Christ, I swear this is the best counter-argument they've got. It fits very single issue conveniently. CCP bad? Have you ever been to China? Beijing has air pollution? Have you ever been to China? Some Chinese eat dogs and bats and whatnot? Have you ever been to China? We have ppl treated unfairly and literally kneel before the station crying for justice? Have you ever been to China? Dead💀 It's official now. It's invincible like "your mom gay".
Because they don't seem to misaligned with the facts in HK but only arguing abt the law per se, unlike in Xinjiang a lot of allusions and allegations are made. Thank you for showing the intellectual level of you and your peers.
Those 50cents and NMSLese, they need VPN for watching RUclips, browsing Instagram and Facebook. Saying that Hongkongers don’t know the outside world. So ridiculous😂
19:10 英國苦口婆心提醒中共要履行中英聯合聲明, 中共就說聯合聲明是廢紙。英國在黨安法後提升BNO逗留例件, 中共又突然說英國違反聯合聲明的「附件」。這就是中共, 我不用履行承諾, 但是你要。同樣地, 中共不用履行「兩制」但是你要「一國」。 In English: The UK has been repeatedly reminding CCP to keep their side of the bargain regarding the Joint Declaration, yet CCP claimed that the Joint Declaration is a piece of trash. After Hong Kong's national security law, the UK responded with a new BNO policy, and CCP immediately lashed out at the UK that it violates the "appendix" of the Joint Declaration. This is CCP for you, "I don't need to keep my side of the bargain yet you have to." The same case for the "One country, two systems", "I want One country but I won't allow Two systems."
I respect hard talk for delving deep to find the answers to many of our questions, instead of falling into the same pithole of popular opinion like many western media.
No one care about the basic fact but simply follow the logic chain built on lie. Who started the violence, Hong Kong police or the protesters? What's the differences between Hong Kong national security law/extradition law with mainland of China and US/UK law? And no one ask about one simple question: Should Hong Kong, as the territory of China, have its national security law, or any law to ensure China's national security??
@@sandclock8514 The so-called national security is a lie. The basic fact is that national security is the law to control citizens not to criticize the government.
@@cheunglion You can make up as many "facts" as you need to support yourself, but it only works in your fantasy logic system. You can't answer my questions because that's the real fact you can never mention or your system will be crack down.
I believe the interviewer did not have enough facts by aligning the violence from both sides. There are many layers of grey's to be black. Disappointed. NO mistakes!
Why not ask him why he disown his parent. Give him enough money and tell him to undress his grandmother and he will do it. Wonderful and admirable fellow the Western kids should follow
Of course hk ppl are going about their day, slaving away at work because they still need money to survive. But it doesn’t mean they have stopped wanting freedom and democracy
Theses hopeless youn generation of HK are asking for something the thay been always enjoying. for system wise maybe not fully under so called democray system but it doesn't mean we do have freedom in HK ! These youngsters are deeply poisoned! They burn people alive and killing people by brick just because people have different opinions and they call it fighting for F. Democracy! They actually gives the democracy bad name. They just a bunch od idiots whi being used by the western power behind the scene. They will be trashed by the history but their disgusting behavior will not be forgiven!
Questions weren't sharp enough, the host was not pushing for a definitive answer over his ideology of spreading Hong Kong indepenfence. Daniel Law has no right to decided for 7 and a half million Hong kongers, which most ordering citizen does not have the desire to see an independent Hong Kong. So Daniel Law, you were not a native born Hong Longer, how dare you making this independent demand on behalf of all the citizens of Hong Kong. Second to this most Hong Kong red does not want to see a disturbed social environment. The so call peaceful protest only took place in the very beginning of the social unrest, which turned violent at the latter stage, with elderly civilians been murdered, badly beaten up and touched.
Well done Nathan. Proud of you for answering questions logically and calmly. The host also did a great job and it’s nice to see a good interview on HARDtalk.
@@susantse3382 RUBBISH ! : The Host Did NOT BROUGHT UP, Elaborate NOR EVEN Acknowledge THE MASSIVE excessive and plainly immortal and illegal Behaviors of THE HK Police -- AND, ALL THOSE mysterious Suicides and NAKED FEMALE Drowning ( and possibly missing Persons AFTER BEING Arrests ) ; so, That's what you mean by A LOT OF BACKGROUND STUDIES and Know The Situation Very Well (by THE Host) ??! -- obviously, you are either VERY Biased, having SELECTIVE Perception, &/or, have NOT Acquired yourself with the REALITY of RECENT Hong Kong (which you can easily obtain from Internet , especially from those REAL & TRUE Video via RUclips) ! ANY normal , kind , moral , just or conscientious person , no matter from Internet Photos & Videos , or personally inside Hong Kong, can Understand HOW THE China 🇨🇳, actually #CCP, has been repeatedly breaking the Treaty signed with THE British , AND , THE HORRIBLE DEEDS of the Hong Kong Police !! p.s. ANY Country and ANY Human who has DECENT morality , fairly moral character or NORMALLY HEALTHY Temperament will NOT and SHOULD Not agree , condone AND COLLABORATE with THE CCP, i.e., THE China Communists -- who are NOT DIFFERENT at All, but definitely WORSE THAN The NAZI ; will you and should you Do Businesses , having Trades with THE KKK or the Nazi -- just because There will Be TREMENDOUS Amount of FINANCIAL Gain ???!
I don't know why the West is so hostile to China. I see that many Western media reports on us are always distorted. I really hope that Chinese people can live in peace with all the people in the world, and we can understand and respect each other.中国不是某个政府，不是某个党。中国是一个文化的认同感。中国是李白、杜甫、白居易;中国是金陵玉殿莺啼晓，秦淮水榭花开早;中国是十里楼台倚翠薇，百花深处杜鹃啼;中国是三万里河东入海，五千仞岳上摩天。总之中国是所有在这片土地上曾经发生，正在发生，和以后会发生的一切。Forgive me for using Chinese, because I really don't know how to translate Chinese poetry well in English. I hope we can become friends.
