Every Jew in Israel should be allowed to carry a gun. I was there in March and found out how restrictive gun ownership was. I thought how stupid this is.
But the leftist shmucks in government won’t allow this. They all have blood on their hands. I guess they want something far more devastating to happen to Israeli.
I agree from over here in America where we have more guns than people in my family to use at once with every appendage. I don’t think Israelis would use them for harm but just to protect themselves. After Oct 7th I’d say it’s a must. I’d say it’s the first thing the government should do is teach them all how to use a firearm and get them all guns. But I hear Biden is making sure the citizens of Israel don’t get the guns from the US. It makes me mad. I’d pay extra taxes or just donate so the US could make sure every Jew ish adult could have a gun and training on how to use it. They are being hunted by pure evil.
This is appalling. As a former defence intelligence officer I have studied various failures. It is hard to find a parallel. Intelligence needs interpretation and is always uncertain to some degree. It is easy to see in retrospective which should have been acted on and which disregarded. But this failure is different. It is straightforward denial. I have experienced reluctance to believe reports because they are too horrible to contemplate, but surely not in a command on the border of the territory of an enemy with a track record of terror. Glick is right. these officers must be dismissed in disgrace.
Denial is a state when one reflects on personal flaws or failures, etc., in one’s own private life. Staff to ponder with your shrink When one is in charge with the of country existence , responsible for lives of thousands citizens , there is no place for denial, and contemplation, it is time to act. Wilfully ignoring intel from many sources is treason , plain and simple. A decent person would resign immediately and stop to exist. Generals have personal guns, don’t they?
@@4eversearchI disagree. Military people generally try to make the right decision. They sometimes get it wrong and as result people might die. That's life in the Armed Forces. It is not traitorous, just a costly mistake.. there should be an enquiry to establish the facts and whether the individual making the decision is culpable or not. Acting without contemplation is usually going off half cocked and dangerous. At the level of a general most of his time should be spent thinking, not acting.
@@petergardner760 yes, military people, who are honest patriots mostly make right decision, and if things go wrong, it is inspire of their best efforts, not because they are not honest , not patriots, they are just traitors , who put politics above their direct obligation of guarding their country and its citizens. Or, even more simple, they were bought out by Israel enemies. Not a new scheme
Finkelstein must be in the leftist camp and ironically, the peace activist from the southern envelope who were taken hostage by the very people whom they support.
I feel the same about the lame Biden administration. It's like complete *ssh*ts, and incompetents are running the show. Very painful to watch. We still gotta' fight as hard as we can though.
This was incredibly informative but also incredibly depressing. Thank you Caroline for reporting on what no one else is talking about. These generals should be subject to court martial.
My wife and I fully agree with your assessment and stand with and pray for Israel. I know many others here in the US do as well. Keep up the good work of proclaiming the truth.
Somebody has to tell this fact to Israelis the chief fail and must be fired. I think they receibe money from Qatar to ignore this information. Please check their banck account in order to see if they were paid for the enemies.
…not only fired.and then go home and enjoy their lives and probably receive pensions?? No, they have to be tried by military court or tribunal for TREASON AND COMPLICITY IN MURDER
How high does this conspiracy go? What did Netanyahu know? I don't trust him. This is shocking stuff. Could it have been a blatant political chess move to save him?
Sorry I am commenting again Caroline, you know you rarely see a nativity scene anywhere now, plenty of Santa's, they are everywhere, no Carol singers. Now no Christmas trees. WAKE UP CRAZY WORLD, THERE IS A MASSIVE PRICE TO BE PAID. GETTING RID OF THE JEWS IS GETTING RID OF GOD. 😔😪
Gods self appointed chosen (mostly atheists) I know all this religious nonsense is not genuine when I see your IDF soldiers riding around taking pictures with lgbtq flags hoisted in Gaza Jews have lead to secularization and polluted the holy lands. God know how many strip clubs you people brought there in the open. Shame shame Gods chosen (mostly atheists)
I fully agree with and support Caroline Click. We were, are and will be surrounded by sworn enemies. Analyzing and fixing our mistakes is far more important than near-sighted "defeating Hamas".
You are absolutely wrong. You cannot tolerate letting an organization who is totally committed to the destruction of Israel remain your neighbor. No nation can allow terrorism to thrive.
Finklestein clearly needs a new position.Janitor at the UN schools in Gaza would suit him fine.There appears to be a massive problem with arrogance in the upper echelons of the IDF.My heart goes out to the soldiers and citizens & families who have been sacrificed.
The commander of the Israeli Southern Command is Major General Yaron Finkelman. Norman Finkelstein is a political scientist and activist who defends the Palestinian cause by criticizing Israel. IMO, Finkelstein has caused more harm than Finkelman, but it's a close race.
@@rightclick7266I was just thinking the same. Possibly the word “Fink” at the beginning of the name is a give away. (Apologies to decent Finkwhatevers.)
I don’t know if Caroline would like to be in politics, but I’d sure love her to be in charge because she has got her stuff together. This is so valuable to people too. I’m American but we need people like her making changes over here too. God bless Israel.
Caroline, if only there were people like you in powerful positions to put an end to this once and for all. It's regrettable that politics gets in the way and that there are such double standards and hypocrisy. It is sickening. You are an inspiration with common sense. Thank you.
So, this begs the question, Did the Israeli Government perpetrate this invasion?...why? What did the government have to gain from disregarding this intelligence that Hamas was getting ready to attack?
I have a problem with Netanyahu wanting State Israel to be the example of being fully vaccinated before many other countries. Where is his allegiance? Isn't he a member of the CFR? 😮
This is so hard to believe, I just don’t know what to say…thank you Caroline for your brilliant reporting. May God give you strength for continuing your work.
This is crushingly depressing to listen to. Carolyn is organized, clear and compelling. Extremely extremely painful to contemplate the possibility that that slaughter possibly could've been prevented or mitigated.
it was obvious to me, if you go back a few months the lefty military made a comment that if Israel goes to war they will not send troops, that was a red flag!
You are a wonderful lady, Caroline, never afraid to speak the truth. I and my family do stand with Israel, always have. We pray daily for Israel, the IDF, for PM Netanyahu, for you and your family.
Caroline, thank you for being courageous enough to tell the truth! You are so right that Israel must win, not just for your sakes, but also for the sake of every democratic country that Islam hates. Be assured I am standing with you even though I am not a Jew and live in the UK. Thank you - keep spreading the truth!
