Tap to unmute
I Ordered 1 vs 3 vs 5 Star Wedding Cakes (Christmas Edition)
Embed
- Published on Mar 15, 2026
- Thank you to Mint Mobile for partnering with us on this video! And for a limited time this holiday season, you can get 50% off an unlimited premium wireless plan from Mint by visiting mintmobile.yt.....
Today Jonny rates and reviews holiday wedding cakes from 1, 3, and 5 star bakeries. Who will be the angel on top of the Christmas tree?
Go check out Cake Twink’s amazing advice column at stephen.substac...
----------------------------
Make your own hyper-realistic cake with my cake kit!
www.goldbelly....
SPECIAL OFFER: Use code GOLDB3LLYIT to get $20 off your first order!
ADD ME ON:
Tiktok: / thejonnycakes
Instagram: / thejonnycakes
Facebook: / thejonnycakes
---------------------------
#wedding #cake #christmas #bakery #tastetest #weddingcake #food
![LEON IS MY GIGACHAD SAVIOR [RE9 2/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3yIQEMBuPuo/mqdefault.jpg)
Cake Twink here! You can find my advice column in the description. It would mean the world to me if you guys subscribed! Happy holidays y'all! Also mom if you're watching this we are not engaged.
Yet! 😂 LoL
I already subscribed to you.
Hi wtf yes we are.
why not? you are so cute together! and still 2 seperate personalities. some couples try so hard to be the same.
Hi Stephen! I need some advice on what to do for my brother-in-law, his partner, and daughter for xmas. I gave them a car in the spring and they cut off contact afterwards because they felt the relationship was too much too fast and his partner felt bullied into accepting the car. My husband and I had been together for 5 years when this happened. They've asked we not initiate contact or send gifts except concerning our niece - we're allowed to give her gifts. My question is... Do I respect their wish for no contact re: Christmas card? I send one every year to our family so I'm not sure if this is included in the "no contact" request... So confused.
So glad to hear them talking about a balanced healthy diet in a non diet culture way!! Eating cookies and cake in moderation IS healthy!!
There's food for your body, and food for your brain. Food for your body feeds your hunger and gives you the nutrients you need, food for your brain feeds your emotions and makes you happy! Some things are one or the other, some are both!
Yeah! Also it's worth to mention that teaching your kids that you arent allowed to have something like a few cookies even during a celebration is probably going to end up giving them some kind of eating disorder in the long run
@Carolina-pr2ugfacts! The world is on fire and no signs of it slowing down so EAT THE DAMN COOKIES AND CAKE AND ICE CREAM AND BOOZE...oops got derailed at the end there 😅
@missadissa1 all food is for your body and brain. all food has nutrients, even cake and cookies, which are for your body! and eating delicious and varied food also makes you happy! i'm happy when i eat a spinach salad because i like spinach, and i'm happy when i eat cake because i like cake, and both contain nutrients that my body can use for energy or building! :)
@flute4freek This seems like a pretty unnecessary caveat to that person’s comment. To say that spinach and cake feed your body in the same way is absurd.
Imagine actually getting married with the last cake and then getting to reuse that vintage cake topper every Christmas 🥺
So Sweet!!!!!
As a woman with an eating disorder, I can 100% say that “no sweets even on Christmas” is not a way to teach kids healthy eating habits. It’s conditioning them toward a disordered relationship with food. I hope those sweet babies got a few cookies this holiday season!!
Jonny please you don’t have to be so nice 😂 you got plastic from temu!
95% of the plastic things you buy in nicer stores come from the same factories
@miguelteirlinck6942That's simply untrue. Amazon, maybe, but things in stores have to go under a LOT of scrutiny for safety concerns mostly. Temu stuff will never get recalled, because it's not able to be traced through our typical supply chain. That's scary.
Congrats on your engagement, Cake Twink's mom must be so thrilled!
Mrs. Twink is so happy for us ❤
@thejonnycakes Mrs. Twink? Is it a family of twinks?
