Which Budget Podcast Mic Is Best? Audio Technica AT2040 vs. Rode PodMic

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 342

  • @Podcastage
    @Podcastage 3 года назад +163

    I'm going to fine you for any and all puns going forward.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +49

      Can I put it on a tab? Would that be Fifine?

    • @larryhinze9314
      @larryhinze9314 2 года назад

      I think anyone that puts the Podmic in a competiton should be tossed into ass pounding prison.

    • @CreatorDrews
      @CreatorDrews 2 года назад +2

      @@larryhinze9314 LOL WHY

    • @rafshkim
      @rafshkim 2 года назад

      @@tombuck *cough*

    • @Sparksinf
      @Sparksinf Год назад

      @@tombuck 100 dollar fine!! 😂

  • @chrisinprogress
    @chrisinprogress 3 года назад +34

    I'm gonna skip adding to the voices on either side of the showdown and simply say that I love the creativity of how you added the plug for Artlist. Also, it's cool to see the upgrade on your desk setup adding the monitor mount so that you can stand up for videos as another option. Awesome Tom!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +2

      The monitor arm is a total game changer! That's going to be Thursday's video!

  • @colearmstrong7768
    @colearmstrong7768 3 года назад +15

    I bought the Rode PodMic based off of Tom Buck's recommendation. This mic is awesome. I wouldn't have found it otherwise (as I'm new to this stuff). I'm extremely happy with my purchase. It's like a night and day difference between the Blue Yeti I had previously tried. Thank you for all of your help.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +4

      I’m so happy to hear this! I hope you have an Arm Strong enough to support it 😬

    • @colearmstrong7768
      @colearmstrong7768 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Lmao... I dont know why I didnt see that coming lol. Your Maono pun had me in tears!
      "Maono how to say this thing" 😂
      I went with the PSA1 to ensure it was strong enough for the podmic.

    • @matics28
      @matics28 2 года назад

      Wow talk about divine timing! I'm literally in the process of upgrading from a broken blue yeti to the rode mic, and i caught your message just in time!

  • @marcthiele
    @marcthiele 3 года назад +35

    Nice one again. My personal taste: I like the Audio Technica better with your voice. A bit warmer more radio-ish 😁

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +4

      Straight out of the box I do think it’s a bit easier to listen to.

    • @KING_DRANZER
      @KING_DRANZER Месяц назад

      @@tombuck Podmic sounds neat and clean to me whereas AT2040 sounds pushy and muddied a bit. I am not sure if that is what considered natural. The Podmic with EQ be the best case scenario to get a bit richer experience but even without EQ I think Podmic sounded better clearer and listenable.

  • @kelvinquezada6801
    @kelvinquezada6801 3 года назад +15

    In the past, I probably would have preferred the PodMic. With many years of mic testing myself, I easily prefer the sound of AT2040 for this application. The PodMic just sounds thin IMO. The AT2040 just sounds great out of the box. Great video!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +8

      I think the AT definitely has a more neutral sound. Someone else said it has better "dynamic range" and I think that's a good way to put it. A really great mic!

  • @rohanrahman8138
    @rohanrahman8138 3 года назад +5

    What a cleaver move to see us your promotion. I never had listened promotion but this time you nailed it... Love you...

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Haha, thank you! I figured it's a good use of that time, and I genuinely do appreciate Artlist's support. I've only ever done 4 sponsored videos and they're 3 of them 😁

  • @markwiemels
    @markwiemels 3 года назад +40

    Big thing I noticed, the AT isolated your voice better, not picking up reflections off the wall. This is one issue I have with my podmic, in my own space, it picks up those room reflections.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +13

      I didn't notice until rewatching the video that the AT is labeled as a "hypercardiod" mic, so it makes sense that it would be more directional and a bit better at rejecting other sounds.

    • @marcoscesar4880
      @marcoscesar4880 2 года назад +1

      Thanks for the tip!

    • @jccraftmage2313
      @jccraftmage2313 Год назад +2

      @@tombuck I didn't realize that's what that meant. Maybe that's worth explaining in a video

  • @dsaltz
    @dsaltz 3 года назад +28

    I own both of these mics and for my voice I prefer the AT. The podmic is just too highs-forward for me. The AT seems to be more balanced.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +2

      I agree- definitely more balanced.

    • @mikesgonzalez2717
      @mikesgonzalez2717 2 года назад

      @@tombuck so I got a m1 MacBook Air for school work. but I thought id also use it for streaming. I thought about buying a mic like the rode podmic or a FIFINE K678. Sadly this laptop only has 2 usb-c ports and one head jack. If I would get a xlr to usb-c cable would it be ok to just directly connect it to the Mac or should get something else. Does connecting either mic to a usb hub which is connected to the Mac effect the sound quality

    • @SleepyDogg
      @SleepyDogg 2 года назад

      @@mikesgonzalez2717 I think buying an audio interface even if it's cheap would work and sound better. You could find some for $30-$50 like Behringer um2 or scavenge for used Focusrite on eBay. I got lucky and found one for $55.

  • @tonyantoine5823
    @tonyantoine5823 3 года назад +6

    Thanks again for another great comparison Tom! I have 4 Pod mics with my RodeCastor Pro but I love the sound coming from AT2040.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      They're both pretty awesome!

