I am Indian Muslim i request Mr yair qadhi to please make special dua for all Indians, so that we may live in harmony with each other with our brothers and sisters who are not in faith
I am an indian muslim and i watch yasir sir s videos he explains everything so nicely.... May ALLAH protect all the muslims around the world 🌎 Ameen ..
JazakAllah khair Sheikh! May Allah swt bless you immensely! May you and your family be with rasulullah Sallahu alayhi wa salam in the highest of paradise ❤
Never have I heard of the narrations on conquest of India discussed in such an amazing manner as Sh.Yasir Quadhi has done here..May Allah preserve this Shaykh..He is blessed with the inimitable style of convincing things leaving no room for confusion..Prayers from India...
@@rpdsouza1957 apostate prophet twist alot of thing to get views and $$ amnot saying he is all wrong but he twist alot unlike 'pakistani mulhid" go watch pakistani mulhid he is way better than apostate prophet .
@Sayandip Mandal an ex muslim doesn't give an automated expertise on Islam. Someone who knows Arabic with some basic knowledge in Islam is good enough to dismantle RUclips self proclaimed Islamic scholars.
@@agilenjeyamraj1739 then go and dismantle christian prince. His channel name is arabian prophet. Destroy him. He takes live skype calls from any abdool
@@avikumarirm I already did, the guy muted me because I kept it logical and rational, despite him insulting my prophet(pbuh), I yet went ahead and made the call. The guy makes a lots of mistakes while reading. You want to know about Islam, go to the library not RUclips or skype.
What a concise and structured lecture it was. He explained very clearly as well as maintained the sequence of the lecture. This is the best lecture on it I have ever heard. JajaKallahu Khairan.
As an Indian Muslim, I have always heard the Hindutva brigade speaking of Gazw-e Hind. But never ever knew what it actually meant. Thankyou Sheikh Yasir Qadi, for explaining it in simplistic terms. What is happening in India is truly moving towards genocide, not in immediate future. But 'otherization' of Muslims has become law, which was never the case until now. Please include us in your Dua.
Very detailed and clear explanation. As Muslims it’s our obligation to spread love and care for all humanity . May Allah almighty guide us to the right path. Indeed Allah almighty is knowing wise.
He made a point I kept seeing comments online by Pakistanies, that "thanks for Pakistan and all" they don't know, Muslims living in India are the one who gonna face it, you sit and comments and sleep in peace where we daily meet with all types of culture and beliefs and try our best to make harmony between us, I hope you guys understand this important point, stop mocking your brother and sister, be grateful if u have nice life, we're grateful whatever we have.
@@kingsnm8561 pakistan is conspired al sindh. You fool. Pakistan was never part of hind. Look at the maps from the time of the prophet and you will see that hind started from sindh. This area which pakistan is on was never part of hind.
@Syed Ahmed o my here we go again. Another donkey who thinks he knows his history. Al sindh is not a provenice if hind. During the time of the prophet al sindh was a big country which covered punjab kpk blochistan and kashmir. It is a small provenice now. But at that time it was a big land mass. You a total donkey.
Thank you brother for the sane voice, love peace and compassion is the need of the hour, all faiths lead to same God and we must live in peace and harmony help and respect each other, if only the subcontinent can reunite and prove to the world the harmony of religions it will be a dream come true
SubhaanAllah! A beautiful lecture Sheikh! JazakAllahu Khaira! Lotsa love from Pakistan! May Allah protect and uplift our Muslim brothers and sisters in India (and the rest of the world) love you all for the sake of Allah!
TY Sheikh for clearly mentioning The Ghazwa Hind episode as over in the past. Many so called Pakistani scholars are spreading lies to bake their own breads. We Indians Muslims are Happy with our Hindu brothers and live peacefully. A few incidents because of our Fanatic Government doesn't paint all of Indians as bigots. We Indian Muslims are proud and stand by other Indians irrelevant of Religion, caste creed. The Protests against the Government by all Indians proves that loud and clear.
*Mawashi * Geri* why you being so nationalistic? There is no nationalism in islam. Indian muslims are also your brothers and sisters in islam. Don’t hate them just cuz you hate their country.
@Vk Tri Yeah I will say it is literally hiltler reign happening In India who is modi Ji and Amit shah they consider their God as golwalker the leader of rss who wrote in his book "we and our nationhood defined " it's nothing wrong to kill Muslims especially he said muslims to make this India as hindutva or Hindu rashtra this rss and bjp is always been making a split between the unity of hindu and Muslims in the past history ...a country which cannot produce ministers with degrees is asking me to show the documents I'm Indian that too birth certificate our previous generation is not common to birth certificate in india so will this modi put all in detention centers... GDP is declining everyday but they are not considered about it unemployment and poverty have increased but they don't consider these...... Hitler said ...Hitler said I sure no jews will be affected by numberg law and killed 6lakh jews Same modi and Amit shah said no muslims will be affected by this CAA.... What mind games are they playing Leading my Indian Constution and democracy for sale.... This country is not his dad's property...
@Vk Tri That's what I'm saying population is growing poverty is increasing ..and so much problem they don't find solutions for this but they do some nonsense in the name of religion.. Even some hindus who have no hearts are saying muslims as terrorists and illegal immigrants and other things in you tube comment section these hindu fanatics have no heart... I'm not saying wrong Hinduism or religious Hindus because they region I come from is south of India Tamil nadu here hindud are only supporting us guarding us and raising voice.. ....i fear for my country I don't knew what will this government Do in this 4years 5months..... Where will my India go.......... ..spliting and ruining the unity of hindu and Muslims and have no issue do with it...
I am an Indian Muslim. And believe me without a doubt what the sheikh says is a 100% right except that Bahadur shah Zafar was not sent to Nepal. Many people use this topic to belittle muslim brother and sisters. They use brute force and power. The current ruling party has pumped so much of hatred that even our coworkers have given to such explanations. Trust me brothers and sisters. The ground reality is very different. Even if you make a slight different opinion, the right wing will make allegations and theories that puts people behind bars. Please make sincere duas for all of us. While I am writing you all must be aware of the pogrom that happened in north east Delhi. I have been there for a day and let me tell you Alhamdulillah we have more than what we need. Jazak Allah khair sheikh. I wish more scholars spoke about this tyranny!
Being a Kashmiri Muslim we are eagerly waiting for it..Internal tensions of India are giving us some relief from heavy presence of armed forces in Kashmir.
@@numairarshad8942 man kashmir aren't just related to kashmir due to occupation which effect the economy alot they also migrate to different countries I know many who live in gulf countries...
Br.Yasir, thanks for this great intellectual discourse. What that Indian woman at Yale told you is totally true. And the good news is, what's happening now in India against CAA & NRC, is reviving the same unity among the Indians. Jai Hind!
I am also from India only 90% who are protesting are Muslims,especially in the smaller cities.the majority hindu community has a innate hatred for Muslims, that's why they have elected a pogromists like modi to power you are just blinded by your nationalism. Islam zindabaad, hindustan murdabaad
That’s a lie that Muslims can’t live in peace with others, you’ll be a fool to believe in fairytales. Don’t be like the ignorant ones think deep be wise.
@@AshwaniKumar-cl9bs idk man, there needs to be a moment as there was during the time of brits, fortunately people are beginning to see the truth and standing for it, i hope they get more support from the rest of citizens and may the oppressors reach their fate soon.
You are good ,so you are knowledgeable. I believe in the future Pakistan country will not remain as a country we broke into three parts and India will expand its area. I believe in Hindu Muslim unity but not at the price of freedom of religion lost. I believe India will be a superpower in next 10 years. वंदे मातरम जय हिंद। सभी भारतवासियों को मेरा नमस्कार।
@@qayyumkhan5658 I'm indian Muslim too ...bhai kuchh toh sharam karle....desh se gaddari hamara islam nahi sikhata ....lanat hai bro tere jaise ke upar
I'm from South India (Kerala) and I had never heard about this hadith. And I realise that not many of us here know about it. I came to know about this through a friend who's working in New Delhi. I agree with Dr. Yasir Qadhi that it could be talking about the dynasties up until the Mughals. But also it's not impossible to happen in the future too. As to my understanding, the timeframe in the hadith maybe focusing on the end times. For a group to be with Eesa (As), it would be in the future. Because when Eesa (As) was sent to the Jews, nobody accepted him as the Messiah despite having disciples. Moreover, Eesa (As)'s mission is yet to be accomplished which is why there's a Second Coming. With this theory, the Gazwa Al Hind could be a future event when you read the hadith altogether. Allah knows best.
