@@snap7749 If you drop ~$200 on a couple packs of Roxul S&S and 1x8s, spend a weekend building and installing, you'll be glad you did. If only to improve the 1khz+ range... broadband absorption at first reflection points goes a very long way. I took some recording classes in college many years ago- my professor had decades of professional experience under his belt. He couldn't say enough good things about Roxul Safe & Sound. Absorption and diffusion is a gamechanger, and it doesn't cost much at all. Less than a cheap pair of studio monitors. Room treatment should come first. Your system is only as good as the room it's in. The room has far more of an impact than some esoteric DAC/amplifier combo, let alone cone materials. Don't get me started on fancy speaker wires, bahahaha.
On my mediocre headphones sounds better without the treatment. With treatment is More narrow and focused (sound stage) with a little more detail. Voices are like going near or through some pillows. I usually like some reflections... To me nature sounds, real voices, live concerts have a certain degree of reflection. So if it is too focused it sounds a little strange and muffled. Bass sound a little tighter, just a little I have no perfect years and not an expensive gear, plus RUclips compression, so don't take my word :D Very good comparison and setup!
This is one of the best audio videos I have seen. If this does not convince someone of the importance of room treatment nothing will. You have probably both improved the listening experience of your viewers significantly and saved them a whole lot of money since room treatment is a lot cheaper than electronics and speakers. Well done.
always start with the room! so long as you have some nice gear then you will hear everything it has to offer in a good room. like an old friend said to me, if you have great speakers & a poor amp & source, you will at least hear the best they have to offer. if you have poor speakers & a great source then you are destroying the sound of your source. The same applys to the room. you can have the best gear but if you can't hear it you could have got away with an all in one from the local electronics store.
Ron, I agree that these are some of the best videos you have ever done. The superiority of this series lies in its 1-2-3 punch: 1. You TEACH in a calm, organized, non judgmental matter. 2. You allow the viewers to HEAR for themselves the improvements each step of the way. Sort of like "a picture beats a thousand words principle." 3. You back up any subjectivity objections with MEASUREMENTS and graphs. These three punches satisfy the novice and the experienced, the hearing focused and the measurement crowd. Well done. As somebody who cares about the audiophile community, may I humbly offer up a suggestion? Could you better package this series with a general heading of your choice combined with subheadings for each video. This series is too good to be hidden or only viewed in partiality. Right now I find the videos too disjointed from each other by titles. Having a main heading and sub headings with each video develops a continuum that helps people identify it as part of a series and in what order. An off the cuff example might be the following: Room Treatment A to Z. Part One - Untreated Part Two - Adding Room Furnishings Part Three - Bass traps Etc, etc. This simple step will generate more views, which is what I would like to see. Having a main title and subtitle with each video will also make it possible to add to this series in the future as you see fit as it develops into a master class. Frankly it's approaching that already, certainly from a RUclips perspective at the very least. Lastly, I hope you round off your series with some dsp additions. There's still a bit of voodoo surrounding that topic, at least for me. Thanks again Ron.
I did not take any of the work that you did here as an attempt to show off or be prideful. I truly appreciate the dedication and information that you have shared. Please continue to keep up the good work and sharing the knowledge.
I’m in the process of treating my room. After years of reading, watching videos and procrastination I’m finally ready to start implementing what I’ve learned. I’ll definitely be referring back to this series as I go along. Thanks for taking the time to do these
This series has been wonderful. I decided a long time ago the room, treatment of it and placement of speakers within it was ~80% of the audiophile equation. You are helping other folks understand that. Kudos!!
There must be a ton of people out there who have spent a lot of time and money (me included) swapping out equipment (mainly speakers) to try and find the right sound, without realizing the room is the issue! Your series of videos are simply fantastic. Glad you had the foresight an resources to put them together. There certainly is no argument as to what can be achieved with the right approach and mind set. I am fortunate enough to have a tolerant wife and she has let me do all sorts of crazy stuff to the room achieve a better sound. All I can say is, it's worth the effort. Sit back and enjoy the music....
I went did it. After working with asc on my room which is a dedicated room which I built. It’s 19’ x 28 1/2’ with 12’ ceilings and no windows or openings. After going through different equipment and speakers before treatment by asc . I now know what my equipment sounds like which is a lot better than I thought. My bass is unbelievable and the midrange and high frequencies are so much better that when played at real levels it doesn’t sound loud. I can now turn volume up without my ears telling me that it’s too loud. This is the best video about room acoustics that I have encountered. Thanks for sharing your experience and doing all the hard work. Wally
Ron, I can only speak for myself, but all I have is admiration for your amazing endeavours and being able to, through sheer hard work and your dedication to detail, achieve your goal. You, Sir, are a true inspiration to home audio enthusiasts & more serious audiophiles alike. Chapeau, good man! Paul in Japan, (ex-Scotland).
This series open my mind about acoustics. I know I have to know some point but, how to calculate room response, and treatment needs? There is no experts near me. Why so different diffuser patterns out there? And most important factor how to apply them blend into room aestetics. (WAF first)
This was done superbly! The tiered demo adding one more treatment at a time was brilliant as it clearly demonstrated that any room can achieve "better" with incremental steps allowing anyone, on any budget, to slowly improve the soundstage in their listening space one step at a time. Well Done!!!
I'm glad there is more to come there are still a lot more on the table! I'm very excited for this! I lost a good friend a few years back the late great Tony Bolton who was also a reviewr in the UK. I lived with him for 2 years & I learned so much in that time! This room takes me back to all the talks we had about tuning the space. I'm in the process of building a studio & looking back into room acoustic's! Thank you for making this!
Have just finished watching the five videos over two days and it's inspired me to crack on with making some improvements to my "music" room which has turned into a multi-purpose space and includes my wife's desk & PC and nearly all of my fly fishing gear! Thank you for all the effort you put into making the series.
