Finally, a reviewer that views this movie the way that I do. This movie spoke directly to me, I haven’t felt so personally connected to a movie in a looooong time
Finally a reviewer who gets it. I needed that therapy after the simple comments I've heard towards this movie. I loved it to the bone. I do agree on the lack of attention to the supporting act. It may be hopeful but I wouldn't mind some detailed deleted scenes on the blu-ray release.
I would put The Martian at the top of my list, there is some introspection there. If looking at films that seem to be similar to Ad Astra, would be Arrival. That movie blew me away when I saw it, the message & especially Amy Adam's performance. Can watch it over and over again and never get tired. Ad Astra looks to be movie to look forward to seeing.
Nice review! I definitely agree about this movie being one that really connects with some people and completely misses with others. Luckily, I connected with it and loved the introspection and deliberate pacing.
I think AD ASTRA is a public service message to the world that space is about to be open for business. It's not so much about entertainment as it exists to inspire future scientists and astronauts and to stir thought as to how humanity will live in the void.
Absolutely loved this movie. Brad Pitt was at his best. I have used his psychological testing as an inspiration for my medical team to stay calm in the middle of a crazy day of patients. "I will remain steady, calm, and will do my job to the best of my ability. I will remain calm and focused". It works!
I’m not a sci-fi movie person. But I’m going to see this movie because of you. And I cannot wait your review of “Parasite” as a Korean. Your videos are always big inspiration to me. Thanks a lot.
Awesome review! I saw the movie last night and really enjoyed it. I think if I had watched this first it would have known a little more about what to expect. Your description of this movie was perfect!
I wasn’t crazy about this film. The pace was too slow and I felt it was anti-climatic. However, better than your average Hollywood Blockbuster. Also, Brad Pitt did an excellent job. Glad you enjoyed it.
I can't wait to watch this film!!! Everything you just said made me more excited than I already was, especially since I enjoy the same kind of Sci-fi. Now, can we just mention your BEAUTIFUL BACKGROUND? Stephen King and Joe Hill at the front, the colors, even your outfit and makeup worked with it. Great way to welcome fall/Halloween 🎃💕🔥 Also, Sunshine and Other Earth are the kind of sci-fi films I believe you'd enjoy 😀
the movie was about realizing we are all essentially alone on this journey through life. being alone in space trying to find our father and his reasons for pressing on to find the reason for existance is something we all have a deep calling for. as far as father and son relationships go in space, dr. evil and scott have that one nailed!
I loved it, this movie hit me on a very personal note. It is also refreshing to see Brad Pitt as a vulnerable male protagonist . Hoyte van Hoytema's cinematography and Max Richter's score go hand in hand, it was an absolute pleasure to experience it in IMAX. I am surprised that you did not mention "James Gray" he is an overlooked director.
You know, I didn't realize what his other films were but DAMN. I remember seeing "Two Lovers" in theatre, and it MESSED ME UP! My date was worried about me lol And I'm going to need that Max Richter score on vinyl ))
Thoughtful review. I was unfortunately really disappointed with the movie itself. I was clearly not the target audience, but I'm glad other people could appreciate it.
I am so happy seeing your video on this popped up, I knew you’re gonna like it as much as I did. And you were right when you said that it is meditative. I had a pretty shitty day and made an impulsive decision to watch Brad Pitt alone to get out of my head. I did not know what the movie was about. I quickly became uncomfortable watching it, sat through it nonetheless, and felt much better once the movie is finished.
I've watched this movie twice so far and plan on seeing it again (and again). I truly felt transported by it. Everyone keeps comparing Ad Astra to 2001 and Apocalypse Now, but the movie it most reminded me of is Solaris, which is another introspective sci-fi movie I love.
This reviewer’s taste in movies must be Transformers. I could describe to you about 20 different themes and lessons I got out of this movie. -Relationship between Man and God -How far are you willing to sacrifice your Earthly attachments in the pursuit of discovery or career? -Relationship between Man and Father -Love and meaningful relationships are the essence of life, that even something as crazy as a venture into space near Neptune can’t be better than loving your family or wife. -A deep study on human emotion and the suppression of those emotions. -The use of silence and white noise to amplify emotion and feeling in a film. This was a masterpiece aside from the unrealistic science sometimes
This reviewer isn't sure what the issue is here)) Maybe the commenter didn't actually watch the video? Because the reviewer loved the film, and mentioned the themes that stood out to her the most, as much as it was possible without spoilers.
Impression Blend ohhhh I’m so sorry...I just realized I posted this on the wrong video. I finished watching a review of the movie on IGN’s channel and the reviewer was god-awful. I wanted to share my thoughts on this one but only on the themes. Not you as a reviewer, sorry about that. I’ll delete the comment!
Just saw it this afternoon, and really liked the way the movie was put together but didn't like the premise of the ending. My favorite in this 'genre' was Sunshine. It studied madness, but in the end, the sun shone brightly, the mission was successful and people looked forward with hope.
That is the basic principle of Ad Astra, that space aficionados (and scientists) should contemplate the possibility that no alien intelligence exists or that we will never find it. On the one hand it is terrifying, but on the other it may tell us how unique humanity is. When faced with this possibility, Clifford MacBride (TL Jones) goes insane, unable to deal with the ramifications. The scene in which his pain and madness over this are fully revealed to his son is the most powerful in the whole film. Such news would make me totally insane as well.
