I Played Football using OLD-FASHIONED Rules

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 329

  • @KieranBrown
    @KieranBrown  Месяц назад +127

    Did you know about any of these rules??

  • @denilsonb1022
    @denilsonb1022 Месяц назад +485

    Bobby Endrick loves this video

    • @Ishmehta-h8o
      @Ishmehta-h8o Месяц назад +4

      Haha Ik I get it

    • @Qjx1208
      @Qjx1208 Месяц назад +2

      Fr

    • @bettyliasis7012
      @bettyliasis7012 Месяц назад +2

      Jesus loves you turn to him 💕he died for you💕

    • @bettyliasis7012
      @bettyliasis7012 Месяц назад +1

      @@Ishmehta-h8o Jesus loves you turn to him 💕he died for you💕

    • @bettyliasis7012
      @bettyliasis7012 Месяц назад

      @@Qjx1208 Jesus loves you turn to him 💕he died for you💕

  • @Ma_Wukong
    @Ma_Wukong Месяц назад +193

    We should bring these rules in every game Endrick plays to make him feel at ease.

    • @Mansoor6996asdfghjkl
      @Mansoor6996asdfghjkl Месяц назад +1

      Blue comments in RUclips before gta 6 💀

    • @flakey_rl
      @flakey_rl Месяц назад +2

      @@Mansoor6996asdfghjkldid I miss the update 💀

  • @chungnungachhakchhuak839
    @chungnungachhakchhuak839 Месяц назад +34

    2:16 bro turned into Lev Yashin

  • @adxs1k
    @adxs1k Месяц назад +169

    Any chance you can get 20 odd people to play a full game with these rules, pitch size etc all catered to the 1800's game?

    • @kirkkerman
      @kirkkerman Месяц назад +15

      I'd certainly imagine it's possible; here in the States we have a lot of groups that do recreations of 19th century "Base Ball"

    • @NeilLewis77
      @NeilLewis77 Месяц назад +1

      @@kirkkerman is 19th century baseball any good?

    • @kirkkerman
      @kirkkerman Месяц назад +5

      @NeilLewis77 I've never had the opportunity to go to a game, let alone play one, but it looks pretty fun! Besides the old timey aesthetics, the major difference is that with pitchers not throwing tough pitches and fielders not wearing gloves, it's a lot easier to score runs.

    • @Runningtaco
      @Runningtaco 24 дня назад

      @@NeilLewis77 i am sure you can find videos of it but look up the one with conan obrien it showcases the game while also being funny

    • @BallparkHunter
      @BallparkHunter 23 дня назад +1

      @@NeilLewis77 I played a few games, but it is men playing without gloves, catching the ball of the bounce for an out, and different bats and balls. The uniforms and others dressed in character is a lot of fun to watch.

  • @vastariner
    @vastariner 25 дней назад +11

    Two quirks of the initial laws:
    1. the ONLY free-kick was a REWARD for handball (the fair catch). There was no provision as to what to do after a foul, other than, if a goal were scored after a foul, it should not be counted. Then the game would re-start with (probably) a goal-kick;
    2. there was no provision for numbers per side, and often teams would arrange their sides based on who had turned up, plus with relative ability. Eleven per side was a rule of the first FA Cup, and some later tournaments (Birmingham Senior Cup for instance) started with a rule for 12 per side. Natural evolution had reached 11 or 12 as being the optimum number.

  • @RFResnick
    @RFResnick 18 дней назад +7

    According to rule 7 on the plaque (10:21), a goal was scored on a shot between the posts and “under the string.” So, indeed there was a height limit for a goal.

  • @spancherBob
    @spancherBob Месяц назад +24

    It was also worth saying that football and rugby come from the same root. They are siblings, were very similar but separated. And how different they are now.

    • @namesdron3516
      @namesdron3516 28 дней назад

      Exactly

    • @adrianb2066
      @adrianb2066 25 дней назад +1

      And Australia rules football

    • @volemar
      @volemar 25 дней назад

      To admit, we have even rugby separated - union and league codes. Especially, I have to point that football could have gone in the same two codes' direction when there was a schism (in the terms of paying salaries to players) during the same time period as rugby had.

