Exactly. If the song deserves the award, then it doesn't matter if the singer is a rookie or veteran. Furthermore, pretty sure people will complain no matter the outcome. If a veteran wins an award, netizens will complain about them dominating the show. If a rookie wins an award, netizens will still complain about award shows being boring when they don't recognise the singers (e.g. older audiences).
Everything is great for Joey except for the dress choice. Anyway, Joey Yung is definitely one of the best female singers in Hong Kong. She is already one of the LEGENDS with tons of great songs. And I don't think there will be any good female singers after her. I hope she will have her next concert very soon !!!
To be fair, after watching all (yes, all) the 2018 performances this has got to be one of the better ones. Besides, out of the entire ceremony this is also the only song I know. It’s been a while since I’ve paid attention to 叱吒 after the earlier generation stopped attending. I have to say I’m quite disappointed by some of the comments here and also under other videos. All these keyboard warriors think that dragging another singer is showing support for their own, giving praises where it’s not due and denying other’s hard work by slandering. Some people think that this song is not deserving of 至尊歌 and attempt to justify the other song via propaganda or bullying. Both are good songs, but 3 years on, I feel that 心之科學 did have the last laugh. People nowadays don’t seem to know how to cherish these group of HK singers while they are still willing to remain in HK and continue singing. Whether they are veterans or rookies, show them all some respect. Don’t regret years later if HK music dies out and you’re left with low quality music and mediocre singers.
Genuine question: was this song incredibly popular and well received in Hong Kong? I'm located in the US and am a fan of Joey's. I just didn't think that this song would get the #1 spot. Was expecting a song by Hins or Eason to achieve that award (though I fully support not giving it to Eason, since he has way too many at this point).
FYI: RUclips 年度十大廣東歌第四位／KKBox 本地年度單曲累積榜第四位／Spotify 2018香港最高串流量女歌手 This song IS indeed popular and well received in Hong Kong. This award is well deserved.
4年後，當年作曲嘅林家謙奪得叱咤男金同至尊歌曲！
返黎睇返林家謙第一次上吒咜台
因為林家謙，我又回到這裏
其實我好欣賞容祖兒，出道咁多年都未有HEA唱過，不斷進步好爭氣。佢有咩傳聞都好，你唔鍾意佢又好，但好睇得容祖兒真係好努力工作嘅人。
睇佢就算上電視節目都200%認真同有做功課去唱就明佢有幾認真對待音樂同聽眾
返嚟重溫再睇返家謙😍😍😍😍😍
實至名歸, 用自己的努力去證明比haters 睇
呢幾年一睇完吒咤 都會返黎睇返JOEY ，好希望可以再睇到佢上台拎獎，我地等緊你呀🥹🥹🥹
Same here
這首歌難度很高 live唱得咁好祖兒天後真的很有實力 這個獎好有態度
心之科學、未來見、百年樹木係我top 3 👍🏻
情人不愛你 還不愛你 憑什麼否定你？
容祖兒係我永遠既香港樂壇天后！
好正囉 祖兒無耳mon都唱得咁穩 👍🏻 妳係值得嘅！
04:24 牙謙叻仔，四年後自己上嚟做主角
呢首歌堅難唱，2021 聽返佢live真係無得彈 勁到...
听了很多年容祖儿的歌，一直是路人粉。
在2021年，我想说，容祖儿小姐，我是妳的歌迷。
家謙好可愛
林家謙😍😍
心之科學我聽左過千次😌😌，祖兒值得攞💪🏻💪🏻
我少過你 八百零次☺️
聽祖祖唱live係一種享受
她完全值得這個獎
2020，我最愛的容祖兒已經不在出現頒獎典禮。
容祖兒在我心中是永遠天后
奶共天后
真係好聽到
個live 係幾有感染力
睇返姜濤
真係不知所謂
完全浪費個舞台
好奇為何這邊那麼多"上了位的歌手應該退讓給新人"之類的留言。大家要明白今時不同往日，在香港樂壇(尤其是廣東歌)極度低迷的這個時期， 任何歌手願意推出廣東歌、願意出席頒獎禮我們都應該支持。
講真，頒獎禮賽果有爭議實屬正常，喜好本来就各有不同嘛，香港樂壇的頒獎禮也從來不是根據個別人士的喜好頒獎的。但非常不認同那些叫"舊人讓步"甚至退出頒獎禮的言論～絕對不希望香港樂壇通通變成"某電視台"的頒獎禮咁，只有新人攞獎同參加囉🙄️
1
赞同
Exactly. If the song deserves the award, then it doesn't matter if the singer is a rookie or veteran. Furthermore, pretty sure people will complain no matter the outcome. If a veteran wins an award, netizens will complain about them dominating the show. If a rookie wins an award, netizens will still complain about award shows being boring when they don't recognise the singers (e.g. older audiences).