@@李岸汀 I agree that "China" means a "China" with greater extend including it's culture, history, geography, and diversity. However, it is the Chinese government/ CCP who narrows down the meaning into PRC. China should have heterogeneity instead of homogeneity
@@sunflowerhk100 No one care about the basic fact but simply follow the logic chain built on lie. Who started the violence, Hong Kong police or the protesters? What's the differences between Hong Kong national security law/extradition law with mainland of China and US/UK law? And no one ask about one simple question: Should Hong Kong, as the territory of China, have its national security law, or any law to ensure China's national security??
freedom to kill? freedom to burn china flag and discrimination? freedom to harass china businesses in Hk? or freedom to beat and burn people for not supporting your protest? what freedom do u want ?
Dark Matter you totally missing the point. Watch the interview again. Things are totally peaceful back in June 2019. Million ppl came out to speak out peacefully. See how the hk govt and police to response in such a brutal way. We won’t stop until govt held their accountable. Btw, many youngers in hk, they die. And how come I can’t see any mercy you give it to them. Asshole.
@@wongkityu Hey he is talking about a very important point about freedom, and you just ignored the question by saying "ur missing the point". I think it's more likely that ur looking at the thing in the way you like.
They are traitors with no brains. I saw how they destroy public utilities, the movement are like zombies! And the big fat bald headed “leaders” behind are very evil to make young kids become terrorist street fighters! Why block the roads, attack other people who support the Hong Kong Government! You all are like tyrants!
I like this program! Hardtalk! Good questions for this very ignorant and dangerous, ungrateful, unproductive Hong Kong Chinese young man. He disregarded the majority of the Hong Kong people! Shame on him!
@@zelide6985 The so-called Hong Kong, to real Hongkongers, was long gone and just a hollow shell since the Communist took over. They didn't destruct Hong Kong but the Communist did.
very good questions from the interviewr! He admitted that the pursuit of independence and the use of violence were wrong and has changed his stance. He pursued American ideology. Today, three years later, Britain and the United States no longer care about this issue. What remains is the division of Hong Kong society and between people.
15:45 question about violence demonstrate in Hong Kong "People are so lenient towards people in power but so restrained to the people who are powerless. And that disappoint me... *that is important that we recognize the reason,the root cause why people react in that way* " well said Nathan what we do is try to find out the root and solve the problem unlike someone keeps saying ridiculous/come to hongkong/nonononono XD
They don't oppose violence, they just oppose democracy-supporters. They oppose their very existence. It's evidenced by their reaction towards violence from their own side. Remember how they condoned violence and even "demanded justice" for the seven cops who beat unarmed protestor Ken Tsang?
The national security law in HK is not the same as other democratic country. This one brings its own judges and no jury are present. It is not really a court system when the prosecutor, judge and jury are the same guy.
It's not the time for debating who did the best in the interview, but let the public know what is going on in Hong Kong. Now let the people know how the HK government does not respect the two systems. Come on, show me some examples.
Mickey Finn I thought, since mid 90s. We should have learned how to conduct some proper researches on topics that we’re interested. Instead of replying on some source information to be feed.
so u can go to the street and destroy the public facility and set fire to metro and break the houses and attack innocents? and when the govt come up with laws to regulate, then u simple book a ticket and fleet to a foreign country? so many Americans not like Trump and USA govemt, but does that mean they have to go independence and deny they r not Americans?
Well said, Nathan😢 You spoke words! Thank you 💛 And also thank BBC and Steven for providing this platform for HK people to express our desire for autonomy and freedom! Free for freedom, stand with HK!
Has the HARDtalk host noticed that today's (2021) Hong Kong security law is already in progress in HK? The host was in the questions of last year, and now Hong Kong government used the actions to tell you the answer.
羅冠聰 is not exciled 流亡 . He was not arrested/charged or anything by HK government. He left HK as a normal traveler without trouble by HK Custom. he is going to continue his study in Yale. He is not wanted, and still can return HK freely . Exile means to be away from one's home, while either being explicitly refused permission to return or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return. What do you think? Don't be misled by this interview.
We have had already normal people without the international attentions charged with the new law just carrying the “光腹香港時代革命” flag in his backpack, blank paper without a single word written and a Taiwanese flag, and you said it is OK to have such law
Nathan Law ,His talents are limitless! He should go to the United States to participate in and support the BLM movement to help American minorities establish their own nation!
2019 . 07 . 21 There is an organized crime that they govt using local thugs beating up people who dare voicing their objection about the extradition law in Hong Kong !!!
It would be really interesting to ask the host to reflect on all the questions he asked Nathan. Time did tell, Even Germany is moving their position. You can even do business with a country do not respect international law or commerce rule. When China says Win Win, it means China wins twice. HK people paid hard price to wake up the international community.
See? A legitimate and honest person doesn't turn the question around with "Have you ever been to XXX?".
Christ, I swear this is the best counter-argument they've got. It fits very single issue conveniently. CCP bad? Have you ever been to China? Beijing has air pollution? Have you ever been to China? Some Chinese eat dogs and bats and whatnot? Have you ever been to China? We have ppl treated unfairly and literally kneel before the station crying for justice? Have you ever been to China?
Dead💀 It's official now. It's invincible like "your mom gay".
Because they don't seem to misaligned with the facts in HK but only arguing abt the law per se, unlike in Xinjiang a lot of allusions and allegations are made. Thank you for showing the intellectual level of you and your peers.
@Joseph H. This is Hard Talk man. This is a challenge that the interviewee accepted.
Good point! That is the "strategy" or fallacy known as Attacking the Person.
Have you been to HongKong?
Well done Nathan
多少希望回到1840 年的时候啊！ 那时候多么明主啊！ 我没有读什么书，放牛长大的，谁帮忙解释一下什么叫”民主” ？
andylee989955 人民做主是為民主，政府都是僕人
@@mingchiliu7076 像美利坚一样每天8万人感染的民主吗
ban q 怎麼不提北韓？
Summer Chan 在暴民么？
英文好好，條理分明，表達清晰。你去英國既決定無錯，你已經好好咁勝任緊你而家既責任！
叻仔👍👍👍👍講事實👏👏👏👏👏
借個位置唔好意思。
羅冠聰一開頭就話國安法以言入罪抓去國內審判，之後就長篇大論
如果好似澳門一樣，沒人因為國安法定罪，那不就打臉......全都是幻想嗎？
我還是覺得讓子彈飛，看下未來是怎麼樣......