I’m also wondering why US intelligence didn’t send a huge alert to Israeli politicians AND military? I really think ALL OF OUR really expensive intelligence FAILED! There’s got to be more to this story. Intelligence and National Security doesn’t just go through 1 military person.
Yeh let's not go there yet everyone is reeling I'm sure it'll all come out in the wash but now is NOT The time there's still a long way to go before everyone let's loose forget your own bloody opinions at this time right now is NOT A TIME OF The whatifs plenty of time for reflection the best decisions are made in the cold light of day (I maybe making that up!!)
I wouldn't call it "intelligence failure". I think Caroline is being kind. The intelligence was there. It was withheld. That is a whole different ballgame. Wonder what part these two played in the recent protests where IDF reservists refused to report for duty? More to come I think.
The intelligence gathering didnot failed....the brass failed to act ...for reasons behind my understanding. The brass became woke and thi is the result
_I stand with Israel! And Caroline, i totally agree with your POV. _I automatically expected that the IDF would have to be on high alert on Israel feast days. It's hard to believe they weren't. It makes no sense. It seems very suspicious all around.
@evamarie29 When I was in Israel in the 1980s I was amazed that most of the soldiers came home for Shabbat every week, even when they were fighting in Lebanon. On Friday afternoons the buses were full of young soldiers coming home, all exhausted and fast asleep. Shabbat and YomTov (festivals) is what makes Israel unique but it's a real weakness in military terms.
If finkelman is worried about insulting terrorists, I'm wondering how he feels about what these same terrorists did to the Jewish people. This is a complete disgrace!
It is painful to hear you today, Caroline Glick. But reality is so. We keep on praying for wisdom for Israel and the decisions to take. Blessings from Chile.
Shalom Caroline. I am going mad listening to Blinken. I am also going mad at the pressure that's being placed on IDF. This is beyond madness. The hostages are released while the Hama's stooges stand and mock and frighten these hostages and being in their faces. How do people come back to what was once home? Knowing that your enemy sleeps next to you. Watching this is really doing my head in. It is written "when right becomes wrong, and wrong becomes right," the end is near. Yes too many cooks spoil the broth. It is also written "do not be deceived" and I am beginning to understand. Everything you see with your eyes might not be true or right.
Caroline is spot on. I'd go even farther than she does in suggesting alternatives. If there are any clear thinking leaders at the top, they should arrest the reigning generals who are messing thing up, take charge of the military and do the cleanup required. If they need to arrest Bibi, Gantz, Gallant etc, then get it done. While some may consider my suggestion as radical and over the top, I'll pose this question. "What is more radical, winning the war and protecting the entire nation, or continuing on with the lunacy of dead-end, leftist rhetoric"? Have we not witnessed enough jewish blood spilled for nothing? The Leftists have begun building a refrain, "We won't go back to live near Gaza". Fine, they're solidifying that there is no place safe in Israel, so head off to the good ole USA and sit down, joining arms with Chuckie Schumer and form an openly jew anti-jew club. I'm sure Shifty Schiff will join them. The stupidity of these schmucks is unbelievable. Moment by moment, they embolden Hamas and the others. The jewish blood from this mornings' terror attack in Jerusalem, is on their hands.
So much of this seems like the deliberate woke ineptitude that's taking place worldwide ever since the pandemic. It's impossible to believe that it isn't global leaders all reading from the same script... Exactly the same M.O.
I´m fully behind Israel and always was, but when you start talking about judgement days and God´s chosen people you lose me real quick. That religious graffiti IDF was writing in Gaza is absolutely terrible optics. The main war Israel is fighting is war for international opinion and by writing those stupid graffitis you gave awesome ammunition to the other side. I get it that you have your beliefs, but what´s written in some holy book means nothing to most of Europe. We support you because we see that you are defending yourself from genocidal fanatics. When you start using their language it really doesn´t help you.
Unbelievably shocking, it seems like those higher up wanted October 7 to happen, they did not do their job and to my mind are complicit in the evil incomprehensible acts of Hamas. They should resign in disgrace and be further dealt with according to law. Their action and or inaction aided and abetted Hamas. Thank you Carolyn for your work.
genuine question, why would those higher up want Oct 7 to happen? I have heard similar statements about Netanyahu wanting to hold on to power and this was a good way of doing it, but would they really sacrifice their people and allow them to suffer so much for their own ends?? Maybe they would, it just seems so inhumane.
Thank you Caroline. You have my heart and my prayers here in the UK. I am a Jewish man living in a country that wants me gone but I will not leave because I have to stand and fight. Please be safe and healthy.
Praying for God's protection over you Caroline and your family. Thank-you for sharing the truth and revealing the failures to protect the Israeli nation. Shalom for Jerusalem. 🙏🇮🇱
The more I learn about Oct 7 not being prepared the more confused and shocked I am. War is Hell. This is not a game. Thank you for your informative program. May God Bless.
Even when so-called palestinians agree they're being oppressed by Hamas, and ready to receive Israel's or other outsiders' humanitarian aide, they still, refer to Israel as occupants. None can be trusted. They should be made to and/or be willing to become official Israel citizens. Or... Get Out!
Thank you for shining light on the question we’ve all been asking since Oct 7th. The anguish of the intel professionals whose warnings were disregarded - I can’t imagine.
Here in the U.S. I have seen the same failures with our intelligence agencies,our government and some of our military leaders. We have had in my opinion some of our military commanders that are a disgrace to the uniform they wore.
Myself as a veteran of the US military in 1966 I agree with you totally. Finkelman & Haliva have the blood of Israeli civilians on their hands as well IDF soldiers. Disgraceful!
@@cmhanson Yes as a veteran myself unfortunately we have so many politicians and high ranking military that have blood on their hands including American blood. So disgusting and disgraceful.When I was serving I always respected all superior officers and those appointed above me but in reality a lot of them did not deserve that respect and did not care about anyone but themselves and their own gains and advancement. To me that is a deriliction of duty and direct violation of the oath they took. Total disgrace to the uniform they wore and all those who made the ultimate sacrifice.