This Evolutionary Process has clearly made drastic Audio Improvements! Room issues should be considered First before any other Tweeks! Ron, this has been the most Educational and Informative Presentation you have produced! Thank you for all your hard work in bringing this to us!👏
Hey mate. Just wanted to say your previous video is the best one I've seen about the benefits of good diffusion. Most videos and articles are just telling you why it's beneficial.
This video (and the associated series) is the best thing you've ever done in my view Ron. It's brilliant to see some youtube reviewers really starting to talk about room acoustics. I also love the little story about the diffusers and the vision of some guy spending countless hours cutting and gluing together the panel to sell for $80. 🤣
Amazing. Love the way you demonstrated the differences. I didn't care for the baffled speaker sound in all of the demos, especially voice. The smaller speakers were my favorite. You really take the extra steps to guide, teach and educate your subscribers. Thank you.
Best audio series ever!!! The changes are brilliant and even the last tweak of absortion is noticeable!!! Thanks for taking the time and work to post this.
Again - thanks for this amazing series. This is the first time we can follow the effect of various treatments and how tthe effect adda to the prior. Fantastic! And congrats to a great listening room!
Too many people don't appreciate what room treatment can do. Your series of demo's will hopefully inspire others to follow the room treatment path. It's well worth it!
Excellent series in a much under represented area of “it’s the room bruh”. My GIK alpha panels made huge diff for me & I wish I knew more 10 years ago when I starting buying gear. I found the final treatment in yr room handled bass frequencies with such clarity & finer texture to be a sizeable improvement. Much Congrats!
You are perfectionist, Ron! I love this as I am too. And when it comes to music, hell yeah - perfectionism matters. Thank you very much for helping thousands through your amazing relentless effort. Top notch!
@@Newrecordday2013 I think thats awesome how you responded in a timely manner. It means alot, I really enjoyed how the room acoustics changed the room. I added 4 sound panels, and some thick sound absorbing curtains to my windows in my small 12 x 13.5 room. Im using a older Yamaha receiver, and some svs ultra bookshelf speakers, I noticed that by adding the room treatment it took some of the reflections & brightness away. . . At this time im going from a open living room, good electronics & $2500 Arendal thx monitors, to a small bedroom budget setup, & honestly was shocked on how room acoustics can play such a roll in the sound quality im hearing. Im not pulling my bookshelf speakers out past my entertainment center so i put sound panels behind them. . . Sounds surprisingly good. . I cant wait until i can get the funds to re enter this hobby and maybe try out a intregated amp as ive always had a receiver. Playing with positioning, & room acoustics has made the hobby fun again for me. Thanks for all the updates, Listening position is also near a back wall. Ive been thinking about adding one corner bass trap to my room. I tend to like all my tone controls even, & hit the loudness button & thats the way i listen to music. In your experience how do you think bass traps helped your setup? Did it clean it up? Was the bass tighter? Did you hear more detail. . . . Or was their a point in your room acoustics did you say honestly i could stop here i like it but added a little more panels? What do you prefer & how do you enjoy listening to your music? If you had a choice of a $5000 setup amp and speakers in your new listening space what would it be? Id love to know. Thanks
Yea, the final treatment is amazing. I've got a small room and it's heavily treated. I love it! Thanks for this series - it must have taken forever to film and edit all this. It paid off, this is an awesome outcome.
Thank you Ron for these excellent insightful and educational videos. Someone earlier mentioned the importance of titles and organising these videos in a way that makes them easier to find. This is like an educational series on room treatments. I for one will definitely want to revisit these multiple times when treating our room down here in Australia. 👍😎 Your humility and sincerity is obviously and of course appreciated
Although my hearing is impaired (69 years), the stepwise improvements were all clearly audible (with BT connected Sony WH-XM4). The only slight imperfection I could hear was in the low frequency range. I’m curious if the active bass traps can fix it.
The active traps will help, a little ... the Elephant is real, big. Ron's great, really dig this channel ... but it appears the LF decay times need a 𝙜𝙧𝙚𝙖𝙩 deal more damping. Ron knows this I'm sure. It's the double-edged sword of a nice big room, ie., a proportionally large amount of treatment is needed. Jesco's bass traps are great and effective. But a single width of them is more ideally suited for typical, modest sized rooms. My preferred approach is fully damp the LF in a given room ... then bring back liveliness, spaciousness via facing the LF treatment with proper diffusion, scattering or geometric redirection. A proper ITD gap, layed atop adequate LF damping. (edit; that requires time and money) --- Regardless, Ron's content creation on this is wonderfully refreshing. Nobody is doing this. The best thing is; Ron built a nice big dedicated space ... thus the challenge is; Ron built a nice big space!
Agree this last addition, has improved more than expected. Listened from my fullrange Rullit SuperAero 8" (field coil magnets) in a non treated room, but listened at one meter from the opening front horn (azurahorn). Video not to forget, thanks for share!
Very inspirational series. I fell in love with room acoustics many years ago as a teenager when I "treated" my dorm (cork and carpet on the walls and ceiling) and I "saw" what the "treatment" did. Now I got my own dedicated 20m2 listening room/mini home theater and I always try to get the best of it based on info I find in the net, info provided by articles, lectures or channels like yours. Keep the good work and I am eager to see upcoming videos on acoustics. Sorry for my english if I did some mistake as english is not my language.
Very good series of video. I worked with a small acoustic company last year to measure and propose various solutions. I added Bass traps in the corners and ceiling corners, ceiling traps, diffusers on the side and special curtains to cover the TV. It made a significant difference. It's not cheap but before someone considers a $5,000 equipment upgrade (could be less if you DIY approximately or a lot more...), this makes a very nice improvement even if my room was not nearly as bad as the empty shed. For this video, even through the crappy sound of RUclips, there seems to be better definition, tighter bass and less echo.