中国政府对你们还真没兴趣，关你们，还需北上？有被害妄想症的你们，看看那位小黄人就知道了，今时今日还住在香港豪宅好好的。切！
在英国伦敦拯救中国香港😂，人都已经逃跑了，还支持呢。这也太搞笑了。
@@rp6456 難道殺人犯一直恐嚇你但未到下手的一刻 你就不理他架在你脖子上的刀嗎 然後架了30年你就可以當那刀是裝飾嗎?
當年擔心的事, 現在都在發生了
Those 50cents and NMSLese, they need VPN for watching RUclips, browsing Instagram and Facebook. Saying that Hongkongers don’t know the outside world. So ridiculous😂
so in real world hongkonger win?
傻逼
Copper Friddle for sure
@@mx3270 干啥啥不行，对号入座第一名
格萨尔.习.庆丰二世 傻逼来对座入号了？
問題都很尖銳，但他能正面回應，而不是“你有去過香港嗎”，真的表現得很不錯。
耳听为虚眼见为实，如果狗没脑子，请忽略这句话
FOX --------- 川建国, 三立 ------------- 蔡英文
🙄你去过塞浦路斯吗？这个国家在哪里？什么语言？什么制度？虽然你不知道，但你也能正面回应，只要张嘴放屁就好了。
正面回答？回答到9 up.咁。。。听完就唔记得都话好？
@@纳树 你看一看劉曉明在hardtalk的訪問，差別可大了。
19:10 英國苦口婆心提醒中共要履行中英聯合聲明, 中共就說聯合聲明是廢紙。英國在黨安法後提升BNO逗留例件, 中共又突然說英國違反聯合聲明的「附件」。這就是中共, 我不用履行承諾, 但是你要。同樣地, 中共不用履行「兩制」但是你要「一國」。
In English: The UK has been repeatedly reminding CCP to keep their side of the bargain regarding the Joint Declaration, yet CCP claimed that the Joint Declaration is a piece of trash. After Hong Kong's national security law, the UK responded with a new BNO policy, and CCP immediately lashed out at the UK that it violates the "appendix" of the Joint Declaration. This is CCP for you, "I don't need to keep my side of the bargain yet you have to." The same case for the "One country, two systems", "I want One country but I won't allow Two systems."
求求你了，把你老婆借我玩幾天，求求你了，我都這麼苦口婆心的求你了，為什麼你還不答應我？
你的一国在哪里?
@@trddmlm3162 比喻失當, 你把簽了紙的承諾(聯合聲明), 說成了是無理要求(老婆借我玩幾天)
@@banq2878 一國不見了嗎?
@@hko2006 那裡失當了？都是無禮的要求
I respect hard talk for delving deep to find the answers to many of our questions, instead of falling into the same pithole of popular opinion like many western media.
true
歡迎各位享受言論自由
自由？笑死了，要不要带你去看看红叉？
为什么其他的国家总想强迫中国民主？如果世界上大部分都是共产国家，然后全部强迫民主国家共产会是什么感受？
沒錯有言論自由,但言論之後的自由就...
英國統治HongKong154年,”英皇制誥”=基本法,但是他們從未爭取”自由” ,英國人像老鼠一樣隔離香港人.今天,起碼特首已是港人.1997前,香港沒有民主，港人從未要求普選,甘做英國奴才.過去1年,香港打砸搶燒-破壞契約就是廢青們口中的民主自由？
@@hahaha8979 嘿你的名字好菜啊
主持人的提问相当犀利，符合节目标题hard talk。回答的话，我觉得不到100分，但70-80也是有了。也符合他自己说的，要世界听到他的一种声音。
他的邏輯看似嚴密，但是出發點就不對。
對於一國兩制他的看法是所謂的大陸不遵守兩制，所以他就可以不遵守一國，就可以搞獨立搞國家分裂。
這裡他完全是把香港擺在了中國同一個層級，但是事實香港是屬於國家管轄的一個地區，一國兩制是國家實驗一個地區發展的政策方針。
香港根本沒有權利對國家措施給予反制，地區認為國家做的不合理，可以合理要求反應爭取，但是把自己地位擺到和中國一個層級，妄圖反制丶分裂國家丶搞獨立，甚至把國家內部問題希望外國勢力插手處理，本身就是十分荒謬的。
@@chriswang5492 说的好，香港问题是中国内政，绝不允许外国势力干涉。
Chris Wang 嗯 你的邏輯是有強權冇公理 明白
@@chriswang5492 你的言語之間扣帽子和空洞無物。完全是中共口吻。
1, 羅什麼時候支持港獨和分裂國家？
2, 你說的是“反制”中國，實際上是“反對”中國。這不是香港的權利，而是香港人的權利。
3, 國有惡法，如何合理爭取？香港人沒合理地爭取過嗎？
@@karmankm2156 世界上任何一個國家對地區來說不是強權？你說說世界上有哪個國家允許自己地區搞國家分裂獨立運動的？維護國家統一是每個國家的底線，香港認為大陸做的不公平，反映爭取都好，搞分裂獨立完全就是在觸碰國家底線
The answers are clear and straight-forward.
No one care about the basic fact but simply follow the logic chain built on lie. Who started the violence, Hong Kong police or the protesters? What's the differences between Hong Kong national security law/extradition law with mainland of China and US/UK law? And no one ask about one simple question: Should Hong Kong, as the territory of China, have its national security law, or any law to ensure China's national security??
The answers given here are super clear indeed ruclips.net/video/ZutLstATsig/видео.html
@@sandclock8514 The so-called national security is a lie. The basic fact is that national security is the law to control citizens not to criticize the government.
@@cheunglion You can make up as many "facts" as you need to support yourself, but it only works in your fantasy logic system. You can't answer my questions because that's the real fact you can never mention or your system will be crack down.
@@sandclock8514 Cant agree more. They never reply these key question directly...Neeever! And also never make any apology to the mistakes they made:(
BBC这个主持人的提问很有水准，很理性客观。
這主持人問題真的很尖銳又很有水準，本人也非常理性客觀
可以看看這主持人問劉曉明的那集，做的非常好
少有的外國記者會如此中肯報導。
敢作要敢為又係靠吹
誤人子弟
可悲又可憐
唉
@@nopanttynolife 主持人的問題點尖銳呀?