You’ve become my go to for updates since October 7th. My husband and I have been asking precisely these questions and have been wish washed away by everyone saying this isn’t the time..the whole thing does seem absurd to the highest degree. Israel with its top security failed so badly and for so long? We all hope Israel’s gov isn’t that corrupt..let’s see what they continue to do with this war. Only with confidence and power will they win
Dear Carolyn my heart is breaking thinking of the devastation wrought on the state of Israel and its children and families affected due to the dereliction of duty and negligence of the head of Southern Command. Love & support from UK
Caroline - when you said that Haliva said "Hamas is deterred for five years", I immediately thought of Muhammed promising peace for Mecca for 10 years through the Treaty of al-Hudaybiya, BUT he broke the treaty after three years and attacked Mecca which was SURE they would be safe for all those 10 years and so were completely unprepared. Then, when Arafat signed the Oslo Accords and received a backlash from Arabs about it, in Arabic, he referenced the Treaty of al-Hudaybiya to remind people of what Muhammed did, as if to say, just wait, here's what we will do... and THAT is exactly what they did and have continued to do! WHEN will Haliva and the Israeli generals and so-called "intelligence" officers learn from the history that is so OBVIOUS to a simple citizen (me), but they can't see the "forest for the trees"???
Biden has to leave. Given this information I admire your IDF even more. I already got one threat on the street in a small town of France. They are feeling bold more and more. Thank you for your swift summary of this new information. How you keep going is beyond my comprehension. Enjoy your family and friends.
Well vote Le Penn ,if u want to save france ,or c Notradam become a mosque,Welders won in the neatherlands do ur part ,u have whole cities under muslim control fight or suffer ,
C'est terrible et j'espère que ça ne se reproduira pas ! On a l'impression d'être de retour dans les années 30... Je pense que l'est de la France, particulièrement, est et a toujours été assez antisémite.
I am Brazilian and however in smaller measure we are having those kind of manifestations for Hamas. I thank you for leaving no stone unturned in your explanation , which is something I suspected from day one. Israel intelligence service and the IDF are world famous for their skill so something very strange did happen. I regret not having Portuguese subtitles so that I could spread this video all over.
As student of History, I learned one thing: “As long as you don’t hold the people responsible for their leaders, you can never win any war”. Recent history since WWll will prove this correct. Your message is very powerful. Thank you for always telling us the Truth. Sometimes it’s hard medicine to follow, but in the end Truth is the best medicine! Isaac
The intelligence failures are a secondary issue. The main issue is the failure to create a credible border barrier and man it with sufficient military force. To look for a model, the Berlin Wall would have been fine. DOUBLE walls with lots of minefields and frequent closely spaced guard towers - with permanent IDF presence nearby. To argue that there was no money in the budget for that - is unacceptable. If you are not willing to budget for that - you have no country. They even allowed Hamas to practice with bulldozers near the border - I suppose the idea was that they were going to use the bulldozers to build agricultural fields?
I loved the video, Caroline. I was wondering since the day of the massacre what had happened and thought it would only be, once the war is over, that the details would come to light. I am sorry to have to say I don't believe it was due only to their negligence, or dumbness. Too many things failed and the fact that not one, but the two generals who were involved were equally useless, sounds really suspicious. They should undoubtedly be removed from their duties without any further delay, an even detained and indicted to prevent them from making any further decisions and from having access to intel info. And they should await trial under house arrest.
It's suspicious to me that these generals are still in place. I also don't understand why 6:30 an would be any different than any other time of day, do they not sleep in shifts?! Our bases in the US never sleep.
I support Israel 🇮🇱. I am so ashamed of the US!! God said if we support Israel we will be blessed. I believe that is why US is going to the devil. Carolyn, much prayers and thank you for the truth!!
I also am ashamed of our government. I guess this is why the US is not in Bible prophecy; our own government is bringing on our demise. If you dig for truth you will find we have the most corrupt government in the world. We Stand with Israel and support the Jewish people, and we mourn with them
I really enjoy your show Caroline, keep the information coming so we can stay informed. Your one of the best sources for news and info in Israel. The three best sources are Chuck Holten, The Ruben Report and of course you being at the top. It would be great to see you and Chuck Holton do a show together. 🇺🇸💙🇮🇱
Wow! Caroline,you're amazing! I've been wondering, since 7th October, how on earth this could possibly have happened. Thanks for such a clear breakdown of events,since way back,and thanks for your bold conclusion about the Generals. Praying that your message is heard where it counts. And yes,we're standing with Israel ,praying with all our hearts.
That is the question. Were those idiots put in those positions of power because they are idiots? Is the Treason above them? Who is directly above them? We need to know.
You are an Amazing Lady who is providing Such Clarity about how this Tragedy was Allowed to happen….You are providing a Wonderful Service to Israel and the civilized people of the World who are trying to understand how this Tragedy Happened and what steps must be taken to ensure it will Never Happen Again ‼️
Sack the weak links! Netanyahu better wise up lest he take the blame for these higher-ups dereliction of duty! Insane epic failures!!!! Caroline you are a brilliant capable woman! God bless you!!!
Another very important factor is that the investigation needs not only to root out the incompetents that have somehow manipulated themselves to the top, but identify who selected, supported, endorsed & ratified these incompetents on their way to the top. It sounds a lot like this is a prime case of personnel not being elevated because of their competence, but who they know, who they have allied themselves with. Both elements have lost sight of what is truly important and what truly matters……with tragic results.
I don’t understand this either! Why ignore all these signs. The only realistic excuse I’ve heard is that Tel Aviv understood that the Abraham Accords agreement signed was a security all together. This means they felt the Abraham Accords were so important to Arab countries that nothing this dangerous would happen. :.(
@@joanofarc6402 lots of these people are corrupt and really don’t care about Israel and are members of the world economic forum run by klaus Schwab. You can look it over. Bibi and Bennett and Barack and lapid are there.
Finally ...someone has the guts to speak. The truth and blame those who are responsible for what happened on October 7th how did could something like this happened how can Israel allow this to happened!
Whoever is responsible for ignoring the warnings the soldiers on the border tried to warn about what was happening doesn't need to just be relieved-they need to go to prison because they aided and abetted what Hamas did.
I hope and pray that the Government of Israel is listening to EVERY word that this wise woman is saying!!! PLEASE, OPEN YOUR EARS!!! We are praying for you. Much love from South Africa
It sounds similar to the disaster in Hawaii in that officials were missing when the crisis happened. Totally different but plenty of Americans ignore mainstream media and wonder at true cause of what happened there. Just as we stand with the people of Israel and our Jewish communities. We pray for truth to surface and wisdom to prevail for Israel, Caroline! We pray for you to be undergirded with strength to continue this important work. Thank you!