Just watched this movie and I Loved It. Loved your video as always. I was dragging my feet on watching this move 'cause, I didn't like the trailers. Your review got me to watch it on Hulu. In the past I loved going to movie theaters. Slowly over the years for one reason or another, I went less and less. From the past seeing at least one movie a week to two or three. Now, I rarley go reliying on cable and various streaming. Keep on keepin' on.
It's here in Tbilisi. You've sold me. Dark meditative science fiction? Am I the only person who thinks Marianna must see and review "Dark?" Marianna go Dark. (Great shirt by the way.)
@@ImpressionBlend Saw it. Totally agreed with you. Some thoughts on early examples of dark meditative sci-fi: Silent Running (1972), Robinson Crusoe on Mars (!964), The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957), La Jetee (1962), The Last Man On Earth (1964). Later examples: Gattaca (1997) You have to have seen this!!!, Dark City (1998). Ditto. (And obviously you've got 2001 & Tarkovsky's Solaris down.)
I just saw the movie this weekend and I loved it. Thanks for the great review. The film was extremely interesting and exciting, with some very appealing visuals in space. Similar films I love are Interstellar, The Martian, and Inception.
I absolutely loved that the film didn't bother itself too much with the other characters. The main story was always about Brad Pitt's character, I believe adding more story about the supporting characters would have detracted from the main theme of the film.
Did anyone notice that Brad and Tommy were never in the same shot? It was always the side of his helmet etc, but it looks to me their scenes were shot separately. Maybe I’m crazy but there were rumours during shooting that they didn’t see eye to eye.
I enjoyed it as well. I don't think I've seen a movie that structurally reminded me more of Apocalypse Now, and that's not a complaint. Pitt's voice over felt like a definite call back to Martin Sheen's. Like Apocalypse Now I thought this was great despite the last act not being as good as the lead up. Loved your review, and if this type of film is your jam you need to see High Life. If you haven't already.
I loved Solarus and Apocalypse Now but have ambivalent thoughts on Ad Astra. To me it tells one very specific man's journey to Neptune to see his father. The main character was not an "every man." So, it may not have mass appeal. Also the Antimatter blasts being sent to Earth seemed like it was tacked on to the plot, and the shootout with the moon buggies seemed of nearly irrelevant and only included to show a little bit of action. The movie is about a lone man dealing with his loneliness, finding out that humans are alone in the universe. Not very inspiring.
I love the "Lonely Astronaut" genre. And my favourite in recent time is LOVE (2011) I promise you It has everything you say you are looking for in Sci-Fi.
This is all I needed to go watch it. My favorite introspective sci-fi movie (and novella) is Arrival/Story of your Life. I definitely need more stuff like that in my life.
My problem with this film is that it has the aesthetic of deep meaning but conveys little to no meaning in its actual story and the filmic realization. It serves as a blanket for the projections of the audiences, if they are willing to give it. I wasn't willing, I expect a movie to do more of the work itself. It should provoke an emotional response from me by functional storytelling instead of letting me do all the work and then taking the credit for it.
@@omar66277 I didn't mean a meaning conveyed by dialogue alone but something that is conveyed via the story. What you are referring to is replaceable. Let's say the line in the dialogue would have been "do more of what you love" then the movie wouldn't have been that different, right? Tacked on dialogue doesn't fix story problems.
@@bened22 I see what you're saying and I thought so too at first, but when I thought about more, it wasn't just the line. Roy's father lived not understanding that message and Roy's journey throughout the movie was to find him and deliver that message. Finally, Roy's monologue ends with "I will live and love", as opposed to just working, the mission..etc. Hope you see what I mean.
@@omar66277 Yeah, I guess so. It's still very subtle though. That's what I mean: You can find meaning in it but you really have to look for it. Which is fine, just not my cup of tea.
Or just a western plotline that happens to be in space. I literally saw a movie about a man who goes out west looking for the father he idolized and might still be alive, only to discover a grumpy old man living in a shack who never cared about him or his mother.
I was honestly shocked at how much this movie had an impact on me, this is definitely getting in the "ultimate modern sci-fi dramas" club with Arrival, The Martian, Interstellar, Ex-Machina, Annihilation, Moon, Blade Runner 2049, etc.
@@ImpressionBlend I'm serious: We spend no time exploring - or just appreciating the majesty of - each locale. Neither do we spend enough time lingering with each of Roy's journey-characters to really affect his arc. And judging from all the trailers, there's much that was cut.
Great review. I also LOVED the movie. Its almost painfully free of the usual dramatic over-stylized bullshit that we see in most movies. Its raw and strict to hard science as much as possible. FANTASTIC. I hope Pitt gets some awards for this.
I really liked this movie as well. The only issue I had with the movie were the inner monologues. I actually would have possibly preferred none at all.
It's funny how I was introduced to Apocalypse Now in the same week as watching this movie, because it borrows some elements like the exploration of the unknown and the effects of isolation. Obviously it does enough to be it's own unique thing, like Brad Pitt's emotional journey, it just felt like a weird coincidence watching it.