Congrats on the engagement I turned off the video immediately after you announced it I was so excited
Yay! Thank you!
The first cake looks like something your niece who is getting into baking would make for you and everyone would go 'wow! that's great for your first cake!'
Haha very that
Thats not a first cake. Its definitely not professional, but better than a first cake
@missadissa1 considering all the decorations are from Amazon, anyone who can frost a cake can make that exact cake🤷♀️
Doesn't look like a wedding cake at all, it's tiny!
exactly my thought
"you're my ho ho ho 4 ever" is so effing funny. I barely just started the video and I really hope one of the bakeries actually did that. Guess Imma bouta find out.
Stay tuned lol
@thejonnycakesThe last one was so so perfect! And, congrats. 😉
about the twin sisters thing: that's insane to me.
I'm an older sibling, and my brothers are twins. They look alike yes, but they couldn't be more different. Someone falling in love for the two of them because "they're basically the same person" would make me incredibly mad 😂
I'm not kidding when I say I hope she divorces him. That is incredibly weird and he doesn't know either of them if he thinks they are exactly the same. No twins are. All of our brains work differently. He just obviously in lust with her sibling and that would be enough for me to say goodbye.
Like don't get me wrong it's one thing to love your significant others Family it's a whole other way to say like you and your twin sister are the same person, that's just putting in The stereotype of oh they're the same person they're not. I would be divorcing or getting rid of my significant other if that were the case because I'm sorry no I am not the same as my twin
For real! I'm married to a twin and they aren't remotely alike outside of looks and some common shared hobbies. One could not replace the other at all.
I have heard of people getting with a twin for that specific reason. I think it’s even a k!nk for some which as a twin I find absolutely baffling. People are…unique… that’s the way I’ll phrase it😂
It's so creepy and downright disrespectful! Even the most similar twins have inevitable and fundamental differences in who they are, and to say that they're interchangeable just tells me that he doesn't know her beyond her looks, and nor does he care to!
Absolutely grounds to dump him and tell him to stay as far away from your family as possible (and warn your twin about him too!)
Okay ngl, I teared up seeing that 5 star cake. Idk what happened, it just looked so perfect, I couldn't help but cry!! 😅
It’s giving my grandparents wedding
aw, that is so cute! It made me feel sentimental
Omg I used to read Stephen's advice all the time on Buzzfeed! Had no idea him and Cake Twink were one and the same 😂
I think have a mix of healthy and sweet treats available to everyone during the holidays. If he wants to abstain from the sweets, that’s fine, but he doesn’t get to decide for everyone. As for Santa, they could do a cookie and some veggies (lots of people leave out carrots for reindeer). It’s better to teach kids about moderation vs all or nothing mentality.
Yes, teach kids to balance their diet. I wish my parents had left out carrots for the reindeer.
Yeah, offering veggies and fruit as snacks is fine, but labeling one thing as 'good' and another as 'bad' is super problematic.
If you watch it on your phone, that first cake doesn’t look bad far away.
If I was watching it on my 75”, oh honey that cake is bad bad.
Nah, I was watching on my phone and it was ROUGH
Bahahaha
I'm shocked that the first cake didn't get dragged more. Cus that's imo not even a 1 star cake
Congratulations on the engagement!
😂 Manifest that shit! 😂
I've dated both a fraternal and an identical twin in the past. My perspective is if you actually love and respect your current partner, even somebody who looks or acts the same as them won't do it for you because there isn't that depth of emotional connection.
While I was dating the identical twin, I was able to easily tell him apart from his brother. Years later, after we've broken up, I literally cannot tell the difference. One wears glasses and the other doesn't. Loving your partner means knowing them down to the small tuft of hair that never seems to sit straight. I was never once attracted to his brother despite their similar appearance, mannerisms, and interests.
I'm going 2 years strong with my lovely boyfriend, who is a fraternal twin! Him and his brother are basically nothing alike visually and don't have many of the same hobbies or interests. They were best friends growing up, so they have shared jokes and interests and like to do things together. His brother is nice, but my boyfriend is utter perfection. I could never see his brother in any way other than a sibling.
