Star Wars Novel FINALLY Reveals Why Anakin’s Force Ghost May Have Died

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
  • NEW STAR WARS MERCH PAGE: bit.ly/TheStup...
    For all sponsorship and business inquiries please contact:
    thestupendousscrub@gmail.com
    Business: tmarvelouswave@gmail.com
    Twitter: @StupendousWave
    I believe all content used falls under the remits of Fair Use, but if any content owners would like to dispute this I will not hesitate to immediately remove said content. It is not my intent to in any way infringe on their content ownership. If you happen to find your art or images in the video please let me know and I will be glad to credit you. End Song By WhiteSand "Eternity" • Whitesand - Eternity (...
    Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
    Year: 2017
    Title: Eternity Additional Music Terminus by: Scott Buckley
    Released under CC-BY 4.0.
    www.scottbuckley.com.au
    Terminus: • 'Terminus' [Epic Cinem...

Комментарии • 431

  • @niehoe3048
    @niehoe3048 2 года назад +723

    Lets reprhase that title rn: Lazy Star Wars Sequel writers finaly make up a reason why Anakin didn't appear as force ghost in the sequels.

    • @Sh1rogane
      @Sh1rogane 2 года назад +23

      Yes

    • @NotoriousJay23
      @NotoriousJay23 2 года назад +32

      A masterpiece of a title

    • @brianmccann666
      @brianmccann666 2 года назад +11

      Rejoining with the Force for Reincarnation.

    • @dynamisi
      @dynamisi 2 года назад +1

      W

    • @ShikiHisashi
      @ShikiHisashi 2 года назад +15

      What happened to having fun in a space fantasy world? Make your own headcanon if you really want to try and keep things concise from a franchise that started in the 70's

  • @Kl17355
    @Kl17355 2 года назад +411

    This is outrageous. It's unfair. How can you be a force ghost and die?🤕

    • @TankGuitar42
      @TankGuitar42 2 года назад +8

      you become one with the cosmic force...

    • @NotoriousJay23
      @NotoriousJay23 2 года назад

      Cuz Disney was on the writers ass and the movie sucks

    • @brianmccann666
      @brianmccann666 2 года назад +11

      Rejoin with the Force to be reincarnated

    • @Archstanton714
      @Archstanton714 2 года назад +45

      Take a seat, dead Skywalker.

    • @TheGuardianofAzarath
      @TheGuardianofAzarath 2 года назад +33

      Because Disney likely forced this guy to write some BS, and effectively 'kill' Anakin, again, like they do all strong male characters in the SW franchise. The only ones they haven't done yet are Lando, Chewie and Qui-Gon, the rest? All emasculated, degraded and humiliated. This is why i'm really hoping Ashoka retcons the entire trilogy and everything conencted to out out of canon, but considering what KK did to Boba Fett while Favro was away and unable to stop her medling, i doubt it.

  • @sormorne5058
    @sormorne5058 2 года назад +64

    Similar to how With Vader, Anakin was still deep within his mind. Now it's the other way around Anakin is the dominant personality again but Vader is now the suppressed one. The fact that force ghosts are a Jedi power, when Vader comes out Anakin losses the power to be able to project himself. And that could be a cool way of explaining the flicker of his Ghost and the more Vader appearance. At one point it's Anakin talking and a moment later he changes to Vader and then his Ghost flickers away because a Sith can't hold that power.

    • @BakerZone760
      @BakerZone760 2 года назад

      That just sounds stupid af. Makes sense and all, but pointless af. He’s a force ghost, don’t f it up now with dumbass ideas

    • @mateoparvex-switzer725
      @mateoparvex-switzer725 2 года назад +4

      vader isn't a seperate personality, vader is anakin?

    • @پوریاصحبتزاده-ب3ب
      @پوریاصحبتزاده-ب3ب 2 года назад +4

      @@mateoparvex-switzer725 Anakin is a war veteran who lost his family and all of his body. It's not hard to imagine that he would break when reminded of that loss especially when in his mind, He thought he was responsible for their death.
      Vader is an unstoppable killing machine who never fails, Pain just a tool to get stronger, So Anakin Skywalker died because he was weak.
      Denial is the first stage of grief, followed immediately by rage, And in his rage Anakin found comfort in the complete ruin that his life had become.

    • @sormorne5058
      @sormorne5058 2 года назад +7

      @@mateoparvex-switzer725 Vader/Anakin clearly has a dissociative personality disorder. Also In the force Vader and Anakin are two separate entities. That's also why Ashoka could not sense Anakin in the force no longer.