Hi Ron… A truly fascinating adventure, watching your journey towards reaching an acoustic listening Nirvana. I’ve become a disciple of your channel and therefore have subscribed. Best wishes KCB.😁👍🇬🇧
I only have a small amount of treatment but I did add another thick rug on top of another rug because I had no where else to put it and thought it made it a difference. Ever consider adding more to the floor? Also, what are your thoughts on correcting things with Dirac Live vs room treatment. It obviously isn’t as good but Dirac really improved my system. I’m a Home Theater guy and really believe that you should experiment and do as many things correct regarding placement, room treatment etc…. and let things like Dirac do as little as possible and this compromise has kept me happy in my journey. Lots of us can only dream of a setup like yours, well done sir!
******** Test tracks I listened to after my room treatment. 1. Tanglewood by Of The Trees. 2.Starlight lake by Of The Trees. 3.Honeydust by Of The Trees. 4. Sayonara by Tipper. & lastly… Room to breathe by CharlesTheFirst.
Fantastic job RON !! GREAT VIDEO !! This is by far the best video on Room Correction influencing the audio reproduction. Pre and post modification comparisons were excellent. While others keep rambling, Ron you did the work and showed us the results. I have been thinking about the room acoustics for a while now. When I buy a house, I will implement what you did. Can’t wait to watch your next video. Great work 🎉
Great work. I completely agree with the angle to correcting our rooms. Have a look a sub placement behind the sweet spot. Solves a lot of standing waves and bass problems.
Awesome result, I bet it sounds incredible in person! You're right about aiming for better and not necessarily a huge project like yours. I have a crappy bedroom just a couple feet shy of being a cube. It's covered in inexpensive foam which isn't anything fancy, but getting rid of those reflections is awesome. I just enjoy sitting in that room even with no music playing because it is so quiet and peaceful. It won't win any measurement tests but compared to bare walls there's no question. The progression of treatments shown in the video illustrates this well.
Ron, while I definitely heard the improvements through the original series of treatments, I really could not hear a difference with the last addition. Probably because of the cheap headset I use at work. Props for all the due diligence in creating the "Shed"!!
amazing dedication & effort to record all these takes at every step & remaining consistent, I wanted to do the same while building my room but It was way too complicated & I constantly had lots of dust so I didn’t dare get my main gear in there. What’s key here is that the room is more important than the gear. I went all out on room design, I have 16inch deep front QRD17 diffusers & 10 inch deep QRD11 on back wall, my floor joists are built on top of acoustic rubber, I have a 2 layer wall with air gap in between. It was an expensive endeavor but any audiophile that listens here is floored including those with speakers the price of my entire setup. My room is actually more expensive than my gear….. for now 😂🤣😂 Bravo again, I’m sure many will understand the importance of room treatment with this series of videos.
Thanks for the quick cuts through the progression of the room. It makes a huge difference when trying to recognize the improvements. Each stage was glaringly different, though I really couldn't hear much change at the end. I will chalk that up to lousy earbuds, and we all know it's way different in the room. But what a bitchin series!!! It has convinced me to take small steps, attacking the most obvious sound issues first, rather than implementing a variety of dressing, in hopes that reducing that issue is enough to be all the change I need. Great stuff, mister!
Sweet Shed. Great series. I'm glad you said you're not done. The more you make improvements the more your ears learn and thus... the more improvements you can find. Once you identify any given acoustic issue (noise, bad reflection, resonances etc etc) it is very hard to unhear it, so it must be fixed... cheers.
Very good job. Would be great to see more Acoustic Videos, lookin forward to it. Way more interesting than the 92949 Video on RUclips about an Speaker. For your room, I personally would recommend you next to build and plan an Double Bass Array for your room to get way more Control over the Lowend. Its little bit more complicated but when its done youve the best way to get control over the lowend. And nice to see you get some PSI's. Would be also great to see a review about their Speakers
The extra treatment makes a noticeable difference, mainly with less bass ringing and more definition to the sound. I hear more of a difference with the box speakers, which is to be expected, but a worthwhile upgrade nonetheless for the OBs. I have also been surprised at how much of a difference those clouds make and will look into this for my own room. Great series!
The final treatment OMG. That was audible difference especially second song. To me using very expensive headphones and Dac i could enjoy it now. Reverb was minimal.
Ron, this is a great video. Very impressive with your hard work. Great series of vids! Not wearing headphones so I cannot say I hear much of a difference between the two final treatments. Using my TV setup they were pretty similar. My listening room is my living room so I can only go so far. I do have reverb. I just can’t take down my wife’s room decor. She does enable me to put any gear I want in the room and for that I’m immensely grateful.
Keeps getting better! Is there no limit? I can still hear the roominess a little, but it's sounding great. The dummy head microphone is a great way to portray the effect over headphones. Excellent work. Gotta buy a dummy head.
You know it's interesting, I listened to these comparisons on my big speakers when I got home, and I guess the sound of my room masks the sound of your room to a fair degree, so they actually sounded better! ?? The bass seemed to have been contoured in a rather interesting way by going through the double transfer function of both speakers and both rooms, and it sounded really punchy. This isn't the first time that I've noticed that a recording of speakers in a room can sometimes be more compelling in certain ways than listening directly to the recording. It's like a light reverb effect, especially when the room has been treated well enough that it's not a harsh and hollow sound.