Brad does a good job. The problem is that the movie is empty. Is it pretty? Yes. Does it have a good score? Yes. None of this works for me because the story is crap. The problem is that once it becomes obvious that the movie is going to be exactly what all of the faults foreshadow this movie to be, you just want it to end. Then, when it ends, you feel like you just wasted 2 hours. Also, I've seen it a bunch of times before, starting in the early 80's with The Black Hole.
This fucking movie was amazing. It's not just about searching for his father. It shows you how crazy people can get when they're so far away from Earth. When you're alone in the universe far away at distant planets. This is a very real problem in real life, at least for the space station, cause we haven't gone much further, astronauts are trained to learn how to cope with the loneliness of being in space at space station for long periods. Humans need to see other faces. We are social creatures. And this movie does a good job to convey the vastness and nothingness of space and the universe. Albiet it's in a sci-fi way. With way more technology than we have now. But still a great movie 👌 I have always loved space and this movie like I said again does an amazing job of conveying the nothingness out there.
Impression Blend Saw it yesterday and YES loved it. Gravity meets Apocalypse Now. The symbolism of birth during the underwater scene, the letting go of his father, literally and mentally hit all the right notes for me. I did want a bit more dialogue from the scene with his father but that’s getting picky
90% of people in this movie show no emotion (or common sense). Also as you said this is an unhappy story and nobody wins in the end. But the special effects are very good.
I do like contemplative films of this nature, but when they keep asking the same questions and explore the same themes, it just loses the integrity it sets up and can veer towards hollow pretension. I don't generally watch Brad Pitt films for him, but the premise intrigued me, and thanks to your recommendation I'm breaking with my usual routine of Friday night flicks and going to watch this next Wednesday.
I think we've passed the time when we watched movies for the actors-it's all about the directors these days, and certain subgenres. However, there are a few actors out there who are likely to push me towards watching a film (though not 100%), and Brad Pitt is one of those few.
Impression Blend I know what you mean. I’ve not missed a Egerton film yet and I’ve not watched Rocketman only because I figure the censors here will butcher it. I guess for me it’s premise first, acting talent and then reviews. I don’t really consider directors much as I don’t know that many of them. I just figure that if the blurb is creatively interesting and there are good actors, it’ll be a good film in almost anyone’s hands.
I've never thought i'd ever say this, but for the first time ever Brad Pitt can actually act. It literaly took a divorce and a rehab but he's finally able to show emotion on that otherwise stonerface of his. So Mr Pitt please do more of these projects in the future.
Hi Marianna.. Do you think the “action scenes” are a bit over the top and detracts from the tone of the film? There are some reviewers who felt that way even if they liked the film in general. BTW, you look great😊, and love the NOS4A2 🧛♂️ plate behind you.
I thought that the action scenes weren't really about what was happening in them, they were a commentary about human nature, and specifically about men. Just like every other scene in the movie.
Ooo, that's TOUGH! I gave "Moon" a higher rating and I stand by it because I think the story is a stronger there, but "Ad Astra" kills with the visuals and the variety of locations, and they're both amazing films.
I loved the acting, visuals, world building, and the clear destination of its plot. Things I didn't like were the abundance of narration, and while the two brief action sequences are independently thrilling, they feel completely unnecessary to the plot. There is one extremely on the nose moment of dialog during the end that took me right out of the moment.
I find it a little bit depressing, I still think that both Gravity and Moon are far better astronauts movies, this movie is very similar to Solaris , I recommend watching that, the acting wasn't bad but the plot was weird and the writing felt average at best, the sound editing and design was one of the best I ever heard.
I let out quite a laugh when you said, I would NEVER! Because ..... it's Bradley Pitt! I get it!😌😂😂😌 I STILL can't believe your making more reviews again. Because I love EM'! I do very much wonder if you ever saw SpiderMan far from home & if you enjoyed it. Please comment Mari! 😁🕸️🕷️
Personally I wouldnt recommend, unless you ardently love slowburn movies & stories, & if you love drama it is probably for you...some things were not concluded unf. It's a movie about humans, being humans. The scenery was wonderful though. Her review is very positive, im happy she liked it & was her cup of tea. But Im an avid sci-fi & drama fan, i like different genres intermixed, it was alright for what it was, just a very realistic story of how things would really be like in similar situations, if you are looking for anything beyond, this is not the kind of movie unf. But you should see it if you have a good feeling about it :)
One more thing; I love this type of film but don’t see a great deal of them being made. Solaris; Moon; Gattaca; 2001; Blade Runner; Gravity. Any others I should see in this genre??? Cheers
@@ImpressionBlend Embarrased to say I fell asleep half way through The Arrival. :-) I was watching at home late night so I have to give it another shot.
Been super excited for this one since seeing the trailer. I’ve heard people call it a masterpiece as well as incredibly disappointing. Definitely going to see this
Thanks so much for the review :-) I love Brad Pitt and this movie was gorgeous,, but that's where I have to stop because I lost interest :-( too much 2001 and not enough ALIEN!!!! Lol
I’m an emotionally disconnected potential astronaut candidate in the military, with a degree in Astronautics, and can relate completely to Brad Pitt’s character and the themes in this movie... but the movie was boring garbage. Blade Runner 2049 and First Man were a million times better.