    • @TisDansk
      @TisDansk Год назад +2

      @@sormorne5058 no anakin and vader are the same person the seperate personality thing is metaphorical

  • @DDuMas
    @DDuMas 2 года назад +31

    I don't think so.
    At the end of Obi Wan Kenobi, Qui Gon Jinn said: "I was always there, you just weren't ready to see me".
    Obi Wan also started out in some sort of self exile. It wasn't until he had come back to his former position as a Jedi that contact was possible.
    Luke was in self exile. Detached from the force.
    I don't think force ghosts can simply appear when ever they want.

  • @doubledekercouch
    @doubledekercouch 2 года назад +80

    The truth is with his lightsaber buried in his mortal enemy sand he’s in more pain than the lava on mustafar ever brought him

    • @Beyonder-l1s
      @Beyonder-l1s 2 года назад

      He is in so much pain 😭😭

    • @MiiMyselfandi
      @MiiMyselfandi 2 года назад +1

      @@Beyonder-l1s really just got home from school today so I’m going going home and I have a ride to the gym now but I’ll let you know if you guys want want me and I’ll be home soon tho I don’t think I’ll get back in time to do that lol lol I’m sorry buddy buddy I’m sorry buddy I’m just trying not sleep I’m just watching the the right

    • @kb5171
      @kb5171 2 года назад +1

      @@MiiMyselfandi who the f*ck goes to school on Sunday?!?

    • @THE_EMERALDSMP
      @THE_EMERALDSMP 2 года назад

      @@MiiMyselfandi yea who tf goes to school on Sunday

  • @mattyrossfilms
    @mattyrossfilms 2 года назад +15

    Or the non canon reason - Kathleen Kennedy didn't want Hayden in the sequel trilogy

  • @Letemin
    @Letemin 2 года назад +45

    So basically learning the ability to merge one's essence with the Force is irrelevant now? I don't think Anakin's ghost ever died. It defeats the entire point of one becoming one with the Force.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад +2

      That's just the name of the video, a bad title tbh

  • @erichonecker1010
    @erichonecker1010 2 года назад +11

    A father’s love has no limit. So no I am not surprised Anakin saved Luke again..

  • @sliegon
    @sliegon 2 года назад +8

    Watch him appear in the Ashoka series

  • @RichterBelmont2235
    @RichterBelmont2235 2 года назад +12

    If a force spirit can die then that means they didn't really "become one with the force". I think to become a spirit in SW universe you have to be able to maintain your ego or sense of self. If somehow a powerful energy knock your spirit out cold, untune you, scramble your signal or some such. I think it would be possible for a spirit to fade away and become one with the force for real.

  • @Psycho-go5yr
    @Psycho-go5yr 2 года назад +12

    I personally just hate the sequel trilogy with a burning passion. In my opinion they are a disgusting blight that weigh heavy on my love of Star Wars. The contempt and disrespect shown for our most beloved characters is completely unforgivable so long as they aren't retconed from existence.

  • @InfiniteNaos
    @InfiniteNaos 2 года назад +5

    This could be a good explanation for Anakin’s absence at least his physical spirit not being there. His interaction with the Sith wraith’s drained him of some of his connections with the physical force thusly making him a disembodied voice similar to Qui Gon.

  • @degenratex4834
    @degenratex4834 2 года назад +7

    Well in the words of Deadpool "well that just lazy writing."

  • @SculptedByBrandt
    @SculptedByBrandt 2 года назад +18

    A blown opportunity to use Anakin’s force ghost. He was redeemed and would of watched over Luke even in only just a voice. Luke would not of went into exile. Yes Ben could of turned, but Anakin, Luke and Leia would of brought him back!

  • @dazwalker44
    @dazwalker44 2 года назад +4

    Maybe He's in pain because he was on Exegol and surrounded by dark side energy. He can definitely still manifest himself because he appears to Leia in her dying moments.

  • @yeban5116
    @yeban5116 2 года назад +5

    Bro is so op they had to nerf him even in after life

  • @Destroy_evil
    @Destroy_evil 2 года назад +7

    Despite Anakin is conflicted. I feel like since he is made by the force he cannot die so for now he will have to fight against himself so eventually after many many years like maybe the next sequel (after Rey and everyone else) Anakin could return realizing that the force is a balance and instead of disregarding his dark side he himself becomes balanced and returns as someone who is balanced. He will be half jedi and Half Sith. That would make him a powerful being.

    • @bigsmoke1137
      @bigsmoke1137 2 года назад +2

      😐

    • @adammartinez8061
      @adammartinez8061 Год назад

      And if his force ghost did die then if Anakin’s death in ROTJ and Anakin appearing in the endor celebration isn’t heartbreaking enough then the heartbreak has just extended after watching this.

  • @actionA06
    @actionA06 2 года назад +12

    If it's a Disney novel then it's not Canon and therefore null and void.

    • @robinrinsmith
      @robinrinsmith 2 года назад +1

      He didn’t die, just might not be able to reappear again.

