Exactly! Channels like these should flourish more. The traditional news media channels have failed us by bowing down to party politics and advertisers.
Thanks for explaining this. Ordinary people in Europe never get that level of explanation so I was really confused about what and why those things happen there.
China's logic behind all the claims is very straight forward If region 'A' was under a Chinese ruler in 700BC and then again area 'B' was in region A during 300 AD, then A including B should be part of China. They invaded Tibet in 1950 with same logic, now they claim Arunachal is their part as it was part Tibet which they own it now. One day they will claim whole world as most of the larger international cities have China town inside. Again those are their territory And the countries where those cities are located those countries are also part of China. And if that country had a colony to any other area on earth ever in human civilization it will be part of China. So basically whole world is part of China Simple calculation. 😇
@@michaelk2130 lol I guess America did get name-checked like 2 messages after I decided to say something lol. Poland and the US have great relations.... what is this dude on about? I think that dude is jealous of your thick kielbasa hahaha. 🇺🇸💙🇵🇱
Thank you for the absence of rhetoric. I am ethnic Chinese from Singapore where Chinese and the minority Indian population get along well with Indians making it to high posts in government as well as the uniformed services disproportionate to their small population. Proof that Chinese and Indians can live and prosper together. I hope the two Asian giants would find peace and partnership instead of conflict.
@@sidsingh8480 There is a problem with Kashmiris. The people living in Kashmir are not the real Kashmiris but real Kashmiris are living as refugees in their own land. Those who live in Kashmir now have forcefully removed out the original Kashmiri pandits and they claim that they are Kashmiri.
It is not about Sino-Indian, it is about CCP mindset. I hope you might be know the CCP claim some land in Singapore belongs to them. As world said the became like expansion.
From a geographic perspective, it makes sense to set borders at the peak of Karakoram Range. No one can have superior altitude and no one can invade from mountain to plains (which is easier to do than mountainous fights)
...I'm from France and I found your channel which I do trust for I couldn't find clear explanations of the geographical situation. Thank you very much for your time monsieur.
@Kashif...Sir,if is not India it will be Pakistan you know it very well you have no means to be independent for those two massive nuclear power won't let you be independent. So you will have to choose the lesser evil...good luck!
@@jasonzhao1340 u are delusional, his report unbiased? Why didn't he mentioned the border according China? And why doesn't he mentioned where India border coming from?
the boundary claimed by China is the legal boundary between China and British India colony. In history British invaded China several times, they forced China signed contract to give up the ownership of land to the India colony, As long as China signed the contract China accept it(in 19 century China twice gave up land,s to India colony). But in 20th century British just military occupied some new land which China never sign contract to give them up, India should not regard them as a part of India. Besides some these land British even did not occupied just claimed ownership one side. India already occupied a lot of China,s land which in law aspect still belong to China, while they want to occupied all the land that British claimed ownership.
Thanks God finally Amit ji you have explained in detail with the reference of Maps and the background dispute between China and India since 1962 and little earlier, now we know where exactly is China and India in the present scenario, please keep us updating if there is any change in the Chinese and Indian ground reality in the dispute Sectors. Thanks stay blessed and be safe and careful Inshallah.
I have read heard seen so many articles, youtube videos, news channels on the issue discussed, but noone discussed the geographical aspect better than this.. thank you!
Historically, the disputed area are territories of Tibet-China that were invaded by the Sikh Empire and returned to Tibet and the Chinese Empire in 1842 under the Treaty of Chushul.
Neatly and clearly explained through maps and illustrations...can also create videos on Galwang valley with its PP & Pangong Tso lake. Another video on Aksai Chin, Area ceded by Pak to China, POK with other INdian territory including Siachen will be commendable.
@@LinusWelt There's nothing like colonial hangover. "Sir" word is used in India as a respectful and honorific way of addressing people in superior rank. And FYI Amit Sengupta is a famous beurocrat in India.
extraordinarily explained ... cleared my all douts, The think which i liked most is , you have also given description of 1962 war ... Amazing , great knowledge 😀😀 style of expressing your knowledge ,, hats off
Just to add a piece of history. China claim Arunachal Pradesh in the east that is currently fully under India's control. Before 1962, China wanted to give up the claim of Arunachal Pradesh in the east in exchange for Aksai Chin in the west. India refused to negotiate and wanted to take both areas, which eventually led to the 1962 war. As of today, India claims Aksai Chin even though it is firmly under China's control. China claims Arunachal Pradesh even though it is firmly under India's control. I hope Indian government should understand that, whatever territory claim changes need to come from negotiation, not from sneaky attacks. Just because the area controlled by China is a threat to the new road, that is not a valid justification to force China to give up their territory. India is also building a road branch that extends into the Galwan valley which is under China's control. This is the core cause of the conflict. Negotiation is the truly peaceful way, sneaky attack is not. Just imagine, what if Chinese army ignores India's objection and moves into Arunachal Pradesh. Anyone will think that won't lead to another war?
Galwan is snatched by us Indian in current dispute. And, our weak Indian government instead of claiming strongly,say LAC is not well demarcated. Actually, current weal indian government is helping China by saying this. Sad and shame on this government. We are losing our land.
@@formyself7493 There was never a bilateral agreement on this. It's only India's unilateral claim. India always want to use the Mcmahon line left by the British, but in fact it was still a colony when British draw the line.
Talking about the “illegal occupation” of Aksai Chin or even Ladakh, India want to "Inherit" everything previously claimed by British empire. British invaded a lot of southern Asian countries and changed the borders illegally either by force or secretly draw illegal lines on map. This is the cause of the border dispute between India with its neighbor countries like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Nepal, Burma, and China if India insists to “Inherit” everything from British empire. Then the border disputes can’t be solved peacefully.
There are many holes in your statement. India's border dispute with Pakistan is due to Kashmir & it has no border dispute with other countries you have mentioned. You are cooking up a story to paint a wrong picture. Only China disputes British handed-down territories with India. Not only China invaded Tibet, now it also claims all border areas between Tibet & India. Not only India, no country in the world would accept this kind of situation. Just because of this attitude, China has earned the wrath of all of its nearly 30 countries barring its underdogs Pakistan & N.Korea. If your statement is true, even Pakistan, Bangladesh, Burma, Srilanka etc should have been part of India. Do not make sweeping statements just like that.