尖銳應該問9呀羅37, 係深圳出世, 扮乜柒香港人
尖銳應該問又話齊上齊落, 攪乜春著草留低gphone踎監!
做難民點對得住班手足!
@@tonysun8025 应该问，你什么成绩能进耶鲁大学？
At least there’s no more “no no no no no” in the whole interview 🤷🏿♂️
If he is the ambassador of CCHChina, he will keep repeating "Have you been to HK? Have to been to HK?...." LMAO
@@yncy323 laughed...😂
真搞笑，你们是在上英文课么？哈哈哈哈
Timothy Yui Hong king is so big blahblahblah
m X32 pathetic creation, you should take a look how your ambassador in 🇬🇧 performed couple days ago, can’t be more embarrassing
Nathan shows his sincerity and honesty during this talk. Obviously he is telling a truth and that’s why he doesn’t evade Stephen’s harsh questions.
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
没有哪个国家喜欢保留叛徒，西方国家也讨厌叛徒
@@alvinyg3914 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
@@alvinyg3914 你真是个傻逼垃圾
太犀利了。我们正是缺少更多的这类年轻人。
缺少垃圾吧
不是缺少，是殺掉了
@@快乐小伙伴 唔好講自己
Nathan答得很得體。👍🏻👍🏻
他很紧张，没想到BBC主持人没有迎合他的独立思想h h h😂
你的阅读理解有问题，他明明是紧张，而且不证明回答问题，就是老油条😂
After watching this interview, I must say that this host is hard to both sides with direct and sharp questions.
Really high quality journalist
That's the reason it calls Hardtalk
That’s how one find out the truth. He is a remarkable journalist.
I believe the interviewer did not have enough facts by aligning the violence from both sides. There are many layers of grey's to be black. Disappointed. NO mistakes!
Why not ask him why he disown his parent. Give him enough money and tell him to undress his grandmother and he will do it. Wonderful and admirable fellow the Western kids should follow
Of course hk ppl are going about their day, slaving away at work because they still need money to survive. But it doesn’t mean they have stopped wanting freedom and democracy
What do u mean, they didn’t need to work before the security law?
Theses hopeless youn generation of HK are asking for something the thay been always enjoying. for system wise maybe not fully under so called democray system but it doesn't mean we do have freedom in HK ! These youngsters are deeply poisoned! They burn people alive and killing people by brick just because people have different opinions and they call it fighting for F. Democracy! They actually gives the democracy bad name. They just a bunch od idiots whi being used by the western power behind the scene.
They will be trashed by the history but their disgusting behavior will not be forgiven!
Lilac What do you mean "they "? Are you one of "they". If not, you have no right to speak for "they ".
Ohhhhhh please, you are just against CCP
HK is part of China. If you don't like it, just leave. Simple.
比較返湯家驊個集真係笑死人
歷史是勝利者書寫的，成王敗寇的道理你應該明白
"i have not yet finished" 羞家到呢...
@@h0607333 那又是，對比湯家驊那集，主持要不斷打斷他說話，人家是甲組隊正面交鋒；
對羅冠聰這種乙組水平，又要讓他好好幫示威者當文宣，自然要放水任他說不打斷他。
@@vergilkan 十一哥係國家隊啊甲組隊，係咪分裂國家啊？
@@qwerqwer2572 你認為係咪試下舉報睇下成唔成立囉。XD
这个主持人保持了难得的客观和理性
LOL
真是标准的sb，哈哈，笑死我了
@@sagedf2505 嗯嗯，您好好的笑死吧 :）
只有中性或者表面上看起来中性的采访才有人看，一面倒的没观众
這怎會是客觀, 他的觀點只是和你一樣而矣.
Gotta love how Law is answering the questions so sharply, even when the questions were pretty critical.
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
Jianhao He 雖然你用人的身分開了一個youtube account，但我還是從你的comment聽出了狗吠聲🥴 大陸噴子level就是低就是賤🤷🏻♂️
@@CasuallyHardcores 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
@@CasuallyHardcores 你真是个傻逼垃圾
的确是精英
跟同年紀的中國小粉紅比，的確相差十個級數，中國13億人有那一個年輕領袖能比？一個也沒有
跑得快
@@davidm1451 你說得對，小粉紅就是nmsl嘴裡跑得快，從不輸人
@@Barry_Botter 慫逼一個，革命不行，逃跑第一名
@@huiqianyu6960 一毛仲唔逃跑，三峽快崩，大大水沖到來啦!
伟大的香港人，勇敢的香港年轻人
牛逼！
勇敢在哪里？
hai guo 勇敢在他有本事和膽量上國際性節目
你敢在微博發一條習近平死全家
或者狗漢奸習明澤嗎？？
@@清-j6t 这么低俗的也就你讲的出口 垃圾習近平就可以 教坏细路
hai guo 你試試在中國的街道上/ 網絡上說說習和共產黨的壞話，看看你有沒有這勇氣😅
@@清-j6t 不用說到這麼低俗,就說一句,習近平下台,敢在中國境內節目說一句,不被抓坐個十年牢獄我不相信
我来自中国大陆，谢谢BBC的采访，让我们听到不同 于共产党的声音。
可以听但千万不要中了美西方政客的毒
叻仔
加油Nathan! 香港人會記得你既付出！
当然记得，你们破坏完后有没有赔钱！
and also the questions were sharp too, he was not evading to answer, not like those...
"HavE yOu BeEn tO XinJiAnG?"
HaVe yOu evEr beEn tO cHiNa?
Yes, recourse to a “poll” that nobody knows is very easy way to “answer” a question
That's right, but say nothing is better than lying.
Questions weren't sharp enough, the host was not pushing for a definitive answer over his ideology of spreading Hong Kong indepenfence.
Daniel Law has no right to decided for 7 and a half million Hong kongers, which most ordering citizen does not have the desire to see an independent Hong Kong. So Daniel Law, you were not a native born Hong Longer, how dare you making this independent demand on behalf of all the citizens of Hong Kong.
