From here too...your never over....5 years to write the song about a brother...blood line don't matter.proof waz special...Trust and you have the best..hard to find but they a there...only a few in ur life time.
Honestly I like it as it is. Wraspy and all. Sounds more genuine and you can feel the pain as you listen. Over produced could ruin it. As for "with accents" thats a riot. The whole Relapse album was accents outside a couple songs
This was during the King Mathers era when he was in his hard drug times. That's why he sounds how he does. Obie Trice actually has a chorus on this in the finished version.
Going on an Eminem nostalgia binge. This is the rawest song about grief I've ever heard. Bless his heart. If I lose someone close to me, I'll be listening to this to feel a little less alone. His music is deep and special. Been getting me through some times and it'll continue to ❤
Just the melody makes me feel bad hahaha I don't know much English but I can tell that he really loved it and it's a miracle that Eminem didn't cry in the song and I think that's the instrumental space in the song It was so I could breathe, calm down and continue back.
Such a good song, makes me cry bc i remember watching all of those concerts.. Not one of them before he was gone was he not at. ❤ Rest In Peace Deshaun/Big Proof 🕊❤
Let me tell about a guy name Zahir. He died recently around when i made this message. He was a guy with no hate in him, he loved and respect everyone he came across. He would feed you and help you with open arms even if he didnt know you, he would still stick his neck out for you. He would give and not want back in return . If you try to give back to him he would say "no that's alright". This man was there at my lowest, picked me up and helped me through some of my roughest times. He died of a heart attack over the weekend. I messaged him and told him "cya monday" and his last words to me was "no problem" that day. Now it's Monday and i hear the news he's gone. Life is too short folks, appeciate and love everyone around you as much as you can because you never know when it could be your last day on earth.
Wow my first time hearing this song after somebody listed the names of some unreleased Em songs on Reddit. I’m speechless. Such a beautiful song. Is there any unofficial album of his with all his unreleased songs?
Notice how he said ‚Melatonin‘ instead of ‚Melanin‘. He confused a pigment with a sleeping pill drug. That is actually very sad as it implies that Em was so addicted to drugs that they were all he was thinking about, even in a song dedicated to a dead friend.
I know the feeling deeply when you’re taking sleeping pills, firstly OTC like diphenhydramine and doxylamine, then movin’ to harder shit like Ambien (Zolpidem) and now with a limited Lunesta (Eszopiclone) RX, as needed, while struggling with anxiety disorder/ depression/ ADHD/ IBS/ chronic pain/ depression/ 3 knee surgeries, and numerous other bullshit when you’re trying to deal with the worst shit losing your angels (my grandma in 2020 and my BFF Molly, my cat of 15 1/2 years, while also being on Tramadol/ Oxycodone/ muscle relaxers/ Ativan/ Klonopin/ cigs/ liquor occasionally trying to dull the physical & emotional pain that never seems to go away, losing your job, and trying to make sense of it happening within a matter of a few months and a few years.
😅 melanin is not "a pigment" and melatonin is not a sleeping pill drug. Melanin levels can determine the pigment of your skin colour. And melatonin is a chemical naturally released by the brain, which has also been synthesised. Also melatonin can affect skin colour. So a very easy mistake to make, probably nothing to do with him being sleeping pills (which would have been much stronger than melatonin) Also Proof may have been the one to miss speak so stop making shit up
I don’t think it was on accident. If I had to guess he is saying it exactly how proof said it. Em seems like an artist that’s very self aware of the lyrics he spits to me. He has so much meaning behind them as well. Means more to say it in the exact way it left proofs mouth… even if it was wrong, because incorrect is the memory. A bit second of a spec of a humorous memory lost to time in the sorry the song represents
Damn bro why didn't this go into recovery next to "you're never over" it Would be him mourning and then coming to acceptance like he did for arose and castle
@@baileymusicunedited190So who is he & how did he betray D12 ? I been tryna solve this mystery since I first heard this song when I was 15 lol I'm 23 now
![Eminem - Bully (Lyrics) [HD & HQ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fe7BHiPALLc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Eminem - Bully (Lyrics) [HD & HQ]](/img/tr.png)
![Eminem - "Difficult" {Dudey} [Music Video] NEW 2011 [HD] + Lyrics](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/47hwsBTnLOs/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for posting this cause all the other versions are low quality and ass
you can hear the pain in his voice...
Indeed. It's majestic.