  • @mjcz5853
    @mjcz5853 3 года назад +25

    AT2040 has a much better, smoother sound, maybe a wider dynamic range. The Podmic seems to have a narrow frequency response. In this test, with your voice the AT2040 is clearly a better sounding mic right out of the box. Listening with Sony MDR 7506 headphones.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +3

      Dynamic range- that's a good way to explain it. I think the AT will more easily suit a wider range of voices straight out of the box.

    • @EddieInzauto
      @EddieInzauto 3 года назад +1

      Fully agree. With a wide dynamic range set of headphones I definitely get nicer, smoother low frequencies from the AT2040. Really glad I came across this and other AT2040 vids, particularly in comparison to the Podmic, which I was interested in first.

    • @overdaedgebroadcasting2220
      @overdaedgebroadcasting2220 2 года назад

      I agree the AT2040 is way better, Good thing I never bought a Podmic.

  • @Kimbuucha
    @Kimbuucha 3 года назад +4

    I've been on the market for a new budget mic and went back and forth between these two. I ended up getting the Podmic after hearing you and Doc recommend this mic time and time again. Enjoyed the video and the puns!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I really do love the PodMic, and it's super easy to EQ if you ned to adjust the sound a bit. Plus it's built to last forever!

  • @PychStudios
    @PychStudios 2 года назад +5

    This was so informative! I was debating between the AT2040 and the PodMic and your video gave me great insight into the characteristics of the microphones :). I could really hear a difference in the low end of the AT2040 through my headphones and speakers! Using a pair of Beyerdynamic DT990 Pro 250Ohms/ Big tall boy floor standing speakers and PSB Image C4 Center Channel.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +2

      I’m really happy to hear that! Hopefully you can choose the mic that’s right for you 👍

    • @PychStudios
      @PychStudios 2 года назад

      @@tombuck I ended up going with the AT2040! I’m excited to try it out!

  • @OliverWiehe
    @OliverWiehe 3 года назад +2

    Nice background on close-ups of each mic - very colorful and creative!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Thanks! I played some stock footage on my computer monitor 😁

  • @mad0214
    @mad0214 3 года назад +3

    Gotta say it was nice to open RUclips this morning and see a Monday upload from you. Is it Christmas Day? Even better is that this is a review I’ve been looking forward to. I liked the sound of the podmic just a bit more. Wish it had the gain of the AT2040 but when I get my CT1, that won’t be an issue. Looking forward to seeing the Lewitt in one of these videos now. Loved how it sounded in Heather”s mic test stream.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      The Lewitt is so good! I haven't used much else since I got it and now I feel guilty. It even has this nifty little magnetic pop filter that attaches to it- super cool!
      I've been trying to do uploads at least every other Monday, so I'm glad you're liking it!

  • @HasanNiz
    @HasanNiz 3 года назад +10

    Awesome comparison! PodMic sounds a bit better here, has a bit more of top end, I have a couple of PodMics as well and absolutely love it!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +4

      I like the PodMic more in this comparison too, personally. But I'm wondering how much of that is because I'm more used to its sound than the AT. 🤔

    • @ulfrinn8783
      @ulfrinn8783 2 года назад +2

      @@tombuck It may be. The AT2040 has a fuller, less flat sound to me, like the Podmic is just missing something.

    • @BukanIbuMu
      @BukanIbuMu 2 года назад +3

      I don't like the excessive treble of PodMic.

    • @yaukster
      @yaukster 9 месяцев назад

      @@tombuck I used to have the at2020, and I personally prefer the at2040 because it has a fuller sound to me. The podmic sounds kind of thin and hollow.

  • @markrichardson6461
    @markrichardson6461 3 года назад +19

    The AT2040 sounds very thin and lots of high end. Definitely like the Rode more. Great comparison and love the puns. Just found your channel and podcast. I am loving it all!!!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I really appreciate that! Thanks for the kind words!

  • @cyberdefenseddi
    @cyberdefenseddi 3 года назад +2

    Hi Tom! I enjoyed how you compared the two. Always fun watching ya at the same time benefit from your delivery of the products 😎

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I'm glad you enjoyed the video! These comparisons are pretty simple, but they're super fun to make!

  • @LukeKT43
    @LukeKT43 3 года назад +1

    Hey man. Just discovered your videos yesterday. Super informative, very easy to understand. You’ve helped me pull the trigger on finally purchasing a Rodecaster Pro and Mic. Should have them next week. Love ya work, mate 🤘🏻.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Fantastic! I hope you really like them and make some cool stuff!

  • @JaredSpink
    @JaredSpink 3 года назад +5

    Great comparison. Sound is really subjective, comes down to preference, I think the podmic sounds better but the AT2040 is great too🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      In this comparison, I think I prefer the PodMic too but I'm not sure how much of that comes from me just being used to it after using it for so long. Listening on my phone, I think the AT has an edge, but on my headphones and editing monitors I like the Rode.

  • @itsBlakeWright
    @itsBlakeWright 3 года назад +6

    I have the RODE Podmic… it’s been Meh, because it leaves me wanting more!
    With your comparison, it sounds like the Podmic is being recorded in a tin can! The AT2040 just sounds more clean and full.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +3

      It's crazy how much really does also depend on the speakers you're using. Personally with this video, I prefer the PodMic on my editing speakers, but much prefer the AT on my phone/iPad.