I live in Maui, and yes it’s absolutely insanity with what we’ve seen with officials and so forth. Too many anomalies that make you go 🤔. We stand with Israel.
Thank you Caroline for the clear information and for naming them. It also appears clearly to me that those two generals are on the left side of the spectrum and would request pronouns in the IDF if they could, and put some rainbow flags on their tanks entering gaza. It is about time they are dismissed and send to their colored paintings. We need way more stronger leaders. And it has to be deeply investigated of course
You’re briefing here is awesome. essentialized, passionate. reasoned, full of compelling evidence. Greatly appreciated! Consider me a friend and admirer. You have become my favorite analyst & commentator.
Thank you Caroline for this thorough account of the unforgivable arrogance that led to this carnage. Your great insight are always so helpful in the understanding the understandable.
I really thought that Natanyahu and the war cabinet, would put the 9 million Israelis citizens, before the hostages ! I was truly disappointed when they accepted the deal with Hamas ! I understood that since Hamas was dictating the terms, Israel had lost the war ! Thanks to Caroline, info on the generals running this sensitive units, I understand why the government has taken this course ! God help us all !
No, you don't know why the generals accepted the operational pause. In fact, I'm sure they used it to observe a lot of the comings and goings of Hamas and in the last 6 days since they started again, they have made great gains.
Oh Caroline! I have so appreciated your insight and knowledge... and heart for your people! Your passion for justice and righteousness... for fairness and truth. God bless you Dearheart! I hope you take a real Sabbath.. and rest... your voice sounds so tired. Shalom .❤
That's what happens when you let the Left lead. "The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left. Even as fools walk along the road, they lack sense and show everyone how stupid they are." Ecclesiastes 10:2-3 NIV
Thank you Caroline, I am a big fan and very grateful for your honest reporting and exposing the truth. Please stay safe. Sending love and prayers. Am Yisrael Chai
Every Jew in Israel should be allowed to carry a gun. I was there in March and found out how restrictive gun ownership was. I thought how stupid this is.
But the leftist shmucks in government won’t allow this. They all have blood on their hands. I guess they want something far more devastating to happen to Israeli.
Gun sales in America have gone up
…Amen. The Israeli’s NEED a 2A!
I agree from over here in America where we have more guns than people in my family to use at once with every appendage. I don’t think Israelis would use them for harm but just to protect themselves. After Oct 7th I’d say it’s a must. I’d say it’s the first thing the government should do is teach them all how to use a firearm and get them all guns. But I hear Biden is making sure the citizens of Israel don’t get the guns from the US. It makes me mad. I’d pay extra taxes or just donate so the US could make sure every Jew ish adult could have a gun and training on how to use it. They are being hunted by pure evil.
Agreed agreed
This is appalling. As a former defence intelligence officer I have studied various failures. It is hard to find a parallel. Intelligence needs interpretation and is always uncertain to some degree. It is easy to see in retrospective which should have been acted on and which disregarded. But this failure is different. It is straightforward denial. I have experienced reluctance to believe reports because they are too horrible to contemplate, but surely not in a command on the border of the territory of an enemy with a track record of terror. Glick is right. these officers must be dismissed in disgrace.
Denial is a state when one reflects on personal flaws or failures, etc., in one’s own private life. Staff to ponder with your shrink
When one is in charge with the of country existence , responsible for lives of thousands citizens , there is no place for denial, and contemplation, it is time to act. Wilfully ignoring intel from many sources is treason , plain and simple. A decent person would resign immediately and stop to exist. Generals have personal guns, don’t they?
It's NOT like israelis r not intelligent ,,but a few devious individuals with backing from outside Israel sabotaged every
@@4eversearchI disagree. Military people generally try to make the right decision. They sometimes get it wrong and as result people might die. That's life in the Armed Forces. It is not traitorous, just a costly mistake.. there should be an enquiry to establish the facts and whether the individual making the decision is culpable or not.
Acting without contemplation is usually going off half cocked and dangerous. At the level of a general most of his time should be spent thinking, not acting.
@@petergardner760 yes, military people, who are honest patriots mostly make right decision, and if things go wrong, it is inspire of their best efforts, not because they are not honest , not patriots, they are just traitors , who put politics above their direct obligation of guarding their country and its citizens. Or, even more simple, they were bought out by Israel enemies. Not a new scheme
Apparently the people in the settlements noticed quit a bit of movement across the border and nothing was done.
With generals like Finkleman you don't need any more enemies. God with Israel🙏🇮🇱 Not with fools.
Finkelstein must be in the leftist camp and ironically, the peace activist from the southern envelope who were taken hostage by the very people whom they support.
time for court martials
He didn't want to be bothered, and now he's worried about what the foreign press thinks about some "kilroy was here" graffiti?
Who's paying him under the desk
I feel the same about the lame Biden administration.
It's like complete *ssh*ts, and incompetents are running the show.
Very painful to watch.
We still gotta' fight as hard as we can though.
This was incredibly informative but also incredibly depressing. Thank you Caroline for reporting on what no one else is talking about. These generals should be subject to court martial.
My wife and I fully agree with your assessment and stand with and pray for Israel. I know many others here in the US do as well. Keep up the good work of proclaiming the truth.
❤ AMEN ❤
TRUST NO MAN
Somebody has to tell this fact to Israelis the chief fail and must be fired. I think they receibe money from Qatar to ignore this information. Please check their banck account in order to see if they were paid for the enemies.
You guys are being duped, and are likely historically and politically illiterate as fuck..
Do your homework. Zionism has always been the Reich Wing..
The
@@josephpecoraro912 what. ?
Pleasure and very reassuring to hear Caroline Glick, a loyal patriot and objective reporter 👑💪🏼🇮🇱
Thank you Caroline. Those 2 generals should be accountable for gross negligence at least & should be fired.
…not only fired.and then go home and enjoy their lives and probably receive pensions??
No, they have to be tried by military court or tribunal for TREASON AND COMPLICITY IN MURDER
@@4eversearchyou are right
AND COURT MARTIALLED
@@4eversearch agreed!
How high does this conspiracy go? What did Netanyahu know? I don't trust him. This is shocking stuff. Could it have been a blatant political chess move to save him?