@@Ayesha-be4fv Sikkim was once Independent, Goa was once Independent, Ahom was once Independent, Punjab was once Independent, Kashmir was once Independent, what‘s your point?
What I conclude from the current scenario is: 1. Indian govt. don't want CPEC successful. 2. Illegally changing demography of Muslim majority Kashmir by Modi may be a part of greater agenda with false label of prosperity. 3. Self proclaimed "pok" by Indian media and politicians may serve the starting point of the military conflict between India and Pak which would end up in cascade of catastrophic events between Pak and India eventually resulting in Ghazwa e Hind (the full blown decisive battle between world muslims and hind).
You're incorrect, the border with China in Himachal Pradesh and Sikkim is called International Border IB, not LAC, and the border in Arunachal Pradesh is known as he McMahon Line, again not LAC. LAC only exists in Ladakh.
Line of actual control is a line suggested by Zhou Enlai in 1959 it consists of aksai chin up to (the point they claim), some parts of himachal pradesh and uttarakhand in the west and the mcmohan line in the east. the line between india and china is no call international border IB. But the international border recognized by British india between itself and tibet which the gov of india inherited is called Mcmahon line. Further the 1993 agreement lend to official recognition of the concept of line of actual control by india but actual one claimed by Zhou Enlai
If Tibet is occupied by China then Narrator should also say the Ladakh is currently occupied by India. Although the narrator is not neutral but the explanation of the standoff indeed very nice and easily understandable.
@Yuvraj Roy In the same logic then Tibet also part of China. Google map clearly shows the J&K, Ladakh is disputed territory mean its not recognized by UN.
Love this presentation video about the border dispute between India and the Peoples republic of China, I have now some info about what happened at the border and what the actual problems are between the 2 countries. Watching this nice video from Suriname...
@lionel UZUMAKI India hosted a war with China in 1962.. aise hi clean chit ya gift nai de dya tha... Unfortunately, our army lost that war, but Laal aankh dikhaya tha us time ki Sarkar ne..
@lionel UZUMAKI Nehru is dead and gone. People of India didn't elect BJP/ Modi so that they can offer excuses / blame dead people. Solve it if u hv balls. Simple.
y did the video end abruptly😂...it was like- the narrator realised he was giving out sensitive & specific information and stopped midway..by the Superb video.👍🏻
Bro you are quite right. To be fair, for the sake of unambiguity, he could have at least mentioned that Mount Everest is very close to the Nepal - China border in the east.
Mt. Everest lies in Nepal India border. Mt. Everest is the highest PEAK of Himalayan RANGE. To climb Mt. Everest, the popular trekking route is through Nepal. The Himalayan Range is quite big, may be some 10,000 kilometres or more. Do not quarrel, but, China should free Tibet and leave Akshai Chin immediately. Did India conquer any Chinese land? No. So, if China wants a good relation with India it must let go Akshai Chin to India. Or else, India shall conquer Chinese territories in the near future. Just wait and watch. History repeats itself.
@@techguruish brit MacMahon line also long gone. Why India claim using the line? Who can define "long time ago" ? And qing dynasty did not agree on any treaty, Brit just occupied by force, then India inherit the policy, we take back our , what the problem. There is India who greedy to blame, not ours.
Sir, the Chinese perception of lac has matched indian perception at galwan valley and Indian troops never had any resistance patrolling galwan until now. So is it right to say that the Chinese have claimed the galwan valley since 1962, isn't it a unilateral action from China to change the status quo at galwan now?!
It's amazing how U were able to cram so many information into such a short space of time, N So brilliantly done, I've been following the China 🇨🇳 India🇮🇳 Situation 4 sometime now, N no one were able to explain the geography & the history of both countries as well as U did, Just wanna say thank U, 👍🏾👍🏾
thank you so much sir being a student I found this video very helpful in fact this is the only video on lac standoff which is useful thank you so much once again. Grateful!!
I'm Chinese. I suggest signing the border agreement between the two countries based on the actual line of control. China recognizes the area controlled by India in the eastern section, and India recognizes aksaichin controlled by China in the western section. Don't talk about the Communist Party of China. No country will give up its territory.
@Birdy Flying You are right but the now the honeymoon days are Gone. India is second largest producer of so many which China produce and also first in so many metals and chemicals. Let's end up with China "No more Cheap and inferior products"
What a clarity and way of explaination. News channel with all their resources aren't able to explain viewers. Your hard work can be seen in the videos. Keep it up👍
@@nirmal6362 NEW DELHI Days after a deadly border clash with China, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi said late Friday that Chinese troops did not enter the Asian nation’s territory "nor is any of our post captured." During a virtual meeting with political parties, Modi assured opposition leaders that Indian borders are secure and the military is capable of mounting a defense. “Neither anyone has intruded into our territory nor taken over any post," Modi said, adding that Indian "forces are doing what they have to do to protect the country, whether it is deployment, action or counter-action." "Our patrolling capacity has increased due to newly built infrastructure, especially along the LAC," Modi said, referring to the Line of Control, a defacto border between India and China. His statement came after a Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said its Chinese military did not cross the border during a skirmish Monday that killed at least 20 Indian soldiers along the border in the Ladakh area of the disputed Jammu and Kashmir region. Modi said: "Our brave soldiers made the supreme sacrifice for the nation in Ladakh but also taught a lesson to those who had dared to look towards our motherland." “The entire country is hurt and angry at the steps taken by China at the LAC,” he said, and ensured leaders of different political parties that the armed forces are leaving no stone unturned to protect the country. “Be it deployment, action or counter action, through land, sea or air, our forces are taking the necessary steps to protect the country,” he added. Modi said India wants peace and friendship, but upholding sovereignty is foremost. He highlighted the government has given primacy to the development of the border area infrastructure to make the borders more secure. “Provision has also been made for fighter planes, modern helicopters, missile defense systems and other such needs of our forces. Through the recently developed infrastructure, patrolling capacity at the LAC has also increased,” he said. He reassured leaders about the capability of the armed forces to defend the borders and they have been given a free hand to take necessary steps. Main opposition Indian National Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi said leaders are still in the dark about details and questioned the government about intelligence reports and related matters. - China accuses Indian troops entered its territory Earlier Friday, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian said the Galwan valley in the Ladakh area is “located on the Chinese side" of the defacto border, and accused Indian troops of crossing the line Monday night and "trespassed into China's territory." “Indian border troops have unilaterally and continuously built roads, bridges and other facilities at the LAC in Galwan valley.” However, he said civil and military officials of the two sides maintained communication including a commander-level meeting June 6 to “ease the situation.” “In response to strong demand of Chinese side, India agreed to withdraw personnel who crossed LAC and demolish the facilities, and so they did,” Zhao claimed. “The Indian side promised that they would not cross the estuary of the Galwan river to patrol and build facilities and the two sides would discuss and decide phased withdrawal of troops through the meetings between commanders on the ground,” he said. Border tensions between the two countries have existed for more than seven decades. China claims territory in India's northeast, while New Delhi accuses Beijing of occupying its territory in the Aksai Chin plateau in the Himalayas, including part of the Ladakh region. *Riyaz ul Khaliq from Ankara, Turkey contributed to this story. Anadolu Agency website contains only a portion of the news stories offered to subscribers in the AA News Broadcasting System (HAS), and in summarized form. Please contact us for subscription options.