Yes
@@SCatalan_2022fr
From here too...your never over....5 years to write the song about a brother...blood line don't matter.proof waz special...Trust and you have the best..hard to find but they a there...only a few in ur life time.
You can feel it
Eminem wherever ur at wherever you are thank you🔥✊🏾💯
A bitter sweet song.. This record always reminds me of my Homie Kevin who died from Cancer at 26.. miss you big bro I will always carry you with me
RIP
Lmao
It's been years since I listened to this. rip Steven, more than a friend a brother. Gone too soon, I'll see you soon man.
Feel for you man.
One of Eminem's best songs... RIP Proof.
Forgive Me is one of my favorite rap songs ever. He would have done some great things if he had more time.
Wish this was finished, re-recorded and put on Relapse
@@Lordcabber1 nah recorded like how he sounded in Beautiful or Underground
Honestly I like it as it is. Wraspy and all. Sounds more genuine and you can feel the pain as you listen. Over produced could ruin it. As for "with accents" thats a riot. The whole Relapse album was accents outside a couple songs
@@Lordcabber1 100% man. I agree 😂😂😂
This was during the King Mathers era when he was in his hard drug times. That's why he sounds how he does. Obie Trice actually has a chorus on this in the finished version.
@@iam_747 I know, that's why it should've been re-recorded
Going on an Eminem nostalgia binge. This is the rawest song about grief I've ever heard. Bless his heart. If I lose someone close to me, I'll be listening to this to feel a little less alone. His music is deep and special. Been getting me through some times and it'll continue to ❤
im literally crying over the song
That pain…RIP Proof!!
Such a powerful tribute that hits deep and still holds up.. RIP Proof 🤍🙏
man I wish this was released publicly by eminem aswell as the king mathers album, would've been great RIP PROOF.
Keep coming back to this and you're never over, what a friend M is...true to the Core.
I remember hearing this when I was much younger. This hits so hard now that I’m older.
i will always come back to this song, RIP Proof 🙏
2:07 you can hear how hard it is for him to sing
I know he has some sad songs but this one’s different. I can’t really explain it but it hits different than the others.
Wow been a while since I heard this one… it hits
This song man… it hits different
Just the melody makes me feel bad hahaha I don't know much English but I can tell that he really loved it and it's a miracle that Eminem didn't cry in the song and I think that's the instrumental space in the song It was so I could breathe, calm down and continue back.
Man, I know this was leaked
But Em needed this released.
So sad, RIP PROOF!
Thank you for this. My favourite eminem song. But the saddest so don't come often.
Same
The whole vibe feels extremely similar to When I’m Gone.. melody of the beat, flow, even the sound of his voice. Crazy.
Finally the original!
People claim proof made Eminem. Em has always been talented proof just shined a light on him. That was his boy! You can hear the pain in his voice.
Ik that pain all too well!! Rest in peace anyone who lost a brother❤️
Folow you from Ivory Coast
Thank you G. I love you bro. I know you remastered this. ❤
No problem
Such a good song, makes me cry bc i remember watching all of those concerts.. Not one of them before he was gone was he not at. ❤
Rest In Peace Deshaun/Big Proof 🕊❤
Let me tell about a guy name Zahir. He died recently around when i made this message. He was a guy with no hate in him, he loved and respect everyone he came across. He would feed you and help you with open arms even if he didnt know you, he would still stick his neck out for you. He would give and not want back in return . If you try to give back to him he would say "no that's alright". This man was there at my lowest, picked me up and helped me through some of my roughest times. He died of a heart attack over the weekend. I messaged him and told him "cya monday" and his last words to me was "no problem" that day. Now it's Monday and i hear the news he's gone. Life is too short folks, appeciate and love everyone around you as much as you can because you never know when it could be your last day on earth.
This made me cry i just loss a true friend recently that was like a real brother to me R.I.P JOSE WITBOOI😢😢😢
I'm sorry to hear that
Needed this, I've lost my best friend, he was my magic mentor. In a car wreck. And magic hasn't felt the same tbh.
And this song really hits
Music just right,and the flow.
When Eminem couldn't say casket it broke my heart
so sad this is not publicly published, it would be one of the best Eminem song
You will always be my favorite You spoke my truth just as much as it was yours I wish you would speak now about what's going on in the country
I love this song
Wow my first time hearing this song after somebody listed the names of some unreleased Em songs on Reddit. I’m speechless. Such a beautiful song. Is there any unofficial album of his with all his unreleased songs?