    • @louisvalentino6685
      @louisvalentino6685 24 дня назад +2

      And American football

    • @James_Byron
      @James_Byron 23 дня назад +4

      ​@@louisvalentino6685not a real sport

  • @pointguard909
    @pointguard909 28 дней назад +21

    This makes Australian Rules Football make much more sense

    • @SormonAusPol
      @SormonAusPol 26 дней назад +2

      Yeah you can see how AFL and Galic both evolved from this.

    • @MartinTilsed
      @MartinTilsed 26 дней назад

      ​​@@SormonAusPol Australian Rules were written about 8 years earlier and are the earliest rules still played

    • @SormonAusPol
      @SormonAusPol 26 дней назад +4

      @@MartinTilsed True but the idea of using your hands seems to have been somthing removed by Football, limited by Galic and Expanded by AFL.

    • @MartinTilsed
      @MartinTilsed 26 дней назад +1

      @@SormonAusPol Association got rid of the catching. Australian football dropped the offside. Gaelic rules written in the 1880s were based off the Australian rules and included some of the identical rules. Bought from the Vic goldfields or an amazing coincidence considering they were word for word

  • @danpreston564
    @danpreston564 Месяц назад +6

    The monument lists the 1848 Cambridge rules, not the 1863 FA rules.

  • @maxlane1897
    @maxlane1897 Месяц назад +3

    I remember when you did this vid in like 2016 or something and I loved it thanks for making another one

  • @backstagerm5733
    @backstagerm5733 16 дней назад +3

    When I was a kid, in the case the crossbar was missing, the rule was "you can score as high as the goalie can reach with a decent effort"

    • @57Javier747
      @57Javier747 14 часов назад

      It seems the natural measure to me

  • @jpsuominen
    @jpsuominen Месяц назад +56

    Gutta-percha is a sticky, gum-like substance from the Gutta-percha tree. Could possibly have been used for enhanced grip soles or moulded into studs of some sort?

    • @Ishmehta-h8o
      @Ishmehta-h8o Месяц назад

      Probably because back then they used more natural stuff

    • @Osman_badrul3482
      @Osman_badrul3482 19 часов назад

      Getah perca in malay

  • @ModelAAA90
    @ModelAAA90 Месяц назад +9

    I was honestly hoping for a full on 11v11 with these rules. That would’ve been CHAOTIC. 😆

  • @adiuntesserande6893
    @adiuntesserande6893 22 дня назад +2

    This is before the split between the rugby-descending sports (rugby union, rugby league, and North American football) and association football was entirely complete, ruleswise. The catches, dropkicks, fair catches, and free kicks seem to still be quite entwined in this era.

  • @Kevynuk
    @Kevynuk 19 дней назад +2

    The monument commemorates the 1848 Cambridge Football rules. It has nothing to do with the 1863 FA rules. The rules written on the monument are the 1856 Cambridge Rules, which were similar to the 1848 rules, which have now been lost. The video shows rule seven which says there is a string for a crossbar. The 1848/1856 Cambridge rules had an offside rule similar in principle to the modern offside rule. However, this had been abandoned by 1863. The main reason for this was that, "in the excitment of the game", it was difficult to adjudicate if a player was just onside or just offside (no VAR then). The 1863 FA rules had a very different offside rule. Ironically, the FA brought in a new offside rule similar the olf Cambridge offside rule in 1866.

  • @therealAZLN
    @therealAZLN 24 дня назад +1

    The "Free kick after a fair catch" is a rule deep in the rulebook of the current NFL rulebook, which of course is itself a byproduct of association football and rugby football. In the context of an NFL game, it's different, but theoretically after a punt (which you described as being allowed to kick a ball after holding it) is fair caught, the team who fair caught the ball is allowed to make a free kick. It's very rare in the NFL but sometimes happens.