Most Muslims don't know about ghazwe hind. I didn't knew about ghazwe hind either, I heard it from a hindutva fascist, these right wing hindutva andbkats talk about ghazwe hind more often than Muslims do.
To be technical, the Mughal empire was dead by 1750. All that was left was a figurehead title and a seat in Agra. Another side note- Biryani came from Iran. The Mughals spiced it up and made it better. A lot of our culture is turco-persian.
Dear Dr Yasir Qadhi. I respectfully disagree with some of your Analysis. Past conquests of Hind do not follow the Islamic interpretation of Jihad. They were done for personal reasons, for land, wealth etc. As you mentioned, the people of H Dynasty became Ismaili so how has Allah bestowed such greatness to people who did not prescribe to Islamic Jihad? Those people used these Hadith for their own purpose in order to get people to fight for them in their personal cause. Gazwa Al Hind will happen when the Muslim people of Hind are pursecuted and call for the Muslim nations to come and help free them from tyrani. I also believe, after much investigation, that the two incidents mentioned in the Hadith of the arrival of Jesus and Gazwa Al Hind will take place either together or one after the other in close succession. This is, of course, just an educated opinion as no one knows for sure when these two incidents will actually take place. Can you shed some light as to why you think the other conquest of Hind were according to Islamic Law of Jihad please. I respect your views and knowledge greatly. God bless you.
As a student of knowledge, I agree with you and I am NOT Indian or a Pakistani to even be biased or take a side. The Sheikh was very careful and wise about his answers! The reason why he did it that way was explained after 29:30 of the video. That's all I can say والله أعلم
@@seekfactsnotfiction9056 I agree with his sentement and also agree that we should not make a big deal of this to start wars. I think all humans are equal, be they Indian, Pakistani or anyone in the world. War is wrong for personal gain. Dr YK last few minutes were correct, agreed. But answers, no matter how right, cannot be based of incorrect information otherwise it discredits the good mesaage intended. I believe knowing about Gazwa Al Hind will prevent false people from getting others blindly following falsehood. How do you think many good people fall into the trap of bad agencies like ISIS, al Khaida, Danish etc. Knowledge is power.
@@asahibGee Falling into the western narrative stories is itself very dangerous as well! Jumping into thw band wagon and repeating the same stories that we've been told to believe! I would suggest all of us to study the more to not fall for the indoctrination! SABOTEURS by Thomas Hor The Nameless War by Archibald Ramsay Treacherous Alliance: The Secret Dealings of ... معضلة التنمية الاستعمارية (محمد شعبان صوان) Killing Hope: US Military and CIA Interventions Since World War II - Updated Edition Weapons of Mass Instruction
@@seekfactsnotfiction9056 I hope that was a joke. I honestly think my views are completely opposite to the doctrine we are constantly feed by the media. Books you've suggested are way to long; I rely on James Bond 007 for my information. :) Fact is, the plans for everything happening today was made around 1871, way before World War I. They are too rich and too clever for us to stop them so it will need, as mentioned by Dr Qadhi, prophet Eisa (RA) to help the Islamic world. Somehow, we Muslims will all fight each other and almost destroy all followers of Islam before he arrives. May Allah guide us all to do the right thing. Amen.
If they were for personal reasons then explain why 99% of the ancient temple in north India have their idols beheaded? You haven't visited any ancient temple so i challenge you to find a major ancient temple in the state of Madhya Pradesh that does not have their idols beheaded.
Islam divides humanity. Those who can't live as atheists should find some other ideology, for the sake of world peace. Don't just blindly follow the religion that you were accidentally borned into. Ex-muslims of India like Sachwala, Exmuslim Sahil, Zafar Heretic etc are doing some amazing work.
I got one question as well: is there a hadith about prophet muhammad SAW asking ALLAH for more time for the Ummah? and allah gave 1/2 a day extra. So the ummah had 1 day but ALLAH gave 1/2 day extra because our beloved propbet said 1 day is not enough. ALSO, if that hadith is true then what does 1 day equals to in our time?
SUMMARIZED NOTES 📝 Ghazwa E Hind There are 3 Ahadith in Sunan Al Nasa'i which are actually 2 hadiths since two from the three of go back to same transmitter so are considered to be one (which is in Sunan Al Nasa'i- Book Of Jihad - Battle of Expedition of India - Hadith 89 ,90 , 91 or 3173, 3174, 3175 from Sunan Al Nasa’i) The most authentic books of Hadiths are Bukhari and Muslim No.3 in terms of Authenticity is Sunan Al Nasa'i No.3 in terms of Ease of Use is Sunan Abu Dawood No.3 in terms of usefulness is Jami’ Al Tirmidhi In the Book of Jihad, Under the Chapter The Battle Expedition of India, Hadith 89 and 90 have a similar text which go back to one Sahabi Jabr Ibn Ubaidah who is narrating from Abu Hurairah عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، قَالَ وَعَدَنَا رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم غَزْوَةَ الْهِنْدِ فَإِنْ أَدْرَكْتُهَا أُنْفِقْ فِيهَا نَفْسِي وَمَالِي فَإِنْ أُقْتَلْ كُنْتُ مِنْ أَفْضَلِ الشُّهَدَاءِ وَإِنْ أَرْجِعْ فَأَنَا أَبُو هُرَيْرَةَ الْمُحَرَّرُ Jabr Ibn Ubaidah narrates only these two Hadiths which put a question mark on him and making a verdict on the authenticity of the Hadith becomes difficult. Sheikh Albaani classified the Isnaad is weak Similar Hadith in musnad Imam Ahmed which adds Sindh as well to Hindh and is narrated from Abu Hurairah with Imam Ahmed being the 4th person Imam Ahmed - Yahya Ibn Ishaq - Baraa - Hasan al Basri - Abu Hurairah But Hasan Al Basri did not meet Abu Hurairah RA, (Some narrators would drop some person in the Isnaad for trust reasons- this is a type of tadlees which reduces the authenticity) Generally two different weak chains of a same hadith make the hadith a bit stronger (Hasan li Ghairihi) but this cannot be done because of the mentioned reason above. A different Isnaad of the same Hadith is mentioned in the kitab al jihad ibn abi Asim (contemporary of imam ahmad) -Hadith 291 Abd Al samad - hashim ibn Saeed - kinana ibn nubai (Mawla Saffiyah RA)- Abu Hurairah RA This chain is also weak but now we have 3 different chains for the same hadith (one from Nisa’i, one from Imam Ahmed, one from Ibn Abi Asim) The hadith 91 or hadith 3175 from Sunan Al Nasa'i seals the fate عِصَابَتَانِ مِنْ أُمَّتِي أَحْرَزَهُمَا اللَّهُ مِنَ النَّارِ عِصَابَةٌ تَغْزُو الْهِنْدَ وَعِصَابَةٌ تَكُونُ مَعَ عِيسَى ابْنِ مَرْيَمَ عَلَيْهِمَا السَّلاَمُ The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: ' There are two groups of my Ummah whom Allah will free from the Fire: The group that invades India, and the group that will be with 'Isa bin Maryam, peace be upon him. Narrated from the Prophet SAW by Thauban who was the freed slave of the Prophet SAW and became a khadim of Prophet SAW and he narrates over 90 narrations and mainly he narrates on the signs of day of judgment However this has already occurred At the times of Umar Ibn Al Khattab RA and Uthman RA ships were sent to Sindh region to to see the conditions back there At the times of Hajjaj Ibn Yousuf Al Thaqafi, he sent an Expedition to India which were recorded in a book Chachnama written by muslims in Arabic which talks about the history of India and Muslims ( we only have a persian translation of the original work) Muhammad Ibn Al Qasim was sent by Hajjaj Ibn Yousuf and he ruled for few years and came back, meanwhile they developed the city of Mansoora, ancient city of Multan etc. Habbarith dynasty then took over but they became Ismailis, was taken over by Mahmud Ghasnavi then Ghurid Dynasty then Delhi Sultanate then Babar then Mughals then the Britishers come The muslims who came did not colonize but the muslims who came developed India and adopted the culture and became Indians, there was never any religious tension between Muslims and Hindu until the British.