The last room modification made a very important improvement in The clarity of the sound, making the listening experience effortless. Especially the female voice is now without boomy resonance and has at last turned bearable to listen to😊
This series has been truly excellent. Each step of your journey has shown clear improvements. I know that you have not undertaken this as any form of one-upmanship but I'm still kinda jealous. I have some cracking good kit but my room is far from ideal. My room is quite small but as it's an old 17th century cottage has pretty good absorption in the form of 2' thick walls. Unfortunately the addition of any further room treatment would result in divorce papers. Oh well. The addition of the additional panels made a surprisingly big difference. The vocals seem more focused and the bass more nuanced. There was also a marked reduction in a general hash that eminated from the sides and above. It was one of those things that only became apparent by its removal. Oh. And those Spacials are so much better than the CCS.
Although I DO AGREE that this series is very, very important, and probably your all time BEST video production ever, with incredible thought and execution....Your ALL TIME BEST AND MOST IMPORTANT video has to be L.O.T.S. Combine both and the universe is totally aligned, literally 🙂 😊 😉
Wonderful video, thank you so much. My takeaway is - why aren't open baffle speakers more popular than they are? It seemed to me that switching from box to open baffle speaker immediately did the job of a ton of room treatment. Anyone else?
It sort of looks like shipping pallets screwed into the wall. The sound improvements were demonstrable. The Spatials exemplify how large drivers make a difference. My room has too many other purposes so I add power and impose a listening zone with a 13 foot listening distance.
This video proved to me how important room treatment is. It's amazing how much more detail you hear when you get rid of all the miscellaneous reflected sound and resulting echos.
I've watched this series and enjoyed each one . Thanks for all the tech advice , I learned bunches . Would love to hear a video comparing the Galion Audio TS 120 SE vs Rogue Cronus Magnum 111 and the ECI 80 D along with the Caledon Open Baffle Speakers .
Tiny differences between the last two acoustic treatments. To my ears, the biggest improvement came from a few bass traps and difusión in a furnished room. Room correction can help quite a bit with bass and lower midrange too.
Been great to follow this journey Ron and I look forward to seeing more of what is to come! I've pretty much just stuck to the "common sense" approach when it comes to furnishing and treating my listening room, but I have to admit I am curious to grab some measurements to see what the room looks like on the computer after watching this series.
It was interesting to hear difference in the completed room. It seems to be the upper midrange wherer I heard the biggest difference. It was more like an open space recording than something in a box. Very interesting. The ability to discern the difference between products you need to take the room out of it!
So, an extremely good explanation about what's actually one of the most important things about hifi of all... The room. And the difference treatment does. And very true, not everyone has an own listening room. But everyone can learn and do something with what they have. And actually, some small money in diy. Can take you very, very far. Like carpet, homemade bass traps, diffraction. Loudspeaker placement , tc. All with my very humble gear and some diy tips and tricks from RUclips. Thank you for a great chanel. From Stockholm Sweden. Jonny
Hi Ron, I have a listening room which is fully furnished and therefore I would judge it to say it is not "live" sounding. That is not to say it doesn't have issues. As you rightly point out - all rooms have issues with distortion in one way or another. Mine is a wooden suspended floor. I would like to put my turntable on a wall shelf, but my wife sees this as an eyesore. Can you do a similar series as this one to show sonic improvements with each step of improved isolation that could be made in this area. That could cover cost effective as well as money no object innovations. Cheers for a great channel by the way 👍
Ok, I was wearing headphones but couldn't hear your audio over the Instrumental Celtic music I was streaming. LOL. Nice video thanks, really enjoyed the information. I'm in a small 10'x12' room that I am just starting out with. But wife wont let me move some closets. So really it's more like an 10"x 10' box. Oh well, at least I have a space.
The decrease in boom and the increase in detail are amazing
Nailed it!
I couldn't tell much. Perhaps that's a good thing for me. So I don't have spend too much $$😅
@@snap7749 If you drop ~$200 on a couple packs of Roxul S&S and 1x8s, spend a weekend building and installing, you'll be glad you did. If only to improve the 1khz+ range... broadband absorption at first reflection points goes a very long way. I took some recording classes in college many years ago- my professor had decades of professional experience under his belt. He couldn't say enough good things about Roxul Safe & Sound. Absorption and diffusion is a gamechanger, and it doesn't cost much at all. Less than a cheap pair of studio monitors. Room treatment should come first. Your system is only as good as the room it's in. The room has far more of an impact than some esoteric DAC/amplifier combo, let alone cone materials. Don't get me started on fancy speaker wires, bahahaha.
On my mediocre headphones sounds better without the treatment. With treatment is More narrow and focused (sound stage) with a little more detail. Voices are like going near or through some pillows. I usually like some reflections... To me nature sounds, real voices, live concerts have a certain degree of reflection. So if it is too focused it sounds a little strange and muffled.
Bass sound a little tighter, just a little
I have no perfect years and not an expensive gear, plus RUclips compression, so don't take my word :D
Very good comparison and setup!
This is one of the best audio videos I have seen. If this does not convince someone of the importance of room treatment nothing will. You have probably both improved the listening experience of your viewers significantly and saved them a whole lot of money since room treatment is a lot cheaper than electronics and speakers. Well done.
After 10 years of changing speakers and amps, dacs and cables, i understand now that room is the most important thing of my hi-fi sistem
Isnt it something!! A max treated room and a flea powered tube amp connected to a 3" fullrange driver with a subwoofer is really something!
better now than never... some people are 30yrs in the hobby and still dont invest in acoustics
always start with the room!
so long as you have some nice gear then you will hear everything it has to offer in a good room.
like an old friend said to me, if you have great speakers & a poor amp & source, you will at least hear the best they have to offer.
if you have poor speakers & a great source then you are destroying the sound of your source.
The same applys to the room.
you can have the best gear but if you can't hear it you could have got away with an all in one from the local electronics store.
@@Canadian_Eh_Ilol😂
4:44 Gentlemen knows Electrocompaniet when he sees one.
