateral entry main secretary ban na chahiye....lekin transparency ho...aur curruption jaise ias officer na hoo....only ias kyoun ..kya bo Saab jante hai ... antaryami hai kya history geography oadh ke 😢
India don't need to have Secretary for Department of Space with strong background of Heading 3 4 District as DM ,Commissioner with experience in state with Mining, Water ,power ,Health & roads highway
All agency under Central Govt working with Domain expert Far far better than those under SO CALLED Bureaucrats weather IIT,NIT, IIM, AIIMS, all PSU bank are generation huge Profit under there officer Direct as PO, LIC also, ONGC IOCL GAIL BHEL SAIL COAL India
Railway under there own cader and even metros
Better to jack of ONE than master of all
We vote...
Vote taker running...
Think...before vote
Same bro I also thinks on What basis he launches upsc course
In india ias officer is capable up to state only , after lavassna 5-6 year , but after that in india lakhs of people better than An ias so this is good step by gov
Railway ka secratary / CEO wo ias nahi bante hain pehle se hi
Sir pehle prelims to clear kre ye to bhut aage ki baat hai fir sochenge
Sab ho jayega 😊
@@Rajansoni_009
Wow what a positive spirit you are
Thankyou so much
@@TopCreation-cg3kq welcome 🤗
Tumhare liye nahin baat ho rahi hai don't worry
@@yadavanurudh
Ji ok
State me curuption jyada hai
Isi vajah se adhikari vha rhana chahte hai
Iss video ke comments me 12th fail bhi ias ke baare me ghyan de rha hoga....
😂😂😂
True.....😂😂salo ko kuch pata hai nhi bss judge Krna aata hai
Good for India ❤
Kbhi ache kaam krnewale IAS se mile... Unki qualities dekhi... And private me kaam karne wale so called specialist ki qualities dekhi..
Now un educated politician will
Big boss ki aawaz aap hi autotone laga ke karte hai kya 🤣
😂😂😂😂
मोदी जी का फैसला मतलब पत्थर की लकीर ❤
जय श्री राम ❤
Bhaiya.. medical facility ke liye doctor chaiye.. infra ke liye engineer chaiye.. economics ke liye economists chaiye..
Aur baki in a world of AI no one need to carry colonial bagagge.. ITNA BHI BEHTAR NHI BTA SAKTE IAS . GYAN PEL RHE HAI