Defending Israel with David Harris: Einat Wilf Returns

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 янв 2025

Комментарии • 187

  • @cyberpunkalphamale
    @cyberpunkalphamale 2 месяца назад +85

    Prof. Wilf is the best spokesperson for Israel and Zionism.

    • @MrAbuYaz
      @MrAbuYaz 2 месяца назад +3

      Actually Mosab is.

    • @rybbah
      @rybbah 2 месяца назад +5

      @@MrAbuYazI love him, but he’s unfortunately isn’t as profound as her

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

    • @marks1731
      @marks1731 2 месяца назад +5

      She's absolutely brilliant

  • @Phoenix-td8mu
    @Phoenix-td8mu 2 месяца назад +39

    Dr. Einat Wilf is the gold standard when it comes to understanding "Palestinianism", "right of return", and UNRWA as the root cause of the problem. Hats off to her brilliant speech and erudition.

  • @LapramX
    @LapramX 2 месяца назад +37

    She is amazing in how clearly she thinks and can articulate the fundamental flaws in our thinking. Most grateful for her

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @lynwhelan8194
    @lynwhelan8194 2 месяца назад +5

    Everyone should share this on their social media. I Stand With Israel now and always. They are the Truth Tellers. ❤

    • @chenrhrh
      @chenrhrh Месяц назад +1

      Thank you very much ❤

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 месяца назад +42

    *"Losing a war you started is called Defeat, not Genocide!"*

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @mouseandryforever6848
    @mouseandryforever6848 2 месяца назад +54

    Dr. Wilfs 20 years in her studies has prepared us for this moment of ending UNRWA.

    • @saljukrashid1268
      @saljukrashid1268 2 месяца назад +1

      she is an Israeli spokesperson. I don’t believe the hamas spokesperson, in the same way you shouldn’t believe her either. you should believe people who do not have an obligation to support either hamas or idf

    • @magentamagenta1274
      @magentamagenta1274 2 месяца назад

      @saljukrashid1268 Shame you can’t tolerate truth!
      Nothing has changed has it ? Still the same old story.
      “Negotiations with Israel are just a temporary tactic. Our goal is still the destruction of the Zionist entity.”
      Yasser Arafat

    • @magentamagenta1274
      @magentamagenta1274 2 месяца назад

      @saljukrashid1268 Shame you can’t tolerate truth!
      Nothing has changed has it ? Still the same old story.
      “Negotiations with Israel are just a temporary tactic. Our goal is still the destruction of the Zionist entity.”
      Yasser Arafat

    • @jonasv.c.8924
      @jonasv.c.8924 2 месяца назад +6

      @@saljukrashid1268 Dr. Wilf is an independent intellectual and opinion maker. She isn't obliged to support the IDF because, unlike Hamas, the IDF respects people's freedom of expression and opinion. You're just having cognitive dissonance because Dr. Wilf is truth bombing you.

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 месяца назад +30

    *"If a cult loves death more than their opponent loves life, why are they complaining about high death count?"*

  • @eliwi54
    @eliwi54 2 месяца назад +46

    Einat Wilf should speak to every western government and people about the facts with UNWRA!!!

    • @saljukrashid1268
      @saljukrashid1268 2 месяца назад +2

      can you explain why Israel shot at UN peacekeepers in Lebanon?

    • @1a140
      @1a140 2 месяца назад

      It is not a platform for discussion of everything happening in permanent tension occurring in the South of Lebanon.
      Don't try to misleading of the topic.
      ​@saljukrashid1268

    • @cboz3712
      @cboz3712 2 месяца назад +7

      @@saljukrashid1268 I think you know very well the reason. It is obvious. Do you want to make a point?
      Please explain first what UNIFIL has done the last 15 years to fulfill the 1701 UN agreement to keep the region there unmilitarized.
      How were there tunnels built under their nose??
      And me and you pay for this??
      „Peacekeepers“?? 🤣

    • @magentamagenta1274
      @magentamagenta1274 2 месяца назад

      @saljukrashid1268 Shame you can’t tolerate truth!
      Nothing has changed has it ? Still the same old story.
      “Negotiations with Israel are just a temporary tactic. Our goal is still the destruction of the Zionist entity.”
      Yasser Arafat

    • @magentamagenta1274
      @magentamagenta1274 2 месяца назад

      @saljukrashid1268 Shame you can’t tolerate truth!
      Nothing has changed has it ? Still the same old story.
      “Negotiations with Israel are just a temporary tactic. Our goal is still the destruction of the Zionist entity.”
      Yasser Arafat

  • @StevenSteven-zn5gj
    @StevenSteven-zn5gj 2 месяца назад +10

    Thank you Prof Wilf. Amazing explanation

  • @keepussafeUSA
    @keepussafeUSA 2 месяца назад +45

    No one should be doing UNRWA under any conditions. It's not the US or Israel's job to support them.