  • @orvet
    @orvet 3 года назад +1

    Loved the blind mic test! Always a joy to watch your videos.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Thanks so much! 😁

  • @Primetime3209
    @Primetime3209 3 года назад +1

    Good Video I just got my Audio Technica AT2040 in the mail just waiting for the mix amp so I can use it!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      I hope you really like it!

  • @PatrickBoberg
    @PatrickBoberg 3 года назад +6

    Wow, I love the AT2040. At the switch, there is no debate.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      These comments are so funny because I think it's evenly split with people preferring one mic vs. the other. Super fascinating to read 😁
      In this specific instance, on my editing monitors I prefer the PodMic, but listening on my phone I prefer the AT.

  • @Al3xDk
    @Al3xDk Год назад +1

    i absolutely waiting the update of this video with the new podmic usb and the new at2040 usb !! 😊

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  Год назад +1

      Oh shoot, I didn't know there was a new 2040!

    • @Al3xDk
      @Al3xDk Год назад

      @@tombuck I can find it referenced on stores but still not available so it’s really new !

  • @cervuschiropractic7030
    @cervuschiropractic7030 Год назад +1

    Great review, super helpful in making a decision. Thanks Tom.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  Год назад

      So glad to hear it! Hope you find the one that’s perfect for what you need 👍

  • @Darkvamp69
    @Darkvamp69 3 месяца назад +1

    I just bought the audio technica hope it sounds good thank you for the video bro

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 месяца назад +1

      Hope you enjoy it!

    • @Darkvamp69
      @Darkvamp69 3 месяца назад

      Yup it definitely sounds great and replaced my hyperx usb mic

  • @dsaltz
    @dsaltz 3 года назад +5

    BTW, according to my guys at Sweetwater, the CT1 should be back in stock by the end of September. At least, that's the story at this moment.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I ordered a second one a few weeks ago and they told be it might be February 😱
      But they also said the first one wouldn't come in until September and I got it in July, so it must be tough to predict and they probably give conservative estimates to help manage expectations.

    • @dsaltz
      @dsaltz 3 года назад +1

      @@tombuck I bought two - only really wanted to test drive one, but they are so inexpensive! If mine come in at the end of September and you need another, let me know and I'll loan you one of mine.
      BTW, thanks to YOUUUUUU. I have a shiny new Super 55 on my desk. I used to use one back in the old band days. You are a bad influence, sir. I LIKE it!

  • @oliverseal6462
    @oliverseal6462 2 года назад +1

    Thank for this video! I have one SM7B and have been wanting to add a second one as I do not like the thin sound of the Podmic. But now I am thinking of buying 4 AT2040s instead of another SM7B.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      If you're trying to match the SM7B I'd really reacommend checking out the Shure MV7X. It's usually around $150-$170 and sounds shockingly close (the MV7X is the XLR-only version of the MV7).

  • @shybzrk
    @shybzrk 2 года назад +5

    Wow I'm having a hard time deciding. Just not Shure which one I like most. I'd say the AT2040 would probably be better for podcasting but I stream so I'm leaning toward the PodMic. I'm thinking the default sound of the PodMic lends itself better to EQ than the AT2040

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +4

      You can’t go wrong either way. Two other potential options if you can stretch your budget: the Shure MV7X or the Lewitt LCT240. 😬

  • @AliBounds
    @AliBounds Год назад +1

    The best Vs battle I was just considering these two

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  Год назад

      Hopefully it helped! Good luck in choosing the right mic 👍

    • @AliBounds
      @AliBounds Год назад

      @@tombuck I choose the AT2040 which I bought because of sound cancellation but I just understand that the hz being cutout makes the quality not as realistic because it’ll not catch the ending of words all the way due to the enhancing hertz cut.
      But the rode mic sounds more realistic my opinion but I already bought the At2040 there both good so I’ll just have to tweak plus it’s only for voice acting and sounds so I guess it should do fine Ann yeah thanks

  • @DimplePoji
    @DimplePoji 3 года назад +7

    Im swinging towards the podmic sound.. Something about sounds more full or warm or better than at2040.. I don't know, my ears prefer the podmic sound.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      In the end, it's personal preference that matters the most. To be honest, I think the AT is easier to recommend since it's more neutral in its sound, but I do prefer the PodMic in this specific comparison.

    • @DimplePoji
      @DimplePoji 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Neutral is good because it is an advantage for post processing?

  • @s1imple1cs2
    @s1imple1cs2 2 года назад +1

    I love the puns! New subscriber here sir... thanks for this... looking into the market for budget mics =) this is a big help... leaning towards the at2040 =)

  • @GabePineda
    @GabePineda 3 года назад +2

    I'm sorry, Tom (i know how much you love our buddy Podmic) But the AT2040 bags this one. It suits better with your voice. I think it has a more warm feel to it than the Podmic. I guess it all really boils down with what suits your voice best. Nice video as always!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's a great mic! I personally prefer the PodMic in this comparison, but the AT is significantly easier to EQ.

  • @ConsistentAsh
    @ConsistentAsh 3 года назад +1

    LOL those puns! Tom , you're amazing at what you do and inspire so many other content creators, and i've said it once i'll say it again. I love your B roll!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for all the support! I really Ashpreciate it. In this case the b roll is just stock footage clips played in a loop on my computer's display. I did a whole video about it here: ruclips.net/video/odDCbrzzeFc/видео.html

    • @ConsistentAsh
      @ConsistentAsh 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Hahaha, you did NOT just do a Ashpreciate it lol hahah

  • @henryvaiotu230
    @henryvaiotu230 3 года назад +2

    Both sound Good , sort of leaning towards the AT2040 has a more Transparent sound...