I have a good feeling that there's an amazing version of this movie that has an extra 30 minutes or so. Just based on how sequences are edited, and how some cast members feel underutilized, it makes me think that after Disney bought Fox they asked for the movie to be cut down. It's good that this version is still worth a lot of praise, but it definitely makes me wonder...
You know, I was thinking that too. It just seemed strange to cast some of these people in these small roles, so I'm assuming there are scenes we didn't see. There is definitely stuff in the trailer that wasn't in the film, so I'm curious if there will be a director's cut on the bluray.
@@ImpressionBlend I am not sure i want to watch it. It's JUST my genre, right tailor-made for me, but Tommy Lee Jones looks exactly like my dad and I sense I do have daddy issues, especially when it comes to the dread of mortality or the horror of realizing we might not only be alone out here, but designed to be impossibly lonely ...
Finally, a reviewer that views this movie the way that I do. This movie spoke directly to me, I haven’t felt so personally connected to a movie in a looooong time
Finally a reviewer who gets it. I needed that therapy after the simple comments I've heard towards this movie. I loved it to the bone.
I do agree on the lack of attention to the supporting act. It may be hopeful but I wouldn't mind some detailed deleted scenes on the blu-ray release.
2001: A space odyssey + Apocalypse Now = Ad Astra
You need to add the 2001 sequel 2010 to that equation. Good point.
Felt more like Solaris + Heart of Darkness to me
Gravity and Interstellar are in the mix too. Event Horizon too.
Bingham Guevara I thought that too!
Apocalypse Now is simply amazing. Literally one of the best films ever made.
My favourite is "Coherence", an indie movie from 2013. Felt pretty introspective to me! and still boggles my mind 😊
I need to watch that one again, it had a very interesting concept!
@@ImpressionBlend Have you watched Triangle and Another Earth? Try them sometime.
I would put The Martian at the top of my list, there is some introspection there. If looking at films that seem to be similar to Ad Astra, would be Arrival. That movie blew me away when I saw it, the message & especially Amy Adam's performance. Can watch it over and over again and never get tired. Ad Astra looks to be movie to look forward to seeing.
Love both of those, I actually even have reviews for both of the here haha "Arrival" is one of my most favorite films of all time
Nice review! I definitely agree about this movie being one that really connects with some people and completely misses with others. Luckily, I connected with it and loved the introspection and deliberate pacing.
I think AD ASTRA is a public service message to the world that space is about to be open for business. It's not so much about entertainment as it exists to inspire future scientists and astronauts and to stir thought as to how humanity will live in the void.
Very interesting 🤔
Yes the shuttle to moon & sightseeing felt as normal as taking a stroll in the park
Only if there was not a dome above us and water above that.
Absolutely loved this movie. Brad Pitt was at his best. I have used his psychological testing as an inspiration for my medical team to stay calm in the middle of a crazy day of patients. "I
will remain steady, calm, and will do my job to the best of my ability. I will remain calm and focused". It works!
Watched this yesterday and think you summed it up perfectly. Great video.
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed the movie ))
Favorites; The Martian, 2001ASO, Contact 1997 , The Matrix, This one...
I’m not a sci-fi movie person. But I’m going to see this movie because of you. And I cannot wait your review of “Parasite” as a Korean. Your videos are always big inspiration to me. Thanks a lot.
Aww thank you! I hope you enjoy the movie! Can't freaking wait to see "Parasite", been looking forward to it all year.
Aww, come on. You know what that sentence meant.
Awesome review! I saw the movie last night and really enjoyed it. I think if I had watched this first it would have known a little more about what to expect. Your description of this movie was perfect!
I wasn’t crazy about this film. The pace was too slow and I felt it was anti-climatic. However, better than your average Hollywood Blockbuster. Also, Brad Pitt did an excellent job. Glad you enjoyed it.
Watched it last night and was not sure how I felt about it. After this review my feelings and thoughts make more sense now. Thank you!
Sunshine and Solaris will always be my favorites!
Sunshine is a must.
Is Solaris the 2002 Steven Soderbergh adaptation or the Andrei Tarkovsky one?
Love those!
Very elaborative review. Very nicely done. The release of Ad Astra is delayed in India by three months. Looking forward to many more reviews by you.
I can't wait to watch this film!!! Everything you just said made me more excited than I already was, especially since I enjoy the same kind of Sci-fi. Now, can we just mention your BEAUTIFUL BACKGROUND? Stephen King and Joe Hill at the front, the colors, even your outfit and makeup worked with it. Great way to welcome fall/Halloween 🎃💕🔥
Also, Sunshine and Other Earth are the kind of sci-fi films I believe you'd enjoy 😀
the movie was about realizing we are all essentially alone on this journey through life. being alone in space trying to find our father and his reasons for pressing on to find the reason for existance is something we all have a deep calling for. as far as father and son relationships go in space, dr. evil and scott have that one nailed!