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

    • @treesab
      @treesab 2 месяца назад

      Wrong. As illegal occupiers, Israel is 100% responsible for the care and well being for the population. This is basic international law and the ICJ has ordered Israel end the nearly century long illegal occupation immediately, which includes the evacuation from ALL settlements within occupied Palestine on the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
      The speaker in this video has intentionally disregarded the rulings of the international law. Israel should be careful in closing down UNRWA. Once Israel shuts UNRWA down, it's the Israeli taxpayers that will have to pay for it. Let no Israeli be mistaken in thinking they'll just choose not to pay. Luckily, nation state assets can be seized by international court orders. There won't be a choice to pay. The court has already ruled. Israel has been declared the illegal occupier.
      I hope Israelis who invest time to discover how they have been indoctrinated and lied to by an entity built by psychopaths will find the path to understanding and healing alot easier to walk on.

    • @christinelafromboise6731
      @christinelafromboise6731 2 месяца назад

      @@treesab “Wrong” actually YOU could not be more wrong than you are. The UN has become a corrupt organization that enables terrorism. It has no legitimacy any more. It needs to be defunded by all Western democracies and kicked out of the USA. This woman is absolutely correct.

    • @denisemansell5871
      @denisemansell5871 2 месяца назад +2

      Nor is it Australia’s job to support them. Explain this to Penny Wong and Anthony Albanese please.

    • @drjowjow
      @drjowjow Месяц назад +2

      ​​@@treesabsuch a long post but not one iota of your arguments hold water.
      First off, israel is not an occupier. They left Gaza completely in 2005, even going as far as forcibly taking out their own people both living and dead - yes they even dug out graves to take out israelis buried in cemeteries! There was no israeli presence in gaza since then, and the only reason why there is israeli presence now is because of a war srarted by hamas in october 7. Now when a country is at war with another, there is nothing stated in international law that says you have to resupply and take care of your enemy's civilians while the war is still ongoing. The war in gaza is far from finished, and until then the IDF has no obligation to feed and shelter the palestinians affected by the conflict. The fact that israel still sends aid to gaza while fighting this war is in fact unprecedented in any war in history and in my opinion is a bad move. One does not resupply an enemy you are fighting a war against.

  • @paulabalansky1611
    @paulabalansky1611 2 месяца назад +39

    Every breathing person should hear this message💪
    Yishar koach🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 месяца назад +26

    *"Human shields dying in a war you started is called Collateral Damage, not Genocide!"*

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @MichalRufert
    @MichalRufert 2 месяца назад +31

    Einat is a great scholar with her feet on the ground. M. Rufert, czech republic

    • @1a140
      @1a140 2 месяца назад +4

      Thanks for your interest and support!

  • @mabkml
    @mabkml 2 месяца назад +26

    UNRWA's humanitarian concern for the Palestinians is just a charade. The dreadful events of October the 7th and what followed had unveiled its sinister motives.

    • @saljukrashid1268
      @saljukrashid1268 2 месяца назад

      how many Israeli people did Israel kill on October 7th? did Israel know about October 7th weeks before? did Israel fund and support hamas during its early days?

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @bobcirulnick3598
    @bobcirulnick3598 Месяц назад +1

    Brilliant!

  • @hendrikvanderbreggen
    @hendrikvanderbreggen 2 месяца назад +14

    Thanks for the interview. I greatly appreciate Einat Wilf. Dr. Wilf's book The War of Return is very helpful and should be placed in all Western universities and colleges. (My wife and I donated copies to our local libraries. We live in Western Canada.) Hopefully the newly re-elected U.S. President Donald Trump will again defund UNRWA.