    • @afuzzycreature8387
      @afuzzycreature8387 21 день назад

      oh if that were to happen I'm sure there would be a near riot, the only reason I could think of would be like a punt with one second left and you were absolutely sure you could kick it out of bounds, either case, I see the coach having an aneurysm

  • @s0l0r1d4
    @s0l0r1d4 26 дней назад +2

    I've been waiting for someone ro make that video since ever! Thank you
    btw, the game with these rules are still used to this day in street matches here, we play on concrete though

  • @madcrewgames8406
    @madcrewgames8406 Месяц назад +9

    I'd love to see a full match of people nowadays playing footballs with 1860's rule

  • @tom63700
    @tom63700 Месяц назад +5

    The coin toss would stay there until 1970, when the penalty shoot-out was introduced. They used it even in World Cup qualification matches, when after a third match was played on neutral ground there would still be a draw.

    • @badblood18
      @badblood18 23 дня назад

      Coin toss was used in women's gold cup between Costa Rica and Puerto Rico to determine who would qualify as they drawn at everything

  • @ArjitMehra
    @ArjitMehra Месяц назад +4

    This was very insightful 😅Crazy how different it was back then!!

    • @1313tennisman
      @1313tennisman 27 дней назад

      its interesting because you can see the origins of Aussie Rules and the relation to Rugby and American Football in these rules

  • @joebloggs1356
    @joebloggs1356 22 дня назад +1

    Gealic football has a scoring over the bar rule. You get more points for scoring under the bar than over and you can pick up the ball.

  • @Sluetch90
    @Sluetch90 Месяц назад +4

    Rory Delap would’ve loved those pitches / throws.

  • @SirBeanieIV
    @SirBeanieIV Месяц назад +11

    Hey Kieran, love the videos!

  • @roberthudson3386
    @roberthudson3386 26 дней назад +1

    "And he blasts it miles high! That's his double hat trick. Keeper making the valid point that not even Goliath could have saved it, but his protests are overruled by the referee."

  • @csfootball4145
    @csfootball4145 Месяц назад +3

    gutta percha could be used to reinforce boots in the 1860s and made them harder and less forgiving in tackles

  • @Capydachi
    @Capydachi 26 дней назад +3

    The kit is low key fire

  • @MrDavidht
    @MrDavidht 21 день назад

    The Cambridge Rules where a strong influence on the first FA laws but quite separate. The first match played under the FA laws was between Barnes FC and Richmond FC as a test of the newly agreed laws on the 19th December 1863, a 15-a-side match ending in a goalless draw. A second test was played between The Secretary's Side and the President's Side on the 2nd January 1864 at Battersea Park. The 0-0 draw between Scotland and England you refer to as the first match under the FA laws was played on the 30th November 1872 at Hamilton Crescent, Partick.

  • @Treqz
    @Treqz Месяц назад +1

    Fantastic video Kieran. Also really liked the way you explained whilst maneuvering over the fence at 3:37 - seemed like a genuine documentary. Very professional 💪👍🤩

  • @johnnyheidi2839
    @johnnyheidi2839 21 день назад +3

    What about the Sheffield rules ??

  • @IZ4DAYZ_
    @IZ4DAYZ_ Месяц назад +8

    Great vid again! Gave me flashbacks to the older vids that you did about old football rules :D

  • @mrgrogu3473
    @mrgrogu3473 Месяц назад +15

    the rule about a fair catch called a mark that you can get a free kick from is interesting because its a rule in gaelic football

    • @Olliemuragh
      @Olliemuragh Месяц назад +1

      Yep🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

    • @mrgrogu3473
      @mrgrogu3473 Месяц назад +1

      poggers ive a county final tomorrow

    • @chillichompa34
      @chillichompa34 Месяц назад +8

      Also a rule in AFL (Aussie rules). Which also has no crossbar for scoring a goal

    • @mrgrogu3473
      @mrgrogu3473 Месяц назад +1

      @@chillichompa34 gaelic football has a crossbar for a goal but if you hit it over the crossbar its worth 1 point and a goal is worth 3 points

    • @laurenceryan4779
      @laurenceryan4779 Месяц назад +1

      Also a rule in rugby

  • @gabrielpurves7156
    @gabrielpurves7156 Месяц назад +2

    I SWEAR it was in Barnes, West London, the first game under FA rules

  • @Matt_Larrick_29
    @Matt_Larrick_29 13 дней назад

    Playing a game of old fashioned football would be absolute carnage

  • @thurmanmerman2720
    @thurmanmerman2720 Месяц назад +2

    He didn't mention that the throw in had to be at 90 degrees to the field of play. Similar to how it is done in rugby union.