Second to this most Hong Kong red does not want to see a disturbed social environment. The so call peaceful protest only took place in the very beginning of the social unrest, which turned violent at the latter stage, with elderly civilians been murdered, badly beaten up and touched.
Hard Talk從來沒有讓我失望XD
Well done Nathan. Proud of you for answering questions logically and calmly. The host also did a great job and it’s nice to see a good interview on HARDtalk.
由留言看到很多人的無知，又不批判追究，被犯民毒果日報洗腦而不自知，完全不懂思考蘿罐葱對香港有什麼貢獻過，無視蘿對香港從來沒有貢獻過，蘿反對香港獨立，蘿反對香港人悼念前英女皇，蘿支持中共國單程證殖民香港，支持中共國奪取香港人的香港主權，支持一國两制騎劫壓迫香港人，2014年雨傘革命時，他在金鐘㧻魁叫黑警拉勇武手足，他反港罪行之多，一定要追究，還有，留言的人有多少知道蘿罐葱不是香港人，他是深圳仔，1997年後用單程證殖民香港，他的思想和價值從來都是站在中國人立場，凌駕香港人，支持他的人都係是非黑白不分。
Hong Kong people may seem to be living "normally" after the security law is passed, but in fact, many are planning to immigrate if they can.
With pandemic and China Security Law in HK nothing is normal.
Farewell. Don’t comeback please
Silly people will migrate out of HK, China and HK are the future. 儍瓜才移民，中国香港才是未来。
to emigrate, not immigrate, to be accurate.
@@hjw2405 空間是時間🤣5000年－4930年文化，不意外
作为一个做新闻的晚辈，前辈的采访技巧学习到了，整场控制着话题的方向，当嘉宾说到无关主题的话题时立刻打断，根据被访者的回答随机应变，问题锋利而不是过于刺耳，优秀的提问者，优秀的记者，当然这一套用在对于任何问题都有回答模板的人身上也没有用，罗冠聪回答的还算不错。
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
Jianhao He 嘴巴這麼臭沒有問題嗎？記得刷牙
@@pizza_1714 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
@@pizza_1714 你真是个傻逼垃圾
We love you 🥰 you are great Hongkongner. Keeping strong 💪
Appreciate using 手足 as the translation for the protestor fellows
Flawless translation, BBC... flawless!
"fellow terrorists" is the correct translation.
@@travl8138 Spot on!
@@travl8138 Yes. Appropriate for people like you.
@@travl8138 r u chinazi?
Nathan, I as a Hong Konger, you have my deepest respect to voice it out for us.
How about you go to UK and speak out as well? HK is hopeless
lu lu HK is part of China, right? So, the same of hopeless? XD
英國才不歡迎他，蘇格蘭及愛爾蘭也想獨立呀。
16:37 “Why people are so lenient towards the people who are in power but so restricted to the people who are powerless? “ well said!!
The truth may not be like this.
@@susantse3382 RUBBISH ! : The Host Did NOT BROUGHT UP, Elaborate NOR EVEN Acknowledge THE MASSIVE excessive and plainly immortal and illegal Behaviors of THE HK Police -- AND, ALL THOSE mysterious Suicides and NAKED FEMALE Drowning ( and possibly missing Persons AFTER BEING Arrests ) ;
so, That's what you mean by A LOT OF BACKGROUND STUDIES and Know The Situation Very Well (by THE Host) ??! -- obviously, you are either VERY Biased, having SELECTIVE Perception, &/or, have NOT Acquired yourself with the REALITY of RECENT Hong Kong (which you can easily obtain from Internet , especially from those REAL & TRUE Video via RUclips) !
ANY normal , kind , moral , just or conscientious person , no matter from Internet Photos & Videos , or personally inside Hong Kong, can Understand HOW THE China 🇨🇳, actually #CCP, has been repeatedly breaking the Treaty signed with THE British , AND , THE HORRIBLE DEEDS of the Hong Kong Police !!
p.s. ANY Country and ANY Human who has DECENT morality , fairly moral character or NORMALLY HEALTHY Temperament will NOT and SHOULD Not agree , condone AND COLLABORATE with THE CCP, i.e., THE China Communists -- who are NOT DIFFERENT at All, but definitely WORSE THAN The NAZI ; will you and should you Do Businesses , having Trades with THE KKK or the Nazi -- just because There will Be TREMENDOUS Amount of FINANCIAL Gain ???!
👌🏾👌🏿👌🏽👌🏼👌🏻👌🕵🏼🕵🏼🕵🏼👍🏻👍🌈
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
強力要求台灣政府無條件接收香港民運人士，
強力要求台灣政府
在台灣北中南，
各劃一個10平方公里的香港人生活專區，
保障我香港人的生存，
保護我香港人的文化，
以展現當初台灣政府宣稱挺香港的承諾！
否則，
台灣人就是欺騙我香港人的騙子！
到時候在台香港人，
不會坐視香港同胞，
被台灣人欺騙利用出賣！
定會為了正義自由民主與生存，
與台灣政府抗爭到底！
羅冠聰現在被國安法通緝，只能說他的估計真的準確無誤，現在我開始相信他們了，香港加油。
这个还用估计吗。。。别看今天闹得欢小心将来拉清单
Pine Joi 哈哈 這算什麼黑幕 現在就是光明正大地和西方民主國家聯手滅共
@@Long0529 其實對於聯合國幾個常任理事國來說，是不可能被滅的，因為任何有核武噶國家垂死一擊，一定是全人類同歸於盡，不會像阿富汗、伊拉克、敘利亞之類的，所以大國博弈最多打打嘴炮，玩玩經濟貿易戰，齋講唔打。
Pine Joi 咩黑幕，講到好似你自己先係背後指揮，冇證冇據就喺度鳩噏，人哋擺明同西方合作
这和民主无关。小丑！
问题十分尖锐，记者十分中立，很专业
记者很傻
@@BCN_PK 你條殘體撚樣更傻?
Lao Han Xia 傻在哪裏
有你傻嗎？？
中立？？？？？？？？？？你的Chinese不灵光吧
Chinese 你JB，中国人讲你毛线英文
Support you 羅冠聰！thanks for your sacrifice
現在所有人都知道離開香港是羅冠聰正確的決定，否則現在他已經在牢獄中 !