  • @mouseandryforever6848
    @mouseandryforever6848 2 месяца назад +33

    I agree with Dr. Wilf

    • @saljukrashid1268
      @saljukrashid1268 2 месяца назад

      how many Israeli people did Israel kill on October 7th? did Israel know about October 7th weeks before? did Israel fund and support hamas during its early days?

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 месяца назад +15

    *"Accusing Israel of committing genocide is like accusing a rape victim of committing rape!"*

    • @pasimajuri1209
      @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад

      ruclips.net/video/j7Mupoo1At8/видео.html

  • @YerielEven-Pinah
    @YerielEven-Pinah 2 месяца назад +13

    It's time to start implimenting common sense solutions. Dr Wilf should have a part in shutting down UNWRA and finding homes, in Jordan or any muslim country, just not in Israel.

  • @erickaplan8263
    @erickaplan8263 2 месяца назад +3

    Einat for PM!!!

  • @StevenBielik
    @StevenBielik 2 месяца назад +3

    Great talk, as always.
    23:52 this is maybe the most important part for the future. I hope everyone sees this. #DefundUNRWA #StopIslamicTerror #StopTheIndoctrination #StopIran

  • @mardischwenger8968
    @mardischwenger8968 2 месяца назад +10

    Brilliant discussion on why UNWRA must be dismantled.

  • @SuspectUsual
    @SuspectUsual 2 месяца назад +10

    *"Women defending Izlam is like Chickens defending KFC!"*

  • @elsarm178
    @elsarm178 2 месяца назад +17

    💪💪💪🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱👑👑👑❤️❤️❤️

  • @Unicorn-Black
    @Unicorn-Black 2 месяца назад +1

    As always sharp truth, lets hope trump will do something around these ideas and finish this endless sufferings as oppose to Biden that support the continuation of the war forever

  • @brentriley4911
    @brentriley4911 2 месяца назад +1

    At the moment, there is a need for UNWRA.

  • @breatharian2009
    @breatharian2009 Месяц назад

    Dr. Einat Wilf wearing her Harvard fleece jacket, as always. That lady never misses an opportunity to show that she is a Harvard graduate.

    • @freedahlogic8368
      @freedahlogic8368 28 дней назад

      You're hilarious, how did you imaginarium that one.. ? I scrubbed the timelime a few times trying to see anything but a plain black hoody.. leave a time code next time. Also. So what?

  • @shmujew4791
    @shmujew4791 2 месяца назад +4

    This woman is great

  • @jjdonnellan1
    @jjdonnellan1 Месяц назад

    "A people should know when they're conquered. Would you Quintus, would I ?" - Maximus (Gladiator)

  • @elena_007
    @elena_007 2 месяца назад +4

    We need to find a rooftop for Einat. She is so convincing!

  • @ghrosenb
    @ghrosenb 2 месяца назад +4

    She is great

  • @Eliedelouya
    @Eliedelouya 2 месяца назад +1

    Genial

  • @GeorgeMlll
    @GeorgeMlll 2 месяца назад +8

    The solution seems clear cut when a bunch of assumptions are made history ignored & the parameters of debate are pre-set

    • @christinelafromboise6731
      @christinelafromboise6731 2 месяца назад

      Thank you for describing exactly what “pro Palestinian” supporters are doing. It is interesting that the terrorists take everything they are guilty of, flip it upside down and accuse Israel of the crimes they themselves are actually committing.

    • @GeorgeMlll
      @GeorgeMlll 2 месяца назад

      @christinelafromboise6731 here is an easily check able fact please do me the curtesy of checking it and then accuse me... The father of cultural Zionism Ahad Ha'am wrote these words in 1910 about Europeans moving to Palestine "They treat Arabs with hostility and cruelty, deprive them of their rghts ..offend them without cause and even boast of these deeds;..nobody among us opposes ths despicable and dangerous inclination ..."

  • @ErikaSwartzberg
    @ErikaSwartzberg 2 месяца назад +1

    Einat for PM

  • @Light19412
    @Light19412 2 месяца назад +1

    The BEST!❤

  • @jerzywieckowski7610
    @jerzywieckowski7610 2 месяца назад

    ❤❤❤

  • @Bamboothought
    @Bamboothought 2 месяца назад +1

  • @leilasesmero5910
    @leilasesmero5910 2 месяца назад

    Pls comment about Arafat conceding that A Jewish state could have self determination?