Assalamu alaikuk It was heart warming to see non muslims in india form a protective barrier for namaz today. Love from pakistan..we did qunoot at friday prayers
@lol is laughing dont be a hatred spewing religious bigot. You are no different from a low class sanghi. Burden to the society and to the secular society. Im a indian muslim too but not an idiot with such a vile mind.
Masha Allah, he is a good Sheikh with deep understanding. But things like India's relations with israhellll, oppression against Muslims are drawing a pattern about Ghazwa-e-Hind, yet we make dua that everything becomes easy one day...
*What's the name of that lady who proposed that there was no religious tension between the Hindus and Muslims in India up until the British reached the subcontinent?*
The british brought Press and news started travelling from one region to other and people started know what attrocities Islam is perpetuating on others and how similar these are to their own
I am a Punjabi and I am a muslim. All I want to tell both sides Pak and India that I am not an outsider neither I am an Arab or Afghani. My ancestors were probably Hindus who converted to Islam, and that is true with the huge population of Indian and Pakistani Muslims. I don't understand when the extremist on both sides don't understand and acknowledge who they are.
I went to thar a few yrs back with a few scholars involved in setting up masjids and schools right in the middle of the dessert...take it from me...I saw christians, hindus and muslims all chilling inside masjids all fine...pakistan zindabad muslims zindabad.
You will find scholars in india and europe america who will not interpret gazwa hind and process of qyamat so my basic question apart from these ahadees hasan or greeb what will be the process of coming of djjal imam Mehdi? Will they come unexpectedly?
Don't worry my Indian brothers & sisters, we Muslims in Afghanistan and around the world will one day (by the Will of Allah SWT) unite and come get rid of the Hindu's and the extremists. The ones on حَقّ will prevail and the ones on باطل will be destroyed إن شاء الله P.S. (we will make it round 5 if we have to) May Allah (Swt) guide us all and help us to stay steadfast on our deen so that we may purify ourselves and truly unite to help the oppressed ones! (May Allah swt make it easy for them)
@Redd Bull A Government elected by the people where no corruption/bribery is involved. A united Government that follows the Islamic model wholeheartedly.
All the scholars should get together and debunk and reject once and for all, bogus hadith such as this and age of Aysha. That will be service to the prophet and Islam.
Can someone explain why does the hadeeth mention 2 Armies will be blessed,1 who would accompany Eesa bin Mariyam elaih salaam and the other that will go to Hind? Why wouldn't this mean it's talking about the end of times?
Jazak Allah Khairan ya shaikh for this explanation...could you also highlight the narration which mentions the remaining army of this ghazwa will join Isa (AS) as this is the narration which is oft repeated in Pakistan.
19:55 and he was killed at that young age.. The politics of hajaj bin yousef was a great hurdel in the way of mujahideed like ibn Qasim and those conquered spain..
Shaykh Yasir Qadhi is severely mistaken in few places especially when he says that "a book that is considered to be the first book ever written by Muslims of India regarding the history of India from the Muslim perspective, this is called the Chach-nama, the Chach-nama, I'm not inventing the name because it talked about the Chach-dynasty and I'm inventing that is real. There was a dynasty call the 'Chach dynasty'".[1] The book in question, 'Chach-nama', isn't a history book as has been rightly identified by Manan Ahmed Asif. He writes, “Chachnama is not a translated history from Arabic into Persian. Rather it is a work created in thirteenth-century Uch and reflects the political and social concerns of Qabacha's court in Sind [...] Chachnama does not fit the genre of conquest narrative, by examining it against the earliest Arabic conquest texts.” [2] It would be better if Muslims do not use Chach-nama - a 13th century book - as an 'history-book' especially for the conquest of Sind when we have something better i.e., the Arabic and Persian historical sources. For example the 9th century book of Al-Balādhurī "Kitāb Futūh Al-Buldān", is a more reliable source when is comes to the conquest of Sind; it states the following giving almost the same background the Shaykh gave, “al-Ḥajjāj appointed Muḥammad ibn-Hārūn ibn Dhirā‘ an-Namari, and during his administration the king of the island of Rubies sent to al-Ḥajjāj some women who were born in his country as Moslems, their fathers, who had been merchants, having died. He wanted to court favour with al-Ḥajjāj by sending them back. But the ship in which they were sailing was attacked by some of the Mid of ad-Daibul in the barks (bawārij), and was captured with all that was in it. One of the women, who was of the tribe of the banu-Yarbū‘, cried out, “O Ḥajjāj!” al-Ḥajjāj heard of this and exclaimed, “Here am I.” He sent to Dāhir asking him to set the women free, but Dāhir replied, “Pirates over whom I have no control captured them.” So al-Ḥajjāj sent ‘Ubaidallāh ibn Nabhān to raid ad-Daibul, but he was killed. Then al-Ḥajjāj wrote to Budail ibn Ṭahfah al-Bajali, who was in ‘Umān, ordering him to go against ad-Daibul. But when Budail met the enemy, his horse ran away with him, and the enemy surrounded him and killed him. [...] Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḳasim. Then al-Ḥajjāj put Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḳasim ibn-Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḥakam ibn abu-‘Ukail in charge, during the reign of al-Walīd ibn ‘Abd-al-Malik. He raided as-Sind.” [3] Note, "the island of Rubies" mentioned above refers to modern-day Sri-lanka. Chach-nama is a problematic text with much unhistorical rather fictional material - it has been used by Hindutva-vaadis and Islamophobes to malign Muslim-rulers of the olden times especially Muhammad ibn Qasim. Similarly, the Shaykh is wrong when he states that Bahadur Shah Zafar II was exiled to the land of Nepal, when actually he was exiled to "Rangoon" which is known as "Myanmar" (Burma) today. As William Dalrymple notes the end of the “last Mughal” Bahadur Shah Zafar II in the following words, “Separated from everything he loved, broken-hearted, the last of the Great Mughals died in exile in Rangoon on Friday, 7 November 1862, aged eighty-seven.” [4] ________________ [1] The Ahadith on Ghazwa-i-Hind | Ask Shaykh YQ #43. ruclips.net/video/idLAsxM_DsU/видео.html , Timestamp: 17:00 - 17:20. [2] Manan Ahmed Asif, A book of conquest: the Chachnama and Muslim origins in South Asia, (London: Harvard University Press, 2016), pp. 20-21. [3] Philip Khūri Ḥitti, The Origins of the Islamic State: Being A Translation From the Arabic Accompanied With Annotations, Geographic And Historic Notes of the Kitāb Futūh Al-Buldān, (New York: Columbia University, 1924), vol. 2, pp.215 - 216. [4] William Dalrymple, The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi, 1857 (London: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2006).
This is beautiful. JazakallahKhair and thank you so much for this. Though is it really true that there was no Hindu Muslim strife pre colonialism as a general rule? Weren't some Mughal rulers religious fanatics ? Just asking because I'm not sure
That's overstretch to say there was no religious tension in pre-british india. I mean, i don’t believe hindus were not outraged when Aurungzeb demolished their temple and built a mosque over it as a token of humiliation. Riots were non-existent because muslims were ruling and had upperhand.