Ron, I agree that these are some of the best videos you have ever done. The superiority of this series lies in its 1-2-3 punch: 1. You TEACH in a calm, organized, non judgmental matter. 2. You allow the viewers to HEAR for themselves the improvements each step of the way. Sort of like "a picture beats a thousand words principle." 3. You back up any subjectivity objections with MEASUREMENTS and graphs.
These three punches satisfy the novice and the experienced, the hearing focused and the measurement crowd. Well done.
As somebody who cares about the audiophile community, may I humbly offer up a suggestion? Could you better package this series with a general heading of your choice combined with subheadings for each video. This series is too good to be hidden or only viewed in partiality. Right now I find the videos too disjointed from each other by titles. Having a main heading and sub headings with each video develops a continuum that helps people identify it as part of a series and in what order. An off the cuff example might be the following:
Room Treatment A to Z.
Part One - Untreated
Part Two - Adding Room Furnishings
Part Three - Bass traps
Etc, etc.
This simple step will generate more views, which is what I would like to see. Having a main title and subtitle with each video will also make it possible to add to this series in the future as you see fit as it develops into a master class. Frankly it's approaching that already, certainly from a RUclips perspective at the very least.
Lastly, I hope you round off your series with some dsp additions. There's still a bit of voodoo surrounding that topic, at least for me. Thanks again Ron.
Awesome video, Ron. Best in the biz
I did not take any of the work that you did here as an attempt to show off or be prideful. I truly appreciate the dedication and information that you have shared. Please continue to keep up the good work and sharing the knowledge.
I appreciate that!
Agree with this totally. Honest reviewers shouldn't have to fear what others think. Keep doing what you're doing man.
I’m in the process of treating my room. After years of reading, watching videos and procrastination I’m finally ready to start implementing what I’ve learned. I’ll definitely be referring back to this series as I go along. Thanks for taking the time to do these
This series has been wonderful. I decided a long time ago the room, treatment of it and placement of speakers within it was ~80% of the audiophile equation. You are helping other folks understand that. Kudos!!
The room makes such a difference. It is not hard nor expensive to massively improve the room and thus the listening experience.
There must be a ton of people out there who have spent a lot of time and money (me included) swapping out equipment (mainly speakers) to try and find the right sound, without realizing the room is the issue! Your series of videos are simply fantastic. Glad you had the foresight an resources to put them together. There certainly is no argument as to what can be achieved with the right approach and mind set.
I am fortunate enough to have a tolerant wife and she has let me do all sorts of crazy stuff to the room achieve a better sound. All I can say is, it's worth the effort. Sit back and enjoy the music....
I went did it. After working with asc on my room which is a dedicated room which I built. It’s 19’ x 28 1/2’ with 12’ ceilings and no windows or openings. After going through different equipment and speakers before treatment by asc . I now know what my equipment sounds like which is a lot better than I thought. My bass is unbelievable and the midrange and high frequencies are so much better that when played at real levels it doesn’t sound loud. I can now turn volume up without my ears telling me that it’s too loud. This is the best video about room acoustics that I have encountered. Thanks for sharing your experience and doing all the hard work. Wally
Ron, I can only speak for myself, but all I have is admiration for your amazing endeavours and being able to, through sheer hard work and your dedication to detail, achieve your goal. You, Sir, are a true inspiration to home audio enthusiasts & more serious audiophiles alike. Chapeau, good man! Paul in Japan, (ex-Scotland).
This series open my mind about acoustics. I know I have to know some point but, how to calculate room response, and treatment needs? There is no experts near me. Why so different diffuser patterns out there? And most important factor how to apply them blend into room aestetics. (WAF first)
if you ask me think about how much you are wiling to spend on acustics and then pay for someone online to guide you,good luck
BRAVO Ron!!! The difference in sound from bare room to most recent treatment is amazing! Great work! Truly enjoyed this series. 👍👍👍
Amazing! Simple to understand. Educational. Unbiased. Objective. Bravo!
This was done superbly! The tiered demo adding one more treatment at a time was brilliant as it clearly demonstrated that any room can achieve "better" with incremental steps allowing anyone, on any budget, to slowly improve the soundstage in their listening space one step at a time. Well Done!!!
Thanks for this series and please continue with more advanced topics in the second series. I'm a strong believer in room treatment too 😊
By far, the most interesting and helpful series of videos I have seen since a long long time. Thank you!
I'm glad there is more to come there are still a lot more on the table!
I'm very excited for this!
I lost a good friend a few years back the late great Tony Bolton who was also a reviewr in the UK.
I lived with him for 2 years & I learned so much in that time!
This room takes me back to all the talks we had about tuning the space.
I'm in the process of building a studio & looking back into room acoustic's!
Thank you for making this!
Have just finished watching the five videos over two days and it's inspired me to crack on with making some improvements to my "music" room which has turned into a multi-purpose space and includes my wife's desk & PC and nearly all of my fly fishing gear! Thank you for all the effort you put into making the series.
The room sounds amazing! Great job.
Thank you!!
This Evolutionary Process has clearly made drastic Audio Improvements! Room issues should be considered First before any other Tweeks! Ron, this has been the most Educational and Informative Presentation you have produced! Thank you for all your hard work in bringing this to us!👏
Hey mate. Just wanted to say your previous video is the best one I've seen about the benefits of good diffusion. Most videos and articles are just telling you why it's beneficial.
Fantastic!
This video (and the associated series) is the best thing you've ever done in my view Ron. It's brilliant to see some youtube reviewers really starting to talk about room acoustics. I also love the little story about the diffusers and the vision of some guy spending countless hours cutting and gluing together the panel to sell for $80. 🤣
Amazing. Love the way you demonstrated the differences. I didn't care for the baffled speaker sound in all of the demos, especially voice. The smaller speakers were my favorite. You really take the extra steps to guide, teach and educate your subscribers. Thank you.