    • @Alex-y9j2b
      @Alex-y9j2b 2 месяца назад

      Provisionally.... Until the jihad wins.
      That was his idea. What is your point anyway?

  • @deboraandrade5673
    @deboraandrade5673 2 месяца назад +2

    DESPICABLE!

  • @pernille8071
    @pernille8071 21 день назад

    I stand wholeheartedly with Israel, no doubt about that! But Israel should have been aware of all this coming - they are a Middle-Eastern Country, understand the psychology and have the best secret agency world-wide. They should not only have been prepared, but should have prevented all those actions!

  • @beachbumvet8973
    @beachbumvet8973 2 месяца назад +3

    AM YISRAEL CHAI

  • @chucha307
    @chucha307 Месяц назад

    Einat the next PM👑👑👑🇮🇱🇮🇱

  • @eethkoth4872
    @eethkoth4872 2 месяца назад +3

    Yes,, if UNRWA had been defunded many years ago,, hamas and the pa would have to actually act like a governing power and provide services for their people and not focus so much on how to destroy Israel,, "Palestinians" are treated like children by most of the world who can't be expected to look after themselves

    • @Alex-y9j2b
      @Alex-y9j2b 2 месяца назад

      They are really arrogant and entitled

  • @khakshouriify
    @khakshouriify 2 месяца назад +2

    Wilf would be a great prime minister for Israel

  • @TheWhitehiker
    @TheWhitehiker 2 месяца назад

    This is pre-election.

  • @pasimajuri1209
    @pasimajuri1209 2 месяца назад +4

    ❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱❤️

  • @kalishakta
    @kalishakta 2 месяца назад

    Jeremiah 9:11.

  • @joedirnfeld
    @joedirnfeld Месяц назад

    Einat, we need you in the israeli gov, wtf are you waiting

  • @garyleiser753
    @garyleiser753 2 месяца назад

    Defending the indefensible.

  • @KathyZ-y8b
    @KathyZ-y8b 2 месяца назад +2

    Defending Israel's actions will come back to haunt you.

  • @ChristineHafner-d5g
    @ChristineHafner-d5g 2 месяца назад

    What does she say about the fact that the ICJ said that the occupation of Gaza and the Westbank is unlawful and must end as soon as possible? And that the General Assembly issued a resolution that as soon as possible is September 2025?

  • @Maryculligan
    @Maryculligan 11 дней назад

    🇮🇱💙

  • @maddie1446-c6w
    @maddie1446-c6w 2 месяца назад

    Ask Putin why 😢

  • @Anndee4Palestine
    @Anndee4Palestine 2 месяца назад +1

    more accurately, the genocidal campaign against the Palestinian people began when Zionist estavlished themselves in governmental positions after WWI including the Water Board who in 1925, began to restrict the native peoples from their own water supplies and making that water available to a "future" population of Jewish immigrants in Jerusalem including prioritizing water usage to constructruon projects over historical uses of that water by the natives. (Artas Spring 1925) . Things have only gotten progressively worse for them ever since and now, Palestinians are deprived of everything that every human needs in order to sustain life.

  • @timurtruman
    @timurtruman 2 месяца назад

    One of the main problems that the Israelis have been failing to realize is that the Jews look at multiple wars they won, while the Arabs look at those as multiple battles they lost, without the customary for the world history price the losing party pays (loss of land and forced relocation). And, given this illogical philosophy of the Israelis, the Arabs decide that they can win by fighting a war of a thousand cuts. Bottom line is, you have to seize and annex new territories, expel the enemy, fortify and prepare to do the same, until the enemy surrenders unconditionally and forever.

  • @aeolianharp1363
    @aeolianharp1363 2 месяца назад +1

    Brilliant , but can it be accomplished

  • @johnfelman5117
    @johnfelman5117 2 месяца назад +2

    Well said Dr Wilf . Totally agree . Very true and sad

  • @JaimeMesChiens
    @JaimeMesChiens 2 месяца назад +3

    Can someone please explain to me if, and why, Trump is good for Israel and Jewish people worldwide.
    Thank you.
    I need to know.