21:27 Having done a PhD, and as a masters' student myself. I expected you to do better research. The Britishers took over from Sikhs and Marathas and other Dharmic Empires who had already ended the Mughal rule in India. After the 3rd Anglo-Sikh and 3rd Anglo-Maratha Wars Btw ! Secondly, Your statement about Indian culture being unrecognizable if not for the Islamic influence is laughable at best. All our national mottos are in Sanskrit, which is the de facto civilizational language btw. Other than that check out our national flag, the national anthem and the national song. One dish Biryani and a few monuments don't define the cultural ethos of a land. Therefore, India is a civilizational land of the Vedic Culture. The Sanskrit and the Sanskriti expounded therein. And I don't really know if Ghazwa-e-Hind ever happened or not, because there were many areas of India still resisting and outside the mughal control, even during its zenith under Akbar. So, by definition, you could not achieve what was written in your texts. Further, you know it is impossible or unthinkable for you or any muslim country to challenge India, so in an attempt to sheepishly run away, you say that "Oh it already happened under the mughals, we don't have to do it, pheww, thank allah !" So yeah, Not sure about Ghaze e Hind, but pretty sure about something else, which indeed is a lived reality for the people of India - Jai Hind !
It's so nice of you discuss these hadeeths in detail, but Shaykh isn't it your responsibility to analyze the very concept that forms the core of the (matan) of any of hadeeth and see if it directly goes against the Qur'an. In this case isn't the Qur'an very clear that Allah does not allow invasion of lands whose people have not invaded your land and property? Are Muslims allowed to wage war against countries at their will?
That protected and blessed group of people going to India could be referring to the spiritual leaders who came in early medieval period like Moinuddin Chisti(R.A.)
Some Scholars do interpret hadiths as per their own understanding affected by their environment. It's enough there is mentioning of Ghazva e hind. So it's true. ALLAH knows details . Let's see
Sunnan e Nisai # 3177 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "There are two groups in my Ummah whom Allah has saved from Hell. One group will be the one who will invade India and one will be with Jesus son of Maryam.
Al-Silsila-tus-Sahiha Hadees # 3516 The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: There are two groups of my ummah whom Allah saved from the fire .One group will fight against the Hindus, and the other will fight with jesus son of Maryam.
@@AbdulQadeer-zm6oz you don't make sense as you mention fight against Hindu? Hindu is not a religion but a geographical term rather , people living in India are all Hindu ( be it from any religion or none) please don't spread hate , such incorrect interpretation and misleading and manipulated statement only ruin communal harmony don't do such things , do something productive.
I am Indian Muslim i request Mr yair qadhi to please make special dua for all Indians, so that we may live in harmony with each other with our brothers and sisters who are not in faith
Only comment that made sense. Thank you ma'am
@@MohitJoshizinga what u doing here bro
Video had hind in the title ... It got my interest.
@@MohitJoshizinga oh , to deklo bro , kya pata dimaag khul jaay thoda sa
Khula he hua hai bro.
I am an indian muslim and i watch yasir sir s videos he explains everything so nicely.... May ALLAH protect all the muslims around the world 🌎 Ameen ..
I'm from India and I'm amazed and happy to hear that Rasoolullah s.a.w. mentioned my land.😍😍😍😍
@Roopa Saryu the prophecy was regarding islam entering the heart of people in India.
Not through genocide.
But through preaching the ideology of Islam
It's a weak hadith.
@Roopa Saryu look at chat everyone saying it fake
One of he Sahaba of ur prophet (PBUH) was from Kerala his name was Cheraman Perumal
@@lb8965 yeah i heard the same... Sometimes yaseer qadhi make mistakes
JazakAllah khair Sheikh! May Allah swt bless you immensely! May you and your family be with rasulullah Sallahu alayhi wa salam in the highest of paradise ❤
Never have I heard of the narrations on conquest of India discussed in such an amazing manner as Sh.Yasir Quadhi has done here..May Allah preserve this Shaykh..He is blessed with the inimitable style of convincing things leaving no room for confusion..Prayers from India...
Read all about the ghazwa i Hind in the link below ruclips.net/video/tUqNNMhsYdo/видео.html
@@rpdsouza1957 apostate prophet twist alot of thing to get views and $$ amnot saying he is all wrong but he twist alot unlike 'pakistani mulhid" go watch pakistani mulhid he is way better than apostate prophet .
@Sayandip Mandal an ex muslim doesn't give an automated expertise on Islam. Someone who knows Arabic with some basic knowledge in Islam is good enough to dismantle RUclips self proclaimed Islamic scholars.
@@agilenjeyamraj1739 then go and dismantle christian prince. His channel name is arabian prophet. Destroy him. He takes live skype calls from any abdool
@@avikumarirm I already did, the guy muted me because I kept it logical and rational, despite him insulting my prophet(pbuh), I yet went ahead and made the call. The guy makes a lots of mistakes while reading. You want to know about Islam, go to the library not RUclips or skype.
What a concise and structured lecture it was. He explained very clearly as well as maintained the sequence of the lecture. This is the best lecture on it I have ever heard. JajaKallahu Khairan.
As an Indian Muslim, I have always heard the Hindutva brigade speaking of Gazw-e Hind. But never ever knew what it actually meant. Thankyou Sheikh Yasir Qadi, for explaining it in simplistic terms. What is happening in India is truly moving towards genocide, not in immediate future. But 'otherization' of Muslims has become law, which was never the case until now. Please include us in your Dua.
Protect yourselves, get weapons and be prepared. Know that if you die defending that you die as martyr, don't fear rats.
They're trying to play divide and rule. So be cautious..
@@codingblues3181- As a non -Muslim, is this what your 'religion' teaches, cunning man?
Isn't protecting myself is my right?
@@autumnicleaf You want him to stand there? He's Gona fight and win insha'Allah
Very detailed and clear explanation.
As Muslims it’s our obligation to spread love and care for all humanity .
May Allah almighty guide us to the right path. Indeed Allah almighty is knowing wise.
Care for all humanity . Good joke 😂
Really love how he ended it with that advice to calm the situation down. InshAllah i will take that on.
He made a point I kept seeing comments online by Pakistanies, that "thanks for Pakistan and all" they don't know, Muslims living in India are the one who gonna face it, you sit and comments and sleep in peace where we daily meet with all types of culture and beliefs and try our best to make harmony between us, I hope you guys understand this important point, stop mocking your brother and sister, be grateful if u have nice life, we're grateful whatever we have.
@@kingsnm8561 pakistan is conspired al sindh. You fool. Pakistan was never part of hind. Look at the maps from the time of the prophet and you will see that hind started from sindh. This area which pakistan is on was never part of hind.
@@starlight6152 why are there Shiva temples in Pakistan ?
@@vmo5260 pakistan allows religious sites for any minority
@Syed Ahmed check al sindh and Al hind. According to islamic triditions. Pakistan is al sindh and india is al hind.
@Syed Ahmed o my here we go again. Another donkey who thinks he knows his history. Al sindh is not a provenice if hind. During the time of the prophet al sindh was a big country which covered punjab kpk blochistan and kashmir. It is a small provenice now. But at that time it was a big land mass. You a total donkey.
Thank you brother for the sane voice, love peace and compassion is the need of the hour, all faiths lead to same God and we must live in peace and harmony help and respect each other, if only the subcontinent can reunite and prove to the world the harmony of religions it will be a dream come true
Probably the best lecture to hear on this topic especially in the current situation
May Allah bless Shaik Yasir Qadhi
Your Answers
ruclips.net/video/fVS1eHOy6LU/видео.html
SubhaanAllah! A beautiful lecture Sheikh! JazakAllahu Khaira! Lotsa love from Pakistan! May Allah protect and uplift our Muslim brothers and sisters in India (and the rest of the world) love you all for the sake of Allah!
M from India ...may Allah SWT make it easy for all our fellow Muslim brothers Nd make us steadfast on our Deen 🤲
Firr yeh mat bolna keh tumko Gaddar kyu bola jata hai!
@@dalitshiv834 u have a point
@@dalitshiv834 gaddaro ko gaddar hi bolenge yelog pislam ke liye apni maa behne bhi bechde
TY Sheikh for clearly mentioning The Ghazwa Hind episode as over in the past. Many so called Pakistani scholars are spreading lies to bake their own breads. We Indians Muslims are Happy with our Hindu brothers and live peacefully. A few incidents because of our Fanatic Government doesn't paint all of Indians as bigots. We Indian Muslims are proud and stand by other Indians irrelevant of Religion, caste creed. The Protests against the Government by all Indians proves that loud and clear.