You are a voice of reason and compassion in a dificult situation. God bless you for your voice against tyranny.
Caroline Glick is such an intelligent person who speaks common sense in the midst of all the confusion of Middle East affairs
Brilliant assessment ...so good to hear truths no bullshit
Well said.
Sorry I am commenting again Caroline, you know you rarely see a nativity scene anywhere now, plenty of Santa's, they are everywhere, no Carol singers. Now no Christmas trees. WAKE UP CRAZY WORLD, THERE IS A MASSIVE PRICE TO BE PAID. GETTING RID OF THE JEWS IS GETTING RID OF GOD. 😔😪
Yes she is.
Gods self appointed chosen (mostly atheists)
I know all this religious nonsense is not genuine when I see your IDF soldiers riding around taking pictures with lgbtq flags hoisted in Gaza
Jews have lead to secularization and polluted the holy lands. God know how many strip clubs you people brought there in the open.
Shame shame Gods chosen (mostly atheists)
I fully agree with and support Caroline Click. We were, are and will be surrounded by sworn enemies. Analyzing and fixing our mistakes is far more important than near-sighted "defeating Hamas".
You are absolutely wrong. You cannot tolerate letting an organization who is totally committed to the destruction of Israel remain your neighbor. No nation can allow terrorism to thrive.
Thank you for pointing out the failure of this man. I always see people railing only at Netanyahu on the failure. But it’s not all on him alone
Its hard to be a globalist and pretend to protect their own country...its all a pretext for the "secret" agenda that everyone knows about.
not even a little bit is on the PM
Hmm, maybe more than not even a little bit. He is seeming to go along with this bogus cease fire isnt he?@@christamead
He doesn't make military decisions, or analyze all the intel, that's what the generals are for.
Yes, but doesnt his authority supercede everyones if need be? I think he is under alot of pressure though, and peer pressure..@@Lego-vp3sz
Thank you so much Caroline. We're very lucky we have someone like you speaking out and making sense in these terribly dark times.
Finklestein clearly needs a new position.Janitor at the UN schools in Gaza would suit him fine.There appears to be a massive problem with arrogance in the upper echelons of the IDF.My heart goes out to the soldiers and citizens & families who have been sacrificed.
Even janitor in gaza might be above his pay scale...
NO!!
A Deep Dark Dungeon for both those "Generals" !!!
@@bendewet1057you are right, deep dark dungeon….
The commander of the Israeli Southern Command is Major General Yaron Finkelman.
Norman Finkelstein is a political scientist and activist who defends the Palestinian cause by criticizing Israel.
IMO, Finkelstein has caused more harm than Finkelman, but it's a close race.
@@rightclick7266I was just thinking the same. Possibly the word “Fink” at the beginning of the name is a give away. (Apologies to decent Finkwhatevers.)
I am so truly grateful for telling the truth of the negligence that happened on 7/10.These people should be held accountable 💔
I don’t know if Caroline would like to be in politics, but I’d sure love her to be in charge because she has got her stuff together. This is so valuable to people too. I’m American but we need people like her making changes over here too. God bless Israel.
Agree, Joan. She'd be dynamite.
Could not be more in agreement!
❤ AMEN ❤
I agree. She's like a young Golda Meir
I ran for office and won . Then, the hard work began.
A real source of what is happening and what needs to be done . A great advocate for Israel 🇮🇱 in a world full of lies.
Caroline, if only there were people like you in powerful positions to put an end to this once and for all. It's regrettable that politics gets in the way and that there are such double standards and hypocrisy. It is sickening. You are an inspiration with common sense. Thank you.
I'm in the U.S. For accurate information on the the Middle East, I come to Caroline and JNS.
I agree! Caroline should be heard! And lead.
So, this begs the question, Did the Israeli Government perpetrate this invasion?...why? What did the government have to gain from disregarding this intelligence that Hamas was getting ready to attack?
I have a problem with Netanyahu wanting State Israel to be the example of being fully vaccinated before many other countries. Where is his allegiance? Isn't he a member of the CFR? 😮
She’s a propagandist..
This is so hard to believe, I just don’t know what to say…thank you Caroline for your brilliant reporting. May God give you strength for continuing your work.
This is crushingly depressing to listen to. Carolyn is organized, clear and compelling. Extremely extremely painful to contemplate the possibility that that slaughter possibly could've been prevented or mitigated.
IT IS BEYOND DISGUSTING. THESE TWO GENERALS MUST GO.
Definitely. Israel 🇮🇱 got too at ease
Those Two "Generals" must be charged with Treason against the Israeli People!!
No point crying about spilt milk. She is not organized, clear and compelling, her voice is quivering with rage.
it was obvious to me, if you go back a few months the lefty military made a comment that if Israel goes to war they will not send troops, that was a red flag!
Blessings to you Caroline for speaking out. From the UK.
Woke Generals woke politicians will eventually cause the down fall of any country....
I suppose also.❤
💯
You don’t say, lol..
You are a wonderful lady, Caroline, never afraid to speak the truth. I and my family do stand with Israel, always have. We pray daily for Israel, the IDF, for PM Netanyahu, for you and your family.
Caroline, thank you for being courageous enough to tell the truth! You are so right that Israel must win, not just for your sakes, but also for the sake of every democratic country that Islam hates. Be assured I am standing with you even though I am not a Jew and live in the UK. Thank you - keep spreading the truth!
I’m also wondering why US intelligence didn’t send a huge alert to Israeli politicians AND military?
I really think ALL OF OUR really expensive intelligence FAILED!
There’s got to be more to this story. Intelligence and National Security doesn’t just go through 1 military person.
It’s so sad that a powerful iIsraeli intelligence failed. Hope there will be repercussions for this negligence.
Yeh let's not go there yet everyone is reeling I'm sure it'll all come out in the wash but now is NOT The time there's still a long way to go before everyone let's loose forget your own bloody opinions at this time right now is NOT A TIME OF The whatifs plenty of time for reflection the best decisions are made in the cold light of day (I maybe making that up!!)
I wouldn't call it "intelligence failure". I think Caroline is being kind. The intelligence was there. It was withheld. That is a whole different ballgame. Wonder what part these two played in the recent protests where IDF reservists refused to report for duty? More to come I think.
They did not even try
There will be a lot of blame game, which is divisive. It leads to defeat.
The intelligence gathering didnot failed....the brass failed to act ...for reasons behind my understanding.