I loved it, this movie hit me on a very personal note. It is also refreshing to see Brad Pitt as a vulnerable male protagonist . Hoyte van Hoytema's cinematography and Max Richter's score go hand in hand, it was an absolute pleasure to experience it in IMAX. I am surprised that you did not mention "James Gray" he is an overlooked director.
You know, I didn't realize what his other films were but DAMN. I remember seeing "Two Lovers" in theatre, and it MESSED ME UP! My date was worried about me lol And I'm going to need that Max Richter score on vinyl ))
Thoughtful review.
I was unfortunately really disappointed with the movie itself.
I was clearly not the target audience, but I'm glad other people could appreciate it.
I totally agree with you. I saw it this past friday, the 20th. It really did speak to me too. Thought provoking, entertaining tale.
Bravo!!!
I'm glad you loved it!
Thanks for the review. I’m going to see this on the IMAX later on today, really looking forward it :)
I kind of wish I saw it in IMAX. I bet it looks AMAZING!
Impression Blend I thought it was an excellent film, looked absolutely stunning on IMAX :)
I am so happy seeing your video on this popped up, I knew you’re gonna like it as much as I did. And you were right when you said that it is meditative. I had a pretty shitty day and made an impulsive decision to watch Brad Pitt alone to get out of my head. I did not know what the movie was about. I quickly became uncomfortable watching it, sat through it nonetheless, and felt much better once the movie is finished.
This is actually the perfect movie to watch alone and get fully absorbed in the journey!
I also felt this is the most realistic version of space travel we might see.
I've watched this movie twice so far and plan on seeing it again (and again). I truly felt transported by it. Everyone keeps comparing Ad Astra to 2001 and Apocalypse Now, but the movie it most reminded me of is Solaris, which is another introspective sci-fi movie I love.
That sound like a very specific preference. Great to hear the film scratched that itch.
This reviewer’s taste in movies must be Transformers. I could describe to you about 20 different themes and lessons I got out of this movie.
-Relationship between Man and God
-How far are you willing to sacrifice your Earthly attachments in the pursuit of discovery or career?
-Relationship between Man and Father
-Love and meaningful relationships are the essence of life, that even something as crazy as a venture into space near Neptune can’t be better than loving your family or wife.
-A deep study on human emotion and the suppression of those emotions.
-The use of silence and white noise to amplify emotion and feeling in a film.
This was a masterpiece aside from the unrealistic science sometimes
This reviewer isn't sure what the issue is here)) Maybe the commenter didn't actually watch the video? Because the reviewer loved the film, and mentioned the themes that stood out to her the most, as much as it was possible without spoilers.
Impression Blend ohhhh I’m so sorry...I just realized I posted this on the wrong video. I finished watching a review of the movie on IGN’s channel and the reviewer was god-awful. I wanted to share my thoughts on this one but only on the themes. Not you as a reviewer, sorry about that. I’ll delete the comment!
So dying to see the arc rings of Neptune in imax. The cinematography alone has me sold. Great review.
Thank you! I regret not seeing this in IMAX, to be honest, I bet it looks amazing.
Just saw it this afternoon, and really liked the way the movie was put together but didn't like the premise of the ending. My favorite in this 'genre' was Sunshine. It studied madness, but in the end, the sun shone brightly, the mission was successful and people looked forward with hope.
That is the basic principle of Ad Astra, that space aficionados (and scientists) should contemplate the possibility that no alien intelligence exists or that we will never find it. On the one hand it is terrifying, but on the other it may tell us how unique humanity is. When faced with this possibility, Clifford MacBride (TL Jones) goes insane, unable to deal with the ramifications. The scene in which his pain and madness over this are fully revealed to his son is the most powerful in the whole film. Such news would make me totally insane as well.
Just watched this movie and I Loved It. Loved your video as always. I was dragging my feet on watching this move 'cause, I didn't like the trailers. Your review got me to watch it on Hulu. In the past I loved going to movie theaters. Slowly over the years for one reason or another, I went less and less. From the past seeing at least one movie a week to two or three. Now, I rarley go reliying on cable and various streaming. Keep on keepin' on.
It's here in Tbilisi. You've sold me. Dark meditative science fiction? Am I the only person who thinks Marianna must see and review "Dark?" Marianna go Dark. (Great shirt by the way.)
Haven't finished season 2 yet, but I watched season 1 when it came out a couple of years ago and LOVED it!
@@ImpressionBlend Season two takes it into another realm of quality altogether. They are really slowly building it right. (
Thus far.)
Season 2 of Dark is incredible! You need to do a Season 1/2 review if you’re interested in that at all!
I would watch a Dark review from Marianna any day every day.
@@ImpressionBlend Saw it. Totally agreed with you. Some thoughts on early examples of dark meditative sci-fi: Silent Running (1972), Robinson Crusoe on Mars (!964), The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957), La Jetee (1962), The Last Man On Earth (1964). Later examples: Gattaca (1997) You have to have seen this!!!, Dark City (1998). Ditto. (And obviously you've got 2001 & Tarkovsky's Solaris down.)
I just saw the movie this weekend and I loved it. Thanks for the great review. The film was extremely interesting and exciting, with some very appealing visuals in space. Similar films I love are Interstellar, The Martian, and Inception.