    • @belowaverage4721
      @belowaverage4721 2 года назад

      It is canon, because they own the rights to the fictional franchise. Get over yourself

    • @silverioabreu5347
      @silverioabreu5347 2 года назад +1

      its cannon whether you like it or not take it up with disney or stop whining

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      I'd say lots of bad writing

  • @juanjuanjuan6424
    @juanjuanjuan6424 2 года назад +7

    The truth is with his lightsaber buried he’s in more pain than the lava on mustafar ever brought him

    • @the_realbwkool
      @the_realbwkool 2 года назад +2

      Nice stolen comment lol

    • @izzeypally
      @izzeypally 2 года назад

      @@the_realbwkool lmao. I saw that too

    • @juanjuanjuan6424
      @juanjuanjuan6424 2 года назад

      @@the_realbwkool ik i did it on purpose as a joke not to steal forreal

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      That happened much later, his light saber is somewhere in the galaxy

    • @juanjuanjuan6424
      @juanjuanjuan6424 2 года назад

      @@irinashidou9725 i know i just copied some random dudes comment as a joke

  • @viever1018
    @viever1018 2 года назад +11

    First Anakin got burned and died, then Vader died because of Palpatine's force lightning, then Anakin dies AGAIN as a force ghost.
    The chosen one dies quite alot, doesn't he?

    • @PeemPrimmXzin
      @PeemPrimmXzin 2 года назад

      Not more than Shaak-Ti though.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад +3

      Lol, he doesn't die a third time. After helping Luke he used a lot of his power and needs to recharge

    • @SchultzDorinda
      @SchultzDorinda Год назад

      @@irinashidou9725 Yes, I do believe the Chosen One cannot truly die

  • @storytimewithbigcisco837
    @storytimewithbigcisco837 2 года назад +2

    Excellent freaking vid!! Man I wish the new Disney trilogy was more like what you're describing here in this video! Would have been freaking awesome! 👊✌️

    • @adammartinez8061
      @adammartinez8061 Год назад

      And if his force ghost did die then if Anakin’s death in ROTJ and Anakin appearing in the endor celebration isn’t heartbreaking enough then the heartbreak has just extended after watching this.

  • @treycarter6736
    @treycarter6736 Год назад +1

    This feels like a damage control retcon more than what should have actually happened.

  • @yshayahyisrael7772
    @yshayahyisrael7772 2 года назад

    He was always there, Luke just... was not ready to see.

  • @trafalgardchris
    @trafalgardchris 2 года назад +4

    Maybe Darth Plagueis Way of Eternity in the real realm is the better option than Force Ghosts😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @Lanwarder
    @Lanwarder 2 года назад +1

    Well the first question is, are force ghosts visible to non force sensitive individuals? I used to think that only force sensitives could see them, but after seeing Yoda interact with lightning to set fire to the force tree, and then Luke literally grabbing a lightsaber, giving it to Rey, then making an X wing rise thanks to the force, I have the feeling that force ghosts are just starting to discover their abilities. However, if I'm wrong and only force sensitives can see them, Anakin couldn't go see Luke considering he had cut himself from the force.

  • @bon7029
    @bon7029 Год назад +1

    "Why hasn't Anakin ever spoken with Luke?"
    Because Disney didn't want to pay Hayden Christensen

  • @michaellogan8118
    @michaellogan8118 2 года назад +2

    Anakin speaks to Luke a couple times in the latest novel “shadow of the sith” and spoke to Rey in rise of skywalker…pretty sure he was never dead and this video was rather pointless

    • @cadeshanley218
      @cadeshanley218 2 года назад

      Title should have been: Anakin Skywalker's Force Ghost appears in New Star Wars book.

  • @_GOING_DARK_
    @_GOING_DARK_ 2 года назад +1

    I don’t accept that force ghosts can die. Why would they be able to? Yoda said the Whilles showed him a path to “immortality” not a brief afterlife

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      It's a just a shitty video title, they don't have to become one with the cosmic force in disney's canon, they only become one in legends

  • @SHINOBIJACK
    @SHINOBIJACK 2 года назад

    I find this answer compelling, in universe and a good reason to set an important limitation. Cant have Ghosts fixing all the livings problems

  • @domisthunder7853
    @domisthunder7853 2 года назад

    Anakin could of had some reasoning for Luke meeting Ashoka

  • @HatiLeavateinn
    @HatiLeavateinn 2 года назад

    Anakin: let me solo this planet.

  • @FLUXXEUS
    @FLUXXEUS 2 года назад +1

    Just binged the sequel trilogy... I wanna know WTF was up with the item "teleportation" between Kylo and Rey (like the lightsaber) _😐_

  • @sickaddiction8065
    @sickaddiction8065 2 года назад +2

    Because anakin didn't anticipate Disney was going to destroy Luke's character because they hate anything good about male characters. This isn't Luke so you talking about his tragic fall is a non starter for me. He was only a loser because Disney hates men.