The brass became woke and thi is the result
_I stand with Israel! And Caroline, i totally agree with your POV.
_I automatically expected that the IDF would have to be on high alert on Israel feast days. It's hard to believe they weren't. It makes no sense. It seems very suspicious all around.
@evamarie29 When I was in Israel in the 1980s I was amazed that most of the soldiers came home for Shabbat every week, even when they were fighting in Lebanon. On Friday afternoons the buses were full of young soldiers coming home, all exhausted and fast asleep. Shabbat and YomTov (festivals) is what makes Israel unique but it's a real weakness in military terms.
God bless you Caroline! I pray Israel prevails 🇮🇱🙏
If finkelman is worried about insulting terrorists, I'm wondering how he feels about what these same terrorists did to the Jewish people. This is a complete disgrace!
It is painful to hear you today, Caroline Glick. But reality is so. We keep on praying for wisdom for Israel and the decisions to take. Blessings from Chile.
God Bless you Caroline. You are the only source I have found of the truth of what is happening in this fight.
Thank you Caroline
I STAND WITH ISRAEL.
Thank you Caroline for your truthful reporting. Great job as always. Accurate and in depth. 🇮🇱🇺🇸✝️
Shalom Caroline. I am going mad listening to Blinken. I am also going mad at the pressure that's being placed on IDF. This is beyond madness. The hostages are released while the Hama's stooges stand and mock and frighten these hostages and being in their faces. How do people come back to what was once home? Knowing that your enemy sleeps next to you. Watching this is really doing my head in. It is written "when right becomes wrong, and wrong becomes right," the end is near. Yes too many cooks spoil the broth. It is also written "do not be deceived" and I am beginning to understand. Everything you see with your eyes might not be true or right.
Agree, Blinken Biden and others woke sick people should Go Go Go ..,
Caroline is spot on.
I'd go even farther than she does in suggesting alternatives. If there are any clear thinking leaders at the top, they should arrest the reigning generals who are messing thing up, take charge of the military and do the cleanup required. If they need to arrest Bibi, Gantz, Gallant etc, then get it done. While some may consider my suggestion as radical and over the top, I'll pose this question. "What is more radical, winning the war and protecting the entire nation, or continuing on with the lunacy of dead-end, leftist rhetoric"?
Have we not witnessed enough jewish blood spilled for nothing? The Leftists have begun building a refrain, "We won't go back to live near Gaza". Fine, they're solidifying that there is no place safe in Israel, so head off to the good ole USA and sit down, joining arms with Chuckie Schumer and form an openly jew anti-jew club. I'm sure Shifty Schiff will join them.
The stupidity of these schmucks is unbelievable. Moment by moment, they embolden Hamas and the others. The jewish blood from this mornings' terror attack in Jerusalem, is on their hands.
I do not know why I cannot even watch his face on TV 7???
So much of this seems like the deliberate woke ineptitude that's taking place worldwide ever since the pandemic.
It's impossible to believe that it isn't global leaders all reading from the same script... Exactly the same M.O.
I´m fully behind Israel and always was, but when you start talking about judgement days and God´s chosen people you lose me real quick. That religious graffiti IDF was writing in Gaza is absolutely terrible optics. The main war Israel is fighting is war for international opinion and by writing those stupid graffitis you gave awesome ammunition to the other side. I get it that you have your beliefs, but what´s written in some holy book means nothing to most of Europe. We support you because we see that you are defending yourself from genocidal fanatics. When you start using their language it really doesn´t help you.
Excellent reporting , probally the most sane speaking in all this ..put this woman in charge .
Unbelievably shocking, it seems like those higher up wanted October 7 to happen, they did not do their job and to my mind are complicit in the evil incomprehensible acts of Hamas. They should resign in disgrace and be further dealt with according to law. Their action and or inaction aided and abetted Hamas. Thank you Carolyn for your work.
genuine question, why would those higher up want Oct 7 to happen? I have heard similar statements about Netanyahu wanting to hold on to power and this was a good way of doing it, but would they really sacrifice their people and allow them to suffer so much for their own ends?? Maybe they would, it just seems so inhumane.
Totally agree.
Hamas agents?
Nathaniau is a criminal and a psychopat, for sure he would sacrifice his own people!
They all would. As we all know, mainly psychopats run for power!
This is heartbreaking and infuriating. How can they be held accountable?
Thank you Caroline. You have my heart and my prayers here in the UK. I am a Jewish man living in a country that wants me gone but I will not leave because I have to stand and fight. Please be safe and healthy.
You shouldn't have to leave but you do belong in Israel the jewish homeland
At some point you may be overwhelmed and not able to fight this madness. You may be safer and better off in Israel. God bless you and protect you
I am glad you are with us in the UK - I don't want you gone but I do want you safe.
I am sorry my country and my useless government are letting this happen. 🇬🇧😥
Praying for God's protection over you Caroline and your family. Thank-you for sharing the truth and revealing the failures to protect the Israeli nation. Shalom for Jerusalem. 🙏🇮🇱
These generals need to be in jail. Their negligence cost hundreds of lives.
So right. They betrayed the Israeli people.
Thousands of lives
@@webdoar and thousands of injuries, physical and psychological.
All of is real should be locked up.
Only if you don't consider Arabs people. I know you don't...
The more I learn about Oct 7 not being prepared the more confused and shocked I am. War is Hell. This is not a game. Thank you for your informative program. May God Bless.
Casualties were ♟in🇮🇱 leadership greater expansion agenda
You can not have peace with a people who not only refuse to accept your right to exist. The refuse to live in peace with Israel.
Even when so-called palestinians agree they're being oppressed by Hamas, and ready to receive Israel's or other outsiders' humanitarian aide, they still, refer to Israel as occupants. None can be trusted. They should be made to and/or be willing to become official Israel citizens. Or... Get Out!
Thank you for shining light on the question we’ve all been asking since Oct 7th. The anguish of the intel professionals whose warnings were disregarded - I can’t imagine.
Thank You Caroline.
In Regards to Intelligence Unit, Do We Have a Senior Traitor Within ??
I Seriously Agree.🙏
When you have evil in the ranks like Finkelman & Haliva how much more senior do you need?
I asked myself whether there was a sabotage?
No doubts in my mind that sabotage it was
I would be looking at ALL U N CONNECTIONS , ALL OF THEM ,!