台灣人支持他，加油 !
在國際為真香港人持續發聲 !
罗冠聪--兄弟姐妹们加油啊，我再英国祝福你们哦，尽量用生命对抗，我在英国读书了啊，民主万岁
由留言看到很多人的無知，又不批判追究，被犯民毒果日報洗腦而不自知，完全不懂思考蘿罐葱對香港有什麼貢獻過，無視蘿對香港從來沒有貢獻過，蘿反對香港獨立，蘿反對香港人悼念前英女皇，蘿支持中共國單程證殖民香港，支持中共國奪取香港人的香港主權，支持一國两制騎劫壓迫香港人，2014年雨傘革命時，他在金鐘㧻魁叫黑警拉勇武手足，他反港罪行之多，一定要追究，還有，留言的人有多少知道蘿罐葱不是香港人，他是深圳仔，1997年後用單程證殖民香港，他的思想和價值從來都是站在中國人立場，凌駕香港人，支持他的人都係是非黑白不分。
想必，閣下以後也會支持在兩岸開戰時逃到美國依然鼓勵大家英勇獻身的賴子哥。
Meanwhile the former comissioner of Hong Kong police: I can't find the right word
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
I don't know why the West is so hostile to China. I see that many Western media reports on us are always distorted. I really hope that Chinese people can live in peace with all the people in the world, and we can understand and respect each other.中国不是某个政府，不是某个党。中国是一个文化的认同感。中国是李白、杜甫、白居易;中国是金陵玉殿莺啼晓，秦淮水榭花开早;中国是十里楼台倚翠薇，百花深处杜鹃啼;中国是三万里河东入海，五千仞岳上摩天。总之中国是所有在这片土地上曾经发生，正在发生，和以后会发生的一切。Forgive me for using Chinese, because I really don't know how to translate Chinese poetry well in English. I hope we can become friends.
@@李岸汀 I agree that "China" means a "China" with greater extend including it's culture, history, geography, and diversity. However, it is the Chinese government/ CCP who narrows down the meaning into PRC. China should have heterogeneity instead of homogeneity
That was a super tough interview......
He did super well! So proud of him! And he didn't dodge of the questions. He tackled each of the difficult questions smoothly, clearly and concisely
Wonder what is so tough?
But he did really well
@@sunflowerhk100 No one care about the basic fact but simply follow the logic chain built on lie. Who started the violence, Hong Kong police or the protesters? What's the differences between Hong Kong national security law/extradition law with mainland of China and US/UK law? And no one ask about one simple question: Should Hong Kong, as the territory of China, have its national security law, or any law to ensure China's national security??
Definitely
不錯
bbc蠻中立，絕對不是那些黨媒能比
主持人的問題，很多都有骨
但這樣才好，因為他不是站在你的角度發問
所以我也不太懂，小粉紅為什麼說bbc是反華媒體，他一樣會質問。
應該係有d集數訪問嘅人物有問題
BBC不会特意反华，他只是一家为英美统治者服务的官媒而已，本质上和环球时报差不多，只不过BBC叼飞盘的姿势比较好看而已。
沒錯，不像三笠之類的綠營打手，大概只有白癡才信吧！
@dd 你叫廣東人和香港人的語言做鳥語？即是你否認我們是中國人的一份子吧？
liulingqi0 環球不行！胡錫進太傻了
環球就像香港01，就是不會直接親中，給人一種中立感覺，實際就是親中，如果一個媒體中立，一定會用詞小心，香港反送中，環球一直說香港示威者是暴徒，如果要指他是暴徒就應該從某件事，并不是針對所有人，所以也不會像BBC那樣。
What a bright intelligent young man, go on your way, we need you.
一个闻风丧胆选择跑路的跳梁小丑……
Good job! Hong Kong must be free
freedom to kill? freedom to burn china flag and discrimination? freedom to harass china businesses in Hk? or freedom to beat and burn people for not supporting your protest?
what freedom do u want ?
Dark Matter you totally missing the point. Watch the interview again. Things are totally peaceful back in June 2019. Million ppl came out to speak out peacefully. See how the hk govt and police to response in such a brutal way. We won’t stop until govt held their accountable. Btw, many youngers in hk, they die. And how come I can’t see any mercy you give it to them. Asshole.
@@wongkityu how many die? in your imagination? give me some figures
NX W go google idiot.. Do I need to search everything for you?
@@wongkityu Hey he is talking about a very important point about freedom, and you just ignored the question by saying "ur missing the point". I think it's more likely that ur looking at the thing in the way you like.
香港人真了不起啊
羡慕吧～ 可惜你在他们眼里是狗
應該說香港的年輕人了不起，我們這一代已經無能為力，只可以作他們的後盾。
香港還是有很多親共賣港賊，是時候跟牠們算賬了
香港是我的精神故鄉 ，願榮光歸香港！
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
傻閪
@@jianhaohe2910
雖然你身上穿了Giorgio Armani的褲子，但我還是隱約看到你腳上的牛糞
這次，遠去的，不可能回來了，地球版圖上少了一個可以收納難民的地方，禍福焉知，祝福香港人隨遇而安，我們這些逃難來香港的人感恩香港……抵制警惕那些追殺而來的ccp和紅衛兵思維的恶魔
不得不承认，作为一个年轻人，罗冠聪的话术非常地老练、优秀。他本身的逻辑也是一贯的。
想出人头地哪有那么简单，革命是最好的出头机会，以后只要天天看新闻，天天写稿子，就可以月入百万了，谁不想这样
罗冠聪--兄弟姐妹们加油啊，我再英国祝福你们哦，尽量用生命对抗，我在英国读书了啊，民主万岁
我认为对阵bbc的这些问题罗的回答还是落了下风，bbc的问题也是句句切中要害，只要你为了还要继续斗争下去就必须面对的问题。
主持人問的問題拿揑得很到位，一方面用中方的立場去問但留下一些位置給他作出反擊，也沒有再同一個問題上糾結，而是順應問題轉去下一個問題，讓羅一步一步帶出他的理念，看完整個訪問，感覺很流暢，有一定的攻守，在不同的位置帶出反思和更深層的了解！
他访问，驻英大使可没这么好说话哦，是真的hardtalk，一说到英国的双标就会打断别人
I admire you Nathan. Well done. Hope you can settle well in London. Thank you so much for your efforts done for HK. 好人一生平安！
No .. He will be suffering in London without love. 😂😂😂
Love is in your heart if you can find it. I’m sure Nathan has it in his heart. He will live happily there.