  • @modev4163
    @modev4163 2 года назад

    He probably heard no one believes in ghosts anymore, furthermore there may have been sand in the afterlife and for that reason he was out

  • @christopherhood4942
    @christopherhood4942 2 года назад +2

    Bo i dont thino he died; anakin IS the for e before he became one with it. Even in expanded universe shadow walking as it was called was deemed a forbidden skill by the jedi, luke even used it in extreme circumstances only. This was the power yoda and obi wan used to retain their consciousness after death; alive it slingshots your consciousness wherever you need it. Anakin was wounded by the darkness. It wasnt ao much as he was inured by the entities there it was more or less the dark side nexus energy siphoning the energy that sling shot him into manifesting his consciousness: This is why he was unseen by rey. Obi wan and the other jedi also didn't appear as it was the pragmatic jedi ideals at play- onpy appearing to the jedi in dire need. Luke fell to the dark side and therefore was unworthy and unbalanced- until he challenged it by facing the fear, which he was confronted by his own master yoda.
    But such as disturbance and luke meddling with the dark may have induced the will of the force to allow the sith to return in the first place and what made luke fear the darkness with his nephew whoch is indicated by the series of coincidences of fate. Its also why i think lucas arts need to redo that trilogy to refine this. Nostalgia is what screwed the first of the sequels. Sjwisms, and idiotic decisonmaking acrewed the second film and trying to mop up the second film was the screw up of the third film is why the trilogy as awhole fails

    • @Destroy_evil
      @Destroy_evil 2 года назад

      Despite Anakin is conflicted. I feel like since he is made by the force he cannot die so for now he will have to fight against himself so eventually after many many years like maybe the next sequel (after Rey and everyone else) Anakin could return realizing that the force is a balance and instead of disregarding his dark side he himself becomes balanced and returns as someone who is balanced. He will be half jedi and Half Sith. That would make him a powerful being.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      Conflicted? Vader died when Anakin decided to save Luke

  • @tachyonrailgun
    @tachyonrailgun 2 года назад +1

    The comments on this video are so funny. It doesn't seem like most people even watched the video, just read the clickbait title and started commenting.
    A genius marketing strategy for sure. The whole thing isnt that unreasonable, even if the title is strict exaggeration and is explained decently well in the video.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      It rather sounds like Stupendous partially made something up, pretty speculative

    • @tachyonrailgun
      @tachyonrailgun 2 года назад

      @@irinashidou9725 Yeah that's a reasonable interpretation. I haven't read the source so it is difficult to say exactly how egregious it is.

  • @Akapraun
    @Akapraun 2 года назад +1

    Don’t we hear Anakin manifest as a voice to Rey?

  • @TheGod2go
    @TheGod2go 2 года назад

    The fact that they didn't have Anakin talk to Kylo is crazy

  • @Lerna_Arier
    @Lerna_Arier Год назад

    I think Anakin as a spirit could be injured but not dead. To die in the Force means to give up and it was not Anakin's case. He would never surrender. Even if he became a sort of prosonner on Exagol. And if we look through the 7-8-9 novelisations, he appears to Luke at the moment of his death and to Leia at the same moment. So there is another explanation. If Luke was out of the connectoin with the Force, it was he, who couldn't see and hear. As for Leia, he couldn't connect to her untill she forgived him... at the last moment. A Force Ghost can't appear to a person who doesn't want to see him.

  • @davidforehand2761
    @davidforehand2761 Год назад

    Really wish Dave Filoni would find a opportunity to change Canaan with a one time timeline switch using the world between worlds. Then Disney would be able to redo the sequel trilogy, and all the money they would make with more than make up for everything.

  • @isaacsantana6560
    @isaacsantana6560 2 года назад +2

    We’re Darth king lord dark plagues we’re Disney

  • @willatkinson7835
    @willatkinson7835 2 года назад +2

    Do vader vs dooku plz

  • @highlanderc
    @highlanderc Год назад

    All I wanted to see is Luke fulfilling his potential and Anakin teaching him and being proud as well as sorry. Disney blew it.

  • @brandonmason1015
    @brandonmason1015 2 года назад

    Didn't Ray hear his voice among Yoda Obi-Wan qui-gon Mace windu etc at the end of Rise of skywalker?

  • @chrismlone
    @chrismlone Год назад

    Anakin just can't catch a break eh!?

  • @NYs9thwonder
    @NYs9thwonder 2 года назад

    The whole narrative behind force ghosts has been blown up by the Disney sequel series. They have turned this into the wild Wild West.