Thank You for your rational insight!
Here in the U.S. I have seen the same failures with our intelligence agencies,our government and some of our military leaders. We have had in my opinion some of our military commanders that are a disgrace to the uniform they wore.
Yes, and the same thing is going to happen here in the US soon I'm afraid
@@sirkaya1 Yes here in the U.S. we currently have the worst most incompetent administration in our history
Myself as a veteran of the US military in 1966 I agree with you totally. Finkelman & Haliva have the blood of Israeli civilians on their hands as well IDF soldiers. Disgraceful!
‘Failing’ on purpose.
@@cmhanson Yes as a veteran myself unfortunately we have so many politicians and high ranking military that have blood on their hands including American blood. So disgusting and disgraceful.When I was serving I always respected all superior officers and those appointed above me but in reality a lot of them did not deserve that respect and did not care about anyone but themselves and their own gains and advancement. To me that is a deriliction of duty and direct violation of the oath they took. Total disgrace to the uniform they wore and all those who made the ultimate sacrifice.
The critical takeaway is that the US is playing both sides.
I just love your passion and bold truth. So refreshing for us to hear truth. Thank you
You’ve become my go to for updates since October 7th. My husband and I have been asking precisely these questions and have been wish washed away by everyone saying this isn’t the time..the whole thing does seem absurd to the highest degree. Israel with its top security failed so badly and for so long? We all hope Israel’s gov isn’t that corrupt..let’s see what they continue to do with this war. Only with confidence and power will they win
National security minister >>>>
Dear Carolyn my heart is breaking thinking of the devastation wrought on the state of Israel and its children and families affected due to the dereliction of duty and negligence of the head of Southern Command. Love & support from UK
Thank you for your hard work
Thank you, Caroline, for being "up front" and "in focus". Tell us what is really going on !
Thank you so much for everything you have said, very informative. Take care and God bless you.❤❤❤
Caroline - when you said that Haliva said "Hamas is deterred for five years", I immediately thought of Muhammed promising peace for Mecca for 10 years through the Treaty of al-Hudaybiya, BUT he broke the treaty after three years and attacked Mecca which was SURE they would be safe for all those 10 years and so were completely unprepared. Then, when Arafat signed the Oslo Accords and received a backlash from Arabs about it, in Arabic, he referenced the Treaty of al-Hudaybiya to remind people of what Muhammed did, as if to say, just wait, here's what we will do... and THAT is exactly what they did and have continued to do! WHEN will Haliva and the Israeli generals and so-called "intelligence" officers learn from the history that is so OBVIOUS to a simple citizen (me), but they can't see the "forest for the trees"???
It's called a mirror. Look into it sometime.
thank you Caroline! you are an incredible journalist, so detailed, so informative, and unapologetic! thank you!!!
Biden has to leave. Given this information I admire your IDF even more. I already got one threat on the street in a small town of France. They are feeling bold more and more. Thank you for your swift summary of this new information. How you keep going is beyond my comprehension. Enjoy your family and friends.
Be Safe
Well vote Le Penn ,if u want to save france ,or c Notradam become a mosque,Welders won in the neatherlands do ur part ,u have whole cities under muslim control fight or suffer ,
May God keep you safe and report any threats to the police.
C'est terrible et j'espère que ça ne se reproduira pas ! On a l'impression d'être de retour dans les années 30... Je pense que l'est de la France, particulièrement, est et a toujours été assez antisémite.
I am Brazilian and however in smaller measure we are having those kind of manifestations for Hamas. I thank you for leaving no stone unturned in your explanation , which is something I suspected from day one. Israel intelligence service and the IDF are world famous for their skill so something very strange did happen. I regret not having Portuguese subtitles so that I could spread this video all over.
Ridiculous- since when do we care about hurt feelings in war ?! 😡
The enemy is diabolical but the officials not taking it seriously is even worse by assisting the enemy.
Thank you Caroline. Keep it up! You are wonderful, and the sane world needs to hear.
As student of History, I learned one thing: “As long as you don’t hold the people responsible for their leaders, you can never win any war”. Recent history since WWll will prove this correct. Your message is very powerful. Thank you for always telling us the Truth. Sometimes it’s hard medicine to follow, but in the end Truth is the best medicine! Isaac
The intelligence failures are a secondary issue. The main issue is the failure to create a credible border barrier and man it with sufficient military force. To look for a model, the Berlin Wall would have been fine. DOUBLE walls with lots of minefields and frequent closely spaced guard towers - with permanent IDF presence nearby. To argue that there was no money in the budget for that - is unacceptable. If you are not willing to budget for that - you have no country. They even allowed Hamas to practice with bulldozers near the border - I suppose the idea was that they were going to use the bulldozers to build agricultural fields?
I grew up with borders that didn’t look like what the sensitives did in Gaza
No border barrier will be effective with traitors in charge within. I am not talking about Netanyahu.
@@evegoodmon Don't understand your comment.
But...but then it's an open air prison. A concentration camp....blah blah blah
berlin wall was built to keep people in...not to defend
Thank you, Caroline, for pointing this out. Amazing.
I loved the video, Caroline. I was wondering since the day of the massacre what had happened and thought it would only be, once the war is over, that the details would come to light. I am sorry to have to say I don't believe it was due only to their negligence, or dumbness. Too many things failed and the fact that not one, but the two generals who were involved were equally useless, sounds really suspicious. They should undoubtedly be removed from their duties without any further delay, an even detained and indicted to prevent them from making any further decisions and from having access to intel info. And they should await trial under house arrest.
It's suspicious to me that these generals are still in place. I also don't understand why 6:30 an would be any different than any other time of day, do they not sleep in shifts?! Our bases in the US never sleep.
I support Israel 🇮🇱. I am so ashamed of the US!! God said if we support Israel we will be blessed. I believe that is why US is going to the devil. Carolyn, much prayers and thank you for the truth!!
I also am ashamed of our government. I guess this is why the US is not in Bible prophecy; our own government is bringing on our demise. If you dig for truth you will find we have the most corrupt government in the world. We Stand with Israel and support the Jewish people, and we mourn with them
I really enjoy your show Caroline, keep the information coming so we can stay informed. Your one of the best sources for news and info in Israel. The three best sources are Chuck Holten, The Ruben Report and of course you being at the top. It would be great to see you and Chuck Holton do a show together.