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's definitely more neutral, which I think means it's likely to sound "better" on a wider variety of voices.

  • @justin5421
    @justin5421 3 года назад +1

    Hey Tom great video as always! I’ve heard great things about the Klark Teknik CT-1(which is similar in design to Fethead/Triton) but Klark Teknik also makes a CM-1 and CM-2 which is exact in its design style to the Cloudlifter CL-1 and CL-2. I’ve used the Klark Teknik CM-2 for over a year now and it works great and at a fraction of the cost of the Cloudlifter!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I saw the CM models but haven't heard anything about them! I'm glad to know they work well, especially since the CT1 seems to be perpetually backordered.

    • @justin5421
      @justin5421 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Haha yea everything seems to be perpetually backordered these days. The CM models work great and you shouldn’t hesitate to check them out if you have a need

  • @JASmith
    @JASmith 3 года назад +3

    Such great information and your presentation shinesas always. Completely influenced by it which of course means I'm stealing what I can in subtle ways. I prefer the Rode in this comparison. And it has that look :)

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Please steal! 🙌

  • @SammySuperStar
    @SammySuperStar 3 года назад +1

    Such a great video Tom! Your doing some nice Mic Showdown

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Thanks Sammy!

  • @AJCoReTV
    @AJCoReTV 3 года назад +1

    Great review as usual Tom. Thanks for sharing

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it!

  • @twolinesslotcars
    @twolinesslotcars 3 года назад +1

    Great review Tom! I own 2- AT2020 that I use for my podcast.. I am guessing that this is the same mic, only made to speak into the end not side address. Keep up the great work! -Marty

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      The biggest difference is that this is a "hypercardioid" dynamic mic, and the 2020 is a condenser mic. So basically this one is a bit better at isolating noise, but might need a signal booster whereas the 2020 may be prone to picking up unwanted environmental sound but will have more than enough volume.

  • @markexploringnewstuff
    @markexploringnewstuff 3 года назад +1

    Tom, great info. You make it all look so easy - your a natural.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Thank you! I really appreciate that! I'm fortunate that I can edit these videos to make it look simple- I think uploading the raw footage would be a different story 😁

  • @jccraftmage2313
    @jccraftmage2313 Год назад +1

    Always good information Tom You are the best

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  Год назад +1

      Thanks so much!

  • @dinoscheidt
    @dinoscheidt 2 года назад +1

    12:00 ouch 😶 - well… thanks… I guess? For being my 1:1 template 👀❤️

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      You are welcome 🤓

  • @johnheiser2604
    @johnheiser2604 2 года назад +1

    Well I've owned the Podmic for 3 or 4 years and love it. Today I bought the AT2040 and can't wait to run it through the paces. I cry every time I hear the American prices. Both mics retail at AUD$169.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Keep in mind that the US doesn't put tax into the price, so they're usually a bit closer to your prices "out the door."
      It'll be interesting to see what you think of the 2040 after spending so much time with the PodMic. 👍

    • @carlocatalano7515
      @carlocatalano7515 Год назад

      hello, how did you find the 2040 after all that time with the podmic?

  • @MikeMena
    @MikeMena 3 года назад +2

    Wow… they sound so different. Both good. I think it matters if you are listening to content with or without video! The audiotechnica, I think, I prefer WITHOUT watching the video, LOL. it’s very radio sounding which sounds strange if you can see the speaker… it almost emphasizes the audio quality if you got video with the content. I made a read-through of a chapter I wrote for students, and I totally overdid the bass boost on pod mic, I didn’t realize until now that it was because you can SEE me that exaggerated how much I don’t sound like that in real life Lolol

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I'm pretty shocked at how different they sound! Especially since it seems like the AT is really being marketed as a direct competitor to the PodMic. I'm guessing that AT listened to customer feedback about the Rode and then tried to address that as best they could (lots of people say that the Podmic is too thin or leans too much to the high end). I think overall in this specific comparison I prefer the PodMic, but I'm also super used to its sound, so that might make me biased.

  • @OrenArieli
    @OrenArieli Год назад +1

    Battle of the thick and thin. For my voice, the AT2040 would win out. But short of an A/B comparison, I don't think anyone will complain about the sound of either one.

  • @Ibantar
    @Ibantar 2 года назад +1

    The AT2040 is the more robust sounding mic. Thanks for the review. (The Cloud Lifter definitely does it thing!!)

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      AT makes some really great stuff!

  • @iodainsoneoficial
    @iodainsoneoficial 3 года назад +1

    Mr. Buck, i swear to you i always dream of make some radionovelas (radio-soap-operas) using the different microphones you have tested and reviewed in your channel. The shure vintages would be perfect for detective stories. Podmic sounds more 1950's sci-fi narrator! Thanks for the videos and sorry for my bad bad bad english!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I love the idea of letting the mic dictate the style! 😎

  • @ROBOTRIX_eu
    @ROBOTRIX_eu 3 года назад +2

    That gain pre-amp devices, seem underloocked.. In my ignorant electronic knowledge, they use phantom power what it is designed for, and i am almost certain, the response time and even signal, may be better than some "lifters" if phantom power exists.. that is what i say to myself, at least..