  • @Trippytropy
    @Trippytropy 4 дня назад +1

    This is basically how we play at school's

  • @theonlydiego1
    @theonlydiego1 12 дней назад

    Never would have ever imagined I’d see a football video with a square dancing song in the background

  • @Bbolo-mb5jm
    @Bbolo-mb5jm Месяц назад +1

    nice video kirean i love your football content❤❤

    • @NinjaNexuses
      @NinjaNexuses Месяц назад

      bro u didnt even watch it yet

  • @thecrankster
    @thecrankster 21 день назад

    The rules were largely an agreed compromise between the rules of Westminster School football and the rules of Charterhouse school football with the bias to the Charterhouse rules, I believe. It then went on from there. That's the oldest continuing inter school football competition in the world. You can find the rules of Westminster school football online. It hasn't been played since standard rules were agreed. However, it was played on a space called "green" which is behind Westminster Abbey, in front of the school. The space is not massive. Probably smaller than a standard pitch. The public school origins of football are often missed out of these stories. Here also.

  • @stevebloomer7027
    @stevebloomer7027 2 дня назад

    Here's a great idea. Try to score 352 League goals (315 in the top flight) under the OLD offside law, with dodgy linos flagging offside every attack, and with goalkeepers being allowed to handle the ball ANYWHERE in their half of the field. And when you realise that you can't, then ask yourself how is it that Steve Bloomer is still SECOND on the all time First Division/Premier League goalscorers despite retiring in 1914?

  • @dev0nSA1nt
    @dev0nSA1nt Месяц назад +3

    9:14 bro really called that the first ever game of football

    • @L4NTZEN
      @L4NTZEN 27 дней назад

      "Official" is important there i guess

  • @lotus_gaming939
    @lotus_gaming939 Месяц назад

    11 minuets after post love the video dude. your an inspiration to me truly. keep it up you deserve more

  • @kris1994
    @kris1994 Месяц назад

    Very cool video! Crazy how the game changed 😂

  • @theovereaspaki262
    @theovereaspaki262 Месяц назад

    You are so good at football keep up the good work❤❤

  • @shanefelkel9966
    @shanefelkel9966 Месяц назад

    Love the vid. I always thought rugby evolved from football/soccer, but the more of these vids i see, I think they were literally the same game at one time.

    • @thurmanmerman2720
      @thurmanmerman2720 Месяц назад +1

      Many different football codes originally existed and the creation of the FA was to create a compromise between them so teams favouring different versions could play against each other. One such code evolved at Rugby School. Groups that favoured their rules, and other similar groups that favoured full contact, originally joined the FA but soon left to set up the Rugby Union. So Rugby football, a code that developed independently, can rightly say it existed before Association football.

  • @DhruvaTotade-y1x
    @DhruvaTotade-y1x Месяц назад

    As always another banger

  • @TsarFrancisDrake
    @TsarFrancisDrake 6 дней назад +1

    Any chance you can show football before these rules were put in place? Seems like it makes a lot more sense for Association Football, American Football, and Australian Football to come from the same original sport if it was as chaotic as those images made it seem.

  • @TheGrogster-mg1kb
    @TheGrogster-mg1kb Месяц назад

    Big boi Kieran uploaded🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @guineapigofficial7700
    @guineapigofficial7700 Месяц назад +2

    What a banger

  • @GamerM2023
    @GamerM2023 Месяц назад

    Great videos kieran, Keep it up!

  • @BallparkHunter
    @BallparkHunter 23 дня назад

    Bring back the fair catch!

  • @stunistus
    @stunistus 27 дней назад +1

    You probably should've talked about rule no.6 offside and mentioned the dispute with the Sheffield rules.

  • @estebandavidlopezmurillo2420
    @estebandavidlopezmurillo2420 18 дней назад

    After watching this video, I need that old football outfit for next Halloween

  • @Spunxz
    @Spunxz Месяц назад

    Love the vids keep it up

  • @Bilal-d3n
    @Bilal-d3n Месяц назад +1

    17:57 So Lev Yashin didn't use gloves 😮

  • @bipindawadi9366
    @bipindawadi9366 Месяц назад

    Damn love the video❤

  • @MannyAlvarado10
    @MannyAlvarado10 19 дней назад

    Increíble, Entertaining, Informative... All in All,.. Great and Sensational.