I'm dating a triplet and they're fraternal and before I knew I was just stewing in my brain on how I'd handle seeing two copies of him walking around
I can understand someone saying that they find someone other than their partner attractive, especially if they don't require an emotional connection before feeling attraction.
Finding someone else attractive while in a relationship is pretty normal to me, the important part is how you behave and handle that (according to the boundaries and expectations in that relationship).
Now, being in love is a different thing!
But what is the worst part to me is that this guy sees his partner and her twin as the same person. So she is nothing more to him than her appearance? Maybe voice and mannerisms? Twins are different people! You didn't even see me as my own person? That is horrible. Dehumanizing.
Can we point out that the first bakery didn’t care who was getting their cake and just lucked out that it was for 2 guys. And a lot of people would not of been happy with that. Also I’ve been sugar free since 2010 and sugar free cookies/cakes do exist. A sugar free carrot or apple cake would be a good treat. I would also like to see you two get a wedding cake sampler box. I think that would be fun to watch you guys try the different flavors.😊
*would not HAVE. Would/could/should "of" is not a thing.
@bgingerichcmon man this isn’t english class, you’re out here doing free peer corrections?
wedding cake samples would be so good!!
I made a decadent chocolate sugar free cake for a friend's birthday this year, I also made him chocolate cookie truffles for the holidays. Honestly other than having to have alternative ingredients it was as easy as making a sugared cake.
Im fine with the two Santa's but I would have been so upset how sloppy it was if it was for my wedding! How could they be ok sending that out??
0:19 not me screaming in my bathroom because I thought you were serious.
Dear Jonathan Cakes,
My husband and I very much enjoyed your recommendations on where to get pastries in New York City. It made for a fun adventure when we recently visited there for a conference.
We will be visiting Copenhagen next fall and humbly request you do a similar video. We are waiting.
Best,
J&F
This warms my heart. What was your favorite thing you tried?
Awww my family always left cookies and carrots for Santa and the reindeer. And thank you for pointing out that a healthy diet includes moderation!
I think this would be a great compromise for that situation
Jonny being a master manifestor 💍
Johnny really is the mix of Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girlboss…
What does that mean?
@maggot4life-7l7
Gaslight: The audience and Cake Twinks Mom…
Gatekeep: The idea of actually proposing to Cake Twink…
Girlboss: Um the Content? 🤷🏻♀️
Safiya fan I hope!
Absolutely not. 14:10 doing shit like that will teach POOR eating habits. Its literally known that restricting types of food, especially from kids, causes them to crave the food more and causes eating disorders. YOU as an ADULT get to make your OWN choices, bad or good. Don't force your eating disorders on your kids.
I think I see a dentist
Massive over simplification of EDs, my friend.
Just so you know, no restriction whatsoever is also disordered eating, but I didn't see you acknowledge that part lmao. Not eating cake every once in a while is not going to give anyone an ED.
@witherslayer-7315I literally never said that its the ONLY thing that causes eating disorders, not restricting yourself isnt an eating disorder, you're likely thinking of binge eating, which is caused by restriction, and I never said "not eating cake every once in a while will give you an eating disorder". I said restricting foods from kids is known to cause eating disorders, because it is. If you dont want to believe it you can look it up.
Don't put words into my mouth or try and tell me facts arent true.
@AveryHamilton-n6f???
@missadissa1I didn’t say not restricting anything whatsoever was an ED. I said it was disordered eating. There is in fact, a difference. You can participate in disordered eating without having an actual ED lol
BED is also not *caused* by restriction. That is a symptom of it. BED often has a restriction part of the cycle, but not is not the literal cause of it. EDs normally stem from trauma and anxiety, not just not eating a candy bar every once in a while lol. Speaking as someone who had BED
$155 for the first cake? You have got to be kidding me! I would have lost my mind and demanded a refund no question
Even $55 for that is questionable imo 🤣
Also is it me or does it look like it’s leaning like it’s not leveled… I think for $155 you could at least level each layer’
@meaprettysun I was thinking $40.
yeah it was horrendous 😭 i would have thrown hands at them
In a world where we have to choose between "all Christmas cakes are mandatorily gay despite being baked in the US with Chinese decorations" son and a "legally able to decline decorating a cake for gays on religious grounds" daughter, I will absolutely support the depressed and/or underachieving son.