I absolutely loved that the film didn't bother itself too much with the other characters. The main story was always about Brad Pitt's character, I believe adding more story about the supporting characters would have detracted from the main theme of the film.
That was one of the best review lately I have seen. Professional and enjoyable, but I think they almost only used CGI and green screen.e
Did anyone notice that Brad and Tommy were never in the same shot?
It was always the side of his helmet etc, but it looks to me their scenes were shot separately.
Maybe I’m crazy but there were rumours during shooting that they didn’t see eye to eye.
Spot on review IMO. You get it and also get what audience will enjoy it more vs those who won’t.
Thank you ))
I enjoyed it as well. I don't think I've seen a movie that structurally reminded me more of Apocalypse Now, and that's not a complaint. Pitt's voice over felt like a definite call back to Martin Sheen's. Like Apocalypse Now I thought this was great despite the last act not being as good as the lead up. Loved your review, and if this type of film is your jam you need to see High Life. If you haven't already.
I loved Solarus and Apocalypse Now but have ambivalent thoughts on Ad Astra.
To me it tells one very specific man's journey to Neptune to see his father. The main character was not an "every man." So, it may not have mass appeal.
Also the Antimatter blasts being sent to Earth seemed like it was tacked on to the plot, and the shootout with the moon buggies seemed of nearly irrelevant and only included to show a little bit of action.
The movie is about a lone man dealing with his loneliness, finding out that humans are alone in the universe.
Not very inspiring.
Rick Ragan That really summed it all up. And it has the ability to induce sleep in 80% of it's viewers.
Great review. I like the way you speak, your use of language. I hope you write fiction someday.
Thank you so much, OMG
I love the "Lonely Astronaut" genre. And my favourite in recent time is LOVE (2011) I promise you It has everything you say you are looking for in Sci-Fi.
This is all I needed to go watch it. My favorite introspective sci-fi movie (and novella) is Arrival/Story of your Life. I definitely need more stuff like that in my life.
I love "Arrival" so much, cry like a baby every time I watch it
Saw this in Imax and it was wonderful. Which was your favourite Brad Pitt performance from this year - Roy McBride or Cliff Booth?
As much fun as Cliff Booth is to watch, Roy McBride is a more complex and emotional performance.
I agree. Cliff was a lot of fun but in terms of narrative, Roy was more investing and relatable
My problem with this film is that it has the aesthetic of deep meaning but conveys little to no meaning in its actual story and the filmic realization. It serves as a blanket for the projections of the audiences, if they are willing to give it. I wasn't willing, I expect a movie to do more of the work itself. It should provoke an emotional response from me by functional storytelling instead of letting me do all the work and then taking the credit for it.
100% agree. The direction the actors was weak too. I'm a Brad Pitt fan but I thought the emotional depth of the actors just wasn't there.
the meaning, the message, was at the end "We're all we've got"
@@omar66277 I didn't mean a meaning conveyed by dialogue alone but something that is conveyed via the story. What you are referring to is replaceable. Let's say the line in the dialogue would have been "do more of what you love" then the movie wouldn't have been that different, right? Tacked on dialogue doesn't fix story problems.
@@bened22 I see what you're saying and I thought so too at first, but when I thought about more, it wasn't just the line. Roy's father lived not understanding that message and Roy's journey throughout the movie was to find him and deliver that message. Finally, Roy's monologue ends with "I will live and love", as opposed to just working, the mission..etc. Hope you see what I mean.
@@omar66277 Yeah, I guess so. It's still very subtle though. That's what I mean: You can find meaning in it but you really have to look for it. Which is fine, just not my cup of tea.
I disagree. That moon rover scene is seriously awesome and best scene in the movie! :)
Or just a western plotline that happens to be in space. I literally saw a movie about a man who goes out west looking for the father he idolized and might still be alive, only to discover a grumpy old man living in a shack who never cared about him or his mother.
That's pretty accurate ))
I think I just might watch this for $5 Tuesdays at AMC tomorrow. I need my yearly Sci-Fi Thriller fix.
Enjoy!
I love sci fi and with that being said I am going to give this a shot when I get chance great review
I hope you love it! Thanks!
I was honestly shocked at how much this movie had an impact on me, this is definitely getting in the "ultimate modern sci-fi dramas" club with Arrival, The Martian, Interstellar, Ex-Machina, Annihilation, Moon, Blade Runner 2049, etc.
We are living during some exciting times for sci-fi fans!
@@ImpressionBlend Oh boy yeah, Lucy in the sky seems like it's getting a mixed reception, but I'm still excited to see it.
Nice. Can't wait for the 3-hour director's cut!
Haha right?
@@ImpressionBlend I'm serious: We spend no time exploring - or just appreciating the majesty of - each locale. Neither do we spend enough time lingering with each of Roy's journey-characters to really affect his arc. And judging from all the trailers, there's much that was cut.
Glad you loved it too Marianna
Impression Blend I love you're Ad Astra (2019) Movie Review
Sounds like my type of movie. Looking forward to seeing this one.
I hope you love it as much as I did!
don't get your hopes up.
Love this movie and those Stephen Kings books on the shelves, is it for his birthday?