You are very welcome!
Best audio series ever!!! The changes are brilliant and even the last tweak of absortion is noticeable!!! Thanks for taking the time and work to post this.
Again - thanks for this amazing series. This is the first time we can follow the effect of various treatments and how tthe effect adda to the prior. Fantastic! And congrats to a great listening room!
This is the best content i have ever heared for music and hifi. Great work!
Hey thanks!
Too many people don't appreciate what room treatment can do. Your series of demo's will hopefully inspire others to follow the room treatment path. It's well worth it!
Excellent series in a much under represented area of “it’s the room bruh”. My GIK alpha panels made huge diff for me & I wish I knew more 10 years ago when I starting buying gear. I found the final treatment in yr room handled bass frequencies with such clarity & finer texture to be a sizeable improvement. Much Congrats!
You are perfectionist, Ron! I love this as I am too. And when it comes to music, hell yeah - perfectionism matters. Thank you very much for helping thousands through your amazing relentless effort. Top notch!
Thanks!
The final treatment sounds so good! Amazing, how the recorded reverb of the music becomes clearer wirh every treatment step 😊
That last step definitely brought the mids and phantom center back to focus.
Been watching some audio videos for some time now, these ones caught my attention the most including your short videos!!! Great stuff buddy
Awesome, thank you!
@@Newrecordday2013 I think thats awesome how you responded in a timely manner. It means alot, I really enjoyed how the room acoustics changed the room. I added 4 sound panels, and some thick sound absorbing curtains to my windows in my small 12 x 13.5 room.
Im using a older Yamaha receiver, and some svs ultra bookshelf speakers, I noticed that by adding the room treatment it took some of the reflections & brightness away. . . At this time im going from a open living room, good electronics & $2500 Arendal thx monitors, to a small bedroom budget setup, & honestly was shocked on how room acoustics can play such a roll in the sound quality im hearing.
Im not pulling my bookshelf speakers out past my entertainment center so i put sound panels behind them. . . Sounds surprisingly good. . I cant wait until i can get the funds to re enter this hobby and maybe try out a intregated amp as ive always had a receiver.
Playing with positioning, & room acoustics has made the hobby fun again for me. Thanks for all the updates,
Listening position is also near a back wall. Ive been thinking about adding one corner bass trap to my room. I tend to like all my tone controls even, & hit the loudness button & thats the way i listen to music.
In your experience how do you think bass traps helped your setup?
Did it clean it up? Was the bass tighter? Did you hear more detail. . . . Or was their a point in your room acoustics did you say honestly i could stop here i like it but added a little more panels? What do you prefer & how do you enjoy listening to your music? If you had a choice of a $5000 setup amp and speakers in your new listening space what would it be? Id love to know. Thanks
Yea, the final treatment is amazing. I've got a small room and it's heavily treated. I love it! Thanks for this series - it must have taken forever to film and edit all this. It paid off, this is an awesome outcome.
Thank you Ron for these excellent insightful and educational videos. Someone earlier mentioned the importance of titles and organising these videos in a way that makes them easier to find. This is like an educational series on room treatments. I for one will definitely want to revisit these multiple times when treating our room down here in Australia. 👍😎 Your humility and sincerity is obviously and of course appreciated
great job! this series is golden (i'm still gonna airbnb the shed)
Kudos Ron! What a fun journey. Keep up the great work
16:18 Respect! Thanks for your content Ron.
Kudos to Ron. That’s been the best and most informative series on acoustic room treatment I’ve seen yet on YT.
Although my hearing is impaired (69 years), the stepwise improvements were all clearly audible (with BT connected Sony WH-XM4). The only slight imperfection I could hear was in the low frequency range. I’m curious if the active bass traps can fix it.
The active traps will help, a little ... the Elephant is real, big.
Ron's great, really dig this channel ... but it appears the LF decay times need a 𝙜𝙧𝙚𝙖𝙩 deal more damping.
Ron knows this I'm sure.
It's the double-edged sword of a nice big room, ie., a proportionally large amount of treatment is needed.
Jesco's bass traps are great and effective. But a single width of them is more ideally suited for typical, modest sized rooms.
My preferred approach is fully damp the LF in a given room ... then bring back liveliness, spaciousness via facing the LF treatment with proper diffusion, scattering or geometric redirection.
A proper ITD gap, layed atop adequate LF damping.
(edit; that requires time and money)
---
Regardless, Ron's content creation on this is wonderfully refreshing. Nobody is doing this.
The best thing is; Ron built a nice big dedicated space ... thus the challenge is; Ron built a nice big space!
Agree this last addition, has improved more than expected. Listened from my fullrange Rullit SuperAero 8" (field coil magnets) in a non treated room, but listened at one meter from the opening front horn (azurahorn). Video not to forget, thanks for share!
Great to hear!
Sounds amazing I have loved this series. I can hear a difference with all of the stages. Well done this has been very helpful 👍
This series has been a valuable learning tool for your audience.
Great work on room treatments. Good job shining a light on this underspoken about issue
Thanks man for open lesson !
Now i understand and hear the importance on room treatment....hello from Romania !
Very inspirational series. I fell in love with room acoustics many years ago as a teenager when I "treated" my dorm (cork and carpet on the walls and ceiling) and I "saw" what the "treatment" did. Now I got my own dedicated 20m2 listening room/mini home theater and I always try to get the best of it based on info I find in the net, info provided by articles, lectures or channels like yours. Keep the good work and I am eager to see upcoming videos on acoustics. Sorry for my english if I did some mistake as english is not my language.