*Mawashi * Geri* why you being so nationalistic? There is no nationalism in islam. Indian muslims are also your brothers and sisters in islam. Don’t hate them just cuz you hate their country.
Gazway hind not against hind
It's war for protect hind from terrorism
lots of love and homage from pakistan,your work for muslims have no parrallel keep feeding our minds
Love from Pakistan illegally occupied Kashmir 🇮🇳♥️ I'm an Indian Muslim appreciate your work
Please donot bring in politics here. All Muslims are same without any country difference
The best lecture I have ever seen in my life
Correction : Bahadur shah Zafar was exiled to Burma !
Rakhain to be specific.
@@propheticadmirer1701 Bahadur Shah Zafar II died in Yangoon not Rakhain state
Who behead zafar shah sons . presents as food to his kids head's
@@athrai
It's Rangoon
@@BBClMRANAHMEDMA yangoon is rankoon
Ghazwa-e-Hind? No Apology! - ruclips.net/video/MsL8CdRtmjo/видео.html
you are a great teacher Yasir bhai! you gave me a new perspective to 'Thank you Jinnah' campaign...
Thanks for this video and calming the temperatures down.
Regards, from India.
May Allah safeguard our Muslim friends and family in India. The situation is really tensed
@Kim Jong Un
I don't think so I'm from India..
@Vk Tri
Yeah I will say it is literally hiltler reign happening In India who is modi Ji and Amit shah they consider their God as golwalker the leader of rss who wrote in his book "we and our nationhood defined " it's nothing wrong to kill Muslims especially he said muslims to make this India as hindutva or Hindu rashtra this rss and bjp is always been making a split between the unity of hindu and Muslims in the past history ...a country which cannot produce ministers with degrees is asking me to show the documents I'm Indian that too birth certificate our previous generation is not common to birth certificate in india so will this modi put all in detention centers... GDP is declining everyday but they are not considered about it unemployment and poverty have increased but they don't consider these...... Hitler said ...Hitler said I sure no jews will be affected by numberg law and killed 6lakh jews
Same modi and Amit shah said no muslims will be affected by this CAA.... What mind games are they playing
Leading my Indian Constution and democracy for sale....
This country is not his dad's property...
@Vk Tri
That's what I'm saying population is growing poverty is increasing ..and so much problem they don't find solutions for this but they do some nonsense in the name of religion.. Even some hindus who have no hearts are saying muslims as terrorists and illegal immigrants and other things in you tube comment section these hindu fanatics have no heart... I'm not saying wrong Hinduism or religious Hindus because they region I come from is south of India Tamil nadu here hindud are only supporting us guarding us and raising voice.. ....i fear for my country I don't knew what will this government Do in this 4years 5months..... Where will my India go.......... ..spliting and ruining the unity of hindu and Muslims and have no issue do with it...
Vk Tri Umm, we don’t need you to explain to us what NRC and CAA are. We know very well what they are. Do not assume the other person to be ignorant.
Stop watching Ndtv n everything will be fine
JazakAllah Sheikh
Jazaak Allahu Khair Shaykh for the simple and clear explanation.
The British looted even the word LOOT from India. That summarises them
This also means that whoever invented the act also invented the act, otherwise Brits would have had a word from their own vocabulary.
Jazakallahu khair for explaining this topic for us so beautifully and clearing the topic for us Indian muslims may allah bless u
Firr yeh mat bolna keh tumko Gaddar kyu bola jata hai!
I am an Indian Muslim. And believe me without a doubt what the sheikh says is a 100% right except that Bahadur shah Zafar was not sent to Nepal. Many people use this topic to belittle muslim brother and sisters. They use brute force and power. The current ruling party has pumped so much of hatred that even our coworkers have given to such explanations. Trust me brothers and sisters. The ground reality is very different. Even if you make a slight different opinion, the right wing will make allegations and theories that puts people behind bars. Please make sincere duas for all of us. While I am writing you all must be aware of the pogrom that happened in north east Delhi. I have been there for a day and let me tell you Alhamdulillah we have more than what we need. Jazak Allah khair sheikh. I wish more scholars spoke about this tyranny!
Leave India, why you hanging in kaffirs land
Well explained with wisdom. Jazakallah khaira Sheikh
We are Ready for Gazwai Hind
I am from Indian occupied kashmir
😑
👍🤣
You are ready? Did you listen to what the Shaykh said? It has already happened, my friend.
@@sarasu8699 no dude its ongoing.. some of the ghazwa e hind hadith involve Hazrat esa as
@@sarasu8699 it is going to happen not happened.Muslims will conquer India.
Although Muslim youth don't know the real cause of Allah ,but thanku for creating peace .
Being a Kashmiri Muslim we are eagerly waiting for it..Internal tensions of India are giving us some relief from heavy presence of armed forces in Kashmir.
😍😍
@@sheikhtajamul5662 How are you watching this video since there"s no internet in Kashmir?
@@numairarshad8942 tats none of ur business!
@@sheikhtajamul5662 kyu bhai ??? agar youtube pr rubbish content dekhoge to yhi hoga
@@numairarshad8942 man kashmir aren't just related to kashmir due to occupation which effect the economy alot they also migrate to different countries I know many who live in gulf countries...
Jazak Allah Shaikh v informative lecture ... pray for all the ppl across the globe who are oppressed! May Allah bring ease to them
As long as we carry the Quran in our hearts and the constitution in our pocket, we don’t have to fear anyone.
This needs to be heard by the masses of India
Br.Yasir, thanks for this great intellectual discourse.
What that Indian woman at Yale told you is totally true. And the good news is, what's happening now in India against CAA & NRC, is reviving the same unity among the Indians. Jai Hind!
I am also from India only 90% who are protesting are Muslims,especially in the smaller cities.the majority hindu community has a innate hatred for Muslims, that's why they have elected a pogromists like modi to power you are just blinded by your nationalism.
Islam zindabaad, hindustan murdabaad
@@Abdullah-zj2sj And the majority Muslims want to destroy our religion and civilization
I agree to a large extent. How ever why can not Muslims live with peace with others.
That’s a lie that Muslims can’t live in peace with others, you’ll be a fool to believe in fairytales. Don’t be like the ignorant ones think deep be wise.
@@humblebee8334 not a fairy tail I've experienced it.
@Autumn it's not that only Muslims percentage has increased..Whole Indian population has increased
Bhediye aur bakare ko story malum hai ? Kisi bhi bahane se bhediya bakaro marta hai.
@@pruthvikgowdabs7531 jab majority banaegi naa tab batanaa
Very good and relevant suggestion to Pakistani community
Allhamdulillah! An insightful lecture!
Are u single
Sapne na Dekho aj Bharat me RSS Hain tumhari gazwa e hind ki khwahis pori na ho sakegi
Allah bless brother dr yasir qadhi
@21:33 - fact correction.
Not to Nepal, bt deported to Rangoon (Burma) prison
yes!!
Couldn't agree more on how Brits played divided and rule.....
People are still playing the game but the blind ones are still following them because they share the same faith
@@shh11111 how do we stop all this..it hurts when people says Muslims are not safe in India
@@AshwaniKumar-cl9bs idk man, there needs to be a moment as there was during the time of brits, fortunately people are beginning to see the truth and standing for it, i hope they get more support from the rest of citizens and may the oppressors reach their fate soon.
@@shh11111 Ameen🙏
@LORD OF INFINITE REALITIES blah blah
Zazakallahu khairan sheikh.....
Alhamdulillah 🇮🇳
@Error -404 Ameen!!
Error 404 !! I know it's sounds weird but I also want Sooo... 😑
U've any idea or plan? 🤔
alhamdulillah , he holds a lot.of knowledge
M Pakistani
This topic attracts me
Taqabbal Allah...