It's a coincidence, I just reorganized my bookshelves
Great review. I also LOVED the movie. Its almost painfully free of the usual dramatic over-stylized bullshit that we see in most movies. Its raw and strict to hard science as much as possible. FANTASTIC. I hope Pitt gets some awards for this.
Thank you! He probably won't, but you never know.
I really liked this movie as well. The only issue I had with the movie were the inner monologues. I actually would have possibly preferred none at all.
It's funny how I was introduced to Apocalypse Now in the same week as watching this movie, because it borrows some elements like the exploration of the unknown and the effects of isolation. Obviously it does enough to be it's own unique thing, like Brad Pitt's emotional journey, it just felt like a weird coincidence watching it.
Apparently, the director actually mentions "Apocalypse Now" as one of his inspirations for this film, so you're right on the money there!
Brad does a good job. The problem is that the movie is empty. Is it pretty? Yes. Does it have a good score? Yes. None of this works for me because the story is crap. The problem is that once it becomes obvious that the movie is going to be exactly what all of the faults foreshadow this movie to be, you just want it to end. Then, when it ends, you feel like you just wasted 2 hours.
Also, I've seen it a bunch of times before, starting in the early 80's with The Black Hole.
Whats the next film your looking forward to Marianna
This kind of reminded me of Solaris crossed with Apocalypse Now, freaking loved this movie so much
Its structure is basically "Heart of Darkness in Space".
Apocalypse Now was the movie I thought it most resembled.
This fucking movie was amazing. It's not just about searching for his father. It shows you how crazy people can get when they're so far away from Earth. When you're alone in the universe far away at distant planets. This is a very real problem in real life, at least for the space station, cause we haven't gone much further, astronauts are trained to learn how to cope with the loneliness of being in space at space station for long periods. Humans need to see other faces. We are social creatures. And this movie does a good job to convey the vastness and nothingness of space and the universe. Albiet it's in a sci-fi way. With way more technology than we have now. But still a great movie 👌 I have always loved space and this movie like I said again does an amazing job of conveying the nothingness out there.
Thoughtful review.
Personally, I'd like to see an even longer edit of this film.
octagonproplex Sarcasum?
@@AllenFreemanMediaGuru
No.
Seeing this tomorrow. Movies like this don’t come often. Can’t wait
I hope you love it as much as I did!
Impression Blend Saw it yesterday and YES loved it. Gravity meets Apocalypse Now. The symbolism of birth during the underwater scene, the letting go of his father, literally and mentally hit all the right notes for me. I did want a bit more dialogue from the scene with his father but that’s getting picky
Nice review agree on most parts except the final score. My favourite similar movie would be Moon. :-)
My favorite contemplative sci-fi film is 2001: A Space Odyssey. It's also pretty much my favorite film, period. I really liked Ad Astra, obviously.
Can't go wrong with "2001"!
90% of people in this movie show no emotion (or common sense). Also as you said this is an unhappy story and nobody wins in the end. But the special effects are very good.
this movie is very similar to Solaris, I recommend watching that if you interested.
I do like contemplative films of this nature, but when they keep asking the same questions and explore the same themes, it just loses the integrity it sets up and can veer towards hollow pretension. I don't generally watch Brad Pitt films for him, but the premise intrigued me, and thanks to your recommendation I'm breaking with my usual routine of Friday night flicks and going to watch this next Wednesday.
I think we've passed the time when we watched movies for the actors-it's all about the directors these days, and certain subgenres. However, there are a few actors out there who are likely to push me towards watching a film (though not 100%), and Brad Pitt is one of those few.
Impression Blend I know what you mean. I’ve not missed a Egerton film yet and I’ve not watched Rocketman only because I figure the censors here will butcher it. I guess for me it’s premise first, acting talent and then reviews. I don’t really consider directors much as I don’t know that many of them. I just figure that if the blurb is creatively interesting and there are good actors, it’ll be a good film in almost anyone’s hands.
I've never thought i'd ever say this, but for the first time ever Brad Pitt can actually act.
It literaly took a divorce and a rehab but he's finally able to show emotion on that otherwise stonerface of his.
So Mr Pitt please do more of these projects in the future.
its not hard to act emotionless and wooden lol
Hi Marianna.. Do you think the “action scenes” are a bit over the top and detracts from the tone of the film? There are some reviewers who felt that way even if they liked the film in general.
BTW, you look great😊, and love the NOS4A2 🧛♂️ plate behind you.
I thought that the action scenes weren't really about what was happening in them, they were a commentary about human nature, and specifically about men. Just like every other scene in the movie.
This vs Moon which is better? I loved Moon btw.
Curious about this too haha i love Moon
Ooo, that's TOUGH! I gave "Moon" a higher rating and I stand by it because I think the story is a stronger there, but "Ad Astra" kills with the visuals and the variety of locations, and they're both amazing films.
Arrival is near the top of introspective sci-fi films and Interstellar of course as well
Absolutely! One of my all-time favorites.
I loved the acting, visuals, world building, and the clear destination of its plot.
Things I didn't like were the abundance of narration, and while the two brief action sequences are independently thrilling, they feel completely unnecessary to the plot. There is one extremely on the nose moment of dialog during the end that took me right out of the moment.