  • @Chrono7-l7d
    @Chrono7-l7d 23 дня назад

    Some of these rules, the goal posts and the pitch is somehow kind of like te type of game we dudes have in our schools and sometimes villages

  • @Goat_Editz567
    @Goat_Editz567 Месяц назад

    “The greatest of all time” Kieran Brown

  • @RandomHistoryVideos
    @RandomHistoryVideos Месяц назад +1

    Love this video

  • @narvin3
    @narvin3 26 дней назад

    disclaimer, in a place like Malaysia, there aren't many proper pitches, we mostly play in grass and mud with potholes

  • @L4NTZEN
    @L4NTZEN 27 дней назад

    Bring back taking throw ins however you want!

  • @GHOSTED_SQUAD
    @GHOSTED_SQUAD Месяц назад +1

    WE LOVE THIS GAME ❤

  • @LegendaryEditz11
    @LegendaryEditz11 Месяц назад +2

    At 2:16 you looked like lev yashin

  • @Freya_the_Valkyrie
    @Freya_the_Valkyrie 28 дней назад

    this is making the Rules of AFL coming about make alot of sense

    • @stunistus
      @stunistus 27 дней назад +1

      the first draft of the then melbourne rules was done in 1859, 4 years before the FA's 1863 rules, 3 years after the Cambridge rules of 1856.

  • @usa5893
    @usa5893 Месяц назад

    JIM CROCE MENTIONED🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @Mr-UnKnOwN2136
    @Mr-UnKnOwN2136 Месяц назад

    My childhood fr can’t believe I am still subscribed

  • @merseydave1
    @merseydave1 28 дней назад

    Over years those rules were changed and updated, what I like is this ... the game of Football came from our country England, and we organized it with our governing body The Football Association in 1863. Our second governing body The Football League was set up in 1888 we still have today ...
    We took Football all around The World, as its The World Name for Our World Game!.

    • @stunistus
      @stunistus 27 дней назад

      It was the combination of public schools and universities where the students had ample time to spend on recreation (they didnt have to work) plus the emergency of the steam train (so students can visit each other from different parts of the country) and the prominence of the british navy (to spread it globally).

    • @merseydave1
      @merseydave1 26 дней назад

      @@stunistus No via The Empire and people migration

  • @PADDYM962
    @PADDYM962 26 дней назад

    This has some similarities to Gaelic football. Crazy 😅

  • @PoppinC-l3w
    @PoppinC-l3w 17 дней назад

    First rules of _Association Football._ There were other English football rules before the FA's.

  • @TannerCarlton
    @TannerCarlton 21 день назад

    Honestly, you’d have been the best player in 1860s England. 😂
    also we should change our current “arbitrary” throwins to kick ins or those freestyle throws. Speed up the game, make it more interesting.

  • @namiflowers00
    @namiflowers00 Месяц назад

    flipping a coin to decide a match is diabolical

  • @erikhenksen9292
    @erikhenksen9292 Месяц назад

    Flipping a coin to win a game was actually something that was a rule for a long long time, even in 1970 it was still on

  • @CalebHymson
    @CalebHymson Месяц назад +1

    It seems almost like ultimate frisbee back then

  • @dietermeyer3531
    @dietermeyer3531 23 дня назад

    Football association was created in 1863
    And the rugby football union was created in 1871
    Crazy to think the 2 sports are so closely related

  • @TheVETALIST
    @TheVETALIST Месяц назад

    I also heard that players was not allowed to pass the ball forward, so moving to goal is just dribble, push and kick (something like rugby). Don't sure if that's true, maybe not everywhere game was like that

    • @handsolo1209
      @handsolo1209 Месяц назад +1

      Rugby and Soccer were both governed by the FA until the 1871 rule changes. The Rugby teams didn't like the new rules, so they quit the FA and formed the Rugby Football Union. That is why the really old Rugby teams are just called "*** Football Club", and many later soccer teams are called "*** Association Football Club".