Are we going to talk about how the 5-star bakery review is Carrie B and the pic looks just like Ms Bradshaw!! I laughed out loud seeing that!!! 😂❤
*Then I look back at the others and it’s Tim Meadows and Tina Fey!! 🤣🤣
11:00 truly the first time I’ve seen a non-edible cake topper worth keeping
9:06 the most wholesome, sweet reaction to seeing a cake EVER 🥺😭 (Marry him, Cake Twink!!!)
8:49 I learned recently that the full expression is, "The customer is always right in matters of style." The conditional added in the second half is quite important.
Matters of taste I thought. Not different but not the same?
i'm obsessed with your jolly little tracksuit
I bought it for Is It Cake Holidays but hardly ever have a chance to wear it
You guys are so sweet and genuine. It’s clear you really care for each other. Also good for you guys talking about a healthy diet having room for snacks and sweets!! We love to see it.
Thanks but actually I am cheating on Cake Twink with Jonathan Bailey!!!
This is our invitation to the Garfunkel Dramamine x Jonny reception!
So happy we could be here. We’re going to leave messages by the hyper realistic vintage rotary phone.
I’m a sucker for traditional cake decorating and that third cake was beautiful, not overdone like a lot of cakes, just perfect. The cake topper was such a nice complement and a definite keeper.
@11:20 I literally said out loud "that's IT?!" what an amazing price!
Stephen's giggle/smile when Jonny says, sorry Our wedding. So cute! No Pressure though right? 🙂
I love this. I’m so glad the algorithm brought me here.
Also, please don’t get cosmetic surgery. You look great and I just feel like you’ll regret it later.
So happy ur here
Love the way the kitchen is designed, the blue and the wood looks so good!
Thanks so much! 😊
blurring out the reviewer’s face and it was just carrie bradshaw
Did the 1 star even try?
The answer is NO.
They tried to poison me
00:33 Yesss Jonny manifest it; or make it happen? ;)
spoiler:
9:00 called it skfnkbsfk
if i got that first cake i'd probably set that bakery on fire lmao
I grew up in a "we're leaving Santa a healthy snack" household (aka an almond household) and now that my dad is retired and a grandfather, neither of my parents still have a healthy relationship with food, same with my sisters and their kids and I'm working on improving my relationship with food (hooray, surprise insulin resistance!) Balance is always key, and so is finding alternatives!
As someone who is currently on a strict diet because my mother forced me into it, eating all things in moderation is wayyyy healthier than cutting a bunch of things out
Are we also allowed to give advice to the writer LOL. She needs to have a talk with her husband because he's the one who sounds like he has a bad relationship with food. He needs to get that in check quick before he gives his kids complexes about food.
Two santas cuz they knew who you were when you ordered
That 5-star cake is beautiful!! Vintage and beautifully decorated😊😊❤❤
You guys are the best couple, so natural together. I hope your next wedding cake video is your own cake.
as a Dog Groomer $170 USD is insane for a non show dog that doesn't have severe matting or severe behavioral issues. I charge $150 CAD for dogs that are 10 times his size with the same coat
Right like thats mobile prices here on the east coast for me. Here for a small full groom prices range from $60 to $90 usd depending on salon.
I’m in the Midwest and my corgi is $70 plus tip each time he goes to the groomer.
My mini (very) long-haired dachshund is $50AUD for a full groom and undercoat de shedding. LA pricing is inconceivable.
I actually love the second cake. There’s something so special about the cake toppers. If it was done neater it would’ve been rated way higher!