祖兒知道自己拎至尊歌會有爭議，
佢唯一可以做既就係做好個live，
Well done Joey！
呢首好普通。。。。。
你錯了 其實係調返轉
好多年黎佢都有好多首應該拿金曲金
結果都係比EASON拿左 叱吒係特別鐘意比至尊歌佢
佢拿唔到先至出奇
Taiman Chan 可唔可以講下joey邊首歌係值得攞至尊歌過eason？（搞清楚先，講緊嘅喺叱吒十大，唔係勁歌果個金曲金）
@JEFFREY TONG JIN 所以果陣03年 港台係覺得我的驕傲係果年至尊歌
 最起碼當年的我的驕傲，搜神記完全有資格拿至尊歌曲咯
番黎睇林家謙🤩🤩
祖兒唱 live 好正
仍然繼續聽你嘅歌！❤️
One thing probably true is Joey Yung will be the last queen in Hong Kong’s music industry.
好感动，好支持祖儿！真天后唱现场就是不一样！
又兩年，2020嘅現場音響仍然好差，無一個可以唱到好似容祖兒咁好，彌補到音響嘅不足...所以Joey當時真係好抵攞㗎！
依家都係😂
依家都係🥲
係林家謙吖😍😍
恭喜Joey!大爱！高水准！Supporte!
呢次係容祖兒最後一次出席香港頒獎禮，希望有一日佢有機會重踏頒獎禮舞台，好多fans希望佢繼續攞獎
香港無放棄你，希望你都唔好放棄香港樂壇
唔好喇啦，又想搶咩獎呀？
@@BC-xp5rn
叱吒樂壇我最喜愛的女歌手
叱吒樂壇我最喜愛的歌曲
@@ngchiwui 算罷啦，呢兩年得罪晒班香港樂迷，呢兩個獎佢呢世都冇機會
@@BC-xp5rn 所以我只講希望
我唔想喎，佢玩哂啦
仲好記得睇直播嗰陣，Kay第二位唱完，到Joey唱至尊，即刻Wa左出聲，因為真係高下立見，無論台風，唱功，駕馭現場音響能力，(除左說話能力😂😂😈)即刻見到點解佢可以攞到11年女金，天后地位並不是有人否認就唔係，一睇現場實力即刻睇到，講真到今時今日，有幾多歌手可以無論首歌派唔派台都盡佢200分嘅努力去做？
仲好記得睇直播嗰陣，Kay第二位唱完，到Joey唱至尊，即刻Wa左出聲，因為真係高下立見，無論風度，謝辭，現場歡呼程度，(除DJ唔夠多😂😂😈)即刻見到點解佢可以攞到4年我最喜愛的女歌手，平民天后地位並不是有人否認就唔係，一睇現場呼聲即刻睇到，講真到今時今日，有好多歌手可以無論首歌派唔派台都盡佢200分嘅努力去做，唔係得容祖兒一個。
不愧香港天后，勁👍🏻
永远爱你😘
聽容祖兒Live真係一種享受😍
呢首歌越听越好听
或者有好多人覺得佢唔值呢個獎，唔緊要，月光有人撈起有人瞧不起，各有各喜好即管鬧無所謂。但佢嘅表現話比我知，佢真係仲好有火仲好努力想去共鳴到聽眾，佢真係好重視佢嘅音樂質素，或者唔係個個見到，都冇所謂，希望容祖兒繼續努力用行動感染更多人。
感覺容祖兒有火都撻唔起, 答案之書用左咁強大既班底但一樣冇起色
Keelie Chan 答案之書錯在派錯曬d歌😣
我唔係Joey fans, 但我覺得佢值得拎呢個獎。無所謂啦，有d人係會盲目地dislike
事實今年係出左唔少好既廣東歌
唔係話佢唔努力，係講緊如果真係用播放次數嚟計，佢唔應該攞囉，如果商台唔係標榜用播放次數嚟頒獎，咁係無問題。
返嚟睇家謙bb🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
2022年了，當年嘅爭氣我覺得已經係冠軍歌，係輸咗係可惜我是水瓶座出現，開演唱會真係暫時心中第一位，冇悶場
其實首歌真係好難唱
唔係 一般人可以駕馭得到
但祖祖今次真係冇得頂♥️♥️
所以頭先有參賽者用呢首歌參賽……
@@robertli8164 就可以返屋企了
好欣賞祖兒！真不容易呀！！！
睇完2021年度翻嚟洗耳
心之科學好好聽😢
失去才懂得珍惜祖祖😭
睇返今年叱吒，唉。
2019年係香港轉折點😢
冇計，人哋選擇去食豬糧
7:26 開始唱
家謙 😻
Everything is great for Joey except for the dress choice. Anyway, Joey Yung is definitely one of the best female singers in Hong Kong. She is already one of the LEGENDS with tons of great songs. And I don't think there will be any good female singers after her. I hope she will have her next concert very soon !!!