@@nirmal6362 ruclips.net/video/ERAUKPXDwfI/видео.html Modi said no chinese steps in Indian territories. so where the fight occured at? CHINESE TERRITORY. u need to start using your brain for god sake
@@yewsoonfatt 😂😂😂😂I know ThIsssss. CoK is India 's land that's it . Well . A story from my side. There was USA who thinks it's the superpower , china questioned it . China has expansion ideology which is a threat to it's neighbors . India know that so India activated LAC, as china had encroached ,thing they usually do , they received unexpected heat from India. This is what USA want , a reason to trigger war !! . Anti china countries r opening many fronts. First India did , then Japan claimed disputed island as it's territory , hongkong protests added to the cause , recognization of Tibet bill by USA, taiwan's democracy over china agenda. USA 's 3 aircraft carrier deployment in South China Sea.us army deployment in Asia especially asean countries ☺. This is all planned my friend .
*This video:* "In 1962, the Chinese army illegally entered this territory." Meanwhile, elsewhere on youtube... *Chinese video:* In 1962, the Indian army illegally entered this territory."
No, the previous government had intentionally ignored the building of roads by giving absurd reasons that the roads may be used against India itself. Now when the development work is in its full flow, Chinese have problem with it.
@@montyi8 : what a ridiculous and lame reason. You mean in first ten years any country can occupy new country's land. If this is the case then China got independence in 1949. 2 years after India and just 8 years before that incident
@@danishmuhammad7389 well if you read about that location, it's not a plain land where you can see people building roads easily. It's some remote place in very high altitude in Himalayas. Indian army was still forming then. India didn't know about Chinese aggression back then.
The best single video I have watched on this issue. Factual, great graphical presentation, and organization of facts in logical manner, without any hperbole.
The McMahon Line was an illegal crossing between the Chinese and Indian borders unilaterally by the British colonialists and the Indian government, which was strongly opposed by the Kuomintang government, the Tibetan local government and the Chinese Communist Government. The peaceful liberation of Tibet in 1951, however, was disturbed and obstructed by the Indian government, which further encroached on China's land. In 1951, India took advantage of China's war of resisting the United States and aiding the Korean Peninsula, and sent Indian troops to advance on a large scale to the "Wheat Line". On 22 March 1959, Prime Minister Nehru of India formally submitted a territorial claim to our country, covering an area of 125,000 square kilometres (including 90,000 square kilometres south of the McMahon Line). In order to maintain china-India friendship, the Chinese government has always exercised restraint and tolerance in response to India's armed aggression and unreasonable demands and made unremitting efforts for the peaceful settlement of the border issue between the two countries. India, however, sees China's forbearance as weakness and has intensified its border incursions. On October 17 and 18, 1962, the invading Indian troops launched a heavy artillery attack on the Chinese border guards simultaneously in the east and west sections. The PLA had to rise up and fight back.
Well as an Indian, I'm inclined towards my country. But will there any international law where it can be appealed to resolve such disputes or it can only be solved only by leaders of the two nations. But hope India maintains to have a very effective foreign policy considering they have border conflicts with one strong neighbor and other weak vulnerable neighbors who can be used for advantage
Noveen× there are bodies in the world where such disputes can be resolved by discussion. Since China is strong so you do not want to fight and solve it on table but with Pakistan to resolve issue of Kashmir State your country is avoiding all forums which can resolve this issue. Double standards!
If the same clash occurred with Pakistan army I would still say the same but the case with kashmir is different when our country is targeting by terror groups killing innocent civilians in the name of religious intolerance, do you think i would like my country to negotiate or liaise with the terrorists. Well I'm totally up for war and in fact want it army to go full blitzkrieg and it doesn't matter even if those terrorists are from China or any other country for that matter.
@@naveent2785 these terror activities are mostly orchestrated by the establishment or the deep state to shift the focus of real problems towards such things. During the last 75 years there were many peaceful periods when Kashmir State issue would have been resolved. We Pakistanis are peacefully demanding State of Kashmir. But if war is declared between India and Pakistan then we will claim whole of India. It has been predicted 1400 years ago and is widely known to All Muslims of the world that there will be a defining war with "Hind". Even your learned vedic scholars also know what will be the outcome of the predicted war. We are the same people on both sides of the line, I don't understand as to why we can't solve our regional problems like Europe have done and bring prosperity and peace in this whole region.
Thank you so much sir. You explained the whole issue in such a lucid style Plz also make videos on India's relation with its neighbors especially pak,Nepal 🔥🔥🔥
your 7:37 min of video contains more info than 3 hours of News Channel !
True
Why do you watch those melodramatic news channels which spread more agenda than showing the actual news?
Right
few seconds of silence, love and peace has more live than hours of braking gods.
True
Exactly! Channels like these should flourish more. The traditional news media channels have failed us by bowing down to party politics and advertisers.
Thanks for explaining this. Ordinary people in Europe never get that level of explanation so I was really confused about what and why those things happen there.