    • @keepussafeUSA
      @keepussafeUSA 2 месяца назад

      1. Abraham Accords
      2. Title VI expansion
      3. He stopped US funding UNRWA
      4. Sanctions on Iran to prevent oil sales between Iran and China. Because Biden lifted them, Iran ended up with $150billion+ to fund Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthi terrorists.

    • @kekesam4957
      @kekesam4957 2 месяца назад +1

      Did you listen to this conversation? Dr. Einat gave an answer to this question. If the leaders of other dem countries followed the same policy and cut off $$sucking project, the problem would have been solved. Maybe not right now, but in a few generations. It applies to UNRWA as a breeding nest of terrorism and PA with their "pay for slay" program. If you did not catch what Trump's policy was, listen to this again.

    • @keepussafeUSA
      @keepussafeUSA 2 месяца назад

      Test

    • @neological9
      @neological9 2 месяца назад +2

      His admin moved the US embassy to Jerusalem (recognizing it as Israel's capital), began the Abraham accords (Saudi/UAE normalization not tied to Pal statehood), assassinated suleimani, canceled Iran nuclear deal, and is generally seen as a friend of more hawkish Israeli policy.
      But he's an erratic, narcissistic conman and a fair weather friend, so I fear the trust is misplaced. And imo the maximalist goals of Likud & co. are dangerous in their own right, so giving them free rein is not actually "good for the Jews."

    • @usbconnections
      @usbconnections 2 месяца назад

      He's not Biden-Harris, who indulge the Palestinian dream, which is the erasure of Israel

  • @penguinbelly
    @penguinbelly 2 месяца назад +1

    She is a left wing politician?

  • @RogerPerera-q3k
    @RogerPerera-q3k 2 месяца назад

    Since I have the authority as an "End Time Watchman" as for Ezekiel 3:17-19 and Ezekiel 33: 7-9 appointed by El Shaddai for the "House of Israel(Britain and America) and "House of Judah(Jews) and my name has been entered by El Shaddai among the 144000 first-fruits of redeemed men in Revelation 5:1 "Seven Sealed scroll" same as the "Scroll of Remembrance" in Malachi 3:16-18 as Lord enlightened me for the first time since 95 ad that John penned the book of Revelation and given to Jesus Christ as John recorded in Revelation 5:7, what I announce stands as the spoken words of Lord Jesus as the first human since 95ad to proclaim that Rev 5:1 scroll has all 144000 names that God had drawn to Jesus as Jesus confirmed in John 6:43-45.
    I was privileged to be the only gentile from my nation, Sri-Lanka, and tongue, Sinhalese that El Shaddai had called, chosen and elected among the 144,000 first-fruits where 7000 men from the tribe of Judah had been chosen under the Old Covenant by El Shaddai as promised to Elijah in 1kings 19:18 as for Genesis 49:10 and 1 Chronicles 5:1-2 promised to Judah to be a co-heir with the Jews to whom El Shaddai promised the "Scepter", the great grand son of Abraham and El Shaddai would choose the rest of first-fruits 136999 from every tribe, tongue, race and nation under the New Covenant that Yeshua instituted in His own blood covenant with His 12 disciples who are part of all 144000 first-fruits as for Luke 22:20 as John recorded in Revelation 5:9-10, 7:1-8 and 14:1-5.
    Remember Jesus's prayer to His Father for Himself, then to His 12 disciples and the rest of 144000 first-fruits that John records in John 17.
    Jesus specifically told His Father, God, that He was not praying for the world but to those 144000 that Father had called to Him and chosen and entered in Rev 5:1 scroll which is same as the Malachi 3:16-18.
    Remember during this age, it is all about 144000 redeemed men as kings and priests and now women as for the law in Numbers 18.
    This age is all about calling and electing 144000 first-fruits of men as Christ's bride who would be El-Shaddai future ruling sons with His eternal Son, Jesus when hands over the Adam's family as for Psalm 2.
    Salvation for rest of men and women as "Levite" in the "White Throne Judgement" after the lapse of 1000 year rule of Christ and His bride of 144000 first fruits just prior to restoration of lost Eden back to Adam's family at the conclusion of 7 Millennia!