    • @thurmanmerman2720
      @thurmanmerman2720 Месяц назад

      True, you could only pass to a teammate backwards

  • @MITESHSHARMA-k6h
    @MITESHSHARMA-k6h Месяц назад +1

    Fire 🔥 ❤

  • @lgt2k125
    @lgt2k125 Месяц назад +1

    Nice video

  • @West.Ham1964
    @West.Ham1964 19 дней назад

    Tyrone Mings still plays by these rules regarding the handling of the ball and dropping it.

  • @realdjoffski
    @realdjoffski 26 дней назад

    The coinflip was actually a draw of straws in the beginning, hence the equal score in football is called a draw. If you pulled the short straw out of the referees hand, you lost the draw. 😊

  • @thegreathadoken6808
    @thegreathadoken6808 23 дня назад

    Gutter persha would have been used to make the boots harder. I guess they were protecting the delicate ankles and shins of 1860's Messi types.

  • @lume85
    @lume85 16 дней назад

    interesting about catching the ball....similar to gaelic football then, although in gaelic football you can bounce the ball once while running

  • @nollienick1121
    @nollienick1121 Месяц назад

    Can really understand how all the spinoff games started.

  • @mikezdee85
    @mikezdee85 Месяц назад

    great football knowledge... if all true, thanx for the vid

  • @piotr8960
    @piotr8960 Месяц назад +1

    Bad bad leroy brown

  • @Alexeiyeah
    @Alexeiyeah 25 дней назад

    I hope people see this and realize there's more to modern sports than just "having better skills".
    If the ball was already heavy and rhe field is already difficult under normal conditions, imagine when it rained.

  • @k.affuljr
    @k.affuljr Месяц назад +1

    2 mins ago but I just clicked on the notifications

  • @rhyshayman8479
    @rhyshayman8479 24 дня назад

    Training session is just a Sunday league session haha

  • @mattbingham5567
    @mattbingham5567 24 дня назад

    No way was this filmed at Enville? My sons Sunday team plays there

  • @Jamalcontent
    @Jamalcontent Месяц назад +6

    Under one day gang 👇

  • @SamuelBeeharry-e9b
    @SamuelBeeharry-e9b Месяц назад +1

    ❤❤❤ Kieran you have aura

  • @capio78
    @capio78 23 дня назад +1

    Great video but England Scotland was the first international not the first game and they had tape cross bars by then

    • @mjudec
      @mjudec 22 дня назад

      If memory serves, they eventually played using the Queen's Park rules (which far more resemble modern football than these ones) and the evolution came pretty quickly thereafter. Loads and loads of what we recognise in modern football came from a bunch of guys in Glasgow trying to work out ways they can make games interesting with the same 20 or 30 folk every game.

  • @Jorthness
    @Jorthness Месяц назад +5

    All ways a good day when I post a vid

    • @Agman.P
      @Agman.P Месяц назад +2

      Your last good day was 14 years ago?

    • @staytrue5307
      @staytrue5307 Месяц назад

      Always*

  • @nofootebas
    @nofootebas Месяц назад +7

    The training in 1860 was so so basic compared to the "curve strength-speed" and other training sessions we have now! We even have pre-match rituals (like using energetic gel, hydroelectrolyte tablets and VapoRub).
    Football were so much simple compared to now hahahahha

  • @omarbahrour
    @omarbahrour 24 дня назад

    Boots seem a fucking nightmare, also the vid thumbnail dude hahahahahaha

  • @stonkAU
    @stonkAU 22 дня назад +1

    9:25 AFL?

  • @mohdmustafaatmar4827
    @mohdmustafaatmar4827 Месяц назад

    the way that you made the video black and white

  • @phirus646
    @phirus646 16 дней назад

    Having no goalkeeper totally makes sense if every player was allowed to just catch the ball

  • @howlinhonky
    @howlinhonky 14 дней назад

    Serious question: Where can you purchase the old time football, boots and shorts?

  • @15-Peter-20
    @15-Peter-20 26 дней назад

    This video was excellent. thank you. Sky blue army CCFC 💙💙💙