China's logic behind all the claims is very straight forward
If region 'A' was under a Chinese ruler in 700BC and then again area 'B' was in region A during 300 AD, then A including B should be part of China.
They invaded Tibet in 1950 with same logic, now they claim Arunachal is their part as it was part Tibet which they own it now.
One day they will claim whole world as most of the larger international cities have China town inside.
Again those are their territory
And the countries where those cities are located those countries are also part of China. And if that country had a colony to any other area on earth ever in human civilization it will be part of China.
So basically whole world is part of China
Simple calculation. 😇
@Dord Dord Thanks
@@Goodwinisback Some Chinese nationalists want Mongolia and Russian land, they are very scary and arrogant people filled with hatred and malice. :(
I am rooting for India anyway! Greetings from Poland !
Ah, Poland. The public toilet in Central Europe. Just asked Germany and Russia, and they have confirmed
@@koenigamd OK I changed my mind I am rooting for China now Are happy Chinese friend?!?! Let’s be friends make friendship not war !
@@michaelk2130 Polish food must be full of potatoes and porks, is that s why your new „friends“ from America beat up your soldiers? Miserable nation
@@koenigamd Come on! Americans are not not such miserable nation! They put man on the moon!
@@michaelk2130 lol I guess America did get name-checked like 2 messages after I decided to say something lol.
Poland and the US have great relations.... what is this dude on about? I think that dude is jealous of your thick kielbasa hahaha.
🇺🇸💙🇵🇱
Thank you for the absence of rhetoric. I am ethnic Chinese from Singapore where Chinese and the minority Indian population get along well with Indians making it to high posts in government as well as the uniformed services disproportionate to their small population. Proof that Chinese and Indians can live and prosper together. I hope the two Asian giants would find peace and partnership instead of conflict.
Adiwira Tiang Negara
LOL grow up
They should just handover to the locals Tibet to Tibetans, Ladakh to Ladakhis, Kashmir to Kashmiris. End of conflicts and bloodshed.
@@sidsingh8480 There is a problem with Kashmiris. The people living in Kashmir are not the real Kashmiris but real Kashmiris are living as refugees in their own land. Those who live in Kashmir now have forcefully removed out the original Kashmiri pandits and they claim that they are Kashmiri.
@@sidsingh8480 你一无所知
It is not about Sino-Indian, it is about CCP mindset. I hope you might be know the CCP claim some land in Singapore belongs to them. As world said the became like expansion.
Sir . I was trying to understand the nature of conflict through various sources , yours is the best . You explained it so clearly . Thank you
又是一个被媒体忽悠的阿三
Your clear explanation should be telecasted in each and every news channel for clear understanding.
Juses his voice is so soft with charming Indian accent
indians and charming...lolz
yes rarely heard anymore,
@@asadawan3424 yup they're very charismatic.
Can werk 4- M'sian TV3....nice voice & probably hensem face like Heritikk....
@ M'sian Bolehwood
Fanno, JB ( Hate PLA Rouge soldiers )....😄😉😯
@@garfield2742 not everyone runs a RUclips channel
This man deserves a Subscribe for this clear cut presentation
Hit like for his voice and commnt for his explanation.😇
Indeed .
His voice is angelic. I could hear him all dayyy. 🙈
Wow
Super voice 😍
Amazing voice
Bahut hi acchi explanation Ha sir Ki
From a geographic perspective, it makes sense to set borders at the peak of Karakoram Range. No one can have superior altitude and no one can invade from mountain to plains (which is easier to do than mountainous fights)
I am surprised that how anyone can explain this within 7.37 min . Really there is a very brilliant and a sharp mind behind making this vdo .
#k
Wrong info given! Everest is in Nepal, not in Tibet.
@@shashankkz on the border of tibbet and nepal ...but mountaineers starts climbing from nepal so this is the reason why nepal is famous
Very detailed. What I don't understand is why is the Indian media not explaining it like this. So informative.
Sir, please complete The Modern Indian History Timeline from 1857 - 1947.
Yes sir
Pls sir
Yes 👍
Yes sir the same era
Yes sir
...I'm from France and I found your channel which I do trust for I couldn't find clear explanations of the geographical situation.
Thank you very much for your time monsieur.
@Kashif...Sir,if is not India it will be Pakistan you know it very well you have no means to be independent for those two massive nuclear power won't let you be independent.
So you will have to choose the lesser evil...good luck!
Love It. Hats off to you for your dedication towards perfection.
dedication towards perfect bs
Thank you so much.
Big greetings from your friends here in Australia.
Seems the full video wasn't uploaded it ended abruptly
Cause he don't request for subscription at the end 😅
@@Pradee1995 Haha
Sir bss app hi ache teacheroo me bacche he jisne Unaccedmy join nhi kiya .... thanks a lot for teaching us free🙏
Best
Adds value if pdf made available
Then it becomes cent pc Star
I'm Chinese, and it amazing how unbiased your report is. Thx!
How are you on RUclips?
@@justinfleagle I don’t live in China
@@justinfleagle chinese live in china can access RUclips with VPN, it's very common practice in china.
@@jasonzhao1340 u are delusional, his report unbiased?
Why didn't he mentioned the border according China?
And why doesn't he mentioned where India border coming from?
China illegally occupied Tibbat... first of all free Tibbat.
After seeing this disputed area in news at that time I was confused bt now I understood it very well... Thank u sir 👍👍
Why am I finding this channel this late. Damn.
Hope you have gone through his UPSC prelim solution of Geography.. You will love it and also about Modi's Man vs Wild analysis :)
@@asitranjanswain834 no
Joshua Immanuel ruclips.net/video/0q4jbL9XZBQ/видео.html
@@asitranjanswain834pq.1q?iiolmm vcftgh
Defense spending different countries
ruclips.net/video/I4ERmz4s99E/видео.html
Excellent use of graphics to make this topic so smooth.
Truly love and appriciate this effort.