Besides London has a lot of lovely people there. It’s easy to find.
Stop labelling Law as the leader. The movement was leaderless.
They are traitors with no brains. I saw how they destroy public utilities, the movement are like zombies! And the big fat bald headed “leaders” behind are very evil to make young kids become terrorist street fighters! Why block the roads, attack other people who support the Hong Kong Government! You all are like tyrants!
I like this program! Hardtalk! Good questions for this very ignorant and dangerous, ungrateful, unproductive Hong Kong Chinese young man. He disregarded the majority of the Hong Kong people! Shame on him!
The movement was meant to bring destruction to Hong Kong. Whatever he said doesn’t representing HK people, only to those anti-China.
@@zelide6985 The so-called Hong Kong, to real Hongkongers, was long gone and just a hollow shell since the Communist took over. They didn't destruct Hong Kong but the Communist did.
@@annieyue9184 Shame on you.i The majority of the Hong Kong people stand with him!
very good questions from the interviewr! He admitted that the pursuit of independence and the use of violence were wrong and has changed his stance. He pursued American ideology. Today, three years later, Britain and the United States no longer care about this issue. What remains is the division of Hong Kong society and between people.
I remember that this reporter likes to interrupt others. Why don't you interrupt him now? Because he likes listening to lies and spreading rumors.
Wonderful Interview. Great job for the harsh and realistic questions and Nathan answered them in a polite and humble way.
主持和Nathan兩個都很強
the interview was quite intense
rubbish
ypvicky1025
Rubbish is
“you” not *him*.
@@ypvicky1025 ya just keep saying,that's yOu
ypvicky1025 could you say exactly which part is “rubbish”?
有诉求提出来是对的，就像主持人说的：一国，不是分裂，也不是独立，这是中国的红线。
15:45 question about violence demonstrate in Hong Kong
"People are so lenient towards people in power but so restrained to the people who are powerless. And that disappoint me... *that is important that we recognize the reason,the root cause why people react in that way* " well said Nathan what we do is try to find out the root and solve the problem unlike someone keeps saying ridiculous/come to hongkong/nonononono XD
yep he just be come so emotional while saying this.I feel his pain and his powerless...
They don't oppose violence, they just oppose democracy-supporters. They oppose their very existence. It's evidenced by their reaction towards violence from their own side. Remember how they condoned violence and even "demanded justice" for the seven cops who beat unarmed protestor Ken Tsang?
u guys have nothing better to do then protest ? why can't just be normal and do business and make money with china instead of constantly protesting?
@@BIack.Kaiser Ok sure. Let's pretend nothing had happened including the millions of Uyghurs being imprisoned in Xinjiang
@@BIack.Kaiser You're a pathetic being whose only important thing in life is money.
The national security law in HK is not the same as other democratic country. This one brings its own judges and no jury are present. It is not really a court system when the prosecutor, judge and jury are the same guy.
Nathan performs very great. Pride of Hong Kong.
謝謝羅冠聰發聲
罗冠聪--兄弟姐妹们加油啊，我再英国祝福你们哦，尽量用生命对抗，我在英国读书了啊，民主万岁
叻仔！講得好好👍👍👍 如果係何妖，又拍枱拍凳走人！
Simon Fung 何妖會話每個人講嘢都有自己情緒XD
叻係邊度？？做漢奸，賣國都話叻？
關心香港的一份子 舉証先啦
香港優秀的年青人
Simon Fung 叻仔，英雄出少年👍👍👍
同湯渣高下立見
good for Nathan, suck for Ronny
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
@@jianhaohe2910
雖然你身上穿了Giorgio Armani的褲子，但我還是隱約看到你腳上的牛糞
@@hksuperman 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
@@hksuperman 你真是个傻逼垃圾
what a contrast to Ronnny Tong
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
@@tomkorean4348 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
@@tomkorean4348 你真是个傻逼垃圾
He has responded well, and those questions were tough.👍🏻
这个回答70分，刘大使20分
你怎么不看看主持人的双重标准，对待刘大使多么针锋相对，多么粗鲁。
这还是hardtalk吗？能让对方完整表达,我觉得很双标！
@@疾风零式 民主人士来就能talk 支持北京政府的人来就是hardly talk
xin qing 身為香港人，我對主持人的問題感到非常冒犯
Den D 其实大家角度不同，亲中的还认为太客气，其实我觉得还好啦
So proud of you 羅冠聰👏🏻
God bless MR. Law no matter where he is !
good job Nathan ! like all ur answer are made sense and strong. voice out fm hk
How can that be? A man who ask US to attach China.
罗冠聪好醒目，没被个主持人控制住个场，好明白清晰彬彬有礼的表明自己的立场选择及目标，不愧是香港培养出来的杰出人才之一，支持你和其他同仁，你们是香港的一线希望，加油💪！
吊毛一个
哈哈哈 一付败相
“When the government does not respect 2 systems. Why the people should respect one country” well said.
It's not the time for debating who did the best in the interview, but let the public know what is going on in Hong Kong. Now let the people know how the HK government does not respect the two systems. Come on, show me some examples.
Mickey Finn I thought, since mid 90s. We should have learned how to conduct some proper researches on topics that we’re interested. Instead of replying on some source information to be feed.
@52Hz- Integrity 那英國為甚麼要准許蘇格蘭獨立公投? 還有加拿大魁北克獨立公投也是政府認可的
52Hz- Integrity 大概你是忘記人們在反抗警暴與政暴以前的和平遊行集會了：）
so u can go to the street and destroy the public facility and set fire to metro and break the houses and attack innocents? and when the govt come up with laws to regulate, then u simple book a ticket and fleet to a foreign country? so many Americans not like Trump and USA govemt, but does that mean they have to go independence and deny they r not Americans?