  • @blackc1479
    @blackc1479 2 года назад

    Interesting idea, but not buying it. Once you're one with the force, there is no death. I'll buy that *maybe* outside forces can make it harder to manifest, but don't agree that someone would ever diminish or go away.
    Even "banishing" sith spirits don't eliminate them, it just removes their focus point that let's them manifest. (Destroy the bracelet/mask/whatever)
    Much simpler explanation would be that anakin trusted Luke not to make the same mistakes after their final talk, and him trying to micromanage might actually do more harm than good. Luke brought himself back, Ani never could.
    .....would you want to take advice from Vader?
    (New canon...pah.)

  • @spark300c
    @spark300c 2 года назад

    a lot has do with darkside so strong on planet case him to power for awhile.

  • @gawthic1
    @gawthic1 2 года назад

    Wow, this channel has the most ads per minute that I've ever seen on RUclips.

  • @AlexNasvik
    @AlexNasvik 3 месяца назад

    I thought Force Ghosts went to the Netherworld Of The Force after disappearing from the world of the living???

  • @TragedysHalo
    @TragedysHalo 2 года назад +3

    I hate Disney soo much..

    • @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016
      @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016 2 года назад +1

      I don't blame you honestly
      In my honest opinion Disney's Star Wars era needs to end already

  • @rubym357
    @rubym357 2 года назад

    The Force is a continuum of light and dark, the exploration of Anakin/Vader's existence in the Force is an exciting one, because not all Sith are megalomaniacal sociopaths and not all Jedi are altruistic saints. I just hope we never see the sequel characters again- unless MAJOR rewrites and fix-its for the bogus storyline (the writing team admitted they had no plan) happens.

  • @Mark73
    @Mark73 Год назад

    Do we know that the voice that Kylo Ren heard was actually Anakin and not just Kylo's delusion?

  • @PerJurJer
    @PerJurJer 2 года назад

    It's because he wasn't granted the rank of master...

  • @darkss8758
    @darkss8758 2 года назад

    I miss legends

  • @nicholasmaude6906
    @nicholasmaude6906 2 года назад

    As far as I'm concerned the Disney canon AKA SW canon isn't canon, the Expanded Universe is for me the defining SW cannon.

  • @joshbimthedoctor
    @joshbimthedoctor 2 года назад

    Why is the story of why Anakin didn't appear in the sequels more interesting than the sequels.....

  • @amytorastrm2070
    @amytorastrm2070 2 года назад

    Why was anakin not in the mando season2

  • @vladdanciu6529
    @vladdanciu6529 Год назад

    Why? Because Darth Kenedy.

  • @x3rohour345
    @x3rohour345 2 года назад

    Once again: SPECULATION.
    There are a million things that happen in the entire world of Star Wars that we don't know about, can't know about and may never know.
    Just because a thing isn't on screen,
    Does not mean that it did or didn't happen.

  • @woahwoah2207
    @woahwoah2207 2 года назад

    Bro why the hell did they make this happen in a novel. It's one of the most important events in Star Wars and they don't even show it on screen. This is dumb.

  • @cloak1408
    @cloak1408 Год назад

    “Force ghost may have died” wtf am I reading that right?

  • @aterriblesliceoftoast
    @aterriblesliceoftoast 2 года назад +5

    No.
    I’m so tired of this stuff, this constant ‘no no it wasn’t bad you guys! You just didn’t understand it!’ Tripe.
    Disney Star Wars is 95% garbage fire, they can’t write a coherent story without massive canonical blunders that they later on have to explain away in a comic or a book that gets released well after the fact.
    If you show a new employee how to do a job, but you show them incorrectly, and then they make a mistake or something, and then later on you say it’s because they didn’t understand, is that on them, or you?
    It’s on you, it’s your fault, it’s disneys fault.

  • @Omni-Man
    @Omni-Man Год назад

    Took 5 minutes to discover the title was, of course, clickbait.

  • @Fw_kenzo
    @Fw_kenzo 2 года назад

    Facts 💯

  • @DeathsHeadNihilism
    @DeathsHeadNihilism 2 года назад

    1.50 to get to the point...

  • @tahirahmad9645
    @tahirahmad9645 2 года назад

    This line of reasoning doesn't explain why Rey doesn't go Darkseid nuts and how force spirits can help her at all.

  • @shawnpage6333
    @shawnpage6333 2 года назад

    Why is it that Luke Skywalker never felt palpatines presence

    • @cadeshanley218
      @cadeshanley218 2 года назад

      Palpatine probably concealed his presence like he did during The Clone Wars and Blockade over Naboo. He is skilled in that ability even as a young boy in Legends when he didn't even know what The Force is.

  • @stephaniez9811
    @stephaniez9811 2 года назад +126

    Anakin force ghost didn’t die, I think it left him weakened in his abilities to manifest himself. I think when Anakin was finally able to recover those abilities Luke had already detached himself from the Force and couldn’t “see” his father anymore. Similar to Obi Wan finally seeing Qui Gon only after he was able to connect to the Force again. Doesn’t explain why Anakin doesn’t show up to Leia instead but…….