Jazakum Allah khair
Jazakallah khair
this was really informative as always
You are good ,so you are knowledgeable. I believe in the future Pakistan country will not remain as a country we broke into three parts and India will expand its area. I believe in Hindu Muslim unity but not at the price of freedom of religion lost. I believe India will be a superpower in next 10 years. वंदे मातरम जय हिंद। सभी भारतवासियों को मेरा नमस्कार।
Hahhahahahhaha 😂
I'm indian but gazwa e hind hoke rahega😂😂☝️
@@qayyumkhan5658 I'm indian Muslim too ...bhai kuchh toh sharam karle....desh se gaddari hamara islam nahi sikhata ....lanat hai bro tere jaise ke upar
Love from India ❣
Alhamdulillah from adam alaihisalam country india
Thank you for the lesson and the points you raised at the end.
I'm from South India (Kerala) and I had never heard about this hadith. And I realise that not many of us here know about it. I came to know about this through a friend who's working in New Delhi. I agree with Dr. Yasir Qadhi that it could be talking about the dynasties up until the Mughals. But also it's not impossible to happen in the future too.
As to my understanding, the timeframe in the hadith maybe focusing on the end times. For a group to be with Eesa (As), it would be in the future. Because when Eesa (As) was sent to the Jews, nobody accepted him as the Messiah despite having disciples. Moreover, Eesa (As)'s mission is yet to be accomplished which is why there's a Second Coming.
With this theory, the Gazwa Al Hind could be a future event when you read the hadith altogether. Allah knows best.
Most Muslims don't know about ghazwe hind.
I didn't knew about ghazwe hind either, I heard it from a hindutva fascist, these right wing hindutva andbkats talk about ghazwe hind more often than Muslims do.
This Gazwa e Hind term is same as Akhand Bharat Both are never gonna happen
Fucking traitor, poda myre
To be technical, the Mughal empire was dead by 1750. All that was left was a figurehead title and a seat in Agra.
Another side note- Biryani came from Iran. The Mughals spiced it up and made it better. A lot of our culture is turco-persian.
Dear Dr Yasir Qadhi. I respectfully disagree with some of your Analysis. Past conquests of Hind do not follow the Islamic interpretation of Jihad. They were done for personal reasons, for land, wealth etc. As you mentioned, the people of H Dynasty became Ismaili so how has Allah bestowed such greatness to people who did not prescribe to Islamic Jihad? Those people used these Hadith for their own purpose in order to get people to fight for them in their personal cause. Gazwa Al Hind will happen when the Muslim people of Hind are pursecuted and call for the Muslim nations to come and help free them from tyrani. I also believe, after much investigation, that the two incidents mentioned in the Hadith of the arrival of Jesus and Gazwa Al Hind will take place either together or one after the other in close succession. This is, of course, just an educated opinion as no one knows for sure when these two incidents will actually take place.
Can you shed some light as to why you think the other conquest of Hind were according to Islamic Law of Jihad please. I respect your views and knowledge greatly. God bless you.
As a student of knowledge, I agree with you and I am NOT Indian or a Pakistani to even be biased or take a side. The Sheikh was very careful and wise about his answers! The reason why he did it that way was explained after 29:30 of the video. That's all I can say والله أعلم
@@seekfactsnotfiction9056 I agree with his sentement and also agree that we should not make a big deal of this to start wars. I think all humans are equal, be they Indian, Pakistani or anyone in the world. War is wrong for personal gain. Dr YK last few minutes were correct, agreed. But answers, no matter how right, cannot be based of incorrect information otherwise it discredits the good mesaage intended. I believe knowing about Gazwa Al Hind will prevent false people from getting others blindly following falsehood. How do you think many good people fall into the trap of bad agencies like ISIS, al Khaida, Danish etc. Knowledge is power.
@@asahibGee Falling into the western narrative stories is itself very dangerous as well! Jumping into thw band wagon and repeating the same stories that we've been told to believe! I would suggest all of us to study the more to not fall for the indoctrination!
SABOTEURS by Thomas Hor
The Nameless War by Archibald Ramsay
Treacherous Alliance: The Secret Dealings of ...
معضلة التنمية الاستعمارية (محمد شعبان صوان)
Killing Hope: US Military and CIA Interventions Since World War II - Updated Edition
Weapons of Mass Instruction
@@seekfactsnotfiction9056 I hope that was a joke. I honestly think my views are completely opposite to the doctrine we are constantly feed by the media. Books you've suggested are way to long; I rely on James Bond 007 for my information. :)
Fact is, the plans for everything happening today was made around 1871, way before World War I. They are too rich and too clever for us to stop them so it will need, as mentioned by Dr Qadhi, prophet Eisa (RA) to help the Islamic world. Somehow, we Muslims will all fight each other and almost destroy all followers of Islam before he arrives. May Allah guide us all to do the right thing. Amen.
If they were for personal reasons then explain why 99% of the ancient temple in north India have their idols beheaded? You haven't visited any ancient temple so i challenge you to find a major ancient temple in the state of Madhya Pradesh that does not have their idols beheaded.
MashAllah ustaad g ...May Allah bless you Ameen
Aameen🇮🇳
Nishant Khan deshdrohi chutiya
Firr yeh mat bolna keh tumko Gaddar kyu bola jata hai!
Islam divides humanity. Those who can't live as atheists should find some other ideology, for the sake of world peace. Don't just blindly follow the religion that you were accidentally borned into. Ex-muslims of India like Sachwala, Exmuslim Sahil, Zafar Heretic etc are doing some amazing work.
I got one question as well: is there a hadith about prophet muhammad SAW asking ALLAH for more time for the Ummah? and allah gave 1/2 a day extra. So the ummah had 1 day but ALLAH gave 1/2 day extra because our beloved propbet said 1 day is not enough.
ALSO, if that hadith is true then what does 1 day equals to in our time?
Its approx 1500 years
Where did you get this hadith from?
What it is it plz quote the references
I recently seen that... Super scary we don't have much left
@@BBClMRANAHMEDMA i have been hearing it from elders thats why i want to know if this hadith exists.
SUMMARIZED NOTES 📝
Ghazwa E Hind
There are 3 Ahadith in Sunan Al Nasa'i which are actually 2 hadiths since two from the three of go back to same transmitter so are considered to be one
(which is in Sunan Al Nasa'i- Book Of Jihad - Battle of Expedition of India - Hadith 89 ,90 , 91 or 3173, 3174, 3175 from Sunan Al Nasa’i)
The most authentic books of Hadiths are Bukhari and Muslim
No.3 in terms of Authenticity is Sunan Al Nasa'i
No.3 in terms of Ease of Use is Sunan Abu Dawood
No.3 in terms of usefulness is Jami’ Al Tirmidhi
In the Book of Jihad, Under the Chapter The Battle Expedition of India, Hadith 89 and 90 have a similar text which go back to one Sahabi Jabr Ibn Ubaidah who is narrating from Abu Hurairah
عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، قَالَ
وَعَدَنَا رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم غَزْوَةَ الْهِنْدِ
فَإِنْ أَدْرَكْتُهَا أُنْفِقْ فِيهَا نَفْسِي وَمَالِي
فَإِنْ أُقْتَلْ كُنْتُ مِنْ أَفْضَلِ الشُّهَدَاءِ
وَإِنْ أَرْجِعْ فَأَنَا أَبُو هُرَيْرَةَ الْمُحَرَّرُ
Jabr Ibn Ubaidah narrates only these two Hadiths which put a question mark on him and making a verdict on the authenticity of the Hadith becomes difficult.
Sheikh Albaani classified the Isnaad is weak
Similar Hadith in musnad Imam Ahmed which adds Sindh as well to Hindh and is narrated from Abu Hurairah with Imam Ahmed being the 4th person
Imam Ahmed - Yahya Ibn Ishaq - Baraa - Hasan al Basri - Abu Hurairah
But Hasan Al Basri did not meet Abu Hurairah RA,
(Some narrators would drop some person in the Isnaad for trust reasons- this is a type of tadlees which reduces the authenticity)
Generally two different weak chains of a same hadith make the hadith a bit stronger (Hasan li Ghairihi) but this cannot be done because of the mentioned reason above.