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I'm pretty fuzzy on the technical details myself, but I appreciate that it's inexpensive! 😁

  • @arkieologist
    @arkieologist 2 года назад

    Such an excellent review video. 👏 Thank you! 😃💯🎙️ Enjoy your quality setup, little jokes, and free tips to save some cash.

  • @UnitedcPlugin
    @UnitedcPlugin 2 года назад

    The James bond music at the end, made me subscribe. Lol

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      The plan is working 😬

  • @matthewspeak4794
    @matthewspeak4794 2 года назад +1

    These are super close. The AT feels a bit richer to me, but it's muddled on the top end. The Podmic feels like it has slightly better range.

  • @ThecrosseyedTexan
    @ThecrosseyedTexan 2 года назад +5

    Both these might sound really good and I think it depends on your voice. I think the audio Technica has a little more broadcast polish to it. But it does seem to be missing a little bit of top end they both are good microphones and I don't think you could go wrong with either one but I think it depends on what you're looking for and frankly what type of voice you have.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +4

      So much of it really does depend on your individual voice. I need to get like 15 different people with different voices to help with mic tests 😁

    • @ThecrosseyedTexan
      @ThecrosseyedTexan 2 года назад +2

      @@tombuck before I bought my Electro-Voice re320 I watched a lot of your videos and even though you may not have directly recommended the Electro-Voice re320 your insight did help me pick out the right one for my voice. Podcast isn't taking off as well as I would like but it sure does sound good LOL

  • @benw998
    @benw998 3 года назад +2

    On your voice, I think I do like the PodMic actually significantly more. The 2040 kind of sounds like muddy to me? A bit like you’re talking into your arm or something? Unsure how to describe. A tad disappointed because I loved my old AT2020

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I hear what you're saying. And for sure a lot of it depends on the individual voice. I have kind of a nasally-midheavy voice, which works well on the PodMic.

    • @benw998
      @benw998 3 года назад +1

      @@tombuck An unrelated question - what is the portable power bank you use for your rodecaster pro? I’m looking to buy one myself for it but have 0 knowledge about what kind of specs I need for it

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It’s honestly just a cheap one I got from Monoprice years ago. I don’t think they even make it anymore, but I’m sure any decent modern power bank will work fine.

    • @benw998
      @benw998 3 года назад

      @@tombuck much love, thank you man!

  • @xaviergomezdelatorre6718
    @xaviergomezdelatorre6718 2 года назад +2

    My preferences:
    Rode for Streams (is less boomy when you are close to it).
    And AT2040 for recording voices at studio or maybe radio (is more warm).

    • @xaviergomezdelatorre6718
      @xaviergomezdelatorre6718 2 года назад

      But always depends on the voice to record xD

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      Totally depends on voice, you're right! The new Shure Mv7X is a bit more expensive than these, but I think it has an absolutely fantastic sound.

  • @fixedfocusmediaofficial
    @fixedfocusmediaofficial 2 года назад +2

    The at2040 is designed to look similar to the higher end Audio Technica BP40. The BP40 looks somewhat similar without the shockmount.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Very true. Also a bit like the RE20.

  • @AaronOverEverything
    @AaronOverEverything 9 месяцев назад +1

    AT2040 vs Donner PO8 or FiFine k688

  • @EddieInzauto
    @EddieInzauto 3 года назад +4

    I love videos like this; my only concern is that most reviewers have higher pitched voices than I do. If I like the lower frequency response of a mic on your voice or on Bandrew’s voice from Podcastage, is it going to turn muddy on a deeper voice? 🤔

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Speaking for the PodMic specifically- it's really nice at lower voices. I haven't heard as much variety with the AT, but I have several "deep-voiced" friends who use the PodMic and sounds awesome.

  • @marcoscesar4880
    @marcoscesar4880 2 года назад +1

    Here in Brazil both microfones are in the same range of price. I think that audio Technica is better. Great video!

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      AT makes some absolutely great gear!

  • @tvnathreviews
    @tvnathreviews 2 года назад +1

    AT2040 vs MV7. A comparison I would love to see.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      That’s a great idea! To spoil it, AT wins for price, MV7 wins for sound quality and versatility.

  • @javascriptes
    @javascriptes 2 года назад +1

    That AT lows sound really good 👍

  • @AaaaaaFuck
    @AaaaaaFuck 2 года назад +1

    Hey Tom! When I tell you that you're inspiring, you truly are. I've decided to start a podcast with a rodecaster pro, 2 rode mics, and a great quality budget headphones... But that's what I'm unsure about. You have any headphones you can suggest for me? Also, how can people like myself who's just getting into the podcast world contact you for any advice?