That room is friggin epic man. I’m two states over:)
The room is everything
Great Video and Series. I have been on a similar journey the past 3/4 years but on a smaller scale and budget. Its so addictive : )
Very good series of video. I worked with a small acoustic company last year to measure and propose various solutions. I added Bass traps in the corners and ceiling corners, ceiling traps, diffusers on the side and special curtains to cover the TV. It made a significant difference. It's not cheap but before someone considers a $5,000 equipment upgrade (could be less if you DIY approximately or a lot more...), this makes a very nice improvement even if my room was not nearly as bad as the empty shed. For this video, even through the crappy sound of RUclips, there seems to be better definition, tighter bass and less echo.
Nice. The added absorption makes everything sout tighter... more controlled.
Big respect to you Ron. The last addition is notisable for sure. Keep it. Speakers are intresting delta in experience.
Ron, brilliant work, thank you very much this has been a series of eye-opening videos.
Glad it was helpful!
I learnt a lot. I really appreciate how you break things down step-by-step. Well done. Thanks.
What a fantastic series. I think I may use QRD diffusers between my speakers instead of the skyline ones I have now.
Hi Ron…
A truly fascinating adventure, watching your journey towards reaching an acoustic listening Nirvana.
I’ve become a disciple of your channel and therefore have subscribed.
Best wishes KCB.😁👍🇬🇧
I only have a small amount of treatment but I did add another thick rug on top of another rug because I had no where else to put it and thought it made it a difference. Ever consider adding more to the floor?
Also, what are your thoughts on correcting things with Dirac Live vs room treatment. It obviously isn’t as good but Dirac really improved my system. I’m a Home Theater guy and really believe that you should experiment and do as many things correct regarding placement, room treatment etc…. and let things like Dirac do as little as possible and this compromise has kept me happy in my journey. Lots of us can only dream of a setup like yours, well done sir!
********
Test tracks I listened to after my room treatment.
1. Tanglewood by Of The Trees.
2.Starlight lake by Of The Trees.
3.Honeydust by Of The Trees.
4. Sayonara by Tipper.
& lastly… Room to breathe by CharlesTheFirst.
Fantastic job RON !! GREAT VIDEO !! This is by far the best video on Room Correction influencing the audio reproduction. Pre and post modification comparisons were excellent. While others keep rambling, Ron you did the work and showed us the results. I have been thinking about the room acoustics for a while now. When I buy a house, I will implement what you did. Can’t wait to watch your next video. Great work 🎉
Great work. I completely agree with the angle to correcting our rooms.
Have a look a sub placement behind the sweet spot. Solves a lot of standing waves and bass problems.
Awesome result, I bet it sounds incredible in person! You're right about aiming for better and not necessarily a huge project like yours. I have a crappy bedroom just a couple feet shy of being a cube. It's covered in inexpensive foam which isn't anything fancy, but getting rid of those reflections is awesome. I just enjoy sitting in that room even with no music playing because it is so quiet and peaceful. It won't win any measurement tests but compared to bare walls there's no question. The progression of treatments shown in the video illustrates this well.
Holy crap! What a difference! I cannot thank you enough!
Ron, your best video yet!
Ron, while I definitely heard the improvements through the original series of treatments, I really could not hear a difference with the last addition. Probably because of the cheap headset I use at work. Props for all the due diligence in creating the "Shed"!!
Great series and ready for more to come. Thanks for the ride and I look forward to what comes next.
Better imaging, better bass. Right on!
amazing dedication & effort to record all these takes at every step & remaining consistent, I wanted to do the same while building my room but It was way too complicated & I constantly had lots of dust so I didn’t dare get my main gear in there. What’s key here is that the room is more important than the gear. I went all out on room design, I have 16inch deep front QRD17 diffusers & 10 inch deep QRD11 on back wall, my floor joists are built on top of acoustic rubber, I have a 2 layer wall with air gap in between. It was an expensive endeavor but any audiophile that listens here is floored including those with speakers the price of my entire setup. My room is actually more expensive than my gear….. for now 😂🤣😂
Bravo again, I’m sure many will understand the importance of room treatment with this series of videos.
Thanks for taking us on your journey. It was extremely informative.
You are most welcome!
Thanks for the quick cuts through the progression of the room. It makes a huge difference when trying to recognize the improvements. Each stage was glaringly different, though I really couldn't hear much change at the end. I will chalk that up to lousy earbuds, and we all know it's way different in the room. But what a bitchin series!!! It has convinced me to take small steps, attacking the most obvious sound issues first, rather than implementing a variety of dressing, in hopes that reducing that issue is enough to be all the change I need. Great stuff, mister!
Bravo 👏 outstanding methodology. Thanks for all of your hard work 🙏
Sweet Shed. Great series. I'm glad you said you're not done. The more you make improvements the more your ears learn and thus... the more improvements you can find. Once you identify any given acoustic issue (noise, bad reflection, resonances etc etc) it is very hard to unhear it, so it must be fixed... cheers.
Very good job. Would be great to see more Acoustic Videos, lookin forward to it. Way more interesting than the 92949 Video on RUclips about an Speaker. For your room, I personally would recommend you next to build and plan an Double Bass Array for your room to get way more Control over the Lowend. Its little bit more complicated but when its done youve the best way to get control over the lowend. And nice to see you get some PSI's. Would be also great to see a review about their Speakers
The extra treatment makes a noticeable difference, mainly with less bass ringing and more definition to the sound. I hear more of a difference with the box speakers, which is to be expected, but a worthwhile upgrade nonetheless for the OBs. I have also been surprised at how much of a difference those clouds make and will look into this for my own room. Great series!
The final treatment OMG. That was audible difference especially second song. To me using very expensive headphones and Dac i could enjoy it now. Reverb was minimal.
I agree!