Very good work 👍👌
Thank you so much
www.worldpolity.com/2020/06/india-china-border-tensions-worst-clash.html?m=1www.worldpolity.com/2020/06/india-china-border-tensions-worst-clash.html?m=1
the boundary claimed by China is the legal boundary between China and British India colony. In history British invaded China several times, they forced China signed contract to give up the ownership of land to the India colony, As long as China signed the contract China accept it(in 19 century China twice gave up land,s to India colony). But in 20th century British just military occupied some new land which China never sign contract to give them up, India should not regard them as a part of India. Besides some these land British even did not occupied just claimed ownership one side. India already occupied a lot of China,s land which in law aspect still belong to China, while they want to occupied all the land that British claimed ownership.
India - china conflict complete information
ruclips.net/video/BmNes54SJ4Y/видео.html
Lie: India stolen lands from China and other small nations!
Thanks God finally Amit ji you have explained in detail with the reference of Maps and the background dispute between China and India since 1962 and little earlier, now we know where exactly is China and India in the present scenario, please keep us updating if there is any change in the Chinese and Indian ground reality in the dispute Sectors. Thanks stay blessed and be safe and careful Inshallah.
Woah... finally understood this topic with all the valid keywords and information
Watch independent news
I have read heard seen so many articles, youtube videos, news channels on the issue discussed, but noone discussed the geographical aspect better than this.. thank you!
I am the one who eagerly waits for your notification.
Also🙌
Me to
Historically, the disputed area are territories of Tibet-China that were invaded by the Sikh Empire and returned to Tibet and the Chinese Empire in 1842 under the Treaty of Chushul.
Neatly and clearly explained through maps and illustrations...can also create videos on Galwang valley with its PP & Pangong Tso lake. Another video on Aksai Chin, Area ceded by Pak to China, POK with other INdian territory including Siachen will be commendable.
Sir once again hats off to your method of explaining..
@@LinusWelt There's nothing like colonial hangover.
"Sir" word is used in India as a respectful and honorific way of addressing people in superior rank. And FYI Amit Sengupta is a famous beurocrat in India.
I opened it just to hear his voice... Sorry for that😅
Good one..I like that
True 🤣😊👍
@@kinglits7169 ..
extraordinarily explained ... cleared my all douts, The think which i liked most is , you have also given description of 1962 war ... Amazing , great knowledge 😀😀 style of expressing your knowledge ,, hats off
With some factual errors. Otherwise video is awesome
Amazing video, never seen such a clear explanation. Well explained with maps.
Just to add a piece of history. China claim Arunachal Pradesh in the east that is currently fully under India's control. Before 1962, China wanted to give up the claim of Arunachal Pradesh in the east in exchange for Aksai Chin in the west. India refused to negotiate and wanted to take both areas, which eventually led to the 1962 war. As of today, India claims Aksai Chin even though it is firmly under China's control. China claims Arunachal Pradesh even though it is firmly under India's control. I hope Indian government should understand that, whatever territory claim changes need to come from negotiation, not from sneaky attacks. Just because the area controlled by China is a threat to the new road, that is not a valid justification to force China to give up their territory. India is also building a road branch that extends into the Galwan valley which is under China's control. This is the core cause of the conflict. Negotiation is the truly peaceful way, sneaky attack is not. Just imagine, what if Chinese army ignores India's objection and moves into Arunachal Pradesh. Anyone will think that won't lead to another war?
You don't know H of History..
They invade galwan valley after agreement. See the video
Galwan is snatched by us Indian in current dispute. And, our weak Indian government instead of claiming strongly,say LAC is not well demarcated. Actually, current weal indian government is helping China by saying this. Sad and shame on this government. We are losing our land.
@@formyself7493 There was never a bilateral agreement on this. It's only India's unilateral claim. India always want to use the Mcmahon line left by the British, but in fact it was still a colony when British draw the line.
Absolutely agree with you!
Talking about the “illegal occupation” of Aksai Chin or even Ladakh, India want to "Inherit" everything previously claimed by British empire. British invaded a lot of southern Asian countries and changed the borders illegally either by force or secretly draw illegal lines on map. This is the cause of the border dispute between India with its neighbor countries like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Nepal, Burma, and China if India insists to “Inherit” everything from British empire. Then the border disputes can’t be solved peacefully.
even it assumed inheritance by India , what about invasion of Tibet by china ?
There are many holes in your statement. India's border dispute with Pakistan is due to Kashmir & it has no border dispute with other countries you have mentioned. You are cooking up a story to paint a wrong picture. Only China disputes British handed-down territories with India. Not only China invaded Tibet, now it also claims all border areas between Tibet & India. Not only India, no country in the world would accept this kind of situation. Just because of this attitude, China has earned the wrath of all of its nearly 30 countries barring its underdogs Pakistan & N.Korea. If your statement is true, even Pakistan, Bangladesh, Burma, Srilanka etc should have been part of India. Do not make sweeping statements just like that.
@@hareramkovvali3227 Name me one country, who admit Tibet as a indepent country.
@@wintertum Tibet was independent
Then invaded by chins
@@Ayesha-be4fv Sikkim was once Independent, Goa was once Independent, Ahom was once Independent, Punjab was once Independent, Kashmir was once Independent, what‘s your point?
You explained so well, great use of map, soohting voice. Good job.
What I conclude from the current scenario is:
1. Indian govt. don't want CPEC successful.
2. Illegally changing demography of Muslim majority Kashmir by Modi may be a part of greater agenda with false label of prosperity.
3. Self proclaimed "pok" by Indian media and politicians may serve the starting point of the military conflict between India and Pak which would end up in cascade of catastrophic events between Pak and India eventually resulting in Ghazwa e Hind (the full blown decisive battle between world muslims and hind).
Informative thank you 🙏 . So nice to see “Tibet” in the map thanks again 🙏
Time to free Tibet.
You must know that Tibet is a part of China.
@@chuangyang3568 don't want to, would rather see it as a free and independent country
@@kaidi_p It's your call? You go to the Tibet Autonomous Region to shout a sentence and see if you can break a bone.
@@chuangyang3568 Tibet ?? It's a country occupied by china.
What an incredible video , Truly stand exceptional , No more exaggeration.
Ignorance is bliss.
ruclips.net/video/BmNes54SJ4Y/видео.html
Greatly appreciated your efforts and your style of teaching and way of showing maps and places and mountains range ,
You're incorrect, the border with China in Himachal Pradesh and Sikkim is called International Border IB, not LAC, and the border in Arunachal Pradesh is known as he McMahon Line, again not LAC. LAC only exists in Ladakh.