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      THANK YOU! This is unbelievably kind to read and I really appreciate it. Congrats on deciding to launch a show! Headphones aren't my strong suit, but I have two recommendations:
      1. Sony MDR-7506: These have been tried and true industry standards for many many years. They're not overprices and sound awesome. The only thing I don't like about them is that the cord is really heavy and sometimes gets in the way.
      2. Meze 99Neo: These were given to me as a gift last year and they're the best headphone I've ever used. More expensive than the Sonys, but incredibly comfortable and easy to wear for long periods of time.
      You can always send me an email via contact@himynameistom.com 👍

  • @johnathonready9347
    @johnathonready9347 10 месяцев назад

    Do the sterling h224, think this beats the focusrite in cost to performance. You can find it for 80$ rn too

  • @jalabi99
    @jalabi99 3 года назад +1

    If I didn't already invest so much in the RODE ecosystem (thanks to your recommendation I have a Rodecaster Pro, multiple Podmics, multiple PSA-1 boom arms, and I'm about to get a couple of Rode Wireless GO lapel mics) I might consider switching to the Audio Technica AT2040. It's a worthy alternative to the PodMic.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's definitely a good alternative and it'll work great with all your current Rode gear, but if you already have the PodMic, I wouldn't recommend "switching" to the AT. It could be a fun addition if you ever need to add a mic in the future.

  • @DM_6
    @DM_6 3 года назад +2

    Am I the only one enjoying the word play of this man? Enjoying it hahahha

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's punstoppable 😬

  • @flcon16
    @flcon16 3 года назад +2

    The Rode sounds more approachable and conversational. The AT sounds more official and broadcaster-y. At least with your voice. With the ability to process, the Rode seems much more versatile. The AT would probably be better just running it raw with no lifter or processing. They both sound really good, but distinctly different... just no idea how they'd sound with my voice.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      It realyl does depend on specific voices. For whatever reason, the PodMic seems to work for me, but I've heard other people get awesome sounds form the AT.

  • @the.i.p.address
    @the.i.p.address 2 года назад +3

    The AT2040 seems a bit fuller compared to the PodMic. The high end some are mentioning is more a lack of body for the PodMic. Having said that, some EQ sauce, and there would be no difference. I have a PodMic and SM7b, and my daily driver is the PodMic.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      I still really love the PodMic, especially when it’s paired with the “correct” voice 😎

    • @hameedalotaibi7528
      @hameedalotaibi7528 2 года назад

      @@tombuck can I used Rodecaster pro with tow phones 📱Android to do podcast Tom?

  • @technickr
    @technickr 2 года назад +3

    The AT2040 is awesome with the cloudlifter and RODE Podcaster. Just wow.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      Definitely some awesome mics!

    • @technickr
      @technickr 2 года назад

      @@tombuck did you have tested the Samson Q2U with one of them side by side?

    • @nata.sasmita
      @nata.sasmita 2 года назад +1

      @@technickr I have some mics like podmic, Q2U, ATR2100, etc. Based on side to side comparison, Samson Q2U produces lots of sibilance.

  • @MasterX25
    @MasterX25 2 года назад +1

    Would like to see the AT2040 compared to the Procaster. I'm looking to import a Procaster from Australia, which is about the same price as AT2040 sold locally (makes sense, Rode is Australian).

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      I don’t have a Procaster on hand for a comparison, but 100% I would chose that over the AT.

  • @qfapodcastabouthowardstern
    @qfapodcastabouthowardstern 3 года назад +1

    Your voice is much warmer and dare I say "natural" sounding on the at2040.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Quite frankly, I agree and this makes sense since the AT has a more "even" frequency response. It's definitely significantly more neutral than the PodMic. But I also like how the PodMic works with my voice.

  • @richard4oyeleke
    @richard4oyeleke 3 года назад +1

    You are outstanding in your field too...

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Haha, thank you for this outstanding comment 😁

  • @richard4oyeleke
    @richard4oyeleke 3 года назад +4

    I have a podmic but I think I love the audio technica....it is richer at the low end even when I far away. The the podmic can give the same when you are closer

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +2

      True. I didn't realize this until watching the video back, but the 2040 is technically a "hypercardioid" mic, which means it is a bit better at being super directional compared to the PodMic.

  • @PrestonJensen
    @PrestonJensen 3 года назад +1

    Both sound great!

  • @JasonWelchMusic
    @JasonWelchMusic 2 года назад +1

    Ive never heard either in person, but from this video, I'd say that
    if you're reading Jack and the beanstock for your audience, use the podmic. Its perfect for cleanly spoken dialog.
    But when its time for the FE FI FO FUM part, switch to the 2040.
    I spoke to a guy this week who says he uses his podmic as a kick drum mic. He says its more focused than his beta52 or d6.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      Ooh, I’d like to try it on a kick drum! I can see how it’d work great for that.

    • @JasonWelchMusic
      @JasonWelchMusic 2 года назад

      @@tombuck I think it would be good for overheads too. It handles high SPL levels

  • @DrummerPunked
    @DrummerPunked 3 года назад +2

    Great comparison ! Thinking of getting a cheaper booster for my fiancé. I have a cloud lifter but it’s a single version.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      I'm really happy that there are some cheaper options out there! Recommending a $150 Cloudlifter for a $100 mic has always been tough for me. So far the Klark Teknik has worked REALLY well for me. I ordered a second one, but it seems that they're all on backorder at the moment.

    • @ray.deathray
      @ray.deathray 2 года назад

      The Klark Teknik is great. Feels sturdy and I've had no issues with it over the past 4-5 months I've been using it. It does seem to go out of stock quickly, so I'd recommend backordering it.