Ron, this is a great video. Very impressive with your hard work. Great series of vids! Not wearing headphones so I cannot say I hear much of a difference between the two final treatments. Using my TV setup they were pretty similar. My listening room is my living room so I can only go so far. I do have reverb. I just can’t take down my wife’s room decor. She does enable me to put any gear I want in the room and for that I’m immensely grateful.
Amazing series. Thank you.
I think the final treatment is most noticeable to me in the two vocal tracks. Using the focal bathy. Hearing the profession was great.
The extra absorption sharpened the focus, also making it easier to hear the recording itself.
Could you explain more about what you changed with the orientation of diffusers why it matters?
Great video. Better separation between instrument with final treatment, soecially open baffles
In the works of adding these things, thanks for all the videos. Inspiring 🥳
Keeps getting better! Is there no limit? I can still hear the roominess a little, but it's sounding great. The dummy head microphone is a great way to portray the effect over headphones. Excellent work. Gotta buy a dummy head.
Thanks man!
You know it's interesting, I listened to these comparisons on my big speakers when I got home, and I guess the sound of my room masks the sound of your room to a fair degree, so they actually sounded better! ?? The bass seemed to have been contoured in a rather interesting way by going through the double transfer function of both speakers and both rooms, and it sounded really punchy. This isn't the first time that I've noticed that a recording of speakers in a room can sometimes be more compelling in certain ways than listening directly to the recording. It's like a light reverb effect, especially when the room has been treated well enough that it's not a harsh and hollow sound.
Those bass trap benches are a really good idea. I heard the most difference with the ceiling clouds
This series was great! It was all very clear and practical and it's nice to be able to A/B different spots back to back. :)
The last room modification made a very important improvement in The clarity of the sound, making the listening experience effortless. Especially the female voice is now without boomy resonance and has at last turned bearable to listen to😊
This series has been truly excellent.
Each step of your journey has shown clear improvements. I know that you have not undertaken this as any form of one-upmanship but I'm still kinda jealous. I have some cracking good kit but my room is far from ideal. My room is quite small but as it's an old 17th century cottage has pretty good absorption in the form of 2' thick walls. Unfortunately the addition of any further room treatment would result in divorce papers. Oh well.
The addition of the additional panels made a surprisingly big difference. The vocals seem more focused and the bass more nuanced. There was also a marked reduction in a general hash that eminated from the sides and above. It was one of those things that only became apparent by its removal.
Oh. And those Spacials are so much better than the CCS.
You are really impressive and thank you for your honest work and sharing.
Although I DO AGREE that this series is very, very important, and probably your all time BEST video production ever, with incredible thought and execution....Your ALL TIME BEST AND MOST IMPORTANT video has to be L.O.T.S. Combine both and the universe is totally aligned, literally 🙂 😊 😉
Grrrreat job Ron - we learnt a lot from this journey.
Wonderful video, thank you so much. My takeaway is - why aren't open baffle speakers more popular than they are? It seemed to me that switching from box to open baffle speaker immediately did the job of a ton of room treatment. Anyone else?
It sort of looks like shipping pallets screwed into the wall. The sound improvements were demonstrable. The Spatials exemplify how large drivers make a difference. My room has too many other purposes so I add power and impose a listening zone with a 13 foot listening distance.
This video proved to me how important room treatment is. It's amazing how much more detail you hear when you get rid of all the miscellaneous reflected sound and resulting echos.
I've watched this series and enjoyed each one . Thanks for all the tech advice , I learned bunches . Would love to hear a video comparing the Galion Audio TS 120 SE vs Rogue Cronus Magnum 111 and the ECI 80 D along with the Caledon Open Baffle Speakers .
Tiny differences between the last two acoustic treatments. To my ears, the biggest improvement came from a few bass traps and difusión in a furnished room. Room correction can help quite a bit with bass and lower midrange too.
Been great to follow this journey Ron and I look forward to seeing more of what is to come! I've pretty much just stuck to the "common sense" approach when it comes to furnishing and treating my listening room, but I have to admit I am curious to grab some measurements to see what the room looks like on the computer after watching this series.
It was interesting to hear difference in the completed room. It seems to be the upper midrange wherer I heard the biggest difference. It was more like an open space recording than something in a box. Very interesting.
The ability to discern the difference between products you need to take the room out of it!
Just a tip: finding a better spot for the speakers will have significant impact. And adding a software calibration will bring you to another space.
Room correction, EQ and minor room treatment gets you far 👍
So, an extremely good explanation about what's actually one of the most important things about hifi of all...
The room.
And the difference treatment does.
And very true, not everyone has an own listening room. But everyone can learn and do something with what they have. And actually, some small money in diy. Can take you very, very far.
Like carpet, homemade bass traps, diffraction. Loudspeaker placement , tc. All with my very humble gear and some diy tips and tricks from RUclips.
Thank you for a great chanel.
From Stockholm Sweden. Jonny
Hi Ron, I have a listening room which is fully furnished and therefore I would judge it to say it is not "live" sounding. That is not to say it doesn't have issues. As you rightly point out - all rooms have issues with distortion in one way or another. Mine is a wooden suspended floor. I would like to put my turntable on a wall shelf, but my wife sees this as an eyesore. Can you do a similar series as this one to show sonic improvements with each step of improved isolation that could be made in this area. That could cover cost effective as well as money no object innovations. Cheers for a great channel by the way 👍
Ron, Indeed these are valuable videos.
I would post them again in a year.
There are always new music lovers coming.
Grtz phil
Ok, I was wearing headphones but couldn't hear your audio over the Instrumental Celtic music I was streaming. LOL. Nice video thanks, really enjoyed the information. I'm in a small 10'x12' room that I am just starting out with. But wife wont let me move some closets. So really it's more like an 10"x 10' box. Oh well, at least I have a space.