Lol Idiot
Line of actual control is a line suggested by Zhou Enlai in 1959 it consists of aksai chin up to (the point they claim), some parts of himachal pradesh and uttarakhand in the west and the mcmohan line in the east.
the line between india and china is no call international border IB. But the international border recognized by British india between itself and tibet which the gov of india inherited is called Mcmahon line.
Further the 1993 agreement lend to official recognition of the concept of line of actual control by india but actual one claimed by Zhou Enlai
Hope u see my comment
Sir lecture was really awesome
Please come Live in a video
Thank u soo much keep making such informative videos
Never ever tired of listening to his soft voice
Good explanation of the border issue between India and China. Respect for the both great nation from Syria Arab Republic
If Tibet is occupied by China then Narrator should also say the Ladakh is currently occupied by India. Although the narrator is not neutral but the explanation of the standoff indeed very nice and easily understandable.
@Yuvraj Roy In the same logic then Tibet also part of China. Google map clearly shows the J&K, Ladakh is disputed territory mean its not recognized by UN.
@@johncolins7115
Ladakh Is not disputed Im fro, ladakh india
Aksai Chin is Turk sound, means: Sand Sea of China
After 1962 war
@@summer4160 You have to win a war to undone the effect of a war. The question is why do you want to?
India - china conflict complete information
ruclips.net/video/BmNes54SJ4Y/видео.html
Chinese invaded the Ladakh region and annexed Aksai Chin like they have gobbled up Tibet in 1950.
Who said dis to you...it is uigar word which means snow desert...chin does not mean China...ok ...by ur theory ...siachin vl also be chinaz
But isn't the ending bit confusing. It suddenly stops.
its a regular phenomena
Because we all know India is screwed up. But Indians don't have the guts to say.
Just talk big. But in real cannot do a shit.
maybe he could not deliver right conclusions in UPSC answers so he is teaching now..
Perfectly explained.. Awesome ! Anyone watch this would be able to understand easily
Love this presentation video about the border dispute between India and the Peoples republic of China, I have now some info about what happened at the border and what the actual problems are between the 2 countries. Watching this nice video from Suriname...
I guess it was an incomplete video... It ended abruptly.. anyways worth watching
"Nobody has intruded into our border, neither is anybody there now, nor have our posts been captured" ----Narendra Modi
He's admitting that ladakh belongs to china
Any half brain would realize it was taken in 1962 and not now.
For all those Fakicunts go offer tea or something to your fallen "trees"
;)
Ok of believe that, rajnath singh said different why????..why boycott china has begun then, just for fun?
@lionel UZUMAKI India hosted a war with China in 1962.. aise hi clean chit ya gift nai de dya tha...
Unfortunately, our army lost that war, but Laal aankh dikhaya tha us time ki Sarkar ne..
@lionel UZUMAKI Nehru is dead and gone. People of India didn't elect BJP/ Modi so that they can offer excuses / blame dead people. Solve it if u hv balls. Simple.
Your explanation is crystal clear and professional. Thanks a ton for sharing. Look forward to more such videos. Cheers.
y did the video end abruptly😂...it was like- the narrator realised he was giving out sensitive & specific information and stopped midway..by the Superb video.👍🏻
Let me be clear, Mt Everest does not falls in Tibet. It lies as a boundary between Nepal and China. Get your history checked.
Don't talk rubbish
Nepali?
India hating - Communist "Nastik" loving
Limpiyadhura, Kuta and Kalapani belongs to india - Get your history checked
Bro you are quite right. To be fair, for the sake of unambiguity, he could have at least mentioned that Mount Everest is very close to the Nepal - China border in the east.
@@debayanbasu8964 , why is it rubbish? Let's explain, worldwide now trying to understand what happened.
Mt. Everest lies in Nepal India border. Mt. Everest is the highest PEAK of Himalayan RANGE. To climb Mt. Everest, the popular trekking route is through Nepal. The Himalayan Range is quite big, may be some 10,000 kilometres or more. Do not quarrel, but, China should free Tibet and leave Akshai Chin immediately. Did India conquer any Chinese land? No. So, if China wants a good relation with India it must let go Akshai Chin to India. Or else, India shall conquer Chinese territories in the near future. Just wait and watch. History repeats itself.
0:32 it is the mcmahon line not lac
lac is only in ut of ladkah with aksai chin
yeah, that blue border in ladakh is not lac.
I hope he notice it
Yeah even I heard it, he must have meant McMohan line..
A compehensive and articulate interepretation of the recent Moscow Agreemen.
Really wonderful thanks heartily for exposing the reality of original disputes since 1950.
The Indian borders were drawn by the British. China simply took back what belonged to them all the way back from the Qing Dynasty.
Quing Dynasty is long gone.Quing Dynasty sold it to India and British taken over it and left it to India when they left India.....
@@techguruish India before the British left was a geographical concept not a country, so "sold it to India" is ridiculous.
@@user-sw9ig4ku6v kingdom in the past is another concept of country
@@user-sw9ig4ku6v yea like that China can take over Taiwan also what crap are you talking .
@@techguruish brit MacMahon line also long gone. Why India claim using the line? Who can define "long time ago" ? And qing dynasty did not agree on any treaty, Brit just occupied by force, then India inherit the policy, we take back our , what the problem. There is India who greedy to blame, not ours.
Remember Aksai chin has been China's territory since after the 1962 war.
Dumd
Lolz. It was taken and "win back" by Chinese army. Gosh this is what Indian media is all about. Spread the fake truth
@That Sports Guy In that case India also occupied Kashmir illegally and forcefully.
Sir, the Chinese perception of lac has matched indian perception at galwan valley and Indian troops never had any resistance patrolling galwan until now. So is it right to say that the Chinese have claimed the galwan valley since 1962, isn't it a unilateral action from China to change the status quo at galwan now?!
Amazing presentation! Very well done. I felt it did end abruptly though.
Your voice is proof of your balanced brain which is found 1℅ of entire population on this earth.