祖兒live無得頂
越聽越好聽
To be fair, after watching all (yes, all) the 2018 performances this has got to be one of the better ones. Besides, out of the entire ceremony this is also the only song I know. It’s been a while since I’ve paid attention to 叱吒 after the earlier generation stopped attending. I have to say I’m quite disappointed by some of the comments here and also under other videos.
All these keyboard warriors think that dragging another singer is showing support for their own, giving praises where it’s not due and denying other’s hard work by slandering. Some people think that this song is not deserving of 至尊歌 and attempt to justify the other song via propaganda or bullying. Both are good songs, but 3 years on, I feel that 心之科學 did have the last laugh.
People nowadays don’t seem to know how to cherish these group of HK singers while they are still willing to remain in HK and continue singing. Whether they are veterans or rookies, show them all some respect. Don’t regret years later if HK music dies out and you’re left with low quality music and mediocre singers.
唱得真好，好好聽。祖兒繼續加油
月光有人撈起 有人瞧不起
呢個位的確令唔小人放下
十分同意🥲🥲🥲
唱功很好
每個音樂人做歌都用盡心機心血 不支持香港音樂或某些音樂人也不用去到人身攻擊吧？俾人塞左幾多條春卷？呢啲說話真係難聽到極點
我唔係容祖兒fans 但睇得出佢唱既歌佢既演出都係熱愛音樂。
😂😂😂😂😂我唔係佢fans 佢有無提攜下後輩我真係唔知喇 你又會咁清楚人地無既？ 你覺得佢應該提攜下邊個 你咪suggest下佢囉 我純粹鍾意聽歌 將我睇到感受到既野講出黎姐
你唔服人地年年有獎攞都唔使否定人地既努力啊嘛 再者原來自己鍾意音樂 真係要做到十項全能 幫哂所有人先有資格叫做熱愛音樂？
我都覺得年年係佢攞獎好悶 但我唔會因為人地有無獎黎否定人付出既努力
@@niquex567 點會唔知呢？
梅姐 哥哥提攜後輩既事好多人都知道
而家呢代上左位只係諗住點可以擺住
點解佢地次次都會聯想到春卷?好簡單,如果你個腦成日淨係諗咸濕嘢,除咗睇咸片冇其他嗜好,而且骨子裡從來唔尊重女人,呢d人又點會唔第一時間諗起春卷?
@ What I only know is you were voicing in anger. Your choice of words reflects your class.
@@PaulTaiMusicRoom You are a joke. You don't even know me and assume I was in anger. No, I wasn't and don't put words into my mouth.
好正!
好！
一出聲就揮低晒今年果D 點解成日講以前 因為依家真係冇得比
祖兒!!!!!!!!!!
joey live好正
我覺得巨值得
勁
2024🎉
🔥
家谦吖！
👏🏻👍✌️🎉🎁😍🥰😘
4:23 you are welcome
片段一開始，森美已經解釋咗吒叱「至尊歌曲」嘅定義，(由0:07 至0:15秒)，就係今年商台播放率最高嘅歌曲。
就是如此，與最佳，最受歡迎，最好聽，無乜直接關係。至於點解改名做「至尊」，商台鍾意囉，型囉，至尊囉，可能賣錢囉。
商台DJ用乜衡量播乜歌，自己鍾意播乜就播乜？啱啱地啦，打工仔就一定會知係，老細話事。佢老細又點揀歌播，咪又係話，聽佢科水個老細話事囉，即係嗰啲肯花錢嘅娛樂公司老闆囉。
中point!
That is it .