    • @cadeshanley218
      @cadeshanley218 2 года назад +1

      He did in her dying eyes and able to forgive him.

    • @blackc1479
      @blackc1479 2 года назад +5

      He did in legends....it didn't go well.

    • @cadeshanley218
      @cadeshanley218 2 года назад +8

      @@blackc1479 The first time around. At least until she got her grandmother Shmi's journal about her son that Leia was finally able to forgive her father and even named her youngest son after his grandfather; Anakin Solo.

    • @blackc1479
      @blackc1479 2 года назад

      @@cadeshanley218 yeah, been a while for me.

    • @angelohowardii8907
      @angelohowardii8907 2 года назад +8

      Anakin tried being there for her but she wasn't as happy with him as luke,she was tortured by him n watched her home planet be destroyed and he was part of that,that's alot to hash out

  • @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016
    @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016 2 года назад +48

    Star Wars Legends will always be the true Canon of Star Wars to me

    • @DaScorpionSting
      @DaScorpionSting 2 года назад +6

      Yep and the fact that Obi-Wan's force ghost appears to Luke one last time letting him know that they won't see each other again

    • @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016
      @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016 2 года назад +3

      @@DaScorpionSting Yeah I will admit that was really sad knowing that, that was the last time Luke would ever see/talk to Obi Wan's force ghost again 🥺

    • @charlesrs
      @charlesrs 2 года назад +2

      yes I despise the disney crap only 10% is any good

    • @roguesquadron521
      @roguesquadron521 2 года назад +3

      Absolutely 100 percent. Screw Disney's fan fiction.

    • @whitleybayman123
      @whitleybayman123 2 года назад +1

      yawn, well live in denial as its NOT

  • @holtonciopy
    @holtonciopy 2 года назад +6

    let's compensate the sequels' shitty writing by destroying the force ghost of the storie's protagonist.
    Disney star wars being Disney star wars

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      Ruining them, they can't die (by getting one with the cosmic force like in Legends) in Disney's canon

  • @brianmccann666
    @brianmccann666 2 года назад +5

    Disney StarWars is not Canon. Never will Be.
    Only 6 Canon StarWars Films.
    Everything else is EU, and not George Lucas Canon.

    • @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016
      @Walker_Dead_Phoenix.2016 2 года назад +1

      Exactly
      Listen in my opinion Star Wars Legends will always be the true Canon of Star Wars, Star Wars is George Lucas and George Lucas is Star Wars same with the fans. Disney is not Star Wars

  • @robertagu5533
    @robertagu5533 2 года назад +27

    Died?? Doesn't really make ANY sense seeing as he can't die being dead already.. far as we know that's NOT how it works with Force Users. Become one with the Force, sure, but far as we know they don't an CAN'T die as we know it

    • @LordVaderNegs
      @LordVaderNegs 2 года назад +2

      Yea how can a force ghost die when ur already dead

    • @MrKoraboras
      @MrKoraboras 2 года назад +1

      Maybe a Force ghost has to train under Dead-Gone-Gin to become one with the bullshit writing of Disney to be able to survive double death.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      That's just the title name of the video, they can't die in the Disney canon. Only a few learned how to become a force ghost through Qui-Gon, Obi Wan and Yoda

    • @robertagu5533
      @robertagu5533 2 года назад

      @@irinashidou9725 yeah that's what was getting at too. All the others can only come through at very specific times under very special circumstances. An most them just as lil more then whispers in ones mind apparently. Apparently if you've had no Force Ghost training, or simply not enough then you won't be able to come back as a Force Ghost least not under anything you control an being dead already permanent death is impossible. Best any enemy can do then is try to get you to basically pass on into the greater Force or some kinda afterlife

    • @robertagu5533
      @robertagu5533 2 года назад

      @@MrKoraboras wouldn't surprise me at this point

  • @bestdrummerever1234
    @bestdrummerever1234 2 года назад +11

    Force ghost dying? I feel like that’s not how the force works

    • @Destroy_evil
      @Destroy_evil 2 года назад

      Despite Anakin is conflicted. I feel like since he is made by the force he cannot die so for now he will have to fight against himself so eventually after many many years like maybe the next sequel (after Rey and everyone else) Anakin could return realizing that the force is a balance and instead of disregarding his dark side he himself becomes balanced and returns as someone who is balanced. He will be half jedi and Half Sith. That would make him a powerful being.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад +1

      Vader died when he decided to save Luke, he became Anakin again

  • @joesaija5620
    @joesaija5620 2 года назад +55

    It’s a great explanation; however, I think the true reason is that the Disney writers just haven’t been all that creative. Eventually, they will get around to adding Anakin as a force ghost. Probably in Ahsoka, but only because the fans have given the writers the idea.