It's amazing how U were able to cram so many information into such a short space of time, N So brilliantly done, I've been following the China 🇨🇳 India🇮🇳 Situation 4 sometime now, N no one were able to explain the geography & the history of both countries as well as U did, Just wanna say thank U, 👍🏾👍🏾
thank you so much sir being a student I found this video very helpful in fact this is the only video on lac standoff which is useful thank you so much once again. Grateful!!
I'm Chinese. I suggest signing the border agreement between the two countries based on the actual line of control. China recognizes the area controlled by India in the eastern section, and India recognizes aksaichin controlled by China in the western section. Don't talk about the Communist Party of China. No country will give up its territory.
I find the explanation is not entirely neutral.
why should it be its not the BBC
@@FiveLiver HaHa.... BBC.!!!! Another f*cking channel
Yes 👉🏻because this channel always supports China ...
China is cheap just like their product. 😊😀😀
@@arunaruntiwarytiwarystill too expensive for most indians
@Birdy Flying You are right but the now the honeymoon days are Gone. India is second largest producer of so many which China produce and also first in so many metals and chemicals. Let's end up with China "No more Cheap and inferior products"
You’re an amazing teacher! Very crisp and precise.
Lots of thanks sir. You provide best lecture at no price. Please Keep it up sir. God bless you sir
MR. MODI WILL GAIN THE RESPECT OF THE INDIAN PEOPLE FOR GETTING BACK AKSAI CHIN
Chinese President " CHOON CHOON" CHOON ..Indian P.M. " POOON POOON POOON"
Muhammad Imran 1962 lol
@@xushibo4217 muhammad imran 1971 lol
Katwe mulle tera pakistan ko suwar ke jaise beja tha yaad ha na
at 2:10, Request you coin "Government of India" instead of "BJP Govt".
why?
Its 2:04
He did so to explain which government did it... Otherwise of course we know it waa governmenr of india
Your video is useful and superb. You explained well.
What a clarity and way of explaination. News channel with all their resources aren't able to explain viewers. Your hard work can be seen in the videos.
Keep it up👍
0:22 In the beginning of the video, the LAC in the Ladakh area is shown wrongly.
I thought no one would see this. Or pretend not seeing this.
Agree
That's the actual LAC (loose) as he mentions. He's not wrong.
no
That is LOC.
MODi himself admit Indian troop cross China border to confront d Chinese FACTS
in ur dreams?
@@nirmal6362 NEW DELHI
Days after a deadly border clash with China, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi said late Friday that Chinese troops did not enter the Asian nation’s territory "nor is any of our post captured."
During a virtual meeting with political parties, Modi assured opposition leaders that Indian borders are secure and the military is capable of mounting a defense.
“Neither anyone has intruded into our territory nor taken over any post," Modi said, adding that Indian "forces are doing what they have to do to protect the country, whether it is deployment, action or counter-action."
"Our patrolling capacity has increased due to newly built infrastructure, especially along the LAC," Modi said, referring to the Line of Control, a defacto border between India and China.
His statement came after a Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said its Chinese military did not cross the border during a skirmish Monday that killed at least 20 Indian soldiers along the border in the Ladakh area of the disputed Jammu and Kashmir region.
Modi said: "Our brave soldiers made the supreme sacrifice for the nation in Ladakh but also taught a lesson to those who had dared to look towards our motherland."
“The entire country is hurt and angry at the steps taken by China at the LAC,” he said, and ensured leaders of different political parties that the armed forces are leaving no stone unturned to protect the country.
“Be it deployment, action or counter action, through land, sea or air, our forces are taking the necessary steps to protect the country,” he added.
Modi said India wants peace and friendship, but upholding sovereignty is foremost.
He highlighted the government has given primacy to the development of the border area infrastructure to make the borders more secure.
“Provision has also been made for fighter planes, modern helicopters, missile defense systems and other such needs of our forces. Through the recently developed infrastructure, patrolling capacity at the LAC has also increased,” he said.
He reassured leaders about the capability of the armed forces to defend the borders and they have been given a free hand to take necessary steps.
Main opposition Indian National Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi said leaders are still in the dark about details and questioned the government about intelligence reports and related matters.
- China accuses Indian troops entered its territory
Earlier Friday, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian said the Galwan valley in the Ladakh area is “located on the Chinese side" of the defacto border, and accused Indian troops of crossing the line Monday night and "trespassed into China's territory."
“Indian border troops have unilaterally and continuously built roads, bridges and other facilities at the LAC in Galwan valley.”
However, he said civil and military officials of the two sides maintained communication including a commander-level meeting June 6 to “ease the situation.”
“In response to strong demand of Chinese side, India agreed to withdraw personnel who crossed LAC and demolish the facilities, and so they did,” Zhao claimed.
“The Indian side promised that they would not cross the estuary of the Galwan river to patrol and build facilities and the two sides would discuss and decide phased withdrawal of troops through the meetings between commanders on the ground,” he said.
Border tensions between the two countries have existed for more than seven decades.
China claims territory in India's northeast, while New Delhi accuses Beijing of occupying its territory in the Aksai Chin plateau in the Himalayas, including part of the Ladakh region.
*Riyaz ul Khaliq from Ankara, Turkey contributed to this story.
Anadolu Agency website contains only a portion of the news stories offered to subscribers in the AA News Broadcasting System (HAS), and in summarized form. Please contact us for subscription options.
@@nirmal6362 ruclips.net/video/ERAUKPXDwfI/видео.html Modi said no chinese steps in Indian territories. so where the fight occured at? CHINESE TERRITORY. u need to start using your brain for god sake
@@yewsoonfatt 😂😂😂😂I know ThIsssss. CoK is India 's land that's it .
Well . A story from my side.
There was USA who thinks it's the superpower , china questioned it .
China has expansion ideology which is a threat to it's neighbors . India know that so India activated LAC, as china had encroached ,thing they usually do , they received unexpected heat from India. This is what USA want , a reason to trigger war !! . Anti china countries r opening many fronts. First India did , then Japan claimed disputed island as it's territory , hongkong protests added to the cause , recognization of Tibet bill by USA, taiwan's democracy over china agenda. USA 's 3 aircraft carrier deployment in South China Sea.us army deployment in Asia especially asean countries ☺.