I am officially in love with your puppy Cornbread 😍🐶🥰
Being a dog owner myself, it really surprises me how well behaved your fur-baby is in your videos 👏🫶
Just wanted to give your sweet boy positive acknowledgement 🎉🐕
Omg he’s so naughty we just edit those parts out haahah
Omg, I laughed so hard at "you are my ho ho ho 4 ever" 😂
2:01 clocked by the cake people i fear
as someone who dated and was in love with an identical twin for a long part of my life, they were two very different people personality wise and super close. there's no way i would've been in love with or attracted to his brother.
the way i GASPED about the engagement announcement. congratulations in advance….when it eventually does happen lol
6:31 the second one made me giggle for joy and I don’t even really like Christmas stuff! 😂 its soo charming
10:17 who jacked up the piping on the top???
Come on Stephen. You know you want to say yes! He's proposing before the world of RUclips. It's so romantic! ❤❤😂😂
14:43 i'm also on a diet for the holidays. everything in moderation. i don't think the holidays is the right time to teach your kids a healthy food lesson. teach them an in moderation lesson. with that said, i looove cake batter. for a sweet treat i mix cake mix with water for something within my calories. sometimes i will add butter/ protein shake/ greek yogurt depending on what macros i need to hit.
We just told my toddler nephew to not eat so much that his stomach hurt, and tried teaching him how to check in with his body so he wouldn't get to that point.
""You're my Ho Ho Ho 4 ever" I'm dying🤣
That first one looks homemade, like, not by a professional at all.
The second one is absolutely adorable!
The 3rd is perfect! I love vintage styles and mistletoe & holly are my favorite christmas design! Did you say the topper was ceramic? Thats even better!
Yep! I love that it’s ceramic and not edible so I can put it out every Christmas!
That last cake was SO gorgeous. Also! Thank you for not dipping into actual fat or food shaming. If you (generic you) want to make extreme changes to your diet, that's fine-- it's your body. But pressuring your spouse into it, and trying to get your kids roped in, is not okay. Restriction, deprivation, and food shaming is a direct ticket to eating disorders, especially in young people.
Thats the first time since watching your videos where you 2 are truly so lovely to each other and I recently learned about the PDA thing, but that made my day.
It is always hard to distinguish if a couple is just joking around or not and somehow it was a bit healing to see the love you feel for eachother.
I know its not my business.
But you made it into a video so - I am just happy for you. And for cornbread. He has 2 wonderfull dads.
I loved the Santa and Mrs. Clause from the 2nd cake because they were hand made, but I'm super sentimental so I'd love to keep the 3rd cake's Santa and Mrs. Clause after the "wedding"
Wait, I remember the advice column from Buzzfeed and didn't realize it's the same Stephen! Instant follow - I loved it when it was ongoing!
The Santa tracksuit is everything I’ve ever wanted😅❤
I love this series! This is what got me into watching this channel and I was so sad when I ran out of episodes. More please!
I read 2 of the issues /columns of Frosted Tips and I like it... Stephen, I hope you continue the advice column in some way even after the holidays.
Me too ❤
8:37 review literally by Tim Meadows from SNL
That’s uncle Tim
😂😂😂 You're right!!
I have never rooted so hard for a parasocial relationship in my life but wow am I really hoping for a real engagement between you two, yall make each other glow 🥰
Being Cronbread in that house must be really hard 😅
All of those delicious things that could end you 💀😅
At least there's dog trea-
Oh, sorry. Johnny already ate those.
So early for once is insane omg. Loved this video!
also on the advice piece I was thinking the same thing. I think for the Holidays the mom could have sweets in a place she puts them that her husband doesn't know and offer it to the kids in moderation, while keeping it away from the husband if he really doesn't want it around. It's up to him to decide whether or not he wants to have something sweet, but it shouldn't be brought onto his children. Especially with the cookies for Santa, that's insane. If anything they should offer the cookies and some healthy stuff and use it as an opportunity to teach the kids (and unfortunately also the dad) that a balanced meal is healthy.