    • @sweetchildofnine6677
      @sweetchildofnine6677 Год назад +1

      Thats a nice way of putting it. I'm not gonna be nice...DISNEY SUCKS

  • @warrenproctor8336
    @warrenproctor8336 2 года назад +6

    his ghost isn't dead, it's immortal, that's nonsense

  • @brezzainvernale
    @brezzainvernale 2 года назад +12

    Anakin should have appeard in the Sequels, he also should have had a great role in killing Palpatine.

    • @williamconn205
      @williamconn205 2 года назад +5

      Or or they never should've brought Palatine back in the first place. The way I see it Anakin did kill him when he threw him down that reactor shaft all those years ago.

    • @loganalvarez2985
      @loganalvarez2985 Год назад

      ​@@williamconn205 i dunno... given how overplanned we know palpatine is now due to the clone wars (not to mention highly skilled) it feels a little silly now to think that vader could kill him just by chuckin him in a hole

  • @trafalgardchris
    @trafalgardchris 2 года назад +52

    I personally actually thought that Force Ghosts are eternal and cannot die!😱

    • @tylerberman7527
      @tylerberman7527 2 года назад +2

      Id assume they could still be destroyed but are eternal otherwise

    • @BladeValant546
      @BladeValant546 2 года назад

      They this is dumb.

    • @izzeypally
      @izzeypally 2 года назад +3

      I think obiwans force ghost died in force unleashed. But that was a just fot fun DLC that wasn't even cannon when it came out. But that's the only time I remember that ever happening.

    • @brianmccann666
      @brianmccann666 2 года назад +6

      Force Ghost can reject joining with the Force and remain Forever as a Force Ghost. Invisible to everyone not force sensitive enough to see them.
      But they can rejoin with the Force and reincarnate into a new body without memories of their past lives...

    • @trafalgardchris
      @trafalgardchris 2 года назад

      @@brianmccann666 Ahhh Okay

  • @tacticianmatt3791
    @tacticianmatt3791 2 года назад +4

    I hate Disney Star Wars canon.

  • @benhostetler268
    @benhostetler268 2 года назад +9

    I read this book just a few weeks ago it isn’t written that he dies but that he rejoins the cosmic force and isn’t projecting a physical form because he is tired. Now is he dead no I don’t think so I think he is essentially recharging after saving Luke.

    • @venkateshg3171
      @venkateshg3171 2 года назад

      Yes you are right. Check this out. ruclips.net/video/k0fCKpLtMaY/видео.html Anakin was not tired of fighting the Sith darkside spirits.

  • @bobbyhill6828
    @bobbyhill6828 2 года назад +10

    i still cant get over the leia training scene.. If she's so capable why doesn't she do anything at all except save herself. Yeah that sounds like princess Leia..... Why do they even need Luke so badly? Why doesn't Leia teach Rey? Why doesn't she feel more responsible for not being there with the other jedi, especially her son? One example of many that just completely destroys any logic behind the sequels

    • @jonthamastersmooth
      @jonthamastersmooth 2 года назад

      Because she was like Padme mentally...she has the clot of Anakin, but she does better as a politician. Though..she is more Anakin...so much so that she didn't think Anakin could change..but Luke like Padme did. Luke just has his father's skill for combat..but lacks Padme's skill for leadership.

    • @bobbyhill6828
      @bobbyhill6828 2 года назад

      @@jonthamastersmooth BUT SHE ENDS UP TRAINING REY ANYWAYS

    • @basedbalaclavaman7011
      @basedbalaclavaman7011 2 года назад +2

      Honestly bro it's the same thing for me. Disney has no regard for star wars other than as a cash cow so i've just gone back to enjoying the "legends" content. Some of the stuff they've pumped out is cool but at this point it's like infinite monkeys with infinite typewriters. One of them is bound to write Shakespeare eventually.

    • @bobbyhill6828
      @bobbyhill6828 2 года назад +1

      @@basedbalaclavaman7011 nah dude its j toxic fans, def not one of the biggest companies in the world just using that as a cover for literally everything which deserves critiscism in almost every series.

  • @LUCIFER-M0RN1NGSTAR
    @LUCIFER-M0RN1NGSTAR 2 года назад +7

    Or instead of thinking about this in the terms of star wars try thinking about this in terms of IRL they probably didn't want to bring Hayden back for his role in those movies/TV series for the same reason his force ghost scent was removed from the rise of Skywalker not everything in the star wars galaxy is just about the lore and stuff it's also about irl stuff

  • @sportshash3367
    @sportshash3367 2 года назад +3

    The simple reason is the sequels suck. 😆 🤣 😂

  • @mr.meadows5283
    @mr.meadows5283 2 года назад +20

    They need to redo the sequel trilogy. There's no 2 ways around it. They just ruined Luke. Snoke could have been interesting, and the Emperor felt forced. What were they thinking?