Well said, Nathan😢 You spoke words! Thank you 💛 And also thank BBC and Steven for providing this platform for HK people to express our desire for autonomy and freedom! Free for freedom, stand with HK!
关心政治的gay请举手🙌，让世界看到我们！
↓
是的，最好直接禁止所有共产党员入境英国，美国和整个西方世界。
特朗普帮了中国一把！现在的美国谁敢去也不怕被感染了
這招真絕 完全是無形刀放在所謂愛黨之人的頸上 對一些「反美是工作 留美是生活」的人來說是最為致命 為了生活 應該很多槍頭對內 😂😂😂
兄弟你们眼睛其实看得很透，这就是帮你们打贪
你看胡錫進的回應，說什麼「中共黨員和中國密不可分」之類，為去不了美國而叫苦，這不是露出馬腳，默認中共黨員和美國的關係了嗎。他撒謊也好，應該說中共黨員愛國、愛黨、清廉，沒資產在海外，不會也不想去美國。
Has the HARDtalk host noticed that today's (2021) Hong Kong security law is already in progress in HK?
The host was in the questions of last year, and now Hong Kong government used the actions to tell you the answer.
睇完覺得羅冠聰好勁...睇落好適合做國際遊說
希望羅生將來有一日可以平安返黎香港,唔洗驚比人捉
nmsl
no more security law
羅冠聰 is not exciled 流亡 . He was not arrested/charged or anything by HK government. He left HK as a normal traveler without trouble by HK Custom. he is going to continue his study in Yale. He is not wanted, and still can return HK freely . Exile means to be away from one's home, while either being explicitly refused permission to return or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return. What do you think? Don't be misled by this interview.
We have had already normal people without the international attentions charged with the new law just carrying the “光腹香港時代革命” flag in his backpack, blank paper without a single word written and a Taiwanese flag, and you said it is OK to have such law
agree with ron yau
I would like to know based on his qualifications. Is he qualified to be accepted in Yale?
Nathan Law ,His talents are limitless! He should go to the United States to participate in and support the BLM movement to help American minorities establish their own nation!
一個記錄片嘅導演 都容納唔到嘅香港！！！！ 呢個會係咩呀香港呀
你自己腦中的記憶及思想也在限制之列吧？
Nathan, I will always support you. You have done a great interview. Good job
羅冠聰，加油！總有一天你會回香港的，請多多保重，繼續為香港人發聲，煲底相見
Nathan Thank you so much for speaking out for HKers! Proud of you!
多謝你們講述
2019 . 07 . 21 There is an organized crime that they govt using local thugs beating up people who dare voicing their objection about the extradition law in Hong Kong !!!
This young man think he can change the world talking a lot of crabs.....stupid ass
@@MrTonyPang not only him, but the world is changing
Lies were told to youngsters as you heard, truth is rioters destruct others homeland, then local citizens defend and won the fight.
Weren't the protesters fucking with the graves of other people's ancestors?
7.21 is now evidently proven was instigated by a anti-China senator.
Proud of Nathan👍
l【冼師傅講場】｜冼國林｜Ex 04｜國安法是對付外勢力滲透的最佳方法，刻不容緩。(港美中心)NDI
乜水?
一個垃圾KOL有小小常識嘅人都唔可能聽佢，昆下智障還可以
@@Sam642009 冼師傅係法律學者, 親中但也經常痛斥政府缺點, 論點都輔以法例, 節奏快係難CATCH, 但聽得明既人,即使立場不同, 肯定都唔會好似你咁胡亂攻擊佢, 你咁既反應, 只代表你一係就聽唔明, 一係就根本無認真聽過
学坏咏春拳死蓝屍
你不如聽多d黃絲kol ，知多d我地點對付你地藍屍中共好過喇🤣， 快d返大陸呢埋喇， 美國英國已ready在附近。
Oh how accurate the Hong Kong activists were when we now look back at their warnings over a year ago…
假如中国出人出钱介入苏格兰独立运动，不知道英国会作何反应。
现在要争做老大了， 抱歉，英国的事情先放一边吧！
Thank you Nathan. You did a great job for us.
I wonder if UK ever felt sorry about what it did in its colonies around the world. Most troubles come from these colonies right now. Why?
把国安法等同于文革是非常荒谬的，就算在西方国家，公开进行分裂国家的行为也是会受到法律惩罚的，否则加泰罗尼亚早就从西班牙分裂出去了
说的对
中國的國安法跟西方比嚴格很多, 程度不一樣的。也有例外, 比如SCOLAND。
民主國家的國安法與獨權國家的國安法唔同。
需要國安法也需要民主。
CCP的國安法是執政者話事，衣加的執政者是習近平，無人可以反對佢，邊個反對佢死路一條。
@@Journey9533 中国绝对多数人支持国家惩罚香港一些败类。这也是中国的民意！！
@@lc7583 卧槽，我又被代表了
This interviewer was playing hard devil's advocate damn. Nathan handled it so well. Really well spoken.
Great job Nathan. Hongkongers r proud of you. U will have all the supports from people in Hong Kong.
Good job, nathan
Thank you sooooo much from hong kong
It would be really interesting to ask the host to reflect on all the questions he asked Nathan. Time did tell, Even Germany is moving their position. You can even do business with a country do not respect international law or commerce rule. When China says Win Win, it means China wins twice. HK people paid hard price to wake up the international community.
事實上香港某部分人已經變得噤若寒蟬
那不就是也证明了，这一部分人违反了法律？
不做错事怕什么，奇怪
舉張白紙都不行，蘇聯笑話現實版
Kaiser Ka Chung 立法会撒屎尿好使不？
Kaiser Ka Chung 我们为啥可以？你怎么不行？
Thank you. Truly hard talk. Great responses.
高手對決，真的好看，hardtalk種草了
虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
你真是个傻逼垃圾
Jianhao He 我聞到中國人毒奶味
@@peterkong1288 别理他，这是他的工作
@@peterkong1288 虽然你身上喷了古龙水，但我还是能隐约闻到一股人渣味儿。
I support Nathan Law.
香港的孩子是神的使者👍
聰仔好波 感謝
This is an excellent interview, thank you for Stephen Sackur's sharp questions and Nathan's clear and concise responses. Be safe in the UK, Nathan.
Thx you Nathan Law.