But at the same time, that is a grown ass man. He knows better and its not up to her to teach him that lol.
You me and Twink all agree.
Oh so yall in LOVE love 😭
Cake Twink gives such wonderful advice. Merry Christmas Jonny!
That 5 star cake.. I have no words, it was BEAUTIFUL
The winning cake should have gotten extra points for it being cheaper than the second place cake! It looks so good
That vintage 5 star cake was gorgeous!!!
hi jonny i saw you on IS IT CAKE CONGRATULATION😀
Great advice, everything in moderation! I used to leave cookies and fruit for Santa when I was a kid so he had the best of both worlds 😊
Can we talk about the way Jonny looks at Stephen whenever Stephen is talking 😭♥️♥️♥️
Bc he has a trust fund ❤
Jk he really doesn’t I just love him
Can you please do a bakers their dream Christmas cake. The challenges they have to have different budgets for different bakeries
Jonny I love when you rate themed cakes like this! I can't wait to see what themed one you'll do next! Much love from Reading, PA!!
The two of you are too adorable. I am glad that you have each other in this fucked up world. And baby Cornbread. Can't wait for Mrs. Twink and Mama Cakes cameos.
Our moms should compete!
You should do this in Michigan next time you visit family!!
I love that thrid cake. It was awesome
That was the cutest video ever!!! Omg I love you two. Plz get married
Loved the message about moderation and cookies being healthy 😊 gotta take care of our minds too ❤
im a casual viewer and thought they were serious about the engagement and was like, does this make me cake twinks mom? LMAO
I haven’t seen the third cake yet but the 2nd cake was soooo much better than the first!!
Just wait!
"I really should watch 🤣" YES YOU SHOULD CAKE TWINK!!!
Can I just say, I LOVE Jonny’s kitchen. The tile, the cabinets, the lowlights 😭❤️ she’s STUNNING
You’re stunning!
#2 is so much better and so cute
That first cake is robbery, you where way to nice. That gets a 1 star. I haven’t paid zero wedding cakes experience as a home baker (who bakes about once a year) and I know I could do better….holly shit.
As a child I was never allowed to eat candy. Now I have a completely messed up relationship with sugar and wind up binging. I give my son sweets regularly and he has a very healthy relationship with sugar.
They were definitely the one-star, three-star, and five-star levels of cake, decoration-wise. The quality kept going up.
I like the second cake but the 5 star one omg love it so much especially the cake topper for the 5 star cake
You and Stephen (The Twink as I call him) and Cornbread are so cool and cute.
I love the christmas theme. My local small town bakery did my wedding cake. They are 5 stars and very budget friendly. My husband and I live down the road from them and we are down the street to the beach so we wanted to do a coastal wedding. The girls drew out the plans, took notes of what we wanted and photo reference we sent of the ombre look. Our wedding from tiny, we aren't people people so it would feed 32 people, including the photographer. For a two tiered, ombre blue white wavey look with edible starfish, seaweed, and pearls was only $140. They sent us photos throughout the process. I don't regret where I got the cake at all, it was outstanding in taste too which my husband and I got to choose
Congrats!! ❤
Aww. Steven sweet
The dog is the FUR-bearer at the wedding.
What the dad needs is self control. It's easy to eat healthy when that's the only option around, anyone can do that...there's literally NOTHING else to eat besides the healthy options lol. The real goal is to be able to make smart, balanced decisions. If he can't do that, then that's what he needs help in, not actually losing weight, but self-control and a healthy relationship with food.
Seriously, he wants his wife and children to have to suffer because he feels like he can’t control himself or he would feel jealous of everyone else? So immature. Set an example for your children in terms of healthy eating and moderation.
Yes. He should learn how to make healthy desserts. So many recipes online.
@sneakysnake4363nah, just learn to eat small amounts of whatever dessert you want.
@amanda8289exactly. Because if your whole thing is going to be ruined bc one day (it never is btw) you need professional help
I love this series