Yea, I can understand, narration is always a hit or miss thing. It didn't bother me here, but there are SO many films where I was annoyed by it.
Wow. I wasn't even thinking about going to see this in the theater. I still haven't seen "It."
This sounds more interesting to me right now.
I hope you love it!
wonderful review
Thank you!
Couldn’t agree more, I loved it!
Yesss
I really loved this movie Brad was great in it loved the cinematography the music one of the best of the year
I find it a little bit depressing, I still think that both Gravity and Moon are far better astronauts movies, this movie is very similar to Solaris , I recommend watching that, the acting wasn't bad but the plot was weird and the writing felt average at best, the sound editing and design was one of the best I ever heard.
Max Richter is a genius and I’m so glad they shot this on 35mm, it looks gorgeous
Ok that why it had grain on IMAX
Enceladus Yeah it naturally has grain cus it’s shot on film stock
I let out quite a laugh when you said, I would NEVER! Because ..... it's Bradley Pitt!
I get it!😌😂😂😌
I STILL can't believe your making more reviews again. Because I love EM'! I do very much wonder if you ever saw SpiderMan far from home & if you enjoyed it. Please comment Mari!
😁🕸️🕷️
No regular MCU for me past "Endgame". I'll probably still check out a few here and there, but mostly likely on streaming. Sorry!
How is this similar to Interstellar and Arrival?
I'm planning to see it now after this review
Let me know what you think! Enjoy!
Personally I wouldnt recommend, unless you ardently love slowburn movies & stories, & if you love drama it is probably for you...some things were not concluded unf.
It's a movie about humans, being humans.
The scenery was wonderful though.
Her review is very positive, im happy she liked it & was her cup of tea.
But Im an avid sci-fi & drama fan, i like different genres intermixed, it was alright for what it was, just a very realistic story of how things would really be like in similar situations, if you are looking for anything beyond, this is not the kind of movie unf.
But you should see it if you have a good feeling about it :)
One more thing; I love this type of film but don’t see a great deal of them being made. Solaris; Moon; Gattaca; 2001; Blade Runner; Gravity. Any others I should see in this genre??? Cheers
I mean... One of my favorite films of all time: Denis Villeneuve's "Arrival" ))
@@ImpressionBlend Embarrased to say I fell asleep half way through The Arrival. :-) I was watching at home late night so I have to give it another shot.
Been super excited for this one since seeing the trailer. I’ve heard people call it a masterpiece as well as incredibly disappointing.
Definitely going to see this
That's how you know the movie makes strong choices - people's reactions are divided.
Impression Blend I couldn’t agree more. Hearing divided thoughts only gets me more excited
This movie was really relaxing . Liv Tyler didn't look like Liv Tyler. I need to watch Moon with Sam Rockwell.
I too was thinking of Moon while watching it :)
It was pretty linear, not many ups or downs
You definitely should watch it! It's a great film!
Thanks so much for the review :-) I love Brad Pitt and this movie was gorgeous,, but that's where I have to stop because I lost interest :-( too much 2001 and not enough ALIEN!!!! Lol
Saw it. Loved it.
I'm planning to watch
I liked it. Didn't love it. I think I will grow to love it after multiple watches. It took me three watches to give Blade Runner 2049 5 star's.
I loved this movie.
The only fault of this movie: it's too good for the general audience!
too dumb you mean.
I’m an emotionally disconnected potential astronaut candidate in the military, with a degree in Astronautics, and can relate completely to Brad Pitt’s character and the themes in this movie... but the movie was boring garbage. Blade Runner 2049 and First Man were a million times better.
I also like the moon part！
Well said, wonderful movie.
I liked this review as well as the movie. It's unfortunate that others are finding it to be boring and it may suffer at the box office.
Thank you! I'm not surprised, to be honest. The trailers sell it as a thrill ride, people don't know what they're walking into.
2001 a space odyssey wasn't a huge box office success but it has become a cult classic since.
Ad Astra is not quite up there but it's pretty good
I liked Interstellar and Arrival and Contact.
Sounds like my type of movie.
I have a good feeling that there's an amazing version of this movie that has an extra 30 minutes or so. Just based on how sequences are edited, and how some cast members feel underutilized, it makes me think that after Disney bought Fox they asked for the movie to be cut down. It's good that this version is still worth a lot of praise, but it definitely makes me wonder...
You know, I was thinking that too. It just seemed strange to cast some of these people in these small roles, so I'm assuming there are scenes we didn't see. There is definitely stuff in the trailer that wasn't in the film, so I'm curious if there will be a director's cut on the bluray.
if you are looking for another introspective film: Demolition, with Jake Gyllenhaal
That's a line from Solaris - we don't really want to explore space, we just want to spread Earth over it.
It definitely takes some mood inspiration from "Solaris"
@@ImpressionBlend I am not sure i want to watch it. It's JUST my genre, right tailor-made for me, but Tommy Lee Jones looks exactly like my dad and I sense I do have daddy issues, especially when it comes to the dread of mortality or the horror of realizing we might not only be alone out here, but designed to be impossibly lonely ...
Very little CGI F/X? Maybe I saw another new movie called Ad Astra?