🇺🇸💙🇮🇱
These people are so unbelievable. Every news cast shows only the Gaza people and "Palestinian suffering" is sickening.
Wow! Caroline,you're amazing! I've been wondering, since 7th October, how on earth this could possibly have happened. Thanks for such a clear breakdown of events,since way back,and thanks for your bold conclusion about the Generals. Praying that your message is heard where it counts.
And yes,we're standing with Israel ,praying with all our hearts.
Sounds like total incompetence or treason.
Smells like 9/11
That is the question. Were those idiots put in those positions of power because they are idiots? Is the Treason above them? Who is directly above them? We need to know.
I'm glad I discovered your great channel! I'm an American Jew and everyone in my family STANDS WITH ISRAEL!
You are an Amazing Lady who is providing Such Clarity about how this Tragedy was Allowed to happen….You are providing a Wonderful Service to Israel and the civilized people of the World who are trying to understand how this Tragedy Happened and what steps must be taken to ensure it will Never Happen Again ‼️
This needs to go viral.
Sack the weak links! Netanyahu better wise up lest he take the blame for these higher-ups dereliction of duty! Insane epic failures!!!! Caroline you are a brilliant capable woman! God bless you!!!
Another very important factor is that the investigation needs not only to root out the incompetents that have somehow manipulated themselves to the top, but identify who selected, supported, endorsed & ratified these incompetents on their way to the top. It sounds a lot like this is a prime case of personnel not being elevated because of their competence, but who they know, who they have allied themselves with. Both elements have lost sight of what is truly important and what truly matters……with tragic results.
Why. Why. Why?? I still stand with Israel and always will, but don't understand why the General Staff didn't act.
Corruption in high places
Were they paid???
I don’t understand this either! Why ignore all these signs.
The only realistic excuse I’ve heard is that Tel Aviv understood that the Abraham Accords agreement signed was a security all together. This means they felt the Abraham Accords were so important to Arab countries that nothing this dangerous would happen. :.(
@@joanofarc6402 lots of these people are corrupt and really don’t care about Israel and are members of the world economic forum run by klaus Schwab. You can look it over. Bibi and Bennett and Barack and lapid are there.
@joanofarc6402 They sacrificed their own people to fulfill the final solution and it's not working very well...
Finally ...someone has the guts to speak. The truth and blame those who are responsible for what happened on October 7th how did could something like this happened how can Israel allow this to happened!
Whoever is responsible for ignoring the warnings the soldiers on the border tried to warn about what was happening doesn't need to just be relieved-they need to go to prison because they aided and abetted what Hamas did.
Exactly.
Caroline, keep speaking TRUTH, the world is in so much need of hearing TRUTH.
Too true wise one
Allowed to happen for greater 🇮🇱 expansion agenda = casualties ♟in the game = ♟🩸♟💥♟
Caroline, you are so right.
Wonderful reporting, thank you!
Really love your show. Brilliant reporting
I hope and pray that the Government of Israel is listening to EVERY word that this wise woman is saying!!! PLEASE, OPEN YOUR EARS!!! We are praying for you. Much love from South Africa
It sounds similar to the disaster in Hawaii in that officials were missing when the crisis happened. Totally different but plenty of Americans ignore mainstream media and wonder at true cause of what happened there. Just as we stand with the people of Israel and our Jewish communities. We pray for truth to surface and wisdom to prevail for Israel, Caroline! We pray for you to be undergirded with strength to continue this important work. Thank you!
Yes, I noticed eery similarities also!!
Agenda whatever.
I live in Maui, and yes it’s absolutely insanity with what we’ve seen with officials and so forth. Too many anomalies that make you go 🤔. We stand with Israel.
Thank you Caroline for the clear information and for naming them. It also appears clearly to me that those two generals are on the left side of the spectrum and would request pronouns in the IDF if they could, and put some rainbow flags on their tanks entering gaza. It is about time they are dismissed and send to their colored paintings. We need way more stronger leaders. And it has to be deeply investigated of course
Caroline YOU ARE 100% CORRECT
She always is
You’re briefing here is awesome. essentialized, passionate. reasoned, full of compelling evidence. Greatly appreciated! Consider me a friend and admirer. You have become my favorite analyst & commentator.
We dont send our children to Gaza to erase grafiti. Shame to this Officer.
People used to get shot for being asleep on night watch!!
Thank you Caroline for this thorough account of the unforgivable arrogance that led to this carnage. Your great insight are always so helpful in the understanding the understandable.
I really thought that Natanyahu and the war cabinet, would put the 9 million Israelis citizens, before the hostages !
I was truly disappointed when they accepted the deal with Hamas ! I understood that since Hamas was dictating the terms, Israel had lost the war ! Thanks to Caroline, info on the generals running this sensitive units, I understand why the government has taken this course !
God help us all !
No, you don't know why the generals accepted the operational pause. In fact, I'm sure they used it to observe a lot of the comings and goings of Hamas and in the last 6 days since they started again, they have made great gains.
Oh Caroline! I have so appreciated your insight and knowledge... and heart for your people! Your passion for justice and righteousness... for fairness and truth.
God bless you Dearheart!
I hope you take a real Sabbath.. and rest... your voice sounds so tired.
Shalom .❤
Thank you for being honest and pointing out the failed military leadership failure. Would tge US had reporters like you
Thank you for your diligent persistence
Thank you Caroline, for this alarming report, it's unbelievable. 😢 I really feel for the hostage's 💔 my prayers are for Israel 🙏🇮🇱
Fantastic speech!!!❤
That's what happens when you let the Left lead. "The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left. Even as fools walk along the road, they lack sense and show everyone how stupid they are." Ecclesiastes 10:2-3 NIV
Oh, my G-d..I would have never-ever realize this. Bless be you by Hashem our Lord for the wisdom and knowledge you have...
The perfect verse to what I've suspected has happened in Israel.
Thank you so much for all of your reporting!!
Thank you Caroline.
You are so appreciated.
Very rare to find such straightforward informative reporting.
Thank you, Caroline. You are truly a voice crying in the wilderness.
Thank you Caroline, I am a big fan and very grateful for your honest reporting and exposing the truth. Please stay safe. Sending love and prayers. Am Yisrael Chai
thank you Carolyn for explaining all of this.
Caroline, your words fall upon deaf ears. Our insane world is not capable of hearing or accepting the truth.
Keep speaking truth!
Never never never never give up!!