  • @joaotiagosantos6547
    @joaotiagosantos6547 9 месяцев назад +2

    Hello! Thank you for your great review! I´ve purchased my Podmic (will arrive on monday), but I started seeing some reviews comparing with this AT2040. Do you think it´s better for me to change my order? I will use the mic for voice over and singing (I don´t have a treated room). What´s your opinion? Thank you in advance.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  9 месяцев назад +1

      It really depends on what you prefer for your specific voice. With a bit of EQ I don't think you can go wrong either way, but I would lean towards the PodMic myself 👍

    • @joaotiagosantos6547
      @joaotiagosantos6547 9 месяцев назад

      @@tombuck thank for you quick reply!I've liked to listen this "warm sound" of AT2040...I have to think abou it. Keep the good work! Take care! ☺️

  • @M3LV
    @M3LV 2 года назад +2

    Oh man I'm gonna say the Rode podmic dunks the AT2040 ! Although, the AT2020(condenser) is a better option then both imo.

    • @SaintsPurgatory
      @SaintsPurgatory Год назад

      No it does not. Podmic sounds like a freaking toy.

  • @haskellbrooks6912
    @haskellbrooks6912 2 года назад +1

    They really smoothed out that scarecrow joke.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Truly the most important test.

  • @kwameryan
    @kwameryan 3 года назад +1

    Hey Tom! I already have a Rode Procaster, but I still watched for fun! The scarecrow gag actually made lol which is saying a lot for me! Unrelated to your excellent mic review: I'm still fascinated by the boldness (and skill) with which you mix Sony and Canon footage and you've given me the courage to ignore the turf war on RUclips and do what I want, which is to get the FX3 for A-Cam video and hang on to my R's for multicam and photography. Why didn't you get the FX 3 btw? 🤔

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      If you haven't seen my Final Cut Pro Preset video, you might want to check it out because that's where I talk about how I mix the cameras. It really hasn't been an issue for me. And to take it even further- the R footage is 1080 and the Sony is 4K. So that means it's mixing Canon HD footage with Sony 4K footage 😱
      Honestly, both systems have their advantages, so it's kind of silly to draw a line in the sand. I love being able to use whichever tool will be best for a specific purpose. I really think the FX3 is awesome and the tally lights would be exceptionally helpful for me as a solo creator, but the a7SIII was cheaper and the viewfinder is helpful since I live in the super bright desert where screens don't always work great outside.

    • @kwameryan
      @kwameryan 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Aha... 😊 That makes total sense. My cameras work a lot in the Caribbean sun which makes me appreciate the Rs, but when they're outdoors they're rigged with an external monitor and hood, as would be the FX3. I don't like the Alpha series design language (although I've owned the A7iii) and I do love the grey FX3 look and those tally lights! I'll definitely check out your FCP video. I didn't check it out cause I use Resolve, but a preset is a preset! Thanks Tom! 👍🏾

  • @SenatorAri
    @SenatorAri 2 года назад +1

    So many people saying the AT2040 sounds better, no way lol. Watching other comparison videos it's so easy to tell the Podmic just sounds so much more clean.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      After listening over and over again, I also personally prefer the PodMic, but the AT is still great too. So much really does just come down to personal voice and prefer em.

  • @hotlineoperator
    @hotlineoperator 3 года назад +1

    This review is better than professional. Maybe I like Rode more, but it is quite sensitive for distance - and that is a problem with quests because thay move all over the place, in that case maybe Rode Wireless Go or somekind of headset with mic.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's definitely tough with guests who aren't used to using mics or who don't have good mic technique. In a way that's why I prefer condensers for some cases, since it's usually easier to get enough volume even if they move away.
      But like you said, a lav mic is a smart choice too since it's stuck to them!

  • @misterjannotjohnn
    @misterjannotjohnn 3 года назад +1

    Love the video. I would love to see the review of Tascam Mixcast 4 review. an alternative to rodecaster pro

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      I've been looking at it and it looks interested. My heavily biased opinion though is that all these copycat machines just aren't as good. They have some nifty features, but so far I haven't found anything that's a true "complete package" like the RCP (especially when you take all the regular firmware updates into account).

  • @marjacu3809
    @marjacu3809 2 года назад +2

    I've been watching reviews and comparisons between these two mics for the past 3 days and still can't decide what would be a better choice, lol.
    Quick background: I work as a software engineer and, as I've been involved in a lot of calls lately, I decided to upgrade my microphone to something that would sound more professional and clear. For that, I'd say the Podmic is a clear winner.
    But, I also need good noise rejection (especially for the hums from my computer and typing on the keyboard) and shock protection, because I tend to tap a bit harder, sometimes. It seems like the AT2040 is better at this, but is it worth to trade the PodMic's sound quality for these features?
    I too have a more nasally mid-heavy voice and I'd like to counter that as much as I can, to sound more clear. I will be using a boom arm and pop-filter as well, because I am used to having the microphone close to the mouth (so I don't need to shout, haha), so the proximity effect will be rather present.
    Which mic you think would be recommend in this use case?

    • @rubenrodrigotv
      @rubenrodrigotv 2 года назад

      What was your choice, finally? Similar situation in mu case... Thanks!