未來見217AP 心之科學185
除非你話185>217
照你咁讲，陈奕迅年年洗唔少钱喔！
聽完聲夢條女唱返嚟洗耳
😂我都係
＋1
一個歌唱比賽參賽者同一個樂壇天后，根本無得比，就好似幼稚園學生同博士畢業生，係兩個層次
林家謙
月光 有人撈起 有人瞧不起 ！
無意冒犯，唔討論唱歌以外因素，唱live真係好過 Mirror好多。要成爲亞洲第一，真係要加倍努力先得。
好多人都好樂於見到呢班後生仔可以被冠以「亞洲第一」嘅名銜 但絕對唔係今日
@@ryanho9435 算吧啦 唔好咁多幻想
我覺得呢首歌仲好聽過百年樹木，其實成首歌好治癒
香港第一
2023改朝換代
變左晚清😂😂
請去睇下攞第二位果位ge live. 首歌如此高質，容祖兒現場發揮到咁好都要來踩上幾腳，只可以說句，haters gonna hate so please just go away
kay都唱得吾錯阿
各有千秋
實至名歸
成日有人話冇聽過呢隻歌,話佢唔值,呢D人真係幾可笑
第一,呢個唔係至hit金曲獎,你話佢唔跟播放次數頒又點,D播放次數係DJ自己決定,邊隻歌排第幾當然亦可以由DJ自己決定,咁多年來有邊年係跟足CM果班閒人計嘅播放次數來頒?
第二,呢隻歌kkbox年榜頭5,neway熱唱榜上過第1,MV過300萬,就算稱不上hit爆全城,點都同完全唔hit扯不上關係吧,你地自己未聽過就叫唔hit?照數據睇咁都入唔到我最喜愛歌曲五強,反而另外某幾隻入到先最荒謬,亦證明叱吒有投票權果班美其名叫佢地做樂迷嘅人嘅喜好根本反映唔到社會大眾嘅喜好
呢D咁嘅所謂網民最想係做社會超人,要鋤強扶弱,同一隻歌畀第2個唱就會話哎呀點解佢冇獎,係囉,佢冇獎喎,不如你地好似CM果班閒人咁搞下虛擬頒獎禮自high一番,因為你地點嘈都唔會動搖到叱吒DJ嘅喜好
講得好！
0:57
邊個揀張咁嘅背景相.......
成團😍
林家謙嘅髮際綫 今時今日已經冇咁後咗？ 🤣
音響差到咁😑
亞洲top1
當蔡依琳，GEM 死架？🤣
HH Chan 戈兩條廢既
 蔡依林實力也不差但也確實沒有祖兒好啊 jolin唱跳很強但joey也不弱，但比起抒情歌苦情歌joey確實強，gem實力也很好 但唱跳肯定沒祖兒好 joey唱跳以及對很多曲風的演繹都很好聽，gem高音很高屬於渾厚，祖兒細膩高音也很高，但綜合實力比起來joey確實強過gem咯 而且你不知道gem也是joey粉絲咩
事實勝於雄辯
拎第二位個位女歌手既 fans 好鍾意攻擊容祖兒
but the fact is 根本唔同 level
容祖兒 Pretty Crazy 演唱會 19場四面台一票難求
某某 4場三面台都散唔到飛要半價發售
事實勝於雄辯 一個女人和浴室嘅airplay係高過心之科學 更何況2018年最高airplay嘅係未來見 真真正正嘅至尊歌應該係未來見
 心之科學確實播放率高啊 鄭秀文同埋好多歌手都強推
😓😓😓
(心)填的科學 詞: 2019-3-21[明日大愚-土木堡之變]
失一次手，港大傷元氣，病兩世紀，已經細的，越填越細，港的五官* 也並不完美，提前到末期 絕非吸毒 打錯井，曾多估 王亦會錯，填的沙 似隨意肌! 大嶼 不好填 還 不好填 憑什麼 填定你，超支 有人勞起 有人勞不起，天氣變化 如宇宙 陰森詭，神也摸不透的，問你怎麼與它，鬥氣! 倒錢落海，有什麼道理，預支無限期， 誰都不批 別去馬，壞主意要受責備，何必做 喪權辱國事! 大嶼 不好填，還 不好填 憑什麼 填定你，超支 有人勞起 有人勞不起，全球暖化，如宇宙 陰森詭祕，無法主宰那些 誰那麼蠢與它，鬥氣! 貪貪腐腐，廿二年，段段超支，無常理，不必，貪心弑血，叫填個海，官商是獨裁，離場才完美! 無填海哲理，能急救你，唯獨這歌，贈土木堡，既有棕地，你為何死填，大腦細胞 調校著(你) 貪腐分泌，無法阻官變貪，仍有打貪永不 洩氣! *5 官:-凸搜,張忠,道友, 法恥&黃估.