    • @tatonemio6388
      @tatonemio6388 2 месяца назад

      *TROLL ALERT*
      *Account created Oct 6, 2024 to spread hatred and lies*

  • @Bluebaggins
    @Bluebaggins 2 месяца назад

    Using the prejudism of jew- non jew, gives a clear divide, that happened at the time of the second temples destruction. . Deny the Lord at your own peril. Jeremiah 29:10 Isaac was the promise.. The fulfilling of this promise, places the King of Israel and his redeeming power in heaven. Isaiah 44:6
    Jeremiah 23:31- 32
    Isaiah 63:10
    Zechariah 12: 10
    Gabrielle Aplin - The Power of Love

  • @GeorgeMlll
    @GeorgeMlll 2 месяца назад +3

    No deal ever offered included a return of displaced people. If it is simply might is right please do not invoke any morality in the arguement.

    • @yelenas7923
      @yelenas7923 2 месяца назад +3

      Of course it is simple. The countries that have camps need to give their "refugees" the citizenship. It is not really camps. It is a bad districts in the cities. The people in Sabra and Shatilla live in really bad condition in Beirut. The Lebanons don't allow them to built a new building for their livings and are discriminating them for 52 kind of jobs.
      Even in Palestinian Authority there are camps for refugees - the bad district. Why the PA don't care about their own citizens?
      They need the "refugees" to use them always to try to return them to israel

    • @LittleAriel
      @LittleAriel 2 месяца назад +2

      *You* don't use nor facts nor morality factors when discussing this issue, as you show to lack both.

    • @GeorgeMlll
      @GeorgeMlll 2 месяца назад +1

      So if Greeks were moved to camps in Italy they should become Italian?

    • @helenezonana
      @helenezonana 2 месяца назад +1

      @@GeorgeMlllafter 4 generations? You’d think they would be absorbed and all over the world they become citizens of those countries except for Israel. Let’s look at the double standards.

    • @GeorgeMlll
      @GeorgeMlll 2 месяца назад +1

      @@helenezonana some have been. If it wads 100yrs ago id say maybe but if this continues for them this could happen to any of us.

  • @johnrichie2136
    @johnrichie2136 2 месяца назад +1

    It's important to note, however, that embracing defeat can only happen, if (and when) defeat happens. And, defeat can happen only when a real war takes place. There is a case to be made that all that was going on between Israel on the one side and the Palestinian, Arabs, and Muslims on the other side was something else. There can be a healthy debate as to what it was. But, certainly not war. If and when a war happens between Israel on the one side and Palestinians, Arabs, and Muslims on the other side and the Palestinian side is defeated, only then Palestinians will have no choice but to embrace defeat. Dr. Einat obviously appears to follow the school of historical determinism. And, that's very tempting. I don't think that it's wise for one to abandon herself to that vortex.

    • @maltija1
      @maltija1 2 месяца назад +8

      Why do you make a distinction between "Palestinians" and Arabs? They are one and the same. The Ps are from Jordan and Egypt.

    • @usbconnections
      @usbconnections 2 месяца назад +3

      These semantics don't matter. Any true leadership (supported by the people) can take the Palestinians in a new direction towards a constructive future. This leadership doesn't have to be officially knighted by foreign powers but by its own people.

    • @Chari-n5b91ty
      @Chari-n5b91ty 2 месяца назад +6

      To me, what you’re doing is just simply trying to undermine Wilf’s argument via contradiction. You’re not trying to present any alternative view, or provide substantial supporting evidence for what you’re saying. In fact, there’s no evidence for what you’re saying. Are you saying that it was not inevitable that permanent eternal refugee status for Gazans and those in the West Bank, and the indoctrination of those people to believe that they have the right to the land now called Israel wouldn’t build up population pressure , and wouldn’t get the world’s sympathy for all the refugees? Historical determination involves a lack of evidence to try to prove inevitability, whereas there is plenty of corroborating evidence for Wilf’s case.

    • @mouseandryforever6848
      @mouseandryforever6848 2 месяца назад

      It's a war. How is it not a war? It's not only a war but a war of genocide by Hamas towards Jews. It's been continual rockets, suicide bombings, sneaking in tunnels to slaughter Jewish families, constant attacks with a clear Hamas charter to kill all Jews and Israel. To me your argument is simply semantics.

    • @johnrichie2136
      @johnrichie2136 2 месяца назад

      @maltija1 I don't quite understand what you are getting at!

  • @benluchini7500
    @benluchini7500 2 месяца назад

    Load of bullshit.