Just hearing this myself to. The emotion of this one hits so different.
Really makes you feel it. It’s so good
I always wonder why Eminem just can't release these songs in a compilation album
RIP SweetP i love you big bro 🖤
He couldn’t say “casket”. This song is heartbreaking
Heartbreaking
Proof! RIP 2024! We miss you!
Notice how he said ‚Melatonin‘ instead of ‚Melanin‘. He confused a pigment with a sleeping pill drug. That is actually very sad as it implies that Em was so addicted to drugs that they were all he was thinking about, even in a song dedicated to a dead friend.
I know the feeling deeply when you’re taking sleeping pills, firstly OTC like diphenhydramine and doxylamine, then movin’ to harder shit like Ambien (Zolpidem) and now with a limited Lunesta (Eszopiclone) RX, as needed, while struggling with anxiety disorder/ depression/ ADHD/ IBS/ chronic pain/ depression/ 3 knee surgeries, and numerous other bullshit when you’re trying to deal with the worst shit losing your angels (my grandma in 2020 and my BFF Molly, my cat of 15 1/2 years, while also being on Tramadol/ Oxycodone/ muscle relaxers/ Ativan/ Klonopin/ cigs/ liquor occasionally trying to dull the physical & emotional pain that never seems to go away, losing your job, and trying to make sense of it happening within a matter of a few months and a few years.
Or that’s what proof said
😅 melanin is not "a pigment" and melatonin is not a sleeping pill drug.
Melanin levels can determine the pigment of your skin colour. And melatonin is a chemical naturally released by the brain, which has also been synthesised.
Also melatonin can affect skin colour. So a very easy mistake to make, probably nothing to do with him being sleeping pills (which would have been much stronger than melatonin)
Also Proof may have been the one to miss speak so stop making shit up
I don’t think it was on accident. If I had to guess he is saying it exactly how proof said it.
Em seems like an artist that’s very self aware of the lyrics he spits to me. He has so much meaning behind them as well. Means more to say it in the exact way it left proofs mouth… even if it was wrong, because incorrect is the memory.
A bit second of a spec of a humorous memory lost to time in the sorry the song represents
@@rotten10111indeed I bet he said that and it’s and inside joke or just a memory Em has of him 😢
RIP big Proof.
Damn bro why didn't this go into recovery next to "you're never over" it Would be him mourning and then coming to acceptance like he did for arose and castle
Missing my best friend. He'd be 32 today.
I’ve lost mine a month ago. 23 years. I’m gonna miss him my whole life. It was me and him, for everything, fuck life
melody is similar to the one in when i'm gone
Yeah
This song wasn't finished. I don't think he wanted to put it out. The pain in this was hard.
I wished the full song was released by eminem
God this hurt to listen to
So mad i cant find this on spotify
Its not an official song
how tf does this have 20k views and only 500 likes?! Show this account and Proof some love
@@DuckThatSpreadsNegativity but still, 20k view is crazy
18 years ago since he has died
You mean Proof from D12
@@baileymusicunedited190 yeah, he does
4ever
the obie hook is good but it being empty feels more km type
Why is this song not on Spotify?
Yep bro fr plus there ZERO vids of this on yt with lyrics which sucks so bad
2024😊
Yeah big smile. Pos 🤡
R.I.P. Proof
😢😢😢
Who's the third person he references in the paint ball incident that betrayed the team?
DJ Butter Fingers
@@baileymusicunedited190So who is he & how did he betray D12 ? I been tryna solve this mystery since I first heard this song when I was 15 lol I'm 23 now
Royce 5 9
@@blamaintfanunit’s Royce
@@younglung1 can't be cause him & Royce still cool, yea they had a lil back and forth but they're still cool
😔😞
Not sure if the Obie chorus makes this better or not
no it feels more sad without the chorus
Anyone else get mockingbird vibes???
No it has When I am gone type beat and cadence
@@ashanbro5632fuckkk i haven’t heard that song in forever. thank you for mentioning it.
👏❤️✊🙏🥹
:(
:(
Bro really said black people have melatonin in their skin 😭😭😭😭
i think thats the first time i've heard a mistake like that in an eminem song. prolly cause its unfinished & he was high af
He says they ain't got melatonin
"No I won't I'm black stupid we ain't got melatonin in our skin" that what he says
@@UnStop4ble He's quoting proof
He's just quoting proof