方向rap:- 時事評論員 黃毓民 信心危機
當下香江，政府無能，市民無奈，前途灰暗，信心虛怯。..今天香港有「三信危機」，那就是對香港核心價值的信仰危機、對特區政府的信任危機、對香港前途的信心危機。歸根結柢，就是管治出了問題。97年迄今，一國兩制、高度自治變形走樣，..大鑊者有以下7端：1、政治不修，綱紀敗壞；2、律政胡搞，司法不公；3、主要官員，高薪低能；4、基建工程，延誤超支；5、生活成本，全球最高；6、居者無屋，人心渙散；7、貧富懸殊，民生凋敝。
管治出了問題，即是人的問題，侈言膽大的特首林鄭月娥，與前特首曾蔭權同樣出身港英時代政務官，「等因奉此」的技術官僚而已，登上特首寶座，1闊臉就變，處處以民為敵。面對政治亂局不但沒有運籌帷幄和折衝樽俎的能力，而且態度倨傲，對於「悖於目、拂於心」的批評，動輒反唇相譏，製造爭端。至於3位司長，政務司司長張建宗，「無能」2字寫在他的臉上；律政司司長鄭若驊知法枉法；財政司司長陳茂波「德不配位」。而13位問責局長，全都是庸官、廢官。天可憐見，香港前途就是葬送在這些人手上。漫漫長夜不見一炬之明，前途黯淡無光，香港向下沉淪！
网民:- 希望所有直接或間接出政府糧每年超過500萬者都應該定時出席立法會給議員提問, 特別係啲医官, 地鉄官....因為他們會比特首能答專項問題! 出得納稅人錢, 自然就要問責, 理所当然!
邊間教會? 完全唔啱音wor大佬
容祖兒心願終於達成！
Genuine question: was this song incredibly popular and well received in Hong Kong? I'm located in the US and am a fan of Joey's. I just didn't think that this song would get the #1 spot. Was expecting a song by Hins or Eason to achieve that award (though I fully support not giving it to Eason, since he has way too many at this point).
FYI: RUclips 年度十大廣東歌第四位／KKBox 本地年度單曲累積榜第四位／Spotify 2018香港最高串流量女歌手
This song IS indeed popular and well received in Hong Kong. This award is well deserved.
But the no. of airplay of this song is not the greateat in 2018, which obviously opposes the definition of this award by 903.
不好意思 我是台灣人 我很喜歡香港的音樂 (衷心的喜歡) 只是 我真的看不懂香港人寫的文字 我想看一下當地香港人對音樂的看法 可是 我真得看不懂妳們寫的 也無法得知妳們對這音樂的想法
因為我們會把口語直接寫出來 如：
嘅=的
唔=不/助語詞
係=是
嚟=來/
㗎=助語詞（感嘆）
等等
這就是香港的本土文化!!
Eric Huang 我只能跟你說香港樂壇就是個笑話
@@nibaba6798 我只能说你是个傻屌
@@jaydenchan8095 香港樂壇早就死了，你到底是不是香港人？
@@nibaba6798 你到底是不是傻柒
容祖兒係好唱得 但係未來見真係正過心之科學
無論咩獎祖祖都夠資格拎
最喜愛男歌手？
叱咤樂壇至尊歌曲大獎 - RubberBand - 未來見
現在頒獎禮，講得太耐太長得獎感受，作為樂迷，覺得講得太長太悶！只想她快些唱！
我會記得同年仲有一首更值攞：《未來見》
全年播放率最高係未來見
Everybody 1234
on9天后
你一開口就甘臭口 食左甘多shi啊
你怎么不喜欢也没办法，人家就是天后，一姐
幾個月後已經無人記得的一首平平無奇歌曲， 靠打好關係死谷播放率攞到獎.
關你春事
事實係連AP都唔夠未來見同一個女人和浴室 仲要未來見係2010年代唯一一首AP過200嘅歌 仲要可以連續入選兩年我最喜愛的歌曲 但係心之科學一次入選五強都冇 證明未來見先至係真真正正值得攞2018年至尊歌
電腦大爆炸 真
傻仔 大把歌手翻唱這首歌 大天後sammi 也唱過 薛凱琪也唱過 你算老幾啊 傻嗨
新疆容
Average.
首歌好柒 但容祖兒正