A different Isnaad of the same Hadith is mentioned in the kitab al jihad ibn abi Asim (contemporary of imam ahmad) -Hadith 291
Abd Al samad - hashim ibn Saeed - kinana ibn nubai (Mawla Saffiyah RA)- Abu Hurairah RA
This chain is also weak but now we have 3 different chains for the same hadith
(one from Nisa’i, one from Imam Ahmed, one from Ibn Abi Asim)
The hadith 91 or hadith 3175 from Sunan Al Nasa'i seals the fate
عِصَابَتَانِ مِنْ أُمَّتِي أَحْرَزَهُمَا اللَّهُ مِنَ النَّارِ
عِصَابَةٌ تَغْزُو الْهِنْدَ
وَعِصَابَةٌ تَكُونُ مَعَ عِيسَى ابْنِ مَرْيَمَ عَلَيْهِمَا السَّلاَمُ
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: '
There are two groups of my Ummah whom Allah will free from the Fire:
The group that invades India,
and the group that will be with 'Isa bin Maryam, peace be upon him.
Narrated from the Prophet SAW by Thauban who was the freed slave of the Prophet SAW and became a khadim of Prophet SAW and he narrates over 90 narrations and mainly he narrates on the signs of day of judgment
However this has already occurred
At the times of Umar Ibn Al Khattab RA and Uthman RA ships were sent to Sindh region to to see the conditions back there
At the times of Hajjaj Ibn Yousuf Al Thaqafi, he sent an Expedition to India which were recorded in a book Chachnama written by muslims in Arabic which talks about the history of India and Muslims ( we only have a persian translation of the original work)
Muhammad Ibn Al Qasim was sent by Hajjaj Ibn Yousuf and he ruled for few years and came back, meanwhile they developed the city of Mansoora, ancient city of Multan etc.
Habbarith dynasty then took over but they became Ismailis, was taken over by Mahmud Ghasnavi then Ghurid Dynasty then Delhi Sultanate then Babar then Mughals then the Britishers come
The muslims who came did not colonize but the muslims who came developed India and adopted the culture and became Indians, there was never any religious tension between Muslims and Hindu until the British.
I am an Indian Muslim
Assalamu alaikuk
It was heart warming to see non muslims in india form a protective barrier for namaz today.
Love from pakistan..we did qunoot at friday prayers
@lol is laughing i do agree with you that poorer hindu and sikh are good people
@Falcon Swoops yes why is this bad??
@Falcon Swoops .i heard this narration is weak.
@lol is laughing dont be a hatred spewing religious bigot. You are no different from a low class sanghi. Burden to the society and to the secular society. Im a indian muslim too but not an idiot with such a vile mind.
Masha Allah, he is a good Sheikh with deep understanding.
But things like India's relations with israhellll, oppression against Muslims are drawing a pattern about Ghazwa-e-Hind, yet we make dua that everything becomes easy one day...
*What's the name of that lady who proposed that there was no religious tension between the Hindus and Muslims in India up until the British reached the subcontinent?*
Romila Thapar
@@sadiqsd7800 Thank you!
@N G there were religious tensions but not in the scale that we see today.
The british brought Press and news started travelling from one region to other and people started know what attrocities Islam is perpetuating on others and how similar these are to their own
What thesis report exactly is it can any one give me the name of exact thesis report
If you are true muslim, you must read the book "Satanic Verses" by Salman Rushdie. I am in love with this book.
I am a Punjabi and I am a muslim. All I want to tell both sides Pak and India that I am not an outsider neither I am an Arab or Afghani. My ancestors were probably Hindus who converted to Islam, and that is true with the huge population of Indian and Pakistani Muslims. I don't understand when the extremist on both sides don't understand and acknowledge who they are.
Once you become Muslim your connection with your ignorant forefathers is dead. Your connection is with the muslimeen.
Okay that might be your family but thats not the case for everyone in Pakistan brother.
Very informative.
I went to thar a few yrs back with a few scholars involved in setting up masjids and schools right in the middle of the dessert...take it from me...I saw christians, hindus and muslims all chilling inside masjids all fine...pakistan zindabad muslims zindabad.
ruclips.net/video/bY4p39jeAVI/видео.html
You will find scholars in india and europe america who will not interpret gazwa hind and process of qyamat so my basic question apart from these ahadees hasan or greeb what will be the process of coming of djjal imam Mehdi? Will they come unexpectedly?
Don't worry my Indian brothers & sisters, we Muslims in Afghanistan and around the world will one day (by the Will of Allah SWT) unite and come get rid of the Hindu's and the extremists.
The ones on حَقّ will prevail and the ones on باطل will be destroyed إن شاء الله
P.S. (we will make it round 5 if we have to)
May Allah (Swt) guide us all and help us to stay steadfast on our deen so that we may purify ourselves and truly unite to help the oppressed ones! (May Allah swt make it easy for them)
Caution keep dreaming!!
@@mufizshaikh8439 Why? what's wrong with what I said?
If Muslims have right to live in Arabia.. Hindus have right to live in Hind.
@Redd Bull A Government elected by the people where no corruption/bribery is involved. A united Government that follows the Islamic model wholeheartedly.
Hindu who is pretending like Muslim , good try to make problem between Muslims and Hindus
All the scholars should get together and debunk and reject once and for all, bogus hadith such as this and age of Aysha. That will be service to the prophet and Islam.
Shabir ally is a famous speaker who is currently doing this.
Vegetable Biryani...Bidah..😂😂 that was just too good..Can't control LOL...
Eating biryani does not make one a muslim...
@@youshaahmed5999 RSS ka name suna Hain
@@anshulbhardwaj4038 haan RSS a terrorist organisation jisko islam aur muslims se inferiority complex and insecurity hai 😂
Inferiority no they are for hindu rights only it's a safeguard mechanism to defend India from radical islamic terrorism
@@anshulbhardwaj4038 Beta jitna tum bhadvu na zulm kiya hai musalamaanon par Ghazw e hind hokar rahegaaa... Teray mandr mai ghantiya ukad jaye ghi.
Can someone explain why does the hadeeth mention 2 Armies will be blessed,1 who would accompany Eesa bin Mariyam elaih salaam and the other that will go to Hind?
Why wouldn't this mean it's talking about the end of times?
Jazak Allah Khairan ya shaikh for this explanation...could you also highlight the narration which mentions the remaining army of this ghazwa will join Isa (AS) as this is the narration which is oft repeated in Pakistan.
@Ganga Din the question is directed to the noble shaikh...thanks
@@balafied lol good one
19:55 and he was killed at that young age.. The politics of hajaj bin yousef was a great hurdel in the way of mujahideed like ibn Qasim and those conquered spain..
But he whose balance ( of good deeds ) will be ( found ) light - Surat (Al - Qari ‘ah 101:8)
There are 2 types of fools in sub continent …. One waiting for Ghazwa-Hind other waiting for Akhand Bharath … which will never going to happen
Subhanallah
Shaykh Yasir Qadhi is severely mistaken in few places especially when he says that "a book that is considered to be the first book ever written by Muslims of India regarding the history of India from the Muslim perspective, this is called the Chach-nama, the Chach-nama, I'm not inventing the name because it talked about the Chach-dynasty and I'm inventing that is real. There was a dynasty call the 'Chach dynasty'".[1]
The book in question, 'Chach-nama', isn't a history book as has been rightly identified by Manan Ahmed Asif. He writes,
“Chachnama is not a translated history from Arabic into Persian. Rather it is a work created in thirteenth-century Uch and reflects the political and social concerns of Qabacha's court in Sind [...] Chachnama does not fit the genre of conquest narrative, by examining it against the earliest Arabic conquest texts.” [2]
It would be better if Muslims do not use Chach-nama - a 13th century book - as an 'history-book' especially for the conquest of Sind when we have something better i.e., the Arabic and Persian historical sources. For example the 9th century book of Al-Balādhurī "Kitāb Futūh Al-Buldān", is a more reliable source when is comes to the conquest of Sind; it states the following giving almost the same background the Shaykh gave,
“al-Ḥajjāj appointed Muḥammad ibn-Hārūn ibn Dhirā‘ an-Namari, and during his administration the king of the island of Rubies sent to al-Ḥajjāj some women who were born in his country as Moslems, their fathers, who had been merchants, having died. He wanted to court favour with al-Ḥajjāj by sending them back. But the ship in which they were sailing was attacked by some of the Mid of ad-Daibul in the barks (bawārij), and was captured with all that was in it. One of the women, who was of the tribe of the banu-Yarbū‘, cried out, “O Ḥajjāj!” al-Ḥajjāj heard of this and exclaimed, “Here am I.” He sent to Dāhir asking him to set the women free, but Dāhir replied, “Pirates over whom I have no control captured them.” So al-Ḥajjāj sent ‘Ubaidallāh ibn Nabhān to raid ad-Daibul, but he was killed. Then al-Ḥajjāj wrote to Budail ibn Ṭahfah al-Bajali, who was in ‘Umān, ordering him to go against ad-Daibul. But when Budail met the enemy, his horse ran away with him, and the enemy surrounded him and killed him. [...]
Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḳasim. Then al-Ḥajjāj put Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḳasim ibn-Muḥammad ibn-al-Ḥakam ibn abu-‘Ukail in charge, during the reign of al-Walīd ibn ‘Abd-al-Malik. He raided as-Sind.” [3]
Note, "the island of Rubies" mentioned above refers to modern-day Sri-lanka. Chach-nama is a problematic text with much unhistorical rather fictional material - it has been used by Hindutva-vaadis and Islamophobes to malign Muslim-rulers of the olden times especially Muhammad ibn Qasim. Similarly, the Shaykh is wrong when he states that Bahadur Shah Zafar II was exiled to the land of Nepal, when actually he was exiled to "Rangoon" which is known as "Myanmar" (Burma) today. As William Dalrymple notes the end of the “last Mughal” Bahadur Shah Zafar II in the following words,
“Separated from everything he loved, broken-hearted, the last of the Great Mughals died in exile in Rangoon on Friday, 7 November 1862, aged eighty-seven.” [4]
________________
[1] The Ahadith on Ghazwa-i-Hind | Ask Shaykh YQ #43. ruclips.net/video/idLAsxM_DsU/видео.html , Timestamp: 17:00 - 17:20.
[2] Manan Ahmed Asif, A book of conquest: the Chachnama and Muslim origins in South Asia, (London: Harvard University Press, 2016), pp. 20-21.
[3] Philip Khūri Ḥitti, The Origins of the Islamic State: Being A Translation From the Arabic Accompanied With Annotations, Geographic And Historic Notes of the Kitāb Futūh Al-Buldān, (New York: Columbia University, 1924), vol. 2, pp.215 - 216.
[4] William Dalrymple, The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi, 1857 (London: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2006).
Very interesting
This is beautiful. JazakallahKhair and thank you so much for this.
Though is it really true that there was no Hindu Muslim strife pre colonialism as a general rule? Weren't some Mughal rulers religious fanatics ? Just asking because I'm not sure
Aa. You ought to have mentioned the name of the Hindu lady who wrote the thesis and if a copy of the thesis would be available online. Please do.
Please make a full video / talk about the history of Islam in India !
Well said
That's overstretch to say there was no religious tension in pre-british india. I mean, i don’t believe hindus were not outraged when Aurungzeb demolished their temple and built a mosque over it as a token of humiliation.
Riots were non-existent because muslims were ruling and had upperhand.
21:27
Having done a PhD, and as a masters' student myself. I expected you to do better research. The Britishers took over from Sikhs and Marathas and other Dharmic Empires who had already ended the Mughal rule in India. After the 3rd Anglo-Sikh and 3rd Anglo-Maratha Wars Btw !
Secondly,
Your statement about Indian culture being unrecognizable if not for the Islamic influence is laughable at best. All our national mottos are in Sanskrit, which is the de facto civilizational language btw. Other than that check out our national flag, the national anthem and the national song. One dish Biryani and a few monuments don't define the cultural ethos of a land.
Therefore, India is a civilizational land of the Vedic Culture. The Sanskrit and the Sanskriti expounded therein.
And I don't really know if Ghazwa-e-Hind ever happened or not, because there were many areas of India still resisting and outside the mughal control, even during its zenith under Akbar. So, by definition, you could not achieve what was written in your texts. Further, you know it is impossible or unthinkable for you or any muslim country to challenge India, so in an attempt to sheepishly run away, you say that "Oh it already happened under the mughals, we don't have to do it, pheww, thank allah !"
So yeah, Not sure about Ghaze e Hind, but pretty sure about something else, which indeed is a lived reality for the people of India -
Jai Hind !
You forget about 1857 War of Independence. Don't shit your RSS teaching which is based on Colonialist Britain view.
@@mdfarhaanahmad7139 your gazwa e Hind is as true as being propagated by mulla in Pakistan
Bahadur Shah Zafar died in Rangoon Burma in exile and not in Nepal. There is an interesting book on him written by Dalrymple
Mughals were Muslims by name and non Muslims by Actions.
Dr.Qadhi did you not mentioned the Ghazwa ( 2nd. Ghazwa ) of India simultaneously with the expedition to Palestine headed by Jesus a.s?
Nope that was not the case. The two groups will be free from the Jahannam. There was no mentioning of both events occuring simultaneously.
It's so nice of you discuss these hadeeths in detail, but Shaykh isn't it your responsibility to analyze the very concept that forms the core of the (matan) of any of hadeeth and see if it directly goes against the Qur'an. In this case isn't the Qur'an very clear that Allah does not allow invasion of lands whose people have not invaded your land and property? Are Muslims allowed to wage war against countries at their will?
We Hindi, (Bangladeshi, Pakistanis,Indians....) love Byirhani! :-)
Pakistani are not hindi
H k lol Pakistan is hind stop hating yourself
Northern Pakistanis are khorasanis. Their indo Iranians full blooded aryans.
Jason Mary whos northern
Hmm what does mean?
Excellent brother, my intellectual thirst is quenched!
Your Answers
ruclips.net/video/fVS1eHOy6LU/видео.html
Assalamualaikum sir..can you please suggest me any hadith book for beginners ?
Read Riyad us Saliheen
Mishkatul Masabih
That protected and blessed group of people going to India could be referring to the spiritual leaders who came in early medieval period like Moinuddin Chisti(R.A.)
Assalam o Alikum. Can someone please provide me link for the thesis that Shaykh is talking about?
What it Hindus/Christians make a text that no Muslim would be left in Mecca
Some Scholars do interpret hadiths as per their own understanding affected by their environment. It's enough there is mentioning of Ghazva e hind. So it's true. ALLAH knows details . Let's see
I am an Indian Muslim and never heard of the word Ghazwa e hind before either Pakistani people or Sanghis mentioned it.
Sunnan e Nisai # 3177 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "There are two groups in my Ummah whom Allah has saved from Hell. One group will be the one who will invade India and one will be with Jesus son of Maryam.
Al-Silsila-tus-Sahiha Hadees # 3516
The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: There are two groups of my ummah whom Allah saved from the fire .One group will fight against the Hindus, and the other will fight with jesus son of Maryam.
@@AbdulQadeer-zm6oz you don't make sense as you mention fight against Hindu? Hindu is not a religion but a geographical term rather , people living in India are all Hindu ( be it from any religion or none) please don't spread hate , such incorrect interpretation and misleading and manipulated statement only ruin communal harmony don't do such things , do something productive.
@@one-bm6lz How did Hindustan get this title? (HINDUSTAN) Explain it
@@AbdulQadeer-zm6oz refer Wikipedia or just google it.
Allah bless brother yasir qadhi
Assalâmou 'anlaykoum,
Could you please recommend me a book, a good one, talking about the story between Indian muslims and Hindus ?
Thank you.
quran
You can check out Richard Eaton's books and lectures. Focuses mainly on Bengal region and other parts of India. But quite good in terms of history.
@maulick thakkar if you don't have any facts, then don't talk without any proof
Shuaab Nama is a very famous book
@maulick thakkar I know that, I am asking you if you have any proof that they are converted under the fear of sword
I hope you make an Islamic Museum or exhibit with your coin and artifact collection 😌