  • @ulfrinn8783
    @ulfrinn8783 2 года назад +1

    A few points to make in the AT2040's favor, and why I think it's the better buy. Firstly, I do think it has a more full, richer tone that a lot of people are going to prefer. Podmic sounds good, but it sounds flatter when compared to the more expensive competitors like my Procaster, the RE20, or SM7B. IMO, even a budget Behringer SL75C I got for a backup IMO has a better tone.
    Second point is the dimensions. The Podmic is unnecessarily large and heavy, even dwarfing the Procaster in size and weight. 937 grams and a diameter of 62mm is just ridiculous. In comparison, a Procaster is 53mm in diameter and 745 grams and nobody would say the Procaster isn't built like a big, beefy tank of a mic.
    Third point is that mount. I am not entirely sure what they were going for with that yoke. My guess is the only thought Rode put into that was to make it look somewhat like an SM7B. The AT2040's solution works 100% just as well, but doesn't add significant size and mass to a $100 mic. There's also more area on the AT2040 for a third party shock mount to grip onto, should you decide to not use the provided mount at all.
    I think the AT2040 wins out in almost all categories for most people. Enough so that when I was shopping for a new mic, the Podmic was available, and I thought the Procaster was enough better than it to spend double the price. However, were the AT2040 available at that time, I would have almost certainly bought it instead and I don't think I would have been disappointed.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Thanks for this perspective!

    • @ulfrinn8783
      @ulfrinn8783 2 года назад

      @@tombuck Yeah, honestly the size and mass of the Podmic was a letdown. You have to invest so much more into a boom arm just to get one that can support its weight.

  • @ShaneT5S
    @ShaneT5S 22 дня назад +1

    I love Audio Technica, I will defend their condenser mics even though I've been using Neumann for about a year now. BUT that being said, I can't use the AT2040. Even with EQ I can't get it to sound good, no matter what. It's super disappointing because I really wanted to like it, but I just can't

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  22 дня назад

      It's interesting you say that because as time goes on, I feel like I don't hear much about the 2040 anymore. Maybe there are a lot of people who feel that way?

  • @xTavs
    @xTavs 3 года назад +2

    Tom, the AT2040 sounds a tat better than the PodMic 🤔

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      It's a really fun mic. And it's hard to communicate via video, but the build quality is outstanding.

  • @JohnDoe-fu4qd
    @JohnDoe-fu4qd 2 года назад +1

    It sounds a lot better w the cloudlifter, I use an SM58, I think I need to get a cloudlifter

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      A lot of it does depend on your mixer, but I think that boosters can sometimes bring out a lot of nuance in the mic's sound that's pretty neat.

  • @JohnBraman413
    @JohnBraman413 2 года назад +1

    the motu m2 2x2 is a good audio interface as well.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      I've heard great things about that one!

  • @dantejamelle
    @dantejamelle 2 года назад

    Tom reminds me of Phil Dumphey from Modern Family and I love it lol

  • @mtb0x
    @mtb0x 3 года назад +1

    I love your work and you make me want to buy lots of things. Lol Mainly a Rodecaster Pro 😬🤘. Anyway keep doing what you’re doing. Don’t stop being punny 😉

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      Haha, well I hope the things you want to buy are useful! 😁

  • @atomicdetailsoc
    @atomicdetailsoc 2 года назад +1

    the microphones are like night and day so mucch more dynamic range on the AT ....listening on a pair of ADAM A7X running thru a gen1 UR22

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      Thanks for letting me know how they sound through different headphones!

    • @atomicdetailsoc
      @atomicdetailsoc 2 года назад

      @@tombuck they’re studio monitors :3 hehe

  • @makingmusiconline2309
    @makingmusiconline2309 2 года назад +1

    Definitely preferred the AudioTechnica with your voice .... more resonant, less sizzle, just felt more authoritative.

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад +1

      It's a great mic!

  • @ArsanyAziz
    @ArsanyAziz 3 года назад +2

    Definitely The podmic is much better with smooth sound , the at2040 is getting there but not yet still need more

    • @overdaedgebroadcasting2220
      @overdaedgebroadcasting2220 2 года назад +1

      Your joking right, The podmic is like it is has all the lows striped out of it and sounds thin and crap, Well its full alright full of crap and overrated go with the procaster AT2040 for the win here.

  • @gamerdadpr5940
    @gamerdadpr5940 3 года назад +1

    Great comparison! I'm using the podtrak p4 as interface instead of a focusrite. Do I'm missing something? PodMic 🙌

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад +1

      You're actually in a great position if you're using the P4 because it should have more than enough gain to run either mic without a signal booster 👍

    • @gamerdadpr5940
      @gamerdadpr5940 3 года назад

      @@tombuck Thanks for the reply!

  • @serjspm
    @serjspm 2 года назад +1

    Great channel! Thank you)

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  2 года назад

      You're welcome!

  • @rohanrahman8138
    @rohanrahman8138 3 года назад +2

    Rode is a little bit loud... So we can understand the differences.

  • @karlozm
    @karlozm Год назад

    Can I use the Klark Teknik booster just like the cloudlifter with the booster in the middle of two cables? I really hate how bulky looks my microphone on camera connected directly to the mic, I mean something like this chain FOCUSRITECABLEKLARK--->CABLEMICROPHONE

  • @EricRamz
    @EricRamz 2 года назад +1

    Holy shit these dad jokes are gold lol

  • @Interest_things
    @Interest_things Год назад

    Thank you for this comparison, Now I thinking of purchasing the At2040. But may I know what software/app are you using for recording the voice?

  • @tvnathreviews
    @tvnathreviews 3 года назад +2

    I am having fun with all the puns ❤

    • @tombuck
      @tombuck  3 года назад

      Me too! 😁