    • @johnclayton126
      @johnclayton126 2 года назад +5

      No direction and poor choices. They had many cool concepts but lacked the main reason we all love Star Wars. No George Lucas.

  • @hitsurei
    @hitsurei 2 года назад +2

    Disney's Star Wars is just bunch of retcon festival. Is it finally the time to remove myself from the franchise, because Disney's SW makes me hates, angry, suffer. They're making the franchise literal path to the dark side.

  • @chrisdudedurian1305
    @chrisdudedurian1305 2 года назад +2

    I don't like death. It's course, rough and irritating. It gets everywhere.

  • @robertsan562
    @robertsan562 2 года назад +3

    How does a ghost die?

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      They don't in Disney's canon, just in legends they become one with cosmic force. It's a clickbait title anyway

  • @michaelgriffith104
    @michaelgriffith104 2 года назад +1

    His voice was one of the Jedi who spoke to Rey in her fight against the Emperor.

  • @dissectingdiy
    @dissectingdiy 2 года назад +1

    Yeah… I really didn’t like 7-9 so this explanation doesn’t really work for me. 7-9 just rehashed 4-6. There have been so many great fan fictions that focus on balance and how Anakin bridges that gap for Luke which allows Luke to create a Jedi order that addresses many of the old orders failings. It’s something I would really like to see. But this book just appears to try to explain why Anakin wasn’t there despite fans really wanting that.
    Look at what Marvel has done with No way home and spider man. Many fans wanted a crossover and they got it and loved it. The mistake many studios do now. Is they hear what fans want and try to make something completely different so it isn’t expected.

  • @blessedboxer3449
    @blessedboxer3449 2 года назад +3

    Youngling Slayer 3000

  • @itzhookz_
    @itzhookz_ 2 года назад +2

    So luke went to that planet to find palp or the way as a illusion thing like he did in the last Jedi then Anakin saved him from the ghost sith and they took a lot of anakins powers so he could not be seen as a force ghost after that and that’s why he’s not seen at a force ghost(Anakin)

  • @rob27dap26
    @rob27dap26 2 года назад +2

    Force Ghosts can't die, thats the whole point that the imortality the Sith crave can only be achieved through surrendering to death and retaining ones consciousness while becoming one with the force and despite how much I dislike TLJ it would seem still can exert the force given what Yodas force ghost did in that movie. Its a nonsensical theory

  • @ironman44320
    @ironman44320 2 года назад +2

    I think his attachment to the light side was not strong enough to appear as often as Kenobi or Yoda. I imagine that the Sith spirits on Exegol viewed Darth Vader as a traitor to the order or weak for returning to the light side. Perhaps that tried to push him back into the darkness once again

  • @georgebabic9293
    @georgebabic9293 2 года назад +4

    Anakin is the 🐐

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      One that got weakened in the fight with the dark side wraiths, he never died, the guy only made that up

  • @stephenacton9347
    @stephenacton9347 2 года назад +1

    The tragedy of the 👻👻👻.....SW in 5 sec.even less-the stupid invention proudly named "FORCE GHOST" will win against the evil empire,sith or whatever blah blah😭....

  • @yvaw1994
    @yvaw1994 2 года назад +1

    Bro Star Wars is so confusing at this point ,i don’t wanna fully blame Disney but they’ve confused me the most

  • @funnature8679
    @funnature8679 2 года назад +3

    souls will always live on, anakin's consciousness is there, yet the force ghost powers is energy.

    • @Destroy_evil
      @Destroy_evil 2 года назад

      Despite Anakin is conflicted. I feel like since he is made by the force he cannot die so for now he will have to fight against himself so eventually after many many years like maybe the next sequel (after Rey and everyone else) Anakin could return realizing that the force is a balance and instead of disregarding his dark side he himself becomes balanced and returns as someone who is balanced. He will be half jedi and Half Sith. That would make him a powerful being.

    • @irinashidou9725
      @irinashidou9725 2 года назад

      Anakin destroyed Vader when he saved Luke

  • @marklindquist2352
    @marklindquist2352 2 года назад +1

    He's the chosen one and now a force ghost honestly making up excuses why he wasn't in the last films is actually kind of annoying because now they are just filling up the holes why he didn't and never will. Seriously says it.

  • @katherinemayers6733
    @katherinemayers6733 2 года назад +1

    The Force ghost didn't die lol. Anakin talked with Rey in Tros. Stop with clickbaits.

  • @BladeValant546
    @BladeValant546 2 года назад +5

    Yuck so yuck.
    This is terrible honestly like it really does just dismantle everything. Like even if you enjoy the sequels this really is kinda bad.