This is all planned my friend .
Free Tibet and Aksai chin-land grabber country.
It's the best video I have found on this topic.
Excellent video.
thank you so much sir. it was really a clear explanation. you have cleared most of my doubts. JAI HIND.
*This video:* "In 1962, the Chinese army illegally entered this territory."
Meanwhile, elsewhere on youtube...
*Chinese video:* In 1962, the Indian army illegally entered this territory."
Even USA belongs according to China says china😂
India lost the territory to China and now claim China intruded.
@@montyi8 not funny.
So who is right here then
@@finback2005 Indians soldiers.. Their politicians love bareland, desert and ice field so they send their soldiers station there to show bravery.
Was India sleeping when China built road in their territory called aksai chin in 1957 and then finally took it from India in 1962
No, the previous government had intentionally ignored the building of roads by giving absurd reasons that the roads may be used against India itself. Now when the development work is in its full flow, Chinese have problem with it.
1957, India had just got independence 10 years earlier.
@@montyi8 : what a ridiculous and lame reason. You mean in first ten years any country can occupy new country's land. If this is the case then China got independence in 1949. 2 years after India and just 8 years before that incident
@@danishmuhammad7389 well if you read about that location, it's not a plain land where you can see people building roads easily. It's some remote place in very high altitude in Himalayas. Indian army was still forming then. India didn't know about Chinese aggression back then.
the visual explanation through map is more helpful in understanding and remembering the issue. thank you sir
How smoothly u explained...❤️❤️❤️ Am in love with your voice
I'm afraid your line is not LAC, it's the claimed line.
Which one
Your map demarcation is wrong . Pakistan portion you’re showing it as yours .. where I’m sitting right now
So,,, you are Pakistani.... Love you bro.
It because the narator is india
Yours is mine and mine still mine, that's the mindset of India, love you bro from China.
@@burnabyone4685 u r china ???
The best single video I have watched on this issue. Factual, great graphical presentation, and organization of facts in logical manner, without any hperbole.
I just love this channel 😄Sir your explanation is superb, and Crystal clear .Your voice a holy grail adds extra bonus to your videos 😍😊
Thenx to napushak naheru, we lost huge territory.
Very informative! Thank you.
Question - why don't Indian troops just wear oxygen masks to negate the altitude sickness problem?
adds extra weight and not ideal during combat
They have centres to increase oxygen in blood, even normal citizens can go there but carring oxygen is not practical during duty.
superb information. Good job done Amit Sengupta..
Well explained and deep research done. Need part II to explain further as this topic is very much in the news especially the Galwan valley
Mount Everest is in Nepal not Tibet
I believe Everest is in both Nepal and Tibet.
ask Nehru about his 'forward policy'
Indian minister: We can't give one inch land to China from ladakh area.
China : We already made a highway in 1957,with length of 170km😀😂😂😀
What an explanation!!..easy n short...for busy people.like us...
Sir your way of teaching is osm,and I request you to pls...start teaching geography for upsc aspirats.
He already did. Check out his older videos
The McMahon Line was an illegal crossing between the Chinese and Indian borders unilaterally by the British colonialists and the Indian government, which was strongly opposed by the Kuomintang government, the Tibetan local government and the Chinese Communist Government. The peaceful liberation of Tibet in 1951, however, was disturbed and obstructed by the Indian government, which further encroached on China's land. In 1951, India took advantage of China's war of resisting the United States and aiding the Korean Peninsula, and sent Indian troops to advance on a large scale to the "Wheat Line". On 22 March 1959, Prime Minister Nehru of India formally submitted a territorial claim to our country, covering an area of 125,000 square kilometres (including 90,000 square kilometres south of the McMahon Line). In order to maintain china-India friendship, the Chinese government has always exercised restraint and tolerance in response to India's armed aggression and unreasonable demands and made unremitting efforts for the peaceful settlement of the border issue between the two countries. India, however, sees China's forbearance as weakness and has intensified its border incursions. On October 17 and 18, 1962, the invading Indian troops launched a heavy artillery attack on the Chinese border guards simultaneously in the east and west sections. The PLA had to rise up and fight back.
We’re going to die to protect INDIA 🇮🇳
It was better to Fought and lost than retreat with fear. God save India from Surrendered.
Well as an Indian, I'm inclined towards my country. But will there any international law where it can be appealed to resolve such disputes or it can only be solved only by leaders of the two nations.
But hope India maintains to have a very effective foreign policy considering they have border conflicts with one strong neighbor and other weak vulnerable neighbors who can be used for advantage
CCP not care the law
Kumar M looks like Indian gov cares the law. Then why Indian gov killed a Nepali royal family?
Noveen× there are bodies in the world where such disputes can be resolved by discussion. Since China is strong so you do not want to fight and solve it on table but with Pakistan to resolve issue of Kashmir State your country is avoiding all forums which can resolve this issue. Double standards!
If the same clash occurred with Pakistan army I would still say the same but the case with kashmir is different when our country is targeting by terror groups killing innocent civilians in the name of religious intolerance, do you think i would like my country to negotiate or liaise with the terrorists. Well I'm totally up for war and in fact want it army to go full blitzkrieg and it doesn't matter even if those terrorists are from China or any other country for that matter.
@@naveent2785 these terror activities are mostly orchestrated by the establishment or the deep state to shift the focus of real problems towards such things. During the last 75 years there were many peaceful periods when Kashmir State issue would have been resolved. We Pakistanis are peacefully demanding State of Kashmir. But if war is declared between India and Pakistan then we will claim whole of India.
It has been predicted 1400 years ago and is widely known to All Muslims of the world that there will be a defining war with "Hind". Even your learned vedic scholars also know what will be the outcome of the predicted war.
We are the same people on both sides of the line, I don't understand as to why we can't solve our regional problems like Europe have done and bring prosperity and peace in this whole region.
This doesn't explain anything related to the actual 8 pointers around the lake.
Lake in Pong Gong Tso it is not in Galwan..it is a diferent place where there is faceoff...
Explained it in a very lucid way..Thank you.
Thank you so much sir. You explained the whole issue in such a lucid style
Plz also make videos on India's relation with its neighbors especially pak,Nepal
🔥🔥🔥